← all systems · see it in The System
Federalism
Federalism is a mode of government that combines a general (central or federal) level of government with a regional level of sub-unit governments (states, provinces, cantons, Länder, territories), dividing the powers of governing between the two levels; in a federation the right of the component units to self-government is constitutionally entrenched and cannot be altered unilaterally by either level. It sits on a spectrum between the confederation (a centre created by and subordinate to its member states) and the unitary state (regions subordinate to the centre, even after devolution). Political science describes it as 'partial self-government with partial shared government' (Elazar), adopted to handle scale and diversity, in 'coming together' forms (independent states uniting) and 'holding together' forms (a unitary state dividing itself). Walked as the thing political science, constitutional law and fiscal economics describe: the two levels, the constitutional allocation between them, the courts and intergovernmental machinery that hold the balance, its forms worldwide, its history from ancient leagues to the federal countries where roughly 40 per cent of the world's population now lives, and the arguments over what it does.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | contested (C-2641): c.1200-1000 BCE (Israelite tribal confederacy, as historians begin it); 280 BC (second Achaean League); mid-14th century (Old Swiss Confederacy); 1787 (the US compound form) |
| born precision | centuries |
| boundary | Inside: the division of governing powers between a central (federal) government and the governments of the constituent units (states, provinces, cantons, Länder, sometimes municipalities, as in Brazil), the constitutional lists and rules that make the division (exclusive, concurrent and residual powers; supremacy; entrenchment and amendment), and the institutions that hold the balance (a supreme or constitutional court as arbiter, a second chamber representing the units, intergovernmental councils, fiscal transfers). Outside: the state as a whole acting among other states (federalism organises it, it is not the state), the society and its peoples, the markets and the economy taxed, the parties and electorate (they run through both levels), and ideas about it (they arrive as an inner channel). |
| nested level | A mode of organising a state (or a supranational union such as the EU, contested): built from two levels of government, a constitution that allocates powers, courts and second chambers; embedded in a state, which it organises from within; runs on citizens who are members of two governments at once. |
| scale | social |
Measures (16) published science
| share of world population in countries described as federal | roughly 40 percent |
| Mexican Supreme Court federalism judgments in the dataset (1995-2022) | 688 judgments |
| challenged provisions in those judgments | 6014 (8.74 per judgment) provisions |
| overall unconstitutionality rate (Mexico) | 12.34 percent of challenged provisions |
| unconstitutionality rate, downward suits by the federal government (Mexico) | 58.5 percent |
| unconstitutionality rate, downward suits by states (Mexico) | 37.7 percent |
| unconstitutionality rate, upward suits by states (Mexico) | 16.67 percent |
| unconstitutionality rate, upward suits by municipalities (Mexico) | 8.38 percent |
| favourable ratings by level, US 2018 (Pew, via Rendleman & Rogowski) | local about two-thirds; state 58; federal 35 percent of Americans |
| preference for devolution by domain (US survey, >2000 adults) | roads and infrastructure 74; economic affairs 46; environment 39; foreign affairs and defence 20 percent of respondents |
| support for a state's right to secede (US survey) | 45 support, 55 oppose percent |
| Nepal's levels of government after 2015 | 1 federal, 7 provinces, 753 local governments |
| Old Swiss Confederacy span (Federal Charter to French invasion) | 1291-1798 (about 507 years) |
| US dual federalism's stable period | over a century (Taney court to the Great Depression) years |
| octopus nervous system split (cross-domain donor) | 180 million central; over 40 million per arm; ~32,000 efferent and ~140,000 afferent fibres neurons / axons |
| federated learning communication saving (cross-domain donor) | 10-100x fewer rounds factor |
Open contentions (5) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1885 What caused the American Civil War?
booked: The map books slavery and its expansion as the central cause, as historians now overwhelmingly agree, and keeps the other readings listed.
