← all systems · see it in The System
Constitution of the United States
The supreme law of the United States of America, in force since March 4, 1789: a written text (Preamble, seven articles, closing endorsement, 27 appended amendments) that frames the federal government in three separated branches, sets the federal-state relation, binds every officer by oath and every state judge by its supremacy, and is kept and changed through Article V amendment and, as constitutional scholars describe it, through judicial review and the body of constitutional law built on it. Walked as the thing it names: the text and the constitutional order it sets up, as constitutional history, comparative constitutional law and the empirical study of courts describe them.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | drafted May 25 to September 17, 1787; ninth ratification June 21, 1788; operational March 4, 1789 (the US walk's founding-date contention C-765 lists 1789 as one reading of the country's own birth) |
| born precision | day |
| boundary | Inside: the text (Preamble, seven articles, closing endorsement, 27 amendments, original text left untouched and amendments appended), the offices and procedures it creates or names (Congress, President, the Supreme Court and the federal judiciary, Article V amendment, the decennial census, the oath, ratification) and the body of constitutional law that interprets it. Outside: the people and the states it governs and draws its authority from, the ordinary statutes and policies the branches make under it, the political parties it never mentions, other countries and their constitutions. |
| nested level | Part of the United States (its constitutional order, US walk board b-constitution L6); a kind of national constitution (one of 935 written national constitutions 1789-2005 in the Comparative Constitutions data); carried on written records and in the minds of officers and citizens. |
| scale | social |
Measures (30) published science
| In force since | March 4, 1789 date |
| years in force | 222 years (as of the 2011 review) |
| Median lifespan of national constitutions | 19 years |
| Life expectancy, least vs most inclusive constitutions | 14 vs 69 years |
| Life expectancy in democracies vs authoritarian settings | 21 vs 15 years |
| Census period | 10 years |
| Ratification of the Constitution | signed September 17, 1787; ninth state June 21, 1788; government started March 4, 1789 dates |
| Bill of Rights: approval to ratification | September 25, 1789 to December 15, 1791 dates |
| Longest pending (27th Amendment) | over two centuries (no time limit); ratified 1992 years |
| Amendments | 27 count |
| Measures proposed to amend | approximately 11,985 (1789 to January 3, 2025) count |
| Proposals per Congress | around 150 per two-year Congress |
| Amendments sent to the states | 33 (27 ratified, 6 unratified) count |
| Amendment chain yield (derived) | about 0.28% of proposals reach the states (33/11,985); about 82% of those ratified (27/33); about 0.23% end to end fraction |
| Convention attendance | 74 appointed, 55 attended, 39 signed delegates |
| Signers | 39 delegates |
| Ratification thresholds | nine of 13 states (1787); three-fourths of states, now 38 of 50, for amendments |
| Acts of Congress held unconstitutional | 176 (as of 2014) acts |
| Laws held unconstitutional 1960-2019 | 483 laws |
| Congressional statutes voided, Civil War to World War II | 77 cases in eighty years, almost one a year |
| Certiorari grants | a few dozen per year |
| Justice tenure | about a quarter century years |
| Federalist Society affiliation effect | about 10 percentage points more likely to vote conservative (almost 25,000 votes, 1986-2022) |
| Federal citation graph | 760,000 opinions, 8.3 million citations (1790-2024); 88,747 constitutional vs 5,445,978 statutory citations count |
| Similarity of other constitutions to the US | 0.30 (1946), peak 0.31 (1981), 0.26 (2006) average correlation |
| Constitutions providing judicial review | 25% (1946) to 82% (2006) share of constitutions |
| Rights provisions | 26 of 60 provisions of the average bill of rights count |
| Adults naming all three branches | 70% (2025), 65% (2024) share of US adults |
| Trust in the Supreme Court | 68% (2019) to 41% (March 2025) share with at least moderate trust |
| Delegates attending | 55 delegates |
Open contentions (5) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-931 How should the US Constitution be interpreted?
booked: The map records each school of interpretation in its own terms and rules none.
the other reading: originalism (original understandings; more prominent in the US than elsewhere, per Law and Versteeg); interpretation that adapts the text (judicial interpretations better viewed as amendments); natural rights as guaranteed in the Constitution (Warren Court coalition after 1962) - C-947 Did the Haudenosaunee Confederacy influence the US Constitution?
booked: The map keeps the influence as a contested input and rules neither side.
the other reading: Grinde and Johansen: 'overwhelming evidence' of influence; Tooker, Payne, Starna, Hamell, Levy: evidence 'largely coincidental and circumstantial'; Hewitt rejected a major influence on the Albany Plan - C-955 Where does the US courts' power to strike down laws come from?
booked: The map records judicial review as inferred from the Constitution's text and established by precedent, and leaves open whether Marbury v. Madison created it or confirmed it.
