same role, different builds our proposal
One role met by different structures in different systems.
Seen in 1,137 walked systems. Each sighting is our reading of that system's sourced walk, in that system's own terms; a shape that turns up everywhere is the finding, and how it differs from place to place is the detail.
Structural: the shape does the work here (748)
- 't Hooft-Polyakov monopole
One far field, two builds: the singular Dirac monopole (with a string) and the smooth 't Hooft-Polyakov soliton; 'Very far from the origin ... reduces to the Dirac monopole'. - 1 + 1 dimensional Minkowski spacetime
The history of an object as a flat stage of p + 1 dimensions: worldline (p = 0), worldsheet 1 + 1 (strings), worldvolume 2 + 1 (M2-branes). - 2 + 1 dimensional Minkowski spacetime
The history of an extended object as a flat p + 1 stage: worldsheet 1 + 1 (strings), worldvolume 2 + 1 (M2-branes). - 6D (2,0) superconformal field theory (projected model)
Worldvolume theories of M-branes as boundary duals of M-theory: the (2,0) theory on M5-branes (AdS7 x S4) and ABJM on M2-branes (AdS4 x S7/Z_k). - ABJM theory (projected model: N = 6 Chern-Simons-matter theory on M2-branes)
Boundary duals of M-theory on AdS x sphere, built on different branes: ABJM on M2-branes (AdS4) and the (2,0) theory on M5-branes (AdS7). - Access control
One job, letting the right ones through a boundary and keeping the rest out, done by unrelated builds: the Egyptian pin lock, a guard with a list, a kernel's access control list, a capability; in cells the nuclear pore's FG barrier with its transport receptors as tickets; in ant colonies many guards - Accounting (the field and practice)
One job, keeping a durable count of goods and debts for a later reader, done by unrelated builds: clay tokens and bullae (Near East), knotted khipu cords (Andes), notched split sticks (English Exchequer), paper journals and ledgers (Italy), digital AIS and shared ledgers. - Acid-base reaction
One job, sensing protons, done by unrelated proteins: OTOP1 (12-transmembrane proton channel) in sour-taste cells; ASICs (proton-gated cation channels) and TRPV1 on nociceptors; TASK-2 (an alkaline-activated K2P channel) and GPR4 (a receptor) in RTN neurons. And one job, carrying the proton out of c - Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter)
Making sound to send into air is done by unrelated builds: frog air sacs, the mammal larynx, the bird syrinx, katydid wing files; hawkmoths alone use three: 'scale-on-scale, scale-on-spine and scale-on-nodule'. - ADM energy
Total mass-energy of an isolated system built at spatial infinity (ADM), at null infinity (Bondi) and from a Killing symmetry (Komar); agreement where more than one is defined. - ADM mass
One role (the total mass of an isolated system) built three ways: Komar (Killing vector, stationary), ADM (spatial infinity), Bondi (null infinity); they agree when stationary or radiation-free. - Advocacy group (interest group)
The shared job: keep a costly shared benefit supplied when others can take it without paying. Advocacy groups do it with members-only benefits, the sociability of membership and the satisfaction of expressing a value; microbes do it by keeping part of a secreted good for the producer (partial privat - Affine parameter
One role (labelling a geodesic) built three ways: proper time for massive bodies (epsilon = 1), a bare linear family for light (epsilon = 0), proper length for spacelike geodesics (epsilon = -1). - Affine parameter of a null geodesic
One conserved-quantity role along geodesics, two builds: Killing vectors give E and L in Schwarzschild; in FRW, with 'no timelike Killing vector', a Killing tensor gives K^2 and the redshift. - African elephant (genus Loxodonta: bush and forest elephants)
Elders as the group's store of ecological knowledge: old matriarchs judge lions best and old bulls lead travel in elephants; old post-reproductive females lead in resident orcas (named side by side by Allen 2020). Addressing an individual by call: dolphins imitate the addressee's whistle, elephants - Air pollution
One job, reading the state of the air, done by unrelated structures: chemical bubblers (iodine, peroxide), lead peroxide candles, satellites (GOME, OMI, MODIS), lichen communities, and moth colour frequencies. - Alexandrov topology (interval topology of a spacetime)
Two topologies on one set of events, one from the smooth structure and one from the chronological order; they coincide exactly when the spacetime is strongly causal. - Algebra (the practice of solving for unknowns and transforming expressions, and the structures it works with)
Keeping both sides equal while the unknown is isolated is done by symbols (the balance rule), by a balance scale's pans, by hands grouping numbers (gesture), by the pictorial model method (Lee et al. 2007: 'similar processes but ... different attentional demands') and by a machine's rewriting rules. - Alloy
Blocking dislocations, one job, done by solute stress fields (solid solution), coherent ordered particles (gamma prime), strong particles dislocations must bow around (Orowan), interstitial carbon, and short-range order (src:wp:solid-solution-strengthening; src:wp:precipitation-hardening; src:chen-2 - Alphabet (one letter per phoneme)
One job, marking the vowel, done four ways: left out (abjads, read from Semitic roots), by diacritics (abugidas), by rotating the letter (Canadian Aboriginal syllabics), or by full letters (Greek, Latin, Cyrillic, Hangul). - American literature
one job, keeping a people's history across generations, done by different builds: Native oral tradition (narratives, songs, poetry), written slave narratives, WPA interviews of speech written down, and now genomics read beside oral history at Picuris - Ammonia
One job, turning inert N2 into ammonia, done by four unrelated builds: lightning's heat, nitrogenase's Fe7MoS9 active site in bacteria, the Haber-Bosch reactor (160 Mt in 2020), and prebiotically FeS/H2S surfaces ('a possible prebiotic formation of ammonia from dinitrogen on iron sulfide surfaces'). - Ancient Greek art
the job of telling skin from clothing in a statue done by paint on marble, by different materials on gold-and-ivory statues, and by different metals (lips, nails) on bronzes - Ancient Greek philosophy
One job, the underlying stuff of everything (the arche), filled by different builds: water (Thales), the unlimited (Anaximander), air (Anaximenes), fire and flux (Heraclitus), unchanging Being (Parmenides), four roots moved by Love and Strife (Empedocles), Mind (Anaxagoras), atoms and void (Leucippu - Angular diameter distance
One ruler role, two builds: the CMB sound horizon (theta*) and the BAO feature in galaxy surveys, both read as d_A. - Angular frequency
One rate set by different restoring builds: a spring (sqrt(k/m)), an LC circuit (sqrt(1/LC)), an orbit (v/r), a wave (2 pi / T). - Animal (kingdom Animalia, Metazoa)
Tissue-scale coordination reached by different builds: nerve nets (cnidarians), syncytial nerve nets (ctenophores, "a convergent solution"), calcium waves (sponges), peptidergic cells (placozoans). - Annelid (segmented worm; phylum Annelida)
The stiff-under-pressure job: annelids hold shape with fluid in septum-walled segments worked by circular and longitudinal muscles, the chordate with a pressurised rod, the spider with hydraulic legs; 'Adverse internal muscle pressures are avoided by design in annelids, in spiders they are only obse - Anthropocene
One job (keeping an annual record of fallout and other markers) done by unrelated structures: varved lakes and anoxic marine basins with no sediment-dwelling animals, cave formations with growth bands, corals and shells with annual growth, ice sheets, peat and urban deposits (the 12 candidate sites) - Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
The shared job, in plain words: making a huge range of receptor genes inside each lymphocyte from a small inherited library. Jawed vertebrates do it by cutting and joining Ig segments; lampreys and hagfish by copying leucine-rich-repeat cassettes into a gapped skeleton gene. 'Different evolutionary - Apparent horizon
Two builds of one job (marking a black hole's boundary): a local surface found on a slice (apparent horizon, used by numerical relativity) and a global surface found only with the whole future (event horizon, 'only retroactively'). - Aqueous solution
Charge moves through the solution by two builds: ions carried bodily ('whose movement is due simply to acceleration by the field') and the proton passed by bond swaps (Grotthuss), which is why the proton diffuses unusually fast. - Archaeon (Archaea)
Swimming by a rotary filament done by two unrelated machines: the archaellum, built like a type IV pilus and assembled from the base, and the bacterial flagellum, kin of the type III secretion system. Division too: FtsZ rings in Haloferax and Methanobrevibacter, ESCRT-III/Cdv rings in Sulfolobus, an - Architecture
Keeping indoors comfortable is done by thick rubble and mud walls with courtyards (rural India), very high thermal mass, small windows and air-drawing chimneys (North Africa), mud over wooden frames (wattle and daub), water-cooled courtyards (Mediterranean), stilts against floods, and closed-loop HV - Areal radius
'The radius' of a sphere built two ways: from its area (areal) or along a geodesic (proper); 'If k != 0, the proper radius a(t) chi and the areal radius a(t) f(chi) do not coincide', and horizon thermodynamics needs the areal one. - Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them
Settling a difference of opinion by exchanging reasons is built differently in each tradition: Greek dialectic with questioner and answerer and Aristotle's truth-preserving syllogistic; Indian debate manuals and pramana theory; Chinese bian, which draws distinctions by analogy to a model without exp - Arithmetic (the practice of calculating, and the operations and laws it works with)
Carrying out an addition is done by parietal-frontal working memory in people, by full adders with a rippling carry in machines, by beads in an abacus, and by composed rotations (discrete Fourier transforms and trigonometric identities) in a small transformer. - Arrow of time
One role (a one-way direction of time), several builds: entropy, expansion, outgoing waves, causation, decoherence, weak decays; the source says the thermodynamic one 'arguably underlies some of them, with the exception of the weak arrow of time'. - Art history (the field)
One job, telling who made a work and when, done by unrelated builds: the connoisseur's eye on 'diagnostic minor details' such as ears (Morelli), documents (provenance, 'essentially a matter of documentation'), physics (bomb-peak radiocarbon of the binder; dendrochronology), elemental imaging (macro- - Art of ancient Egypt
blue made three ways: imported lapis, synthetic Egyptian blue fired at 900-1000 °C, faience and glass as stand-ins - Artificial intelligence
Object recognition done by the primate ventral stream and by a silicon network trained only for performance; the network's top layer predicts IT spiking and its middle layers V4, though never fitted to neural data. And one job (reasoning) built two ways: symbols and rules (GOFAI) or learned weights. - Atmospheric methane (the methane reservoir of Earth's air)
One job (taking methane out) done by three builds: photochemical radicals in the air (OH, Cl, O(1D)), aerobic methanotroph bacteria in soils, and anaerobic methanotrophic archaea with sulfate in sediments ('Only three key functional groups of microorganisms ... regulate the fluxes of methane on eart - Atomic nucleus
Two doors into one recoil floor: a neutrino reaches it by Z exchange (weak), a fast neutron by the nuclear force, a WIMP (hypothetically) by a weak-scale interaction; all end as a recoiling nucleus ionising its neighbours. - Attention
One job, picking the relevant input out of many, done by different builds: V1's saliency map in primates and the tectum's in lower vertebrates; feedback to the retina in birds, with no mammalian parallel; insects' own mechanisms; and, as a named borrowing rather than a convergence, the transformer's - Authentication
One job, telling one's own or the genuine from an impostor's copy, done by unrelated builds: seals and passwords (people), egg 'signatures' (hosts of brood parasites), cuticular hydrocarbon profiles (ants), face and voice matching (people as verifiers), signed keys (machines). - Average four-velocity of matter
The standard of cosmic rest is built two ways: from matter (counts of quasars, average motion) and from radiation (the CMB dipole); the test is whether the two builds agree. - Aztec Empire (the Triple Alliance of Mexico-Tenochtitlan, Tetzcoco and Tlacopan, 1428-1521)
Keeping a calendar in step with the solar year: Basin farmers used horizon peaks and a mountain-top causeway where 16th-century Europeans used gnomon, compass, quadrant or astrolabe ('a similar goal ... achieved with widely different technologies'). Also: Maya cities grew crops inside the city while - Bargmann-Michel-Telegdi equation
Spin turning built two ways in one equation: by torque from the field on the magnetic moment (Larmor) and by pure kinematics of a curved world line (Thomas, Fermi-Walker), with no torque at all. - Basal ganglia
Selection among competitors done three ways (fixed-priority subsumption, distributed reciprocal inhibition, a central switch); the BG proposed as the central build. Songbird Area X (GPi equivalent) acts on thalamus by rebound bursts where mammals are read as gating. - Baum-Frampton cyclic model (phantom energy; the universe comes back empty)
One job, keeping an infinite cycle clear of Tolman's entropy build-up, done three ways: jettison all but one causal patch (Baum-Frampton), a net expansion each cycle (Steinhardt-Turok), conformal rescaling of an emptied aeon (Penrose). - Bearing (mechanical)
One job, letting one part move on another with little friction, is met by sliding surfaces, rolling balls, a fluid film, a magnetic field and a flexing element ('by virtue of its shape, by its material, or by introducing and containing a fluid ... or by separating the surfaces with an electromagneti - BFSS matrix model (projected model: M-theory as matrix quantum mechanics)
Candidate definitions of M-theory built differently: nine large matrices of D0-brane quantum mechanics (BFSS) and boundary field theories on branes (the (2,0) theory on M5-branes, ABJM on M2-branes). - Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical)
One role, turning contraction into expansion without a singularity, built three ways: quantum geometry (LQC), spinor-torsion spin-spin repulsion (Einstein-Cartan), and a nonsingular matter bounce in standard Einstein gravity (2012); colliding branes (ekpyrotic) a fourth. - Biodiversity
Plain job: many different responders keep the total steady when some fail. Ecology's insurance (species), economics' portfolio (assets, Markowitz 1952) and cybernetics' requisite variety (Ashby) do it with unrelated parts; Loreau et al. trace the shared idea. - Biology (the field)
Standing in for a human disease is done by three different builds of animal model: homologous (same causes, symptoms, treatments), isomorphic (same symptoms and treatments), predictive (similar in only a couple of aspects). - Bird song culture
One job, learning sounds from others and passing them on so a group shares them, done by different builds: songbirds with a two-sided syrinx and a forebrain song system; humpback whales with a U-fold larynx in the sea; people with the larynx and speech; parrots and hummingbirds with song systems of - Black hole
Holding a dead core up against gravity is done by two builds in turn: electron degeneracy pressure (fails above the Chandrasekhar limit) and neutron degeneracy with nuclear repulsion (fails above the TOV limit); the black hole is where both have failed. - Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
The selecting step is built differently on each medium: the photon environment (einselection), the antigen (clonal selection), refutation (Popper), the higher court (overruling), stability (mineral species lost when 'unstable on Earth in its oxidized state'). - Blood
Oxygen carried by haem-iron haemoglobin, copper haemocyanin and non-haem di-iron hemerythrin; wound plugs built from fibrinogen, horseshoe-crab coagulogen and crayfish clottable protein (kin to vitellogenin); platelets in mammals, whole thrombocytes elsewhere. - Blood pressure
Getting blood up to a high head against gravity is done by different builds: the giraffe's high arterial pressure, long legs and stiff jugular segments; arboreal snakes' higher pressure, a heart near the head and tight skin; humans' baroreceptors plus PIEZO2 volume receptors and the skeletal-muscle - Bondi mass
The role 'mass of an isolated system' built three ways in general relativity: at spatial infinity (ADM, constant), at null infinity (Bondi, can only fall), for stationary spacetimes (Komar); they agree when there is no radiation. - Bonobo (Pan paniscus)
Telling others how good the food is: chimpanzees vary the acoustic structure of one graded call (rough grunts), bonobos combine different call types into mixed sequences whose composition tracks food quality - Born rigidity
One role (a family keeping its distances) built as boosts (Rindler observers), rotations (a uniformly spinning disk) and the other constant-curvature helices: 'In case all three Frenet-Serret curvatures are constant ... congruences satisfy the condition of Born rigidity'. - Botnet
One job, getting commands to the bots, done by IRC channels, web domains, DGAs, fast-flux, P2P overlays, social sites (GitHub, Twitter, Reddit), XMPP and Tor services. - Bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops)
Telling individuals apart by a name-like label: humans by words, dolphins by an invented whistle contour carried independent of voice; child-directed pitch raised by human and dolphin mothers alike (convergent); keeping echoes at a usable level: dolphins turn their clicks down, bats and sonar turn t - Brand
The job 'tell one source's goods or offspring apart from others, consistent within one source' is done by burnt marks, seals, potters' stamps, tituli picti, hallmarks and logos in human trade, and in nature by host egg signatures against cuckoos, colony hydrocarbon signatures and MHC self-signatures - Brane-world scenario (projected model: our universe as a brane in a higher-dimensional bulk)
Hiding extra dimensions: by small size (Kaluza-Klein, compactification), by large flat volume with matter confined (ADD), or by warped curvature ('protected from the large extra dimension (at low energies) by curvature rather than straightforward compactification', RS). - Bumblebee (Bombus)
Carrying a foraging skill from one animal to another without genes: bumblebees by local and stimulus enhancement plus trial and error; macaques washing potatoes, crows' pandanus tools, great tits' puzzle boxes by their own routes - Bumblebee colony
Rousing nestmates to a food find: honeybees dance the location; bumblebees, with no spatial dance, run excitedly and release a tergal-gland pheromone in the nest. - Bureaucracy
One job, administering people and resources at a distance by written rule, done by scribes on clay tablets (Sumer), exam-recruited scholar-officials (China), proconsuls (Rome), prikazy (Russia), ministries in Kumasi (Asante), the Exchequer (Britain). - Business
The job: pooling outsiders' money with a merchant's work for a venture and sharing the profit. Built as the Old Assyrian merchants' financial contracts with 'local investors involved in financing the risky long-distance trade' (c. 1900 BCE), the Muslim qirad and Italian commenda (investor and travel - Business continuity
Keeping a job done when a part fails, by having a different part able to do it: organisations keep unused capacity, multiple sourcing, parallel processes and alternate sites (Duchek; NIST); in biology, degeneracy lets structurally different elements perform the same function, in the genetic code and - Calabi-Yau manifold
The hidden-shape role built as a Calabi-Yau (six dimensions, superstrings), a G2 manifold (seven, M-theory) or a torus (22, bosonic strings). - Calcium atom
Excitable cells carry the spike with different ions: 'Sodium-based action potentials usually last for under one millisecond, but calcium-based action potentials may last for 100 milliseconds or longer'; single-celled eukaryotes use calcium spikes, animal axons sodium, plants chloride release. - Calculus (the practice of handling change and accumulation by limits, and the structures it works on)
The same two operations are built differently: differentiation by a bacterium's molecular circuit (three alternative topologies realize 'the same concept of signal differentiation'), by finite differences or the chain rule in software, and by a person's rules; integration by a recurrent brainstem ne - Capuchin monkey (Cebus and Sapajus)
One job, opening mechanically protected foods, done by the body in robust capuchins (heavy jaws, sagittal crests) and by held stones in some populations that 'go beyond body limitations'; gracile Cebus mostly lack both - Carbon atom
Turning four protons into one helium-4 in a star: the CNO cycle 'uses nuclei of carbon, nitrogen and oxygen as intermediaries and in the end produces a helium nucleus as with the proton-proton chain'. - Carbon dioxide (CO2)
One job, fixing CO2 into organic carbon, done by different machines: RuBisCO (CO2 + ribulose bisphosphate -> 2 x 3-phosphoglycerate), carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CO2 -> CO, about -0.53 V) and, in methanogens, methanofuran-bound formylation (CO2 + H2 + MF -> HCO-MF). - Casimir effect
One force, two derivations: zero-point energy of the field between the plates, or retarded van der Waals forces between their charges ('can be formulated on the same footing'). - Cauchy momentum equation
The one Cauchy balance gives every non-relativistic momentum equation by choosing the stress: viscous (Navier-Stokes), inviscid (Euler). - Cauchy time (temporal) function
One job (a global clock with Cauchy levels), two builds: Geroch's volume ratio (continuous, maybe not smooth) and Bernal-Sanchez time step functions (smooth, temporal). - Causal (non-spacelike) curve
One job, carrying a causal influence, done by two builds: timelike curves (matter, 'below light speed') and null curves (light); 'causal ... if the tangent vector is timelike or null'. - Causal boundary (c-boundary) and causal completion
Ideal points at infinity built two ways: from indecomposable sets (intrinsic, any strongly causal spacetime) and by conformal rescaling (ad hoc, only some); 'its accessible part ... agrees with the causal boundary'. - Causal future of a set, J+[S]
Edges made of light: the boundary of the future of a set, like the event horizon (the boundary of the past of infinity), is generated by null geodesics. - Causal past of a set, J-[S]
The past of a set as a horizon: drawn from future timelike infinity it is the absolute event horizon. - Cave painting
lighting the dark is done by wooden torches, fat lamps and hearths, each built differently; dating a painting is done by U-series of the crust, AMS radiocarbon of carbon black, or wasp nests over ochre - Cell
Remembering a chemical gradient, built two ways: receptor methylation in prokaryotes; 'Local Excitation Global Inhibition' in eukaryotes. - Cell cycle
The G1/S brake: Whi5 in yeast and Rb in animals both hold the S-phase transcription factor (SBF, E2F) off until CDK phosphorylation removes them, and 'these proteins share no sequence similarity'. The division ring: FtsZ in bacteria, ESCRT-III (CdvA/CdvB) in Sulfolobus, actomyosin furrow or cell pla - Cell lineage (cells descended by division from a founder cell: clones, germline and soma)
One job, making the cells that become the next generation, done by different builds: a germline set aside early in the embryo (bilaterians, mouse primordial germ cells at days 6.25-7.25); gametes from multipotent stem-cell lines that also make soma (sponges, corals); germ cells from old somatic meri - Cell membrane
One job, a closed permeability barrier, done by ester-linked fatty acid bilayers in bacteria and eukaryotes and by ether-linked isoprenoids (some forming a tetraether monolayer) in archaea; light-driven ion transport by unrelated rhodopsin families. - Central bank
One job, providing the economy's highest-quality money and its settlement, done by very different builds: a city's public bank (Barcelona 1401, Amsterdam 1609), a parliament's bank (Riksbank 1668), a private joint-stock company (Bank of England 1694 to 1946), a state-owned bank (Russian Assignation - Central processing unit
The job 'carry out a stored sequence of operations on data' done by relays, tubes, transistors, clocked and clockless logic, Harvard and von Neumann layouts; and the job of computing done by brains with 'massively parallel in-memory computing analogue circuits' instead of 'serial, bit-precise, clock - Centrifugal force
Weight built two ways: by gravity, and by rotation. A centrifuge is 'effectively Archimedes' principle as generated by centrifugal force as opposed to being generated by gravity'; rotating stations would make artificial gravity; local 'gravity' on Earth is already a mix of both. - Cephalopods (octopus, squid, cuttlefish, nautilus)
A brain centre for learning and memory: the octopus vertical lobe (1.8 million inputs onto 25 million amacrines, LTP at the input synapse) beside the vertebrate pallium and hippocampus and the insect mushroom body; Shigeno: 'the best candidate for vertebrate pallium analog within the molluscan linea - Chaos and nonlinear dynamics (the practice, and the chaotic behaviour it studies)
One job, 'going from steady to chaotic by repeated period doubling at the same geometric rate', is done by unlike builds: an iterated quadratic map, a convecting fluid (Libchaber), flour-beetle populations (equilibrium to cycles to chaos), and the Lorenz equations found again in lasers, dynamos and - Chemical bond
Holding atoms together is done by unlike builds: a shared pair (covalent), a handed-over electron and Coulomb attraction (ionic), a sea of electrons shared by all (metallic), a hydrogen between two electronegative atoms, induced dipoles (dispersion), electron pairs in empty Na8 cubes (eight-centre b - Chemical element (the periodic table)
The same job (making new kinds of atom by changing the proton count) is done by six builds: Big Bang fusion, stellar fusion, slow and rapid neutron capture, cosmic-ray spallation, radioactive decay, and the accelerator's fusion-evaporation. - Chemical elements (the set of atomic species, Z = 1 to 118)
Species beyond iron are made by two different builds, slow capture in AGB stars and rapid capture in mergers and supernovae, each giving about half; iron by core-collapse and Type Ia explosions. - Chemical equilibrium
One job, getting a mixture to its equilibrium sooner without moving it, done by unrelated builds: an iron surface in ammonia synthesis, a contact catalyst for SO2 to SO3, the enzyme carbonic anhydrase in blood (o18, o36, o37). Plain words: open the barrier for both directions alike. - Chemical kinetics
Shared job in plain words: making a reaction go faster by offering another path, and coming out unchanged. Done by proteins (enzymes, o90), by metal and cloud surfaces (o56), by dissolved catalysts, by single atoms (chlorine in ozone loss, o53), and by a reaction's own product (autocatalysis, o24). - Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes)
Getting termites out of a mound: probes made from twigs at Gombe and elsewhere, bare hands at Tai (same job, different builds across communities) - Chinese art
keeping the dead's household and rank in the tomb done by different builds: ritual bronze sets sized to rank, jade suits to preserve body and souls, and pottery figures that replaced actual sacrifices; bronze vessel shapes also made in pottery - Chloroplast
One job, keeping CO2 high around Rubisco, done by unrelated builds: the glaucophyte carboxysome, the green-algal and hornwort pyrenoid ('functionally similar to the glaucophyte carboxysome'), C4 plants' split between mesophyll and bundle-sheath chloroplasts, and CAM. - Chordate (Chordata)
Giving the swimming muscles something to push against: in most invertebrates 'the constraint of internal fluids and soft tissues by a rigid or elastic body wall'; in chordates 'an internal rod, the notochord, which functions as a flexible compression strut' (src:annona-2015-notochord). Spiders and a - Chromatin
One job, packing a genome: histone octamers in eukaryotes, stacked single-type histone dimers (hypernucleosomes) in archaea, nucleoid-associated proteins (H-NS, StpA) in bacteria, protamines in sperm. - Circular orbit around a compact object
The circular orbit built for massive particles (stable and unstable bands) and for light (the photon orbit at 1.5 r_s); spin splits it into prograde and retrograde builds. - Circulatory system
Oxygen carriage met by unrelated builds: iron haemoglobin in vertebrate red cells, copper haemocyanin in arthropod and most mollusc hemolymph, and in insects no carrier at all, the tracheae taking air 'directly' to the tissues. - Civilization
Keeping administrative records is done by writing in most civilizations and by knotted cords (quipu) in the Inca state. - Climate change
Three stores take the heat: ocean about 90%, land about 5%, ice about 3%, air about 1% (AR6), and three sinks take the CO2: air, ocean and land, each with its own mechanism and speed. - Climate system (climate)
Storing the imbalance: ocean (89%), land (6%), ice (4%, as melt), air (1%). Carrying heat poleward: the atmosphere's cells and the ocean's thermohaline circulation. - Clock transport
Distant clocks are compared by carrying a clock or by signals; slow transport round the world gives 207 ns, 'equal to the time difference that is found for a relay of pulses'. - Closed null curve
One role, marking where closed timelike curves begin, built three ways: Misner's flat loop t = 0, Goedel's non-geodesic circle at r_c, and the closed null geodesic generators of a Cauchy horizon. - Cloud computing
Keeping tenants on one machine apart is done by a hypervisor running VMs as guests, by containers on one kernel (cgroups and namespaces), and by a chroot jail in Borg. - CNO cycle (carbon-nitrogen-oxygen cycle)
The CNO cycle 'is one of the two known sets of fusion reactions by which stars convert hydrogen to helium, the other being the proton-proton chain'; the CNO build replaces the pp chain's weak two-proton step with captures on borrowed catalysts. - Coframe field
The metric can be carried by a vector frame or by its dual coframe: 'Whether this is used to obtain the metric tensor after writing down the frame (and passing to the dual coframe), or starting with the metric tensor ... it must always hold true'. - Columbian Exchange
The job 'the staple that feeds a population' done by unrelated plants: potatoes in Ireland and eastern Europe, cassava in Africa (replacing sorghum and millet), maize and sweet potatoes in China; and honey made by Maya stingless bees (Melipona, Trigona) and by European Apis mellifera. - Combinatorics: the practice of counting, arranging and choosing finite structures (permutations, combinations, partitions, designs, graphs), the structures it studies, and the people and machines who work with them
One job, arranging 36 items so every row and column holds one of each rank and each regiment, is impossible with discrete officers and done with entangled ones: orthogonal quantum Latin squares meet the role with a different build. - Comet
Slowing the solar wind into a shock ahead of an obstacle: Earth, Jupiter, Saturn and Neptune do it with their own magnetic fields; comets, Mars and Venus do it with a field induced in ionised gas ('comets have no magnetic field. Like Mars and Venus, comets are said to have an induced magnetosphere') - Communication: the passing of messages between senders and receivers through a channel (and, on other readings, the making of meaning between them), and communication studies, the field that studies it
One job, getting information from a sender to a receiver so that the receiver's behaviour changes, done with different builds: crickets' songs, moths' pheromones, fireflies' flashes, bees' dance, weakly electric fishes' fields, seismic drumming, maple volatiles, bacterial autoinducers, human speech, - Compact extra dimensions
The role 'hide the extra dimensions' built differently: small size (circle, torus, Calabi-Yau, G2, orbifold) or confinement to a membrane with large or warped bulk (ADD, Randall-Sundrum). - Competition for a solute's hydrogen-bond sites (possible only)
Two ways to take water off a solute bond: burial in a hydrophobic core ('Minimizing the number of hydrophobic side chains exposed to water is the principal driving force behind folding') and, for a bond left exposed (a dehydron), binding of a protein or ligand that strips the water ('Dehydrons promo - Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA)
Removing the 2'-hydroxyl from a ribonucleotide by a radical, built three ways: an iron (or manganese) tyrosyl radical (class I, aerobic), a cobalamin radical (class II), a glycyl radical (class III, anaerobic only). - Compiler
Turning a high-level description into the parts a substrate runs is done by builds that share nothing physical: compilers to machine code, hardware compilers to transistors or lookup tables, and the Seesaw Compiler to DNA strands. Inside the compiler, register allocation is done by graph colouring o - Computational physics (computer simulation of physical systems: the practice and the simulated systems it stands for)
Running a physical scene forward to predict it is done by machines (numerical integration on computers) and by brains (an intuitive physics engine of approximate, probabilistic simulations), which the source likens to game engines. - Computer
The two-state element (the relay job) built from locked wheels, telegraph relays, vacuum tubes, cathode-ray tubes, transistors; the store built from punched cards, mercury delay lines, Williams tubes, DRAM. - Computer ethics
The job: make someone answer for harm done with a technology. Medicine does it with fiduciary duties, licensing and malpractice law; computing with professional codes and accident analysis; AI with voluntary principles; ICT research with ethical impact assessment and review boards; value sensitive d - Computer hardware
One job, holding a bit, done by unrelated builds over 90 years: steel plates in the Z1, relays, sound waves in mercury delay lines, spots on a Williams tube, capacitors in DRAM, cross-coupled flip-flops in SRAM, trapped charge in flash, magnetic domains on disks. Switching likewise: steel plates, re - Computer law
The same job, protecting personal data, built three ways: a comprehensive EU regulation, US sectoral laws with no comprehensive statute, and China's PIPL shaped by its own aims; software patents met by a ban, no limits, or a line between mathematics and embodiments. - Computer memory
One job, holding a bit until it is read back, done by unrelated structures: charge on a capacitor (DRAM), a cross-coupled flip-flop (SRAM), electrons on a floating gate (flash), the direction of a ferrite core's magnetization, a sound pulse recirculating in mercury, a charge spot on a CRT face, a co - Computer network
Sharing one medium among many senders is done by listening and backing off on a cable (CSMA/CD), by acknowledgment on radio (CSMA/CA), by passing a token round a ring (Token Ring, FDDI), and by dividing frequency and space (spectrum allocation). Regulating outflow by the rate of returns is done by T - Computer science (the field: the practice and the computation it studies)
One job, computing, met by people with paper, gears (Schickard, Babbage), relays and electronics, and DNA strands (Adleman): 'independently of the type of information carrier'. - Computer security
The job: tell what belongs to the body from dangerous outsiders, and remove the outsiders. Done by peptides on MHC in the immune system and by short sequences of system calls in a computer: 'distinguishing self from dangerous nonself' (Forrest et al.), who borrow distributed detection, imperfect mat - Computer-aided design
One job, holding a solid so every geometric question can be answered, done by unrelated structures: boundary representation, constructive solid geometry, spatial enumeration (voxels), implicit functions; all 'different ways of organizing the same geometric and topological data'. Also pointing: light - Condensed matter physics
