← all systems · see it in The System
Nationalism
An ideology and a movement holding that the nation should be congruent with the state: it promotes a particular nation's interests and its sovereignty (self-determination) over a homeland, builds a single national identity from shared characteristics (language, culture, ethnicity, religion, a shared history or shared political will), and has driven the making and breaking of states since the late eighteenth century. Walked as historians and social scientists describe it: its origins (contested), the nation-state it aims at, its movements and wars (booked as competitions, QUEUE-BRIEF addendum 7), how it spreads, and its effects on people and states.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | late 18th century (1755-1789: Corsica, America, France) |
| born precision | decades; contested back to antiquity (C-2209) |
| boundary | Inside: the national idea and its carriers: nationalist movements, parties and intellectuals; the nation-building work of states (schools, censuses, conscription, symbols); national identities as people hold and practise them; national narratives and the claim to sovereignty. Outside: the states, empires, economies, wars and media it acts on and runs through, and the other identities (ethnic, religious, class, cosmopolitan) it competes with. |
| nested level | Runs on human societies (their print, schools, armies and everyday practices); one political ideology among several, combinable with conservatism or socialism; its aim, the nation-state, is the dominant unit of the international system. |
| scale | social |
Measures (25) published science
| The English word 'nationalism' | around 1798 date |
| Herder's term | 1772 date |
| Number of states in the world | fewer than 60 a century ago; nearly 200 today (2021) states |
| War rate near nation-state creation | more than twice the number of territories at war in the years around nation-state creation compared with decades before or after ratio (about 2) |
| War rate at imperial incorporation | roughly twice as high at the turning point as in the decades that follow ratio (about 2) |
| Estonian nation-building, from no ethnic name to a nation-state | within 100 years (from the start of the 19th century) |
| Settling of founding national narratives | the decades after a nation is first established |
| Wait from Muslim political organisation (1906) to the demand for Pakistan (1940) | 34 years (1906 to 1940) |
| Revanche for Alsace-Lorraine | a quarter century after 1871 years |
| Spanish American revolts | 1808 to 1826 dates |
| French speakers at the Revolution | 12-13% spoke French 'correctly'; about half spoke some French, a quarter of those the literary language % of population |
| French schoolchildren without written French, 1863 | about 11% spoke no French; another 37% spoke or understood it but could not write it % of children aged 7-13 |
| Ferry Laws | 1881-1882 dates |
| Age of Mass Migration (US compulsory-schooling context) | tens of millions of migrants, 1850-1914 people |
| National identification and public health, survey size | N = 49,968 across 67 countries (April-May 2020) respondents |
| National identification and pandemic mobility across 42 countries | r = -0.40 correlation |
| Oxytocin flag-liking effect duration | maintained 1 week after treatment (51 adults) days |
| Brain-structure sample | 433 men and 344 women, age 20.7 +/- 1.9 years people |
| Empowerment rights lower under highly nationalist executives | six of seven rights examined (partial democracies) |
| Vaccine doses per 100 people, mid-2021 | 99 (US), 117 (UK), 25 (India), 3.8 (Africa average) doses per 100 people |
| Scottish independence referendum 2014, vote against | 55.3 % |
| Sudeten German Party share of ethnic-German votes, May 1938 | 88 % |
| Poland officially declared ethnically Polish after 1945 | 99 % |
| Pan-French West Africa aim (Senghor, Toure) | as late as 1957 date |
| Pottery-signal network span (southern Ontario) | A.D. 1350-1650; initial nation formation about 1500-1550 years |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1077 Which came first, the nation or the state?
booked: The map leaves it open and keeps the competing views side by side.
the other reading: states made nations (Hobsbawm; the Spanish 'To make the Spanish nation a nation that neither is nor has been'); nations made states (German and Italian unification: cultural movement first) - C-2161 Is there civic nationalism and ethnic nationalism?
booked: The map keeps the distinction contested.
the other reading: civic ('Western', democratic) versus ethnic ('Eastern', undemocratic) (Kohn); the dichotomy oversimplifies; national narratives are rarely uncontested and both strands coexist (Smith 1997 on the US; Shulman, Marx, Tamir); Habermas: only the constitutional, idea-based kind is morally worthy - C-2208 Were there nations before nationalism?
booked: The map keeps the comparison as a contention.
