EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Supreme Court of the United States

The highest court of the federal judiciary of the United States, created by Article III of the Constitution and organised by the Judiciary Act of 1789; nine justices since 1869 (a chief justice and eight associate justices) who hold office during good behaviour, are nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate, and decide by majority vote. It has final appellate jurisdiction over federal cases and over state cases turning on federal law, a narrow original jurisdiction (in practice, disputes between states), and since Marbury v. Madison (1803) the power of judicial review over acts of Congress and of the executive. Walked as historians and legal scholars describe it: its constitutional place, the justices and their appointment, judicial review, how cases reach it (certiorari, the rule of four, the cert pool) and how it decides them (briefs, oral argument, conference, opinions), its limits (no sword or purse; amendment and statutory override; Congress's control of size and jurisdiction), and its history by chief justice from Jay to Roberts.

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

aliasesSupreme Court and federal judiciary (Article III)
born at1790-02-02 (inaugural session, Royal Exchange, New York; justices confirmed 26 September 1789)
born precisiondays
boundaryInside: the nine justices (the chief justice and eight associate justices), their law clerks (four each; the chief justice up to five), the Court's officers (the Clerk, the Reporter of Decisions), the cert pool, the conference, the Supreme Court Building and the Supreme Court Police. Outside: the parties and their lawyers (the Supreme Court bar, the Solicitor General), amici, the lower federal courts and the state high courts whose judgments it reviews, Congress (which sets its size and appellate jurisdiction and whose Senate confirms the justices), the president (who nominates them and whose acts it reviews), the states, the press and the public whose support it draws on, and the markets and people its rulings act on. The boundary is crossed by every case: a dispute enters as a petition and leaves as an order or an opinion; justices enter through the appointments door and leave by death, retirement, resignation or impeachment.
scalesocial

Measures (43) published science

justices9 members (one chief justice, eight associate justices; since 1869)
justices at founding6 members (Judiciary Act of 1789)
quorum6 justices
votes to grant certiorari4 of 9 (rule of four)
certiorari petitionsabout 7,000 (another count: 9,000-10,000) per year
cases grantedabout 80 (80-100 with argument; 50-60 more summarily) per year
certiorari grant rateabout 1% of petitions
opinions per term70-90 opinions (about 700 justice votes)
opinions in the U.S. Reports30,161 opinions, Feb 1790 to Mar 2012
Acts of Congress held unconstitutional176 Acts
laws held unconstitutional 1960-2019483 laws (whole or part)
cases striking statutes before Marbury31 state or federal cases (Treanor)
amendments overturning decisions6 occasions
nominations165 nominations 1789-2022
nominations confirmed128 (78%) of 165
unsuccessful nominations37 (11 rejected, 11 withdrawn, 15 lapsed) nominations
nomination to final action (median), 1789-19667 days
nomination to final action (median), 1967-202266 days
nomination to first hearing (median)10 before 1967; 26 from 1967 to 2022 days
interval between new justicesabout 2 years (average)
mean tenure (contemporary)about 25 years
termfirst Monday of October to June or early July annual cycle
petition filing window90 (+60 extension) days
oral argument per side30 minutes
salary298,500 (associate); 312,200 (chief) US dollars per year (2024)
law clerks4 per associate justice; up to 5 for the chief clerks
approvalabout 66% (late 1980s) to about 40% (mid-2021 to Feb 2024) percent approving
unanimous decisionsnearly 50% (20-year average) to nearly 30% (2021) share of decisions
party-line rulingsa 60-year average just above zero to 21% (2021) share of decisions
unanimous share of votes36% average over 18 natural courts
effective number of justices4.68 ideal justices (second Rehnquist Court, Shannon information)
vote patterns in six valleysmore than 99% (508/512) patterns (second Rehnquist Court, 895 votes)
consensus decay timenearly 100 years (36 justices, 1946-2016)
prediction accuracy (case outcome / justice vote)70.2% / 71.9% out of sample, 1816-2015
justice votes 1816-2015more than 240,000 votes; 28,000 case outcomes
reverse rate (last 35 terms)57% of votes; 63% of case outcomes share
vote predicted from the other justices83% (experts 67.9%; content-based 66.7%) accuracy
crowd prediction80.8% case-level accuracy (over 600,000 predictions, 7,000+ participants)
Federalist Society effectabout 10 percentage points more likely to vote conservative (about 25,000 votes, 1986-2022)
court relative to the public (2021)right of roughly three quarters of Americans
abnormal returns after decisions79 of 211 cases (37%), average 4.4% two-session window
oral-argument exchanges studied50,389 justice-lawyer exchanges
lifetime1790-present years

Open contentions (6) open contention

Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.

