← all systems · see it in The System
Old English literature
Old English literature is the poetry (alliterative verse) and prose written in Old English in early medieval England, from the 7th century to the decades after the Norman Conquest of 1066 (src:wp:old-english-literature): walked as literary scholars describe it, the works (sermons, saints' lives, translations, chronicles, laws, practical works and poetry, Beowulf among it), the language and verse craft they are made in, the over 400 manuscripts they survive in, and how they have been kept, lost, read and studied since.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | turn of the 7th century |
| born precision | decades |
| boundary | Inside: the works written in Old English (poetry and prose), their verse and prose craft, the manuscripts and inscribed objects that carry them, and their reading and study from the later Middle Ages to now. Outside, as partners: the Old English language itself, the Church, kings, the Latin books translated, the animals whose skins became parchment, the libraries and collectors, fire, and the people who read it. |
| nested level | Part of literature (L7, the literary culture) and of Anglo-Saxon England's culture; built from works, manuscripts and the verse tradition. Runs on: people (readers and writers, Human L6-L7) and the Old English language. What runs on it: Tolkien's legendarium, Grendel, the translations, romantic-nationalist curricula, language models of Old English. |
| scale | social |
Measures (32) published science
| Span of the literature | 7th century to the decades after 1066 (latest Old English verse mid-12th century; Chronicle updated to 1154) centuries |
| Chronicle span | 1154 year of the last active update |
| Chronicle annual entry (characteristic clock) | 1 year (annals by year) |
| Surviving manuscripts | over 400 (about 189 major) manuscripts |
| Beowulf length | 3,182 alliterative lines |
| Beowulf manuscript date | 975-1025 AD |
| Beowulf scribe change | 1939 line where the second scribe takes over |
| Similes in Beowulf | at best 5 similes |
| Characters in Beowulf | 74 unique characters |
| Giant component of Beowulf's character network | 68 % of nodes |
| Assortativity of Beowulf* (friendly network without the hero) | 0.012 r |
| Exeter Book share of surviving poetry | about one sixth of the surviving Old English poetry |
| Exeter Book leaves | 130 or 131 originally; first 8 lost leaves |
| Exeter Book riddles | 94 to about 100 riddles |
| Manuscripts of Cædmon's Hymn | 19 (OEL article) or 23 (Hymn article) manuscripts |
| Chronicle manuscripts | seven and one fragment (Hayakawa et al.) or nine (encyclopedia) manuscripts |
| Cotton library fire, 1731 | 13 destroyed, some 200 seriously damaged (Cotton library article); about a quarter of Cotton's manuscripts destroyed (Beowulf article) |
| Letters recovered from the Thorkelin transcripts | at least 2000 letters |
| Wait from fire to transcript | 55 years (1731 fire; Thorkelin 1786) |
| The Battle of Maldon | 325 lines (beginning and end lost) |
| Andreas | 1,722 lines |
| Celestial sign observation window | 25 March 775 to 25 December 777 dates |
| Stylometry: full-line metrical patterns before vs after line 2300 | p = 0.0112 (goodness of fit) chi-square p-value |
| Human DNA on the York Gospels | 11.1 (range 4.2-20.8) % of reads |
| Endogenous (calf) DNA in the York Gospels | 19.3 (range 0.7-51.4) % of reads |
| York Gospels folia | 167 parchment folia |
| Sex of parchment calves | 4 female, 1 male typed animals |
| Continental ancestry, early medieval eastern England | up to 76 % |
| Machine translation into Old English (BLEU) | 26 to over 65 BLEU |
| Maldon transcript to print | c. 1724 to 1726 years |
| Alfred | 849-899 lifespan |
| Ælfric's sermons in use | late 10th century to well into the 13th century centuries |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: as C-413 lists - C-2253 Was the 'red crucifix' seen in the 770s an aurora or a halo?
booked: The map keeps both readings.
the other reading: aurora seen after sunset; enhanced solar activity in the mid-770s; window 25 March 775 to 25 December 777 (Usoskin et al. 2013; Hayakawa et al. 2019); halo display (horizontal arc and pillar), dated 776, near a solar minimum (Neuhäuser and Neuhäuser 2015) - C-2255 Was Beowulf the work of one poet?
booked: The map keeps both readings.
the other reading: unitary authorship: quantitative evidence consistent with one poet (Neidorf et al. 2019); significant stylistic heterogeneity, the boundary near the scribal change at line 1939 (Plecháč et al. 2019) - C-2256 When was Beowulf composed?
booked: The map keeps the datings side by side.
