← all systems · see it in The System
Middle English literature
Middle English literature is the literature written in Middle English, from the late 12th century until the 1470s (src:wp:middle-english-literature): walked as literary scholars describe it, the works (religious writing, romance and courtly love, Arthurian tales, Chaucer, Langland, the Gawain poet, Julian, Kempe, Malory, the play cycles, lyric, chronicle, science and medicine), the dialects and verse craft they are made in, the manuscripts and first printed books they survive in, and how they have been kept, lost, read and studied since.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | late 12th century |
| born precision | decades |
| boundary | Inside: the works written in Middle English (verse and prose, plays, lyrics, devotional, scientific and practical writing), the dialect spellings and verse forms they are made in, the manuscripts and the early printed books (to about 1500) that carry them, and their copying, keeping, loss, reading and study since. Outside, as partners: the Middle English language itself, French and Latin and their books, the Church, kings and patrons, the Black Death and the 1381 Rising, the sheep whose skins became parchment, Caxton's press, collectors and libraries, and the people who read it. |
| nested level | Part of English literature and of literature (L7 the literary culture), and of late medieval England's culture (the Middle Ages walk); built from works, manuscripts, prints and verse traditions. Runs on: people (writers, scribes, readers, Human L6-L7) and the Middle English language. What runs on it: retellings (Shakespeare and Fletcher's Two Noble Kinsmen), translations and collages, the 1381 rebels' use of Piers, corpora and AI study tools. |
| scale | social |
Measures (25) published science
| Span of the literature | late 12th century to the 1470s (transition to early Modern English to the mid-16th century) centuries |
| York cycle performance (characteristic clock) | 1 year (each feast of Corpus Christi, recorded from 1376 to suppression in 1569) |
| Manuscript half-life (Old French chivalric corpus, similar system) | about 20-35 years |
| Canterbury Tales manuscripts | 83 (Chaucer article) or 84 plus four incunabula (Tales article) manuscripts |
| Troilus and Criseyde manuscripts | 16 manuscripts |
| Prick of Conscience manuscripts | over 130 / about 130 manuscripts |
| Wycliffite manuscripts | over 250 (20 complete bibles; two thirds New Testament only) manuscripts |
| Prose Brut manuscripts | 181 (Matheson 1998, cited) manuscripts |
| Known Piers Plowman manuscripts | 29 before Skeat, 45 after; over fifty unique versions known today (SEENET, as cited) manuscripts |
| Fréchet variance of the three Piers versions | A 4338.38; B 2189.93; C 2713.33 (randomisation p = 3/5000 that B is least variable by chance) edit-distance variance |
| Prosodic variability, Gawain against Piers (220-line sample) | ratio 1773/1601 = 1.107, two-tailed p = 0.094 variance ratio |
| Prosodic variability, Piers against Gawain (Oakden's counts) | 193.15/35.33 = 5.47, one-sided p = 0/1000 variance ratio |
| Words first attested in Chaucerian manuscripts | almost 2,000 words |
| Caxton's output | as many as 108 books, 87 different titles, 26 translated by Caxton himself; four-fifths in English |
| Ormulum length | just under 19,000 lines |
| Ormulum: share of the promised work surviving | about one fifth fraction |
| Sir Gawain length | 2,530 lines in 101 stanzas |
| Piers Plowman B against A | B extends A by over 4000 lines |
| Canterbury Tales: written against planned | 24 tales written; four planned for each of some 30 pilgrims |
| York cycle size | 48 pageants |
| Index of Middle English Prose | 24 printed volumes so far, several more in progress |
| Polaris offset from the pole in Chaucer's time | about 4 degrees |
| Accuracy of an astrolabe built to Chaucer's plan | about 2-3 degrees in elevation; latitude and longitude to around 1 degree; time to within 30 minutes |
| Caxton's press set up | 1476 year |
| Words to print: Chaucer's death to first printed Tales | roughly 75 years |
Open contentions (9) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: the medieval faculty psychology Saunders sets out; divine revelation, as Julian and Kempe describe; modern accounts (see Human's thought channel) - C-2355 Was the alliterative revival a revival or a hidden continuity?