Reading internal magnetism is done by unrelated probes: neutrons (moment scattered by unpaired electrons), muons (implanted spins precessing in the local field), magnetic X-ray diffraction and RIXS, NMR. Each is a different build for one job: telling where the spins point and how they move. - Contract
One job, holding a trade to its terms against cheating, done by courts and damages (legal contract), by code on a blockchain (smart contract), by reputation (repeat dealing), by sanctions and partner choice (legumes cutting off non-fixing rhizobia), and by joint commitment (great apes resuming inter - Coordinate time
One role (a time label for orbit computations) built in different frames: barycentric (TCB, TDB), geocentric (TCG, TT), comoving (cosmic time). - Core of the trapped region (Z)
One job, the surface of a black hole, now five builds: event horizon, all MTTs, B, a preferred MTT, and the core's boundary. - Coriolis force
Rotation sensing built two ways on two media: mechanically through the Coriolis term (Foucault pendulum, vibrating flow tubes, fly halteres) and optically through the Sagnac phase of light sent both ways round a rotating ring (ring-laser and fibre gyroscopes). - Corporate law
Overseeing the managers is done by a single board elected by shareholders (US, UK) or by a supervisory board that picks the management board, with workers electing up to almost half its seats (Germany). - Corporation
The job of holding business assets apart from owners' other debts was done by different builds: the Roman family and the slave-run peculium, the societas publicanorum, the medieval compagnia, the Medici's hub-and-spoke of separate partnerships, the chartered joint-stock company, the modern corporati - Cosmic dust
The one job of making grain cores is done by differently built factories: cool oxygen-rich red giants (silicates), carbon stars (carbon), supernova interiors (several percent, graphite even in oxygen-rich gas), novae, R Coronae Borealis stars, and Type Ia ejecta meeting interstellar matter. - Cosmic microwave background
A relic background filling all space is built by different carriers: photons (this background, released at 379,000 years) and neutrinos (the cosmic neutrino background, decoupled at about one second); the cosmic background radiation article sorts the electromagnetic ones by band and says 'See also c - Cosmic neutrino background
A relic background filling all space, built by neutrinos here and by photons in the CMB: 'while the CMB dates from when the universe was 379,000 years old, the CnuB decoupled from matter when the universe was just one second old'. - Cosmic rays
One job (accelerating the flux), several builds: supernova-remnant shocks, active galactic nuclei (centrifugal or shock acceleration), young fast-spinning neutron stars and magnetars for iron nuclei, and accretion shocks after z ~ 10. - Cosmic time
Several clocks for one history: cosmic time, temperature, redshift, particle horizon and Hubble horizon all date the universe; only cosmic time 'is blind to the expansion'. - Cosmic topology
Finite with no edge built two ways: 'the 3-sphere is simply connected and has positive curvature, whereas the 3-torus is multiply connected and flat'. - Cosmological component
One role (a term in the Friedmann budget), many carriers: photons and neutrinos, baryons and dark matter, the vacuum, even curvature and topological defects, each sorted only by w. - Cosmological distance measure (distance measures in cosmology)
One role (a distance to an object at redshift z), several builds: from flux (standard candles, d_L), from angular size (standard rulers, d_A), from parallax (local), all tied by d_L = (1+z)^2 d_A. - Covalent bond
One job, holding two atoms together by shared electrons, is done by different builds: a two-electron pair (H2), one electron (H2+, Li2+ stronger than Li2), three electrons (He2+, O2's two three-electron bonds), a pair from one atom (dative: H3N-BH3, metal complexes), a pair over three centres (dibor - Critical infrastructure
One job, 'keep the services a society cannot do without flowing and protected', done by different national builds: 16 US sectors with lead agencies, 10 Canadian sectors, Germany's KRITIS under the interior ministry, the EU's ECI with Operator Security Plans; and inside each, the five resilience prin - Cryptographic hash function
One job, 'take any message and give a short fixed fingerprint that is hard to forge', done by an ARX compression function chained Merkle-Damgard style (SHA-2) and by a bit-permutation sponge (SHA-3), chosen on purpose to differ. Across domains, the job 'make similar inputs come out very different' i - Cryptography
One job, telling a genuine sender from a forger and keeping meaning from outsiders, done by unrelated structures: factoring (RSA), discrete logarithms (Diffie-Hellman), lattices (ML-KEM), quantum states (QKD), a language few outsiders speak (Navajo code). Across domains: drongo egg 'signatures' agai - Crystal
Skin colour change done two ways: most vertebrates move pigment-containing organelles; chameleons retune a lattice of guanine nanocrystals (a photonic crystal). And gravity sensing by a dense mass: calcite otoconia in mammals, reptiles and birds; aragonite otoliths in many fish. - Culture
One job, carrying behaviour between generations without genes, done by unrelated builds: tandem-running ants, bumblebees, fruit flies, fish, birds, whales and apes - Curriculum
One job, making a hard thing learnable by ordering it easy to hard, done by unrelated builds: the Nippur scribes' four stages from three wedges to sentences, school prerequisites, machine-learning curricula 'from the easy samples to the hard ones', reinforcement-learning task sequences, and a rodent - Cyanobacterium (Cyanobacteria, phylum Cyanobacteriota)
One job, keeping nitrogenase away from the cell's own oxygen, done by different builds: a separate walled cell (heterocyst) in space, and night-time fixation in time ('using different methods to circumvent the deleterious effect of dioxygen on nitrogenases'). Also staying at the right depth: gas ves - Cyber threat intelligence
One job, telling others who face the same danger what you saw of it, done by unrelated builds: CTI sharing among organisations (feeds, ISACs), epidemic intelligence systems pooling internet reports of outbreaks (one system 38-72% sensitivity, pooled 93%), and birds and monkeys eavesdropping on other - Cybercrime and its underground economy
One job, taking what someone else has already gathered rather than finding it oneself, done by unrelated builds: kleptoparasites stealing food other animals found (spiders, birds, snails, lizards, fish, primates, carnivores, insects) and cybercriminals taking money and data others earned and stored; - Cyberwarfare
One job, punishing a state for a cyber attack, done by unrelated builds: a cyber attack back (US on Iranian weapons systems, June 2019), economic sanctions (EO 13694, 13757), a kinetic strike (IDF, 5 May 2019), quiet punishment known only to the rival's leaders, or public blame. - d'Alembert force (rectilinear inertial force)
A uniform mass-proportional pull built by acceleration (-m a) and by gravity; 'All fictitious forces are proportional to the mass ... which is also true for gravity'. - D-brane (projected model)
One object two ways: at weak coupling a boundary condition for open strings, at strong coupling a black p-brane of supergravity, and in string field theory a lump of the tachyon field. - Dark energy
The job of speeding up the expansion is met by unrelated builds in the literature: a constant energy of empty space, a light scalar field rolling in a potential (quintessence, k-essence, tachyon, phantom), a coupled dark sector, a QCD-vacuum term tracking H with no field at all, or gravity itself ch - Data centre
Keeping chips below their temperature limit is done by unrelated builds: outdoor air straight in, air through a heat exchanger, chilled water from compressors, evaporating towers, seawater (Hamina's paper-mill site), liquid to the chip or immersion. Riding through a grid dip is done by batteries (st - Data structure
One job, different builds: storing a sequence with an array (address arithmetic) or a linked list (stored addresses); the same lookup done by hash tables, search trees or a learned model; in brains, an index for memories made of hippocampal barcodes (chickadee). - Database
Keeping a business's history so it can be checked and undone: double-entry books on clay and paper, punched-card master runs, logging plus locking, and time-domain addressing ('two apparently different approaches to implementing the transaction concept'). Also: an email system 'performs many of the - de Sitter family of quasinormal modes
The slowest-decay role filled by different families in different ranges (de Sitter for small holes, photon-sphere for large, near-extremal near maximal charge). - Degenerate matter
Holding a dead core against gravity is done in turn by electron degeneracy (white dwarf), then neutron degeneracy plus strong repulsion (neutron star), perhaps quark degeneracy in cores. - Denial-of-service attack
One job, denying a service to its users, done by unrelated builds: filling a link (floods), filling a backlog (SYN), holding connections (slow POST), driving a hash table to its worst case, crashing the kernel with one packet, flashing bad firmware, occupying phone lines. In nature a tiger moth deni - Desert ant (Cataglyphis)
Holding a heading: polarised skylight, the sun, steady wind and the Earth's magnetic field each serve as a compass, weighed against each other - Differential form
A field strength as the curvature of a connection, built two ways: abelian F = dA (electromagnetism) and non-abelian F = dA + A ^ A (Yang-Mills). - Digestive system (the gut and its accessory organs)
moving content along a tube: Hydra's nerve net, the vertebrate ENS, and sea urchin larval sphincters under light - Digital forensics
One job, 'keep the original unchanged while reading it', done by unrelated builds: a hardware write blocker for drives, a Faraday bag for phones, a hash computed before and after for anything that cannot be blocked, and working only on a copy of the copy. A second job, 'find what happened from the t - Digital identity
One job, showing that one particular subject stands behind an account, done by unrelated builds: passwords and certificates through a provider, behavioural history scored against the past, signed claims on a ledger, other people vouching that one living human holds one identity, and a state's papers - Digital signatures and certificates
One job, marking one's own so a checker can tell it from a stranger's, done by unrelated builds: the handwritten signature (a motor gesture), name-seals, thumbprints, the digital signature (a trap-door function), and in bacteria host-dependent DNA methylation, where the cell's own DNA carries the ma - Dijkgraaf-Witten model (topological gauge theory with a finite gauge group; walked as an idea)
One topological order, two constructions: a Z2 x Z2 x Z2 theory with a special 3-cocycle and an ordinary gauge theory with the dihedral group of order eight (dual, 1995); built in 2024 by gauging a Z2^3 SPT and identified as D(D4) order. - Dilaton (projected model; hypothetical scalar)
A constant of nature as a field's settled value: the string coupling 'is the expectation value of a field ... just like the spacetime metric ... (or, indeed, like the Higgs vev)'. - Dinosaurs (Dinosauria)
Holding the legs under the body: dinosaurs do it with 'a laterally facing recess in the pelvis ... and a corresponding inwardly facing distinct head on the femur'; rauisuchians 'also had erect limbs but achieved this by a "pillar-erect" configuration of the hip joint', the ilium 'rotated to form an - Discrete rotational symmetry (n-fold, C_n)
One abstract group, three geometric builds: point groups 1-bar, 2 and m 'contain different geometric symmetry operations (inversion, rotation, and reflection, respectively) but all share the structure of the cyclic group C2'. - Dissolved ferrous iron (Fe2+, notably in the early ocean)
One job (the divalent ion that folds RNA and runs translation) is done by Mg2+ today and by Fe2+ (or Mn2+) under anoxic conditions: 'the roles of Mg2+ in RNA folding and function can indeed be served by Fe2+'; Fe2+ and Mn2+ 'can replace Mg2+ as the dominant divalent cation during translation'. - Domestic dog (Canis familiaris)
Detecting warm bodies' thermal radiation: dog's cold rhinarium, pit vipers' pit organs, vampire bats, a fire beetle - Domesticated germline (crop and livestock lines held and propagated by people)
Other domesticators run the role with other builds: leafcutter ants (Atta: 'complete; it took 30 million years'), fungus-growing termites ('exactly once, 25-40 mya', 'fully obligate symbiosis on both sides'), ambrosia beetles, and damselfish farming algae fertilised by mysid shrimp. - Drainage basin (watershed)
Holding water and letting it out later is done in one basin by peat soils (828-840 mm in the top metre), groundwater in fractured rock and drift, riparian wetlands that set the transit-time distribution, beaver dam cascades and, in people's basins, reservoirs: one job, unrelated builds. - Drama (the literary form)
the comic piece between serious plays: the Greek satyr play after three tragedies, kyōgen between Noh plays; the stock clown in Sanskrit drama (vidusaka), kyōgen and commedia dell'arte - Dynamical horizon
One job (a growth law for black holes) on two boundaries: the event horizon's area theorem (qualitative, global) and the dynamical horizon's area balance law (quantitative, quasi-local, exact in the non-linear regime). - Early childhood education
One job, many builds: helping a young child learn through its own activity with an adult who supports rather than directs is done by Froebel's gifts and free work, Montessori's prepared environment and freely chosen work, Reggio's hundred languages with documentation, HighScope's shared control, and - Earth in the Paleozoic era (Cambrian to Permian)
Oxygen held by two builds in one era: an early-Cambrian marine burial see-saw ('This cycle was repeated several times') and, after land plants, 'a permanent shift in regulatory regime' to fire-mediated negative feedbacks. - Earth in the Proterozoic eon (2500 to 538.8 Ma)
Fixing carbon with light, built three ways in the sources: cyanobacteria splitting water and releasing oxygen; purple bacteria using hydrogen sulfide and releasing sulfur; and earlier archaeal retinal pumps absorbing green light. - Earth's core
One job, keeping a magnetic field alive for ages, done by different conductors: liquid iron in Earth's core, ionised gas at the Sun's tachocline, conducting fluids in Mercury and the Jovian planets. - Earthquake
One job, storing energy and letting it go all at once so that something moves, done by a sliding block on a lathe, an animal's jump and a fault (Bejan's store-and-release rhythm). - Ecological succession
The same job, refilling an opened site in stages, done by microbes on leaves, guts and till and by plants on dunes and lava: 'like many plant communities, microbial communities also exhibit predictable patterns during primary succession'. - Economics (the field)
One job, allocating the factors of production, done by market prices or by central planning (the calculation debate); one job, measuring income growth, done by national accounts or by lights seen from space. - Education
One job, passing what a group knows to its novices, done by unrelated builds: Aka caregivers' natural pedagogy by touch and showing, apprenticeship in guilds, Confucian state examinations, madrasas, yeshivas and Aztec mandatory schooling - Einstein constraint equations
One job (restrict the slice's data so it can be evolved), two builds: a scalar from varying the lapse (Gauss equation) and a vector from varying the shift (Codazzi equation). - Einstein pseudotensor
Einstein's mixed, asymmetric pseudotensor and Landau-Lifshitz's symmetric one are different structures doing one job (the field's energy-momentum); for every Kerr-Schild metric they give the same energy, momentum and angular-momentum distributions. - Einstein synchronisation
Light round trips and slow clock transport give 'the same synchronisation'; 'The literature discusses many other thought experiments for clock synchronisation giving the same result.' - Einstein-Cartan-Sciama-Kibble bounce (spinor-torsion big bounce)
One role, turning contraction into expansion without a singularity, built from spinor-torsion coupling here, from quantum geometry in LQC, from a ghost-condensate scalar in the matter bounce. - Ekpyrotic universe (colliding-brane origin of the hot Big Bang; hypothetical)
One job (solve horizon, flatness and monopole problems and make nearly scale-invariant perturbations) done by a slow contraction with w >> 1 instead of inflation's fast expansion with w ~ -1: 'without inflation'. - Election
One job, filling public office from among the people, done by different builds: voice voting (Sparta 754 BC), potsherds, allotment machines (Athens' kleroteria), palm leaves drawn from a pot (Chola Uthiramerur, about 920 CE), paper ballots, electronic machines. - Electric circuit
one job, store charge and let it leak (a resistor beside a capacitor), built from metal and dielectric in electronics, from lipid membrane and ion channels in neurons (copied in silicon), from elastic artery and peripheral vessels in the Windkessel, and as resistive living wires in cable bacteria - Electrical grid
Holding the frequency in the first seconds is done by the rotating mass of synchronous machines, by grid-forming inverters that set voltage and frequency like a synchronous machine, and by batteries; black start is done by small diesels, by hydro plants, and (2017) by a battery. - Electrochemical gradient
The job, pushing protons to one side of a membrane, done by unrelated builds: redox pumps that carry protons through the protein (respiratory complexes), vectorial chemistry that binds protons on one side and releases them on the other without carrying them (photosystem II), a light-driven retinal p - Electron
Holding a dead star up against gravity: 'the degeneracy pressure of electrons balances gravity' in white dwarfs; for more massive stars 'the star compresses until neutron degeneracy pressure resists gravity, forming a neutron star'. - Electronics
one job, a small signal steering a much larger current, done by a heated cathode and grid in vacuum, by a base current in a bipolar junction, by an insulated gate's field in a MOSFET, by ions in an electrolyte gating an organic channel, and by a vacuum channel shorter than electrons' mean free path - Electroweak interaction
One start, two builds of the carrier role: 'four massless electroweak vector bosons, each similar to the photon'; after breaking, one stays massless with infinite range (photon) and three become massive and short-range (W+, W-, Z). - Elliptic Moebius transformation (a rotation of the celestial sphere)
A rotation built two ways: an orthogonal 3x3 matrix turning space, and an elliptic Moebius map turning the sky. - Elliptic space
One manifold, two jobs: elliptic 3-space is a candidate shape of space for a closed universe and is also the shape of the set of orientations of a rigid body (SO(3) homeomorphic to RP3). - Emotion (feelings)
One shared job (a scalable, persistent, valenced state that outlasts its trigger and steers behaviour) built in flies (shadow-driven running and hopping), rats (tickle and 50 kHz calls) and humans (felt emotion), 'even if the species-typical behaviors that express them are not' shared. - End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released
One role (holding body heat against volcanic-winter cold) met by two builds that both came through: dinosaurs' protofeather-like insulation and mammaliaforms' fur with a higher metabolic rate. - Endoplasmic reticulum
Driving a chain through the translocon channel: eukaryotes pull it in with BiP (Sec62/Sec63 helping BiP use ATP), bacteria push it with the SecA ATPase ('push-and-slide'). - Engine
Turning energy into mechanical work: heat engines (piston, turbine, jet, rocket), electric, pneumatic, hydraulic and clockwork motors, and in cells protein molecular motors that run on ATP inside the thermal bath. Seifert separates two classes: 'isothermal ones like molecular motors, and heat engine - Engineering design process
One job, narrowing a space of possible designs to one that works under uncertainty, done by different structures: a funnel with gates (Stage-Gate), decomposition and integration (Vee), short reintegrated cycles (agile), several designs kept per subsystem (SBCE), and in microbes the DBTL cycle with s - English language: a West Germanic language of the Indo-European family, from its Old English beginnings to its varieties and its use as a global lingua franca, as linguistics and its history describe it
Marking who did what to whom: done by case endings in Old English, by fixed subject-verb-object order and prepositions (of) in Modern English; large languages use lexical strategies where small ones inflect. - English literature
one job, getting a work to many hearers or readers, done by unrelated builds: the open-roof playhouse (about 5,000 places in London c. 1580), the printed book (from 1476), the monthly part (Pickwick, 1836-37), the circulating library, BBC radio drama (from the 1920s) - Enteric nervous system
Setting the rhythm of gut contractions: non-neural ICC in mammals, prototypical pacemaker neurons in Hydra, with a conserved gene program (ANO1, SCN, TRPM channels) - Entrepreneurship
The job 'bear unmeasurable uncertainty to try something new' is done by unrelated structures: a lone founder's savings, a VC fund's portfolio of staged equity, a corporation's intrapreneurship unit, a cooperative or social enterprise, a state's grant programme. - Entropy
One job, turning sunlight into free energy, done by different builds with different tolls: the Earth's physical heat engines under 1% (o47), photosynthesis under 3% (o46), solar panels about 20% 'because they are not heat engines' (o75, o76). - Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies)
One job, warning people of a harmful change in their surroundings before it reaches them, done by unrelated builds: a caged canary, a water flea read by omics, an infrared CO2 analyser, a satellite spectrometer, a blood test - Enzyme
Biocatalysis by proteins, by RNA (ribozymes) and by condensates; and 'Unrelated enzymes that have the same enzymatic activity have been called non-homologous isofunctional enzymes.' - Epic poetry
the job of keeping and singing a people's long tale is done by Greek aoidoi and rhapsodes, South Slavic guslars, Kyrgyz manaschi, hereditary Mande griots and Celtic bards; the epic line by hexameter, alliterative verse, the shloka or Sumerian repetition and parallelism - Ergosurface (static limit)
The static limit is the event horizon in Schwarzschild ('Within this surface, no observer/particle can maintain itself at a constant radius ... sometimes called the static limit') and a separate surface outside the horizon in Kerr. - Erosion
One job, taking surface material away and carrying it elsewhere, is done by unrelated agents: rain splash and runoff, river flow, sliding ice, wind, waves, gravity, groundwater solution, boring sponges and people. Each has its own detachment physics (splash craters, shear thresholds, plucking, the f - Essay
one job, testing what a candidate can reason and write under set conditions, done by the Ming-Qing eight-legged essay (for government service), US/UK exam essays and university admission essays, and US federal job KSAs: separate builds of the same role - Eternal Emergent Universe
Holding the Einstein static balance: matter plus Lambda (Einstein 1917), radiation plus Lambda (Harrison), or a scalar field rolling at constant speed on a flat potential (here; 'dynamically ... a stiff fluid plus cosmological constant'). - Ethics (moral philosophy: the study and the morality it studies)
One job, protesting a partner's better reward, done in capuchins, macaques, chimpanzees, dogs and crows; its spread follows cooperation with non-kin, not ancestry. And in the theory: different schools reach the same verdict by different justifications. - Ethnic group
One job, marking who belongs, done by unrelated builds: language (ethno-linguistic), phenotype (ethno-racial), religion, polity, region, culture; and Tongan motifs, accents, faces all serve as markers. - Euclidean distance
One job (how far apart) done by different rules: Euclidean, taxicab, Chebyshev, geodesic distances. - Event horizon of a non-rotating black hole
One-way black-hole boundary built two ways: here at r_s where g_tt also changes sign; in Kerr at the larger root of Delta = 0 with the g_tt flip on the ergosurface. - Event horizon of a rotating black hole
One-way black-hole boundary built two ways: at r_s where g_tt also flips (Schwarzschild), or at the larger root of Delta = 0 with the g_tt flip moved out to the ergosurface (Kerr). - Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea)
Plain job: keeping the costly matter small. Built in space as a thin shell at the joint of two flat spaces (Visser) and in time as 'flashes' of violation: 'the temporal analogue of the spatial confinement of exotic matter to an infinitesimally thin shell'. - Experiment, measurement and uncertainty (the physics lab as a practice: designing, measuring, estimating error)
Guarding a result against the experimenter's expectations: double-blind randomised trials in medicine (patients and clinicians blind), hidden signal boxes and hidden offsets in particle physics, a machinist's hidden angle (Dunnington), a mass known only to 1% (the Irvine gravity group). - Exterior field of an ordinary star (the Sun)
Reading the Sun's exterior four ways: deflection, delay, perihelion shift, redshift; deflection and delay test the same parameter gamma. - Extracellular matrix
Multicellularity evolved independently in different lineages, so ECM composition varies, yet cell adhesion, communication and differentiation are common functions (EPS in biofilms, glycoproteins in Volvox, cellulose walls in plants, collagen in animals); the basement membrane may have separate origi - Extremely accelerated observers (first torsion zero)
Keeping gyroscope axes: in general the Fermi-Walker frame does it; on these orbits the orbit's own Frenet-Serret frame does it (up to a boost), as on hyperbolic motion where 'the Frenet-Serret formulas and Fermi-Walker formulas produce the same tetrad'. - Eye
Forming an image is done by a graded lens of protein (vertebrates, cephalopods, box jellyfish), a lens of aragonite (chitons), calcite (trilobites, per the encyclopedia, itself contested there), a concave mirror (scallops, spookfish), thousands of small facets (compound eyes) or a pinhole pit; ten b - F-theory (projected model)
Exceptional gauge symmetry built two ways: from singular fibres where 7-branes meet in F-theory, and from the E8 x E8 current algebra of the heterotic string ('otherwise realized only in the heterotic string'). - Family (the human family as a system)
One role (being a family: producing and caring for persons) built from blood, from marriage, from living together and sharing food (milk kinship), or from care alone ('feel and function like a family'). - Federalism
One job, letting local parts decide for themselves while a centre handles what all share, met by unrelated builds: the federation (constitutional division between two governments), anarchist council federalism (higher units only the expression of lower units delegating), the octopus (a central brain - Feebly distinguishing spacetime
Causal continuity's first ingredient can be distinction or feeble distinction: two different rungs doing the same job with reflectivity. - Fermi normal coordinates
One role (making spacetime look flat locally) built about a point (Riemann normal coordinates: 'a constructive proof of the local flatness theorem') and about a whole curve (FNC: 'local flatness on the entire curve' when gamma is a geodesic); the Rindler chart is the flat-space accelerated build. - Fermi-Walker tetrad
A standard of non-rotation built two ways: by the transport rule D_F X/ds = 0 and physically by 'a system of three gyroscopes' (GP-B's gyroscopes in orbit). - Ferrous iron in the ocean (the reservoir)
The oxygen sink was held by several reductant pools at once: oxygen 'depleted all the surface reducing capacity from ferrous iron, sulfur, hydrogen sulfide and atmospheric methane'. - Fictitious force
Mass-proportional acceleration built two ways: by the frame's acceleration (fictitious forces) and by gravity; 'All fictitious forces are proportional to the mass ... which is also true for gravity', so a closed box cannot tell them apart. - Financial statement
One job, different structures: reporting a period's result is done by the income statement in companies and by a statement of activities in charities; showing ability to pay was done by the 1863 comparison balance sheet, the 1973 sources-and-uses-of-funds statement and, from 1987, the cash flow stat - Finite-time Emergent Universe
Ending the static phase: a tachyonic roll, quantum tunnelling, or a cooling-driven change of the potential, three different triggers for one exit. - Firewall (computing)
One job, letting only wanted traffic cross between two compartments that trust each other differently and stopping harm from spreading, done by unrelated builds: a fire-rated wall between building compartments; the mesenteric lymph nodes and then the liver stopping gut microbes from reaching the bod - Firm (the economic unit)
One job, coordinating production, done by two unrelated builds: prices across a market and administrative direction inside a firm; and, across domains, a division of labour among microbes built by gene loss (the Black Queen) where firms build it by contract. - Fish
Shared job: moving fast through water with a streamlined body. Fish and, separately, cetaceans and ichthyosaurs built the same fish-like shape. And electric sensing: non-homologous electroreceptors evolved again and again - Fish school (shoal)
Keeping station in the school is done by vision in most fish, by the lateral line in blinded saithe, by antennae in krill; loss of schooling ran through vision in cave Astyanax and through the lateral line in benthic sticklebacks. - Fishery
Keeping a shared fish stock from being fished down by everyone taking more, done by different builds: Maori limits on take; North Norwegian fields allocated by local committees; transferable quotas (Iceland 1984/1990, Alaska halibut 1995); fishers counting arapaima to set quotas with the state; excl - Five-dimensional spacetime (Kaluza-Klein)
One extra dimension hidden two ways: small and flat (Kaluza-Klein circle) or warped with matter confined to a brane (Randall-Sundrum). - Fluid dynamics (the flows of liquids and gases, and the practice of describing them)
Efficient undulatory swimming: 53 species of mammals, sharks, scombrids, other fishes, amphibians and reptiles, with lunate tails or elongated bodies, all swim near the predicted optimum Strouhal number. Second form: Murray's minimum-work branching is met by animal vessels, insect tracheae and plant - Fluid equations of motion
One role (momentum balance of a fluid) built three ways: inviscid Newtonian (Euler), viscous Newtonian (Navier-Stokes), relativistic ideal (relativistic Euler). - Fold (geology)
Keeping rock volume while the layers shorten is done by flexural slip, by buckling with thickening, by dissolving and redepositing material, or by passive flow. Resisting deflection is done by an elastic foundation or by gravity, with the same mathematical term. - Formal security policy model
The job 'say exactly what a computer may allow, and show that it keeps to it' built as a state machine with a basic security theorem (Bell-LaPadula), an automaton with inputs and outputs (noninterference), certified transformation procedures with separation of duty (Clark-Wilson), access history (Br - Fossil
One job, sealing the remains away from decay so their form outlasts them, done by unrelated builds: a microbial mat's EPS sarcophagus, bed-capping carbonate cement, a siderite nodule the body's own decay makes, tree resin hardened to amber, an overgrowing oyster or bryozoan skeleton. - Four-gradient
Differentiation built two ways: the comma (partial, flat) and the semi-colon (covariant, curved), joined by Christoffel symbols. - Four-vector
One vector form carries many payloads by one rule: energy-momentum (P = m0 U), charge flow (J), baryon flow (S = nU), waves (k, null for light), forces (F = dP/dtau). - Four-velocity
One vector carries three payloads by one rule: mass (P = m_o U), charge (J = rho_o U), number (N = nU); 'the gamma factor combines with the Lorentz scalar term to make the 4th independent component'. - Four-wavevector
One vector carries light waves (null, K = (omega/c)(1, n)) and matter waves (timelike, |K| = m0 c / hbar): 'four-wavevector applied to matter waves as well as to light waves'. - Fourier analysis (the practice of splitting signals into waves and rebuilding them, and the structure it works on)
Frequency analysis done by different builds: the mammalian basilar membrane, insect tympana with travelling waves (grig, bushcrickets; 'frequency discrimination is not unique to vertebrates', src:woodrow-2022), a glass lens or metalens (src:wp:fourier-optics; src:metasurface-4f-2022), the FFT on a c - Fraction (parts of a whole): the ratio sense, the practice of fractions, and the rational numbers they name
Judging which mix gives the better draw from relative frequency is done by kea and by great apes and human infants, in brains 'with a highly different structure from primates' (convergent). - Free will
One job, injecting controlled variability into motor output, done by different builds: the fly's ellipsoid body (walking), downstream central-brain neurons (optomotor head turns), Aplysia's feeding circuit, and the vertebrate motor cortex adding variability to the spinal stretch reflex. - Frenet-Serret (TNB) frame
A comoving frame built from the curve's own derivatives (rotating) versus held by a gyroscope (inertial): the top 'will be observed to rotate' against the Frenet-Serret frame. - Frenet-Serret tetrad (comoving tetrad of a world line)
A comoving frame built two ways on one line: from the curve's own derivatives (Frenet-Serret, rotating) or held fixed by gyroscopes (Fermi-Walker, non-rotating); the two differ by the rotation omega = kappa_3 e(1) + kappa_2 e(3). - Fruit fly (Drosophila melanogaster)
The liver's jobs done by the fat body and oenocytes; macrophage jobs by hemocytes; a hypothalamus-like region for sexual state - Fullerenes (buckyballs and nanotubes)
The job of taking the electron from the donor polymer in an organic solar cell is done by fullerene derivatives (PC61BM, PC71BM, ICBA) and, after 2015, by unrelated fused-ring non-fullerene acceptors (ITIC). Also: closed cage containers built from carbon, from MoS2/WS2 sheets, or from boron. - Function (mathematics): the assignment of exactly one output to each input, and the practice of defining, drawing, composing and using it
Stating a function for a reader is done by a formula, a graph, a table, a rule in words or a tone: different builds for one job. - Fundamental interaction
Binding into new wholes built four ways: curvature (planets, stars, galaxies), photon exchange (atoms, molecules), gluon exchange (hadrons) and its residual (nuclei). - Fungi (yeasts, molds and mushrooms: absorptive eukaryotes with chitin walls)
One job, keeping some cells for the body and others for reproduction, built separately: fungal multicellular structures 'consisting of somatic and reproductive cells' are 'a feature independently evolved in animals and plants'. - Future timelike infinity (i+)
The far-future end of timelike curves built by conformal rescaling (i+) and by terminal indecomposable past sets (the causal boundary); they agree on the accessible part. - Future trapped region T
One job, the surface of a black hole, four candidates: 'the old and well defined event horizon', 'all possible MTTs', 'the boundary B as defined above', or 'a preferred MTT'; and the new one, the core's boundary. - Galactic bulge
One role, a central concentration of stars, built two ways: classical bulges by mergers (random orbits, elliptical-like) and pseudobulges by secular evolution of the disc (ordered orbits, disc-like). - Galaxy
Stopping star formation is done by unrelated means in different galaxies: black-hole jets (massive ellipticals), strangulation (most local galaxies below 10^11 solar masses), ram-pressure stripping (cluster satellites), photoheating (halos below 10^8). Mass and environment quenching are separable. - Galilean invariance