the other reading: Marbury (1803) as the assertion of review over Acts of Congress; Treanor: thirty-one earlier state or federal cases struck statutes; Marbury crystallized an accepted doctrine - C-988 What drives US Supreme Court justices' votes?
booked: The map records the finding that individual leanings, case context and interaction among justices act together, and names no single driver.
the other reading: ideology scores (liberal-conservative valence); peer interaction among justices (Lee and Cantwell); organisational affiliation and training (Komatsu and Collins); the law and the case at hand - C-989 Why has the US Constitution lasted so long?
booked: The map notes that it has endured since 1789 against the predictions of design theory, and lists the explanations without ruling.
the other reading: judicial interpretation supplies the flexibility (some interpretations better viewed as amendments: Levinson, per Roznai); amendment culture rather than the formal rule (Ginsburg and Melton, per Contiades and Fotiadou); veneration that time bestows (Madison, Federalist No. 49); an outlier: a woman who lived to 122 on cigarettes and chocolate (Elkins et al.)
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (22) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Election via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
- American Civil War via sys:united-states-constitution · Constitution of the United States gain
- American Revolution via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with) via sys:written-record · Constitution of the United States gain
- Government via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:written-record · Constitution of the United States gain
- Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases) via sys:written-record · Constitution of the United States gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
- Democracy via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States mixed
- United States (the country across time) via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
- Ancient Rome via sys:mental-representation · Constitution of the United States gain
- Supreme Court of the United States via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
- Articles of Confederation (1781-1789) via sys:written-record · Constitution of the United States gain
- National constitution via sys:international-system · Constitution of the United States even
- United States Congress via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
- President of the United States · Constitution of the United States mixed
- Civil rights movement (United States) via sys:law · Constitution of the United States gain
- Reconstruction era · Constitution of the United States gain
- Women's suffrage · Constitution of the United States gain
- Federalism via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
- Separation of powers via sys:human-society · Constitution of the United States gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (10)
- United States (the country across time)
- Bill of Rights (Amendments 1-10)
- United States Congress
- President of the United States
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Article V amendment process
- The decennial census (Article I, Section 2)
- Judicial review (inferred, not written)
- The Constitution replacing the Articles of Confederation
- Federalists against Anti-Federalists over ratification
Sits inside / holds (7)
- Written record (durable external marks: texts, archives, canon)
- Law (rules and law)
- United States (the country across time)
- United States Congress
- President of the United States
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Separation of powers
expressed by (21)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Overcome Barrier
- Battlespace Shaping
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Delay/Redirection Tactics
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (19)
- United States (the country across time)
- American Revolution
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- Government
- Written record (durable external marks: texts, archives, canon)
- Law (rules and law)
- Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases)
- Human brain
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Bill of Rights (Amendments 1-10)
- United States Congress
- Supreme Court of the United States
- The decennial census (Article I, Section 2)
- US state constitutions
- President of the United States
- Reconstruction era
- Federalism
- Separation of powers
Kinds (3)
Notes published science
- The US Constitution 'completely contradicts' the best theory of why constitutions last: it was written by an exclusive elite and is rigid and vague, yet it has outlived the median national constitution (19 years) many times over; its students compare it to a woman who lived to 122 on cigarettes, chocolates, olive oil and port wine (src:roznai-2011).
- Its most copied idea is not in it: judicial review appears nowhere in the text, yet the share of the world's constitutions that write it in rose from 25% in 1946 to 82% in 2006, while the rest of the US text drifted out of the mainstream (src:law-versteeg-2012).
