← all systems · see it in The System
American Civil War
The civil war of 1861-1865 in the United States between the Union (the US government and the states loyal to it) and the Confederate States of America, formed by Southern slave states that seceded to preserve slavery after Lincoln's 1860 election. Walked as historians describe it: its causes (slavery and its expansion at the centre; other readings kept as contested), the war as a competition for the state itself, its campaigns and theatres, its human and economic toll, and emancipation. Dates, death toll, causes, the Union's motives and the war's name are contested and kept so.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | April 12, 1861 (secession from December 20, 1860) |
| born precision | day |
| boundary | Inside: the contest from the secession crisis (December 1860) to the last surrenders (1865) and the legal end (August 1866): the two governments and their armies and navies, the mobilisation of men, money and industry, the campaigns in five theatres, the blockade and the diplomacy around it, the enslaved people's flight and emancipation as a war measure, the dead and wounded. Outside: slavery as an institution (its own walk), the decades of sectional politics that led to the war (booked as the war's incoming channels and its causes contention), and Reconstruction (the sibling walk), which the war hands on to. |
| end precision | day (contested which day) |
| ended at | May 26, 1865 (often cited); legal end August 20, 1866 |
| nested level | Built from people (soldiers, civilians, the enslaved), two governments, armies and navies, railroads, rivers and ports; one of the United States' periods (Civil War and Reconstruction) and one of the world's civil wars; a war of the industrial age. |
| scale | social |
Measures (40) published science
| Duration of the war | April 12, 1861 to May 26, 1865 (often-cited end; Appomattox April 9); legal end August 20, 1866 dates |
| Characteristic clock: a campaign season / siege | Petersburg trench warfare over nine months; Port Hudson nearly eight weeks |
| Election-to-inauguration wait | four months (November 1860 to March 4, 1861) |
| Proclamation to Texas (Juneteenth) | January 1, 1863 to June 19, 1865: about 2.5 years (our arithmetic on sourced dates) |
| Surrender news latency | Lee's April 9, 1865 surrender reached Savannah on April 15 (6 days) |
| War deaths | about 698,000 (bounds 647,439 to 748,561; full-count census) deaths |
| War deaths: earlier estimates | 618,222 (de facto official for over a century); about 751,562 (1% sample, Hacker 2011, via Barcelo); Walker 1870: at least 850,000; over 1 million counting enslaved deaths (Downs) |
| Excess mortality, Confederacy vs Union | 13.1% of military-age native-born white males in the Old South against 4.9% in the Old North; 20-33% of those aged 15-34 in most Confederate states percent |
| Casualties | at least 1,030,000 (3 percent of the population); two-thirds of deaths by disease; 60,000 lost limbs people |
| Forces | Union 2,200,000 served (698,000 at peak); Confederacy 750,000-1,000,000 (360,000 at peak) soldiers |
| Population 1860 | Union states 22,100,000 (71%); Confederacy 9,100,000 (29%), of whom 3,550,000 enslaved people |
| Railroad miles 1860 | Union 21,800 (71%); Confederacy 8,800 (29%) miles |
| Enslaved share of population | 47 percent in the Confederate states; 24 percent in the upper South |
| Union draft yield | 168,649 procured; 117,986 substitutes; 50,663 conscripted (0.30 of those procured served as conscripts: our arithmetic) men |
| Desertion | North about 280,000 (plus 120,000 evaded the draft); South at least 100,000, about 10 percent men |
| Prisoner-of-war deaths | about 56,000 of 409,000 after the exchange system collapsed (10 percent of fatalities) deaths |
| USCT | about 190,000 volunteered soldiers |
| USCT mortality | 21 percent of US Colored Troops died, against 15 percent of US Volunteers and 9 percent of white Regular Army troops |
| Disease to combat deaths (Union) | 2:1; disease mortality varied tenfold by state; R2 = 0.58 with farming share ratio |
| Malaria mortality, Union soldiers | 16/1,000/year Black against 5/1,000/year White (reported) per 1,000 per year |
