← all systems · see it in The System
United States Congress
The legislative branch of the federal government of the United States: a bicameral legislature of 535 voting members (100 senators, two per state, six-year staggered terms; 435 representatives from population-apportioned districts, two-year terms; plus 6 non-voting delegates), created by Article I of the Constitution and meeting since 1789. Walked as historians and political scientists describe it: the two chambers and their unique powers (revenue and impeachment in the House; treaties, nominations and impeachment trials in the Senate), the procedures that carry a bill from introduction through committee, floor, the other chamber and the President, the committee system where most of the work is done, the parties that organize it, the information it takes in (elections, the census, constituents, donors, lobbyists, testimony, its own research agencies, the executive, the courts, the press), and its history in Zelizer's four eras.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Congress (Article I) |
| born at | 1789 (foundation March 4, 1789 in the encyclopedia's infobox) |
| born precision | days |
| boundary | Inside: the two chambers and their members (535 voting, 6 non-voting), their officers and party leaderships (Speaker, majority and minority leaders, whips, the Rules Committee), about two hundred committees and subcommittees with their staffs, and the legislative-branch support agencies (Library of Congress with the Congressional Research Service, Congressional Budget Office, Government Accountability Office, Architect of the Capitol, Capitol Police). Outside: the voters and states that choose the members, the President and executive agencies, the federal courts, parties as organizations in the electorate, donors, lobbyists and interest groups, the press, and the people and world the laws act on. The boundary is crossed constantly: lobbyists and executive agencies draft bills that only members can introduce; donors fund members' campaigns; parties are outside the Constitution but organize the chambers inside. |
| nested level | Rung 11 (humans, culture). One of the three branches of the US federal government (Article I), built from two chambers, committees, members and staff; a kind of legislature, bicameral; the arena where the two major parties compete for control. |
| scale | social |
Measures (42) published science
| voting members | 535 members (100 senators, 435 representatives) |
| non-voting members | 6 delegates and resident commissioner |
| House size fixed | 435 (since 1911; 437 in 1959-1963) seats |
| a Congress | 2 years (two sessions) |
| Senate term | 6 years, one-third elected every two years |
| census and reapportionment | 10 years |
| cloture layover | second day of session after filing days |
| post-cloture cap | 30 hours |
| presidential action on a bill | 10 days, Sundays excepted |
| suspension of the rules debate | 40 minutes |
| cloture threshold | three-fifths of senators duly chosen and sworn (normally 60) votes |
| veto override, treaty, conviction, amendment proposal | two-thirds of each house (treaty, conviction: Senate) |
| House Rules Committee ratio | 9 to 4 majority to minority |
| committees and subcommittees | about 200 count |
| standing committees | 20 House, 16 Senate count |
| bills passing the House | 10.98% (111th), 7.3% (112th), 9.8% (113th), 11.84% (114th), 13.49% (115th) share of House bills |
| bills enacted into law | 3.87%, 2.96%, 3.55%, 3.31%, 3.84% (111th-115th); roughly 3% overall share of bills |
| House bills with cosponsors | at least 87.85% share (each of 10 terms) |
| incumbent reelection rate | around 90 percent |
| officials impeached | 16 (7 convicted) count, history to date |
| troop actions without declaration (to 1970) | 149 count (Time, 1970) |
| federal lobbying spending | $1.4 billion (1998), $3.5 billion (2010) USD per year |
| registered lobbyists | over 12,000 (12,281 in 2013); fewer than 300 firms handle most spending count |
| lobbying disclosure reports | more than 1.6 million LDA reports (LobbyView) |
| former members who become lobbyists | about 29% (House), 34% (Senate) share (2019 study) |
| number of PACs | 608 (1974) to 3,803 (1984) count |
| oil and gas contributions to congressional candidates (2018) | more than $84 million USD |
| social-science testimony 1946-2016 | 15,506 testimonies at some 10,347 hearings count |
| CRS staff | about 900 employees |
| votes reconstructed from two dimensions (107th House) | 984 of 990 (about 99.4%) roll-call outcomes |
| two leading SVD components (107th House) | 45.3% and 29.6% share of the voting matrix |
| roll-call votes analysed | approximately 7 million (85th-114th Congresses) votes |
| Congresses whose polarization direction the model predicts | 28 of 30 Congresses |
| representative pairs analysed | over 5 million pairs (House 1949-2012) |
| cooperator pairs held by seven members (110th Congress) | 98.3 percent |
| approval of Congress (low) | 5% (October 2013); around 25% in recent decades percent approving |
| largest to smallest state population | about 12:1 (1787), California 70 times Wyoming (2006) ratio |
| cloture rule adopted | 76-3 (1917) Senate vote |
| Civil Rights Act cloture vote | 71-29 (June 10, 1964) after a 75-hour filibuster and 60 days Senate vote |
| cloture votes 1917-1970 | 49 count |
| North Carolina ensemble | over 24,000 redistricting plans sampled |
| Congress lifetime | 1789-present years |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-2327 How are members of Congress assigned to committees?