Two builds of one job (relating inertial frames so the laws keep their form): Galilean, with universal time and unbounded relative velocity, and Lorentzian, with each frame's own time and relative velocity 'bounded above by the speed of light'. - Galilean/Newtonian present (absolute simultaneity)
The role of 'now' across space: one universal instant (Galilean) or one hyperplane per observer (relativity). - Gamma-ray burst
One output, a gamma-ray burst, from different engines: a collapsar black hole (long), a neutron-star merger (short), a newborn magnetar (alternative), a supermassive black hole shredding a star (jetted TDE, Swift J1644+57 'originally classified as GRB 110328A'), and compact mergers behind some long - Gastrulation (the embryo's cell sheet folds and moves into two or three germ layers)
One job, bending a sheet into a pit or tube, done by different builds: apical constriction (frog, fly ventral furrow), basal wedging (chick and mouse neural plate), a swelling matrix layer (sea urchin), supracellular cables (fly salivary gland), cell rounding at mitosis (tracheal placode) - Gauge boson
The force-carrier role built massless and long-range (photon), massless and confined (gluons), and massive and short-range (W, Z) from the same spin-1 template. - Gear
Keeping two parts turning in step: done by meshing cuticular teeth on the hindleg trochantera of planthopper nymphs (Hemiptera), by interlocking gear-like structures in horned beetles' mandibles (Coleoptera), and by synchronized adductor-muscle activity in the desert locust's mandibles (Orthoptera, - Gender
One job, sorting people into recognised gender categories with roles, done by different builds: a two-category binary in most cultures, a third gender (hijras, two-spirit, Hawaiian māhū, muxe), five genders among the Bugis, and legal non-binary categories. - Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping)
Two unrelated enzyme classes (Rossmann fold vs a fold like biotin ligases) charge tRNAs; lysine has one of each: 'two distinct versions of the LysRS'. - Geodetic effect
One gyroscope, two drifts at right angles: one from mass (geodetic), one from rotation (frame dragging). - Geology (the field)
One job, giving a rock an age, done by unrelated builds: superposition and cross-cutting (geometry), faunal succession (fossils), U-Pb in zircon and Ar-Ar (decay), 10Be (cosmic rays), luminescence (trapped charge), paleomagnetic reversals. - Germ theory of disease with Koch's postulates (one microbe, one disease, four tests)
Establishing a cause is done by differently built tests: Koch's culture postulates, Pasteur's vaccine proof (1881), the Bradford Hill criteria, Falkow's gene postulates (1988), sequence-based guidelines (1996), modified postulates for prions. - Glacier
One job, getting ice downhill, done three ways: internal deformation of the ice (a power-law creep), basal sliding on a film of water, and deformation of a soft bed that slips beneath frozen ice like toothpaste. Removing ice also has builds: melt, sublimation (all of it on Mars), and calving. - Globalization
One job, carrying news of a distant market across the ocean: done by mail steamships (7-15 days), the cable (about a day), then low-cost networks and the Internet. One job, moving goods between continents: sail, steam with Suez, the container ship, air freight. One job, reading how integrated the wo - Glueball (predicted)
One colour-neutral boson role built three ways: two quarks (meson), three quarks (baryon), and two or three gluons with no quarks: 'Theoretical studies of glueballs have focused on glueballs consisting of either two gluons or three gluons, by analogy to mesons and baryons'. - Gluon
Four kinds of gauge boson do one job, carrying a force by exchange, with different builds: one massless uncharged photon (U(1)), three massive W/Z, eight colour-charged massless gluons (SU(3)). - Grammar (the structure of a language, as linguistics describes it)
Marking who did what to whom is done by word order in analytic languages and by inflection in synthetic ones: 'Analytic languages use syntax to convey information that is encoded by inflection in synthetic languages.' - Graph theory: the practice of studying vertices joined by edges (problems, proofs, algorithms, its people and books) and the graphs it works on
The job of holding who-is-joined-to-whom done by unrelated builds: a drawing on paper, an adjacency list or matrix in a computer, a map-like hippocampal-entorhinal structure in a person. - Grassland
Keeping trees out of the grass is one job done by unrelated builds: fire, grazing, drought, freezing ('maintained by fire, grazing, drought and/or freezing temperatures'), and in semi-natural grasslands mowing and livestock; low soil fertility does it on serpentine and calcareous ground. - Gravitational field
Holding a body up against gravity is done by different builds as mass rises: thermal and radiation pressure in a star, electron degeneracy pressure in a white dwarf, neutron degeneracy pressure in a neutron star; in a black hole nothing holds and 'gravity operates alone'. - Gravitational redshift
One shift read by different clocks: Mossbauer 57Fe gamma rays, hydrogen masers, Al+ ions, Sr lattice clocks, white-dwarf and solar spectral lines. - Gravitational time dilation
One dilation read by different builds: nuclear gamma resonance (Pound-Rebka), atomic clocks (airplanes, GPS, 33 cm optical clocks), stellar spectra (Sirius B). - Gravitational wave
Radiant energy at c built two ways: 'Gravitational waves transport energy as gravitational radiation, a form of radiant energy similar to electromagnetic radiation', but from a changing quadrupole (gravity 'has no equivalent to negative charge', so no dipole) and with polarizations 45 degrees apart - Gravitational wave background (stochastic background)
One job, filling all of space with a random hum of gravitational waves, done by two unrelated builds: 'intrinsically random, due to stochastic processes in the early Universe' or 'an incoherent superposition of a large number of weak independent unresolved' astrophysical sources; which build made th - Great Acceleration
Telecommunication done by landlines in the OECD and by mobile networks in the BRICS and the rest, 'leapfrogging over the need to build and support landline infrastructure'; fish supplied by wild capture, then by aquaculture ('grow livestock in the ocean'); and the question whether distributed renewa - Great tit (Parus major)
Making heat by letting mitochondria leak: mammals do it in brown fat (non-shivering thermogenesis); great and coal tits do it in red blood cells in winter - Green-Schwarz mechanism (anomaly cancellation by a transforming two-form)
Anomaly cancellation by a transforming two-form (here), by field content alone (type IIB supergravity) and by inflow from a bulk (Horava-Witten walls). - Grey parrot (Psittacus erithacus)
Seeing the Müller-Lyer illusion, completing contours and handling exact small numbers: the same jobs done with a bird pallium of densely packed neurons and a primate cortex, 175-fold different in volume - Gross domestic product
One job, telling how big an economy is and how well it is doing, is done by different builds: market-value accounts (GDP), China's earlier Marxist-inspired accounts, night lights from orbit (a physical proxy), consumer-surplus experiments (GDP-B), composite indexes (HDI, GPI, Better Life, Gross Nati - Hair cell
Frequency selection is done by at least three builds: electrical resonance of the cell (Ca2+ and BK channels; all non-mammals), prestin-driven contractions (mammals), passive mechanical resonances perhaps boosted by active bundles (frogs, lizards); geckos add tectorial sallets and a Ca2+-dependent b - Hamiltonian and Lagrangian mechanics (analytical mechanics: classical mechanics built from energy functions and the stationary action, and the practice of using them)
One job (predicting a mechanical system's motion) done by different builds with the same content: Newton's force vectors per particle, Lagrange's one scalar on configuration space, Hamilton's 2n first-order flow on phase space, Hamilton-Jacobi's one function; 'Both theories ... describe the same phy - Harmonic oscillator
Keeping a period, done by unrelated builds: a pendulum in gravity, a balance wheel on a hairspring, a quartz crystal, an LC circuit, a hair bundle, a silicon nanobeam; their models are identical. - Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966)
Three different initial conditions do the same job of trapping the past: past-trapped surfaces (1965), an everywhere-expanding slice (1966), a reconverging past light cone (1967). - Heart
Pumping hearts are built as tubes (arthropods, Drosophila dorsal vessel), two-chambered fish hearts, three-chambered amphibian hearts, four-chambered bird, mammal and crocodilian hearts, and cephalopod branchial plus systemic hearts. - Heterotic M-theory (Horava-Witten theory; projected model)
Two routes from eleven to four dimensions: an interval plus a Calabi-Yau here, seven dimensions on a G2 manifold there. - Heterotic SO(32) string theory (projected model; gauge group Spin(32)/Z2)
SO(32) gauge symmetry from a left-moving current algebra here, from Chan-Paton labels on open strings in type I; the two are S-dual. - Higgs boson
One job, making a Higgs boson in a collider, done by different structures: gluon fusion through a heavy-quark loop (dominant, about ten times any other process), weak boson fusion and Higgs-strahlung from a virtual W or Z (dominant at LEP), and top fusion / ttH. - Higgs branch (N = 2 hypermultiplet moduli space; projected model)
Making gauge fields massive by a charged scalar's vacuum value: the Higgs branch's charged vevs ('Higgses the U(1) it is charged under') and the Standard Model Higgs mechanism. - Hippocampus (memory)
learning and memory centres built separately: vertebrate hippocampus, insect mushroom bodies, octopus vertical lobe - Historiography
One job, judging which accounts of the past to trust, met by unrelated builds: Herodotus weighing reports by travel, the isnad's chain of transmission and rijal grading of narrators, Liu Zhiji's scepticism of primary sources (c. 710), and philology's textual criticism raised by Ranke. - History of science (the field and the story it tells)
The job of certifying a scholar done by different builds: a madrasa's ijazah, issued by one teacher as a licence to teach specific texts, against a university degree issued by an institution for broad knowledge. Keeping the year: Egypt's fixed 365-day calendar against the Babylonian and Greek luniso - Honeybee (western honey bee, Apis mellifera)
Gauging how far you have travelled: desert ants count strides (a stride integrator, shown by putting ants on stilts); honey bees read optic flow, and tunnel flights inflate their dance distance - Horizon (general relativity)
One job (marking where an observer's signals stop) done by different structures: a black hole's event horizon, a de Sitter universe's cosmic horizon, an accelerated observer's Rindler horizon, the particle horizon set by the universe's age, the opaque last-scattering surface. - Horizon of a temporarily accelerated observer
A one-way edge from two builds: acceleration in flat spacetime (the observer's apparent horizon at c^2/a) and curvature (a black hole's event horizon); both share that the proper acceleration of observers held near the edge grows without bound, 'Both of these facts would also be true if we were cons - Hubble's law (Hubble-Lemaitre law)
Two independent builds of one number: the late-universe distance ladder (Cepheids, supernovae) and the early-universe inverse ladder (CMB acoustic scale), which disagree at >5 sigma. - Human anatomy
One job, seeing inside a living body without cutting it, done by unrelated builds: X-ray film and CT, magnets and radio (MRI), sound echoes (ultrasound), tracer photons (PET). Measuring muscle loss by DXA, CT and MRI was tested for 'comparable outcomes'. - Human cultures (anthropology)
Kinship does the same job everywhere (the matrix children are born into) built on very different terms; lactase persistence built by one mutation in Europe and several in Africa and the Middle East. - Human physiology
Evaporative heat loss is one job built three ways: humans sweat, dogs pant, rodents spread saliva on their fur. - Humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae)
Making a tool to get food: humpbacks build nets from air, controlling ring number, size, depth and bubble spacing; chimpanzees, orangutans, New Caledonian crows and Goffin's cockatoos build theirs from plant material (Szabo 2024 names them side by side) - Humpback whale song
One job, learned behaviour spreading through a population and outliving its first carriers, done by different builds: whale song by ear across ocean basins (horizontal transmission over 11 years), bumblebee string-pulling by watching, in chains of up to four learning generations; songbirds by learni - Hydrogen atom
Carrying heat out of collapsing gas: hydrogen does it with line photons (Lyman-alpha, then H2 rotational lines), while in an opaque protostellar cloud 'the dust within the cloud becomes heated to temperatures of 60-100 K, and these particles radiate at wavelengths in the far infrared where the cloud - Hydrogen bond
One job, a hydrogen-like bridge from an electron-poor atom to a lone pair, is done by different builds: the hydrogen bond itself (N, O, F donors; S, Cl, C weakly), the bifurcated bond (one acceptor, two donors), the dihydrogen bond (a metal hydride as the acceptor) and the halogen bond, where 'by an - Hydrogen sulfide
Photosynthesis with two electron donors: 'purple sulfur bacteria and green sulfur bacteria use hydrogen sulfide as an electron donor in photosynthesis ... This mode of photosynthesis is older than the mode of cyanobacteria, algae, and plants, which uses water as electron donor and liberates oxygen.' - Hydrogen-bond network (water)
The one job of moving charge through water is done by two builds: ordinary ions carried bodily by the field, and the proton passed by bond swaps; the Grotthuss relay 'explains the unusually high diffusion rate of the proton ... relative to that of other common cations whose movement is due simply to - Hyperbolic motion in curved spacetime
The horizon neighbourhood is Rindler: the held observer near a black hole and the accelerating observer in flat spacetime share one horizon shape and one thermal reading (Unruh vs Hawking). - Hyperbolic world line
One horizon shape, two builds: the Rindler wedge of a hyperbola in flat spacetime and the neighbourhood of a black-hole horizon ('the geometry close to the event horizon can be described in Rindler coordinates'); Unruh and Hawking radiation as the two readings. - Hyperspherical universe
A finite closed universe built as the whole 3-sphere (simply connected) or as a quotient of it (the dodecahedral space): same curvature, different global build. - Ideal clock
One role, keeping proper time, built by a weak decay (the muon: 'the clock is the time taken by processes leading to muon decay') and by atomic transitions (caesium clocks, hydrogen masers). - Ideal gas
One job, reading thermodynamic temperature (and with it the Boltzmann constant) from a gas, done by different builds: acoustic gas thermometry (0.71 ppm), dielectric-constant gas thermometry, and Doppler broadening thermometry from a line shape (24 ppm), plus constant-volume gas thermometers before - Igneous rock
One job, turning solid rock into melt, is done three unrelated ways: lowering pressure on rising mantle (ridges, plumes), adding water (above slabs; wet peridotite melts at 800 C, dry at 1,500 C) and adding heat (continental crust). In the early Solar System the same job was done by flash heating (n - Incident response
One job, answering a damaging event as it happens (take the call, size it up, contain it, put it out, restore, and keep a record for next time), done by unrelated builds: the computer security incident response team; the fire department the CSIRT handbook compares it to; the Incident Command System - Incompressible Euler equations
One motion, two builds: Newton-Cauchy momentum balance with a pressure multiplier, and a geodesic flow on volume-preserving diffeomorphisms (Euler-Arnold), which also gives Euler's rigid-body equations. - Indecomposable future set (IF), as a PIF
Spacetime's edge built from IFs/IPs (causal boundary) and by conformal rescaling: the conformal boundary's 'accessible part ... agrees with the causal boundary'. - Indecomposable past set (IP)
One job, endpoint of a timelike curve, done by a real point (PIP) or an ideal point (TIP). - Inextensible future-directed timelike curve
An endless curve gets an endpoint two ways: as a TIP (causal boundary) or at a point of the conformal boundary ('agrees with the causal boundary' on its accessible part). - Infinite flat universe
Two flat universes with the same local geometry: E3 (simply connected, infinite) and the 3-torus (multiply connected, finite), 'locally indistinguishable'. - Infinitesimally thin light bundle
Two curvature parts do two jobs on one bundle: Ricci (matter) focuses, Weyl (tidal, conformal) shears; the timelike twin is the tidal tensor's trace and trace-free parts acting on a test cloud. - Infinity: the boundless or endless as mathematics and philosophy describe it (potential and actual infinity, Cantor's sizes of infinity, infinity in calculus, geometry, physics and computing) and the practice of the people who argue over it
One job, closing the line or plane by adding infinity so that special cases vanish, done by different builds: two signed points (+∞, −∞, the extended reals), one unsigned point (the projective line, the Riemann sphere), hyperreal infinities with field arithmetic; and two incompatible ways of reasoni - Inflation (economics)
One job, tying down the value of money so the price level is determinate, done by different builds: a gold standard, an exchange-rate peg, a money-growth target, an explicit inflation target, or an implicit anchor (Mishkin's four regimes). - Information security
One job, proving who you are, done by unrelated structures: something one knows (a password), has (a card) or is (fingerprints, retina). Classification does the same job with different label sets in business, government, cross-sector (TLP) and personal settings. - Information warfare
One job, a voice in the crowd that isn't what it seems, done by unrelated builds: bots, human-run accounts, cyborgs, hacked accounts, AI swarms; and one job, a phantom army, built from dummy landing craft, sound trucks, fake radio traffic and double agents' reports. - Insect (class Insecta)
Fast oscillation of a muscle: insect asynchronous flight muscle above 1,000 Hz by stretch activation, against a toadfish's synchronous swimbladder muscle at 200 Hz. - Insider threat
One job, keeping a single insider from acting alone on a critical asset, done by unrelated builds: two crew locks on a missile safe (two-person rule), split duties in accounting (separation of duties), developer-reviewer-tester change control, encryption keys under two people. - Instanton (QCD vacuum tunnelling)
One tunnelling role in several builds: the kink of quantum mechanics, the BPST instanton of four-dimensional gauge theory, the bounce of vacuum decay, and in three dimensions the 't Hooft-Polyakov monopole; 'the formalism for dealing with these instantons is relatively dimension-independent'. - Institution (social)
One job, keeping large-group cooperation from unravelling by monitoring and punishing free-riders, done by clans, age sets, merchant guilds, assemblies, governments and justice systems. - Insurance
Surviving losses that strike some members at unpredictable times by pooling across many: insurance contracts pool premiums; Maasai osotua transfers livestock on need (more risk pooling, higher herd survival than account keeping); vampire bats regurgitate blood to bonded kin and nonkin that failed to - International trade
The job 'each does what it is relatively best at and swaps for the rest' is done by countries (Ricardo's cloth and wine), by microbial species trading metabolites when each cannot make all it needs, and by plants and mycorrhizal fungi that prefer partners offering better exchanges. Biological market - Interpersonal communication
One job, taking turns in an exchange of signals so they do not collide, done by unrelated builds: human talk, gestures in great apes, monkey grooming, bird song, bat antiphony, frog calls, insect duets - Interstellar medium
One job, heating the gas, done by differently built mechanisms, each dominant in its own phase: low-energy cosmic rays, photoelectric heating by grains, photoionisation (H II regions), X-rays (warm diffuse gas), H2 formation on grains, grain-gas collisions (deep in GMCs), plus shocks, winds and MHD - Intonation
One job, marking a yes-no question, done by a particle (585 languages), verb morphology (164), word order (13), intonation alone (173) or no marking (1); and within intonation, by a final rise (Dutch H%), a raised register (Chinese), a boundary peak (Hungarian) or a final fall (Sesotho). - Intrinsic magnetosphere
Holding off the wind: by the body's own field at many body radii (intrinsic), or by the atmosphere, ionosphere or ionised coma the wind wraps round (induced: Venus, comets). One job, two builds; comets even grow a bow shock, 'wider and more gradual'. - Intrinsically disordered protein (no single fold)
Binding a target: folded proteins use a pocket made by tertiary structure; 'IDPs do not have spatially-disposed active pockets' and use pre-structured motifs, 'the putative active sites in IDPs'. - Intruder (burglar and trespasser)
One job, raiding a guarded store of someone else's goods, done by different builds: human burglars choosing homes by nearness, easy access and number of targets, reading cues by sight; robber bees choosing colonies by size, health, food and accessibility, finding them by smell; and within burglary i - Intrusion detection system
One job, telling an intruder from the normal run of things and raising the alarm, done by unrelated builds: statistical profiles of users (IDES), byte-pattern rules (Snort), short system-call sequences as a host's 'self' (Forrest); in bodies the immune system's T cells censored against self; in the - Ionic compound (salt)
One job, sensing salt on the tongue, is done by different builds: ENaC alpha-beta-gamma in mice (amiloride-sensitive), ENaC delta-beta-gamma plus the chloride channel TMC4 in humans, where Cl- dominates. A second job, keeping a cell's water against outside salt, is done by holding KCl inside (salt-i - Islamic art
the gold-and-silver table, barred by hadith, rebuilt as lustre (gold-like shine from silver and copper nanoparticles), as glazed pottery and as glass; the word as decoration built in tile, stucco, metal, coins and textiles - Isolated horizon
One job (black-hole mechanics in equilibrium) on two builds: the event horizon of a globally stationary spacetime, and the isolated horizon, which needs only local conditions and allows radiation nearby. - Journalism
The job of judging which news sources are reliable is done by professional fact-checkers and, nearly as well (r = 0.90), by politically balanced lay crowds; the watchdog job by newspapers, nonprofits (ProPublica) and international consortia; checking by people and by machine aids. - Jupiter
A planetary dynamo from different conducting fluids: 'whereas Earth's core is made of molten iron and nickel, Jupiter's is composed of metallic hydrogen'. - Killing horizon
One construct, three builds: a boost in flat spacetime (Rindler), a stationary black hole (rigidity), a cosmological constant (de Sitter); each has a surface gravity and the same thermal rule kappa/2 pi. - Killing tensor
Conserved quantities of free motion come from two builds: Killing vectors (tied to isometries: energy, angular momentum) and higher-rank Killing tensors with no isometry behind them (Carter's constant, the FLRW constant). - Kinship
One job, telling kin from non-kin, done by different builds: perinatal and co-residence cues in humans, faces in mandrills, odour in lemurs, immunogenetic (MHC) similarity in some species, and familiarity alone in viscous populations. - Kodama vector field
A reference time direction that keeps trapped surfaces out: the timelike Killing vector in stationary spacetimes ('if the Killing vector is timelike on S, then S cannot be weakly trapped, unless it is minimal') and the Kodama vector in dynamical spherical ones (Lemma 8.1, Theorem 9.1); the two coinc - Komar mass
The role 'mass of an isolated system' built three ways: from a time-translation symmetry (Komar), at spatial infinity (ADM), at null infinity (Bondi); they agree where more than one is defined. - Labour market
One job, putting people's work to the tasks that need doing, is met by different builds: a market where workers sell labour for a wage; assignment by political authority, serfdom, indenture and forced labour (the wage-labour page's list of how labour is traded); and in ant colonies, distributed task - Landau-Lifshitz pseudotensor
Landau-Lifshitz's symmetric pseudotensor and Einstein's mixed one do one job with different structures and agree on every Kerr-Schild metric. - Language (human language)
The subject/object distinction is carried by word order in English and by case morphology in Latin; one language is carried by speech, sign, writing, whistling or braille; ergative and accusative alignments map the same semantic roles differently. - Lanthanides (the 4f series, La-Lu; as an opacity source in kilonovae)
Oxidising methanol with a PQQ cofactor: done with Ca(II) (MxaF, coordination number 7) or with Ln(III) (XoxF, 9); XoxF-type 'proposed to have arisen prior to the Ca-MDHs' and 'more widespread'. - Lateral line
Feeling water movement at a distance is done by vertebrate neuromasts, by the ciliated epidermal head lines of cuttlefish and squid (threshold 0.2 micron at 75-100 Hz, a convergent analogue), and by people's artificial lateral lines (pressure sensors and hair-like MEMS on robot fish). Electrorecepti - Law (rules and law)
The job of keeping a group's rules held by sanctioning those who break them is done by state courts and police, by Ju/'hoansi foragers through talk (shaming, ridicule, ostracism), by a few policing pigtailed macaques whose removal shrinks the group's social networks, and by 2-3-year-old children pro - Learning
One job, learning from experience, done by unrelated builds: synaptic plasticity in Aplysia and mammals; in Stentor a shift in mechanoreceptor channels' voltage dependence in one cell; proposed non-synaptic stores in single cells (DNA methylation, histone marks, phosphorylation tug-of-war); auxin an - Length contraction
One observation (muons reaching the ground) explained as time dilation in Earth's frame and as length contraction in the muon's frame. - Lexicon: the stock of words and word parts of a language, and as each person holds it (the mental lexicon), as linguistics and psychology describe it
The job of putting a language's words on record for later readers is done by unrelated builds: Sumerian-Akkadian bilingual lists, Chinese monolingual dictionaries, a Sanskrit verse lexicon of about 10,000 words, Arabic dictionaries ordered by rhyme, by root or by first letter, and alphabetical Europ - Life (the living world, as biology describes it)
One job (turn an outside energy source into ATP) done by different builds: photoautotrophs and photoheterotrophs from light, chemoautotrophs and chemoheterotrophs from oxidation reactions; bacteriorhodopsin pumps protons in response to sunlight, hydrogenases feed an acetogen's pathway. - Limit (mathematics): the value a sequence or function approaches, and the practice of approaching, bounding and proving it
One job, making "as close as you like" exact, done by unrelated builds: exhaustion with reductio, Newton's kinetic ultimate ratios, Cauchy's infinitesimals, Weierstrass's epsilon-delta, Heine's sequences, Robinson's standard part, and Euler's stopping at the right moment for divergent series. - Linguistics (the field: the practice and the languages it studies)
One job, carrying a meaning, done by unrelated builds: 'cat' as sound patterns, as hand and face movements, as written symbols; and one information rate reached by dense-slow and sparse-fast languages. - Lipid (amphiphile)
One job, a water-tight sheet around a cell, built two ways: ester-linked fatty acids on G3P glycerol in bacteria and eukaryotes, ether-linked isoprenoids on mirror-image glycerol in archaea (o70), sometimes as a monolayer (o71), with unrelated headgroup enzymes (o69). - Literacy
One job, mapping print to spoken language, is done by very different scripts (alphabetic or logographic, opaque or transparent) yet skilled readers of Spanish, English, Hebrew and Chinese converge on one speech-print network. - Lithium atom
One output, four unrelated builds: lithium-7 from Big Bang nucleosynthesis, from cosmic-ray spallation (the only route to lithium-6), from red giants (Cameron-Fowler, via convected beryllium-7) and from classical novae. - Liver
Keeping ammonia low is done by two different enzyme systems in two zones of one lobule: the urea cycle periportally and glutamine synthetase pericentrally. Across vertebrates, liver glucokinase activity was lowered 'by the loss of GCKR gene function by multiple mechanisms on multiple lineages'. - Local Lorentz invariance
One invariance tested through two builds: light isotropy (cavities, Michelson-Morley) and matter isotropy (Hughes-Drever nuclear levels). - Local position invariance
One invariance read through two builds: in space (clocks at different heights) and in time (constants recorded by Oklo nuclei, meteorites and quasar spectra). - Logic gate
One job, computing a Boolean function, done by relays, tubes, bipolar transistors, CMOS pairs, steel plates (Z1), phonons in lattices, light in amplifiers, molecules with two receptors, spins under magnetic resonance, and superconducting flux parametrons. Outside engineering, modelled human dendrite - Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason
One job, sorting good arguments from bad, done by different builds: Aristotle's three-term syllogism, the Nyaya five-membered inference with its example, Dignaga's two-example syllogism and wheel of reasons, Mohist analogical disputation over this and not-this; in the brain, different networks for r - Luminosity distance
One distance read by different builds: flux and luminosity (D_L), angular size (D_A), parallax and rulers (comoving), all 'converted between each other'. - Lymphatic system
Moving lymph back to the veins: lymph hearts of skeletal muscle beating on their own (frogs, reptiles, birds' embryos; up to 200 in some amphibians), smooth-muscle lymphangions pumping themselves (mammals), and in adult birds skeletal-muscle squeeze and breathing that supersede the lymph hearts. - Lyric poetry
one job, a planned break that sets two parts of a short poem against each other so the reader must join them, done by the sonnet's volta at line 9, the haiku's cutting word, the classical caesura, and in English haiku by a dash or an implied break: 'A kireji fills a role analogous to that of a caesu - M-theory (projected model; conjectured eleven-dimensional theory behind the superstring theories)
Six descriptions (five superstring theories and eleven-dimensional supergravity) of one theory, each natural at one cusp of the family; 'the two theories are mathematically different descriptions of the same phenomena'. - M-theory on G2 manifolds (projected model)
Two routes from eleven to four dimensions: seven dimensions on a G2 manifold, or heterotic M-theory's interval plus Calabi-Yau ('a more indirect approach to compactifying eleven-dimensional spacetime'). - M5-brane (fivebrane of M-theory; projected model)
Black-hole entropy counted two ways: D-brane states in string theory (Strominger-Vafa 1996, S = A/4) and wrapped fivebranes in M-theory (Maldacena-Strominger-Witten 1997), each matching the horizon formula. - Machine
Turning a supply of power into rotation is done by water wheels (falling water), windmills (wind), steam and internal combustion engines (heat), electric motors (current), and in cells by the flagellar motor (ion flow through stator units) and ATP synthase (proton gradient, turbine-like). Large mach - Magnesium atom
Magnesium in the centre of the porphyrin ring in chlorophyll 'functions in a manner similar to the iron in the center of the porphyrin ring in heme': one ring, two metals, two jobs (light capture, oxygen carriage). And 24Mg is made by two stages: carbon burning (12C + 12C) and neon burning (20Ne + 4 - Magnetic seed field (kind)
One job, giving an amplifier the first non-zero field it can grow, done by unrelated builds: thermoelectric gradients (Biermann battery), anisotropic electron momenta (Weibel instability), inflation or phase transitions (primordial), stellar ejecta and black-hole jets (injection). Shared job named i - Mali Empire (Manden; the West African empire c. 1235 to c. 1600)
The broker of gold between merchant networks built at opposite sizes: Kilwa, a tiny island with no goldfields, and Mali, a vast realm without direct rule of its goldfields; Ghana's desert-edge city before them. The Silk Road's oasis markets do the same job between zones (roster point). - Malware
One job, telling a dangerous mimic from self and beating it by diversity, done by unrelated builds: the vertebrate immune system's self/nonself discrimination (Forrest's computer immune systems); drongos whose varied egg 'signatures' reject 93.7% of near-perfect cuckoo mimics; and the computing rule - Mammal (class Mammalia)
Endothermy in birds and mammals separately ('Birds are also endothermic, so endothermy is not unique to mammals'); down feathers trap warm air 'just as hair in mammals acts as a good insulator'; birds lack a diaphragm and breathe with a rocking keel and air sacs. - Management
The job of coordinating work is done by a command hierarchy (management), by prices across a market (Coase, via Bandiera et al.), and by workers' self-management where management functions are spread among workers. - Manifold topology of spacetime
Two topologies on one set of events, one from the charts (manifold) and one from the chronological order (Alexandrov); 'This topology coincides with the manifold topology if and only if the manifold is strongly causal'. - Mantle (geology): Earth's mantle
One job, carrying the interior's material and heat to the surface, done by two builds: the steady plate regime (cold plates sinking) and the punctuated plume regime (narrow hot columns from the core-mantle boundary). Contested by the plate hypothesis (C-2222). - Mantle convection (with plate tectonics, its surface expression)
One job, carrying a planet's interior heat out, done by different builds: moving plates over a convecting mantle (Earth), a single conducting plate (Moon, Mars), advection by heat-pipe volcanism (Io, perhaps early Earth). Firing rule: the job in plain words: getting the heat out. - Marginally bound orbit
One divide between bound and unbound circles, built at a different radius for each spin and direction: prograde to GM/c^2, retrograde to 2.9142 R_S. - Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS)
One job (saying where a black hole is) done by a quasilocal surface found on each slice (outermost MOTS) and by the global event horizon, which 'can be (approximately) located, but only retroactively after a simulation is complete'. - Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
One job, marking where a black hole is, done by different builds: the event horizon (global, teleological), MOTTs and their kinds (quasilocal, non-unique), and the boundary of the trapped region. - Marginally trapped tube (MTT)
The black-hole boundary is built two ways in Vaidya: the event horizon, which 'originate[s] in the flat space-time region', and the MTT (DH), which 'exists only in the curved region'; 'the numerous roles played by the event horizon in equilibrium situations get split in dynamical contexts'. - Marine ecospace (the sea's modes of life)
Building living structure that other organisms then live in is done by unrelated builds: 'corals, kelp, mangroves and seagrasses, are ecosystem engineers which reshape the marine environment to the point where they create further habitat for other organisms' (an animal, a brown alga, and two kinds o - Marketing