the other reading: 8th century (linguistic, palaeographical, metrical and onomastic arguments; Kaluza's law); 7th century at Rendlesham (Sutton Hoo links); the 890s under Alfred (Davis); early 11th century, near the manuscript (Kiernan; the scribes as poets) - C-2295 How many Old English manuscripts survive?
booked: The map keeps the differing counts.
the other reading: Cædmon's Hymn in 19 manuscripts (Old English literature article) or 23 (Hymn article); Chronicle: seven manuscripts and one fragment (Hayakawa et al.) or nine manuscripts (encyclopedia); Cotton fire: 13 destroyed and some 200 damaged (Cotton library article) or about a quarter of Cotton's manuscripts destroyed (Beowulf article) - C-2296 Was Old English poetry composed orally?
booked: The map keeps both readings.
the other reading: oral-formulaic composition (Magoun; Lord: Beowulf composed orally); written-formulaic: written poems with oral influence (Benson); literate composition drawing on oral tradition
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (10)
- Old English poetry
- Old English prose
- Beowulf
- Anglo-Saxon Chronicle
- Exeter Book
- Nowell Codex
- Junius manuscript
- Vercelli Book
- Alliterative verse
- English literature
Sits inside / holds (3)
Trades with (valence) (18)
- English language: a West Germanic language of the Indo-European family, from its Old English beginnings to its varieties and its use as a global lingua franca, as linguistics and its history describe it via sys:acoustic-wave · Old English literature gain
- Sun via sys:sensory-environment · Old English literature gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Old English literature gain
- Religion via sys:human-society · Old English literature gain
- Fire via sys:thermal-energy · Old English literature loss
- Large language model via sys:written-record · Old English literature mixed
- Book via sys:written-record · Old English literature gain
- Cattle, sheep and goats (parchment animals) via sys:parchment · Old English literature gain
- Nationalism via sys:human-society · Old English literature gain
- Literature via sys:written-record · Old English literature gain
- The archive and the historical record via sys:written-record · Old English literature gain
- History (the field) via sys:written-record · Old English literature gain
- Protestant Reformation (the 16th-century religious movements in Western Christianity, and the confessions, states and wars they shaped, from 1517 to a contested end) via sys:human-society · Old English literature mixed
- William Shakespeare via sys:english-language · Old English literature even
- Human migration via sys:human-society · Old English literature gain
- Old English (the language) via sys:old-english-language · Old English literature gain
- Middle English literature via sys:written-record · Old English literature loss
- English literature via sys:written-record · Old English literature even
expressed by (16)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (28)
- Sun
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Religion
- Fire
- Large language model
- Human brain
- Book
- Cattle, sheep and goats (parchment animals)
- Nationalism
- Literature
- The archive and the historical record
- History (the field)
- Oral tradition
- Human migration
- Beowulf
- Anglo-Saxon Chronicle
- Exeter Book
- Nowell Codex
- Junius manuscript
- Vercelli Book
- Alliterative verse
- Old English (the language)
- Scriptorium
- Cædmon's Hymn
- Alfred the Great
- Ælfric of Eynsham
- Cynewulf
- English literature
Kinds (10)
- English literature
- Old English poetry
- Old English prose
- Heroic poetry
- Elegies
- Riddles
- Charms
- Homilies and saints' lives
- Medical texts
- Laws, wills and charters
wired (1)
Notes published science
- A 'red crucifix' that an English annalist saw in the sky after sunset in the 770s is now evidence in a physics argument: solar physicists check it against a radiocarbon spike in tree rings and beryllium in ice cores to decide whether the Sun was stormy then (an aurora) or whether it was an ice-crystal halo; the two camps still disagree (src:hayakawa-2019-asc-celestial-sign, src:neuhauser-2015-halo-770s).
- A thousand-year-old English eye salve from Bald's Leechbook, rebuilt from the Old English text by microbiologists and medievalists together, killed MRSA in a mouse wound model, but only when all the ingredients were combined as the recipe says; no single ingredient did it alone (src:harrison-2015-balds-eyesalve).