booked: The map keeps the competing theories.
the other reading: several contrasting theories of committee assignment strategies (Porter et al.); parties 'stacking' important committees with partisans; near-random assignment - C-2329 Where did the polarization of Congress come from?
booked: The map keeps the competing explanations.
the other reading: origins in the electorate (McCarty et al.); among political elites (Fiorina and Abrams); a combination of the two (Jacobson); party effects (Cox and McCubbins), ideological effects (Krehbiel), or their interaction (Rohde; Aldrich and Rohde); narrow majorities as a cause (encyclopedia); donors and voter polarization correlated with the model's polarization utility (Lu et al.) - C-2330 Has Congress lost its power to declare war?
booked: The map keeps the readings side by side.
the other reading: executive usurpation of Congress's war power (critics; Kinsley); periodic disagreement throughout the nation's history about the extent of each branch's power; Congress's reassertion through the War Powers Resolution - C-2339 What is the filibuster for, and where did it start?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings.
the other reading: a promoter of consensus: supporters write bills to attract three-fifths (CRS); a weapon 'prominently and persistently wielded in defense of white supremacy' (Wirls); Hamilton's warning in Federalist 22 against giving a minority a negative upon the majority; origin: a filibuster at the very first session (1789, Maclay) versus the conventional story that it began after the previous question was dropped (1805-1806) - C-2365 Does campaign money buy votes, or follow them?
booked: The map keeps the competing hypotheses.
the other reading: the purchase (influence) hypothesis; the investment hypothesis (Goldberg et al.); donors as the strongest correlate of legislators' issue attention (Goel et al.); campaign money as free speech that 'enables candidates to communicate with voters' - C-2383 Does the Senate give small states too much weight?
booked: The map keeps the competing views.
the other reading: a steady redistribution of resources from large states to small states (Levinson); a deliberate design that gives each state equal footing and works well on balance
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (13)
- Constitution of the United States
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Political party
- House of Representatives
- Senate
- Committees and subcommittees
- Support agencies: CRS, CBO, GAO, Library of Congress
- Reconstruction era
- Presidential against congressional Reconstruction
- Congress against the presidency over shared powers
- President against Congress over policy and authority (1789-)
- War powers: commander in chief against Congress's power to declare war
- Control of the executive branch: removal, independent agencies, the civil service
Sits inside / holds (3)
Trades with (valence) (15)
- Political party via sys:human-society · United States Congress mixed
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · United States Congress gain
- Mass media via sys:mass-media · United States Congress mixed
- United States (the country across time) via sys:human-society · United States Congress gain
- Constitution of the United States via sys:human-society · United States Congress gain
- President of the United States · United States Congress mixed
- Supreme Court of the United States via sys:human-society · United States Congress mixed
- Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies) via sys:human-society · United States Congress even
- US state legislatures via sys:human-society · United States Congress mixed
- Lobbying and organised interests via sys:human-society · United States Congress mixed
- Donors and political action committees via sys:money · United States Congress mixed
- Central bank via sys:human-society · United States Congress gain
- Federalism via sys:human-society · United States Congress gain
- Advocacy group (interest group) via sys:human-society · United States Congress mixed
- Separation of powers via sys:law · United States Congress mixed
expressed by (19)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Mapping/Modeling
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Reactive Response
- Delay/Redirection Tactics
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Deterrence
- Scheduled Build-and-Dismantle (On-Demand Structure)
floor filled by (20)
- Constitution of the United States
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Mass media
- Political party
- United States (the country across time)
- President of the United States
- Supreme Court of the United States
- The decennial census (Article I, Section 2)
- House of Representatives
- Senate
- Committees and subcommittees
- Support agencies: CRS, CBO, GAO, Library of Congress
- US state legislatures
- Lobbying and organised interests
- Donors and political action committees
- Central bank
- Reconstruction era
- Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies)
- Federalism
- Separation of powers
Kinds (3)
wired (5)
- President of the United States
- US state constitutions
- Freedmen's Bureau
- US Army (occupation and military districts)
- Supreme Court of the United States
Notes published science
- Two numbers are enough to describe almost every vote: in the 107th House, a member's voting record collapses to two coordinates (one partisan, one 'everyone agrees'), and those two alone reconstruct 984 of 990 roll-call outcomes (src:porter-2005-committees).