Drawing a receiver to an offer with a signal tuned to its senses: firms advertise products to consumers; flowering plants advertise to pollinators by colour, shape and scent; unrelated builds, same job. - Mass media
One role, reaching large audiences from one source, met by seven builds in turn: print, recordings, cinema, radio, television, the internet, mobile phones (the 'seven mass media'); and three national builds of the media system (liberal, democratic corporatist, polarized pluralist). - Materials science (the field)
One job, several builds: holding a drink and keeping its CO2 in is done by glass, aluminium alloy and polyethylene, each with its own bonds and structure (encyclopedia's beverage containers); stopping dislocations (strength) is done by grain boundaries (Hall-Petch), alloying pins, work hardening and - Mathematical logic: the field that studies logic within mathematics (model theory, proof theory, set theory, computability theory) and the formal systems, structures and limit results it works on
One job, defining effective computability, done by unrelated builds: Turing machines, lambda calculus, general recursive functions, all equivalent; deduction done by Hilbert systems, natural deduction and sequent calculus. - Mathematical proof: the practice of showing that a statement follows from axioms and earlier theorems, how it is written, checked (by people and machines) and accepted, and the derivations it works on
Certifying a proof is done by unrelated builds: a community of referees convinced 'by a social/voting process', a kernel of about 400 lines, multiple independent programs, and foundations as different as ZFC (Mizar, Metamath), HOL and dependent type theory (Coq, Lean). - Mathematics (the field: the practice and the structures it studies)
Checking a proof done by unrelated builds: the community's scrutiny ('quite good at detecting potential weaknesses'), the referee, and a proof assistant's kernel of 'a few hundred lines'. And one concept, the derivative, held seven ways (infinitesimal, symbolic, logical, geometric, rate, approximati - Matrix (mathematics): the rectangular array of numbers and its algebra, determinants and eigenvalues, matrices as linear maps, their history, and their use in physics, graphics and machine learning; the practice and the structure both booked
Multiplying two arrays of numbers is done by hand row by column, by elimination tables, by BLAS on CPUs and GPUs, by a 256 × 256 systolic array on the TPU, by Strassen's recursive 7-product blocks and by AlphaTensor's discovered factorizations; computing a determinant by the Leibniz formula, Laplace - Matter bounce (nonsingular bouncing cosmology with matter-dominated contraction)
The bounce-maker built four ways: ghost condensate, quintom pair (Lee-Wick), Galileon-type field, Horava-Lifshitz modified gravity; and across the family, torsion and quantum geometry. - Measurement (the practice of comparing a quantity with a unit, and the units and standards it uses)
One job (how far have I gone?) done by counting steps (desert ants), summing optic flow (bees), and pacing or rods (people). - Measuring rod
One outcome, the muon reaching the ground, built two ways: length contraction in the muon's frame, time dilation in Earth's; 'Both effects are equally valid ways of explaining the fast muon's unusual survival over distances'. - Mechanical engineering (the field)
Turning a shaft continuously is done by engines and electric motors built of metal and by the bacterial flagellar motor, 'a bidirectional rotary nanomachine' of about 25 proteins with 'a central rotor surrounded by multiple inner membrane-associated stator complexes', driven by ion flux (src:guo-liu - Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule)
Starting the exchange (a break) is met by different builds: SPO11; X-ray damage that rescues spo11 mutants; uracil base-excision repair in S. pombe and C. elegans; nicks and gaps in rad2 mutants; social amoebae that lost Spo11 yet keep meiotic sex. - Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)
Keeping track of where you are from your own movement: desert ants do it from 'polarized light or sun position' and 'monitoring leg movement or optical flow'; mammals with grid cells 'playing the role of the path integrator'. - Metamorphic rock
One job, warming crust to metamorphic grade, is done by unrelated means: radiogenic heat, conduction of mantle heat, magma intrusion, asthenospheric upwelling, viscous dissipation, impact shock, and on Ceres the decay-heated core. A second: weakening rock enough for strain to localize is done by dis - Metaphysics (the branch of philosophy: its practice and the questions about reality it works on)
One job, naming what everything rests on, built separately in India (ultimate reality as the ground of all being, the Upanishads), China (the Tao; later li) and Greece (first principles; Plato's forms; the Neoplatonic One). In applied ontology, two upper ontologies (SUMO, BFO) do the same integratin - Metastable de Sitter string vacuum (KKLT type; projected model)
Uplifting can be done by anti-D3 branes, or by 'susy breaking effects other than the introduction of D3 branes alone', such as D3/D7 or brane-antibrane models; the dS role has several builds (classical, non-geometric, quantum). - Methane (CH4)
Methane removal (one job) is done by different builds: OH radicals in the troposphere (90%), chlorine atoms in the stratosphere, aerobic methanotrophs with methane monooxygenase in soils, and ANME archaea with sulfate reducers by reverse methanogenesis in sediments. - Metric separation (distance-like measures)
One role (how far apart) built many ways: Euclidean, geodesic, taxicab, the interval, Hamming. - Middle English literature
The job of binding a verse line together by sound is done three ways in one literature: repeated initial sounds (the alliterative long line of Langland and the Gawain poet), end rhyme (Chaucer), and both at once (Gawain's rhyming bob and wheel; Layamon's half-lines often linked by rhyme as well as a - Mind–body problem (how mental states relate to physical states)
One job, saying how experience and the body hang together, done by unrelated builds: two substances with a gland between them (Descartes), God's coordination (Malebranche, Leibniz), one substance with two properties, one neutral stuff with two aspects (Spinoza, Russell, Solms's lightning and thunder - Mineral
The job: a hard mineral skeleton. Echinoderms build it of calcite inside a tubular compartment made by syncytial cells; vertebrates mineralise a cartilage-like scaffold with apatite; the two networks share little, and 'Biomineralization is proposed to have evolved independently in different phyla th - Mineral surfaces (rock and grain surfaces at a planet's surface)
Plain job: getting nutrient ions out of solid rock. Lichens do it with hyphae and chelating compounds, roots with CO2, organic acids and proton exchange, mycorrhizal fungi by releasing nutrients from apatite and biotite, bacteria by oxidoreduction, protons, acids and chelators: four unrelated builds - Mirror symmetry (string theory; projected model)
One physics on two different geometries; the same move as T-duality (radius R and 1/R) and S-duality (strong and weak coupling), here between shapes. - Misner-Sharp(-Hernandez) mass
The mass of a system read at different places: E on any round sphere, ADM at spatial infinity, Bondi-Sachs at null infinity; 'the asymptotic energies (in spherical symmetry) are just special cases of E'. - Mitochondrion
Iron-sulfur cluster assembly is done by the mitochondrial ISC pathway in nearly all eukaryotes and by a cytosolic SUF system taken from bacteria in Monocercomonoides, which lost the organelle. - Moduli space of vacua (vacuum manifold)
Exact degeneracy of vacua kept against quantum corrections by two different builds: an ordinary symmetry (vacua 'related by a symmetry which guarantees that their energy levels remain exactly degenerate', the Higgs circle) or supersymmetry (vacua 'not related by any symmetry'). - Moebius group PSL(2, C) (conformal maps of the Riemann and celestial sphere)
One group built three ways: as Lorentz transformations of spacetime, as conformal maps of the Riemann (celestial) sphere, and as orientation-preserving isometries of hyperbolic 3-space, whose conformal boundary is that sphere. - Molecular chaperone
Closing the room: a separate lid (GroES, group I), a built-in lid that 'closes in an ATP-dependent manner' (group II), and phage T4's own taller lid gp31. - Molecular cloud
Holding the cloud up against its own gravity is done by thermal pressure, turbulence, rotation and magnetic fields: 'Both rotation and magnetic fields can hinder the collapse of a cloud. Turbulence is instrumental in causing fragmentation of the cloud, and on the smallest scales it promotes collapse - Molecular hydrogen (H2, dihydrogen)
One product, many builds: H2 is made by excited-state recombination routes, the H2+ channel, the H- channel (electron catalyst), the HeH+ channel, three-body reactions at high density, dust-grain surfaces today, serpentinization in rock and hydrogenases in cells. - Money
One job, medium of exchange, done by barley, cowries, metal rings, coins, cigarettes in POW camps, paper notes, bank database entries and chains of digital signatures; outside our species, free-ranging Bali macaques use stolen objects as tokens to buy food from people. - Moon (Earth's natural satellite)
Telling the moon's phase from night light is done by three different builds: corals with cryptochromes and a melanopsin-like photoreceptor and no eyes; a bristle worm with r-Opsin1 for moonrise plus L-Cry to tell moonlight from sunlight; people, whose sleep shifts on bright early nights. - Morphology (linguistics): how a language builds its words from smaller meaningful parts (roots, affixes, compounding, inflection and derivation), how languages differ in this, how speakers learn and use it, and the field that studies it
The same job, marking tense, negation, possession or evidence, is done by inflection in small-community languages and by separate words in large-community ones; in sign languages by space and movement rather than affixes. - Motor neuron
One job, telling a muscle fibre to contract, done with acetylcholine in vertebrates and with glutamate in crayfish and fruit flies ('Not all species use a cholinergic neuromuscular junction'). - Movable type (reusable cast sorts x the alphabet; the European press)
One job, copying a text, done by carved blocks (woodblock), by single cast sorts (hand type, Monotype from 1887), and by whole cast lines (Linotype): 'Linotype cast entire lines of text at once rather than individual sorts, while ... Monotype still cast the sorts individually'. - Multiply connected universe
The same job (a finite space with no edge) done by flat, spherical and hyperbolic cells: torus, dodecahedral space, Picard horn. - Muon
The negatively charged slot in an atom is filled by different particles: 'electrons may be replaced by other negatively charged particles such as muons or pions' (exotic atoms). - Muscular system
Calcium switches muscle on in every myocyte, but the switch is built differently: troponin on the thin filament in striated muscle, calponin and caldesmon (with calmodulin-MLCK) in smooth muscle. - Museum
One job, keeping a society's traces for later readers, done by temples (votive offerings), palaces, cabinets, public museums, libraries and archives; one natural-history job (specimens for science) done by herbaria, xylaria and museums - Natural environment
Plain job: building a better place to live. Beavers build dams, termites build mounds, people build huts and cities; the animal builds count as natural, the human ones as artificial (the definition turns on who built it). - Navier-Stokes equations
One role (momentum balance of a fluid) built several ways from the one Cauchy equation: inviscid (Euler), viscous Newtonian (Navier-Stokes), relativistic ideal (relativistic Euler). - Neolithic Revolution (the First Agricultural Revolution)
One job, a reliable staple from managed plants, met by unrelated builds: cereals and pulses in the Fertile Crescent, paddy rice on the Yangtze and millets on the Yellow River, taro and bananas in mounds and ditches at Kuk Swamp, maize, beans and squash in Mesoamerica, sorghum and pearl millet in the - Nervous system
Whole-tissue coordination done by a synaptic net (cnidarians), a syncytial net (ctenophores) or a chemical peptidergic network. - Neutrino
One job, carrying a star's energy out to space, done by two unrelated builds: photons diffuse out through the envelope over tens of millennia in the Sun, while in a collapsing core 'neutrinos interact only via the weak interaction and can escape easily, whereas photons are trapped', so neutrinos tak - Neutron star
Holding a dead star up against gravity: the white dwarf does it with electron degeneracy pressure; the neutron star with 'a combination of strong-force repulsion and neutron degeneracy pressure'. One job, two rooms. - Neutron star magnetosphere
Slowing the star is done by two builds: a vacuum dipole radiates only when tilted (L_vac ~ (2/3) mu^2 Omega^4 sin^2 chi / c^3, zero when aligned), while a plasma-filled magnetosphere brakes the star with its currents and Poynting flux even when aligned (L ~ mu^2 Omega^4 (1 + sin^2 chi)/c^3). PSR B19 - Neutron star superfluid interior
Two different structures are proposed for one job, the sudden spin-up: a crust that ruptures in a starquake, or superfluid vortices that de-pin. The Neutron star article presents both and the Glitch article says 'the exact cause of glitches is unknown'; Haskell & Melatos call the vortex picture 'the - New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides)
Getting grubs out of holes in wood: woodpeckers do it with the bill; this crow, on an island without woodpeckers, does it with tools; the crow's straight bill sits nearest the woodpecker's among Corvus yet differs in depth and its upturned lower mandible - Newspaper
The job 'tell a broad public the news at regular intervals' is done by manuscript avvisi and Fugger newsletters, Tang China's block-printed Kaiyuan Za Bao, Joseon Korea's daily Jobo, the printed Relation (1605), the penny press and online papers; and the job 'pay for it' by parties and patronage, ad - Newton's second law
Force as rate of change of momentum built three ways: F = m a for a body, F = dP/d tau on a world line, Du/Dt = (1/rho) div sigma + a for a continuum. - Nitrogen atom
Hydrogen to helium in a star by two builds: the CNO cycle 'uses nuclei of carbon, nitrogen and oxygen as intermediaries and in the end produces a helium nucleus as with the proton-proton chain'; nitrogen is the CNO build's slow station. - Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking)
One job, keeping some pairing when the quarks' Fermi surfaces are pulled apart, met by unlike builds: a kaon condensate ('bend rather than break'), gapless pairing, pairs with momentum in a crystal, single-flavour pairing, a gluon condensate, mixed phases ('Another way for a system to deal with a st - Noncommutative torus
Equivalence of tori: Morita equivalence under SL(2, Z) in the algebra; T-duality of the compactified theory; CDS identify the two. - Nonverbal communication
One job, conveying a state or intent without words, done by unrelated builds: faces and gaze in primates, a dog's evolved eyebrow muscle, cuttlefish chromatophores, electric organs in weakly electric fish, the bee's waggle dance, bioluminescence - Normal coordinates
One job (a chart flat at the base) built about a point (Riemann) and about a world line (Fermi). - Nuclear fission
Splitting when charge outgrows cohesion: a heavy nucleus (nuclear force as surface tension against Coulomb), a charged liquid droplet ("unstable above the critical charge squared-to-volume ratio given by the Rayleigh limit") and a doubly charged potassium cluster ("the Rayleigh limit nRay for which - Nuclear fusion
One job, turning four protons into one helium-4, is done by two unrelated reaction sequences: the pp chain and the catalytic CNO cycle (Adelberger 2011: 'the pp chain ... or CNO cycles'). A second job, holding hot fuel together long enough to burn, is done by gravity, by magnetic fields or by the fu - Null conformal boundary (asymptotically flat, Lambda = 0)
The boundary at infinity is built null for Lambda = 0 and spacelike for Lambda > 0 (de Sitter: 'timelike infinity has codimension 1'): one role, two causal characters set by the cosmological constant. - Null curve (lightlike curve)
Boundaries of futures, event horizons and Cauchy horizons are all generated by null curves: one generator, several walls. - Null geodesic congruence (light-ray bundle)
Focusing of light done by two different curvature parts: Ricci (matter on the rays) focuses directly, Weyl (tides from distant mass) through shear. - Number and counting (the number sense, the practice of counting, and the structure it works on)
Number neurons tuned to a preferred numerosity on a log scale in the macaque fronto-parietal cortex and the crow's nidopallium caudolaterale, endbrains that evolved separately; zebrafish pallium and chick NCL show the same code without a layered cortex. - Number-flux four-vector
One vector carries different payloads by one rule: number (N = nU), mass (p = mU; T = p N), charge (four-current). - Nursing (the field: the practice and the care it gives)
One job, attending a person who cannot care for themselves, done by different builds: Neanderthal group members caring for a disabled child for 6+ years; nuns, monks and deaconesses; families at home; trained secular nurses; nursing assistants under delegation; electronic self-report tools and monit - Open-source software
The job of paying for maintenance is done by unrelated builds: individual donations (Open Collective), state agencies (Sovereign Tech Agency), firms' paid developers and dual licences, foundations (Core Infrastructure Initiative). - Operating system
One job, protecting a program's memory, is done by 'memory segmentation and paging'; access control by UNIX permission bits and set-user-ID or by Windows' access-control lists and security descriptors; and the job of regulating a system's parts by E. coli's transcriptional regulatory network and Lin - Optics (light's behaviour: reflection, refraction, interference, lenses and instruments)
gathering light onto receptors is done by lenses and, equally efficiently, by curved mirrors (scallops, some crustaceans, deep-sea fish), and in camera and compound eyes; high-resolution eyes evolved in vertebrates, cephalopods and arthropods - Orangutan (Pongo)
One job, sounding bigger by lowering a call's maximum frequency, done with a held tool (leaves at the mouth) in orangutans and by vocal tract elongation in male deer, as the source itself compares - Orca (killer whale, Orcinus orca)
Finding prey by listening to the echoes of one's own calls: toothed whales make clicks with phonic lips and a fatty melon and take echoes in through the lower jaw; bats do it in air - Organism (the living thing, as biology describes it)
Getting rid of excess carbon by excreting a partly oxidised by-product: acetate by Pdh/Pta/AckA in E. coli, ethanol by Pdc/Adh in yeast, lactate by Ldh in mammalian cells ('different names, same game'). Gravity sensing: plants and animals share some mechanisms yet 'each species has its own'. - Organization
The job of getting many people's work done together is met by unrelated structures: peers voting (committees, juries), internal competition (ecologies), two crossed hierarchies (matrix) and the pyramid; and between firms, by prices instead ('markets and organizations are alternative coordination mec - Oscillating universe (Friedmann 1922; Einstein 1930; Tolman 1934)
The crunch-to-bang turn this model assumes is built later in three ways: quantum geometry (LQC), spinor-torsion coupling, a nonsingular matter bounce. - Painting
holding pigment on a surface is done by drying oil (oxidising), egg yolk, beeswax, lime setting round pigment in fresco, acrylic emulsion and gum water - Pancreas
The job of making digestive enzymes and blood-sugar hormones near the gut is done by a compact organ (humans), diffuse tissue in the mesentery and other organs (teleosts, rabbits), nodules in the gut wall (lampreys, lungfish), or a separate endocrine gland (some teleosts). And the job of secreting i - Parallel transport along curves
Keeping a direction 'unchanged' along a curve, built two ways: parallel transport (free fall) and Fermi-Walker transport (accelerated curves, adds Thomas precession). - Past light cone (past null cone)
One construction, two apexes: a past null cone of an ordinary event bounds what can reach it; the past null cone of future timelike infinity is the absolute event horizon. - Past reflecting spacetime
One condition built three ways: set inclusions (Lemma 3.42), outer continuity of the set-valued map I- (Lemma 3.46), continuity of the volume function t- (Proposition 3.41). - Past timelike infinity (i-)
The far-past start of timelike curves built by conformal rescaling (i-) and by terminal indecomposable future sets (the past causal boundary, 'the set of all the TIFs'). - Past-trapped surface
The cosmological boundary is drawn two ways: the apparent horizon (local, from null expansions) and the event and particle horizons (global integrals, which 'do not exist in all FLRW spaces'). - Penetration testing
The job: present a controlled, survivable version of the attacker to a defence on purpose, so its weak points show and it learns before the real one arrives. Penetration testing and red teaming do it with authorised attacks under rules of engagement; chaos engineering injects failures into productio - Penrose singularity theorem
One conclusion (incompleteness), two builds: null rays forward from a trapped surface (Penrose) and timelike paths backward from an expanding slice (Hawking). - Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems
One conclusion, two builds: Penrose (null rays, null energy condition, forward into a black hole) and Hawking (timelike paths, strong energy condition, backward to the Big Bang). - Perception
One job, getting an object's shape into the percept, met by sight, by active touch, and by a sensory substitution device turning images into touch or sound; and depth from over half a dozen different cues. - Personal finance (how a household earns, spends, saves, borrows and plans)
One job, meeting a $400 shock, done by cash or savings, a card paid off next statement, a carried card balance, borrowing or selling something; 12% could not meet it by any means. - Petrov type D
The tidal field of an isolated body: a Coulomb-type potential in Newtonian gravity, a type D Weyl tensor in general relativity, with the same (-2,1,1) pattern ('very closely analogous'). - Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
One job, 'sorting reliable from unreliable ways of knowing', built differently: Nyaya accepts four means (perception, inference, analogy, testimony), Vaisesika and Buddhists two, Charvaka rejects inference for universal knowledge; Western empiricism and rationalism (43.90% / 33.51% of surveyed philo - Phishing
One job, luring a receiver with a copy of a signal it already answers, done by unrelated builds: a phishing page copying a bank's login; a katydid answering male cicada songs with the female's wing-flick reply (clicks and body jerks); a Photuris firefly copying female reply flashes of up to eleven s - Phonetics: the study of speech sounds (how they are made, carried through the air and heard, and how they are recorded and transcribed) together with the speech sounds it studies
One job, putting a sound source into the vocal tract, done by different builds: the vibrating vocal folds (voicing), turbulence at a narrow constriction (frication), pressure released from a closure (stops), a closed glottis moved as a piston (ejectives, implosives), air rarefied between two tongue - Phonology: how languages organise the meaningless units their words are built from (phonemes in spoken languages; handshape, location and movement in signed ones), together with the field of linguistics that studies those systems
One job, giving a language a finite stock of meaningless units that tell words apart, done by sounds made in the vocal tract, by handshape, location and movement of the hands, and (in rudiment) by recombined call elements in chestnut-crowned babblers. - Photography
Recording light in a lasting image is done by bitumen hardening (Niépce), silver-mercury amalgam on silver (daguerreotype), silver grains in gelatin, dyes in layered film, and charge in silicon photodiodes (CCD, CMOS, SPAD) - Photon
One role, force carrier, built four ways: 'Photons, W and Z bosons, and gluons are gauge bosons'; 'Unlike the photon, these gauge bosons have mass', and the eight gluons carry colour. The jet walk sees the same pairing from the other side (QED radiation of photons, QCD radiation of gluons). - Photon region of a rotating (Kerr) black hole
Drawing the shadow edge: a single sphere of circular light orbits in Schwarzschild, a shell of spherical non-planar orbits in Kerr ('the construction of the shadow is related to the existence of a photon region, not of a horizon'). - Photon surface
Drawing a black hole's shadow: in spherical symmetry the photon sphere (a photon surface) does it; around spinning holes no photon surface exists and the photon region does it ('the construction of the shadow is related to the existence of a photon region, not of a horizon'). - Photosynthesis
Concentrating CO2 around Rubisco is done in space (C4 bundle sheath), in time (CAM, fixed at night), by protein shells (carboxysomes), by pyrenoids, and by calcium-oxalate stores (alarm photosynthesis). - Physical security
One job, keeping strangers away from what a group holds, done by unrelated builds: walls, locks and paid guards in human settlements; a soldier subcaste 30% heavier than foragers guarding a stingless-bee nest entrance; collective vigilance in prey groups ('many eyes') and residents keeping entrances - Planet
The layer between core and outside is built differently: silicate mantles sealed under crusts (terrestrials), metallic hydrogen (Jupiter, Saturn), water, ammonia, methane and other ices (Uranus, Neptune). - Plant seed
One job, holding the young plant's first food, done by different tissues: endosperm, cotyledons, perisperm from the nucellus, the haploid female gametophyte in gymnosperms, and in the Brazil nut the hypocotyl. - Plate tectonics
Surface material recycled into the interior by sinking plates: rock lithosphere into Earth's mantle; on Europa, surface ice into the subsurface ocean, only for shells ≲10 km thick and set off by periods of enhanced eccentricity rather than by slab density. - Plato
One job in plain words, reading a hidden structure from its shadows, is built four ways: Plato's cave and Forms (philosophy), the Platonic Representation Hypothesis (neural networks), Plato's Cave Algorithm (signalling networks inferred from early-gene 'shadows'), and the fragmentation geometry in w - Play
One job, keeping a mock fight from turning into a real one, done by different signals in different animals: a kitten's crouch and paddle, a dog's attention-getting nudges and barks, primates' play faces and play-derived gestures, rats' 50-kHz calls; cooperation is inserted in 'several different ways - Poetry
The job of making speech rhythmically regular and predictable is done by stress (English, German), syllable weight (classical Greek and Latin), syllable count (French, Chinese), tones (classical Chinese), parallel lines (Hebrew) and alliteration (Germanic); French and German recitations, built diffe - Poincare dodecahedral space
A finite universe by gluing a cell's opposite faces: twisted dodecahedron in curved space here, cube in flat space for the 3-torus; the same construction with more twist gives the hyperbolic Seifert-Weber space. - Polar photon orbit
The last orbit of light, which draws the shadow edge: one circle at 3M without spin, a shell of spherical orbits (this one among them) with spin. - Police
The job of policing conflict and enforcing a group's rules done by unrelated builds: state police forces; pigtailed macaques in which 'a policing function, performed infrequently by a small subset of individuals' keeps social networks stable (knocked out, networks shrink and fragment); insect coloni - Political party
Picking who leads the party is done by unrelated builds: the whole electorate, members at a conference, a few executives, one individual, or hereditary succession; raising money too, from members' dues, corporations, unions or the state. - Pollution
The job "cut acid emissions from power plants" done two ways: Europe by critical loads and integrated assessment models, the United States by an emissions trading programme under the Clean Air Act. Also: particles taken out of a gas stream by baghouses, cyclones, electrostatic precipitators or scrub - Pragmatics
One job, marking the social relation in how one speaks, done by unrelated builds: T-V pronouns, honorifics, female Koasati verb suffixes, a whole separate Dyirbal lexicon before in-laws. Second job, taking turns, done by human speech, signing, gaze and marmoset calls. Third: large language models ch - Prairie dog (Cynomys)
Predator-specific alarm calls, with different escapes per call, built by a rodent here and reported in vervet monkeys and Japanese tits; sciurid repertoire size tracks social role complexity - Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases)
Civil law reaches the stabilising role by another build: jurisprudence constante, where 'a series of adjudicated cases, all in accord' is highly persuasive, against stare decisis, where 'a single court decision can provide sufficient foundation'; highest-court precedent is 'de facto binding' in Fran - Precessing orbit
Apsidal precession is one role built by several causes: GR curvature, the central body's quadrupole, tides, and perturbing bodies (omega_total = omega_GR + omega_quadrupole + omega_tide + omega_perturbations). - Prime numbers (the practice of number theory that finds, proves and uses them, and the structure of the primes it works on)
One job, telling prime from composite, done by unrelated builds: a day-old chick by perceptual grouping (prefers 7 or 11 over 9), adults slowing on primes when arrays are grouped, a savant whose times follow a sieve, trial division, the sieve, Fermat/Miller-Rabin/AKS tests, and the Lucas-Lehmer test - Principle of relativity
One role, three builds: the equivalence of frames is realised by Galilean transformations (Newtonian mechanics), Lorentz transformations (special relativity) and arbitrary smooth coordinate changes (general relativity); 'There have been several main areas of physics where a version of the Principle - Privacy
One job, keeping others from learning about a person what they would use against them, done by unrelated builds: a wall or hedge, clothing and reserve, a social norm, a statute, a cipher, an onion of relays, calibrated noise; and in other animals a squirrel digging its cache facing away from rivals. - Probability: weighing chances, in brains and in people's mathematics, and the structure it works on
Statistical inference built twice: in great apes and in a parrot whose brain has 'a highly different structure from primates'. - Prograde circular photon orbit
The last orbit of light, which draws the shadow edge: one circle at 3M without spin, a shell of spherical orbits (this one among them) with spin. - Programming language
Freeing memory no longer used, safely, is done by a tracing garbage collector (Lisp, 1958), by ownership checked at compile time (Rust, 'without sacrificing much efficiency'), or by hand (C). Running a program is done by a compiler, an interpreter or a JIT. - Proper coordinates with a rotating tetrad
Absolute rotation is read two ways: by gyroscopes, whose axes define the Fermi-Walker (non-rotating) legs, and by light sent both ways round a ring (Sagnac), 'an absolute rotation, that is, the platform's rotation with respect to an inertial reference frame'. - Protein folding (a chain reaching its working shape)
One job, keeping a chain from sticking to others while it folds, done by different structures: Hsp70 binding hydrophobic stretches, the chaperonin barrel, SecB keeping chains 'translocation-competent', crowding counteracted by GroEL, and the ER's lectin chaperones. - Protein secondary structure (alpha helices, beta sheets, turns)
One job, pairing up every backbone hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor, done two ways: 'Both the α-helix and the β-sheet represent a way of saturating all the hydrogen bond donors and acceptors in the peptide backbone' (within one chain i to i+4, or between strands). - Proteostasis (the cell's network that makes, folds, repairs and clears its proteins)
Marking proteins for destruction: ubiquitin in eukaryotes and Pup in Actinomycetota do 'the same function (targeting proteins for degradations)', though 'the two families share no homology'. - Proton
The job 'tell how acid the fluid is' is done by unrelated proteins: the otopetrin channel OTOP1 (sour taste), the DEG/ENaC-family ASICs (acid pain), the receptor GPR4 and the K2P channel TASK-2 (breathing). Before OTOP1 'only one type of proton-selective ion channel has been found in eukaryotic cell - Proton-proton chain
One job, hydrogen to helium, two builds: the pp chain is 'one of two known sets of nuclear fusion reactions by which stars convert hydrogen to helium', the other the CNO cycle; the pp chain goes through a weak step between two protons, the CNO cycle through borrowed carbon, nitrogen and oxygen. - Pseudorapidity
The beam-axis boost coordinate built from energy and longitudinal momentum (rapidity y) and from the angle alone (pseudorapidity), equal for massless particles; eta 'can be measured when the mass and momentum of the particle are unknown'. - Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time
Holding information about another time is done by footprints, craters, fission tracks, photographic film, flash drives, computer RAM and brains; Rovelli lists 'footsteps, impact craters, memories in brains and computers, fossils, gravitational waves'. The shared job in plain words: keeping a mark of - Psychology (the mind and behaviour as psychology describes them)
The Weber–Fechner law (a logarithmically compressed number line) holds in pigeons, which have 'significantly fewer pallial neurons', as in monkeys and corvids: one law, different brains. - Public opinion
One job, reading what a population thinks, done by unrelated builds across time: medieval fama publica as legal proof, coffeehouse talk and papers, newspaper straw tallies (1824), mass postcard polls (Literary Digest), scientific sampling (Gallup, Crossley, Roper), and sentiment analysis of online p - Public speaking (oratory)
One job, carrying one speaker's words to an audience too big or far for the unaided voice, done by a trained voice (Demosthenes), a public address system, radio and television, and online posting and videoconference. - Public-key cryptography
One job (two parties with no shared secret agree a key over a channel others can hear) done by unrelated builds: the hardness of factoring (RSA), of discrete logs in finite fields and on elliptic curves (Diffie-Hellman, ECDH), of noisy linear equations (ML-KEM), and by physics instead of computation - QCD matter (quark matter and its phase diagram)
Hadrons are melted into quark matter by two different builds: heat, 'when the temperature reaches the QCD energy scale (T of order 10^12 kelvins)', or squeeze, when 'the density rises to the point where the average inter-quark separation is less than 1 fm (mu around 400 MeV)'. The first is the cooli - QCD vacuum
The job 'give particles their mass' is done twice in the Standard Model by different builds: the Higgs field's vacuum value gives the quarks their small current masses, while the QCD vacuum's broken chiral symmetry and the conformal anomaly give about 99% of the proton's and neutron's mass. Lee et a - Quantum mechanics
One job, measuring a field or frequency with a two-level quantum system, done by unrelated builds: spin qubits in diamond, neutral atoms, trapped ions, superconducting circuits, atomic vapours and SQUIDs (Degen et al. 2017). - Quantum null energy condition (QNEC)
One job, keeping negative energy from running free, done by different builds: the QNEC (pointwise, with an entropy term), the ANEC (integrated along a null geodesic), quantum energy inequalities (time-integrals bounded below), and the Martin-Moruno-Visser quantum conditions (a scale hbar N/L^4). - Quantum spin chain
