← all systems · see it in The System
Government
A government is the system or group of people which lead a state, responsible for directing the only entity whose use of force is socially acceptable (Wikipedia). Walked as the thing it names: the people and institutions that govern a polity, how they take in votes, opinion, taxes, records, rivals, disputes, audits and ideology, and how they act back by force, law, services, transfers and publication, as political science, economic history and cultural macroevolution (Seshat) describe it.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Governments and funders |
| born at | contested: first small city-states about 5,000 years ago; earliest states about 5,500 years ago; Tilly: states in the archaeological record as of 6000 BC; leadership in small-scale societies undated |
| born precision | millennia |
| boundary | Inside: the people and institutions that lead a state: legislature, executive, judiciary, bureaucracy and officials at every level (local to central), the military and police they direct, governing parties, and the records they keep. Outside: the governed population and its society, the economy taxed, rival polities, the media and civil society, and the state itself (the legal person a government acts for). |
| nested level | Built from branches, officials and records; one of a society's institutions; acts for a state; one government per state at a time, succeeded by the next; of many forms. |
| scale | social |
Measures (24) published science
| national governments on Earth | approximately 200 governments |
| democracies among nations (2021) | 97 of 167 nations |
| first city-states | about 5,000 years ago |
| earliest states | about 5,500 years ago |
| Seshat sample (2018) | 414 polities in 30 Natural Geographic Areas, 100-year slices from as early as 9600 BCE to as late as 1900 CE |
| variance captured by PC1 (Seshat) | around three-quarters share of variation |
| hypotheses tested (Seshat drivers) | 17 proxies from five classes of theory, >100,000 model combinations; 373 societies in 35 regions |
| governance variables (Gov) | 11 variables, summed and scaled 0-1 |
| Seshat time step (characteristic clock) | 100 years per step |
| lag from agriculture to large states | most commonly two millennia years |
| lag from cavalry to megaempire | three or four centuries years |
| bureaucracy threshold | political control beyond a day's round trip from the capital travel time |
| tax revenue share of GDP | 10-20% (low-income countries); about 40% (high-income average) % of GDP |
| countries with income-tax withholding (WWII) | share doubled share of countries (18-country sample) |
| countries with strongest executive constraints (2000) | 7% (poorest third by GDP per head) vs around 40% (upper two-thirds) % of countries (Polity IV) |
| capitation grant reaching schools, Uganda 1991-95 (per-hand-off efficiency) | 13% (mean) % of central contribution |
| capitation grant reaching schools, mid-1990s (as restated 2005) | around 20% (average school) % of central spending |
| schools receiving little or nothing, Uganda 1991-95 | roughly 70% % of schools |
| median school's share of entitlement, Uganda 2001 (after publication) | 82% % of entitlement |
| face-judgment exposure needed | 100 ms |
| races predicted by face judgments (2006) | 68.6% (gubernatorial); 72.4% (Senate) % of races |
| ideology-brain samples | n = 90 (+28) (Kanai 2011); n = 928 (replication) participants |
| autocratizing democracies that became dictatorships | 60 of 75; 22 countries declining in 2017; 33 of 47 episodes since 1994 led by elected incumbents countries / episodes |
| OECD countries in thermostat-feedback analysis | twenty-one countries |
Open contentions (5) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-715 How did governments first arise?
booked: The map doesn't pick an origin. It records the first city-states about 5,000-5,500 years ago and the finding that agriculture and warfare were the chief drivers, with the other theories alongside.
the other reading: agricultural surplus let some rule others (encyclopedia); managerial: water infrastructure needed central administration (Fukuyama, as cited); 'more egalitarian and decentralized complex societies' succeeded too; external conflict: warfare selects centralised, specialised states (Turchin et al. 2022); internal conflict: class struggle, stratification; predatory: Tilly, states as protection rackets; contractarian: states form because cooperation benefits all; information management: governance evolved to manage information flows (Seshat Hypothesis 8: weak support); Tilly: states seen in the archaeological record as of 6000 BC - C-716 Do the brains of liberals and conservatives differ?
