← all systems · see it in The System
Science (as a human social and cultural system)
Science is a systematic discipline that builds and organises knowledge in the form of testable explanations about nature and society. It is driven by the scientific method: an empirical cycle that typically involves making observations, producing hypotheses, testing them with evidence, and drawing conclusions. Science encompasses this process and the body of knowledge it produces, which the scientific community continuously challenges, validates, and organises.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the scientific community ("a network of interacting scientists who conduct scientific research"), its method (observation, hypothesis, test, conclusion), its instruments, its peer review and journals ("an archival record of science"), its learned societies, universities and research institutions, and the body of tested knowledge. Outside: nature and society as studied, the public, governments, companies and funders, religion, the media, and pseudoscience that "masquerades as science". |
| nested level | A social system of humans: built from scientists and their institutions on top of language, writing and cumulative culture; predecessors in Bronze Age Egypt and Mesopotamia, the method from the 17th-century Scientific Revolution, and "many of the institutional and professional features" from the 19th century. Embedded in human societies, which fund and use it. |
| scale | social |
Measures (33) published science
| characteristic clock: Royal Society meetings (1660 "College") | weekly meetings |
| characteristic clock: Nobel Prize awarded | annually per year |
| characteristic clock: paradigm turnover (Copernicus 1543 to Ptolemy falling out of favour) | about 70 years |
| earliest written records of science | Bronze Age Egypt and Mesopotamia; Egyptian decimal numbering from the 3rd millennium BCE era |
| Plimpton 322 (Pythagorean triples) | 18th century BCE date |
| Chinese sunspot records | 112 records from 364 BCE |
| first university in Europe (Bologna) | 1088 year |
| printing press: cities / volumes by 1500 | about 270 / more than 20 million cities / volumes |
| telescope patent (Lipperhey); Galileo's telescope | 1608; 1609 year |
| stars visible through Galileo's telescope vs naked eye | at least ten times more ratio |
| Newton's reflecting telescope; achromatic lens; first purpose-built radio telescope | 1668; 1733; 1937 year |
| Royal Society founded; Philosophical Transactions begins | 1660; 1665 year |
| first peer-reviewed publication (possible); first evidence of formal external review | 1731; 1752 year |
| Nature makes peer review standard; term "peer review" first used | 1973; early 1970s year |
| word "scientist" introduced (Whewell) | 1834 year |
| scientific and technical journals in publication (one estimate) | 11,500 (1981) journals |
| total research funding, most developed countries | 1.5-3 percent of GDP |
| OECD R&D carried out by industry / universities / government | about two-thirds / 20 / 10 percent |
| rejection at top journals | over 90 percent of submissions |
| desk rejection rates, economics journals (2017) | 21-66 percent |
| discoveries stumbled upon rather than sought | 33-50 percent (estimate) |
| false-positive rate accepted at p < 0.05; with moderately flexible analysis | 5; above 60 percent |
| average statistical power of psychology studies (200 meta-analyses); adequate power | 33.1-36.4; 80 percent |
| median statistical power: neuroscience (49 meta-analyses) / economics (6,700 studies) | 21 / 18 percent |
| 2012 survey of psychologists: early stopping / only analyses that "worked" / post hoc exclusion | 56 / 46 / 38 percent admitting |
| replication success with vs without author overlap (2012) | 91.7 vs 64.6 percent |
| citing papers that mention a failed replication | 12 percent |
| journals with result-blind peer review; null results under it vs earlier | more than 140; 61 vs 5-20 journals; percent |
| NIH-funded scientists admitting faking data / plagiarism / self-plagiarism (poll of 3,247) | 0.3 / 1.4 / 4.7 percent |
| retractions after fake peer review: BioMed Central / Springer (2015) | 43 / 64 (in 10 journals) articles |
| replication funding: NWO 2016 / Arnold Foundation for Center for Open Science 2013 (+2017) | EUR 3 million / USD 5.25 million (+10 million) currency |
| Germans who had not heard of replication failures / who see replication as quality control | more than 75 / 65 percent |
| Americans seeing climate change as a threat: right / left | 22 / 85 percent |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (9) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Science (as a human social and cultural system). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- templating (structural)
One article form, one significance convention (p < 0.05) and shared reporting guidelines (CONSORT, EQUATOR) recur across journals and fields. - who opens the door (structural)
A claim enters the record only through referees the editor chose and placed ahead of time ("chosen for their expertise and distance from the authors"); the journal, the society behind it, built the door. - borrowed-then-held (partial)
The first telescope record "did not appear in a work of natural philosophy but rather in a patent filed by a spectacle maker"; instrument making later sat "near a center of learning or research, such as a university". - not-diluting wins (partial)
Oral tradition was fluid, with "no archives or reports"; writing stored knowledge "across generations with much greater accuracy", and printing replaced a culture "where facts were few and far between". - outside-to-inside (partial)
