← all systems · see it in The System
Religion
Religion is a range of social-cultural systems, including designated behaviors and practices, ethics, morals, beliefs, worldviews, texts, sanctified places, prophecies, or organizations, that generally relate humanity to supernatural, transcendental, and spiritual elements, although there is no scholarly consensus over what precisely constitutes a religion. It is an essentially contested concept.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | contested: burial with grave goods and red ochre from about 100,000 years ago; oldest religious text about 2600 BCE |
| born precision | tens of millennia |
| boundary | Inside: the beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, "things set apart and forbidden", and those who adhere to them, with a definition of what constitutes adherence or membership. Outside: the profane, other traditions and the religiously unaffiliated. The boundary itself is contested: scholars disagree on a definition, and social constructionists argue the category is a modern Western one. |
| nested level | Built from human members, their rituals, sacred texts and specialists (shamans, clergy); embedded in culture (Geertz: "a cultural system") and, since the Neolithic, often bound up with the state. Rides on language and on ordinary human cognition (agent detection, theory of mind). |
| scale | social |
Measures (41) published science
| characteristic clock: calendrical rites | weekly, monthly or yearly cycles |
| characteristic clock: doctrinal-mode ritual (e.g. daily recitations of sacred texts) | daily (frequent, routinized) per day |
| characteristic clock: transmission between generations (religious legacy from parents) | one human generation (no figure given) |
| clock: secular 19th-century US communes | majority failed within 8 years |
| communes still functioning 20 years after founding (religious vs secular; ~200 communes) | 39 vs 6 % |
| communes coded for costly requirements | 83 19th-century U.S. communes |
| fire-walk duration analysed | 30 min |
| fire-walk sample (fire-walkers / related spectators / unrelated spectators) | 12 / 9 / 17 people |
| moralistic-god study sample | 591 participants, 35,400 observations, 8 field sites count |
| odds ratio for a coin to a distant co-religionist per unit of god punishment/knowledge belief | 1.11-1.23 odds ratio |
| rituals tested for imagistic/doctrinal clustering | 645 rituals (HRAF) |
| distinct religions worldwide | about 10,000 religions |
| share of world population in Christianity, Islam, Hinduism and Buddhism | over 73 % |
| earliest known modern-human burial with grave goods and red ocher (Qafzeh) | 100,000 years ago |
| oldest known religious text (Kesh Temple Hymn) | around 2600 BCE |
| printing press begins mass production of religious texts | 1440 CE |
| neocortex share of brain, chimpanzee vs modern human | 50 vs 80 % |
| Christians in Africa, 1900 vs recent estimate | 10 million vs about 200 million people |
| Hutterite colony size at fission (97 fissions, 1880-1970) | 166.5 ± 25.8 SD people |
| characteristic clock: interval between Hutterite fissions (the carry's wait) | 14.3 (range 4-39) years |
| Hutterite population growth rate | 4.5 (Schmiedenleut), 4.1 (Lehrerleut) % per year |
| 19th-century US commune survival, religious vs secular (mean) | 35.6 ± 32.5 vs 7.7 ± 8.0 years |
| community size maximising longevity, religious vs secular communes | 171.1 vs 64.4 people |
| adults leaving religion per adult joining from no religion (ages 18-54, 117 countries) | 3.2 : 1 ratio |
| Christianity: left per joined | 3.1 : 1.0 ratio |
| Christians worldwide, 2020 | 2.3 billion (28.8%) people |
| Muslim growth 2010-2020 | +347 million; share 25.6% people |
| religiously unaffiliated, 2020 | 1.9 billion (24.2%), +270 million people |
| Hindus worldwide, 2020 | 1.2 billion people |
| Buddhists worldwide, 2020 | 324 million (down 19 million) people |
| Jews worldwide, 2020 | 14.8 million people |
| share attending a religious service in the past year, southern Sweden 2008 (n=24,855) | 13.9 % |
| nucleus accumbens activation before peak spiritual feeling | 1-3 s |
| devout Mormons scanned | 19 people |
| fire-walk heart-rate participants | 38 people |
| Marathi Hindu participants, ritual-anxiety study | 75 people |
| moralizing-gods economic games sample | 2228 participants, 15 populations people |
| Austronesian cultures in the moralizing-gods phylogeny | 96 cultures |
| Austronesian cultures in the sacrifice phylogeny | 93 cultures |
| societies coded in the retracted moralizing-gods analysis | 414 societies, 30 regions, 10,000 years |
| penetrating brain-injury patients vs controls (mystical experience) | 116 vs 32 people |
Open contentions (5) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-959 Did belief in moralising gods come before or after large complex societies?