the other reading: see research/CONTENTIONS.md C-1885 - C-2636 Do top courts shift power to the central government?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: apex courts are centralisers; courts are neutral umpires; the drift comes from crises and amendments; holding-together federations show a reverse trend (regions taking powers) - C-2639 Is the European Union a federation?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a federation (supra-national); a confederation or an international organisation - C-2640 Does federalism make government work better or worse?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: federalism improves representation and policy; federalism blurs accountability and lets units leapfrog or race to the bottom - C-2641 Which was the first federal system?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: ancient leagues are federalism; ancient leagues were 'more like today's intergovernmental organizations' (IDEA); federalism proper begins in 1787; Swiss mid-14th century as first modern
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Constitution
- Federal (central) government
- Constituent unit (state, province, canton, Land)
- Second chamber representing the units
- Fiscal arrangements (fiscal federalism)
- The centre and the units competing for authority
- South Carolina against the federal government over the tariffs (1832-1833)
Sits inside / holds (2)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
Trades with (valence) (18)
- Political party via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- Election via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- Government via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- Money via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- Market and trade via sys:human-society · Federalism mixed
- Democracy via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- American Civil War via sys:human-society · Federalism loss
- Constitution of the United States via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- United States Congress via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- Supreme Court of the United States via sys:human-society · Federalism mixed
- Constitution via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
- European Union via sys:human-society · Federalism even
- Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies) via sys:human-society · Federalism even
- COVID-19 pandemic via sys:human-society · Federalism mixed
- Separation of powers via sys:human-society · Federalism gain
expressed by (17)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Risk-managed Exploration
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Proactive Defense
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
- Positional Identity (Body Map)
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (13)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Government
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Political party
- Democracy
- Constitution of the United States
- United States Congress
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Constitution
- Constituent unit (state, province, canton, Land)
- Fiscal arrangements (fiscal federalism)
- Subsidiarity
represents (1)
Kinds (9)
- Dual (layer-cake) federalism
- Cooperative (marble-cake) federalism
- Asymmetric federalism
- Symmetric federalism
- Coming-together (integrative, aggregative) federalism
- Holding-together (devolutive) federalism
- Market-preserving federalism
- Anarchist (council) federalism
- New Federalism (US)
Notes published science
- In Mexico's Supreme Court, when the federal government sues a state or city over a law, 58.5% of the challenged provisions are struck down; when a city sues upward, only 8.38% are. Whether courts are quietly centralising federations is the open question the dataset was built to test. (src:rivera-leon-2024-mexico)
- The same constitutional clause runs in opposite directions: in the US and Germany anything not handed to the centre stays with the states, while in Canada anything not handed to the provinces belongs to the federation. (src:wp:federalism, src:bulmer-2017-idea-federalism)
- An octopus runs a federal body: a central brain of 180 million neurons talks to arms of over 40 million neurons each through only about 32,000 outgoing fibres, and where an arm starts moving is settled between global commands and local sensing. Federated learning in phones does the same job in silicon: data stays home, only updates travel. (src:zullo-2019-octopus-arm, src:mcmahan-2017-federated-learning)
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
federalism: a territory's peoples to self-rule plus shared rule (reader's view)
- L1: The territory and its peoples: scale and diversity; roughly 40% of the world's population lives in countries described as federal
- L2: The doors: the units' own governments and constitutions; elections at each level
- L3: The allocation: exclusive, concurrent and residual powers; supremacy; reserved powers (US Tenth Amendment)
- L4: Umpires and representatives: the supreme or constitutional court; the second chamber representing the units
- L5: Intergovernmental machinery: transfers, framework laws, councils, statewide parties; layer cake or marble cake
- L6: The federal bargain: partial self-government with partial shared government, entrenched; divided sovereignty; subsidiarity
- L7: The federal balance acting: one sovereign outward (defence, foreign policy), policy varying inward, the union held together or broken
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The intergovernmental machinery: two levels of government meeting through fiscal transfers, framework laws, intergovernmental councils, second chambers, statewide parties and court rulings; layer cake (separate spheres) or marble cake (overlapping duties)