One job, a line of spins whose neighbour coupling yields a gapped Haldane phase with fractional ends, done by unrelated builds: Ni2+ ions in a crystal (NENP), carbon molecules (triangulene, 'S = 1 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon') on gold, and cold fermions in two-leg ladders (Sompet et al.); the Is - Quantum tunnelling
One job, a wave crossing a thin region it cannot travel in, done by matter waves (electrons, protons, alpha particles), by light between two prisms (frustrated total internal reflection), by sound in a solid between liquids, and by phonons across a nanometre gap. The source: the rectangular-barrier - Quark condensate (chiral condensate)
Mass for fermions by two builds: chiral symmetry breaking 'also occurs through the Brout-Englert-Higgs mechanism'; the Higgs vev gives the explicit quark masses, the quark condensate the ~300 MeV constituent masses of the light quarks. - Quasinormal mode
Ringing that decays because energy leaks: a struck wine glass (sound), an open optical or plasmonic resonator (light, 'Q-factor is limited to about 10 or less' for deep sub-wavelength modes), a perturbed black hole (curvature). - Quintom dark energy (quintom scenario; hypothesised)
One role (an equation of state that crosses -1) with many builds: two scalar fields, extra fermion fields, higher-derivative terms (Galileon), modified gravities (f(R), f(T), f(Q), Horndeski), matter-dark energy interactions, extra dimensions (DGP). - Radiative arrow of time
One arrow, several carriers: radio waves, sound waves and pond ripples all 'expand outward from their source'. - Radio
The detector's job (turn a radio-frequency signal into an audible one) done by the coherer, the electrolytic detector, galena crystal contacts 'by trial and error', Fleming's vacuum diode, then transistors; the job of finding a position done by echoes (radar) and by beacons' arrival times (GPS, VOR) - Radioactive decay
One job, getting rid of a nucleus's excitation energy, done by unrelated builds: a photon leaves (gamma decay), or the energy is handed to an atomic electron that leaves instead (internal conversion), the two competing for the same transition. A second job, turning a proton into a neutron, is done b - Ratio and proportion: comparing two quantities by how many times one contains the other, the practice of keeping proportions, and the structure it works on
Fold-change detection is produced by different circuit motifs (incoherent type-1 feedforward loop; non-linear integral feedback loop); in Ciona the two visuomotor circuits use one each. - Real number (the practice of measuring the continuum, and the complete ordered field)
One job, holding a real number, done by unrelated builds: cuts, sequence classes, infinite decimals, quasihomomorphisms of the integers (slopes), the largest Archimedean subfield of the surreals; in machines by floating point, symbolic formulas or computable digit streams; in the brain fractions and - Recursion: defining or computing a thing in terms of smaller versions of itself, as computer science and mathematics describe it, with its base cases, call stack, recursive data, induction, and its sightings in language and nature
Holding the pending instances is done by a call stack in machines, a push-down list in LISP, working memory in people, a stack tape added to Transformers; nested tempo in orangutan calls. - Redox
The job 'take the electrons at the end' is done by oxygen, nitrate, sulfate, iron oxides or a graphite electrode; the job 'reduce low-potential ferredoxin' by flavin bifurcating enzymes in cells and by native iron with H2 without any enzyme; the job 'make light by oxidizing a luciferin' by luciferas - Redox gradient (environmental redox zonation)
Plain job: taking hydrogen sulfide out of the water just below the boundary. In Framvaren Fjord it is 'attributed to manganese and iron oxides, photo-autotrophic bacteria, and entrainment of oxygen horizontally from the boundaries of the fjord': minerals, cells and water movement doing one job. - Redshift
One shift (1 + z) built three ways: relative motion, gravity, expansion; and carried by two messengers, light and gravitational waves. - Reflecting spacetime
One condition built on four structures: set inclusions, closures, boundaries (Lemma 3.42), continuity of set-valued maps (Lemma 3.46) and continuity of volume functions (Proposition 3.41). - Reinsurance
Keeping one place's catastrophe from landing on one holder by spreading it over places that are not hit at the same time: professional reinsurers (Thieme's internationalisation: 'losses on all lines in one country would be compensated by gains on all lines in another'), cat bonds held by investors, - Relativistic aberration of light
One displacement toward the direction of motion built by three motions: Earth's orbit (20.5 arcsec), Earth's spin (0.32 arcsec), the Sun's galactic orbit (150-165 arcsec, drift 5.8 microarcsec/yr). - Relativistic Doppler effect
One effect read by different builds: canal-ray spectra, accelerator H-alpha at 90 degrees, Mossbauer rotors, laser spectroscopy of fast neon. - Relativistic kinematic effect
One effect explained by different kinds in different frames: muons reach the ground by time dilation (Earth frame) or a contracted atmosphere (muon frame). - Relativistic precession
One role, an axis or orbit that slowly turns, built three ways: curvature from a mass (geodetic), rotation of the mass (frame dragging), and pure boost kinematics in flat spacetime (Thomas). - Renewable energy
One job, turning a natural energy flow into electricity, done by unrelated builds: a semiconductor junction (light), a rotor in moving air, a turbine under falling water, steam from the Earth's heat or burning biomass, and a tidal stream generator. Storage likewise: pumped water, batteries, molten s - Respiratory system
One job, a large thin wet surface where gas meets blood or cells with flow on both sides, built as gill lamellae, alveolar lungs, parabronchi, tracheoles, book lungs and skin; 'Disparate systems exhibit similar directions of adaptation'. - Retina (eye and retina)
a camera-eye retina built twice: vertebrate (inverted, brain outgrowth, ciliary receptors) and cephalopod (non-inverted, not from the brain, rhabdomeric receptors), 'not homologous, but have evolved separately' - Retrograde circular photon orbit
The last orbit of light, which draws the shadow edge: one circle at 3M without spin, a shell of spherical orbits (this one among them) with spin. - Ribosome
Holding an unfolded chain so it does not fold too early or stick to others: the rRNA surface ('ATP-independent holdase'), trigger factor (no ATPase) and Hsp70 (ATP-driven) do the one job with unrelated structures. - Riemann curvature tensor
Curvature built four ways: commutator of covariant derivatives, parallel transport round a shrinking loop, a Christoffel-symbol expression, and the tidal acceleration of neighbouring geodesics. - Rindler horizon
The one-way boundary is built by acceleration in flat spacetime (Rindler), by gravity (black-hole horizon) and by accelerating expansion (de Sitter horizon); all three are Killing horizons with a temperature kappa/2 pi. - Risk management
Surviving an unpredictable catastrophe by not staking everything on one outcome: organisations pool and share losses (risk-retention pools, insurance, Law 238's split of a ship's value); plants spread germination so some seeds sit out a drought, as antibiotic-tolerant bacteria sit out a drug (Abley - Ritual
One job (bonding a group) done by unlike builds: dysphoric ordeals (fire-walking, a national funeral's sadness), euphoric synchrony (marching, rowing, music), mourning rites; dysphoric and euphoric elements vary independently (orthogonal factors), two routes to the same cohesion. - River
Slowing the flow and holding sediment is done by beaver dams, riparian vegetation, the hyporheic zone and human reservoirs, each built differently. - RNA
Self-cleavage of the backbone: RNase A uses histidine and lysine; self-cleaving ribozymes use the 2'-OH as nucleophile. Gene control: proteins (repressors, activators) and RNAs (riboswitches, miRNAs). - Rock
One job, breaking a rock open, done by unrelated means: ice (9.2% expansion or ice lenses), salt crystals, roots, thermal fatigue, unloading, fungal hyphae, a hammerstone (and macaques cracking nuts). - Rock cycle
One job, keeping rock moving between kinds, done by different engines: plate tectonics on Earth, an episodic lid that recycles in bursts, heat-pipe volcanism driven by ~100 TW of tides on Io, interior cooling on Mercury and the Moon, a migratory sedimentary rock cycle on Mars without plate tectonics - Roman art
one job, conveying the ruler's authority and legitimacy, done by veristic Republican heads, idealised Augustan images and geometric Severan-Tetrarchic portraits - S-duality (strong-weak duality; projected model)
'Two seemingly different physical systems turn out to be equivalent in a nontrivial way ... mathematically different descriptions of the same phenomena': type I and SO(32) heterotic strings do one job with different strings. - Sagnac effect
'A conventional gyroscope relies on the principle of conservation of angular momentum whereas the sensitivity of the ring interferometer to rotation arises from the invariance of the speed of light': one job (a rotational reference), two builds. - Schiff frame-dragging precession of a gyroscope
A spin axis turned by the central mass (geodetic) and by its rotation (frame dragging): two builds, one gyroscope, right angles. - School
The same job, teaching the young a group's knowledge in a place set apart, built very differently: the Mesopotamian eduba in private houses, the Vedic gurukula in the teacher's house, the madrassa apart from the mosque, cathedral schools for clergy, West African bush schools in the forest, Madras Pi - Schwarzschild null geodesic
One role (light turned by mass) at two strengths: a 1.75-arcsecond nudge at the Sun's limb and a full wind onto the photon orbit at b_crit; the same equation builds both. - Sculpture
giving a durable three-dimensional figure is done by removal (carving stone or ivory), building up (modelling clay), and a matrix (casting metal) - SE(3): the group of rigid motions of three-dimensional space
One displacement, two builds: a rotation followed by a translation (rototranslation) or a single screw about one axis (Chasles); 'every rigid motion can be decomposed as the composition of a rotation and a translation' and 'all rigid motions are also screw motions'. - Secure software development
One job, checking a product for errors before it is released, paying effort or energy for accuracy: code review and static analysis before merge, and kinetic proofreading in the cell, which hydrolyses extra ATP to reject the wrong amino acid before a tRNA is charged. Also: diversity as protection, b - Security audit and compliance
One job, 'someone other than the claimant checks the claim', done by unrelated builds: medieval auditors hearing accounts read aloud, CPA attestation (SOC), certification bodies (ISO), national labs (Common Criteria), automated scanners (PCI ASV), an authorizing official (RMF), data protection autho - Security awareness
One job, warning a whole population against careless disclosure, done by different builds: World War II slogans and posters in four countries ('Loose lips sink ships', 'Careless Talk Costs Lives', 'En svensk tiger', 'Schäm Dich, Schwätzer!'), and today's simulations, embedded training and awareness - Security information and event management (SIEM)
One job, turning a flood of alarms from many sources into a few that carry meaning, done by unrelated builds: the SIEM's correlation rules; telecom network management's alarm correlation ('a conceptual interpretation of multiple alarms such that new meanings are assigned'); public-health syndromic s - Security operations center (SOC)
One job, watching a stream of alarms for the rare one that matters, done by different builds that all meet the same alarm fatigue: SOC analysts at a SIEM (99% of alarms called false by one analyst; 0.01% tied to true attacks at NCSA), intensive-care staff at patient monitors (72% to 99% of alarms te - Security policy and governance
The job 'keep any one actor from doing harm alone and say what may be done' is built as a written policy hierarchy (SP 800-12), as two signatures on a cheque (accounting's separation of duty), as Clark-Wilson's rule that certifier and implementer differ, as machine-checked labels (Bell-LaPadula) and - Sedimentary rock
One job, making new rock at the surface out of loose material, done four unrelated ways: cementing fragments of older rock (clastic), organisms building skeletons and mats (limestone, chert, microbialites), inorganic precipitation from supersaturated water (evaporites), and cementing erupted or impa - Semantics: meaning in language (the meanings of words and sentences, sense and reference, how meanings combine, how they are held in minds and brains and shared in a community) and the field of linguistics and philosophy that studies it
Composing a meaning from meaningful parts in order is done by human words and by Japanese great tit call notes (ABC + D = scan and approach; the reversed order fails). - Separation of powers
One job, keeping state power from collecting in one hand, done by unlike builds: separate election of executive and assembly (US presidential), a fused executive with an independent judiciary (Westminster), a dual executive (French semi-presidential), a second chamber outside the confidence relation - Series (mathematics): sums of infinitely many terms, and the practice of summing, testing and using them
One job, different builds: proving the pi series by arc length (Madhava) or by area (Leibniz); giving a sum to a divergent series by averaging (Cesaro), by a power-series limit (Abel), by an integral transform (Borel), by an infinite matrix (Silverman-Toeplitz methods); speeding a slow series by Mad - Set theory: the study of sets (collections taken as single objects), membership, Cantor's infinities and the axioms, and the practice of the people and machines who work with them
One job, laying a foundation for all of mathematics, done by different builds: ZFC (sets and membership), category and topos theory (objects and arrows), homotopy type theory (a set as a 0-type). Machine checkers split the same way: Metamath on ZFC, Lean on type theory. - Shape of the universe
Locally indistinguishable spaces with different global builds: 'a multiply connected space like a 3 torus has everywhere zero curvature but is finite in extent, whereas a flat simply connected space is infinite in extent'. - Shapiro time delay
The same delay for photons, neutrinos (SN 1987A, within 10%) and gravitational waves (GW170817). - Short story
Releasing the story's built tension at its close is done by two different builds: the twist and the open ending ('Final twists are one way of unleashing the full power of the antithetical forces, but “open endings” can serve a similar purpose'). Getting a reader into the story fast is also done two - Sign language (the natural signed languages)
Counting syllables is done by movements in sign and by vowels in speech: 'Syllables in sign languages are based on number of movements, just as syllables in spoken language are based on number of vowels'; and the same left perisylvian network runs both. - Signals intelligence
One job, finding where a transmitter is, done by unrelated builds: a hand-rotated loop (a minute or more), HF/DF arrays read on an oscilloscope (essentially instantaneous), Wullenweber ring arrays ('elephant cages'), time of arrival at GPS-synchronised receivers, interferometry. - Silicon atom
28Si is made by two different burning stages: alpha capture on 24Mg in the neon stage (9.98 MeV) and oxygen burning (16O + 16O -> 28Si + 4He, 9.593 MeV); the same product from two reaction routes, as for 32S. - Silk Road
The carrier-middleman job was done by Parthians, Sogdians, Kushan merchants, Armenians, Radanite Jewish merchants and Austronesian sailors; long-distance carriage by camel caravans (Bactrian in cold, Arabian in heat) and by ships. - Simple machine
The job, multiplying force or speed by trading it against distance about a pivot or along a helix, done by unrelated builds: wood and iron levers, myosin's light-chain neck, pennate muscle fibres, fish jaw four-bar linkages ('many-to-one mapping of form-to-jaw mechanical properties' in wrasses), a w - Simply connected universe
Finite without edge, by curvature rather than by gluing: the 3-sphere 'is simply connected and has positive curvature, whereas the 3-torus is multiply connected and flat'. - Simultaneous hyperplane
The role of 'now' across space built two ways: one universal instant for all frames (Galilean/Newtonian, 'All inertial frames share a universal time') and one hyperplane per observer (relativity, 'N depends on v'). - Skeletal system
Support met by bone, cartilage, chitin cuticle, calcium carbonate shell, silica, and pressurised fluid (hydrostatic skeletons, the majority of animals). - Skin
Shedding heat with water or without: sweating in humans, panting in dogs, thermoregulatory salivation in rats; cutaneous vasodilation does it with no water lost - Slow clock transport
Distant clocks are put in step by a light signal and its echo, or by carrying a clock slowly; 'The same synchronisation is achieved'. - Slow clock transport round a rotating body
The rotating body's lag is found by carrying a clock or by relaying light pulses: 'equal to the time difference that is found for a relay of pulses'. - Small business
One job, getting a big firm's buying power while staying small, is done by three unrelated builds: a retailers' cooperative owned by its members, a franchise contract with a corporation, and an association that buys health insurance in bulk. - SO(3)-invariant photon surface
One job, keeping tangent light on a hypersurface, three builds: the static photon sphere (SO(3) x R-invariant), the dynamic SO(3)-invariant tube obeying an area law, and any null hypersurface ('trivially a photon surface'). - Social class
One job, placing people in lasting ranked groups, done by different builds through history: legal estates and orders, caste by birth, and class by economic position; class replaced estates and orders as the main build in the late 18th century. - Social contagion
One job, passing a state from neighbour to neighbour, is done by light in fish schools and stadiums, by sound in concert halls, by text in feeds and by face-to-face ties in villages. - Social engineering
One job, getting a target to give up its resources by passing a forged signal as a trusted one, done by unrelated builds: a cuckoo egg in a reed warbler's nest, a logo and display name in an email, a cloned voice on the phone. The resisting job is also built differently: egg rejection learned with b - Social network
One job, keeping track of and servicing relationships, done by different builds: grooming in primate groups, face-to-face meeting, letters and calls, and online platforms; online friend counts land at the same size as offline networks (155-183 against 150). - Social norm
One job, sanctioning norm violators, done by different builds that track the economy: reputational punishment with egalitarianism and no food storage, material with storage, physical with hunting, execution with stratification (131 societies); across 57 countries gossip stands in where physical conf - Social stratification
One job, ranking a society's people into layers that persist, done by different builds: class (economic position, open), caste (birth, ritual purity, endogamy, closed), feudal estates (land and lordship), and, at rung 10, the linear dominance ranks of macaques set by order of arrival. - Social structure
Handing scarce reusable units on: jobs and houses in human vacancy chains, empty snail shells in hermit crabs, anemones for clownfish, cavities for birds. - Socialization
One job, teaching newcomers a group's ways, done by unrelated structures: parents in families, peer groups, schools and their hidden curricula, broadcast media, onboarding in firms, staff in total institutions, and breeders and owners for puppies - Sodium atom
The spike's current is carried by different ions in different lineages: sodium in animal axons ('the sudden flow of sodium ions into the cell through voltage-gated sodium channels enables transmission of a nerve impulse'), calcium in single-celled eukaryotes and slow spikes, chloride release in plan - Software
Breaking the normal flow to run a handler is done three ways at three floors: CPU-defined interrupts, OS-defined signals, language-defined exceptions ('Each layer requires different ways of exception handling'). Running source code is done by compilation ahead of time, interpretation at run time, or - Software engineering
One job, getting a large program from need to working release, met by different process builds: sequential phases (waterfall), the spiral, agile iterations; and the same communication job met by stand-ups, reviews and documents. - Software vulnerability
One job, a built-in response that an outsider can trigger to make the receiver act for the outsider: a parser that trusts a length field (Heartbleed), a lock whose weakness a picker exploits (Hobbs, 1851), a female sea lamprey's attraction to the larval cue, which the male pheromone mimics (a sensor - Solution (chemistry)
Keeping what is dissolved from falling out of solution, done two unrelated ways: blood holds supersaturated calcium phosphate by a carrier protein (fetuin-A) that turns it into colloids, while a cell's own ions are chosen so that kosmotropic anions pair with chaotropic cations into 'highly soluble, - Songbird (oscines, suborder Passeri)
Learning sounds by copying others, done by songbirds with a syrinx and a forebrain song system, and by people with a larynx and speech cortex; sweet taste done by songbirds and hummingbirds by separate retunings of the umami receptor; planning ahead done by ravens and apes with unrelated brains - Sorting algorithm
One job, putting a list in order, done by unrelated builds: insertion, merging, partitioning, heap selection, digit distribution; by fixed comparator networks in hardware; by memristive in-memory minimum search; by a person taking the largest item first; by self-moving elements in the cell-view mode - Sound
Picking sound out of the medium: a mammal eardrum, insect tympana, a fish's dense otolith lagging as an inertial mass, a swim bladder reradiating pressure as particle motion, elephants' feet for ground-borne infrasound - Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH)
The surface of a black hole as a quasilocal, non-teleological SFOTH, 'can not be formed in flat space-time', versus the event horizon, which can 'form in a flat region of space-time and grow even though there is no flux of energy of any kind across them'. - Spacelike curve
Both sides of a Cauchy horizon close their geodesics: 'One side ... contains closed space-like geodesics and the other side contains closed time-like geodesics.' - Spacelike hypersurface
One role, 'an instant of time', built as one observer's hyperplane in flat spacetime and as a Cauchy surface in curved spacetime. - Spacelike infinity (i0)
The far ends of geodesic families: one point for all spacelike geodesics (i0), points for timelike ones (i+-), null sheets for light (I+-). - Spacetime topology
Nearness of events built two ways on one point set: from charts (manifold topology) and from the causal order alone (Alexandrov); in a strongly causal spacetime the two builds give the same answer, so the clock-order rebuilds the shape. - Spectral triple
Carrying the metric: a metric tensor g on spacetime, or a Dirac operator whose commutators bound distances; for a spin manifold both give the same geodesic distance. - Spectroscopy
one job, sorting light by wavelength, done by a prism, a grating, an interferometer plus a transform, living tissue itself, and an eye's cones - Speech (human spoken language)
Carrying language is done by the voice (larynx and tract) and by the hands and eyes in sign; learned vocal production is done by the human larynx and by the songbird's syrinx; a speech BCI does the speaker's last floors with electrodes and a decoder. - Speed of gravity
One speed limit carried by different builds: photons (electromagnetism), gluons (strong force) and gravitational waves all move at c. - Speed of light
Two different fields, one propagation speed: electromagnetic waves (c = 1/sqrt(epsilon_0 mu_0)) and gravitational waves (GW170817: equal to c within -3 x 10^-15 to +7 x 10^-16). - Sperm whale (cachalot, Physeter macrocephalus)
Homing on prey with a rapid final burst of sonar: creaks in sperm whales (nasal clicks) are analogous to terminal buzzes in bats (laryngeal calls); and marking which cultural group you belong to, done by identity codas in whales and by ethnic markers in people - Spherical photon orbit
One job, the limit curve that draws a shadow edge: circular light rays filling the photon sphere at a = 0, spherical non-planar rays filling the photon region at a != 0 ('the notion of a photon region is the relevant generalization of the notion of a photon sphere'). - Spiders (order Araneae)
A pressurised body part for muscles to work against: spiders extend their legs by hemolymph pressure from the prosoma pump (no extensor muscles), 'a system inherited from their pre-arthropod ancestors'; the chordate notochord is a pressurised rod; cephalopod arms are muscular hydrostats. - Standard Model of particle physics
Giving things mass, done by two unrelated builds inside one model: the Higgs vacuum value gives the W, Z and the elementary fermions their masses (Yukawa terms), while 'the mass of ordinary matter derives almost entirely from energy – the energy of massless gluons and nearly massless quarks' (Wilcze - Star and interstellar medium matter cycle (stellar recycling)
One job, returning enriched matter to the gas, done by differently built channels: 'planetary nebulae, stellar winds, and supernovae', and at low metallicity the pair-instability explosion that returns the whole star. - Startup company
One job, paying for a startup's early experiments before it has revenue, is done by unrelated builds: founders' savings and family (bootstrapping), angels, venture funds, equity crowdfunding, revenue-based lenders, factoring, startup studios, and established companies' internal startups. - State of matter
One job, making matter flow without friction or resistance as one quantum state, done by different builds: bosons condensing directly (helium-4, rubidium), fermions first pairing into bosons and then condensing (superconductors, helium-3, lithium-6). Firing rule: the job in plain words: flowing as o - Static observer in a fluid ball
A static observer is held at rest by 'ideal rocket engines' or by 'the net effect of pressure holding up the fluid ball': one job, two supports. - Static observers (Schwarzschild)
Holding an observer at fixed r is done by rocket thrust or by pressure holding up a fluid ball against its own gravity. - Static spherically symmetric perfect fluid
The same job (hold a ball up against its own gravity) done by different matter laws: degenerate electrons (white dwarf), neutron matter (neutron star); each law gives its own ceiling. - Stationary spacetime
Stationarity read three ways: a timelike Killing vector, time-independent metric components, and a time-independent geometry on the quotient V = M/G. - Statistical mechanics
The job 'say how ordered this phase is' is done by different quantities: magnetisation in a ferromagnet, density in the liquid-gas transition, a staggered magnetisation in an antiferromagnet, the electric field in a ferroelectric (Kadanoff's order parameters). - Statistics: the practice of collecting and reasoning from data, the intuitive statistics it grows from, and the structure (samples, distributions, estimators) it works on
Statistical inference in kea and great apes with brains 'of a highly different structure': 'may have arisen twice on our planet via convergent evolution'. - Steel
Keeping iron from rusting is done by chromium's own passive film (stainless), a zinc layer (galvanized, 'a similar effect'), a stable rust skin (weathering steel), concrete's alkali around rebar, and sacrificial zinc anodes: one job, five unrelated builds. - Steep temporal function
One quantity, the Lorentzian distance, built two ways: as the longest proper time along causal curves (realised by a geodesic in globally hyperbolic spacetimes, Avez-Seifert Th. 4.123) and as the infimum of clock differences over all steep temporal functions (Th. 5.10). - Stellar magnetic field
Giving a star a field is done by a tachocline-assisted dynamo (Sun), a convection-only dynamo (fully convective dwarfs and brown dwarfs) and kept fossil flux (white dwarfs). - Stellar remnant (compact star)
One job, holding a dead star's core up against gravity, three builds: electron degeneracy (white dwarfs), neutron degeneracy plus 'repulsive neutron-neutron interactions' (neutron stars), and none at all, a horizon (black holes); each takes over where the last fails. - Stored-program principle (instructions held in the same memory as data)
One description used two ways, executed and copied: von Neumann's tape is read by the constructor and copied by the copier, which 'parallels DNA translation' and 'DNA replication' and was proposed before DNA's structure was known; a quine is built the same way, 'code used to do the actual printing a - String field theory (projected content: the string field)
The D-brane built two ways: a boundary condition for open strings, and a lump solution of the tachyon in the string field. - String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
Dualities: 'two theories are mathematically different descriptions of the same phenomena'; IIA on one Calabi-Yau and IIB on its mirror give 'the same physics'. - Strong (colour) field
Binding done at two ranges by two carriers: 'observable at two ranges, and mediated by different force carriers in each one': below ~0.8 fm gluons hold quarks into hadrons; up to ~3 fm mesons bind nucleons into nuclei (the source's table 'Two layers of strong interaction'). - Sulfur atom
32S is made by two different burning stages: oxygen burning gives it directly (16O + 16O -> 32S + gamma, 16.539 MeV), and silicon burning makes it again by alpha capture (28Si + 4He -> 32S) before feeding it on to 36Ar. - Sun
Heat leaves the core by two different structures: radiation (photons absorbed and re-emitted) out to 0.7 solar radii, then convection (thermal cells) where the plasma is no longer dense or hot enough to carry it by radiation. - Superconductivity
the job of binding fermions into pairs is done by different glues: the electron-phonon interaction in metals, van der Waals forces between He3 atoms, the nuclear force in nuclei and neutron stars (Cooper); and by repulsion with a sign-changing gap in cuprates (Keimer) - Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter)
One job, gluing two fermions into a bound pair below a temperature, done by different glues in different bodies: phonons for electrons in metals, the nuclear force for protons and neutrons in neutron stars, gluons for quarks in dense quark matter, an atomic attraction for helium-3. 'The BCS theory, - Supernova
One outcome (the star blown apart, a supernova) by two unrelated builds: core collapse powered by gravity and neutrinos, and thermal runaway of a white dwarf powered by carbon fusion. - Supersymmetric anti-de Sitter string vacuum (projected model)
The exponential term that holds the volume comes from two different builds: a Euclidean D3 instanton or gaugino condensation on D7 branes ('effects 1) and 2) have rather similar consequences'). - Supersymmetry (projected model)
Holding a degeneracy against quantum corrections is done by an ordinary symmetry (vacua 'related by a symmetry which guarantees that their energy levels remain exactly degenerate') or by supersymmetry (vacua 'not related by any symmetry'). - Supply and demand
Matching what is supplied to what is wanted is done by different builds: a double auction's cross of bids and asks, a vervet group's grooming rates, metabolic supply and demand blocks linked by one metabolite, a power grid's frequency, which 'indicates the balance of supply and demand'. - Supply chain security
The job 'check that an arriving part is what it claims and unaltered' is done by tamper-proof seals on containers, code signatures and reproducible rebuilds on software, power side-channel fingerprints on chips, and laboratory quality testing on medicines. - Surface gravity (of a horizon)
One job, the temperature-like number of a horizon, four builds: Killing-horizon kappa (stationary), WIH kappa(l) (equilibrium, normal-dependent), effective kappa-bar on dynamical horizons, Hayward's trapping gravity on trapping horizons. - Surveillance
One job, watching members of a group and sanctioning those who break its rules, done by unrelated builds: a tail, an informant network, a camera with face recognition, a wiretap, a data broker's profile; and in honeybee colonies by nestmates who eat worker-laid eggs (worker policing), which keeps mo - Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model)
One job, marking the boundary, done by several criteria built from different evidence: black-hole thermodynamics (no global symmetry, completeness, weak gravity), string dualities (distance), no-go theorems (de Sitter). - Syntax: how a language combines words into phrases and sentences (constituency and dependency, word order, agreement, recursion), how speakers build and parse it, how children learn it, how it differs across languages, and the field that studies it
Marking who did what to whom: by order (English), by case and agreement (Latin, Polish), by space and the face (sign languages). - T-duality (target-space duality; projected model)
Two geometries, one physics: a circle of radius R and of radius alpha'/R; IIA and IIB; a Calabi-Yau and its mirror. 'the two theories are mathematically different descriptions of the same phenomena'. - Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox)
A route into one's own past built two ways: two spacelike faster-than-light legs in flat spacetime (antitelephone) or a closed timelike curve in curved spacetime ('return to the same place and time that it started'); both open the grandfather paradox. - Tax
One job, getting resources from people to the ruler or the public purse, done by different builds: labour owed (corvée), a tenth of produce (tithe), coin per head (poll tax), a share of property, income or value added, duties at the border, and money creation (seigniorage, the inflation tax). - Teacher
A dedicated helper that does not do the productive work but makes others able to: human dedicated teachers, chaperones that help proteins fold without taking part in enzymatic activity, post-reproductive mammals passing on information, and teaching in killer whales, elephants, meerkats and birds - Telephone
Turning voice into current: a diaphragm in a magnetic field (magneto), a needle in acid water (Gray, Bell 1876), loosely packed carbon granules (Hughes, Edison, Berliner), moving coils, later electret microphones. Alerting: whistling into the transmitter, a bell on a second wire, a bell behind a cap - Television
Carriage met by terrestrial transmitters, coaxial cable, satellites and Internet streaming; display by spinning disks, CRTs, plasma, LCD, OLED and DLP; funding by advertising, licence fees, subscriptions and taxes. - Temporal function
The global clock of a stably causal spacetime built two ways: a continuous time function (Hawking's averaged volumes) or a smooth temporal one (timelike gradient); Theorem 3.56 makes them equivalent for existence. - Terminal indecomposable future set (TIF)
The past edge built from TIFs and the conformal past edge (i-) built by rescaling agree on the accessible part. - Terminal indecomposable past set (TIP)
The causal boundary (built from TIPs) and the conformal boundary (built by rescaling) agree on the accessible part. - Thalamus
The job of passing the senses up to the pallium/cortex is done by the thalamus proper in most vertebrates but by a convergent, non-homologous 'thalamus-like sensory relay station' (the preglomerular complex) in teleosts; the job in plain words: a relay station between senses and the forebrain's roof - The archive and the historical record
The job of keeping a society's records for later readers is done by clay-tablet rooms (Ebla), the archon's house, Roman tabularia, a synagogue storeroom (the Geniza), oral literature (hikaye), web crawlers (866 billion pages) and film in a permafrost vault. - The world through the senses (sensory environment)