Cross-scale patterns seen here (1) our proposal

Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Supreme Court of the United States. Each links to every other system that shows it.

Valence: what it trades, and with whom (15) published science

Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (12)

Sits inside / holds (3)

expressed by (16)

floor filled by (18)

Kinds (1)

wired (3)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

the Supreme Court as historians and legal scholars describe it: disputes to binding judgment (reader's view; the Courts by chief justice in `periods`)

  1. L1: The disputes of people, firms, states and governments arising under the Constitution and federal law, already judged below, and the public and branches the Court shares power with
  2. L2: The doors: petitions for certiorari (about 7,000 a year), direct appeals, certified questions, original complaints, applications to circuit justices, and nominations
  3. L3: Routing: the Clerk's office and the Rules, the cert pool and clerks' memos, briefs and amicus briefs, special masters
  4. L4: Integration: the discuss list and the rule of four, Rule 10 reasons, the record from below, oral argument
  5. L5: Regulation: the conference of nine by seniority; preliminary votes; quorum and recusal; independence secured by tenure and pay
  6. L6: Meaning: the Constitution as fundamental law, statutes, precedent and doctrine; the ideological space the justices' votes sit in
  7. L7: Decision and action: the judgment and opinion of the Court, binding on all courts; laws struck down; orders and decrees

the boardroom (shared floors)

  1. L5: The conference: the nine justices alone (clerks and public excluded), speaking and voting in order of seniority from the chief justice down; the rule of four on petitions; preliminary votes on argued cases; quorum six. Justices hold office during good behaviour with undiminished pay. Read as a whole, the nine act as about 4.68 independent justices, and a pairwise model of their votes puts more than 99% of vote patterns in six valleys (unanimity, the 5-4 ideological split, 7-2)
  2. L6: Meaning: the Constitution read as fundamental law (Federalist 78; Marbury: 'actually law'), the supremacy of federal law, statutes, precedent and doctrine (substantive due process, incorporation, constitutional avoidance), and the ideological space in which justices and the public can be placed on one scale
  3. L7: The Court deciding as one: the judgment by majority vote, the opinion of the Court assigned by the chief justice or the senior justice in the majority, binding precedent on all courts; an even split affirms below without precedent

way in: Applications and the emergency (shadow) docket

  1. L1: Parties needing interim relief: stays, injunctions, extensions of time
  2. L2: Applications to the circuit justice for the circuit (one justice per one or two of the 13 circuits; circuit riding ended 1891, abolished 1911)
  3. L3: The circuit justice endorses 'granted' or 'denied', writes an in-chambers opinion, or refers the application to the full Court
  4. L4: The full Court's orders on the emergency docket, often without each justice's reasoning shown

way in: Appointments: new justices through the president and Senate

  1. L1: The legal profession from which presidents choose (no constitutional qualifications); in recent decades mostly federal appellate judges and former Supreme Court clerks, screened through networks such as the Federalist Society
  2. L2: A vacancy (on average a new justice about every two years) and the president's nomination sent to the Senate
  3. L3: The Senate Judiciary Committee: public hearings since 1946 for almost all nominees, four or more days in recent decades; a nomination may be withdrawn or left to lapse (Garland, 2016)
  4. L4: Senate debate and vote (cloture by simple majority since 2017), the commission, and the two oaths; seniority runs from the commission

way in: Congress's structural acts: size, jurisdiction, override

  1. L1: Congress, which under Article III ordains the inferior courts, makes exceptions to the appellate jurisdiction, and by custom sets the number of justices; and can impeach (once: Samuel Chase, 1804, acquitted)
  2. L2: Statutes that build and reshape the Court: the Judiciary Act of 1789 (six justices, circuit riding), the size changes of 1801-1869 (nine since 1869), the Circuit Court of Appeals Act (1891), the Certiorari Act (1925), and statutes superseding statutory rulings (Lilly Ledbetter Act, 2009)
  3. L3: The Court's own Rules implement the discretionary jurisdiction (Rule 10 reasons, Rule 13's 90-day window) and are enforced strictly to manage the caseload

way in: Each justice's own leanings (the inner channel of attitudes)