An outside system is carried inside as a model: "the resulting model, in place of the corresponding system, can be analysed through purely mathematical and computational means" and translated back by correspondence rules. - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
Mitroff's counter-norms are "a one to one opposition of Mertonian norms": communality vs secrecy, universalism vs particularism, disinterestedness vs self-interestedness, organized skepticism vs organized dogmatism. - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
"Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace independently proposed the theory of evolution by natural selection in 1858"; and "Science has no single origin ... taking different forms around the world". - red-queen (surface)
Fraud and defence escalate: fake reviewer contacts exposed in 2014, then a COPE warning and 107 retractions in 2015; p-hacking met by pre-registration and result-blind review. The sources do not call it an arms race. - seed (surface)
One method unpacks into many disciplines: "a large number of hypotheses can be logically bound together by a single theory"; basic research "leads to technological advances that were not previously imaginable". No source counts the combinatorics.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (123) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Moon (Earth's natural satellite) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Comet via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Strangelet via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- Ocean currents (the ocean circulation) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Social contagion via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Gamma-ray burst via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Religion via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- Electromagnetic field via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Language (human language) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Printing press via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Government · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- University via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Engineering (design) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Special relativity via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Movable type (reusable cast sorts x the alphabet; the European press) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Extragalactic cosmic rays via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Cyclic model (Steinhardt-Turok, periodic brane collisions; hypothetical) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Ekpyrotic universe (colliding-brane origin of the hot Big Bang; hypothetical) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Gravitational wave background (stochastic background) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- Dynamical Casimir effect via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Casimir-Polder force via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- Bosonic string theory (projected model; the original string theory) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Superstring theory (projected model; supersymmetric string theory) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- M-theory (projected model; conjectured eleven-dimensional theory behind the superstring theories) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Theory of everything (projected model; final theory) via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- Self-interacting dark matter via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Lanthanides (the 4f series, La-Lu; as an opacity source in kilonovae) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Mineral via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Magnetar magnetosphere via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- Two-dimensional causal dynamical triangulation (2D CDT) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Tipler cylinder via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Einstein-de Sitter universe via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Terbium (Tb, Z = 65) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Primordial black hole evaporation via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- Chemistry (the field: the practice of chemists and the structure of substances and their reactions it works on) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Ultracool dwarf via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Dijkgraaf-Witten model (topological gauge theory with a finite gauge group; walked as an idea) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Exterior field of a planet via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Exterior field of a compact star via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Metric tree (real tree, R-tree; walked as an idea) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Quantum null energy condition (QNEC) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Decoherence via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Speed of light via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Exterior field of a neutron star via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Exterior field of a white dwarf via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Exterior field of an ordinary star (the Sun) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Gravitational constant G via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) mixed