| Union navy 1865 | 6,000 officers, 45,000 sailors, 671 vessels, 510,396 tons |
| Confederate navy | over 130 vessels built or converted, including 26 ironclads |
| Blockade effectiveness | 95 percent effective at stopping trade goods |
| Cotton exported through the blockade | less than 10% of the crop percent |
| Arms smuggled | 600,000 (and 400,000 rifles among Wise's lifeline supplies) arms |
| Alabama claims | US$15 million paid by Britain in 1871 dollars |
| Named battles | 237 in four years battles |
| Gettysburg casualties | over 50,000 (Lee 28,000; Meade 23,000) casualties |
| Value placed on enslaved people, 1860 | $2.8 billion (Yancey, October 1860) dollars (1860) |
| Southern income per person relative to the North | less than 40 percent, into the 20th century |
| People freed at once by the Proclamation | about 20,000 (contraband population of Union-occupied North Carolina and the Sea Islands); 3.5 million covered in law people |
| Contraband camps | more than 250 by war's end; about 3,500 people at Roanoke Island camps |
| West Point peer effect on allegiance | +5.4 percentage points (15% of the mean) per one-SD rise in Free-State peers (about 5 of 40) |
| Sons' mortality, worst-period ex-POW fathers | hazard 1.11 against sons of non-POWs; 1.09 against sons of better-period ex-POWs; 1.2 for sons born in the second quarter; none for daughters hazard ratio |
| Veteran health after the war | enlisting at 18 or younger: mortality HR 1.52 against over 30; 17,700 veterans' records matched hazard ratio |
| Equines killed | over 32,600 Union and 45,800 Confederate (other estimates up to 1,000,000) animals |
| Battlefield park visitors | 3 million in 2018, down 70% from 10 million in 1970 (five major NPS parks) visitors per year |
| USCT recruits' heights | 8,592 recruits; heights declining from the 1820s birth cohorts |
| Legacy: mortality gap per 10% enslaved share in 1860 | about 22 additional Black deaths per 100,000 relative to White Americans (2010-2020) |
| Survival per hand-off, recruit to soldier to survivor (derived) | draft: 0.30 of procured men served as conscripts; Union army: 359,528 dead of over two million served (about 0.85 survival); prisoners after 1863: about 0.86 (1 - 56,000/409,000); our arithmetic on sourced numbers fraction |
Open contentions (9) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1884 How much did the Union blockade hurt the Confederacy?
booked: The map books it as a major factor and keeps the blockade runners' lifeline beside it.
the other reading: blockade runners gave a lifeline that kept Lee fighting additional months (Wise); 600,000 smuggled arms enabled two more years of fighting - C-1885 What caused the American Civil War?
booked: The map books slavery and its expansion as the central cause, as historians now overwhelmingly agree, and keeps the other readings listed.
the other reading: Lost Cause: slavery not the principal cause, secession lawful (called pseudo-historical and disproven by the secession documents in the sources); 'Needless war' (Buchanan) and the revisionists' 'blundering generation' (Randall, Craven); economic conflict between sections (Beard; rejected by most historians after 1950); elite overproduction and popular immiseration (Turchin); the union 'died of democracy' (Donald); the Union's own reasons: historians 'disagree' (nationalism, the republic's survival, anti-slavery) - C-1886 How many people died in the American Civil War?
booked: The map books about 698,000 from a full census count, and keeps the older and higher estimates beside it.
the other reading: 618,222 (the long-official count, from Union mortality rates applied to a rough Confederate total); about 750,000 (Hacker 2011, 1% sample; booked by the united-states walk); at least 850,000 (Walker, 1870 census); over 1 million if enslaved people's wartime deaths are counted (Downs) - C-1887 When did the American Civil War end?
booked: The map books the often-cited dates and keeps Appomattox, the last surrenders and the legal end beside them.
the other reading: April 9, 1865 (Appomattox); June 23, 1865 (Stand Watie, last general); November 6, 1865 (CSS Shenandoah); August 20, 1866 (legal end) - C-1888 What should the war be called?
booked: The map uses 'American Civil War' and lists the other names in use.
