← all systems · see it in The System
Journalism
Journalism is the practice of gathering, checking and reporting news: in the encyclopedia's words 'the production and distribution of reports on events, facts, ideas, and people that constitute the "news of the day" and inform society with a commitment to accuracy and verification'. Reporters, sources, news agencies, documents and users' posts bring material in; verification (the 'discipline of verification', Kovach and Rosenstiel) and fact-checking test it; news values and the editor's gate select it (nine-tenths of one wire editor's copy rejected); newsrooms, paid by advertisers, readers, owners, states or donors, publish it under codes of ethics (242 to about 400 of them) and the contested norm of objectivity; and the purpose acted on the world is citizens informed and power watched (the fourth estate). Research measures that purpose: one more newspaper raised US turnout about 0.3 points; officials covered less work less for constituents; after a local paper closes, municipal borrowing costs rise 5-11 basis points. Its current pressures are measured too: classified revenue lost to Craigslist, copying within minutes online, falsehood that spreads farther and faster than truth, negativity that wins clicks, and journalists jailed, harassed and traumatised. Walked as the practice and the people and institutions doing it, as media studies describes it.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Journalism (reporters, correspondents) |
| born at | contested: Han dynasty bulletins (officials only); Ming private publishers 1582; Strasbourg 1605; the profession c. 1900-1908 |
| born precision | contested / year (1605) |
| boundary | Inside: the gathering, checking, selecting, writing and publishing of news by reporters, editors, fact-checkers and news organisations (professional or not), with their norms and codes. Outside: the events and people reported on, the sources who supply material, the audiences who read and share, the advertisers and owners who pay, the state and law that protect or restrict, and the platforms that carry and compete. The line is porous: citizen journalists and the 'socially mediating public' cross it, and platforms' feed algorithms make editorial decisions outside any newsroom. |
| nested level | Part of the mass media (its 'who', the news gatherers, at mass media's L2); carried out by people (runs on Human's L7 and its speech and movement outlets); among a society's institutions; works on news, the medium of current-events information. |
| scale | social |
Measures (22) published science
| characteristic clock: the news cycle | daily, with strict deadlines (24-hour on news channels since 1980) cycle |
| characteristic clock: online copy latency | one quarter of stories reproduced in under 4 minutes |
| characteristic clock: an investigation | months or years time per report |
| wire copy rejected by one wire editor (Mr. Gates) | nine-tenths share of wire copy, one week (White 1950) |
| independent share of US urban dailies | 11% (1870) to 62% (1920) share of dailies |
| turnout effect of one additional newspaper | about +0.3 percentage points (US presidential and congressional) |
| municipal borrowing cost after a newspaper closure | +5 to 11 basis points; about $650,000 per issue basis points; US dollars |
| Craigslist's savings to classified-ad buyers | $5.0 billion (2000-2007, year-2000 dollars) US dollars |
| true and false news on Twitter studied | ~126,000 stories, ~3 million people, >4.5 million tweets; fact-checkers 95-98% agreement counts |
| click-through lift per negative headline word | +2.3% click-through rate per word |
| lay vs fact-checker source ratings | r = 0.90 correlation |
| fact-check effect vs misinformation effect on belief | at least -0.59 vs under +0.07 points on a 5-point scale |
| press-release exaggeration carried into news | 58%, 81%, 86% (vs 17%, 18%, 10% when the release was not exaggerated) share of news stories |
| public expression activated by coverage | ~62.7% more discussion; 13,166 extra posts in a week share of a day's volume; posts |
| war journalists' lifetime PTSD | 28.6% lifetime prevalence (n = 140) |
| journalists harassed online at least weekly | 26% (65 of 246) share of one Canadian newsroom |
| journalists jailed worldwide (CPJ census, 2017) | 262 (a record) journalists |
| US counties with no local news organization (2024) | 206 (and 1,561 with only one); 55 million Americans in news-desert counties counties; people |
| US confidence in TV news or newspapers (2014) | 22% share of Americans with a great deal or quite a lot |
| journalists surveyed worldwide (Worlds of Journalism, 2012-2016) | 27,500 in 67 countries; 57% male; mean age 38 journalists |
| codes of journalism ethics | over 242 / around 400 codes |
| agenda-setting studies since Chapel Hill | more than 400 studies |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1127 How strong are online echo chambers?
booked: The map records echo chambers where they are observed, and keeps the experiments that find smaller effects alongside.