booked: The map keeps both readings.
the other reading: a conscious revival of an old artistic tradition; a tradition continuing in some form 1200-1350 with no poems surviving in writing - C-2356 How much did the Chancery Standard shape written English?
booked: The map keeps the influence as disputed.
the other reading: it provided the core around which Early Modern English formed; its influence is disputed (Middle English article) - C-2357 How many manuscripts of the Canterbury Tales survive?
booked: The map keeps the differing counts.
the other reading: Canterbury Tales: 83 manuscripts (Chaucer article) or 84 plus four incunabula (Tales article); Prick of Conscience: over 130 or about 130; Caxton's first printed Tales: 1476 (Tales article) or the first folio editions 1478 and 1483 (Chaucer article) - C-2358 Did one poet write Pearl and Sir Gawain?
booked: The map keeps authorship unproven.
the other reading: one poet, on stylistic and thematic similarities; not proven; John Massey of Cotton the most suggested candidate - C-2359 Why did Langland revise Piers Plowman?
booked: The map keeps the reasons open.
the other reading: a conservative revision disassociating the poem from Lollardy and John Ball's radicalism after 1381; other reasons for revision (not given in the sources read) - C-2360 Was Adam Pinkhurst Chaucer's scribe?
booked: The map keeps the identification as disputed.
the other reading: Scribe B (Hengwrt, Ellesmere) is Adam Pinkhurst, Chaucer's own scribe (Mooney 2006; widely accepted); doubt on palaeographical, literary and historical grounds (Roberts 2011; de Hamel 2016); Pinkhurst copied a Piers manuscript but not Hengwrt or Ellesmere (Warner 2015, 2018); the Adam Scriveyn poem itself is a disputed attribution - C-2361 Did Langland and the Gawain poet use the same metre?
booked: The map keeps both results.
the other reading: a 220-line sample: Langland and the Gawain poet plausibly use the same prosodic rules (p = 0.094); Oakden's full counts: Piers's metre about 5.5 times more variable (p < 0.001) - C-2362 Who made the Wycliffite Bible, and for whom?
booked: The map keeps the competing accounts.
the other reading: made by Wycliffe or his team to promote Wycliffite ideas; for Lollard public reading; orthodox translations by unknown Catholic translators, read by later Catholics
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (16)
- The Canterbury Tales
- Piers Plowman
- Sir Gawain and the Green Knight
- Pearl
- Prick of Conscience
- Wycliffite Bible
- York Mystery Plays
- Revelations of Divine Love (Julian of Norwich)
- The Book of Margery Kempe
- Le Morte d'Arthur
- Ormulum
- A Treatise on the Astrolabe
- Cotton Nero A.x (the Pearl manuscript)
- Hengwrt Chaucer
- Middle English alliterative verse
- English literature
Sits inside / holds (3)
Trades with (valence) (17)
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Middle English literature gain
- Religion via sys:human-society · Middle English literature mixed
- Printing press via sys:written-record · Middle English literature gain
- Large language model via sys:written-record · Middle English literature mixed
- Book via sys:written-record · Middle English literature gain
- Middle Ages via sys:earth · Middle English literature gain
- Black Death (the mid-fourteenth-century plague pandemic) via sys:human-society · Middle English literature mixed
- Literature via sys:written-record · Middle English literature gain
- Theatre via sys:sensory-environment · Middle English literature gain
- The archive and the historical record via sys:written-record · Middle English literature gain
- William Shakespeare via sys:written-record · Middle English literature gain
- Old English literature via sys:written-record · Middle English literature gain
- Anglo-Norman French via sys:human-society · Middle English literature mixed
- Middle English (the language) via sys:acoustic-wave · Middle English literature gain
- Sheep (parchment) via sys:parchment · Middle English literature gain
- The Peasants' Revolt (1381) via sys:human-society · Middle English literature mixed
- English literature via sys:written-record · Middle English literature even