- Hubble's law (Hubble-Lemaitre law) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Weakly deflected light ray via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Orbital elements via sys:gravitational-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Large Hadron Collider (LHC) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Large language model via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Plate tectonics via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- TRAPPIST-1 system via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Complex network (scale-free growth, preferential attachment, small worlds; walked as an idea) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Laboratory dynamo (liquid-sodium dynamo experiments) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- genealogy (descent as a medium) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- General relativity via sys:mental-representation · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Photography via sys:electromagnetic-field · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Measurement (the practice of comparing a quantity with a unit, and the units and standards it uses) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Education via sys:human-society · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Algebra (the practice of solving for unknowns and transforming expressions, and the structures it works with) via sys:sensory-environment · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Native peoples of North America (Indigenous peoples of North America, across time) via sys:written-record · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- Earthquake via sys:seismic-wave · Science (as a human social and cultural system) gain
- … 43 more
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (27)
- Scientist
- Scientific method
- Learned society
- Peer review
- Scientific journal
- University
- Scientific instrument
- Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest)
- Competition between Koch's culture proof and Pasteur's vaccine proof of a cause
- Competition for physicists' allegiance (field theory vs action-at-a-distance electrodynamics)
- Competition for the frame of the rule's speed of light (aether fixes vs special relativity)
- Competition for chemists' allegiance (Mendeleev's system vs Meyer's and earlier schemes)
- Competition among quantum-gravity research programmes
- Millikan's unit charge against Ehrenhaft's subelectrons (1910-1917)
- Phlogiston theory against the oxygen theory of combustion (the chemical revolution)
- Priority for the principle of least action (Maupertuis against Koenig's Leibniz letter, 1751)
- Competition among theories of gravity (general relativity and its rivals)
- Competition to explain Mercury's perihelion (a hidden planet or curved spacetime)
- Credit for discovering carbon nanotubes
- Uranium mining and science over the Oklo reaction zones
- Competition between general relativity and entropic (emergent) gravity
- Readings of gravity: force, curvature, quantum mediator, emergent equation of state
- The science wars (1990s): scientists against sociologists and externalist historians
- Subjects competing for instructional time
- Theories of consciousness tested against each other (the Cogitate adversarial collaboration)
- Kinetic theory against caloric theory (what heat in a gas is)
- Universities and private patrons competing for scientists (early modern)
Sits inside / holds (1275)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
- Special relativity
- Maxwell's equations (classical electromagnetism as a codified law set)
- Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest)
- Germ theory of disease with Koch's postulates (one microbe, one disease, four tests)
- Cyclic model (Steinhardt-Turok, periodic brane collisions; hypothetical)
- Ekpyrotic universe (colliding-brane origin of the hot Big Bang; hypothetical)
- Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical)
- No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical)
- Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical)
- String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model)
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
- Bosonic string theory (projected model; the original string theory)
- Superstring theory (projected model; supersymmetric string theory)
- M-theory (projected model; conjectured eleven-dimensional theory behind the superstring theories)
- Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy)
- Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical)
- Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical)
- CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical)
- Theory of everything (projected model; final theory)
- Ultimate fate of the universe
- Spectroscopy
- Two-dimensional causal dynamical triangulation (2D CDT)
- Clifton-Pohl torus
- Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it)
- Chemistry (the field: the practice of chemists and the structure of substances and their reactions it works on)
- the idea of Absolute elsewhere (spacelike region), as held by science
- the idea of absorption as held by science: how matter takes up a photon's energy, measured by absorption coefficients and spectroscopy
- the idea of Anti-de Sitter spacetime, as held by science
- the idea of the Apparent horizon as held by science (general relativity: the theory, its exact solutions and their literature)
- asymptotic safety as held by science (Weinberg 1976, Reuter 1996)
- the idea of Belinfante-Rosenfeld stress-energy tensor, as held by science
- the idea of Big Bang, as held by science
- the Big Bounce hypothesis (contraction, bounce, expansion), as held by science
- the idea of Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR), as held by science
- bosonic string theory as held by science (a superseded model)