booked: The map records the findings as the sources state them: a 2011 study linked political views to two brain regions, but a much larger replication found only a very small amygdala link and no causal direction.
the other reading: larger amygdala, more fear-sensitive, more inclined to conservative views (Kanai's testable hypothesis); structure shaped by stress, development and social status (as the replication discusses); no meaningful structural difference (ACC finding not replicated) - C-730 Does public opinion push back against government policy, or come to support it?
booked: The map keeps both: opinion acting like a thermostat that pushes back, and policies building their own support, with studies finding different patterns in different countries.
the other reading: thermostat: opinion moves opposite to policy; Pierson: attitudes come to match existing institutions; Busemeyer et al.: accelerating, self-reinforcing and self-undermining, specific and general, short- and long-term - C-733 How much of Uganda's school funding was lost in the 1990s?
booked: The map keeps both figures from the same researchers: 13% on average in 1991-95, and around 20% as restated later.
the other reading: 13% mean of the 1991-95 survey years; about 20% as restated in 2005 - C-734 What is a government?
booked: The map describes government by what it does, the system or group that leads a state and directs its legitimate use of force, and keeps the other definitions side by side.
the other reading: a group of people (the particular administration) vs a system (the institutions); government as the state's agent ('representation and authorized agency') vs 'state' and 'government' used as synonyms; Weber: the state claims the monopoly of legitimate force; Scheidel's common core; Montevideo's four criteria (government as one); Easton: the authoritative allocation of values (the political system)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (1) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Government. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- borrowed-then-held (partial)
Administration done first by generalists ('chiefs and subchiefs', coded as no full-time bureaucrats) and leadership that becomes institutional only in some domains, then held by full-time bureaucrats, examination and merit systems once control reaches beyond a day's round trip.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (73) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) · Government gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with) via sys:written-record · Government gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:law · Government gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Mass media via sys:law · Government mixed
- Money via sys:money · Government gain
- City via sys:law · Government gain
- Education system via sys:money · Government gain
- Market and trade via sys:law · Government gain
- Farming (agriculture) · Government gain
- Industrial Revolution (the first, c. 1760 to c. 1840) via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Internet via sys:mental-representation · Government gain
- Data centre via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Electrical grid via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Labour market via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Firm (the economic unit) via sys:law · Government mixed
- Bureaucracy via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Political party via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Democracy via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Police via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Election via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Supply and demand via sys:law · Government gain
- Fossil fuel via sys:government · Government mixed
- Civilization via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Constitution of the United States via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Statistics: the practice of collecting and reasoning from data, the intuitive statistics it grows from, and the structure (samples, distributions, estimators) it works on via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Cryptography via sys:written-record · Government mixed
- Accounting (the field and practice) via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Society as sociologists see it (sociology's object: social structure and social action) via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Public opinion via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Central bank via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Great Depression via sys:human-society · Government gain
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945) via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Personal finance (how a household earns, spends, saves, borrows and plans) via sys:money · Government gain
- Economy via sys:government · Government gain
- Pollution via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Public-key cryptography via sys:law · Government mixed