the other reading: archaeologists' 'nation formation' among ancestral Wendat, Tionontate and Neutral (A.D. 1500-1550) names a nation in the political-community sense; the modern sense: nations as products of modernity (modernists), so the word names a different kind - C-2209 When did nationalism begin?
booked: The map keeps the datings side by side.
the other reading: 1775-1789: American Declaration of Independence or French Revolution (most scholars); 17th century (Kohn 1944); about 1700 in Britain, full form in the 1830s (Colley); the aftermath of the Reformation (Wells); the Middle Ages (Hastings on England); antiquity: Jewish nationhood from the 7th century BCE (Smith); Ancient Israel as the model (Hastings); nation formation in Iroquoia about 1500-1550 (Hart et al.), if 'nation' there names the same system - C-2210 Where did nationalism come from?
booked: The map lists the theories and rules none.
the other reading: modernism: industrialisation, urbanisation, print capitalism and mass education made nations (Gellner, Anderson, Hobsbawm, Deutsch); 'currently the most commonly accepted theory'; perennialism: modern nations with long historical roots, 'subject to academic debate' (Hastings, Gorski on religion); ethnosymbolism: symbols, myths and traditions (Smith): 'History is no sweetshop'; primordialism: nations have always existed; 'rejected by most scholars'; evolutionary primordialism: group attachment from human evolution; 'popular with the general public but ... typically rejected by experts'; states made nations (Hobsbawm, Weber; Spanish and French cases) versus nations demanding states (C-1077) - C-2211 Is nationalism good or bad?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: a force for freedom, cultural revival, democracy and public goods (Gandhi, Mandela; public-health compliance); a cause of war, exclusion and genocide ('the measles of mankind', Einstein; Acton's 'insanity'); exclusionary nationalisms, not nationalism per se, are the problem (Tudor & Slater; Straus); an amplifier of both (Singh) - C-2212 Does nationalism cause war?
booked: The map books the measured link and keeps its direction open.
the other reading: nationalism causes war (top cause of WWI; Posen: intensifies war; Wimmer & Min: war rates peak near nation-state creation); war causes nationalism (Sambanis et al.: wars induce national identification; Herbst: threats foster it; Tilly's 'war made the state'); Tilly's argument's reach beyond Europe and its causal direction debated (Centeno; Mazzuca)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Mass media
- Nationalist movements and organisations
- National identity (individual identification with the nation)
- Mass schooling with national content
- National symbols (flags, anthems, personifications, myths)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (36)
- School via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Political party via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Language (human language) via sys:language · Nationalism gain
- Religion via sys:human-society · Nationalism mixed
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Industrial Revolution (the first, c. 1760 to c. 1840) via sys:economy · Nationalism gain
- Mass media via sys:mass-media · Nationalism gain
- Sport via sys:sport · Nationalism gain
- Democracy via sys:human-society · Nationalism mixed
- United States (the country across time) via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945) via sys:international-system · Nationalism mixed
- Cold War via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Russo-Ukrainian war (2014-; full-scale phase from 2022) via sys:international-system · Nationalism mixed
- French Revolution via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Protestant Reformation (the 16th-century religious movements in Western Christianity, and the confessions, states and wars they shaped, from 1517 to a contested end) via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- The Holocaust (the Shoah) via sys:human-society · Nationalism even
- Chinese Communist Revolution via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Populism via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Ethnic group via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- COVID-19 pandemic via sys:economy · Nationalism mixed
- Wendat (Huron) and neighbouring confederacies, A.D. 1350-1650 via sys:human-society · Nationalism even
- Partition of India (1947) via sys:nationalism · Nationalism gain
- Decolonization (the end of colonial empires, especially 1945-1975) via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Colonialism via sys:colonialism · Nationalism gain
- Meiji Restoration via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Great Depression via sys:mental-representation · Nationalism gain
- Epic poetry via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Historiography via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Museum via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies) via sys:human-society · Nationalism even
- Russian Revolution via sys:human-society · Nationalism mixed
