← all systems · see it in The System
Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases)
Precedent is a judicial decision that serves as an authority for courts when deciding subsequent identical or similar cases. Fundamental to common law legal systems, precedent operates under the principle of stare decisis, where past judicial decisions serve as case law to guide future rulings ... a legal precedent may be applied / adopted ... distinguished ... modified ... or overruled.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Common law: precedent (stare decisis) |
| arrives | the concept of a common law developed under Henry II, late 12th century; first extant Year Book 1268 |
| boundary | Inside: the generating rule (stare decisis, vertical and horizontal; the ratio decidendi binds, obiter dicta do not; each new case is applied, distinguished, modified or overruled against the old; a case of first impression makes a new precedent; overruling needs a 'special justification'), plus its shell: the law reports that keep the units (Year Books from 1268, nominate reports, official reporters, citators) and the bar that alone may argue them (the railing that 'separates the parts of a courtroom reserved for spectators'). Outside: the body of case law it unpacks into (6.7 million US cases), the disputes and litigants that supply new facts, the courts and their hierarchy (carriers), statutes and legislatures, civil-law codes, and the judges' and lawyers' minds that hold it. |
| nested level | A Seed within BVSR: cases vary, appeal and overruling select, reports retain; Brandeis names it 'the process of trial and error, so fruitful in the physical sciences ... appropriate also in the judicial function'. Carried by the royal courts from Henry II's circuits (reign 1154-1189) and on the written record, but not workable as a binding rule until the 19th century: 'Before the printing press, the state of the written records of cases rendered the stare decisis doctrine utterly impracticable', and only unified hierarchies plus 'reliable private case reporters made adherence ... practical'. |
| quantum | the rule of precedent (stare decisis) plus the case of first impression: each decided case becomes a new unit that later decisions must combine with |
| scale | social |
| shell | Law reports and court records keep the quanta (since 1268; official reporters from Massachusetts after 1776); the bar keeps the practitioners. Overruling by a higher court is the repair channel. |
Measures (11) published science
| published US court decisions (Caselaw Access Project) | over 6.7 million cases; over 40 million pages; 360 years of U.S. legal history |
| Year Books, continuous series | 1268 to 1535 years |
| first Year Book abridgment (Statham) | around 1470 date |
| US Supreme Court reversals of itself, 1946-1992 | about 130 cases |
| House of Lords rejections of its own past decisions after the 1966 Practice Statement, up to 2005 | no more than 20 cases |
| unpublished share of US Courts of Appeals decisions | some 80% (2004); 4th Circuit 92% (2000-2008) percent |
| federal appeals filed per year | 23,200 (1980); 33,360 (1985); 55,000 (2000) appeals per year |
| share of world population in common-law or mixed jurisdictions | approximately one-third fraction |
| countries using civil law (the rival rule) | about 150 countries |
| characteristic clock: law terms (plea rolls bundled by Hilary, Easter, Trinity and Michaelmas) | 4 terms per year |
| characteristic clock: precedent lifespan before overruling (examples) | about 1 year (Anderton v Ryan 1985 to R v Shivpuri 1986); 22 years (R v Caldwell 1981 to R v G 2003) |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Law (rules and law)
- Ratio decidendi, the holding (role: quanta)
- Distinguishing (rule: a new rule beside the old)
- Overruling (rule: the repair and selection channel)
- Law reports and citators (shell: the retention record)
- The bar (shell: the profession that alone argues the rule)
- Codified law against custom and case law
- Competition for Europe's courts (received Roman law vs English common law vs local custom)
- Judge-made precedent against legislated codes for the law of a jurisdiction
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- The common-law courts and their hierarchy (carriers)
Trades with (valence) (14)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR) via sys:written-record · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
- Corpus Juris Civilis (Justinian's codification: Codex, Digest, Institutes, Novels) via sys:mental-representation · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:written-record · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
- Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest) via sys:mental-representation · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) even
- Law reports and citators (shell: the retention record) via sys:written-record · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
- The bar (shell: the profession that alone argues the rule) via sys:mental-representation · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
- The common-law courts and their hierarchy (carriers) via sys:written-record · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
- Case law (what it unpacks into) via sys:written-record · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
- Legislatures and statutes via sys:written-record · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) mixed
- Legal codes and the civil law (the rival) via sys:written-record · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) mixed
- Glossators' reading method (gloss and commentary) via sys:mental-representation · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) even
- Constitution of the United States via sys:written-record · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
- Supreme Court of the United States via sys:law · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
- Corporate law via sys:written-record · Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) gain
expressed by (22)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Multi-Scale Data Fusion / Triangulation
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Optimal Stopping & Patch-Switching
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (5)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Law (rules and law)
- Constitution of the United States
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Corporate law
seed within (1)
Notes published science
- The Supreme Court described its own Seed as BVSR in 1932. Brandeis, dissenting in Burnet v. Coronado Oil & Gas: 'The Court bows to the lessons of experience and the force of better reasoning, recognizing that the process of trial and error, so fruitful in the physical sciences, is appropriate also in the judicial function.' The same dissent holds that 'in most matters it is more important that the applicable rule of law be settled than that it be settled right'. That is a stopping rule written into the retention clause.