- canonical loop quantum gravity as held by science (Ashtekar variables, Thiemann's Hamiltonian)
- the idea of Canonical (Noether) stress-energy tensor, as held by science
- causal dynamical triangulation as held by science (Loll, Ambjorn, Jurkiewicz)
- the idea of Causal future (absolute future), as held by science
- the idea of Causal past (absolute past), as held by science
- the causal set element as a concept held by science
- causal set theory as held by science (Sorkin; Bombelli, Lee, Meyer, Sorkin 1987)
- the causal set as a concept held by science
- the idea of Causal spacetime, as held by science
- the idea of Causally continuous spacetime, as held by science
- the idea of Causally simple spacetime, as held by science
- the chameleon model (screened scalar dark energy) as proposed, tested and held by science
- the idea of Chronological spacetime, as held by science
- the idea of the Closed timelike curve as held by science (general relativity: the theory, its exact solutions and their literature)
- the idea of Closed universe (positive curvature), as held by science
- the idea of a particle collision event as held by science, 'modeled by scattering theory based on an underlying quantum field theory'
- the idea of complexified Minkowski spacetime as held by science: 'a new model to present the states of a two-state quantum system' (Friedman 2021)
- Penrose's conformal cyclic cosmology, as held by science
- the idea of Cosmological component, as held by science
- the cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy) as a term of the field equations and the simplest model of dark energy, as held by science
- the idea of the Cosmological event horizon as held by science (general relativity: the theory, its exact solutions and their literature)
- the idea of Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical), as held by science
- the CPT-symmetric (universe/anti-universe) model, as held by science
- the Steinhardt-Turok cyclic model, as held by science
- the idea of Dark energy, as held by science
- the idea of de Sitter spacetime, as held by science
- the idea of particle decay as held by science: a Poisson process with mean lifetime tau, described with the same terminology as radioactive decay
- the idea of Distinguishing spacetime, as held by science
- the idea of Dominant energy condition (DEC), as held by science
- the idea of Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0), as held by science
- the ekpyrotic (colliding-brane) model of the origin of the hot Big Bang, as held by science
- the idea of Electromagnetic stress-energy tensor, as held by science
- the idea of Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical), as held by science
- the idea of emission as held by science: Einstein's 1916 rate coefficients and Dirac's quantum theory of radiation
- the idea of Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy), as held by science
- the idea of Euclidean space as held by science: 'introduced ... as an abstraction of human-observed physical space', collected in Euclid's Elements and re-formalised after non-Euclidean geometries
- the idea of the Event horizon as held by science (general relativity: the theory, its exact solutions and their literature)
- the idea of Flat universe (zero curvature), as held by science
- the idea of Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime, as held by science
- the idea of Galilean relativity and its group of motions (Galileo 1638, Newton's absolute space and time) as held by science
- the idea of Minkowski spacetime in any number of dimensions as held by science, used 'in theories where spacetime is assumed to have more or less than 4 dimensions'
- the idea of Globally hyperbolic spacetime, as held by science
- the idea of the Goedel universe as held by science (general relativity: the theory, its exact solutions and their literature)
- … 1195 more
expressed by (42)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Search/Foraging
- Mapping/Modeling
- Navigation/Pathfinding
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Risk-managed Exploration
- Intrinsic Motivation / Curiosity-Driven Sampling
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Multi-Scale Data Fusion / Triangulation
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Surprise / Change-Point Detection
- Frontier Outposts / Sensing Extension
- Hypothesis Portfolio / Multiple Hypothesis Tracking
- Optimal Stopping & Patch-Switching
- Offline Simulation & Replay-Guided Planning
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Overcome Barrier
- Reactive Response
- Proactive Defense
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Technique-Based Identification (a.k.a. Technique-Based Detection)
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Deterrence
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (225)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Weak field
- Dark energy
- Black hole
- Helium hydride ion (HeH+)
- Hard partons / jets
- Stellar magnetic field
- Earth's crust (primordial, oceanic and continental)
- Primordial black hole
- Moon (Earth's natural satellite)
- Comet
- Galactic bulge
- Strangelet
- Seafloor sediment (marine sediment)
- Ocean currents (the ocean circulation)
- Social contagion
- Gamma-ray burst
- Mineral surfaces (rock and grain surfaces at a planet's surface)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)
- Special relativity
- J/psi and open-charm hadrons for the charm quarks of a quark-gluon plasma
- Air shower (extensive air shower; secondary cosmic rays)
- Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking)
- Extragalactic cosmic rays
- Intergalactic magnetic field
- Cyclic model (Steinhardt-Turok, periodic brane collisions; hypothetical)