- Spanish American wars of independence via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Globalization via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
- Women's suffrage · Nationalism gain
- Old English literature via sys:human-society · Nationalism gain
expressed by (23)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Mapping/Modeling
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Divide & Isolate
- Cascade Induction
- Reactive Response
- Proactive Defense
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Enclave/Segregation
- Resilience & Repair
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (28)
- School
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Language (human language)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Human brain
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Mass media
- Sport
- International system of states
- Land (pool)
- Census
- Nation-state
- Nationalist movements and organisations
- National identity (individual identification with the nation)
- Mass schooling with national content
- National symbols (flags, anthems, personifications, myths)
- Populism
- Print capitalism
- Conscript (mass) army
- National narrative (constitutive story)
- Epic poetry
- Museum
- Russian Revolution
- Chinese Communist Revolution
- Ethnic group
- Partition of India (1947)
- Spanish American wars of independence
- Old English literature
Kinds (17)
- Japanese nationalism
- Civic nationalism
- Ethnic nationalism (ethno-nationalism)
- Anti-colonial nationalism
- Creole nationalism
- Economic nationalism
- Integral nationalism
- Pan-nationalism (Pan-Slavism)
- Irredentism and revanchism
- Left-wing nationalism
- Religious nationalism (Hindu, Buddhist, Christian)
- Banal (everyday) nationalism
- Jewish nationalism (Zionism)
- Nativist nationalism
- Racial nationalism
- Territorial nationalism
- Vaccine nationalism
Notes published science
- A flag can change a vote without being seen: Israeli participants flashed their national flag too briefly to notice shifted their political attitudes and their actual votes, and it narrowed the gap between strong and weak nationalists (src:hassin-2007).
- When Revolutionary France declared that the people were the nation, only 12-13% of them spoke French 'correctly'; as late as 1863 about 11% of French schoolchildren spoke no French at all, and the Third Republic's teachers, called 'priests of the Republic', made the nation by forbidding children their parents' language (src:tada-2020-durkheim).
- Nationalism and war feed each other in both directions: wars make people identify with the nation, and the higher payoff of national unity makes leaders readier to fight; across 185 years of data, war rates more than double in the years around a nation-state's creation (src:mylonas-tudor-2021, src:wimmer-min-2006).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
nationalism as historians and social scientists describe it: people, land, languages and states, through print, schools, symbols and threats, to national identity, movements and narratives, and the claim that nation and state be congruent (reader's view; historians' periods in `periods`)
- L1: The world it touches: people, land claimed as homeland, the languages they speak, and the states and empires they live under
- L2: The doors in: newspapers read, school lessons, flags and anthems seen and heard, censuses and maps, threats at the border, sport
- L3: Routing and carriage: print capitalism in vernacular languages, mass schooling and its teachers, conscript armies, mass social mobilisation and political communication
- L4: Integration: the imagined community and each person's national identification
- L5: Organisation (the board): nationalist movements and parties, the nation-building state, and everyday practice negotiated between elites and people
- L6: Meaning: the nation's constitutive story, its markers (civic or ethnic) and its us-them boundary
- L7: Purpose and action: the claim that nation and state be congruent; making, unifying, defending or breaking states; nation-building, exclusion and war
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: Nationalist movements, parties and intellectuals
- L5: The nation-building state: schools, censuses, conscription, cultural machinery
- L5: Everyday nationalism: people practising, accepting, renegotiating or rejecting the nation
- L6: The constitutive story, its markers and its us-them boundary
- L7: The congruence claim: a nation's sovereignty over its territory
way in: Censuses and maps
- L1: Maps of the claimed national territory
- L2: Census enumeration reifies categories
way in: External threat and war
- L1: A foreign military force mobilised on the nation's borders
- L2: People feel threatened as a nation
- L3: The state's extractive capacities rise with threat
- L4: Wars make individuals identify in national terms
way in: Flags, anthems and national symbols
- L1: Constructed symbols: flags, anthems, personifications, myths
- L2: The flag met by sight, even below awareness
- L3: A selective liking for the nation's people and flag, raised by oxytocin, not for other cultural symbols