booked: The map keeps the findings that broad supernatural punishment came first and moralising high gods followed in Austronesian societies, and notes that a 2019 study arguing the order was retracted in 2021.
the other reading: moralizing high gods enabled large-scale cooperation and complex societies (MHG hypothesis); moralizing gods follow megasocieties (Whitehouse et al. 2019, retracted 2021 after Beheim et al. 2021 showed missing-data treatment determined the result); broad supernatural punishment, not high gods, came first (Watts 2015) - C-970 What is religion?
booked: The map doesn't pick a definition. It describes religion by what it does in a group (practices, beliefs and communities that relate people to what each tradition holds sacred) and lists the definitions alongside.
the other reading: Durkheim: a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, uniting a moral community; Geertz: a cultural system; Asad: an anthropological category; social constructionism: a modern Western concept modelled on the Abrahamic religions; an essentially contested concept (encyclopedia) - C-971 How did religion originate?
booked: The map doesn't rule and lists each account side by side.
the other reading: cognitive by-product (agent detection, theory of mind, minimally counterintuitive concepts); adaptation for cooperation (costly signals, supernatural punishment); meme / 'mind virus' (Dawkins); awareness of individual death, a sense of community, dreams (encyclopedia: 'an open question') - C-972 What is religious experience?
booked: The map leaves what religious experience is to each tradition, and records the brain activity measured alongside it without treating that as its cause or as explaining it away.
the other reading: each tradition's own account (e.g. 'feeling the Spirit'); neural account: reward and salience networks, executive down-regulation; social-learning account: a feeling learned and named in devotional practice - C-976 Is the world becoming less religious?
booked: The map keeps both: growing non-affiliation in many countries, and much of the world staying religious, with global religiosity possibly rising through birth rates.
the other reading: rationalist secularization: science's rise marginalizes belief; religious economy: state monopolies, not modernity, depress religiosity; Berger: much of the world as religious as ever
Cross-scale patterns seen here (10) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Religion. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- borrowed-then-held (structural)
Religious concepts first ride on mechanisms "functional outside of the context of religion" (agent detection, theory of mind: a spandrel or exaptation, Gould), then cultural traditions "have recruited such beliefs to motivate prosocial behaviour" (dual inheritance). - templating (structural)
Canon, from a Greek word for "a cane used as a measuring instrument": "measure, standard, norm, rule"; ritual's restricted code and invariant choreography repeat the same form in every performance. - holding / entrainment (partial)
Calendrical rites hold a community to repetitive weekly, monthly or yearly cycles; in Bali the ritual calendar of the water temples schedules irrigation across the whole system. - outside-to-inside (partial)
Group scrutiny of behaviour, done by other members in primate groups, is carried inside as "ever-watchful ancestors, spirits and gods" (Rossano); belief in a knowing god goes with impartial play in private (Purzycki). - partner-becomes-part (partial)
Religious and political authority fuse in theocracies, "with chiefs, kings and emperors playing dual roles of political and spiritual leaders"; secularization later separates them again. - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
Two modes from one ritual toolkit: imagistic (rare, high-arousal, episodic memory, small exclusive groups, identity fusion) and doctrinal (frequent, low-arousal, semantic memory, large inclusive communities, categorical bonds); clustering confirmed in 645 HRAF rituals. - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
Organized religion traces its roots to the Neolithic Revolution in the Near East "but may have occurred independently in several other locations"; virtually all state societies and chiefdoms justify political power through divine authority. - seed (partial)
A small grammar of memorable concepts: standard ontological categories (person, artifact, animal, plant, natural object) with one or two violated expectations make minimally counterintuitive concepts that are easier to remember and retell; there are an estimated 10,000 distinct religions. - who opens the door (partial)
Shared arousal at the fire-walk reached related spectators and "did not extend to non-related spectators": the receiving door is already set by social ties. Ritual speech likewise lands in a formal code that authority obliges participants to use. - lightning (surface)
Collective effervescence: on the rare occasions the whole tribe gathers, "a sense of heightened energy and unity" emerges and is projected onto objects; Gluckman's rituals of rebellion release tensions cyclically. Build-up and release, but held in a ritual frame.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (67) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Primate social group via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Religion gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Language (human language) via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Religion gain