  1. L1: Each justice's career, clerkships and networks; Federalist Society affiliates about 10 percentage points more likely to cast a conservative vote
  2. L2: Leanings measured from votes and from outside: Segal-Cover, Martin-Quinn and Judicial Common Space scores
  3. L3: Stable a priori attitudes toward the law, read as stable justice blocks
  4. L4: Drift over a tenure: on average centrist for the first 15 years, then a slight tendency toward more liberal votes

way in: Oral argument: the advocates heard in the courtroom

  1. L1: Advocates speaking in the courtroom before about 250 public seats, two-week sittings each month from October through April
  2. L2: Thirty minutes a side; the first two minutes uninterrupted since 2019; the justices interrupt with questions
  3. L3: No recording devices in the courtroom; transcripts and the running dialogue are what later studies read (50,389 justice-lawyer exchanges)
  4. L4: What the exchange carries beyond the words: justices ask more questions of the side they doubt; lawyers echo the style of justices they depend on; male advocates heard as less masculine win more often

way in: Original actions: states against states

  1. L1: Disputes between two or more states (boundaries, water rights), and the narrow other classes of Article III original jurisdiction
  2. L2: A complaint filed directly with the Supreme Court; the Court may decline to hear it
  3. L3: A special master appointed by the Court takes evidence and makes recommendations
  4. L4: The special master's recommendations, followed by briefs and oral argument as in an appellate case

way in: Petitions for certiorari and appeals: the disputes of the country

  1. L1: Disputes decided by the federal courts of appeals and by state high courts on federal questions, each arriving with the record the lower courts assembled
  2. L2: The petition for a writ of certiorari, filed with the Clerk within 90 days of the lower decision (about 7,000 a year; 9,000-10,000 in another count); the respondent may file a brief in opposition within 30 days
  3. L3: Law clerks in the cert pool write memos outlining the questions and recommending grant or denial; all justices but Alito and Gorsuch take part
  4. L4: The chief justice's discuss list, petitions relisted or held for the Solicitor General's view, judged against Rule 10's compelling reasons (a circuit split, an egregious departure, an important federal question); a live case or controversy only

way in: Public opinion and legitimacy

  1. L1: The American public's preferences on the issues before the Court; a court without sword or purse must draw its legitimacy from public support
  2. L2: Polls and surveys: approval around 66% in the late 1980s, an average of around 40% between mid-2021 and February 2024; surveys placing the public's views against the Court's rulings
  3. L3: Evaluations filtered by agreement: those who agree with the Court's outputs see it as legal, those who disagree as political; elites may denigrate a Court seen as out of step
  4. L4: Taken in by the Court as concern for its legitimacy and for curbs (term limits, expansion), voiced by the chief justice; or reflected in which cases it chooses to hear

way in: The Court's own past: precedent

  1. L1: The United States Reports: 30,161 opinions from February 1790 to March 2012, published as slip opinions, preliminary prints and bound volumes
  2. L2: Citation: briefs and opinions cite earlier opinions by volume and page
  3. L3: The citation network: citations formed by reciprocity, transitivity and popularity as much as by case features
  4. L4: Stare decisis: 'precedent is the starting point for any good judge' (Gorsuch), though the Court has never set a coherent theory of when to overrule

way in: Written argument: merits briefs, amicus briefs and scholarship

  1. L1: Parties, organised interests and scholars writing for the Court: briefs on the merits, amicus curiae briefs, law review articles
  2. L2: Briefs filed under formal rules that govern every aspect of them; amici with the parties' consent or the Court's leave
  3. L3: Clerks research the case and prepare bench memoranda for their justice
  4. L4: The justice reads the briefs before argument (counsel are told to assume they have); the Court cites amicus briefs and law reviews in its decisions, about one law review article per decision on average

way out: Announcement to the public and the markets

  1. L1: The public, press and markets: 37% of 211 cases with firm-level abnormal returns averaging 4.4%, absorbed over hours and days
  2. L3: Paper copies once carried out by the 'Running of the Interns'; now electronic copies posted as they are announced
  3. L7: Opinions announced from 10 a.m. on opinion days, at least weekly from mid-May to the end of June

way out: Decrees between states

  1. L1: Boundaries, water rights and land settled between states (United States v. Texas; Kansas v. Colorado; New Jersey v. Delaware)
  2. L7: Judgment in an original action between states

way out: Judicial review: laws and acts held unconstitutional

  1. L1: The law voided in whole or part: 176 Acts of Congress; 483 laws in 1960-2019
  2. L6: The constitutional reading that grounds it (the Constitution preferred to the statute: Federalist 78)
  3. L7: A holding that a statute or executive act violates the Constitution (Marbury 1803; Dred Scott 1857 next for a federal statute)

way out: Opinions and judgments

  1. L1: Binding precedent on every lower court; the parties, governments and people the ruling reaches, relying on others to carry it out
  2. L3: Published as a slip opinion on the website, then a preliminary print, then a bound volume of the United States Reports
  3. L5: Drafts circulate among the justices, votes may change until publication; one opinion of the Court since the Marshall Court
  4. L7: The judgment by majority vote; the opinion of the Court (majority: binding; plurality: partly binding; concurrences and dissents: not binding)

way out: Orders: grants, denials and the emergency docket

  1. L1: A denied case ends with the lower ruling final; a granted case is set for briefing and argument
  2. L3: One-sentence orders without explanation on the orders list
  3. L5: Conference votes on petitions and applications