- Ekpyrotic universe (colliding-brane origin of the hot Big Bang; hypothetical)
- Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical)
- No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical)
- Phantom dark energy (phantom energy; hypothesised)
- Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical)
- Quintom dark energy (quintom scenario; hypothesised)
- Interacting dark energy (coupled dark sector; hypothesised)
- Chameleon dark energy (chameleon field; hypothesised)
- Cosmological component
- CNO cycle (carbon-nitrogen-oxygen cycle)
- String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model)
- Dynamical Casimir effect
- Casimir-Polder force
- Unruh effect (Fulling-Davies-Unruh effect)
- Hawking radiation
- Graviton (hypothetical quantum of gravity)
- Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical)
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
- Bosonic string theory (projected model; the original string theory)
- Superstring theory (projected model; supersymmetric string theory)
- M-theory (projected model; conjectured eleven-dimensional theory behind the superstring theories)
- Stress-energy-momentum pseudotensor (gravitational energy-momentum)
- Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy)
- Collision (encounter) event
- Observation or absorption event
- Complexified Minkowski spacetime
- Primordial gravitational waves (inflationary tensor modes)
- Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical)
- Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical)
- Electroweak baryogenesis
- CP violation
- CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical)
- Theory of everything (projected model; final theory)
- Self-interacting dark matter
- 't Hooft-Polyakov monopole
- Yang-Mills theory
- Lanthanides (the 4f series, La-Lu; as an opacity source in kilonovae)
- X boson (X and Y bosons; hypothetical GUT gauge bosons)
- Mineral
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense)
- Quark epoch
- Proton-proton chain
- Intrinsic magnetosphere
- Magnetar magnetosphere
- Spectroscopy
- Quantum Einstein gravity (walked as a projected model)
- Two-dimensional causal dynamical triangulation (2D CDT)
- Tipler cylinder
- Van Stockum dust
- Poincare dodecahedral space
- Domain wall network
- FLRW dust (matter-dominated Friedmann models)
- Dust solution
- … 145 more
represents (5)
- Grammar (the structure of a language, as linguistics describes it)
- Positional (place-value) notation with zero
- Alphabet (one letter per phoneme)
- Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy)
- Chemical kinetics
Kinds (1)
wired (11)
- Star
- Supernova
- Neutron star
- Galaxy
- White dwarf
- Special relativity
- General relativity
- Observable universe
- Weakly deflected light ray
- ATLAS detector and trigger
- Oklo natural nuclear reactors
Notes published science
- Science tests its own immune system: in 1998 researchers sent peer reviewers a fictitious manuscript with planted errors to see what review catches, and most reviewers missed that the conclusions did not follow from the results.
- Wrong results win the attention race: non-replicable papers in top journals are cited more than reproducible ones, and after a failed replication only 12% of citing papers mention it.
- When journals agree to publish before seeing the results, 61% of studies come back null, against 5-20% before: the published record had been filtering for surprise.
- Science really does 'advance one funeral at a time': when one of 452 star life scientists died early, outsiders' papers in that star's subfield rose by 8.6%, and those papers were more often highly cited (src:azoulay-2019-funeral).
- Joseph Needham's verdict after decades on Chinese science: 'China was homeostatic, but never stagnant' (src:wp:joseph-needham).
- Forgetting costs energy: erasing one bit must dump at least kT ln 2 of entropy as heat, but any computation can in principle be done without that toll if it keeps a copy of its input. The physicist who wrote the notes defending this, Charles Bennett, won computer science's top prize, the Turing Award, for 2025 (src:bennett-2003, src:wp:turing-award).
- A political science experiment did not just measure an election, it changed it: one message shown to 61 million Facebook users in the 2010 US congressional elections added about 340,000 votes, and most of that came from close friends passing it on, not from the message itself (src:bond-2012).
- Environmental science has its own rich-get-richer bias: in 78 journals over 2000-2009, the top-20 chemicals took 12% of all chemical mentions and their ranking barely moved, while in the early 1980s 78% of the most-produced industrial chemicals had not even been minimally tested (src:grandjean-2011).
- About a fifth of all the energy humanity uses goes simply to overcoming friction, and another 3% to remaking parts that wore out; and the whole science of thermodynamics began as engineers trying to make steam engines burn less coal (src:holmberg-erdemir-2017, src:saslow-2020-thermodynamics).
- A robot lab announced 41 new compounds in 17 days; after other chemists checked, the paper was corrected in 2026 to say they were 'new to the prediction platform, not necessarily new to science' (src:szymanski-2023-alab, src:szymanski-2026-alab-correction, src:cheetham-seshadri-2024).
- Failing teaches, but only past a threshold: in tens of thousands of startup careers (and in science grants), people who eventually succeed and people who never do look alike at the start, yet the eventual winners' gaps between attempts shrink as a power law, and the two groups can be told apart by the second failure. The model behind it has a phase transition (src:yin-2019-failure-dynamics).