expressed by (14)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
- Scheduled Build-and-Dismantle (On-Demand Structure)
floor filled by (23)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Religion
- Printing press
- Book
- Guilds and merchant leagues
- Black Death (the mid-fourteenth-century plague pandemic)
- William Shakespeare
- Scriptorium
- The Canterbury Tales
- Piers Plowman
- Sir Gawain and the Green Knight
- Wycliffite Bible
- Cotton Nero A.x (the Pearl manuscript)
- Hengwrt Chaucer
- Middle English alliterative verse
- Anglo-Norman French
- Middle English (the language)
- Sheep (parchment)
- Royal court
- Chancery Standard
- Index of Middle English Prose
- Early English Text Society
- English literature
Kinds (8)
- English literature
- Middle English religious writing
- Middle English romance and courtly love
- Middle English Arthurian literature
- Middle English lyric
- Mystery and miracle plays
- Morality plays
- Middle English prose
wired (3)
Notes published science
- Chaucer's Treatise on the Astrolabe, written for his ten-year-old son, is apparently the earliest technical manual in English, and it still works: a mathematician built an astrolabe to Chaucer's plan, used it for a few years, and measured the sizes of the planets' orbits with it, noticing on the way that Polaris sat about 4 degrees off the pole in Chaucer's day (src:robinson-2022-astrolabe).
- A late-15th-century English parchment birth girdle, written in English and laid on women in labour, still carries their proteins: rubbing it with an eraser picked up human peptides found in cervico-vaginal fluid, plus traces of honey, cereals, milk and legumes, and the text is worn illegible in places from being touched and kissed (src:fiddyment-2021-birth-girdle).
- In 1381 the rebels of Norfolk took the name hidden in Langland's poem, 'Will Long Will', as a pseudonym, and the chronicles then tied Piers Plowman to heresy and rebellion; some scholars read Langland's last version as a revision to pull the poem back from the Rising (src:wp:piers-plowman).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Middle English literature as literary scholars describe it: from the speech, books, verse tradition, faith, plague, revolt and skins it drew on, through households, cloisters, scriveners and the press, craft and works, to the manuscripts and early prints that carry it and the scholarship that reads it (reader's view)
- L1: What it drew on: spoken dialects, French and Latin books, popular romance and the alliterative tradition, the Church, plague and revolt, skins
- L2: Intake: patrons and households, translation, devotion and vision, readers' demand, the scientific and medical book
- L3: Routing: court and household, cloister and anchorhold, guilds and pageant wagons, London scribes, Caxton's shop
- L4: Craft: dialect verse and prose; the revived alliterative long line, the bob and wheel, rhyme, translation; the Chancery Standard
- L5: The works: religious, courtly and Arthurian; Chaucer, Langland, Gower, the Pearl poet, Julian, Kempe, Malory, the cycles, lyric
- L6: The manuscripts and early prints: copied, varied, worn, lost, collected; printed from 1476
- L7: Reading and afterlife: readers then; retellings, editions, catalogues, criticism, science and machines now
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Composition: verse in many dialects, the revived alliterative long line (aa/ax most common), alliteration bound with rhyme in the bob and wheel, rhymed verse and stanza-linking, prose of translation, homily, chronicle, vision and science; a London-based standard emerging from Chancery
- L5: The works: religious writing (the Katherine Group, Rolle, Julian, the Prick of Conscience, the Wycliffite Bible), romance and courtly love, Arthurian tales (Gawain, Malory), Chaucer, Langland, Gower, the Pearl poet, Kempe, lyric, the play cycles, chronicle (Layamon, the prose Brut), science and medicine
- L6: The manuscripts and early prints: no holograph of Chaucer; 83 or 84 manuscripts of the Tales, about 130 of the Prick, over 250 Wycliffite, 181 of the prose Brut; single copies of Gawain, Pearl, Kempe, the Ormulum; Caxton's editions from 1476