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Religion gain
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Religion mixed
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions) via sys:mental-representation · Religion gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:mental-representation · Religion mixed
- Human brain via sys:human-brain · Religion gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Dance via sys:sensory-environment · Religion gain
- Story (narrative) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Religion gain
- Religiously unaffiliated ('nones') via sys:human · Religion loss
- Ritual via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) via sys:written-record · Religion mixed
- School via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Sport via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Painting via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Sculpture via sys:mental-representation · Religion gain
- Ancient Egypt (the civilization across time) via sys:mental-representation · Religion gain
- Ancient Greece (the Greek city-state world across time) via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Middle Ages via sys:mental-representation · Religion gain
- Renaissance (European period and cultural movement, c. 14th-17th centuries) via sys:religion · Religion mixed
- Black Death (the mid-fourteenth-century plague pandemic) via sys:religion · Religion mixed
- Ottoman Empire (from Osman's beylik, c. 1299, to the abolition of the sultanate in 1922) via sys:religion · Religion gain
- Silk Road via sys:religion · Religion gain
- Socialization via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Human culture via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Nationalism via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Human cultures (anthropology) via sys:mental-representation · Religion gain
- Literature via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Institution (social) via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Ethics (moral philosophy: the study and the morality it studies) via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- History (the field) via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Mughal Empire (from Babur's victory at Panipat, 1526, to the deposition of Bahadur Shah Zafar, 1857) via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- History of science (the field and the story it tells) via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Art history (the field) via sys:human-society · Religion even
- Museum via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Abbasid Caliphate (750-1258, with its ceremonial Cairo line to 1517) via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Thirteen Colonies · Religion gain
- Reconstruction era · Religion gain
- Mali Empire (Manden; the West African empire c. 1235 to c. 1600) via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Protestant Reformation (the 16th-century religious movements in Western Christianity, and the confessions, states and wars they shaped, from 1517 to a contested end) via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Cave painting via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Art of ancient Egypt via sys:mental-representation · Religion gain
- Ethnic group via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Globalization via sys:human-culture · Religion gain
- Colonialism via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Scramble for Africa (the partition and conquest of Africa, c. 1881-1914) via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Curriculum via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Old English literature via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Middle English literature via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Nursing (the field: the practice and the care it gives) via sys:sensory-environment · Religion gain
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on) via sys:sensory-environment · Religion mixed
- Social structure via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Epistemology (the theory of knowledge: the study and the knowing it studies) via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Metaphysics (the branch of philosophy: its practice and the questions about reality it works on) via sys:human-society · Religion mixed
- Ancient Greek art via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Drama (the literary form) via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Infinity: the boundless or endless as mathematics and philosophy describe it (potential and actual infinity, Cantor's sizes of infinity, infinity in calculus, geometry, physics and computing) and the practice of the people who argue over it via sys:sensory-environment · Religion even
- Gender via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- Free will via sys:sensory-environment · Religion gain
- Chinese art via sys:mental-representation · Religion gain
- Ancient Greek philosophy via sys:acoustic-wave · Religion mixed
- Mind–body problem (how mental states relate to physical states) · Religion gain
- Truth via sys:human-society · Religion gain
- American literature via sys:written-record · Religion mixed
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (17)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Ritual