- Computer security via sys:written-record · Government mixed
- Journalism via sys:news · Government mixed
- Open-source software via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Incident response via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Information security via sys:written-record · Government mixed
- Organization via sys:law · Government mixed
- Newspaper via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Management via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Cyber threat intelligence via sys:written-record · Government mixed
- Vulnerability management via sys:law · Government gain
- Business continuity via sys:organization · Government mixed
- Formal security policy model via sys:government · Government mixed
- The archive and the historical record via sys:written-record · Government gain
- Imperial China (China under its dynasties, from Qin unification in 221 BC to the Qing's fall in 1912) via sys:human-society · Government even
- History (the field) via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Security audit and compliance via sys:law · Government gain
- Critical infrastructure via sys:infrastructure · Government gain
- Economics (the field) via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies) via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Meiji Restoration via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Consumer via sys:law · Government gain
- Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies) via sys:natural-environment · Government gain
- Air pollution via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Business via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Unemployment via sys:government · Government mixed
- Federalism via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Inflation (economics) via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Gross domestic product via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Advocacy group (interest group) via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Voting via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Renewable energy via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Sustainability via sys:human-society · Government mixed
- Tax via sys:human-society · Government gain
- Separation of powers via sys:human-society · Government mixed
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (38)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Legislatures and statutes
- Courts (the judiciary)
- Bureaucracy
- Military (professional soldiers and officers)
- Local and regional governments
- Political party
- Executive (government)
- Achaemenid (Persian) Empire
- Byzantine Empire (the Eastern Roman Empire, from Constantinople's founding in the early 300s to its fall in 1453)
- The New Deal court-packing plan against judicial review
- Luddites against mill owners and the state (1811 on)
- Economy
- The Crypto Wars: states against industry and researchers over strong encryption
- States and the open community over the strength of deployed cryptography
- Correspondents against state interceptors for the secrecy of letters
- Document handlers against enemy capture in the Second World War
- Civil war in a warming climate (sub-Saharan Africa)
- States and countries competing to host data centres
- Imperial China (China under its dynasties, from Qin unification in 221 BC to the Qing's fall in 1912)
- Whose past is kept
- Abbasid Caliphate (750-1258, with its ceremonial Cairo line to 1517)
- Competition over emission limits: industry and agriculture lobbies against regulators
- Petitioner against respondent in each case
- Federal and state power before the Court
- The press and governments over what the public learns
- The press and the state over what may be printed (licensing, censorship, suppression)
- Gross domestic product
- Autocracies' reported growth against night lights from orbit
- The inflation tax: issuer against money holders
- Parties, governments, media and interest groups competing to frame issues for the public
- Petrostates and renewable-rich states over influence in the energy order
- Short-term profit and politics against long-term viability
- Populist governments against independent central banks
- Tax havens against other countries over the tax base
- The government against many interest groups (Langtry's contest)
- Political masters and bureaucrats over control of policy
- Groups seizing control of a bureaucratic state
Sits inside / holds (11)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Bureaucracy
- Police
- Statistics: the practice of collecting and reasoning from data, the intuitive statistics it grows from, and the structure (samples, distributions, estimators) it works on
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Central bank
- Information security
- The archive and the historical record
- Tax
- Separation of powers
expressed by (16)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Reactive Response
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Deterrence
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (75)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- Law (rules and law)