- L7: Reading and afterlife: readers and listeners then, retellings (Shakespeare and Fletcher), collectors, the Early English Text Society, critical editions, catalogues and corpora, criticism, the laboratory and computational sciences, translations and new works
way in: Caxton's press
- L1: The new printing industry in Cologne, then a press in Bruges with Colard Mansion
- L2: Demand: the success of his Troy translation
- L3: The press at Westminster, 1476
- L4: Choosing and fixing the text: dilemmas of dialect and standard; the Bible and Piers left out
- L5: Editions: the Canterbury Tales (1476), Malory (1485)
way in: Court, patrons and households
- L1: The court: Chaucer taken into the close court circle in his teens, there for life
- L2: Women as patrons, owners, occasional writers and above all readers
- L3: The commission: Margaret of York urged Caxton to finish his Troy translation (1471)
way in: Crown and Church as rule-makers
- L1: English back in Parliament and the courts (1362); the King's signet letters in English (1417)
- L2: Licensing: no new Bible translation without approval (1408); the York plays cut and then suppressed (1569)
- L3: The approved alternative: Arundel promoted Love's Meditations against Wycliffite lives of Christ
way in: Editors, cataloguers and corpus builders
- L1: What survives to be read: often one scribal copy, author unknown (Gawain)
- L2: The search for copies: Skeat raised the known Piers manuscripts from 29 to 45
- L3: Catalogues: the Index of Middle English Prose, 24 printed volumes so far
- L4: The critical edition: Skeat's three versions of Piers, his B-texts least variable
- L5: Editions in print: the Early English Text Society's Pearl, Patience and Cleanness (1864)
- L6: Computation: string statistics on alliterative lines, parsed corpora (PPCME2), language-model search over variant spellings
way in: French and Latin: the languages of power and the books translated
- L1: Law French in courts, parliament and polite society; Anglo-Norman or Latin for high culture and administration
- L2: Source books taken in: Wace's Anglo-Norman Brut for Layamon; French and English Arthurian sources for Malory; stories shared across vernaculars less likely to be lost in both
- L3: The translator: Caxton translated 26 of his titles himself; translation as the port where a foreign book becomes English
way in: Handling, error, wear and loss
- L1: Hands on the page: images touched, rubbed or kissed in devotion
- L2: Copying error: the scribe's 'negligence and haste', corrected by rubbing and scraping
- L3: Attrition: in a sister tradition a manuscript's half-life is some 20-35 years
- L5: What is left: a worn girdle with large sections illegible; the Ormulum a fifth of its plan; the original of Kempe lost
way in: Laboratory, instrument and model readings
- L1: The object: an English parchment birth girdle (Wellcome MS 632)
- L2: Sampling without harm: eraser samples analysed by MALDI-TOF
- L3: What the proteins say: human peptides from cervico-vaginal fluid; honey, cereals, milk, legumes
- L4: Models borrowed from other sciences: sequence-evolution programs for manuscript trees, unseen-species estimators for lost works
- L5: An instrument rebuilt from the text: Chaucer's astrolabe, used for years, measures the planets' orbits
- L6: Machine readers: ChatGPT and text-to-speech used to study Chaucer, helpful at first, shallow later
way in: Labour, taxes and the 1381 Rising
- L1: Work and its laws: a poem against the din of night-time forges, perhaps echoing legislation against night work; structural change after the Black Death
- L2: The poll tax of 1381: the General Prologue perhaps a pastiche of Harry Bailey's poll-tax account
- L3: The Rising in the works: the Revolt mentioned in the Tales; chronicles blame Ball and the Lollards and tie Piers to rebellion
way in: Listeners and readers
- L1: Romances read aloud in courtly circles and households to mixed audiences, and read alone
- L2: New readers: the rising literate middle and merchant classes