- L4: Banal nationalism: everyday representations reproduce belonging
way in: Globalisation, trade shocks and migration
- L1: The rise of globalism; waves of refugees
- L2: Import trade shocks felt in regions
- L3: Movements combine anti-elite and anti-globalisation appeals
- L4: Narratives of culture and identity weigh as much as economics
way in: Ideas: popular sovereignty, rights and romantic peoplehood
- L1: Enlightenment and revolution against rule by divine right
- L2: Political theorists develop the idea that 'the people' should rule
- L3: Romanticism: the nation as the 'natural' expression of a people (Fichte), opposed by Renan
- L4: The nation as a daily plebiscite of will
way in: Industrialisation, urbanisation and the national economy
- L1: An industrial economy, cities and mass education
- L2: A nation-encompassing economy and public sphere
- L3: Mass social mobilisation and political communication
- L4: Urban, educated, employed people identify with the nation above ethnicity
way in: Inherited language, religion, myths and ethnic ties (origin contested)
- L1: Shared characteristics: culture, ethnicity, homeland, language, religion, traditions, a shared history
- L2: A common language as the source of legitimate authority (Herder)
- L3: Intellectuals generate cultural perceptions and the ideology of political nationalism
- L4: Ethnic past as building block, or not (Smith against Gellner)
way in: Mass schooling with national content
- L1: Children of a multilingual, largely illiterate population (1863 France: 11% of schoolchildren spoke no French)
- L2: The compulsory primary school, opened by law ahead of time (Ferry Laws 1881-1882; US compulsory schooling laws)
- L3: Teachers as 'priests of the Republic' carry the national language and story
- L4: National identity fixed at the first round of national schooling
way in: Neighbours' movements and international diffusion
- L1: Revolutions and mobilisations next door; the age of revolutions
- L2: Focal points for collective action in the street
- L3: Diffusion through international organisations
- L4: Elites borrow the rubric once the nation-state dominates the region
way in: Print and the press in vernacular languages
- L1: Printed media in vernacular languages
- L2: The reader of the daily paper, the mass ceremony performed in private
- L3: Print capitalism standardises calendars, clocks and language
- L4: The image of communion in each reader's mind
way in: Rule from outside: empires and colonial regimes
- L1: Empires that deny peripheries autonomy
- L2: The chain of control from the crown broken (creole case); blocked mobility of settlers
- L3: Rights refused to educated colonial subjects; elites adapt nationalism
- L4: The nation-state taken up once it legitimates local aims
way in: Sport contests between nations
- L1: World Cup and other spectacles with worldwide audiences
- L2: Fans tie loyalty and identity to national teams
- L3: Victories and their screen depictions modify everyday belonging
- L4: Victories make national identification more likely
way out: Economic nationalism: tariffs, controls, stockpiles
- L1: Doses per 100 people: 99 and 117 (US, UK) against 25 and 3.8 (India, Africa)
- L3: Vaccine stockpiling for the citizenry
- L7: Domestic control of the economy even at the cost of tariffs and restrictions
way out: Exclusion: minorities suppressed, rights curtailed, populations transferred
- L1: Populations killed and transferred: Poland declared 99% ethnically Polish
- L4: Highly nationalist executives: lower respect for six empowerment rights
- L6: The boundary: a certain amount of exclusion at the crux
- L7: Exclusionary nationalisms as the problem for democracy, genocide prevention and public goods
way out: Making, unifying and breaking states
- L1: The world map remade: fewer than 60 states a century ago, nearly 200 today
- L3: Unification by war (Germany); consolidation of states (Italy 1861)
- L5: Nationalists overthrow regimes or absorb administrative units when power shifts
- L7: The demand that nation and state coincide
way out: Nation-building: schooling, language, assimilation
- L1: Dialects and patois resolved into one national language
- L3: Teachers forbid parents' languages
- L4: Compulsory schooling laws as a nation-building tool (US, 1850-1914)
- L6: Assimilation, minority rights or exclusion toward noncore groups
- L7: States as self-conscious nation builders
way out: Solidarity: sacrifice and cooperation for the public good
- L1: Lower mobility in countries with higher national identification (r = -0.40)
- L4: Stronger identifiers engage more in public-health behaviour
- L7: National attachment as a battery for public-good sacrifice
way out: Symbols made: flags, anthems, personifications
- L1: The Union Jack (1801), Rule Britannia (1740), John Bull (1712)
- L5: Nationalists construct symbols, anthems, myths and flags
way out: War: mass armies, unification, secession and revanche
- L1: War rates more than double around nation-state creation
- L3: More powerful mass armies
- L5: Mass conscription: the levee en masse (1793)
- L7: States promote nationalism to improve military capability; nationalism intensifies war