- Google's ranking descends from a lawyers' sticker sheet. Frank Shepard's 1873 'Adhesive Annotations' were gummed slips 'torn to bits and stuck to pertinent margins' of case reporters to show if a case had been overruled. Garfield's Science Citation Index (1960) was 'heavily influenced' by Shepard's, and it inspired the link analysis 'which became the heart of the Google search engine'.
- Most of the variants never reach the retention store. About 80% of US Courts of Appeals decisions were unpublished by 2004 (92% in the 4th Circuit, 2000-2008), and the Justice Department settles some cases 'simply to avoid creating adverse precedent'. The selection filter sits before retention, and the parties can game it.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
mental representation: precedent held and applied by bench and bar
- L1: Trained legal knowledge held by judges and lawyers: apprentices 'learned their craft primarily by attending court sessions' for 'at least seven years'; 'A judge's normal aids include access to all previous cases'
- L2: Appraisal under the reasoning: 'The felt necessities of the time, the prevalent moral and political theories, intuitions of public policy, avowed or unconscious, even the prejudices which judges share with their fellow men' (Holmes)
- L3: Legal concepts: a ratio held as a principle, e.g. Donoghue v Stevenson, 'a person owes a duty of care to those who he can reasonably foresee will be affected by his actions'
- L4: Reasoning from cases: 'extract the principles, analogies, and statements by various courts'; distinguishing on 'materially different facts'; Cardozo's 'inductive' method
- L5: Predicting other courts: 'to determine how the next court is likely to rule on the facts of the present case'; a federal court must 'predict how the state courts would resolve the issue'; parties 'can predict whether a proposed course of action is likely to be lawful'
- L6: Bench and bar: 'the bar advocates and the bench adjudicates'; 'The phrase bench and bar denotes all judges and lawyers collectively'
- L7: The rule of law as collective representation: 'the very concept of the rule of law underlying our own Constitution requires such continuity over time that a respect for precedent is, by definition, indispensable'; 'bedrock principles are founded in the law, rather than in the proclivities of individuals'
sound: pleading and oral argument heard in court
- L1: Pleading and oral argument: the Year Books 'containing reports of pleas heard before the Common Bench'; 'parties often have the opportunity to present an oral argument to a judge or panel of judges'
written record: case law kept in law reports under stare decisis
- L1: Court records and reports: plea rolls ('official court records ... written in Latin', bundled by law term), Year Books (1268-1535), nominate reports, official reporters, West's National Reporter System ('well over 10,000 volumes'), and court websites
- L2: Decision into report: the reporter compiles the citation, case name, catchwords, headnote, facts, arguments of counsel and the verbatim judgment; 'It is only the last item that is authoritative'
- L3: The holding bound: the ratio decidendi 'creates binding precedent'; obiter dicta 'are not legally binding on other courts'
- L4: Case law assembled: 'the collection of precedents and legal principles established by previous judicial decisions on specific issues or topics'; abridgments by subject (Statham c. 1470), digests and Key Numbers
- L5: Each unit's status regulated: applied, distinguished, modified or overruled; citators (Shepard's from 1873) show 'if a case has been overturned, reaffirmed, questioned'; selective publication and depublication decide what may be cited
- L6: The hierarchy of binding: vertical stare decisis 'binds lower courts to strictly follow the decisions of higher courts within the same jurisdiction'; horizontal, a court 'adheres to its own previous rulings'; en banc and top courts 'overrule and unify'
- L7: 'the means by which we ensure that the law will not merely change erratically, but will develop in a principled and intelligible fashion' (Vasquez v. Hillery); 'consistency and predictability'
Who fills each layer
Sources (20) published science
Non-publication of legal opinions in the United States (Wikipedia, rev 1380698381, 2026-10-17, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Universal Darwinism (Wikipedia via Wikimedia Enterprise, rev 1366843201, 2026-07-30; article flagged "more citations needed") (behind its links)
Year Books (Wikipedia, rev 1342493959, 2026-03-09, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Civil law (legal system) (Wikipedia, rev 1380529130, 2026-10-16, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Ratio decidendi (Wikipedia, rev 1351743271, 2026-04-29, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Law report (Wikipedia, rev 1332028535, 2026-01-09, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Bar (law) (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Shepard's Citations (Wikipedia, rev 1316847504, 2025-10-14, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Baconian method (Wikipedia, rev 1380040592, 2026-10-13, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Roman law (Wikipedia, rev 1368691460, 2026-08-10, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Saks, E. & Borgida, E. How people reason about stare decisis: the role of political ideology. Behavioral Sciences 16(7): 1087 (2026). doi:10.3390/bs16071087 (behind its links)
Delaware Division of Corporations. 2025 Annual Report (official statistics). (behind its links)
Appeal (Wikipedia, rev 1374508712, 2026-09-12, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)