- Legislatures and statutes
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Money
- Courts (the judiciary)
- Bureaucracy
- Military (professional soldiers and officers)
- Local and regional governments
- Political party
- Executive (government)
- Public policy
- Industrial Revolution (the first, c. 1760 to c. 1840)
- Internet
- Data centre
- Electrical grid
- City
- Labour market
- Democracy
- Police
- Election
- Supply and demand
- Native peoples of North America (Indigenous peoples of North America, across time)
- American Revolution
- Fossil fuel
- Civilization
- Mesopotamia (the society of the land between the rivers, across time)
- Ancient Rome
- Ancient China (the early Chinese states from the first Bronze Age state to the end of the Han, across time)
- Middle Ages
- Constitution of the United States
- Statistics: the practice of collecting and reasoning from data, the intuitive statistics it grows from, and the structure (samples, distributions, estimators) it works on
- Byzantine Empire (the Eastern Roman Empire, from Constantinople's founding in the early 300s to its fall in 1453)
- Cryptography
- Accounting (the field and practice)
- Society as sociologists see it (sociology's object: social structure and social action)
- Public opinion
- Central bank
- Great Depression
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945)
- Economy
- Pollution
- Signals intelligence
- Public-key cryptography
- Information security
- Newspaper
- Russo-Ukrainian war (2014-; full-scale phase from 2022)
- Vulnerability management
- Business continuity
- The archive and the historical record
- Imperial China (China under its dynasties, from Qin unification in 221 BC to the Qing's fall in 1912)
- Great Acceleration
- Information warfare
- Critical infrastructure
- Abbasid Caliphate (750-1258, with its ceremonial Cairo line to 1517)
- Thirteen Colonies
- Reconstruction era
- Economics (the field)
- Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies)
- Meiji Restoration
- Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies)
- Air pollution
- Water pollution
- Unemployment
- Federalism
- Inflation (economics)
- Gross domestic product
- Advocacy group (interest group)
- Voting
- Renewable energy
- Sustainability
- Tax
- Separation of powers
Kinds (17)
- Organization
- Chiefdom (simple and complex)
- Local and regional governments
- Autocracy
- Oligarchy (aristocracy)
- Democracy
- Republic
- Monarchy
- Federation (federalism)
- Totalitarian regime
- Authoritarian regime
- Hybrid regime
- Central (federal) government
- Coalition government
- Parliamentary system
- Presidential system
- Semi-presidential system
wired (28)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Household
- Order book and double auction (market institution)
- Firm (the economic unit)
- Bureaucracy
- Irrigation canals, dams and levees
- Factory system
- Economy
- Armed forces (armies, navies, air forces)
- Records management
- Owners and operators (utilities, pipeline companies, control-room operators)
- The gold solidus (nomisma) and the mint
- Byzantine emperor
- Abbasid provinces
- Statistical agency
- Policy committee (FOMC, MPC, governing board)
- Commanderies, counties, districts and hamlets
- Walls, watchtowers and beacon towers
- Emperor of China
- Statistical office
- Intelligence service
- Trade unions, friendly societies, cooperatives
- The imperial examination system
- The Grand Canal
- Constantinople (New Rome)
- Caliph (the office)
- Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies)
- Labour force surveys and statistics
Notes published science
- 'Government' and 'cybernetics' are the same word: both come from the Greek for steering a ship, and political scientists now model the public as a literal thermostat that signals government to adjust until 'the signal stops' (src:wp:government, src:wp:cybernetics, src:busemeyer-2021).
- In Uganda in the early 1990s, schools received on average only 13% of the money the central government sent them; once the government started printing the monthly transfers in newspapers, the median school got 82% of its entitlement by 2001 (src:reinikka-svensson-2001, src:reinikka-svensson-2005).
- A tenth of a second looking at two candidates' faces was enough for strangers to pick the winner of US governor races as well as unlimited viewing did, and thinking harder made the guesses worse (src:ballew-todorov-2007).
- To reach the sultan's government, an ordinary subject (in an empire where only 2-3% could read) hired a professional petition-writer who knew the strict form, and even a patriarch's petitions went to the grand vizier, not the sultan (src:dipratu-2026, src:wp:ottoman-empire).
- The office has an inner sense of its own body, and the president is its only judge: under the 25th Amendment presidents decide for themselves when they are fit to take power back (Reagan did it 7 hours 50 minutes after handing it over), and people elected to lead a country live about 2.7 years less than the runners-up who lost (src:johnstone-2025-anesth-analg-25th, src:olenski-2015-bmj-heads-of-government).