- Consciousness researchers mostly think science can fully explain consciousness biologically (67.3%), yet nearly all of them (89.6%) also think Mary, a colour scientist who knows every physical fact about vision, learns something new the first time she sees red; the survey did not ask them where they stand on mind and body (src:francken-2022).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
light and radiation into scientific instruments
- L1: Electromagnetic radiation emitted, absorbed or reflected by distant objects; only visible, near-infrared and part of the radio band reach the ground
- L2: The objective (light-gathering element): lenses, curved mirrors, radio dishes, glancing-incidence and coded-aperture optics; balloons and satellites above the atmosphere
- L3: The image "observed, photographed, studied, and sent to a computer"; measurements carrying uncertainty estimates from repeated measurement and error propagation
- L4: Analysis: statistics to "assess the reliability of experimental results"; correlating several dishes (aperture synthesis); significance tests against a threshold
- L5: Interpretation through theory: "there is no pure observation as theory is required to interpret empirical data"
mental representation: beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions
- L6: Experiments performed before the members; the Royal Society's code of experiment, "trustworthy because witnessed by its members"
- L7: Thought collectives: a thought-style "instilled through the experience of learning", largely invisible to members (Fleck)
speech at meetings, lectures and conferences (sound)
- L1: Speech in air at weekly society meetings, lectures and conferences
- L2: Discussion and debate within conferences; "regular conferences for the presentation and discussion of new research results"
the scientific record: papers, journals and archives (written marks)
- L1: Written and printed text: Babylonian records of the motions of the stars, planets and moon "left on thousands of clay tablets created by scribes"; manuscripts, printed books (movable type from about 1440), journals, digital archives
- L2: The scientific article: research "normally expressed in the form of a scientific article", with mathematics, statistics and reporting guidelines
- L3: Peer review: desk evaluation by the editor, then anonymous external referees who recommend accept, revise or reject; grant panels for proposals
- L4: Publication in a journal, "an archival record of science"; archived data and methods; citation
- L5: Replication by independent researchers, metascience, replication databases, retraction
- L6: The community: learned societies, academies, conferences, funding agencies; consensus and paradigms ("a logically consistent portrait of the world"); norms (communism, universalism, disinterestedness, organized skepticism) and counter-norms
- L7: The goal: "the extension of certified knowledge"; knowledge "in the form of testable explanations about nature and society"
Who fills each layer
- L1: Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy), Stress-energy-momentum pseudotensor (gravitational energy-momentum), Hyperbolic trajectory, Orbital elements, Comet, TRAPPIST-1 system, Experiment, measurement and uncertainty (the physics lab as a practice: designing, measuring, estimating error), Economics (the field)
- L2: Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical), Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical), CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical), Cyclic model (Steinhardt-Turok, periodic brane collisions; hypothetical), Ekpyrotic universe (colliding-brane origin of the hot Big Bang; hypothetical), Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical), Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical), No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical), Two-dimensional causal dynamical triangulation (2D CDT), Mineral, Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter), Laboratory dynamo (liquid-sodium dynamo experiments)
- L3: Collision (encounter) event, Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest), Resonance, Elliptic orbit, Weakly deflected light ray, Primordial black hole evaporation, Strangelet, Terbium (Tb, Z = 65), Lanthanides (the 4f series, La-Lu; as an opacity source in kilonovae)
- L4: Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest), Germ theory of disease with Koch's postulates (one microbe, one disease, four tests), Exterior field of a compact star, Exterior field of a planet, Calabi-Yau manifold, Compact extra dimensions, Eleven-dimensional spacetime (M-theory, supergravity), Five-dimensional spacetime (Kaluza-Klein), 2 + 1 dimensional Minkowski spacetime, Steady-state universe (Bondi-Gold, Hoyle 1948), Two-dimensional causal dynamical triangulation (2D CDT), Exterior field of a neutron star
- L5: Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy), Gravitational constant G, Hypersurface (codimension-one submanifold of spacetime), Dijkgraaf-Witten model (topological gauge theory with a finite gauge group; walked as an idea), Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea), Chaos and nonlinear dynamics (the practice, and the chaotic behaviour it studies), Mathematics (the field: the practice and the structures it studies)
- L6: Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical), Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical), Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy), Maxwell's equations (classical electromagnetism as a codified law set), Bosonic string theory (projected model; the original string theory), Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it), No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical), M-theory (projected model; conjectured eleven-dimensional theory behind the superstring theories), Stress-energy-momentum pseudotensor (gravitational energy-momentum), String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model), String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything), Superstring theory (projected model; supersymmetric string theory)
- L7: Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR), Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical), CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical), Cyclic model (Steinhardt-Turok, periodic brane collisions; hypothetical), Ekpyrotic universe (colliding-brane origin of the hot Big Bang; hypothetical), Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest), Germ theory of disease with Koch's postulates (one microbe, one disease, four tests), Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical), Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it), M-theory (projected model; conjectured eleven-dimensional theory behind the superstring theories), String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything), Superstring theory (projected model; supersymmetric string theory)