the other reading: War of the Rebellion (Northern usage); War for Southern Independence (Confederate usage); War of Northern Aggression (some Southerners) - C-1889 Could the Confederacy have won?
booked: The map books the common reading that its victory was possible but Northern victory likely, with the other readings listed.
the other reading: the North 'fought that war with one hand behind its back' (Foote); the Confederacy lacked will (Coulter; rejected by most historians) - C-1890 Did fathers' prison-camp suffering shorten their sons' lives?
booked: The map books the finding and keeps both the epigenetic and the social explanations open.
the other reading: psychological or cultural transmission, which the authors 'cannot rule out fully' - C-1891 Did the planter elite keep its power after the war?
booked: The map books the prevailing view that it did, with a study finding more mobility beside it.
the other reading: greater economic mobility in the South than in the North after the turmoil (a 2017 study) - C-1892 Who freed the enslaved: the Union or the enslaved themselves?
booked: The map books both: law and armies, and people who freed themselves by flight.
the other reading: slavery ended where Union armies arrived (encyclopedia); self-emancipation by flight (contraband article); the Proclamation freed no one (Bennett; called inaccurate in the sources: about 20,000 freed at once)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Confederate States of America (1861-1865)
- The Union (the US government and the loyal states, including the border slave states)
- Union Army
- Confederate States Army
- Union navy
- United States Colored Troops
- Railroads
- The electrical telegraph
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Industrial Revolution (the first, c. 1760 to c. 1840)
- United States (the country across time)
- Civil war (the kind)
Trades with (valence) (17)
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human · American Civil War gain
- United States (the country across time) via sys:united-states · American Civil War mixed
- Native peoples of North America (Indigenous peoples of North America, across time) via sys:indigenous-peoples-of-north-america · American Civil War gain
- Confederate States of America (1861-1865) via sys:confederate-states-of-america · American Civil War gain
- Constitution of the United States via sys:united-states-constitution · American Civil War gain
- Slavery (cotton plantations of the US, Brazil and the West Indies) via sys:slavery · American Civil War mixed
- Cotton (raw fibre in trade) via sys:cotton · American Civil War loss
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945) via sys:world-war · American Civil War even
- Civil rights movement (United States) via sys:civil-rights-movement · American Civil War even
- Atlantic slave trade via sys:atlantic-slave-trade · American Civil War even
- United Kingdom via sys:united-kingdom · American Civil War mixed
- Reconstruction era · American Civil War even
- Railroads via sys:railroad · American Civil War gain
- Infectious disease via sys:infectious-disease · American Civil War loss
- Union Army disability pension via sys:union-army-pension · American Civil War even
- President of the United States · American Civil War mixed
- Federalism via sys:human-society · American Civil War mixed
expressed by (22)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Mapping/Modeling
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Overcome Barrier
- Encirclement
- Speed
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Battlespace Shaping
- Leverage Host/Amplification
- Divide & Isolate
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
floor filled by (25)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Ocean
- River
- Landscape (neighbouring ecosystems)
- United States (the country across time)
- Confederate States of America (1861-1865)
- Slavery (cotton plantations of the US, Brazil and the West Indies)
- Abolitionism (African, Black, European and American)
- The Union (the US government and the loyal states, including the border slave states)
- Union Army
- Confederate States Army
- Union navy
- United States Colored Troops
- Railroads
- The electrical telegraph
- Conscription
- Battle
- Siege
- Guerrilla warfare
- American nationalism
- Abraham Lincoln
- Jefferson Davis
- Ulysses S. Grant
- Robert E. Lee
- Reconstruction era
Kinds (1)
Notes published science
- Counting every census return instead of a 1% sample moved the Civil War's toll to about 698,000 deaths, and showed how lopsided it was: in most Confederate states 20 to 33% of white men aged 15 to 34 in 1860 died in the war, against under 10% in most Northern states (src:barcelo-2024-mortality).
- Friends changed sides in the war: at West Point, about five more Northern classmates in a class of forty raised a Southern cadet's chance of joining the Union by 5.4 percentage points, but the pull vanished for cadets from heavily slaveholding places or who owned slaves themselves (src:guo-2026-west-point).