- Rubbing a medieval gospel book with a conservator's eraser picks up enough DNA to tell which calf each page came from: the York Gospels (c. 1000) are calfskin, four of the five calves typed were female, perhaps skins from a cattle plague of 986-988, and about 11% of the DNA on the pages is human, from a thousand years of handling and kissing (src:teasdale-2017-york-gospels).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Old English literature as literary scholars describe it: from the speech, legend, Latin books and skins it drew on, through monastery, craft and works, to the manuscripts that carry it and the scholarship that reads it (reader's view)
- L1: What it drew on: the speech the settlers brought, Germanic legend, the Latin books of the Church, the events of war and sky, and the skins of calves and sheep
- L2: Intake: the scop's stock of formulas, monastic literacy and schooling, royal programmes (Alfred), news of battles and signs
- L3: Routing: the monasteries and their seven major scriptoria; dialects channelled into the West Saxon standard
- L4: Craft: alliterative verse (five Sievers types, formulas, kennings, variation) and the prose of translation, homily, annal and law
- L5: The works: in descending order, sermons and saints' lives, biblical and Latin translations, chronicles, laws, practical works, and poetry (Beowulf, 3,182 lines, the longest)
- L6: The manuscripts: over 400 (189 major), four poetic codices, copied, glossed, dispersed, burned, collected
- L7: Reading and afterlife: glossing, antiquarian collecting, dictionaries, editions, national culture, Tolkien, theory, computation, the laboratory sciences, translations and new works
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Composition: the alliterative line (two half-lines over a caesura, five Sievers types, formulas, kennings, variation, litotes, few similes) and the prose of translation, homily, annal and law
- L5: The works: sermons and saints' lives, biblical translation, Latin works translated, chronicles, laws, practical works (grammar, medicine, geography, computus), and poetry (heroic, elegiac, riddles, saints' lives, biblical paraphrase, Christian lyric, charms, mnemonic verse)
- L6: The manuscripts: over 400 (about 189 major), most of the 9th-11th centuries, from seven major scriptoria; the four poetic codices (Junius, Exeter, Vercelli, Nowell); copies, glosses, annotations; runic and carved texts on objects
- L7: Reading and afterlife: later medieval glossing, antiquarian collecting, dictionaries and editions, the 19th-century search for national roots, Tolkien and literary criticism, critical theory, computation and the laboratory sciences, translations and new works
way in: Battles and Viking raids
- L1: War: Viking raids and invasions, battles between kingdoms
- L2: News of battles: Brunanburh (937), Maldon (991)
- L3: Turned into heroic verse (the Beasts of Battle theme) or into a sermon that reads the raids as punishment for sin (Sermo Lupi)
way in: Christianity and the monasteries
- L1: The conversion of the English in the 6th and 7th centuries
- L2: Monastic houses where literacy lived (Whitby under Hild; the seven major scriptoria)
- L3: Reform and teaching: Ælfric, pupil of Æthelwold, the Benedictine reform's writer of homilies and saints' lives
way in: Fire, decay and handling
- L1: Fire: Ashburnham House, 1731 (also the Peterborough fire of 1116)
- L2: Damage: Beowulf's margins charred, readings lost; Maldon burned
- L3: Slow loss: crumbling, rebinding that covers letters; bacteria on the leaves
- L4: Copies as witnesses: Maldon's transcript (c. 1724), Thorkelin's Beowulf transcripts (1786)
- L5: Recovery by imaging: fibre-optic backlighting and ultraviolet reveal lost letters
way in: Germanic legend and the scop's stock of formulas
- L1: Germanic heroic legend of a 5th-6th-century Scandinavian past (Heorot at Lejre: a mid-6th-century hall), carried by word of mouth; oral practice leaves no direct trace
- L2: The scop: a repertoire of formulae and themes from a stock common to the profession, scenes improvised at each telling
- L3: The formula fitted to the half-line of the metre
way in: Inspiration (the poet's inner channel)
- L1: Where a poem comes from: in Bede's account a vision gives an illiterate herdsman the gift of poetry; origin not ruled
- L2: The poet's own making: most poems anonymous; Cynewulf signs his
- L3: Sung in the traditional form; Bede gives only a Latin translation of the Hymn
way in: Keepers: libraries, the Dissolution, collectors
- L1: Monastic and cathedral libraries (the Exeter Book given by Leofric in 1072)
- L2: The Dissolution of the Monasteries disperses them, with considerable losses
- L3: Antiquarians collect them: Nowell, Parker, Cotton, Wanley
- L4: Catalogues: Smith (1696) and Wanley (1705) catalogue the Cotton library
- L5: Unique copies held in national collections (Cotton: Beowulf, Maldon; the British Library)
way in: Kings and bishops
- L1: Royal and episcopal power: Alfred (849-899), Athelstan, Edgar, Cnut; bishops such as Leofric of Exeter