the other reading: see research/CONTENTIONS.md C-1127 - C-2774 How many journalism ethics codes are there?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: 242+; about 400 - C-2775 Where and when did journalism begin?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Han dynasty bulletins; 1582 / 1605 newspapers; the professional era (c. 1900-1908) - C-2776 Where does an editor's sense of what is news come from?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: shared news values; personal subjectivity; political usefulness - C-2779 Is journalism for experts (Lippmann) or for a public that decides (Dewey)?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Lippmann; Dewey - C-2790 Is objectivity journalism's core norm, or an ideology?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: objectivity as the professional ideal; objectivity as an ideology - C-2791 Did market scale make the press informative, or a channel for propaganda?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: informative press from competition; propaganda model
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (11)
- Mass media
- Gatekeeping (editors)
- Journalists (reporters, correspondents, editors)
- News agencies
- Fact-checking
- Codes of ethics
- Newspaper
- Outlets competing for stories and audiences (scoops and copying)
- True news against false news for people's sharing
- The press and governments over what the public learns
- Fake news websites posing as newspapers
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (15)
- Photography via sys:news · Journalism gain
- Public opinion via sys:human-society · Journalism gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:news · Journalism gain
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:news · Journalism gain
- Government via sys:news · Journalism mixed
- Mass media via sys:news · Journalism gain
- Democracy via sys:news · Journalism gain
- Election via sys:news · Journalism gain
- Social media platforms via sys:news · Journalism mixed
- Advertisers via sys:news · Journalism mixed
- Insider threat via sys:human-society · Journalism gain
- Newspaper via sys:human-society · Journalism mixed
- Privacy via sys:written-record · Journalism mixed
- Television via sys:news · Journalism gain
- Truth via sys:news · Journalism gain
expressed by (16)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Search/Foraging
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Surprise / Change-Point Detection
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Deterrence
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (23)
- Mass media
- Photography
- Public opinion
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Democracy
- Gatekeeping (editors)
- Social media platforms
- Advertisers
- Newspaper
- Journalists (reporters, correspondents, editors)
- News agencies
- Fact-checking
- Codes of ethics
- Citizen journalism
- Automated fact-checking
- News values
- Newsroom
- Nonprofit journalism
- Journalistic objectivity
- Agenda-setting
- Freedom of the press
- Truth
Kinds (13)
- Mass media
- Investigative journalism
- Data journalism
- Broadcast journalism
- Citizen journalism
- Photojournalism
- War journalism
- Science journalism
- Advocacy journalism
- Access journalism
- Tabloid journalism
- Yellow journalism
- Sensor journalism
wired (2)
Notes published science
- When a town's local newspaper closes, the town pays more to borrow: municipal bond costs rise 5 to 11 basis points, about $650,000 more per bond issue, and government wages and deficits go up. Nobody is watching (src:gao-lee-murphy-2020).
- Most exaggerated health news starts in universities' own press releases, not in newsrooms. When a release turned a mouse result into a human claim, 86% of the news stories did too; when it didn't, only 10% did (src:sumner-2014-press-releases).
- Ordinary people, as a politically balanced crowd, rate the trustworthiness of news sources almost exactly as professional fact-checkers do (correlation 0.90), even though each party distrusts different outlets (src:pennycook-rand-2019).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
journalism as media studies describes it: from events in the world to an informed public and accountable power (reader's view)
- L1: Events, facts, ideas and people: the news of the day, and the public it is for
- L2: Newsgathering: reporters and correspondents, sources and witnesses, news agencies, documents and data, users' posts
- L3: Verification: the discipline of checking, internal fact-checking before publication, external fact-checking after
- L4: Selection: news values and the editor's gate; limited time and space
- L5: The newsroom and the news organisation: editorial boards, desks, separate editorial and advertising departments; ownership and funding (advertising, subscriptions, the state, donors)
- L6: Norms, codes and the news agenda: truthfulness, accuracy, objectivity, independence, limitation of harm; the issues made salient
- L7: Purpose acted on the world: citizens given reliable information; an independent monitor of the powerful (the fourth estate)
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Selection: news values (frequency, negativity, proximity, eliteness, conflict, shareability...) applied at the editor's gate under limited time and space