- Religious text (scripture)
- Clergy and ritual specialists
- Congregation / local religious community
- Competition between religious and secular authority over public institutions (secularization)
- Civilization
- Reformation against the Roman Church
- Intergroup conflict sustained by sacred values
- Human cultures (anthropology)
- Censorship of literature
- Thirteen Colonies
- The papal schism (from 1378)
- Enlightenment against Counter-Enlightenment: the contest over authority in belief and politics
- State and Church competing for primary schooling (France)
- Aniconic rules against figurative sculpture
- Aten reform against the Amun priesthood over religion and its art
Sits inside / holds (6)
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Ritual
- Renaissance (European period and cultural movement, c. 14th-17th centuries)
- Protestant Reformation (the 16th-century religious movements in Western Christianity, and the confessions, states and wars they shaped, from 1517 to a contested end)
expressed by (22)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Search/Foraging
- Mapping/Modeling
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Quick Harm Avoidance
- Reactive Response
- Proactive Defense
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
- Deterrence
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (56)
- Metabolite pool (small molecules made, carried and turned over in a cell)
- Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Ritual
- Religious text (scripture)
- Clergy and ritual specialists
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)
- Written record (durable external marks: texts, archives, canon)
- Human brain
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Story (narrative)
- Congregation / local religious community
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Law (rules and law)
- School
- Empire
- Dance
- Sport
- Painting
- Sculpture
- Native peoples of North America (Indigenous peoples of North America, across time)
- Civilization
- Ancient Egypt (the civilization across time)
- Mesopotamia (the society of the land between the rivers, across time)
- Ancient Greece (the Greek city-state world across time)
- Ancient India (the Indian subcontinent's societies from the Indus cities to the Gupta empire)
- Middle Ages
- Renaissance (European period and cultural movement, c. 14th-17th centuries)
- Black Death (the mid-fourteenth-century plague pandemic)
- Ottoman Empire (from Osman's beylik, c. 1299, to the abolition of the sultanate in 1922)
- Silk Road
- Social stratification
- Human culture
- Society as sociologists see it (sociology's object: social structure and social action)
- Human cultures (anthropology)
- Mughal Empire (from Babur's victory at Panipat, 1526, to the deposition of Bahadur Shah Zafar, 1857)
- Abbasid Caliphate (750-1258, with its ceremonial Cairo line to 1517)
- Thirteen Colonies
- Reconstruction era
- Inca Empire (Tawantinsuyu)
- Cave painting
- Art of ancient Egypt
- Colonialism
- Scramble for Africa (the partition and conquest of Africa, c. 1881-1914)
- Old English literature
- Middle English literature
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
- Social structure
- Ancient Greek art
- Drama (the literary form)
- Free will
- Chinese art
- Kinship
- Mind–body problem (how mental states relate to physical states)
- Truth
- American literature
Kinds (12)
- Institution (social)
- Agents of socialization
- Abrahamic religions
- Indian (dharmic) religions
- East Asian (Taoic) religions
- Folk religions
- Indigenous religions
- New religious movements
- World religions
- Universal religions
- Ethnic religions
- Aztec religion
wired (3)
Notes published science
- Hutterite farm colonies split like clockwork: once a colony grows past about 150 people it divides, at an average size of 166.5, roughly every 14 years, with one half starting over on new land (Dunbar & Sosis 2018, src:dunbar-sosis-2018).
- In devout Mormons, the brain's reward hub (nucleus accumbens) lit up 1 to 3 seconds before people pressed a button to say they were 'feeling the Spirit' (src:ferguson-2018).
- At a Spanish fire-walk, the walkers' heartbeats fell into step with their relatives and friends in the crowd, but not with strangers standing beside them watching the same thing (src:konvalinka-2011).
- When a Lahore mental hospital had to be split by religion, the patients waited years because there was nowhere to send them; when the Amritsar asylum was finally built, it took 450 in 1950, kept 282 and sent the rest on to Ranchi. Manto turned the exchange into 'Toba Tek Singh' (src:jokinen-assadullah-2022).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
goods, food and labour (offerings, sacrifice, feasts, taxes)
- L1: Food, animals and goods given or consumed in rites: special food, drink, sacrifices, feasts
- L2: Consecration of the offering, which "is usually destroyed in the ritual to transfer it to the deities" (Mauss)
- L3: Gift exchanges of pigs between tribal groups in Papua New Guinea
- L4: Redistribution: local surpluses of pig distributed as pork; high quality protein when people are most in need of it
- L5: The central authority's right to collect taxes in return for social and security services, justified by organized religion
light: images, symbols and sacred texts
- L1: Light from pigments, images and inscriptions: red ocher from at least 100,000 years ago; Upper Paleolithic cave art