- L2: Alfred's programme: students educated in Old English, the best to Latin; books necessary for all to know
- L3: Commission and distribution: the Chronicle's common stock written at Alfred's court and copies sent to religious houses
way in: Latin books: Bible, Church Fathers, Boethius, Bede
- L1: Latin writings: the Bible, the early Church Fathers, Gregory, Boethius, Orosius, Bede; Anglo-Latin works the largest volume of the period's writing
- L2: Read by the literate: monks, nuns, ecclesiastics and the laypeople they taught
- L3: Translation into Old English (Alfred's books, Ælfric's homilies, biblical paraphrase), some original content woven in
way in: Listeners and readers in hall, church and cloister
- L1: Voice in the hall or church: verse performed, sermons preached
- L2: Hearing patterned verse: sound repetition registered below awareness (shown for Welsh cynghanedd), alliteration linked to better recall
- L3: Use: sermons copied and adapted for use into the 13th century
way in: Scholars: editions, dictionaries, criticism, computation, translation
- L1: The surviving texts, in a language largely incomprehensible without study
- L2: Editions: Junius (1655), Thorkelin (1815), Klaeber (1922)
- L3: Dictionaries: Somner (1659), Bosworth-Toller (1898)
- L4: Criticism: Tolkien (1936), the turn to manuscripts (Ker 1957), critical theory from the 1970s
- L5: Computation: stylometry (unitary or composite Beowulf), character networks, treebanks and language models
- L6: Translation into modern languages: hundreds after 1900 (Heaney 2000)
way in: Signs in the sky
- L1: The night sky over England and the Continent: aurorae and halos (the 774/775 radiocarbon event the backdrop)
- L2: Seen by eye: the red sign "after sunset" (read as aurora by Hayakawa et al., as a halo by the Neuhäusers)
- L3: Entered as an annal under its year; some signs copied in from Continental annals (806)
way in: Skins, ink and script
- L1: Herds of cattle and sheep; mortality events (the murrain of 986-988) may have supplied calfskins
- L2: Skins chosen: calves slaughtered young; the York Gospels calfskin, later additions sheepskin
- L3: Parchment made from the skins (cattle killed as juveniles for it)
- L4: Leaves gathered into codices in the scriptoria (the York Gospels at St Augustine's, Canterbury, c. 1000)
- L5: Script on the leaf: Insular minuscule kept for Old English, thorn and eth for the dental fricatives; runes before the 7th century
way in: Spoken Old English and its dialects
- L1: Speech of the Anglo-Saxon settlers: languages brought across the North Sea in the mid-5th century, with a shift in language after Roman rule ended and migrants in large numbers (up to 76% continental ancestry in eastern England)
- L2: Regional dialects: Northumbrian, Mercian, Kentish, West Saxon
- L3: The West Saxon literary standard: poetry probably translated into West Saxon; Beowulf keeps forms from several dialect areas
way in: The Norman Conquest
- L1: The Conquest of 1066, the conventional end of the Old English era
- L2: Anglo-Norman replaces English among the upper classes
- L3: The last scribes trained in standard West Saxon die out; grammar inconsistent in the 12th century
way in: The sciences reading the books
- L1: The books as matter and record: skins, grime, recipes, annals
- L2: Sampling without harm: the eraser waste of dry cleaning
- L3: Laboratory reading: proteins and DNA; the annal's sky checked against eyewitness aurorae and halo ray tracing
- L4: Reconstruction from the text, where translation is ambiguous
- L5: Mixed teams, sciences and humanities
- L6: Findings: calfskin and handling; a remedy that kills MRSA; aurora or halo
way out: Copied and sent on
- L1: Copies sent to religious houses and continued there
- L3: Copied by hand, with variation and change (Cædmon's Hymn; the 806 cross)
- L6: An exemplar in a scriptorium
way out: Editions, facsimiles and translations
- L1: Printed and digital pages that readers take in
- L3: Translations into modern English and other languages
- L5: Editions and digital facsimiles (Electronic Beowulf 1999-2014; the Facsimile Project)
- L7: Scholarship ready to publish
way out: Laws, wills and charters acting on land and people
- L1: Land held and transferred
- L3: Charters granting land (Kent and Mercia, written in West Saxon)
- L5: Law codes, wills, charters, guild rules
way out: National culture and the curriculum
- L1: Students and readers in universities
- L4: Old English a regular part of the university curriculum
- L7: 19th-century search for the roots of national culture
way out: New works drawn from it
- L1: Novels and poems in circulation (The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, Grendel)
- L4: Poems after Cædmon (Levertov, Heaney, Muldoon, Fanthorpe); translation as re-creation (Morgan)
- L7: Writers take up its matter and forms
way out: Performed and preached
- L1: Voice in the hall or church
- L3: Sung to the harp (proposed) or preached in church
- L5: A poem or homily ready to be voiced