- Cross-party cooperation in the House has come to rest on a handful of people: in the 110th Congress just seven members accounted for 98.3% of all pairs of a Democrat and a Republican who agreed more than chance, while before 1990 no single member ever made up even 5% (src:andris-2015).
- The Senate runs a carry-lookahead: a cloture motion has to sit until the second day of session before it can be voted on, so leaders file cloture on the substitute and on the bill back to back, letting 'the two-day layover required for each cloture motion' run 'simultaneously for both' (src:crs-rl30360-2017).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the US Congress as historians and political scientists describe it: the people and interests to the law (reader's view; Zelizer's eras in `periods`)
- L1: The people, states and organised interests Congress represents and acts on, and the executive and courts it shares power with
- L2: Points of contact: elections in 435 districts and 50 states, constituent requests, lobbyists, witnesses at hearings, the President's messages
- L3: Routing: referral of bills by the Speaker on the parliamentarian's advice, member and committee staff, Legislative Counsel, the support agencies (CRS, CBO, GAO), party whips
- L4: Integration: about two hundred committees and subcommittees, hearings, markups and oversight
- L5: Regulation: the two chambers' floors under their own rules and party leaders (Speaker, Rules Committee, suspension; unanimous consent, filibuster and cloture)
- L6: Meaning: Article I's enumerated and implied powers as the courts read them; party positions in a two-dimensional voting space; partisanship
- L7: Decision and action: identical text passed by both chambers, or supermajorities to override, convict, ratify or propose amendments; laws, appropriations, investigations, confirmations, declarations of war
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: The committees: about two hundred committees and subcommittees (20 standing in the House, 16 in the Senate) that hold hearings, mark up and report bills, and oversee the executive; 'independent fiefdoms' where much of the policy expertise resides
- L5: The two chambers' floors under their own rules and party leaderships: in the House the Speaker, the Rules Committee (9 majority to 4 minority) and suspension of the rules; in the Senate unanimous consent, the filibuster and cloture
- L6: Meaning: Article I's enumerated and implied powers as the courts read them, the separation of powers, and the parties' positions (a voting record described by two coordinates; partisanship rising)
- L7: Congress acting as one: both chambers agree to the same bill in the same form, or reach the supermajorities the Constitution and rules ask (two-thirds to override a veto, convict, ratify a treaty or propose an amendment; three-fifths for cloture)
way in: Campaign money: donors and PACs
- L1: Donors' money: individuals, corporations, unions (oil and gas companies gave more than $84 million to congressional candidates in 2018)
- L2: Contributions through political action committees (608 PACs in 1974, 3,803 in 1984)
- L3: Fund-raising: members spend ever-increasing hours raising money; donors fund incumbents they expect to win
- L4: The member's priorities: donors have the strongest association with legislators' issue attention in floor speech (House 1995-2018); money follows votes (investment)
way in: Colleagues: the members' own network (inner channel)
- L1: The 535 members' positions and relationships; cross-party cooperation now concentrated in a few 'super-cooperators'
- L2: Dear Colleague letters and cosponsorship (at least 87.85% of House bills had cosponsors; cosponsoring rises in election years)
- L3: Party cues through caucus, conference and whips; a party switch realigns a member's votes at once
- L4: Communities of legislators: cosponsorship and voting blocs measured by modularity
way in: Constituents: requests and the public's issue attention
- L1: The public's problems and priorities (what people talk about, here measured on Twitter in the 113th Congress)
- L2: Requests for help with government, letters, posts: 'Constituents request assistance with problems'
- L3: Members' staff and the chambers' nonpartisan Legislative Counsel turn requests into casework or bill language
- L4: The member weighs it: legislators follow public issue attention more than they lead it, and respond more to their supporters than to the general public
way in: Elections: the voters' choice of members
- L1: Voters in 435 population-apportioned districts and in 50 states as wholes (two senators each, the Connecticut Compromise)
- L2: Elections: the House every second year by the people; senators statewide for six-year staggered terms (chosen by state legislatures until the Seventeenth Amendment, 1913)
- L3: Districting: after each census officials draw district lines, which can favour a party (gerrymandering; North Carolina's enacted plans were outliers in an ensemble of 24,000 plans)
- L4: The seat won: incumbents re-elected at around 90%; each House judges the elections and qualifications of its own members
way in: Expertise: witnesses and Congress's own research agencies
- L1: Knowledge held by agencies, industries, universities and think tanks