Detecting infrared: pit vipers, pythons and boas do it by radiant heating of TRPA1 in a pit organ, not by photochemistry as eyes detect light - Theatre
One role (an event enacted before a live audience) built as Athenian dance-drama, Sanskrit theatre under a sutradhara, Nō and Kabuki, Peking opera, wayang shadow puppets, ta'ziyeh, rakugo's single seated storyteller, and the Broadway musical. - Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
Shedding body heat by evaporation, built differently: 'humans achieve evaporative heat loss primarily by sweating, whereas dogs rely on panting and rodents spread saliva on their fur' (o64). And holding a body warm: brown fat in some, shivering in muscle (o59). - Thermodynamics
One role, turning heat into work under Carnot's cap, met by very different builds: steam and gas-turbine power plants, a single trapped calcium ion, a colloidal particle in a feedback trap (information engine), solar cells read as heat engines. - Threat actor
One job, running intrusion campaigns, done by unrelated builds: a network of 5-10 people with no strict hierarchy (most of 40 criminal networks), a firm with 100+ staff, payroll and departments (Conti), a leaderless collective (Anonymous), a military unit (GRU Unit 26165), a lone insider. - Three-torus universe
Finite with no edge, built two ways: the 3-sphere by positive curvature (simply connected), the 3-torus by gluing flat space (multiply connected): 'Both are compact and have no boundary'. - Thurston geometries
Eight different model geometries each serve as the local geometry of a closed 3-manifold piece; the fundamental group decides which. - Tidal (electrogravitic) tensor
One role (reading curvature as relative acceleration) built twice: the relativistic E[X]_ab = R_ambn X^m X^n and the Newtonian gravity gradient tensor -grad grad V, whose free-space trace vanishes as E's does in vacuum. - Time dilation
Different clocks read the one dilation: muon decay (weak field), caesium and optical atomic clocks and canal-ray Doppler frequencies (electromagnetic field). - Time function
One job (a global clock that climbs along every causal curve), four builds: an averaged volume function (Hawking), the volume functions themselves (causally continuous), Geroch's log ratio of past and future volumes (globally hyperbolic), and time step functions smoothed into a Cauchy temporal funct - Time-orientable Lorentzian metric
Time orientation built three equivalent ways: a smooth choice of cones, a global timelike vector field (Proposition 2.3), or a non-vanishing vector field on the bare manifold (Theorem 2.4). - Timelike infinity (i+ and i-)
Far ends of geodesic families: i+- for timelike, i0 for spacelike, I+- for null. - Tokamak
The job 'twist the field lines so the drifts cancel' is done by a current in the plasma (tokamak) or by twisted external coils with no current (stellarator); the job 'hold the fuel hot and dense' by a magnetic field here, by gravity in stars, by inertia in laser-driven implosions. - Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equation
Hydrostatic support in two builds: the Newtonian hydrostatic equation and the TOV equation do one job; they agree when 1/c^2 terms are negligible and part ways in compact stars. - Tool
Opening hard-shelled food is done by chimpanzee hammer and portable anvil stones, sea otters' chest anvils and fixed emergent anvils, capuchins and macaques, mongooses on rocks and tree stems, and gulls dropping mussels; extracting embedded prey by chimpanzee termite probes, crow hooks and woodpecke - Trapped region
The surface of a black hole built from trapping: Hawking's apparent horizon (3-dimensional, outer trapped, regular predictability), Hayward's trapping boundary and trapping horizon (4-dimensional, no global assumption). - Trapped surface
Two builds of one job (marking a black hole): a local surface that implies a singularity, and a global surface (event horizon) for which 'there is no corresponding theorem'; trapped surfaces 'actually preceded' event horizons. - Trapping boundary
Three builds of 'the surface of a black hole': the boundary of the trapped region (global, foliation-free), the apparent horizon (slice-bound) and the event horizon (global, teleological); they coincide in Schwarzschild and part ways when matter falls in. - Trapping horizon
One job (laws of black-hole mechanics) done on two boundaries: Hawking's area theorem on the global event horizon and Hayward's second, first and zeroth laws on the quasi-local trapping horizon. - Trophic network (food webs: who eats whom, from primary production through consumers to decomposers)
One job, fixing carbon at the base of the web, done two ways: photosynthesis by plants and algae, and chemosynthesis by bacteria and archaea that 'use hydrogen sulfide and methane from hydrothermal vents and cold seeps as an energy source (just as plants use sunlight)'. - Truth
One job, settling whether a claim fits how things are, done by unrelated builds: observation and experiment (empirical sciences), deductive proof (formal sciences), standards of proof and admissible evidence (courts), verification against reliable sources (journalism), probability between 0 and 1. - Turing machine: the abstract machine that reads and writes one symbol at a time on an unbounded tape by a finite table of rules, the model of computation of logic and computer science
One job, computing the computable functions, built as Turing machines, lambda calculus, recursive functions, Post systems, register machines, Rule 110 and the Game of Life, two-dimensional billiards, oscillating chemistry, DNA string rewriting, Lego and relays. - Two-way speed of light
One synchronisation, several builds: Einstein's light round trip, slow clock transport ('The same synchronisation is achieved by transporting a third clock from clock 1 to clock 2 slowly'), and Reichenbach's and Laue-Weyl's round-trip conditions; all rest on an isotropic two-way speed. - Type I (spherically symmetric) weakly isolated horizon
The black-hole surface in equilibrium is built three ways by symmetry class (type I, II, III), and the zeroth and first laws hold in each. - Type I supergravity (ten-dimensional N = 1 supergravity, with super Yang-Mills)
One low-energy theory, three string completions: type I (open and closed strings), heterotic SO(32) and heterotic E8 x E8 (closed hybrid strings). - Type I superstring theory (projected model)
The SO(32) gauge symmetry is built two ways: Chan-Paton labels on open-string ends here, a left-moving current algebra on a closed string in heterotic SO(32); S-duality says they are one theory. - Type II (axisymmetric) weakly isolated horizon
The black-hole surface in equilibrium is built three ways by symmetry class (type I, II, III); mechanics and multipoles are written for type II, the class of spinning holes. - Type IIB supergravity (projected model)
Anomaly cancellation done by the field content alone here (three equations that happen to be dependent), by a transforming two-form in the N = 1 theories (Green-Schwarz). - Ultracool dwarf
Holding the body up against gravity: thermal ionic pressure in the stars, electron degeneracy in the brown dwarfs, both together near the limit (degeneracy parameter 2 to 0.05). Form: the build shifts continuously with mass. - Ultraviolet completion (parent kind)
One role (finite, predictive physics at all energies) built as a Gaussian fixed point, a non-Gaussian fixed point, extended strings or a fundamental length. - Unemployment
One job, carrying people of working age through a gap in paid work, is met by different builds: punishment and moving-on (Tudor 'sturdy beggars'), the workhouse (until 1948), state insurance (UK 1911, US 1935), union-run funds (the Ghent system), public works (WPA, CCC), a proposed job guarantee. Ac - Uniform circular motion world line
One role (a clock whose rate depends only on its speed), two builds tested: muons on a straight fast path in the atmosphere and muons going round a storage ring ('the proper time of an accelerated clock is unaffected by acceleration'). - Uniform translation (inertial straight world line)
One role (the free path a body takes when nothing acts on it), two builds: a straight line in flat spacetime and a geodesic in curved spacetime ('World lines of freely falling particles/objects are called geodesics'). - Unit normal vector (hypersurface)
A normal built two ways: as the (metric dual of the) gradient of the slicing field, or as the cross product of two tangent edges (then a pseudovector). - Universe
One role in the expansion law met by different contents: 'matter' (w = 0) is met by both baryons and dark matter; 'radiation' (w = 1/3) by photons and relic neutrinos. - Unstable circular orbit
One role (a circle that cannot hold), built for massive particles across 1.5-3 r_s and for light at exactly 1.5 r_s; spin splits it into prograde and retrograde builds. - Urinary system
Making urine and reclaiming what is needed is done by a blood filter plus tubule in vertebrate nephrons, by secretion into Malpighian tubules in insects (analogous, not kidneys), by nephridia in other invertebrates, and without glomeruli in some marine fish. - V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule)
Two independent builds fill one role, a per-lifetime receptor repertoire: jawed vertebrates split Ig/TCR segments with RAG, while jawless fish assemble variable lymphocyte receptors from leucine-rich-repeat cassettes 'via a process resembling gene conversion, mediated by a family of cytidine deamina - Vacuum solution (general relativity)
One job, curvature with no local source, done by different builds: a static sphere (Schwarzschild), a spinning body (Kerr), a travelling wave (pp-waves), an empty expanding universe (Milne). - Vagus nerve
Sugar sensing done three ways: taste cells by T1R2/T1R3, beta cells by metabolism and KATP channels, enteroendocrine cells by SGLT1 sodium transport - Vaidya spacetime
'The numerous roles played by the event horizon in equilibrium situations get split in dynamical contexts, some taken up by the DH': in Vaidya one horizon role is built twice, teleologically (event horizon) and quasi-locally (dynamical horizon). - Vascular plants (tracheophytes)
Anchoring the plant and drawing water from soil was built at least twice: lycophyte rhizophores, 'equivalent to stems, with organs equivalent to leaves performing the role of rootlets', and the true roots of the other plants; 'roots are initiated and their growth promoted by different mechanisms in - Vector calculus (the calculus of fields: gradient, divergence, curl; the practice and the structures it works on)
The gradient and curl are taken by very different builds. Gradient: pseudopods splitting toward a chemical (a cell), ampullae of Lorenzini (a shark), backpropagation and a learning rate (a machine), del notation (a person). Curl: MSTd neurons tuned to spirals (a brain), the paddle wheel imagined (a - Velocity
Three builds of 'how fast': velocity dx/dt (observer time), proper velocity gamma u = dx/d tau (traveller time) and rapidity (additive). - Visual art (drawing, painting, sculpture)
Showing an image to others is done by pigment sprayed round a hand, an ochre crayon line, carved ivory, a woodcut matrix and a camera's timed exposure: one job (a lasting image for the eye), many builds. - Volume function
Global clocks built from volumes three ways: t+- themselves (causally continuous), Hawking's average over metrics (stably causal), Geroch's log ratio (globally hyperbolic). - Voting
One job, adding up members' choices to commit the group, done by unrelated builds: ballots counted in human elections, sneezes counted to a quorum in wild dogs, waggle dances with stop signals in bee swarms, initiators' moves in baboons, sampled reasoning paths in a language model (self-consistency) - Vulnerability management
Spending a limited repair capacity where harm is likeliest: VM ranks by severity, exploitation and asset context; trauma field triage sorts patients to trauma centres; the cell runs a whole-genome scan (GG-NER) and repairs the transcribed strands of genes in use first (TC-NER), as VM scans everythin - W boson
The carrier role is built three ways: 'The W and Z bosons are carrier particles that mediate the weak nuclear force, much as the photon is the carrier particle for the electromagnetic force'; the photon is massless (infinite range), the W massive (sub-proton range), and gluons are massless but confi - Water cycle (hydrologic cycle)
Lifting water into the air by evaporation, by sublimation of snow and ice, or through plants (transpiration); cooling air to its dew point by adiabatic, conductive, radiational or evaporative cooling. - Water pollution
One job, removing contaminants from wastewater, done by unrelated builds: activated sludge reactors, membrane bioreactors, constructed wetlands, sunlit waste stabilization ponds, chlorination and ozonation. - Wave
Carrying a change across space faster than the parts move: built from elasticity and inertia (sound, seismic waves), gravity and buoyancy (ocean waves), self-coupled fields (light), spacetime curvature (gravitational waves), diffusion plus positive feedback (Cdk1, Rho-actin, calcium waves), fluid co - Wave speed
One role (the travel rate of a wave) built by different media: vacuum (c for light and gravity), air (343 m/s), water (1481 m/s), iron (5120 m/s), glass (c/n). - Wave vector
One vector describes ocean waves (excess water height), sound (excess air pressure), light (null, v_p = c) and electron waves in crystals (via the envelope). - Weak field
The carrier role in each interaction is built differently: 'The Standard Model of particle physics recognizes four kinds of gauge bosons: photons, which carry the electromagnetic interaction; W and Z bosons, which carry the weak interaction; and gluons, which carry the strong interaction' (massless - Weakly distinguishing spacetime
Telling events apart, built three ways: by I+ alone (future distinction), by I- alone (past distinction), or by the pair together (weak distinction); each of the first two implies the third. - Weakly isolated horizon
The laws of black-hole mechanics (zeroth and first) are carried by a global build (Killing horizon of a stationary spacetime) and by a quasi-local one (the WIH, which needs only its own intrinsic geometry, with radiation possibly right outside). - Weather
One job, lifting air until its water condenses, done three unrelated ways: convection over heated ground, large-scale motion along fronts, and mountains (orographic lift). Birds soar on all three (thermals, ridge lift, sea-breeze fronts). - Weathering
Prying rock apart from inside a crack is done by growing ice lenses, growing salt lenses, plant roots and lichen hyphae, and by thermal expansion: one job, unrelated builds. - Wetland
One job, getting oxygen to roots in anoxic mud, done by unrelated builds: aerenchyma in cattails, sedges, water-lilies and rice (made by cell death, lysigenous, or by cells separating, schizogenous) and the black mangrove's pneumatophores, aerial roots that 'stick up out of the soil like straws for - White dwarf
Support against gravity done by three structures: thermal pressure (main-sequence star), electron degeneracy (white dwarf), neutron degeneracy plus nuclear repulsion (neutron star); 'electron degeneracy pressure is a manifestation of the more general phenomenon of quantum degeneracy pressure'. - William Shakespeare
One plain job, telling who wrote a text, done by unrelated means: title pages and the Stationers' Register, line-ending ratios (Spedding 1850), pause positions, rare words, speech lengths, function-word frequencies, rhythmic types with machine learning, personality-based word semantics, network clus - Wireless network
The job: let many senders share one medium without wrecking each other's signals. Built as random access with resend (ALOHA), listen-first with acknowledgment and backoff (Wi-Fi CSMA/CA), a central scheduler granting time-frequency blocks (LTE/5G OFDMA), master-polled slots (Bluetooth), frequency ho - Word: the unit of a language's lexicon (spoken, signed or written) as linguists describe it, and as it is held, learned and retrieved in each speaker's mental lexicon
The job of marking where one word ends and the next begins is done by different structures: syllable statistics, fixed stress, vowel harmony (Turkish), a two-syllable minimum (Walmatjari), spaces in alphabetic writing, kanji-kana switching in Japanese. - World sheet
The history of an object is built at each size: 'A particle sweeps out a worldline in Minkowski space. A string sweeps out a worldsheet'. The action follows: length for the particle, area for the string. - World tube
One role, the history of an object, built by size: a world line for a point, a world sheet for a string, a world tube for an extended body, a world volume for a p-brane ('A p-brane sweeps out a (p+1)-dimensional volume'). - World tube of a small compact body
One role (a compact mass moving as a point) built by matter (a neutron star) and by pure geometry (a black hole, whose inner spacetime has a singularity where the outer one is smooth). - Wound healing
Closing the hole is done by different builds: lamellipodial crawling or a purse-string actomyosin cable (embryos, cnidarians), re-epithelialization over a scab (humans), contraction (loose-skinned rodents), a regeneration blastema (salamanders), neoblasts (planarians), soft-tissue rearrangement (Hyd - Writing system (a script plus the rules binding it to a language)
One job, binding marks to a language, built on different units: consonants (17 abjads), consonant-vowel units (56 abugidas), phonemes (44 alphabets), syllables (11 syllabaries), morphemes (4 logosyllabaries), features (Hangul). - Z boson
The carrier role built three ways: 'The W and Z bosons are carrier particles that mediate the weak nuclear force, much as the photon is the carrier particle for the electromagnetic force'; massive Z, massless photon, massless but confined gluons. - Zero angular momentum observer (ZAMO)
The reference family for circular orbits is the static observers in Schwarzschild and the ZAMOs in Kerr: 'In this limit the ZAMOs coincide with the static observers'.
Match (7)
- Competition for a companion's envelope (binary mass transfer)
Three builds take the same overflow: 'the accretor, which can be a white dwarf, neutron star or black hole'. Their taking floors differ (disc and surface burning, magnetic funnel onto the poles, disc into the horizon). The white-dwarf anchor became real in wave B when valence 1 was re-pointed onto t - Competition for atomic hydrogen (stars vs molecule formation)
Two molecule builds do one job: gas-phase HeH+ + H in the primordial gas ('the first molecule', then H2) and grain-surface H + H in the interstellar medium ('This process yields 4.48 eV'). Both turn pool atoms into H2. - Competition for cloud gas (competitive accretion and stellar feedback)
Three builds disperse the cloud: ionising light (H II regions, champagne flows), stellar winds ('also known to contribute to cloud dispersal') and supernova shocks. - Competition for core protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle)
One job, hydrogen to helium, two builds: the CNO cycle 'is one of the two known sets of fusion reactions by which stars convert hydrogen to helium, the other being the proton-proton chain'. The pp chain goes through a weak step between two protons; the CNO cycle through borrowed carbon, nitrogen and - Competition for galactic gas (black hole vs star formation)
Two builds regulate star formation by acting on the gas: AGN feedback (quasar and radio modes) and stellar feedback (supernovae, winds, photoionisation, radiation pressure). - EPRL model (Engle-Pereira-Rovelli-Livine spin-foam model; projected model)
One vertex amplitude, two derivations: EPRL by weak operator constraints, FK by coherent states in expectation values; they coincide for gamma < 1 and differ for gamma > 1. - FK model (Freidel-Krasnov spin-foam model; projected model)
Same vertex as EPRL for gamma < 1, reached by a different route (coherent states, expectation values) rather than operator constraints.
Partial: part of the shape (305)
- Absolute elsewhere (spacelike region)
The one role 'the events that are now' is built two ways: a thin 3D present shared by all (Galilean/Newtonian) or a thick 4D elsewhere holding every observer's own simultaneous hyperplane. - Acausal set
One role (an instant of time) built as a topological acausal slice or, in the smooth setting, as a spacelike one: stable acausality is 'a kind of replacement for the spacelikeness notion'. - Accelerating observer (non-inertial frame; Rindler frame)
One effect, two builds: a detector accelerating in empty space (Unruh) and a detector hovering above a black hole (Hawking) see the same thermal form, T proportional to a or to the surface gravity g. - Active galactic nucleus
An emergent thermostat: 'the cooling limited by the feedback/heating provided by AGN radio sources' does the job of the star's core thermostat, built from jets and hot gas instead of fusion and pressure (the quasar walk's sighting, re-anchored to its owner kind). - AdS x S product spacetimes
One job (a gravitational bulk dual to a superconformal theory), several builds: AdS5 x S5 from D3-branes, AdS7 x S4 from M5-branes, AdS4 x S7 from M2-branes, AdS3 x S3 from D1-D5. - AdS/CFT correspondence (projected model)
One duality, several builds: IIB on AdS5 x S5, M-theory on AdS7 x S4 and AdS4 x S7, and pure three-dimensional gravity with no strings at all (Liouville theory, the monster CFT). - AdS3 (three-dimensional anti-de Sitter space)
A black hole built two ways: in 3+1 dimensions by collapse that curves spacetime, in AdS3 by identifying points of an already constant-curvature space (BTZ is 'locally isometric to anti-de Sitter space'), with the same thermodynamics. - Age of the universe (time since the Big Bang)
Independent clocks give the age or its floor: the CMB acoustic peak (early universe), the distance ladder through H0 (late universe), main-sequence turnoff and white-dwarf cooling (the oldest objects). - Air shower (extensive air shower; secondary cosmic rays)
Two builds of one cascade: 'If the primary particle is a hadron, mostly light mesons like pions and kaons are produced ... Primary photons and electrons, on the other hand, produce mainly electromagnetic showers'; both end by spreading the primary's energy through the air. - Algebraic quantum gravity (AQG; walked as a projected model)
One dynamical job, the master constraint, built on embedded spin networks (LQG) and on an abstract algebraic graph with no topology (AQG). - Amino acid
Three proposed sources (discharge, vents, meteorites) give the same ranking of the early ten; one outcome, different builds. - Asymptotic safety in quantum gravity (walked as a projected model)
Two-dimensional Planck-scale spacetime reached by the RG flow (QEG) and by lattice triangulations (CDT). - Atmosphere of Earth
Screening short UV from the ground, done by CO2, water vapour and nitrogen in the Archean air (UV still reached the troposphere) and by dioxygen and ozone since oxygenation. - Atom
Binding parts into a whole is done twice inside one atom with different builds: electrons held in an electrostatic well (13.6 eV for hydrogen), nucleons held by the residual strong force (2.23 million eV to split deuterium). - Bianchi identities
Local conservation of energy-momentum, built two ways: in curved spacetime by the Bianchi identity through the field equations ('This conservation law is a physical requirement. With his field equations Einstein ensured that general relativity is consistent with this conservation condition'); in fla - Black hole cosmology (Schwarzschild cosmology; walked as a projected model)
Collapse halted by a pressure that wakes up at a limit density: degeneracy pressure in compact stars, torsion spin-spin repulsion inside a parent black hole, quantum-geometry repulsion in LQC. - Bonnor-Steadman solutions
Closed timelike curves made by very different sources: a rotating dust universe (Goedel), an infinite rotating cylinder (Van Stockum), and here a charge and a magnet or two spinning balls; in each the rotation of the metric tilts a cyclic coordinate timelike. - Born coordinates frame (Langevin observers)
Distance on the disk is defined by radar in the small, radar in the large, or co-moving inertial rulers; they agree only for nearby observers ('statements referring to the geometry of a rotating disk always require careful qualification'). - Bouncing no-boundary history (classical history of the no-boundary state that bounces; hypothetical)
One job (turn contraction into expansion at a finite radius) built by a classical scalar field and Lambda violating the strong energy condition here, by quantum-geometry repulsion in loop quantum cosmology. - BTZ black hole
Keeping time loops out of reach, done here by a curvature wall from matter at r = 0 and by the horizon r+, and elsewhere by the inner horizon (Kerr) or by quantum back-reaction (the conjecture). - Canonical (ADM) variables: three-metric and conjugate momentum
One field, several ways to evolve it on slices: the original ADM equations ('rarely used in numerical simulations'), 3+1 decompositions close to them, and Pretorius's 'generalization of harmonic coordinates' that made the 2005 binary run. - Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model)
One dynamics of loop quantum gravity built two ways: the canonical Hamiltonian/master constraint acting on spin networks, and the covariant sum over spin foams; the extended master constraint maps one onto the other. - Carbon bonding (tetravalence and catenation)
Covalence recurs one scale down: 'An analogous effect to covalent binding is believed to occur in some nuclear systems, with the difference that the shared fermions are quarks rather than electrons ... quark interchange ... is the dominant process of the nuclear force at short distance.' - Carter constant
One role, a conserved label for free motion, built two ways: from Killing vectors (energy, axial angular momentum) and from a Killing tensor (Carter's constant), 'Unlike Killing vectors' a symmetry not of the spacetime itself. - Cauchy development (domain of dependence)
One job (the edge of what data on S determine), two builds: the Cauchy horizon inside a charged or rotating hole, and the boundary of the chronology-violating set ('The boundary of the causality violating set is a Cauchy horizon'). - Causal arrow of time
One role (time's direction) built two ways in the sources: a geometric choice of the future half of each light cone, and correlations that grow with entropy. - Causal diamond
Volume as a curvature gauge, two builds: the Riemannian 4-ball 'V(r) = pi^2/2 r^4 (1 - R r^2/36 + ...)' reads only the Ricci scalar; the causal diamond's volume is 'directional' and reads the whole Ricci tensor. - Causal dynamical triangulation (CDT; walked as a projected model)
Two-dimensional spacetime near the Planck scale found by two different builds: lattice triangulations (CDT) and the renormalization-group flow of quantum Einstein gravity. - Causal link (nearest-neighbour relation in a causal set)
Proper time built as a continuum curve length, or as a count of links along the longest chain. - Causal path (parametrised future-directed non-spacelike curve)
The causal order built two ways: from paths with timelike or null tangents, or taken as primitive in a causal space with no differential structure. - Causal set (causet; hypothetical discrete spacetime)
The role 'spacetime' built as a smooth Lorentzian manifold or as a discrete partial order plus a count ('Order + Number = Geometry'). - Causal set element (hypothetical discrete event)
'A point of spacetime' built as a zero-extent manifold point or as an indivisible element of a discrete order whose count gives volume. - Causal set grown by classical sequential growth
A causal set made against a background (sprinkling) or grown with no background (CSG); comparisons of sub-causal-set abundances show convergence. - Causal set theory (causal sets programme; walked as a projected model)
Discrete causal structure for quantum gravity built two ways: general causal sets (more freedom in the action) and causal dynamical triangulations (a specific lattice and an explicit Lagrangian). - Causal space (Kronheimer and Penrose 1967)
The causal-structure role built three ways: a causal space (two relations on any set), a Lorentzian manifold's light cones, a causal set's locally finite order. - Causal spacetime
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): no causal loop, irreflexive <. - Causally continuous spacetime
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): distinguishing + reflecting, distinguishing + continuous volume functions, volume functions that are time functions. - Causally easy spacetime
One condition reached by three different builds: no lightlike lines (Th. 4.106), future distinction plus future reflectivity (Prop. 4.107), causal continuity (Th. 4.110). - Causally simple spacetime
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): closed J+-(p), closed J+-(K) for compact K. - Chameleon dark energy (chameleon field; hypothesised)
Screening: chameleon and symmetron are two builds that 'dynamically suppress deviations from general relativity in the solar system' by different self-interactions. - Child development
Attachment security is reached by different builds across cultures (52% avoidant in a North German sample); false-belief understanding shows universality without uniformity across Namibian and German communities: one job, different routes and rates. - Chirality
One job, breaking the mirror, proposed through many builds: circularly polarised light, quartz crystals, Earth's rotation, beta-radiolysis, the magnetochiral effect, the electroweak interaction, spin-polarised magnetite (CISS). - Chlorine atom
The spike's depolarisation is carried by sodium entry in animals but 'by release of negative chloride ions' in plant cells: one job, a different ion and channel. - Christoffel symbols
One set of chart terms plays two roles: in general relativity 'the gravitational force field', in mechanics in curvilinear coordinates the 'fictitious forces like the Centrifugal force and Coriolis force'; in Cartesian inertial coordinates they vanish. - Chronological spacetime
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): no timelike loop, irreflexive <<, d(p,p) < infinity. - Chronology protection conjecture
Keeping time loops out of reach is done by different structures: quantum back-reaction at a chronology horizon (conjectured), a horizon that hides them (Kerr; BTZ), and a classical curvature wall from matter (BTZ). - Circular orbit
One role, a bound free path held at fixed radius, built three ways: the Newtonian circle (any radius), the Schwarzschild stable circle (r_outer > 3 r_s), and the Kerr equatorial circle at Q = 0. - City
Delivering resources to every unit through a space-filling network: vascular systems in organisms (metabolic rate as M to the 3/4) and road, cable and fuel networks in cities (beta about 0.8), both showing economies of scale. - Classical Hamiltonian constraint
One constraint written in different variables: metric variables (non-polynomial), Ashtekar's SU(2) connection and densitized triad (polynomial after rescaling, but complex), real Barbero-Immirzi variables. - Classical mechanics (Newtonian mechanics: bodies, forces and motion, and the practice of describing them)
Predicting where a body will be is done by an internal model of gravity in the brain (downward motion judged shorter), by printed ephemerides fitted to ranging data, and by computers stepping Newton's laws; three unrelated builds of one job. - Closed string (projected model)
The graviton role built two ways: elementary quantum of the metric field (QFT reading) vs a vibration of a closed loop (string reading). - Comoving distance
One job (how far is it?) built as comoving, proper and light-travel distance, which agree only for nearby objects. - Comoving frame (comoving observer)
One role, the frame in which a body is at rest, built three ways: an instantaneous inertial rest frame, an accelerated proper frame with Fermi-Walker gyroscopes, and the cosmic Hubble-flow frame. - Competition for carbon nuclei (oxygen vs nitrogen)
Each channel has a slow door that keeps carbon from being used up: the proton channel queues at nitrogen-14 ('the limiting (slowest) reaction'), the alpha channel is slowed because an oxygen-16 excited state sits just off resonance ('if it were slightly higher it would speed the reaction and almost - Competition for dissolved calcium (carbonate against apatite)
The job: a carbonate mineral takes a divalent cation out of the brine so phosphate is not bound by it. Calcium carbonate does it for Ca2+ against apatite; siderite (FeCO3) does it for Fe2+ against vivianite, 'similar to solubility relations in the CaCO3–apatite system'; and unlike calcite, siderite - Competition for free electrons at recombination (hydrogen vs helium)
Two takers, one job: helium (two electrons, two steps at z ~ 6000 and z ~ 2000) and hydrogen (one electron, through n = 2) both capture free electrons; 'The ionization energy of helium is larger than that of hydrogen and it therefore recombines earlier'. - Competition for ionising photons (hydrogen vs helium)
Two takers, one role: hydrogen (one electron, 13.6 eV) and helium (two electrons, 24.587 and 54.418 eV) both take ionising photons and are unbound by them; the thresholds sort the pool (13.6-24.6 eV is hydrogen's alone). 'the primordial helium also experienced a similar reionization phase change, bu - Competition over the ensemble of universes: black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation (projected contest)
Two builds for adding universes to the ensemble: black-hole bounces (gravitational field) and bubble nucleation (inflaton field). - Competition: attraction against quantum-geometry repulsion in the Planck regime (projected contest)
Self-gravity against a pressure that halts collapse: in a degenerate core the pressure loses past the Chandrasekhar limit (sys:competition-degenerate-core-support), in the Planck regime the quantum-geometry pressure wins. - Complex network (scale-free growth, preferential attachment, small worlds; walked as an idea)
Preferential attachment done by different means: actors cast with established stars, webmasters linking popular pages, authors citing well-known papers, metabolism growing in evolution, and the causal graph of an accelerating universe. - Conformal boundary (conformal infinity)
Ideal points at infinity built two ways: by conformal rescaling (this walk) and by indecomposable past and future sets (the causal boundary); 'the accessible part of a well-behaved conformal boundary agrees with the causal boundary'. - Conformal Killing vector field
Conserved-along-light structures come in several builds: a conformal Killing field's flow, the metric's own Killing fields (lambda = 0), and conformal Killing tensors (constants along null geodesics). - Consciousness
Conscious experience in mammals (layered cortex) and birds (a differently built pallium): the declaration finds strong support in both; the encyclopedia reports bird structures as homologous counterparts. One role, two builds; whether they are independent is open (C-2816). - Consistent discretizations (discrete space-time approach to quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
Singularity avoidance built two ways: lattice points that miss the singularity (consistent discretizations) and a quantum-geometry repulsion with a bounce (loop quantum cosmology); 'quite distinct' mechanisms. - Consumer
Paying a rising price for a good and buying less as it rises: people pay in money, mice in nosepokes (hard for water, little for sweet drinks when water is free). Mice and people share a mammal brain, so the builds are not unrelated: partial. - Continent
The job 'raise crust above the sea' done two ways in the sources: magmatic thickening in plateau-like, non-plate settings (Singhbhum, 3.3-3.2 Ga) and collisional orogenesis at plate margins (the broad consensus, ~2.5 Ga). - Cortical folding (gyrification: the cerebral cortex folds into gyri and sulci)
One job, more basal progenitors and so more surface, reached by different molecular builds: lower Trnp1, the hominid gene ARHGAP11B, FGF or SHH signalling, Cdk4 with cyclin D1 - Cosmic antipode
Magnification by geometry (the antipode makes nearby objects look very large and bright) and by mass (gravitational lensing: multiple images, Einstein rings). - Cosmic censorship hypothesis