- A prison camp reached into the next generation: sons born after the war to men held in the worst Confederate camps were 1.11 times more likely to die after 45 than sons of other veterans, with no effect on daughters, and none at all for sons whose mothers were well fed while pregnant (src:costa-2018-ex-pows).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the American Civil War as historians describe it: the divided country, its people and resources, to the decisions that began, ran and ended the war (reader's view; periods in `periods`)
- L1: The divided country it worked on: 31 million people (22.1 million in the Union states, 9.1 million in the Confederacy, 4 million enslaved), its land, rivers and coasts
- L2: Mobilisation: volunteers, drafts, the enslaved who fled and enlisted, money and materiel
- L3: Movement: railroads, rivers, sea lanes and the telegraph; the blockade line
- L4: Engagement: battles, campaigns and sieges in the theatres (eastern, western, trans-Mississippi, lower seaboard, Pacific)
- L5: Organisation: the two governments, their armies and navies, their war economies and finance
- L6: Meaning: what the war was for (slavery and its expansion, Union, independence, emancipation) and the will to fight on
- L7: Decisions: secession, war, blockade, emancipation, persistence, surrender
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The two governments: Lincoln's administration and Congress, Davis's government and the Confederate Congress, with their treasuries (income tax, legal tender, bonds) and diplomats
- L5: The armies and navies and their high commands: from a tiny frontier force to the largest and most efficient armies in the world; Grant in command of all Union armies from 1864
- L6: What the war was for: slavery and its expansion, the Union, independence, emancipation as a war goal; the will to keep fighting
- L7: The decisions: to secede, to hold the forts, to fire, to blockade, to emancipate, to fight on, to surrender
way in: Cotton and the trade it bought (arms through the blockade)
- L1: The cotton crop grown by enslaved labour (4.5 million bales in 1860), pushed west by soil exhaustion
- L2: Exports, the self-imposed embargo of 1861, and high-priced cotton for arms
- L3: Blockade runners through Bermuda, Cuba and the Bahamas
- L4: British financiers and arms makers (S. Isaac, Campbell & Company; the London Armoury Company): 600,000 arms smuggled
way in: Disease: the invisible front
- L1: Pathogens and the Southern disease environment (malaria; feared yellow fever)
- L2: Infection of recruits: rural and isolated men had little immunity
- L3: Spread through 2,000 regiments; disease killed twice as many Union soldiers as combat
- L4: The medical departments: quinine by the ton, vaccination campaigns (Confederate ones failing)
way in: Fear and fervour (inner channel: emotion)
- L1: Events that frightened or roused: the memory of Haiti, John Brown's raid, Fort Sumter
- L2: Feeling: fear of abolition in the South, patriotic fire in the North, Watch Night hope among African Americans
- L3: Sustained loyalty and morale (soldiers' letters); cohesion in companies
way in: Ground and water: mountains, rivers, coasts
- L1: The ground: the Appalachians dividing eastern and western theatres; the Mississippi and its tributaries; the Atlantic and Gulf coasts
- L2: Rivers as roads into the Confederate heartland (Tennessee, Cumberland, Mississippi)
- L3: Theatres and marches shaped by the ground (Jackson's interior lines in the Valley)
- L4: Campaign plans written for the ground (the Anaconda Plan; four axes of 1862)
way in: Ideas and arguments (inner channel: thought)
- L1: Print and pulpit: books, sermons, newspapers, speeches
- L2: Arguments: free labour against the 'positive good' of slavery; homestead laws feared more than tariffs
- L3: Movements and strategies: containment of slavery; states' rights claimed both ways
way in: Industry, farms and railroads
- L1: Factories, mines and farms: 90% of manufactures in the Union states in 1860
- L2: Arms and ships produced: 97% of arms production in the North; many copies of the Monitor
- L3: Railroads, steamships and the telegraph carrying men and supplies
- L4: Supply bases and depots feeding the armies (Sherman's base at Atlanta)