- L2: Representational art anchoring supernatural beings in material form, so the concepts become easier to communicate and understand
- L3: Consecration: particular objects become sacral symbols by being set apart from the profane; the totem becomes a collective representation of the group
- L4: Sacred texts: the Kesh Temple Hymn (c. 2600 BCE), Pyramid Texts (2400-2300 BCE), Rigveda (1500 BCE); information not easy to remember stored in writing
- L5: Canon: a "catalogue of sacred scriptures"; authority derived from ratification, enforcement and use across generations; texts maintained by a select group (clergy)
- L6: Coherent doctrinal systems independent of time and place; mass production and distribution after the printing press (1440)
mental representation: beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions
- L2: The hazard-precaution system, which ritual triggers; it "associates individual, unmanageable anxieties with coordinated action with others"
- L3: Minimally counterintuitive concepts: mostly fit human preconceptions but break with them in one or two striking ways, so they are easy to remember and easy to use
- L4: Myth and sacred history: "a story that is important for the group, whether or not it is objectively or provably true", preserved in oral traditions | Memory systems: imagistic rituals generate vivid, flashbulb-like episodic memories; doctrinal repetition is stored in procedural and semantic memory
- L5: Agent detection, causal narrative (etiology) and theory of mind, which "allow human beings to imagine purposeful agents behind many observations"; the hyperactive agency detection device
- L7: Ritual authority: performatives that cannot be contradicted ("I do thee wed"); ritual supports traditional forms of hierarchy and authority; shamans and clergy as specialists | The moral community: beliefs and practices "which unite into one single moral community called a Church, all those who adhere to them"; communal rites where a community comes together to worship
religion: lived experience to the sacred (reader's view)
- L1: People's lives, bodies, goods and misfortunes: the problems of human life religion takes up
- L2: Members' bodies and brains take in rite, word and image: shared arousal, reward, social cognition in prayer
- L3: Memorable concepts and fixed forms: minimally counterintuitive ideas, restricted ritual speech, consecrated symbols
- L4: Practices: rituals, sermons, prayer, sacrifice, festivals, initiation, meditation, music, dance
- L5: The community and its specialists (b-congregation)
- L6: Shared belief: doctrine, myth, sacred history (b-doctrine)
- L7: The sacred order, held as each tradition's own; ritual authority; the moral community (b-sacred)
ritual arousal and cognition (electrochemical signalling in participants)
- L1: Heart and nerve signalling in each participant, recorded as heart rate through a 30-minute fire-walk
- L2: Shared arousal: strong alignment among the heart rates of fire-walkers and related spectators
- L6: Group bonds: identity fusion from rare dysphoric rituals; diffuse, categorical bonds with larger communities from frequent low-arousal rituals
sacred texts: the written record (tablets, manuscripts, canon, print)
- L1: Inscribed clay tablets (the Kesh Temple Hymn of Sumer, c. 2600 BCE), papyrus and manuscripts
- L2: Writing "was initially used for accounting. Soon after, writing was used to record myth"
- L4: Sacred texts: the Kesh Temple Hymn (c. 2600 BCE), Pyramid Texts (2400-2300 BCE), Rigveda (1500 BCE); information not easy to remember stored in writing
- L5: Canon: a "catalogue of sacred scriptures"; authority derived from ratification, enforcement and use across generations; texts maintained by a select group (clergy)
- L6: Coherent doctrinal systems independent of time and place; mass production and distribution after the printing press (1440)
speech, chant and music as sound (oral tradition, sermon, prayer)
- L1: Sound in air from ritual speech and music: special gestures and words, recitation of fixed texts, performance of special music, songs or dances
- L2: Ritual's "restricted code": a formal oratorical style limited in intonation, syntax, vocabulary, loudness, and fixity of order
- L7: Dealing with "problems of human life that are significant, persistent, and intolerable", by a set of ideas that lets people accommodate anxieties and deal with misfortune
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The community and its specialists: congregations, clergy and ritual specialists, institutions that hold the movement
- L6: Shared belief: doctrine, myth and sacred history, collective representations held by the group
- L7: The sacred order: what the tradition relates humanity to (supernatural, transcendental, spiritual), held as each tradition's own claim; ritual authority; the moral community
way in: Members: born, raised, joining and leaving
- L1: People born to members: natural increase is greater for groups with higher fertility and lower mortality
- L2: Raised in a religion: most people still identify with the religion in which they were raised
- L3: Switching in and out between childhood and adulthood (3.2 leave religion for every 1 who joins, ages 18-54, 117 countries)
- L4: Adherence or membership defined by the group (initiation, rites of passage)
way in: Misfortune and anxiety
- L1: Anxiogenic situations in members' lives (in the study, anxiety induced by public speaking)