The same refusal (no overcharging) is done by the potential barrier at test order and by second-order self-force effects for near-extremal holes. - Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
'Dark energy is broadly similar to inflation and is thought to be causing the expansion of the present-day universe to accelerate. However, the energy scale of dark energy is much lower, 10^-12 GeV, roughly 27 orders of magnitude less than the scale of inflation.' One job (vacuum energy with negativ - Cosmological arrow of time
One role (time's direction) built by expansion on the metric and by entropy in matter; the source says the second 'ultimately results from the cosmological set-up'. - Cosmological comoving observer (Hubble-flow frame)
The rest frame is found two ways: by the CMB dipole and by matter (quasar counts); the quasar dipole is 'significantly different', so the two builds do not yet agree. - Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy)
Dark energy's one role (negative pressure that accelerates the expansion) has a static build, the cosmological constant ('in most respects the simplest solution'), and dynamical ones (quintessence and its kin); DESI's 2.8 to 4.2 sigma preference for evolving w is the test between them. - Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical)
The selecting step built from black holes: fitness is the number of black holes, where biology counts offspring and clonal selection counts antigen binding. - Cosmological proper distance
A distance built at one time (proper), fixed for all time (comoving), or along the light's journey (light-travel): one job, three builds that agree only nearby. - Coulomb branch (N = 2 vector-multiplet moduli space; projected model)
Confinement of charge built two ways: by monopole condensation on the perturbed Coulomb branch (Seiberg-Witten) and by colour flux tubes in QCD. - Crystallization (nucleation and crystal growth)
Starting a crystal is done by different structures: dust and organic particles for snow (c84), scratches and impurities in glassware (c50, c31), a seed of the same salt (c60), an organism's organic matrix (c119). - Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
The four core criteria of cumulative culture are met by homing pigeons (route chains) and zebra finch song as well as by humans, with very different machinery; non-human cases reach 'a single trait up to a single, fixed optimum'. - Dance
Moving the body in time with a heard beat is done by humans and by two vocal-mimicking parrots, with unrelated nervous systems; only vocal mimics showed it in a global video database. - Dark matter
One role (the unseen mass that obeys rho ~ a^-3) with several candidate builds: weak-scale particles (freeze-out), light bosons (axions), primordial black holes; baryonic MACHOs tried and mostly excluded. - Dark matter constituent (unidentified; hypothesised WIMP or axion)
One role (the matter behind dark matter's gravity), several builds: particle-like WIMPs (weak-scale, thermal freeze-out), wave-like axions (ultralight field, misalignment), and primordial black holes with no new particle. - Dark matter-baryon partnership (structure formation)
One job, regulating star formation in the well, done by two builds: stellar feedback ('a feedback loop that regulates the process of star formation') and AGN feedback (radio-mode jets with 'X-ray bubbles that possess enough energy to counterbalance cooling losses'). - Decoherence
A one-way direction of time built by decoherence ('the dynamics of the system alone are irreversible') beside the thermodynamic, radiative and cosmological builds of the arrow-of-time walk. - DGP gravity (Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati braneworld; walked as a projected model)
Late-time acceleration built from leakage into an extra dimension (DGP), from a geometric term (f(R)) or from a component (dark energy). - Direct plunge orbit (capture with low angular momentum)
No return reached with no balance at all: capture with only one real root, beside the spiral-down from the inner radius and disc gas leaving the ISCO (the parent's three ways). - Distinguishing spacetime
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): injective I+-, small neighbourhoods causal curves do not re-enter. - Doplicher-Fredenhagen-Roberts quantum spacetime
Keeping events from being located below the Planck length: here a noncommutative algebra whose relations 'exactly implement' uncertainty bounds; in spacetime foam, strong fluctuating geometry ('Our proposal differs radically'). - Dynamical Casimir effect
Turning the vacuum's fluctuations into real quanta: done here by a moving boundary, at a black hole by a horizon. The receding mirror's thermal spectrum is the bridge: 'Thus we establish the connection between the dynamical Casimir effect and Hawking radiation.' Shared job in plain words: real parti - Earth in the Cenozoic era
Isolated faunas filled the same roles with different lineages: eutherians in the north, metatherians in the south; South America's 'dog-like marsupial relatives called borhyaenids' and 'vaguely elephant-like pyrotheres'; the GAI page pairs thylacosmilids with saber-toothed cats and borhyaenids with - Einstein field equations
'Analogously to the way that electromagnetic fields are related to the distribution of charges and currents via Maxwell's equations, the EFE relate the spacetime geometry to the distribution of mass-energy, momentum and stress'; one is linear, the other nonlinear. - Einstein manifold
One curvature condition built in Riemannian geometry (instantons, Calabi-Yau) and in Lorentzian geometry (vacuum spacetimes). - Eleven-dimensional spacetime (M-theory, supergravity)
The stage fixed by a consistency condition at 26, 10 and 11 dimensions; here from above (the supersymmetry ceiling). - Emotional contagion
Contagious yawning "may have evolved several times in different lineages": in budgerigars it does not seem related to social closeness, unlike primates and wolves; and in fish the alarm spreads by smell (Schreckstoff) or by seen distress (oxytocin). - End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released
Oxygen transport by different molecules decided survival: 'organisms that relied on haemocyanin or haemoglobin for transporting oxygen were more resistant to extinction than those utilizing hemerythrin or oxygen diffusion'. Two different builds of the same role both came through; the other builds of - Energy
Detecting radiation is done two unrelated ways: 'an infrared receptor could detect photons directly, similar to photochemical activation of opsins in the eye, or indirectly through heating of tissue within the pit, leading to activation of a thermoreceptor'. The snake uses the second; the eye the fi - Engineering (design)
Quiet flight through air is done by feathers (owl serrations, velvet, fringes) and by serrated metal or composite blade edges on airfoils and wind turbines; the shared job is cutting edge noise in a flow, built from unrelated materials; the gains do not carry over one-to-one ('do not translate linea - Epistemology (the theory of knowledge: the study and the knowing it studies)
One job, knowing how well one will perform (prospective metacognition), done by the human anterior lateral prefrontal cortex and by distributed macaque areas 45a and 47/12o; one job, group accuracy, reached by independence (Galton's crowd) or by network learning (decentralized influence). Homologous - Ernst vacuum
Schwarzschild, a spherical geometry, comes from the potential of a rod: the Newtonian source and the physical source need not share a shape. - Euclidean n-space (n > 3)
A perpendicular vector from others: a binary product in 3 and 7 dimensions, an (n - 1)-fold product in general. - Eukaryote
a cell wall made of different polysaccharides in different lineages (cellulose, hemicellulose and pectin in land plants; LECA's cyst of chitin and/or cellulose); the job is a support layer outside the membrane that stops over-expansion - Exponential map (Riemannian geometry)
Two maps turn tangent vectors into points: the Riemannian exponential (via geodesics) and the Lie-group exponential (via one-parameter subgroups); they coincide for a bi-invariant metric, and R+ gives the 'honest' e^x. - Exterior field of a compact star
Mass read from the exterior two ways: Shapiro delay in radio timing (PSR J1614-2230) and relativistic ray-tracing of X-ray hot spots (NICER, PSR J0030+0451). - Exterior field of a neutron star
Weighing a neutron star through its exterior: X-ray ray-tracing here (NICER), Shapiro delay of radio pulses on the compact-star walk (PSR J1614-2230). - Exterior field of a white dwarf
Weighing a white dwarf through its exterior: redshift of its own light, deflection of background starlight, delay of a companion pulsar's pulses. - Extrinsic curvature (second fundamental form)
How a piece sits in a larger space is split into two builds: the induced metric (intrinsic, 'independent of the way the manifold is embedded') and the extrinsic curvature (depends on the embedding); the Gauss relation joins them, 'a generalization of Gauss' Theorema Egregium'. - f(R) gravity (modified gravity; walked as a projected model)
Cosmic acceleration built from geometry (the effective density of f(R)) or from a component (dark energy, quintom fields): one role, different builds. - Fermi-Walker transport
'No rotation' is kept by a rule (D_F X/ds = 0), by three gyroscopes, or (in free fall) by parallel transport checked against a guide star. - Finite noncommutative space F
Breaking the symmetry: in GUTs 'the Higgs fields are then added by hand to break the GUT symmetry'; here 'the symmetry is broken by a specific choice of the finite geometry', as a spacetime geometry breaks general covariance. - Finsler manifold
One role, measuring the length of curves, built three ways on a smooth manifold: an inner product per tangent space (Riemannian), a norm per tangent space (Finsler: 'length, but not angle'), a metric on admissible directions only (sub-Riemannian). - Flat metric (zero curvature)
One role (the zero-curvature reference form) built in two signatures: the Euclidean dot product and the Minkowski metric. - Fluid solution (of the Einstein field equation)
One fluid form serves a star's interior and a whole universe's eras. - Foliation (of spacetime by spacelike hypersurfaces)
The same spacetime sliced by different lapse choices: geodesic slicing (N = 1, observers squeeze), maximal slicing (K = 0, singularity avoidance), harmonic and 1+log slicing ('mimic maximal slicing'). - Fossil fuel
The job 'hold buried hydrocarbons until someone opens them' is done by unrelated builds: a sealed trap above a porous reservoir in conventional fields; the source rock itself, whose kerogen hosts much of the porosity, in shale; ice-like crystals in methane clathrates; the coal seam itself. - Four-force
The time component of the force is built two ways: the mechanical power f.u, or in thermo-mechanical cases power plus a heating rate h ('work and heat cannot be meaningfully separated, though, as they both carry inertia'). - Frame dragging
'The gravitational analog of electromagnetic induction': a mass current makes a gravitomagnetic field as a charge current makes a magnetic field. - Frame field (tetrad, vierbein)
One curvature, three readings: static, Lemaitre and Hagihara observer families each build a different tidal tensor from the same Schwarzschild geometry ('a different tensor ... because it is defined using a different family of observers'). - Frame of reference
One job, describing motion, done by a frame (state of motion, physical) and by a coordinate system (language, mathematical); the source insists they are distinct ('frames correspond at best to classes of coordinate systems'). - Future Cauchy development D+(S)
One job (where data on S stop fixing the future) done by different edges: the Cauchy horizon generated by lightlike geodesics, and, in Hawking's proof, a lightlike line inside the development on which an imprisoned curve accumulates. - Future reflecting spacetime
One condition built several ways: set inclusions (iv), up-sets (v), outer continuity of p -> I+(p) (vi), continuity of the volume function (vii), the K relation (viii). - Future-distinguishing spacetime
One condition built four ways (injective set map; neighbourhoods causal curves do not re-enter; local causal relation agreeing with the global one; a volume function that is a generalized time function). - Galactic magnetic field
One role (seeding the field), many builds: primordial fields, the Weibel instability, protogalactic plasma fluctuations, first stars, first black holes, the Biermann mechanism in the first supernova remnants, and the first cosmic rays' current. - Galaxy cluster
The core thermostat (heating holds cooling to within about ten per cent) does the star's core-thermostat job with jets and hot gas; booked by the quasar walk, sighted again here from the cluster's floors. - Generalized Minkowski spacetime (any number of dimensions)
The role 'stage' built at different dimension counts in different theories: 1 + 1 (string worldsheet), 4 (observed), 5 (Kaluza-Klein), 10 (superstring), 11 (M-theory), 26 (bosonic string). - Globally hyperbolic spacetime
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): compact diamonds, a Cauchy surface, an orthogonal splitting, compact spaces of causal curves. - Gluon jets (gluon-rich environments)
The jet role built by two seeds: a gluon jet carries (asymptotically) 9/4 the multiplicity of a quark jet, is broader and fragments softer, yet 'hadronizes much as a quark does'. - Gorkavyi's oscillating universe (black holes and gravitational waves; no dark matter, no dark energy)
The cosmic acceleration explained by a varying gravitational mass here, by dark energy in the standard model ('no dark matter and no dark energy'). - Graviton (hypothetical quantum of gravity)
One role, carrying a force between charges, built as different quanta: the photon (spin 1, sourced by the four-current), gluons, W and Z, and the graviton (spin 2, sourced by the stress-energy tensor). 'The three other known forces of nature are mediated by elementary particles.' - Gromov hyperbolic space
One large-scale shape built from smooth curvature (hyperbolic space, 2-hyperbolic), from branching (trees, 0-hyperbolic), from groups (Cayley graphs of surface groups) and from human networks (effective hyperbolic geometry of the Internet). - Hagihara observers (frame of stable circular orbits)
One geometry, two readings at one radius: the hovering static frame and the orbiting Hagihara frame build different tidal tensors ('slightly larger' radial tides, anisotropic transverse tides). - Hard partons / jets
Just as accelerated electric charges emit QED radiation (photons), accelerated coloured partons emit QCD radiation (gluons); unlike the uncharged photons, gluons carry colour and radiate further, so the one role builds a shower. - Hawking-Ellis type III stress-energy
Two eigenvector structures give the same outcome: III0 (nilpotent, one null eigenvector) and IV0 (complex eigenvalues, no null eigenvector) both have an 'always spacelike' flux read as tachyonic matter and fail every standard condition. - Hawking-Ellis type IV stress-energy
Two different eigenvector structures give the same outcome: the cores III0 and IV0 both have an 'always spacelike' flux, read as 'tachyonic matter', and both violate every standard condition. - Holonomy (parallel transport round closed loops; its trace is the Wilson loop)
One holonomy, three jobs: sorting Riemannian geometries (Berger), the configuration variable of loop quantum gravity, and the confinement order operator of gauge theory. - Horismos (the relation x -> y: lightlike separation)
The causal order built two ways: from causal curves on a manifold, or from the horismos alone as a reflexive relation whose transitive extension is the causal relation (Stoica 2016). - Human society (from local community up to societies)
One job, reaching a group decision, is done by different integration rules: some societies follow an established leader, others build consensus; voting systems vary. - Human voice
Telling others how you feel is done by face, voice and gesture: 'Humans use a range of different cues to communicate to others how they feel, including facial, vocal, and gestural signals'; the voice's own build differs by emotion: negative emotions cross cultures, most positive ones do not - Hyperbolic 3-space
One geometry, three physical builds: the velocity hyperboloid of our spacetime, the spatial slice of a negatively curved universe, and the constant-time slices of AdS4 in Poincare coordinates. - Hyperbolic plane
One geometry, several builds: planar velocities in Minkowski space, the spatial slices of AdS3, finite pseudospherical patches in Euclidean space, and human builds (crochet, paper, superconducting resonator lattices). - Hyperbolic space
One geometry, two physical builds: the unit hyperboloid of four-velocities inside Minkowski spacetime and the spatial slice of a negatively curved universe; plus several isometric mathematical models (half-space, disc, hyperboloid, Beltrami-Klein) 'each suited to different aspects of its study'. - Hyperbolic trajectory
One role, escape, built three ways: the hyperbola (excess speed), the parabola (minimum-energy escape) and the radial hyperbolic line (straight out, speed always above escape). - Hyperspherical space (n-sphere)
One sphere, several jobs: the slice of a closed universe, the spatial section of de Sitter, the angular directions of AdS, and the hidden compact dimensions of AdS x S. - Induced metric
The sheet's geometry is carried two ways that agree: the induced metric (Nambu-Goto) and an independent metric fixed by its equation of motion (Polyakov, g = 2f gamma). - Inertial observer (inertial frame of reference)
One role, an inertial frame, built three ways: Newton's frame at rest in absolute space (fixed stars), Lange's operational frame of three rectilinear throws (1885), and the free-fall lift of general relativity. - Infinite-dimensional Riemannian manifold
Physical laws of motion as geodesics of one construction: incompressible Euler, KdV (Virasoro-Bott), Camassa-Holm, Hunter-Saxton, and geometrodynamics on superspace. - Inflaton field
'Dark energy is broadly similar to inflation ... However, the energy scale of dark energy is much lower, 10^-12 GeV, roughly 27 orders of magnitude less than the scale of inflation.' A rolling scalar driving acceleration is also the quintessence build. - Initially singular no-boundary history (classical history of the no-boundary state that starts at a singularity; hypothetical)
The start of a classical history built two ways in one ensemble: a singularity here, a bounce in the sibling history; the state's predictions do not depend on which. - Instantaneous (momentarily comoving) rest frame
One job, carrying axes along an accelerated path, done two ways: 'comoving orthonormal tetrads, which can be formulated in terms of spacetime Frenet-Serret formulas, or alternatively using Fermi-Walker transport as a standard of non-rotation'. - Interacting dark energy (coupled dark sector; hypothesised)
The coupled dark sector is one of several builds that let w cross -1 ('Matter-dark energy interactions, e.g. interacting dark sector' in the quintom list) and of several answers to the coincidence problem. - Intergalactic medium
One job, ionising the gas, done by differently built sources: dwarf galaxies (primary), Population III stars, and quasars (subdominant, 'do not exist in high enough numbers to reionize the IGM alone'). - Internet
Carrying on while parts fail: 'local failures rarely lead to the loss of the global information-carrying ability of the network', named in the same sentence as organisms' metabolic networks. In the Internet the job is done by rerouting around losses and by fate-sharing at the ends. - Internet protocol suite (TCP/IP): the layered datagram protocols every host and router runs, the RFC record that specifies them, and the community that keeps them
The genetic-code parallel. One role, a fixed shared interface frozen at the middle of a layered system, is met by two builds: IP at the 'narrow waist' between 'many heterogeneous lower-layer technologies and many diverse higher-layer applications' (src:wp:hourglass-model), and the codon table. Both - ISCO of a spinning test particle
Two different spins (the hole's a, the body's s) move the same edge, with slopes 4 sqrt(2/3) and 2 sqrt(2/3). - Japanese macaque (Macaca fuscata)
One job, keeping the body warm in winter, done by long fur and a large body, by pressing bodies into huddles (to over 100 at Shodoshima), and by sitting in geothermal water at Jigokudani - Japanese tit (Parus minor)
The job 'get the young out of the cavity before the snake comes in' is done by the Japanese tit's 'L' (jar) syllable and the varied tit's 'f' syllable: different syllables, statistically distinct, overlapping enough that each species' nestlings fledge to the other's call - k-essence (kinetic quintessence; hypothesised)
A third build for dark energy's role, beside the constant and canonical quintessence: here the kinetic energy, not the potential, makes the negative pressure. - Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle)
Hiding the extra dimension: Klein's compactification (small circle), projective theories (extra coordinates not real) and noncompactified theories (matter induced from the fifth coordinate) each give up a different one of Kaluza's three features. - Kerr-Newman spacetime
g = 2 twice over: the Kerr-Newman hole's gyromagnetic ratio is 'the same as that of an electron', from a classical geometry; the electron gets it from the Dirac equation. - Labelled 2-complex (the cell structure a spin foam lives on)
One carrier job, three builds: the dual 2-skeleton of a triangulation (BF, EPRL), arbitrary linear 2-cell complexes (KKL), branched coloured surfaces (Reisenberger-Rovelli). - Laboratory dynamo (liquid-sodium dynamo experiments)
Lowering the threshold is done by different things: a concentric back-flow that 'converts the convective instability into an absolute one', an outer layer of sodium at rest, an annulus sharpening the shear layer, and high-permeability iron disks. - Laboratory frame
One calculation, two frames: 'any frame (including the COM frame) may be used to calculate the momenta of the particles'; the lab frame measures, the COM frame simplifies. - Lambda-CDM model
One parameter, H0, read by two routes that disagree: the CMB through the model (67.4 km/s/Mpc) and stellar distances (the late universe): 'many different kinds of observations agree with one of these two values'. - Larmor precession
'The phenomenon is conceptually similar to the precession of a tilted classical gyroscope in an external torque-exerting gravitational field': one precession, a magnetic torque here and a gravitational torque there. - Lemaitre observers (radially infalling free-fall frame)
Hovering and falling observers build different tidal tensors from one curvature ('a different tensor ... defined using a different family of observers') that happen to share components in the Schwarzschild vacuum. - Lense-Thirring precession
Two builds tilt the PSR J1141-6545 orbit: the white dwarf's Newtonian quadrupole and its Lense-Thirring drag ('LT precession is required for any orbital orientation'). - Lepton (the class of six)
The muon "did not have the expected properties of a meson, but rather behaved like an electron, only with higher mass": the same slot built at three masses; exotic atoms put a muon or tau where an electron would be. - Light cone (null cone)
The one role 'boundary of what an event can reach' is built two ways: in flat spacetime the cone is exactly the boundary of the causal future; in curved spacetime lensing folds part of the cone strictly inside, so the cone only 'includes' the boundary. - Light-travel distance
One question (how far is it?) built as light-travel, comoving and proper distance, which agree only at low redshift ('all the distances are asymptotic to z . d_H for small z'). - Lightlike (null) separation
The causal relation is built from the null link: 'The causal relation is the smallest transitive extension of the horismos relation', so chains of light-speed links build every causal relation. - Lightlike ray (future or past)
Light generates causal boundaries three ways: past rays make Cauchy horizons, future rays leave every edge point, lines make achronal sets with edges. - Linearized Einstein field equations
Waves in both fields come from linear equations: 'Maxwell's equations of electromagnetism are linear' and give light; the linearized EFE give gravitational waves at the same speed c, generated 'by a changing quadrupole moment'. - Literature
Keeping diversity stable against loss: even, insular assemblages hold up, in island literatures and in island ecosystems alike (Kestemont et al. link the two). - LLM-based agent
One job, bringing stored text back into a limited context, done by different builds: embedding relevance + recency + importance (Generative Agents), paginated function calls (MemGPT), progressive disclosure (skills). - Local inertial (free-fall) frame
Gravity and acceleration build the same local reading: 'no experiment observers can perform to distinguish whether an acceleration arises because of a gravitational force or because their reference frame is accelerating'. - Loop quantum cosmology (LQC; walked as a projected model)
A collapse halted by a pressure that is negligible until a limit density, then rises steeply: degeneracy pressure in white dwarfs and neutron stars, quantum-geometry repulsion at the Planck density in LQC (and the Planck star inside black holes). - Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model)
Black-hole entropy S = A/4 is built from horizon punctures by spin-network edges in LQG, and from D-brane counting in string theory (Strominger and Vafa 1996). - Lorentz frame (inertial frame of special relativity)
Two builds of the inertial frame: 'related by Lorentz transformations' in special relativity and 'related by Galilean transformations' in Newtonian mechanics; 'these approximately match when the relative speed of the frames is low'. - Lorentzian wormhole
One handle shape built three ways: vacuum (Einstein-Rosen), exotic-matter (Morris-Thorne), evolving with ordinary matter (Kar-Sahdev). - Magnetar magnetosphere
Plain job: carrying energy out of the twist. Done by surface bombardment (hot spot), resonant upscattering (hard tail), radio from the j-bundle, and in flares by a relativistic outflow and an evaporating fireball. - Magnetically charged Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
Electric charge and magnetic charge give the same Reissner-Nordstrom geometry (only Q^2 + P^2 enters the metric). - Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet)
The continuum's volume built as an integral of the metric, or as a count of elements. - Marginally past-trapped surface
One job, marking a cosmological horizon, by different builds: the apparent horizon (quasi-local, 'always exists'), the Hubble sphere, and the particle and event horizons ('they do not exist in all FLRW spaces'). - Maximizing null curve (maximizing lightlike geodesic)
Maximizing is one role with two builds: the timelike maximizer depends on the metric (longest proper time) while the null one is 'a pure conformal' notion (no timelike shortcut at all). - Mean curvature vector
A curvature-zero condition picks out the extremal object: H = 0 for minimal surfaces in space and spacetime, K = 0 for maximal slices, H = 0 at the soap film with no pressure difference (Young-Laplace). - Meson
One job, carrying the nuclear force, done by different builds: the pseudoscalar pion and the vector rho and omega mesons; 'the vector mesons account for the spin-dependence of the nuclear force in this virtual meson picture'. - Metric connection
Keeping inner products under transport is done on the tangent bundle by the Riemannian connections (gravity) and on gauge bundles by Yang-Mills connections; the same condition, two builds. - Metric space
One role (distance) built many ways on one set: the plane carries Euclidean, taxicab, Chebyshev and discrete metrics; the Earth's surface carries great-circle and through-the-interior metrics; strings carry the Hamming distance. - Metric tensor
Free motion obtained two ways from the metric: by varying length or by varying energy; 'the geodesic equations may be obtained by applying variational principles to either the length or the energy'. - Metric tree (real tree, R-tree; walked as an idea)
The job of showing a hierarchy as branching distance is done by different builds: a subdominant ultrametric of stock correlations (finance), hyperbolic coordinates under a network (Internet), embeddings in the Poincare ball (machine learning), an edge-weighted tree of species (phylogeny). - Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time)
One job in plain words: bringing scarce elements together until they are concentrated enough to form a mineral of their own ('This left little or no chance for them to come together and form minerals until external influences concentrated them'). Done by melting cycles in granitoids and pegmatites ( - Minimal surface
The least-area surface on a frame is built by a soap film's surface tension (rung 5) and by the geometry alone in a black-hole slice (rung 1): one variational role, two builds. - Motivation
The job of telling a foraging animal 'this is food, learn to seek it' is done by dopamine in nematodes, molluscs and vertebrates and mostly by octopamine in insects and crustaceans, where dopamine serves aversive learning instead. - Multiverse (the hypothetical ensemble of universes; walked as a projected model)
New universes by three different builds: bubble nucleation in inflating space (Level II), black-hole bounces (fecund universes, black-hole cosmology), branching of the wave function (Level III). - Music
Moving in time with a musical beat is done by humans and by a sulphur-crested cockatoo, a vocal learner, on the hypothesis that beat entrainment rides on vocal-learning circuitry. - Naked singularity
One outcome (an exposed singularity) by too much charge, too much spin, aimed dust, scalar-field collapse, or a pinching black string. - Neocortex (six-layered isocortex)
Receiving thalamic input: layer IV in most mammals, inner layer III in elephants, cetaceans and hippopotamus, which 'do not have a layer IV'; in birds, nuclear pallial masses with no layers. - New ekpyrotic cosmology (non-singular ekpyrotic bounce; hypothetical)
The bounce is built by a ghost condensate here, by brane collision in the original ekpyrotic and cyclic models, by quantum geometry in loop quantum cosmology, by torsion in Einstein-Cartan. - Newton's law of universal gravitation
One job, two builds: the attraction between masses as a force (Newton) and as geodesic motion in curved spacetime, where 'the gravitational force is a fictitious force resulting from the curvature of spacetime'; the two agree where phi/c^2 and (v/c)^2 are small. - No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical)
The same job (an origin with no initial singularity in the way of prediction) built differently: no-boundary geometry here, an Einstein static start in the Emergent Universe, a bounce in bouncing models. - Non-totally vicious spacetime
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): d(p,q) = infinity, I+(p) = I-(p) = M, p << p (for its complement). - Noncommutative geometry (as a projected model of spacetime and quantum gravity)
One role, metric distance, built two ways: from a positive-definite metric tensor (Riemannian) or from a Dirac operator (Connes' distance formula). - Nonspinning frame (Fermi-Walker)
Non-rotation is held by Fermi-Walker transport in the geometry and realised by a system of three gyroscopes (angular momentum) or by a ring interferometer (invariance of light speed). - Nonspinning inertial (NSI) frame
The non-rotating standard: GP-B's gyroscopes (conservation of angular momentum) versus ring interferometers (invariance of light speed); both read rotation relative to a nonrotating frame. - Novel
the job 'get a long story to readers who will not buy the whole book' done by different builds: cheap fascicles (to 'reduce the price and expand the market'), circulating libraries lending for a fee, magazine serials, web serials released chapter by chapter - Numeracy
Telling how many: a precise system for a few items and an approximate one for many, and in Ghana non-symbolic, elsewhere symbolic magnitude, carry the job of predicting maths. - Nutrition (food and nutrition: how bodies take in and use food)
Getting carbon and energy is done by consuming other organisms, by fixing inorganic carbon, by absorbing light, or by mixing these (heterotroph, autotroph, mixotroph) - Observer (frame of reference, physics sense)
One role, 'observer', built differently across rungs: a nonlocal lattice of synchronized clocks (special relativity), a person or machine making passive local measurements (general relativity usage), a measurement apparatus (quantum mechanics), and an experimenter reading coincidences against a refe - Ocean currents (the ocean circulation)
Carrying heat from the equator to the poles is done by both the ocean and the air: 'poleward heat transport outside the tropics is considerably larger in the atmosphere than in the ocean'. - Old English literature
Binding a line of verse with repeated sound is done by alliteration on stressed initial sounds in Old English, by consonant repetition and stress in Welsh cynghanedd (detected implicitly by untrained readers), and by rhyme elsewhere; all are linked to readers' responses (recall for alliteration, emo - Overextreme Kerr spacetime
Naked singularity by too much spin here, by too much charge in superextremal Reissner-Nordstrom, by both in Kerr-Newman. - Ozone layer (ozone shield)
One job, keeping hard ultraviolet off the ground, done by different absorbers in turn: nitrogen for 10-100 nm, dioxygen below 200 nm, ozone from about 200 to 315 nm. Firing rule: the job in plain words: stopping the light that breaks molecules before it reaches the surface. - Pallium (the dorsal telencephalon of vertebrates)
Sensory processing and cognition done by a laminated six-layer sheet in mammals and by nuclear, unlayered pallial masses in birds ('reminiscent of the mammalian cerebral cortex'); spatial memory held by the medial pallium of tetrapods and by the everted fish pallium. - Parabolic trajectory
Escape built three ways: parabola (minimum energy), hyperbola (excess speed), radial line (straight out). - Past Cauchy development D-(S)
One job (where data on S stop fixing the past) done by different edges: the Cauchy horizon generated by lightlike geodesics, and, in Hawking's proof, a lightlike line inside the development on which an imprisoned curve accumulates. - Past-distinguishing spacetime
One condition built four ways (injective set map; neighbourhoods causal curves do not re-enter; local causal relation agreeing with the global one; a volume function that is a generalized time function). - Pauli exclusion principle
Two different structures hold up a stellar remnant against gravity: electron degeneracy pressure (white dwarf) and neutron degeneracy pressure (neutron star), the same rule on two carriers at two densities. - Perfect fluid
One model, many interiors: 'A flock of birds in the medium of air is an example of a perfect fluid; an electron gas is also modeled as a perfect fluid', and the quark-gluon plasma is nearly one. - Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it)
One job, showing the periodic recurrence, done by different layouts: 18- and 32-column, left-step, spirals ('Both forms represent the same periodic table'). - Pion (pi meson)
One role, carrying the nuclear force, done by different builds: the pseudoscalar pion and two vector mesons, rho and omega; 'the vector mesons account for the spin-dependence of the nuclear force in this virtual meson picture', while pion exchange is attractive, pulling nucleons together. - Plant (kingdom Plantae)
Fast long-distance signalling: plants use glutamate and GLR channels to send a Ca2+ signal to distant organs; 'The amino acid glutamate acts as an excitatory neurotransmitter in the vertebrate central nervous system'. - Plunging orbit
One role (no return) reached three ways: capture with low angular momentum (only u1 real), spiral-down from the inner radius (u2 = u3), and disc gas crossing the ISCO. - Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies)