Sources (27) published science

Constitution of the United States (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise, version 1381340946)
Supreme Court of the United States (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01)
Jessee, S., Malhotra, N. & Sen, M. Is the Supreme Court veering rightward? The ebb and flow of representation. PNAS Nexus (2026). doi:10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag060 (behind its links)
Jessee, S., Malhotra, N. & Sen, M. A decade-long longitudinal survey shows that the Supreme Court is now much more conservative than the public. PNAS 119(24): e2120284119 (2022). doi:10.1073/pnas.2120284119 (behind its links)
Schmid, C. S., Chen, T. H. Y. & Desmarais, B. A. Generative dynamics of Supreme Court citations: analysis with a new statistical network model. arXiv:2101.07197 (2021) (behind its links)
The Constitution of the United States: A Transcription (US National Archives) (behind its links)
Procedures of the Supreme Court of the United States (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Katz, D. M., Bommarito, M. J. & Blackman, J. A general approach for predicting the behavior of the Supreme Court of the United States. PLoS ONE 12(4): e0174698 (2017). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0174698 (behind its links)
Judicial review in the United States (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
McMillion, B. J. Supreme Court Nominations, 1789 to 2022: Actions by the Senate, the Judiciary Committee, and the President. CRS Report RL33225 (2022) (behind its links)
Komatsu, T. and Collins, P.M. Jr (2025) The consistency of Federalist Society-affiliated U.S. supreme court justices. PLoS One. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0329692 (behind its links)
Lee, E. D., Broedersz, C. P. & Bialek, W. Statistical mechanics of the US Supreme Court. arXiv:1306.5004 (2013) (behind its links)
Sirovich, L. A pattern analysis of the second Rehnquist U.S. Supreme Court. PNAS 100(13): 7432-7437 (2003). doi:10.1073/pnas.1132164100 (behind its links)
Lee, E. D. Strong consensus on US Supreme Court spans a century. arXiv:1712.09696 (2017) (behind its links)
Guimerà, R. & Sales-Pardo, M. Justice blocks and predictability of U.S. Supreme Court votes. PLoS ONE 6(11): e27188 (2011). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0027188 (behind its links)
Katz, D. M., Bommarito, M. J. & Blackman, J. Crowdsourcing accurately and robustly predicts Supreme Court decisions. arXiv:1712.03846 (2017) (behind its links)
Katz, D. M., Bommarito, M. J., Soellinger, T. & Chen, J. M. Law on the market? Abnormal stock returns and Supreme Court decision-making. arXiv:1508.05751 (2015) (behind its links)
Danescu-Niculescu-Mizil, C., Lee, L., Pang, B. Echoes of power: language effects and power differences in social interaction. WWW 2012; arXiv:1112.3670 (behind its links)
Bulmer, E. (2017). Federalism. 2nd ed. International IDEA Constitution-Building Primer 12. Stockholm: International IDEA. CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 (behind its links)
Alexander Hamilton, The Federalist No. 78 (1788), Avalon Project, Yale Law School (behind its links)
Saks, E. & Borgida, E. How people reason about stare decisis: the role of political ideology. Behavioral Sciences 16(7): 1087 (2026). doi:10.3390/bs16071087 (behind its links)
Herron, F., Carlson, K., Rockmore, D.N. and Livermore, M.A. (2024) Judicial hierarchy and discursive influence. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 382:20230145. doi:10.1098/rsta.2023.0145 (behind its links)
United States Congress (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01, version 1380457534) (behind its links)
Powers of the president of the United States (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Advocacy group (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Gadarian, S. K. & Strother, L. Institutional hybridity and policy-motivated reasoning structure public evaluations of the Supreme Court. PLoS ONE 18(11): e0294525 (2023). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0294525 (behind its links)
Zhou, X. & Müller, H.-G. The dynamics of ideology drift among U.S. Supreme Court justices: a functional data analysis. PLoS ONE 17(7): e0269598 (2022). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0269598 (behind its links)