- Of about 11,985 proposals to amend it since 1789, 33 reached the states and 27 made it; one of them waited more than two centuries, proposed in 1789 and ratified in 1992 (src:senate-amendment-measures, src:wp:constitution-of-the-united-states).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the US Constitution: the people to the frame's purposes (reader's view)
- L1: The people of the United States and the states: the governed, who are also its authors ('We the People'); 50 states and their citizens
- L2: The doors: ratifying conventions, Article V proposals, cases and controversies, the decennial census, elections, treaties
- L3: The text: Preamble, seven articles, closing endorsement with 39 signatures, 27 amendments appended; handwritten on five pages of parchment
- L4: Interpretation: judicial review and constitutional construction (McCulloch, incorporation, justiciability), read by courts, branches and scholars
- L5: The frame: Congress, President, the federal judiciary and the states, with separation of powers, checks and balances and federalism
- L6: The constitutional order: supreme law of the land, rights (Bill of Rights, Reconstruction amendments), limited enumerated powers, the body of constitutional law
- L7: Purpose and action: 'We the People ... do ordain and establish': constituting and limiting government for the Preamble's six ends; a model for other constitutions
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The frame: Congress (Article I), the President (Article II), the federal courts (Article III) and the states (Article IV), separated and checking one another
- L6: The constitutional order: the supreme law of the land with its rights and limits, interpreted, supplemented and implemented by a large body of constitutional law
- L7: 'We the People': the people as the source of legitimacy, ordaining the frame for six stated ends
way in: Amendment (Article V: demands for change)
- L1: Grievances and movements wanting the frame changed (rights in 1788; abolition; suffrage; temperance)
- L2: Proposals introduced in Congress: about 150 per two-year Congress; about 11,985 from 1789 to January 2025
- L3: Screening: committees, then two-thirds of both Houses (or a convention called by two-thirds of the states, never yet used)
- L4: Ratification by three-fourths of the states (38 of 50), verified by the Office of the Federal Register and certified by the Archivist
- L5: Appended to the text: original text and prior amendments left untouched
way in: Cases and controversies (the courts)
- L1: Disputes arising under the Constitution, federal laws and treaties
- L2: Standing: actual cases and controversies only, with adverse parties; no advisory opinions
- L3: Certiorari: the Supreme Court chooses a few dozen petitions a year; its influence on legal language comes mostly through this selection
- L4: Nine justices decide by majority; their votes show individual bias and peer interaction
way in: Elections (the people choosing officers)
- L1: Voters in the states; who could vote was left to the states and widened by amendment
- L2: Elections held under state law: times, places and manner set by each legislature, alterable by Congress
- L3: Representatives every second year; senators by legislatures, then (1913) by direct popular vote
- L4: The officers chosen take their seats and oaths
way in: Founding ideas (law, philosophy and other republics)
- L1: Magna Carta and English common law; Locke, Montesquieu, Hume, Blackstone; ancient and modern republics; possibly the Haudenosaunee Confederacy (contested)
- L2: Read and cited by the framers; state declarations of rights already written
- L3: Compared and argued: models from ancient history, European constitutions found unsuitable; the Federalist Papers
- L4: The Convention's rival plans (Virginia and New Jersey) and committees (Detail, Style)
way in: Interpretive theories (the inner channel: how the text is read)
- L1: Judicial philosophies: originalism, natural-rights readings, interpretation that works like amendment (contested, none ruled)
- L2: Carried by legal organisations, training and networks
- L3: Selection of justices: nominated by the President, confirmed by the Senate
- L4: Justices' votes: affiliation shifts votes; biases recovered after interaction differ from ideological scores
- L5: Doctrine built over time: precedents; some judicial interpretations work as amendments
way in: Public attachment and trust (the inner channel: emotion)
- L1: What the public knows and feels: 70% name the three branches; trust in the Court fell from 68% to 41% (2019-2025)
- L2: Symbols and rites: the documents displayed and revered as a civil religion
- L3: Veneration built by time (Madison), against Jefferson's rewrite-every-generation
- L4: Political life reinforcing (or not) the Court's rulings
- L5: Legitimacy for the branches: decrees must be enforceable
way in: The branches' own practice (political construction)
- L1: Political life the text is silent on: parties, executive privilege, foreign affairs
- L2: Presidents and Congresses act on their reading of their powers ('important political powers')
- L3: The political question doctrine leaves such questions to the political branches
- L4: Foreign affairs held political, left to the political departments
way in: The census (the actual Enumeration)
- L1: The people living in the states, counted by their respective Numbers
- L2: The enumeration every ten years, in the manner Congress directs by law
- L3: The count weighted: three-fifths of enslaved persons until the Fourteenth Amendment superseded the rule
- L4: Read into seats in the House and into direct taxes
way in: Treaties (other states)
- L1: Other states and international agreements
- L2: The President negotiates and makes treaties
- L3: Two-thirds of senators present must concur
- L4: Treaties made under the authority of the United States become supreme law
way out: Apportionment (seats and taxes by the count)
- L1: States' weight in Congress and the Electoral College set until the next count
- L3: Each state equal in the Senate; House seats by population (the Great Compromise)
- L5: Representatives apportioned among the states by their numbers
way out: Limits and rights (laws voided, government restrained)
- L1: Statutes voided, state laws struck, government acts restrained
- L4: Courts refuse to enforce conflicting laws; rights applied to the states by incorporation
- L6: Rights and limits held as supreme law (Bill of Rights; Reconstruction amendments)
way out: Model abroad (other constitutions borrowing)
- L1: Other constitutions' texts, now moving away from the US model
- L3: Borrowed institutions: judicial review, from 25% of constitutions (1946) to 82% (2006)
- L7: A model for governance worldwide, especially through the 1970s
way out: The oath (binding officers)
- L1: Officers acting under the oath (Marshall grounded judicial review in it)
- L5: The President's oath to preserve, protect and defend it
- L6: Every federal and state legislator, officer and judge bound to support the Constitution
way out: Vesting power (constituting the offices)
- L1: Offices held and acting on the people and the states
- L5: Powers vested in Congress, the President and the courts
- L7: The people ordain the frame