- The form that standardised a civil service for four centuries spread through pirated study guides. Chinese printers sold successful eight-legged examination essays as models in the 16th century; the government approved the practice in 1587, and the format held until it was abolished in 1905. (src:wp:eight-legged-essay)
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
government: the governed to authoritative rule (reader's view)
- L1: The governed: a population and its conduct within a territory, its economy and its neighbours
- L2: Inputs: votes, expressed opinion, taxes, registers, word of rivals, disputes brought to court, audits
- L3: Records: writing, record-keeping and texts; tax records; legal codes
- L4: Administration: full-time officials and bureaucracy in nested levels (local, regional, central); bureaucracy appears when control reaches beyond a day's round trip from the capital
- L5: Branches and institutions: legislature, executive, judiciary; parties and coalitions; checks and balances
- L6: Public policy and law: the authoritative allocation of values
- L7: Leading the state: rule backed by the monopoly of legitimate force, acting back on the governed and on rivals (force, law, services, transfers, publication)
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The branches and institutions: legislature, executive, judiciary (trias politica), plus electoral or audit branches where they exist; parties forming majority, minority or coalition governments
- L6: Public policy and law: the authoritative allocation of values (Easton); laws, budgets, taxes, services; the sum of the government's direct and indirect activities
- L7: Leading the state: directing the only entity whose use of force is socially acceptable (Weber's monopoly of legitimate force within a territory)
way in: Disputes among the governed (adjudication)
- L1: Disputes among members of the population; intragroup conflict
- L2: Courts (specialised buildings for justice)
- L3: A formal legal code
- L4: Full-time judges and professional lawyers
way in: Elections (votes cast for representatives)
- L1: Voters judging candidates: rapid judgments of competence from faces, preference for lower-pitched voices
- L2: The vote: citizens select representatives; some systems keep initiatives, referendums and recall
- L4: Seats held by parties: majority, minority or coalition government
way in: Ideology (the inner channel: what members believe)
- L1: Political attitudes held in people's brains; a small replicated link between amygdala volume and conservatism
- L2: Movements and the parties that carry them into power, often named after their ideologies
- L4: Parties agree a coalition and form a government
way in: Oversight and audit (the government watching its own spending)
- L1: Public funds reaching (or not reaching) their destination
- L2: A public expenditure tracking survey (PETS) follows the money to the schools
- L3: Audit and electoral bodies, sometimes their own branch
- L4: An oversight branch able to audit and impeach (Taiwan's Control Yuan; elsewhere fused in the legislature)
way in: Public opinion (the thermostat signal)
- L1: Policy changes as citizens meet them
- L2: Expressed support or opposition: a departure from the favoured policy 'temperature' produces a signal
- L3: Aggregate support for more spending, read against last period's spending
- L4: Picked up by responsive policy makers (dynamic representation)
way in: Registration and records (the information system)
- L1: The governed population and territory (polity population, extent of territory)
- L2: Registration of commoners (past the information threshold)
- L3: Writing, record-keeping and texts; writing or quipus centralise vital information
- L4: Full-time bureaucrats (absent where chiefs do administration as generalists); examination and merit systems
way in: Revenue (taxes drawn from the economy)
- L1: The economy taxed: incomes, trade flows, firms; a large informal sector is hard to tax
- L2: Collection doors: border posts for trade taxes; payroll withholding by formal firms for income taxes
- L3: Tax records, cross-checked between individuals and firms
- L4: Fiscal capacity: tax administration built by forward-looking investment in institutions
way in: Rival polities (warfare in the environment)
- L1: Neighbours' threat, read in the variety of means of attack and defence
- L2: Contact at the frontier: mounted warfare spreading from the steppes into farming societies
- L4: Military hierarchy: decision levels, professional officers and soldiers
way out: Force: war making and protection (military, police)
- L1: Outside rivals eliminated or neutralised; inside rivals too; clients protected
- L5: Professional officers and soldiers; military hierarchy
- L7: Directing the monopoly of legitimate force
way out: Laws and regulations
- L1: Conduct of the governed regulated (law.json L1)
- L5: Legislature makes statutes, executive decrees and regulations (law.json ch-legislation, ch-regulation)
- L6: Creating laws
way out: Public services and public goods
- L1: Services delivered: courts, education, emergency services, health care, military, policing; infrastructure
- L5: The public sector: civil servants, government property, state-owned enterprises; officials solving collective-action problems
- L6: Spending: social protection, health care, general public services, education, economic affairs, public security, defence, recreation and culture
way out: Publication (information released to the governed)
- L1: Parents and head teachers informed, able to monitor local officials
- L3: National newspapers and their local-language editions
- L6: Decision to publish monthly transfers (citizen enforcement)
way out: Transfers down the chain (grants to lower levels and to schools)
- L1: Schools receive part of it: 13% on average 1991-95; about 70% of schools little or nothing
- L5: Districts manage it for the central government; grants often stuck in the chief administrative officer's account
- L6: A central grant allocated (Uganda's capitation grant for schools' non-wage spending)