Measuring a regime's openness: expert coding (V-Dem), surveys, text analysis and case studies each do the job of reading how open a polity is, from different builds. - Positional (place-value) notation with zero
Position sets a part's role: a digit's value 'depends not only on its appearance but also on its position', as a Hox gene's place in its cluster sets the body region it specifies (colinearity). The numeral's parts do not read their place; the reader does. - Positive energy theorem
Two independent proofs reach one conclusion: Schoen-Yau by variational methods and minimal surfaces (by contradiction), Witten by spinors ('logically direct'). - Primate social group
Bonding by grooming another's body is done with hands, teeth or tongue in primates, beaks in birds (allopreening), licking in cattle, nibbling in horses: one role, different structures. - Primordial black hole
The unseen mass that holds galaxies together by its gravity has two main candidate builds: new particles (WIMPs, axions) or primordial black holes, compact bodies made from the early plasma with no new particle; 'There are two main candidates for non-baryonic dark matter: new particles and primordia - Prograde ISCO of a rotating hole
The inner disk edge is built at a different radius for every spin; the same edge reads out the spin. - Proper reference frame
The comoving tetrad is built either by Frenet-Serret transport (can rotate) or by Fermi-Walker transport (non-rotating); 'connected by a rotation matrix'. - Proper time (its parameter)
Proper time is read by physically different clocks that agree: caesium atomic clocks, muon decay, Doppler-shifted canal-ray light. - Protein
One job, speeding a chemical reaction, done by two builds: protein enzymes and certain RNAs ('With the exception of certain types of RNA, most other biological molecules are relatively inert elements upon which proteins act'). - Quantum field theory
Divergences handled two ways: renormalization (counterterms, Feynman-Schwinger-Dyson-Tomonaga) and Schwinger's source theory, in which 'there are no divergences, and no renormalization'. Re-walk: the muon's hadronic term now has two builds as well, data-driven dispersive and lattice QCD (WP25), whic - Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
One role, a quantum account of gravity and of black-hole entropy S = A/4, built in different ways: strings (one-dimensional objects; D-brane counting, 1996) and loop quantum gravity (quantized area and volume; horizon geometry, 2012), plus a long list of other candidates. - Quantum-geometry repulsive force (LQC; walked as a projected model)
A collapse halted by a pressure that is negligible until a limit density and then rises steeply: degeneracy pressure (Pauli exclusion) in compact stars, quantum-geometry repulsion at ~0.41 Planck density, torsion spin-spin repulsion in Einstein-Cartan bounces. - Quark
Valence and sea quarks: the same particle kind in two roles inside one hadron; valence quarks set quantum numbers, sea pairs are virtual, 'much less stable', and annihilate within the hadron. - Quark–gluon plasma
The job 'the most ideal fluid' is done by a hot liquid of quarks and gluons and, in the dual description, by black-hole horizons: 'black hole horizons are dual to the most ideal fluids'. - Quasar
An emergent thermostat: the cluster-core heating/cooling balance ('if too much gas starts to cool then the accretion rate should increase making the heating rate go up and vice versa') does the job the star's core thermostat does (less energy production compresses the core and raises the fusion rate - Quintessence field (hypothesised alternative)
Two builds for dark energy's one role: a static cosmological constant (w = -1, 'by definition, does not change') and a dynamical rolling field (w varying in [-1, 1]); DESI's preference for evolving w is the test between them. - Radial trajectory
Escape on a straight line (radial parabolic, radial hyperbolic) alongside the curved escapes (parabola, hyperbola). - Reading
Alphabetic readers decode phonemes; Chinese and Japanese readers lean on whole words or syllables; yet all literate adults use one left ventral reading site. - Relativity of simultaneity
A shared 'now' built by Einstein synchronisation in one inertial frame and by cosmic time for comoving observers in the expanding universe. - Resonance
Picking one frequency out of many: tuned LC circuits, mirror cavities, nuclear spins in a field, moons' orbits. - Rhetoric (speech and argument)
Changing another's mind with a message, done by different builds: human orators and writers; language models in debate (81.7% higher odds with personal data) and dialogue (~20% less conspiracy belief); and, contested, social animals by vocalization, display and deception (biorhetorics). - Rho meson
Carrying the nuclear force: the pseudoscalar pion pulls nucleons together, while the vector rho and omega 'account for the spin-dependence of the nuclear force'. - Ricci tensor
One job, reading the Ricci tensor, done by three structures in the sources: the volume of a thin cone of geodesics (Riemannian), the expansion of a congruence of test particles (Raychaudhuri), and the 4-volume of a causal diamond. - Ricci-flat manifold
Ricci-flatness reached through different holonomy groups: SU(n) for Calabi-Yau, Sp(n) for hyperkahler, G2 and Spin(7) (Ambrose-Singer); 'all known examples of irreducible Ricci-flat Riemannian metrics on simply-connected closed manifolds have special holonomy groups'. - Riemannian metric of constant negative curvature
The same metric built as the pullback of the flat Minkowski form onto a curved sheet, and as the spatial part of an expanding open universe. - Ring singularity
The edge of a black hole geometry built two ways: a point (Schwarzschild, spacelike) and a ring (Kerr, timelike). - Rotating frame of reference
Rotation is detected by fictitious forces (Foucault pendulum) or by light (Sagnac ring): two builds reading the same absolute rotation. - Scalar-field stress-energy (Klein-Gordon field as a source)
Accelerated expansion by a pure cosmological constant or by a scalar field with vanishing kinetic energy, 'equivalent to a cosmological constant'. - Seafloor sediment (marine sediment)
Plain job: joining the oxidised top of the sediment to its reduced depths. Animals do it by flushing burrows with overlying water ('Bioirrigation is responsible for a large amount of oxidative transport'); cable bacteria do it with electrons, 'connecting these areas of undersupplied and excess elect - Self-interacting dark matter
Flattening a halo's cusp into a core: done by baryonic feedback (a time-varying potential from gas outflows), by self-scattering (SIDM), and in simulations by warm dark matter. Shared job in plain words: making the halo centre less dense than collisionless dark matter would leave it. - Semi-time function
Global clocks that order events, built with different strictness: semi-time, time, temporal, Cauchy time functions. - Shapes (geometry): the practice and the structure
Reorienting by the shape of the borders is found in rats, children, ants, chicks and fish: one job across insect and vertebrate nervous systems. - Smooth (differentiable) manifold
One topological manifold can carry inequivalent smooth structures: 'Some topological manifolds admit many smooth structures which are not equivalent' (exotic 7-spheres, exotic R^4), while in dimensions 1-3 'all distinct smooth structures are equivalent'. - Social change
One job, tipping a society toward a new pattern, done by different builds: price crossing (energy), divestment (finance), moral reframing (norms), education, information disclosure, carbon-neutral cities; six social tipping elements in six domains. - Spacelike separation (spacelike interval)
'Now' for a pair is built differently by each frame: simultaneous for one observer, A-before-C for another, C-before-A for a third. - Spacetime
A horizon that glows thermally, built three ways: by a black hole (Hawking: 'black holes emit Hawking radiation with a perfect thermal spectrum'), by acceleration through empty space (Unruh: an accelerating observer 'will perceive a thermal bath'), and by the local Rindler horizons through every poi - Spacetime event
The one role 'a point of spacetime' is built two ways: a zero-duration point of a smooth manifold, or an element of a discrete causal set whose order and count recover the geometry ('Order + Number = Geometry'). - Special conformal transformation
One symmetry met in two unrelated settings: free Maxwell fields (form invariance) and the fluctuations at a critical point. - Special relativity
one job (account for contraction and dilation) built two ways: as spacetime geometry, or as the dynamics of the forces holding rods and clocks together Re-walk (11-13) adds a second, stronger form: one job, 'check that light and clocks behave the same in every direction and at every speed', done by - Sphaleron
Baryon number broken by different builds: the sphaleron's gauge-field winding, monopole catalysis (Rubakov-Callan) and GUT X bosons (named on sys:matter-antimatter-balance). - Spherical harmonics
The sphere's Fourier series: 'similar to periodic functions defined on a circle that can be expressed as a sum of circular functions'; modes organised by spatial angular frequency. - Spherical orbit (Kerr)
One role, the threshold between plunge and survival, built by spherical orbits off the equator, by the ISCO and marginally bound orbit in the equatorial plane: 'Such threshold orbits play an important role in modelling the capture of matter and light'. - Spin foam (covariant loop quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
A non-perturbative path integral over geometries built from discrete pieces: spin foams (discreteness fundamental) and causal dynamical triangulations (discreteness a regularization to remove). - Spin network (labelled graph; a state of quantum geometry)
Gauge-invariant labelled networks built twice: spin networks for connections and Levin-Wen string-nets from tensor categories ('the exact connection with spin networks is not clear yet'); and the spin-network functional is 'an exact duality over a lattice' for any compact gauge group. - Spinal cord
Making the rhythm for walking or swimming is done by pattern generators in the vertebrate spinal cord and 'in each neuromere of the invertebrate ventral nerve cord' (a solid, ventral, ladder-like cord), built differently. - Sprinkled causal set (Poisson sprinkling into a Lorentzian manifold)
Discretising spacetime by a regular lattice (frame-dependent, fails n ~ rho V under boosts) or by random sprinkling (frame-free). - Stable circular orbit
One role (a lasting circle) built Newton's way far out (r^3 = G(M+m)/omega^2) and Einstein's way near 3 r_s, and split by spin into prograde and retrograde builds. - Stably causal spacetime
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): wider-cone causal metric, a time function, a temporal function. - Standard static spacetime
Global hyperbolicity reached three ways that the source proves equivalent: completeness of g_S/beta, Cauchy slices, the general Cauchy-hypersurface test. - Star cluster (open and globular)
Holding the core up against collapse is done by different things: hard binaries ('a net heat source to the cluster'), stellar-mass black-hole binaries (argued), and the enhanced mass loss of merger products ('a net heating effect'). - Static observer of de Sitter's static patch
A thermal reading from the vacuum: here a geodesic observer bounded by a cosmological horizon sees T_dS = 1/(2 pi l); in flat space a uniformly accelerating observer sees the Unruh bath. - Stationary world line
Steady reading of the vacuum: the time-independent detector response is one role built by six different motions (thermal for the boost, closed-form for null rotation, numerical for the rotating kinds). - Strange matter
Holding a dead star's core up against gravity by degeneracy pressure is done by different builds: electrons (white dwarfs), neutrons (neutron stars), and here a sea of three quark flavours, where adding the strange flavour 'relieves' the down-quark pressure. - String axion (projected model)
Escaping the fifth-force limit two ways: heavy (stabilised) moduli versus light axions protected by a symmetry. - Strongly causal spacetime
One condition, several equivalent definitions built on different structures (curves, relations, neighbourhoods, functions, topologies): causally convex neighbourhoods, Alexandrov topology equal to the manifold topology, Hausdorff Alexandrov topology. - Sub-Riemannian manifold
One role, the length of curves, built three ways on a smooth manifold: inner products on all directions (Riemannian), norms on all directions (Finsler), inner products on admissible directions only (sub-Riemannian). - Superextremal Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
No horizon and an exposed singularity by too much charge here, by too much spin in overextreme Kerr. - Supermassive black hole
The seed role is filled by rival builds: remnants of the first stars, supermassive stars or quasi-stars, dense-cluster collapse, direct collapse of metal-free gas, primordial holes, self-interacting dark matter. 'Early BHs likely fill a continuum from stellar-mass to the super-massive regime, reflec - Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution
One job, keeping the hole's fuel from cooling and collapsing onto it, done by two builds: quasar mode (radiative wind, energy or momentum injection) and radio mode (jets whose X-ray bubbles 'counterbalance cooling losses'). - Superstring theory (projected model; supersymmetric string theory)
Five versions with different strings, supersymmetries and gauge groups, conjectured to be one theory's limits; dualities show pairs are 'mathematically different descriptions of the same phenomena'. - Supertranslation
The conserved-energy-momentum role of the 4 translations is extended to infinitely many supermomentum charges, one per supertranslation. - Sustainability
One job, keeping use of a resource below what it renews, done by different builds: traditional and indigenous restrictions, Carlowitz's replanting rule (1713), community rules with monitors and graduated sanctions (Ostrom), national taxes and limits, a global treaty (Montreal). Shared lineage among - Ten-dimensional spacetime (superstring)
The role 'stage for a consistent string theory' built at 26 (bosonic), 10 (superstring) and 11 (M-theory) dimensions, each fixed by a consistency condition. - Terbium (Tb, Z = 65)
Turning an electrical drive into strong sound under water: Terfenol-D does it by magnetostriction, PZT8 by the other route the source names; Terfenol's larger strain reaches greater depths. - Terrell rotation (Terrell-Penrose effect)
The appearance is made either by a real object near c (spacetime) or by slowing the effective speed of light to below 2 m/s with gated femtosecond light (laboratory). - Theory of everything (projected model; final theory)
One role (join gravity to the rest), five candidate builds: strings, loops, twistors, noncommutative geometry, asymptotic safety. - Three-dimensional Euclidean space
One job, three dimensions apart: a vector perpendicular to others is a binary product only in 3 and 7 dimensions; in n dimensions it takes n - 1 vectors. - Time
Time is read by many unrelated periodic systems: 'the apparent motion of the sun across the sky, the phases of the moon, and the passage of a free-swinging pendulum', caesium atoms, and in cosmology the cooling bath and redshift. - Torsion tensor (of an affine connection; Einstein-Cartan gravity)
A loop that fails to close, measured by one vector: torsion in spacetime ('analogously to a screw dislocation') and the Burgers vector of a crystal dislocation. Cartan was inspired by the Cosserat brothers' continuum mechanics. - TRAPPIST-1 system
One job, heating the planets' interiors, done by three builds: tidal flexing (dominant on the inner planets), radioactive decay, and induction heating from the star's changing field (contended). Night-side ice can be returned by tidal or geothermal heat alike. - Trigonometry (the practice of tying angles to lengths, and the structure it works on)
Fixing a position from a known baseline and measured angles or delays: the surveyor's triangle, the avian brainstem's comparison of interaural delays (it 'spatially codes the sound source location'), the insect's integrated home vector. Different builds, one role. - Twenty-six-dimensional spacetime (bosonic string)
The string stage fixed by a consistency condition: 26 here, 10 for superstrings, 11 for M-theory. - Two-sphere S^2 (the ordinary sphere)
Least area for the volume enclosed, reached by different forces: 'surface tension minimizes its surface area' in a soap bubble, and 'gravity minimizes surface area for large celestial bodies'. - Vector space: sets whose elements can be added and scaled, as mathematics describes it, with bases and dimension, linear maps, inner products, and their use as the state spaces of physics and data
Holding quantities that add and scale is done by arrows (geometry), n-tuples (arithmetic), functions (analysis), firing-rate vectors (neuroscience) and learned word vectors (language models). - Vervet monkey (Chlorocebus pygerythrus)
Telling the group which kind of danger is near: vervets by largely innate call types read with context; Japanese tits by call combinations; meerkats and birds by their own calls - Wave equation (massless scalar field)
The propagation role is built from different restoring mechanisms: tension in a string, springs between masses (Hooke's law), elasticity and density in solids, and the coupled electric and magnetic fields of light. - Weakly deflected light ray
One deflection read out by different instruments: photographic eclipse plates (1919), radio interferometry on quasars (VLBI), whole-sky astrometry (Hipparcos, Gaia). - Weakly trapped surface
Marking the black-hole region: locally by a weakly trapped surface (which under the energy conditions 'must be contained inside a black hole') and globally by the event horizon (the boundary of the past of future null infinity). - Weyl curvature spinor (Psi_ABCD)
The same Weyl curvature takes two physical shapes by its type: the static exterior of a star or hole (type D) and transverse radiation (type N). - Weyl solution
One class holding vacuum (Laplace, linear) and electrovac (Poisson-like, nonlinear) members: 'Unlike the nonlinear Poisson's equation Eq(7.b), Eq(8.b) is the linear Laplace equation'. - Weyl tensor (Weyl curvature tensor)
One role, tides, split into two builds: the Weyl tensor distorts shape, the Ricci part changes volume ('contains precisely the information about how volumes change'). - Wheeler-DeWitt equation (the Hamiltonian constraint of quantum geometrodynamics; walked as a projected model)
Time from inside a timeless universe built three ways: WKB time from a classical solution (here), a quantum clock operator with conditional probabilities (consistent discretizations), a massless scalar field (loop quantum cosmology). - World line
The one role 'history of an object' is built at three sizes: a world line for a point, a world sheet for a string, a world tube (world volume) for an extended object. - Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules)
Law held as a fixed set of articles on different carriers: cuneiform stelae and tablets (c. 2100 BC on), Chinese bronze inscriptions (536 BC), and Iroquois constitutional wampum, 'each component symbolizing one of the many laws within the 117 articles'. - X boson (X and Y bosons; hypothetical GUT gauge bosons)
Baryon-number violation (proton decay) by different structures: X-boson exchange, a heavy colour-triplet Higgs, magnetic-monopole catalysis, and Standard Model sphalerons ('groups of baryons ... into antileptons').
Candidate (3)
- Electromagnetic four-potential
One effect, two complete accounts: 'the magnitude of the Aharonov-Bohm effect can be calculated using the electromagnetic fields alone, or using the four-potential alone', the first needing fields where the particle never goes, the second only the potential where it does. - Kilonova
A glow powered by radioactive decay of freshly made nuclei, as in a supernova's late light curve (56Ni to 56Co to 56Fe); here the nuclei are r-process products and the glow fades in weeks. - Neutron star merger
The r-process runs in two named kinds of site: the re-expanded core of a core-collapse supernova (about 1e24 free neutrons per cm^3 made by electron capture) and the decompression of neutron-star matter thrown off by a merger. Both deliver rapid neutron capture onto seeds, then beta decay to stabili
Surface: a resemblance (72)
- Ambitwistors (ambitwistor space)
Yang-Mills fields are encoded two ways in twistor geometry: self-dual ones as holomorphic bundles on twistor space (Ward, the Penrose-Ward transform) and full ones as vanishing curvature on null lines in ambitwistor space. - Aristotle
He noted that sharks have a placenta like the live-bearing tetrapods: one job (nourishing the embryo by a cord) met by unrelated lineages; to a biologist it is convergent evolution. - Canonical (Noether) stress-energy tensor
Three inequivalent definitions do the one job of describing non-gravitational stress-energy: the canonical Noether current, the Hilbert metric derivative and the Belinfante-Rosenfeld improvement; in general relativity the last two agree. - Cauchy horizon
The edge of predictability is built by a charge (Reissner-Nordstrom), a spin (Kerr), and by closed timelike curves (chronology horizon of a wormhole time machine or the Gott spacetime). - Classroom
Seeing everyone in the room (supervision) done by different builds: rows with space to walk around, the raised master's desk at Lancaster's lower end, a circle where everyone sees everyone, the teacher moving swiftly through the room - Closed timelike curve
The same closed curve is built by different geometries: rotating dust (van Stockum, Goedel), a rotating black hole's interior (Kerr), a rotating cylinder (Tipler), wormholes, cosmic strings (Gott), two spinning balls (Bonnor-Steadman). - Compactified complexified Minkowski space
One role, a point of spacetime, built as an event of Minkowski space, as a 2-plane in C^4, and as a point of a quadric in CP^5. - Complex spacetime
One role, a calculation of real-time physics, done in two builds: directly in Lorentzian spacetime, or on the Wick-rotated Euclidean section and continued back. - Complexified Minkowski spacetime
One role, the relativistic spin state of a spin-1/2 particle, in two builds: the usual bispinor and this complex 4D vector ('the relativistic spin state rho in our representation is a complex 4D vector and not a bi-spinor'). - Conformal group of spacetime C(1,3)
'angle-preserving' is built three ways: inversions in circles (the sphere, the Moebius group), inversions in hyperspheres (Euclidean n > 2), linear fractional maps over biquaternions, split-complex or dual numbers (spacetime). - Contractible closed timelike curve
Two builds of one job, keeping a CTC from being shrunk away: here the cones turn the shrinking loop null (geometry); in the noncontractible kind the loop winds a hole in the manifold (topology). - Covariant derivative
Two generalisations of the directional derivative: the covariant derivative (extra structure, depends on the direction at one point) and the Lie derivative (canonical, needs both fields in a neighbourhood); they 'differ by the torsion of the connection'. - Determinant energy condition (DETEC)
Nonlinear conditions keep semi-classical violations bounded where linear ones fail without bound: the determinant and the trace of the square are two builds of that role. - Dust solution
One idealised dust grain stands in for very different bodies: galaxies, clusters and superclusters in toy universes, stars in a galaxy disk (Meinel: 'with the stars considered as dust grains'). - Einstein-de Sitter universe
Two flat models of the expanding universe: matter only (Einstein-de Sitter, 1932) and matter plus dark energy (Lambda-CDM), the second replacing the first after 1998. - Einstein-Hilbert action
One role, the gravitational Lagrangian, built as R (GR), f(R), R + R^2 (Starobinsky), Gauss-Bonnet, Lovelock, or R with a scalar replacing the constant (Brans-Dicke); and in discrete form as the Benincasa-Dowker action. - Equation of state (cosmology)
Very different contents (a free scalar field, photons, cold matter, a vacuum energy, a network of strings) all enter the expansion through one number w; strings share w = -1/3 with curvature. - Ergosphere
One job (taking energy out of a rotating hole) done by a split particle (Penrose), by fields (Blandford-Znajek), by amplified waves (Zeldovich): the see-also shelf. - Exterior Schwarzschild solution
One exterior field for any spherical body (Birkhoff): a planet, the Sun, a neutron star or a black hole all give the same outside geometry, told apart only by mass. - Folding funnel (a protein's folding free-energy landscape)
One job, a landscape that leads to one stable form, met differently: protein landscapes funnel; RNA landscapes 'are generally rugged with multiple minima', and RNA folds need protein help in ribosomes. - Galilean boost (uniform frame motion of Newtonian physics)
Change of inertial frame built two ways: a shear of (x, t) with universal time, or a hyperbolic rotation of a spacetime plane. - Gibbons-Hawking-York boundary term
The value of the gravitational action is carried by the bulk R term or by the boundary term: on vacuum solutions R = 0 and the principal function is 'given entirely in terms of the boundary term'; in the Euclidean approach 'the entire contribution' to black-hole entropy 'comes from the GHY term'. - Goedel universe
Rotating dust builds closed timelike curves here; the Kerr interior, the Tipler cylinder and wormholes build the same curve with other structures (CTC walk). - Gravitational singularity
The same end of spacetime built as a point (Schwarzschild), a ring (Kerr), a null surface (Cauchy horizon) or the whole of space at t = 0 (Big Bang). - Hadron
Composite bound states by two forces: hadrons 'are analogous to molecules, which are held together by the electromagnetic force'. - Hilbert stress-energy tensor (metric energy-momentum tensor)
Canonical, Hilbert and Belinfante-Rosenfeld definitions describe one quantity; in general relativity the Belinfante-Rosenfeld tensor 'is precisely the symmetric Hilbert stress-energy tensor'. - Horava-Lifshitz gravity (walked as a projected model)
Short-distance gravity tamed three ways: anisotropic scaling (Horava), a causal lattice (CDT), a UV fixed point (asymptotic safety); in 2D the first two are one theory. - Improved (Callan-Coleman-Jackiw) energy-momentum tensor
A traceless energy-momentum built two ways: by nature for the Maxwell field in 4D, by the phi^2 improvement for a massless scalar. - Innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO)
The same 'last stable circle' built by a static hole (6GM/c^2), a spinning one (GM/c^2 to 9GM/c^2), a charged one (inward), or a compact neutron star. - Invariant hyperbola of spacelike separation
The same one-sheeted hyperboloid is a locus of events here and a whole spacetime (de Sitter) elsewhere. - Kasner dust (Heckmann-Schucking solution)
One R^-6 term built two ways: by the shear of an anisotropic expansion and by a stiff fluid (p = rho); in the generalised solution they add into one constant. - Large language model
Picking which inputs count more for the next step: done by query-key weighting in transformers and by attention in brains. Lindsay: machine attention is 'inspired by psychology' but 'its implementations do not always track with what is known about biological attention'. - Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi dust
The same supernova dimming is built two ways: by dark energy (acceleration) in a homogeneous model, or by a radial variation of the expansion in an LTB dust model ('a trick of light'). - Lorentz group (homogeneous Lorentz group, O(1,3))
The night-sky picture: the same restricted group appears as matrices on spacetime, as SL(2, C) on spinors and as Moebius maps on the Riemann (celestial) sphere. - Modified gravity
One role, the gravitational dynamics, built many ways: changed Lagrangian (f(R), Lovelock), added fields (scalar-tensor, vector-tensor, bimetric, TeVeS), extra dimensions (DGP), torsion (Einstein-Cartan). - Momentum constraint
The same constraint in two variable sets: D_j K^j_i - D_i K = 8 pi p_i (3+1 geometry) and P^i = -2 pi^ij_;j (ADM canonical momentum). - Neugebauer-Meinel dust (rigidly rotating disk of dust)
One rotating role, different builds: the same rigid-rotation physics gives an infinite cylinder with time loops (van Stockum), a disk that becomes a Kerr black hole (Neugebauer-Meinel), and squeezing van Stockum to a ring also ends at Kerr. - Noncontractible closed timelike curve
The same removable loop is built by periodic time, a boost quotient, a torus or a wormhole handle. - Novikov self-consistency principle
One job, letting only consistent histories occur, done four ways: classical consistency constraints, least action (Carlini et al.: minimizing paths are exactly the self-consistent ones), a quantum sum over consistent histories, and Lloyd's post-selection. - Null hypersurface
A viscous fluid and a horizon: Damour read the projected Einstein equation on a null hypersurface as a two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equation with pressure kappa/8 pi and shear viscosity 1/16 pi. - Parity P (spatial inversion) and P-symmetry
In three dimensions inverting all axes is a parity; in two dimensions the same move is a 180-degree rotation: the role 'mirror' is built differently by dimension. - Pauli-Lubanski pseudovector
One role, the spin of a particle, built two ways: w^2 = -m^2 s(s+1) for m > 0, and w = lambda p (helicity) for m = 0. - Photon sphere
The same trap for light (a photon sphere) is built around a black hole, a naked singularity or a body of very compact matter (Claudel-Virbhadra-Ellis); around a spinning hole it is built by frame dragging into a whole shell of orbits. - Prefrontal cortex
the job called prefrontal is done by granular lateral cortex in primates and by agranular medial cortex in rodents (if the rodent areas count: C-849) - Projective space
One role, the projective point, in three builds: a line through the origin, a class of coordinates up to scale, a pair of antipodal points on a sphere. - Pseudo-Riemannian (semi-Riemannian) manifold
One role (a measuring form on every tangent space, with a Levi-Civita connection and curvature) built two ways: positive-definite and indefinite. - Pseudovector (axial vector)
One role, angular momentum, built two ways: a classical pseudovector r x p, or 'the 2-form Noether charge associated with rotational invariance'. - Quantum Einstein gravity (walked as a projected model)
Quantum descriptions of the gravitational field: the metric as quantum field (QEG), spin networks (LQG), strings (string theory). - Quantum sum over causal sets
One job, a dynamics for causal sets, built three ways: classical stochastic growth (CSG), quantum growth with a quantum measure (QSG), and a continuum-inspired path sum with the BD action. - Quantum weak energy condition (QWEC)
Two builds bound negative energy: the local QWEC (a floor at -zeta hbar N/L^4) and the nonlocal, time-integrated Ford-Roman quantum inequalities. - Relativistic mass
The inertia role is built three ways in the history read: Lorentz's longitudinal and transverse masses (force over acceleration), relativistic mass (momentum over velocity) and, in modern use, energy itself. - Restricted Lorentz group SO+(1,3) (proper orthochronous Lorentz group)
One group, three builds: 4x4 matrices on spacetime, SL(2, C) on spinors (two-to-one), and Moebius maps of the celestial sphere. - Reuter fixed point (non-Gaussian UV fixed point of gravity)
UV completion by a fixed point: the Gaussian point (couplings to zero, asymptotic freedom of the colour field) and the non-Gaussian Reuter point (couplings finite). - Ricci scalar (scalar curvature)
The value of the gravitational action is carried by the bulk R term or, on vacuum solutions where R = 0, entirely by the boundary term. - Rindler space (the Rindler wedge)
Three distinct 'but reasonable' notions of distance for the same pair of observers: ruler (induced metric), radar (light round trip) and optical diameter distance. - Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest)
Making new law or knowledge from old by testing new cases against a kept record is built twice: stare decisis and the method; Bacon's tables of instances may come from the common law ('has been proposed as a source'). - Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical)
Planck-scale structure of spacetime built as a fluctuating foam (Wheeler), as labelled 2-complexes (spin foam), as a discrete order (causal sets) or as simplices (CDT). - Spin tensor (spin current)
Intrinsic angular momentum carried by very different media: spinning molecules, circularly polarized light, small turbulent vortices. - Strengthened dominant energy condition (SDEC)
DEC and SDEC have one effective form (rho >= 0, |p| <= rho) and two geometric/physical builds that differ only off type i. - Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
Inequivalent definitions do the one job: the Hilbert tensor (variation of the matter action with the metric), the canonical Noether tensor, and the Belinfante-Rosenfeld tensor, which 'in general relativity ... agrees with the Hilbert stress-energy tensor'. - Supergravity (projected model: the gauge theory of local supersymmetry)
'Many different versions of SUGRA ... inequivalent in the sense that their actions and constraints upon the torsion tensor are different, but ultimately equivalent' under a field redefinition. - Tipler cylinder
Time machines built from different materials: a positive-energy rotating cylinder (Tipler), exotic matter in a wormhole (Morris-Thorne-Yurtsever), moving cosmic strings (Gott), a bounded vacuum torus (Ori). - Trace energy condition (TEC)
Two ceilings on stiffness built differently: the trace condition (p <= rho/3) and the dominant condition (|p| <= rho); nature (neutron-star cores) breaks the first and sits on the second's edge. - Trace-of-square energy condition (TOSEC)
Nonlinear conditions that keep semi-classical violations bounded: the trace of the square and the determinant. - Transport theorem
The rotating-frame derivative is the n = 3 case of a generator equation T' = G T 'important for trajectories in Lie group theory': the cross product here, a skew-symmetric matrix for SO(n) in general. - Traversable wormhole
One job, holding a throat open, done by an exotic-matter shell (Morris-Thorne), a reversed-sign scalar field (Ellis), Casimir energy of charged fermions (Maldacena-Milekhin-Popov), negative-mass cosmic strings (Visser, Cramer), a boundary coupling (Gao-Jafferis-Wall) or bare geometry (Gauss-Bonnet). - Twistor space
One role, a spacetime event, in two builds: a point of Minkowski space, or a line CP^1 in twistor space ('events being derived objects that correspond to compact holomorphic curves'). - Twistor string theory
Tree amplitudes of N = 4 super Yang-Mills are produced two ways: by D-instantons of the B model (Witten) and by open-string trees (Berkovits). - Two-dimensional causal dynamical triangulation (2D CDT)
One 2D quantum gravity reached two ways: a lattice with a causal rule, and a continuum theory with anisotropic scaling (projectable HL); their Hamiltonians are identical. - Van Stockum dust
Rotation builds closed timelike curves in different bodies: a dust cylinder (van Stockum), a rotating dust universe (Goedel), a spinning ring (Kerr), a spinning string (8 pi J time-jump). - Weak energy condition (WEC)
Negative energy near a rotating hole and negative energy between Casimir plates look alike, but only the second breaks the condition: the Kerr negative energy is the Killing-field energy, 'not the ordinary energy density as measured by any observer'. - Zero-energy universe
The negative reservoir role: baryonic gravity covers 26-37%, dark matter is assumed to cover the rest.
Structural (picture only) (1)
- Hyperbolic Moebius transformation (a boost seen on the celestial sphere)
A flow from a source point to a sink point built twice: the hyperbolic Moebius flow and the field lines of a positive and a negative charge ('These pictures resemble the field lines').
Strong (1)
- Wave function of the universe (quantum state of a closed universe; hypothetical)
One job (pick the one solution of the Wheeler-DeWitt equation) built three ways: a Euclidean sum over compact geometries, outgoing waves at the boundary of superspace, a reversed Euclidean rotation.