- L2: The hazard-precaution system, which ritual triggers
- L3: Habitual ritual in a temple: lower perceived anxiety and lower physiological anxiety (heart-rate variability)
- L4: Rites of affliction seek to mitigate spirits or forces inflicting misfortune; divination consults oracles for causes
way in: Offerings, food and labour
- L1: Food, animals and goods given or consumed in rites: special food, drink, sacrifices, feasts
- L2: Consecration of the offering, usually destroyed in the ritual to transfer it to the deity
- L3: Gift exchanges of pigs between tribal groups in Papua New Guinea
- L4: Redistribution: local surpluses distributed as pork when people most need protein
way in: Other religions, science and secular ideas (contact and competition)
- L1: Cultural exchange between complex societies
- L2: Competition for adherents between religious and irreligious segments of secular societies
- L3: Rationalist secularization theories: science's rise marginalizes belief; others note much of the world is as religious as ever
- L5: Syncretism: diverse beliefs and practices fused (Chinese folk religion)
way in: Political power and the state
- L1: Rulers and central authority collecting taxes in return for services
- L2: State religious monopoly or regulation restricting the supply of religion
- L4: Stratified societies: human sacrifice stabilizes stratification once it has arisen
way in: Religious experience (felt by members)
- L1: A devotee's brain and body during devotional practice (prayer, scripture study, music, quotations)
- L2: Reward circuitry: nucleus accumbens activation precedes peak spiritual feelings by 1-3 s
- L3: Social cognition in improvised prayer: temporopolar region, medial prefrontal cortex, temporo-parietal junction, precuneus; prayer read as intersubjective
- L4: Executive gate: the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex down-regulates mystical experience (lesions there raise it); the tradition trains members to recognise the feeling
way in: Sacred texts (the written record)
- L1: Inscribed clay tablets (the Kesh Temple Hymn of Sumer, c. 2600 BCE), papyrus and manuscripts
- L2: Writing used for accounting, then soon to record myth
- L4: Sacred texts: the Kesh Temple Hymn, Pyramid Texts, Rigveda; many traditions keep teachings by oral practice instead
- L5: Canon: a catalogue of sacred scriptures, authority by ratification, enforcement and use
way in: Shared arousal in collective ritual
- L1: Bodies of performers and onlookers in one place: heart rates during a 30-minute fire-walk
- L2: Synchronized arousal between fire-walkers and related spectators, not unrelated ones
- L3: Synchrony activates self-other overlap, perceived cooperation and the opioid system (pain threshold)
- L4: Prior social ties: only relatives and friends of performers share the arousal; the mechanism 'may be informational'
way in: Speech, chant and music (oral tradition, sermon, prayer)
- L1: Sound in air from ritual speech and music: special gestures and words, recitation of fixed texts, performance of special music, songs or dance
- L2: Ritual's restricted code: a formal oratorical style limited in intonation, syntax and vocabulary
- L3: Minimally counterintuitive concepts: mostly fit preconceptions but break one or two, so they are remembered and retold
- L4: Myth and sacred history retold: a story important for the group
way out: Fission: a daughter community on new land
- L1: One daughter community stays on the farm, the other starts a colony on new land
- L5: The colony splits when it overruns its limit (about 150, normative upper limit about 200)
way out: Legitimating political power
- L1: Taxes, rank and inherited class
- L5: Theocracy: rulers as political and spiritual leaders; sacrifice in stratified societies
- L7: Divine authority invoked for political power
way out: Moral norms and supernatural monitoring
- L1: Money shared with local and distant co-religionists and outsiders (2228 participants, 15 populations)
- L5: Social scrutiny extended to supernatural agents; barriers to exit from freedom of religion to death for apostasy
- L6: Moral norms and sacred values that work as imperatives immune to material incentives
- L7: Gods held to monitor and punish (each tradition's own claim)
way out: Offerings, sacrifice, temples and redistribution
- L1: Goods destroyed in the rite or redistributed as food
- L5: Temple economy and feasts; consecration
- L7: Transfer to the deity (the tradition's claim)
way out: Ritual performance
- L1: Bodies, chant and music in one place; fire-walkers and spectators together
- L5: Specialists lead; participants held to the formal style
- L6: Liturgy and calendar: weekly, monthly or yearly rites
- L7: Ritual authority: performatives that cannot be contradicted
way out: Teaching, example and mission
- L1: Children and converts who take up the religion
- L3: Instruction and the power of example
- L5: Parents, clergy and missionaries
- L6: Doctrine to be passed on
Who fills each layer
- L4: Ritual
- L5: Protestant Reformation (the 16th-century religious movements in Western Christianity, and the confessions, states and wars they shaped, from 1517 to a contested end)
- L6: Protestant Reformation (the 16th-century religious movements in Western Christianity, and the confessions, states and wars they shaped, from 1517 to a contested end)
- L7: Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)