- L6: The federal bargain: partial self-government with partial shared government, entrenched so neither level can change it alone; sovereignty divided ('distinct and independent portions of the supremacy'); subsidiarity; a double security for rights
- L7: The federal balance in action: one sovereign state outward (defence, foreign policy), many governments inward, policy varying across the units, the union held together, renegotiated or coming apart
way in: Constituent units: the states', provinces' and cantons' own governments, laws and claims
- L1: The constituent units: states, provinces, cantons, Länder, territories, in Brazil also municipalities
- L2: Their own constitutions and legislation, amendable by them; federal constitution prevails in conflict
- L3: Claims pressed against the centre: a unit declares a federal law void (South Carolina 1832) or challenges it in court (upward litigation)
- L4: Port: the second chamber where units are represented (Senate of two per state; Bundesrat of state governments)
way in: Crises and unforeseen circumstances: depressions, pandemics, wars
- L1: A crisis: the Great Depression; the COVID-19 pandemic as public-health crisis and recession
- L2: Expectations split by level: states on public health, the centre on counter-cyclical aid
- L4: Port: new central powers, by amendment or by courts broadening interpretation
way in: Disputes between levels brought to the courts
- L1: Conflicting laws where powers overlap; a supremacy rule is needed for concurrent powers
- L2: Constitutional controversies filed (Mexico: 688 judgments, 1995-2022)
- L3: The provisions challenged, judged one by one (6,014; 12.34% struck overall)
- L4: Port: the supreme or constitutional court at the apex (supermajority rule in Mexico)
way in: Ideas and attitudes about where power should sit (inner channel)
- L1: Theories: Althusius and Montesquieu; Kant's nation of devils; subsidiarity (Aquinas, Taparelli); anarchist federalism
- L2: Citizens' evaluations of levels: local two-thirds favourable, state 58%, federal 35% (US, 2018)
- L3: Structured by ideology and evaluations of performance more than by short-term interests
- L4: Port: ideational theories of adoption (commitment to decentralist ideas); best practices exchanged among federations
way in: Outside states: common enemies and the international system
- L1: Common enemies or existential challenges facing small states
- L2: A league or union bound by treaty (foedus); Hellenistic cities surrendering part of their sovereignty
- L4: Port: foreign policy and defence as exclusive federal powers
way in: People and capital moving between units
- L1: Mobile residents and capital; units smaller than the area of free trade and capital movement
- L2: Voting with one's feet: moving to another jurisdiction
- L4: Port: competitive pressure on local public goods (Tiebout), or a race to the bottom
way in: Revenue: tax bases, revenue sharing and transfers
- L1: Tax bases: whether units have their own tax base and revenue-raising powers
- L2: Revenue sharing: by origin, or by population and assessed need (equalising)
- L3: Budget rules: most US states bound by balanced-budget requirements
- L4: Port: fiscal transfers and the vertical gap; without sharing, inequality between units grows
way in: Territorially concentrated peoples: language, ethnicity, religion, region
- L1: Communities of distinct identity, territorially concentrated
- L2: Demands to be recognised as a people with a distinct identity and interests
- L3: Boundaries of units drawn (nationality, ethnicity, language, religion among the factors weighed)
- L4: Port: asymmetric powers (Bavaria's international role, 1871; Spain's historical communities)
way in: Two electorates: citizens voting for both levels
- L1: Citizens: the people, whose surrendered power is divided between two governments; a more informed and involved public in one line of the literature
- L2: Elections at each level (Nepal's 2017 local elections, the first in two decades)
- L3: Assigning blame and credit to the right level: costly, and often missed
- L4: Port: representation at two levels at once (a chamber by population, a chamber by unit)
way out: Policy that varies from unit to unit
- L1: Residents live under different rules; risks diversified across the territory
- L5: Unit legislatures enact differing laws (abortion law after Dobbs; pandemic measures)
- L7: Letting units choose: a single state as a laboratory; variety fitted to voters' ideals
way out: Restructuring the federation: federalising, redrawing units, or breaking apart
- L1: A new map of units (Nepal: seven provinces, 753 local governments); or secession and civil war where differences are not mediated
- L6: A constitution redrawn (Nepal 2015: unitary to federal)
- L7: Federalising: coming together or holding together
way out: Rulings that redraw the line between levels
- L1: The laws in force change at the level that lost
- L4: Provisions struck: 58.5% when the centre sues downward, 8.38% when municipalities sue upward (Mexico)
- L5: A ruling hands an issue back to the units (Dobbs) or keeps it at the centre
way out: The common front: defence, foreign policy and the common market
- L1: Goods and factors move across unit borders; other states meet one sovereign
- L5: The centre polices the common market and the mobility of goods and factors
- L7: Foreign policy and national defence held by the centre; force against a defiant unit (Force Bill, 1833)
way out: Transfers down: grants, equalisation and counter-cyclical aid
- L1: Units' budgets and services: local bodies managing drug procurement and logistics (Nepal)
- L4: Counter-cyclical aid and automatic stabilisers run through the states (Unemployment Insurance, Medicaid, SNAP)
- L5: Grants: conditional (with the centre's spending instructions) or unconditional (equalisation)