- L3: A reader's complaint reaches the printer: the customer whose manuscript differed from Caxton's print
way in: Owners, collectors and houses
- L1: Private libraries: the Gawain manuscript with Henry Savile in Yorkshire
- L2: The collector: Robert Cotton, whose shelf-mark names the manuscript
- L3: Found again: Kempe's book in a Derbyshire country house (identified 1934); Malory's Winchester Manuscript (1934)
way in: Popular story and the alliterative tradition
- L1: Popular entertainment: romances and lyrics; Robin Hood tales already a tradition by Piers
- L2: The alliterative line: Layamon's Brut c. 1190 the last before a gap; a revival or an unrecorded continuity (contested)
- L3: First datable poem of the Revival, Wynnere and Wastoure, about 1352
way in: Science, medicine and the arts of number
- L1: Latin scientific texts translated into English for the first time since the Anglo-Saxon period: a vernacular scientific voice
- L2: Chaucer's Treatise on the Astrolabe for his son Lewis
- L3: Medical recipe collections: Arderne's Liber medicinarum, charms and experimenta among the recipes
way in: Skins and parchment
- L1: Sheep: sheep parchment predominant in English legal documents; the girdle is sheepskin
- L2: A parchment roll made in England in the late fifteenth century and written in the vernacular
way in: Spoken Middle English and its dialects
- L1: Spoken Middle English: Northern, East Midland, West Midland and Southern dialects, varying in vocabulary, grammar, pronunciation and spelling
- L2: Dialects heard across regions: Trevisa (1387) on how Midlanders understand north and south better than these understand each other
- L3: No standard to route into: the West Saxon literary language lost its hold, so each writer writes his own dialect
way in: The Black Death and the plague years
- L1: The Black Death and the Revolt felt as an apocalyptic end, reflected in literature
- L2: Plague in the writers' own lives: Julian six when it reached Norwich in 1349; Blanche of Lancaster dead of plague in 1369, mourned in The Book of the Duchess
way in: The Church and devotion
- L1: Religious writing everywhere: the Katherine Group, Rolle, Julian
- L2: Enclosure: Julian in permanent seclusion as an anchoress in a cell attached to St Julian's Church, Norwich
- L3: The liturgical year as the routing: Orrm's homilies keyed to the texts set for the mass
way in: Visions, dreams and imagination (the inner channel)
- L1: Showings and visions: Julian's sixteen showings in 1373 when near death; Kempe's revelations; the dream of Pearl
- L2: The medieval account of how a thought forms: sense impressions put together by the inner senses, through imagination, cognition and memory (Avicenna's five cells)
- L3: Set down: Kempe, claiming illiteracy, dictated her book to two scribes; Julian wrote a short and, years later, a long text
way out: Copied by scribes
- L1: A new manuscript, every copy different in spelling
- L3: The scribe: Hengwrt and Ellesmere by one hand (named Pinkhurst by Mooney, doubted by others); Kempe's book copied by Salthows
- L6: An exemplar to copy (no holograph of Chaucer survives)
way out: Into the English language
- L1: The basis of Modern English spelling, while pronunciation moved on
- L3: A London standard spread through government and print
- L4: Words and spellings fixed in the works: almost two thousand first attested in Chaucerian manuscripts
way out: Printed
- L1: Printed books, four-fifths of Caxton's in English
- L3: Set and printed at Westminster
- L6: A text chosen for print
way out: Read aloud, preached and staged
- L1: Voice in hall, household, street and church
- L3: Staged by the guilds on pageant wagons at Corpus Christi, each guild one play
- L5: A romance, sermon or pageant ready to be voiced
way out: Retold, translated and re-made
- L1: New works quoting the old: a collage quoting Pearl and Cleanness
- L3: Retellings and translations: The Two Noble Kinsmen; modern Gawain renderings
- L7: Works read anew
way out: Taken up as a watchword
- L1: Rebels of 1381 in Norfolk using the names as pseudonyms
- L3: The author-name 'Will Long Will' read from a reverse cryptogram
- L5: The B-text of Piers in circulation