- L5: The newsroom and the organisation: editors and desks, the editorial-advertising wall, ownership and funding; the propaganda model's filters sit here (ownership, funding, sourcing, flak)
- L6: Norms, codes and the agenda: truthfulness, accuracy, objectivity, impartiality, fairness, limitation of harm, accountability (codes number 242 to about 400, each shaped by its society); the issues made salient and how they are framed
- L7: Purpose: first loyalty to citizens, the discipline of verification, an independent monitor of power (the fourth estate)
way in: Documents, records, data and leaks
- L1: Records, datasets and leaked documents; sensors placed for inquiry
- L2: Obtained by request, leak or collaboration across newsrooms (Panama Papers)
- L3: Analysis: data journalism; months or years of investigation
way in: Events seen and heard on the scene (the reporter as witness)
- L1: Events where they happen: crime scenes, disasters, wars, public events
- L2: The reporter's own senses on the scene (Human sight and hearing), photographers' and camera crews' lenses; war correspondents in danger
- L3: Notes, images and recordings; sudden events that fit the schedule are taken, slow trends pass
way in: Money: advertisers, subscribers, owners and donors
- L1: Advertisers and readers who pay; owners and benefactors
- L2: Revenue: classified, display and subscription; print sinking faster than digital grows
- L3: Prices and products set in reply (subscription prices up, less content online)
- L4: Budget turned into staff and coverage: cuts, and expensive investigations hard to fund
way in: News agencies (wire services)
- L1: The four global agencies (AFP, AP, Reuters, EFE): one objective feed to all subscribers
- L2: The wire arriving on the desk: far more stories than space
- L3: The wire editor reads the copy; agencies attribute and avoid judgement
way in: Public claims to be checked (political statements, circulating misinformation)
- L1: Claims by politicians and others; misinformation spreading
- L2: Claims selected for checking by in-house checkers and external fact-checking organisations (US early 2000s, worldwide in the 2010s)
- L3: Verification: claim detection, matching earlier checks, evidence retrieval, the verdict; increasingly with automated aids
way in: Rival outlets' stories
- L1: Stories published by other outlets
- L2: Watched and reproduced fast: a quarter of stories copied online in under 4 minutes
- L3: A rival's news judgement endorsed (the competition news value)
way in: Sources: officials, spokespeople, press releases, experts, confidential informants
- L1: People with information: officials, celebrities, institutions, experts, whistleblowers
- L2: Interviews, press conferences, press releases; pre-scheduled events
- L3: Attribution and checking against the source's own record; confidentiality kept at legal risk; press-release exaggeration carried into news
way in: The audience's response: reading, clicks, shares, trust
- L1: Readers deciding what to read and share (self and social cognition feeding the brain's value system)
- L2: Clicks and shares logged; headline tests (negative words lift click-through)
- L3: Analytics in the newsroom: story impact (shareability) as a news value
way in: The journalist's own experience, values and emotions (inner)
- L1: Exposure: war, disaster, online harassment (weekly for 26% of one newsroom's journalists)
- L2: Feelings: anxiety, depression, PTSD (lifetime 28.6% in war journalists)
- L3: Values, attitudes and moral injury, carried into judgement (Mr. Gates' subjective rejections; political usefulness bias)
way in: The state and the law: press freedom, censorship, libel, source protection, violence
- L1: Governments' policies towards journalists, from constitutional press freedom to none (a third of the world's people)
- L2: What reaches the newsroom: intimidation, harassment, jailing (262 in 2017), killings; or legal protection
- L3: Self-censorship and access journalism
- L4: Legal exposure weighed: contempt of court for protecting sources; libel
way in: Users' posts: social media and citizen journalism
- L1: User-generated videos, pictures and posts; bot-amplified low-credibility content among them
- L2: Monitored by journalists as a source (40% in a 2014 US survey)
- L3: Checked against a stream in which falsehood travels farther and faster than truth
way out: Broadcast news (radio, television, 24-hour channels)
- L1: News on air round the clock since 1980
- L5: Programming and story packages (CNN halved its packages 2007-2012)
way out: Corrections and fact-check verdicts
- L1: Belief in misinformation reduced (at least 0.59 on a 5-point scale)
- L3: The correction or fact-check written
- L7: Accountability for errors made under time pressure
way out: Online and social distribution
- L1: Shared by readers; public expression and national conversation activated
- L4: Posted online and copied by others within minutes
way out: The published story (print and web)
- L1: Readers informed and moved to act (one more newspaper, about +0.3 points turnout)
- L4: Printed and distributed (newspapers spread with the press)
- L6: Fact kept apart from opinion; the agenda and framing
- L7: The decision to publish what citizens should know
way out: Watchdog and investigative disclosure
- L1: Officials work harder, spend more for constituents; borrowing costs held down
- L3: The investigation published (months or years in the making)
- L7: The independent monitor of power