way in: News from the field (reports, telegraph, press)
- L1: Battlefield events: 237 named battles and many smaller actions
- L2: Reports and reconnaissance (including balloons, the first aerial warfare)
- L3: Telegraph and trains carrying messages faster than horses
way in: Other states: diplomacy and foreign opinion
- L1: The powers: Britain and France courted by both sides; Russia for the Union
- L2: Their needs and opinions: grain ('King Corn'), cotton surplus, anti-slavery feeling
- L3: Legations and public diplomacy (Adams in London; Schurz; the press)
- L4: Decisions on recognition, mediation and war (the Trent Affair; Palmerston)
way in: Recruits: the men who fought
- L1: Men of military age: 22.1 million people in the Union states and 9.1 million in the Confederacy (1860); immigrants; divided border states
- L2: Volunteering: enthusiasm, peers and loyalties (West Point cadets swayed by their classmates)
- L3: State quotas, regiments and the drafts (substitutes and commutation in the North; exemptions in the South)
- L4: Muster into the armies; rank and fate inside them
way in: The ballot: votes and secession conventions
- L1: The electorate, sectionally divided: the free states outgrowing the slave states in voters
- L2: Ballots: the 1860 election (Lincoln not on the ballot in ten Southern states) and the wartime elections
- L3: Parties: Republicans, the split Democrats, War Democrats and Copperheads
- L4: Results and conventions: the Electoral College count; state secession conventions and ordinances
way in: The enslaved: flight, labour and enlistment
- L1: Four million enslaved people, 47% of the Confederate states' population
- L2: Flight to Union lines; following the armies
- L3: Contraband status and the camps (Fort Monroe Doctrine, May-August 1861; more than 250 camps)
- L4: Enlistment in the United States Colored Troops (about 190,000) and paid labour for the army
way out: Combat: armed force on soldiers and land
- L1: The dead and the families: fatherless children with worse labour outcomes; sons of the worst-treated prisoners dying sooner
- L2: Wounds, disease and death: two-thirds of deaths by disease; 60,000 lost limbs
- L3: Trench warfare where open fighting failed
- L4: Battles and sieges: Antietam, Gettysburg, Vicksburg, Petersburg
- L5: Armies in the field
- L6: Battle doctrine: Napoleonic charges against rifled weapons
- L7: The strategy: strike the whole Confederacy at once (Grant, 1864)
way out: Emancipation
- L1: Four million freed; wealth held in people wiped off the books
- L2: Legal status changed; General Order No. 3 in Texas, June 19, 1865
- L3: Carried by the armies: slavery ended where Union armies arrived
- L4: Exclusions: border states and occupied regions not covered
- L5: Laws before it: the Confiscation Acts; compensated emancipation in D.C.
- L6: 'A fit and necessary war measure', limited to rebel-held territory
- L7: The Proclamation: abolition becomes a Union war goal
way out: Hard war on the economic base
- L1: About 20% of Georgia's farms laid waste; the South poor for a century
- L6: Total war not in killing civilians but in injuring capacity
- L7: Destroy the capacity to supply the war
way out: Memory: cemeteries, monuments, names, myths
- L1: Monuments on the ground: the Hazen Brigade Monument (1863), battlefield parks
- L3: National cemeteries founded during the war
- L5: Veterans in office: five presidents
- L6: A central event in American collective memory; the Lost Cause
way out: Surrender and the end of the war
- L3: The last surrender, CSS Shenandoah at Liverpool, November 6, 1865
- L5: The legal end, declared August 20, 1866
- L7: Lee surrenders at Appomattox; a chain of surrenders follows
way out: The blockade
- L1: The Southern economy ruined (with a lifeline of runners)
- L2: The thousands of ships that never tried
- L3: Insurance withdrawn; regular traffic ended
- L5: The Union navy: 671 vessels by 1865
- L6: The Anaconda Plan's idea: suffocate the South
- L7: Blockade of all Southern ports announced (April 1861)
way out: Wartime law and order
- L3: Martial law and suspended habeas corpus in Maryland
- L4: An income tax to finance the war
- L5: Homestead Act, land-grant colleges, transcontinental railroad, National Bank Act, legal tender
- L7: Republicans pass the projects that had been blocked