- L2: Testimony at hearings: social scientists at some 10,347 hearings, 15,506 testimonies (1946-2016), economists far more than others
- L3: The support agencies digest it: CRS (about 900 staff), CBO (cost estimates and projections, since 1974), GAO (audits)
way in: Fire alarms: complaints about the executive
- L1: What executive agencies do to citizens (e.g. veterans' wait times for care)
- L2: Citizens, interest groups, the press and inspectors general raise the alarm (McCubbins and Schwartz's fire alarms)
- L3: Committee investigations with subpoena power; witnesses who refuse may be cited for contempt
way in: Lobbying: organised interests
- L1: Firms, unions and groups that 'live and die' by government decisions; rent seeking spends resources on a non-productive activity
- L2: Lobbyist contacts, disclosed in more than 1.6 million Lobbying Disclosure Act reports; lobbyists help members write legislation
- L3: Over 12,000 registered lobbyists, but fewer than 300 firms handle most spending; the targets they approach shift with each change of government
way in: The President and executive agencies
- L1: The executive branch: agencies and the President; most bills originate there
- L2: The President's information on the State of the Union, recommended measures and annual budget; agency testimony; veto messages
- L3: Referral of bills by the Speaker on the parliamentarian's advice to committees of jurisdiction (and, until 1946, executive staff detailed to friendly Senate committees)
way in: The census: how many seats each state holds
- L1: The population of the states (large-to-small ratio about 12:1 in 1787, California 70 times Wyoming in 2006)
- L2: The enumeration every ten years 'in such Manner as they shall by Law direct'
- L3: Apportionment of a fixed 435 seats among the states by population (each state at least one)
- L4: Each state's House delegation, and so its weight in the House and the Electoral College
way in: The courts: judicial review
- L1: Cases arising under the laws Congress made
- L2: The federal courts decide; since Marbury v. Madison (1803) the Supreme Court can nullify a congressional law
- L3: Rulings published: striking down (Dred Scott, 1857, against an act of 1820) or extending congressional power (McCulloch v. Maryland; the Commerce Clause)
way in: The press and the public picture of Congress
- L1: Events and Congress's own doings, covered (important hearings widely reported)
- L2: Journalists and broadcasters; members' own social media
- L3: The media agenda: coverage of partisans' issues, which often leads the political agenda; 'tabloidization'
- L4: Public approval of Congress (around 25%, 5% in October 2013), which tracks the language members use on the floor
way out: Advice and consent: nominations and treaties (Senate)
- L1: Officers, judges and ambassadors appointed; treaties in force
- L4: Nominations and treaties referred to committees and reported
- L7: The Senate's consent: two-thirds to ratify a treaty; a majority to confirm, with cloture on nominations by majority since 2013/2017
way out: Counting the electoral votes
- L1: The presidency filled (the count interrupted by the attack of January 6, 2021)
- L7: Joint session on January 6 after a presidential election counts the votes; the House chooses if no majority
way out: Impeachment and removal
- L1: An officer removed (seven of sixteen impeached officials convicted)
- L5: Impeachment by a simple majority of the House; trial in the Senate
- L7: Conviction by two-thirds of the Senate removes the officer
way out: Investigation and oversight
- L1: Executive agencies changed, officials tested, future laws informed
- L3: Reports and transcripts published: Congress 'can be described as a publisher'
- L4: Committee hearings and subpoenas
- L7: The decision to investigate (police patrols on Congress's own initiative, or fire alarms raised by others)
way out: Legislation
- L1: The law acting on people, states and agencies
- L3: Recorded and published: votes in an online database, laws arranged in the United States Code
- L5: Enrolled and presented to the President, who has 10 days (Sundays excepted) to sign or veto
- L7: A bill passed by both chambers in identical form (or a veto overridden by two-thirds of each)
way out: Proposing constitutional amendments
- L1: Proposed to the states, three-fourths of which must ratify
- L7: Two-thirds of both houses propose an amendment by joint resolution
way out: Speech: members' messages to the public
- L1: Heard by voters, who reward grandstanding with vote share
- L3: Carried by press and members' social media
- L5: Floor speeches and hearing statements (123+ million words on the House floor 1996-2014; grandstanding in hearings)
- L7: Members choose what to say (Fenno's motives: reelection, policy, power in the chamber)
way out: The power of the purse: taxes and appropriations
- L1: Money drawn from the Treasury to agencies; when appropriations lapse, shutdown (October 2013, several weeks)
- L5: Appropriations committees and the budget process (with CBO estimates)
- L7: Appropriations made by law; revenue bills originate in the House
way out: War powers: declaring war and raising forces
- L1: The armed forces raised and sent (formal declarations for 1812, Mexico, Spain, WWI, WWII)
- L7: A declaration of war by joint resolution; raising and supporting armies (no appropriation longer than two years)