← all systems · see it in The System
Partition of India (1947)
The division of British India in 1947 into two independent dominions, the Union of India and the Dominion of Pakistan (the latter in two non-contiguous wings, the eastern one Bangladesh since 1971): the provinces of Punjab and Bengal split by district majorities through the Radcliffe boundary commissions, the army, civil service, railways and treasury divided, the princely states released to accede; set forth in the Indian Independence Act 1947 and carried out at midnight on 14-15 August 1947; accompanied and followed by the displacement of 12 to 20 million people along religious lines and by large-scale violence whose death toll is disputed (200,000 to 2 million), leaving a lasting India-Pakistan hostility, a disputed Kashmir, and the borders the successor states still hold.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Partition of India |
| born at | 3 June 1947 (the Mountbatten Plan accepted); roots from 1905 and 1940, the violence from 16 August 1946 |
| born precision | a day (as a decision); a decade (as a process) |
| boundary | Inside: the process that divided British India: the political contest over whether and how to divide (Congress, the Muslim League, Sikh leaders, the Viceroy and the Labour cabinet), the plan (3 June 1947) and the Act (18 July), the Partition Council and the two boundary commissions, the division of army, services, railways and treasury, the award and its publication, the transfer of populations with its violence, the recovery of abducted women, and the resettlement of refugees by the successor governments to the 1951 censuses. Outside: the subcontinent's peoples and lands it acted on (the pool), the princely states (released, then acceding), the wider decolonisation of Asia, the Second World War and Britain's exhausted exchequer that pressed on it, and the long afterlife it handed to the successor states (Kashmir, the Indus waters, later waves of migration, memory). |
| end precision | years, by reading |
| ended at | 15 August 1947 (transfer) and 17 August 1947 (the award); resettlement to about 1951; migration from East Pakistan to 1973 |
| nested level | One transfer of power within decolonization, and the end of the British Raj within colonialism; built from parties, officials, commissions, censuses, armies and the people who moved and fought; acting on the peoples, lands, rivers and institutions of British India; running on people's votes, speech, movement and violence (Human L7). |
| scale | social |
Measures (50) published science
| date of transfer | midnight 14-15 August 1947 date |
| transfer deadline | no later than June 1948 (announced early 1947), advanced to 15 August 1947 date |
| time from plan to transfer | less than six months; 3 June Plan to 15 August about 10 weeks time |
| time given to draw the line | five weeks (Radcliffe arrived 8 July 1947) |
| award publication delay | 2 days after independence (17 August 1947); two hours for the two sides to study it |
| span of the process | 1946 killings to 1951 censuses; migration from East Pakistan to 1973 years |
| people displaced | 12 to 20 million people |
| migratory inflows and outflows | inflows 14.5 million; outflows 17.9 million; 3.4 million 'missing' people |
| displaced persons, 1951 censuses | 7,226,600 (Pakistan); 7,295,870 (India) people |
| deaths | 200,000 to 2,000,000; most scholars about 1 million; West Punjab governor 500,000 Muslims entering his province; British High Commissioner 800,000 people |
| Punjab population losses | 2.3-3.2 million (deaths or unrecorded migration) people |
| Punjab population shortfall, 1951 | 2.9 million below 1931-41 growth people |
| missing along the Punjab border | about 2.2 million (1.3 million Muslims, 0.8 million Hindus and Sikhs) people |
| migration across Punjab | 12 million (6.5 million Muslims west, 4.7 million Hindus and Sikhs east) people |
| migration across Bengal | 3.3 million (2.6 million Hindus to India, 0.7 million Muslims to East Pakistan) people |
| refugees from East Pakistan to 1973 | over 6 million, in waves people |
| population of undivided India, 1947 | about 390 million people |
| shares of population and land | India 82.55% of population, 77.10% of land; Pakistan 17.44%, 22.89% percent |
| territory and people under the commissions | 175,000 square miles; 88 million people sq mi; people |
| Punjab Boundary Force | 50,000 men; less than one soldier per square mile; 77% of killings rural |
| Calcutta killings, August 1946 | about 4,000 dead in three days (official) people |
| Meo dead and displaced | 100,000 fled; about 30,000 massacred people |
| deaths in Hyderabad, 1948 | 27,000-40,000 (official) to 200,000 or more (scholarly) people |
| women abducted (governments' claims) | 33,000 Hindu and Sikh (India's claim); 50,000 Muslim (Pakistan's claim); 'around 75,000' (Tanveer et al.) people |
| women recovered by 1954 | 20,728 Muslim women from India; 9,032 Hindu and Sikh women from Pakistan people |
| Delhi population 1941 and 1951 | 917,939 to 1,744,072 people |
| relief camps in East Punjab, December 1948 | 85 camps; 721,396 people camps; people |
| Pakistan's refugees from East Punjab and Rajputana | 5,783,100 (80.1%) people |
| land abandoned and available, Punjab | 67 lakh acres abandoned by Hindu-Sikh owners in West Pakistan; 47 lakh available in East Punjab; 43 against 13 lakh irrigated acres (lakh) |
| graded cut | 25% (claims up to 10 standard acres) to 95% (over 500 standard acres) percent of claim |
| consolidated landholdings in East Punjab | 700,000 acres (1948) to 22.084 million acres (1966) |
| wheat yield gain in high-refugee districts | +9.4% (1957-2009) percent |
| tractor use gain in high-refugee districts | +56% (1957-1987) percent |
| infant mortality, India 1950-1955 | 164 to 181 per 1000 live births deaths per 1000 |
| cross-border marriages per year | 40,000 (1950s-60s) to about 300 (1995) marriages per year |
| Kashmir war losses | India 1,104 killed, 3,154 wounded; Pakistan about 6,000 killed, 14,000 wounded people |
| princely states | 562 states |
| Indus flow allocated | India about 20%, Pakistan 80% (33 and 135 million acre-feet a year) percent |
| asylum patients exchanged | 450 non-Muslim patients to Amritsar (1950), 282 kept, rest to Ranchi; 233 Muslim patients to Lahore |
| Congress share of non-Muslim vote, 1946 | 91% percent |
| League seats in UP, 1937 | 29 of 64 reserved Muslim seats |
| electorate after 1935 | 35 million voters |
| Muslim League membership, 1916 | 500 to 800 members |
| intergenerational trauma sample | 62 (31 children, 31 grandchildren of survivors); both medium; difference not significant (p = .49) participants |
| contemporary publications on partition's impact | 24 (1947-1951) publications |
| oral-history interviews archived | nearly 9,700 from 18 countries (June 2021) interviews |
| polio disparity, 2006 | Muslims 16% of population in affected states, 70% of paralytic cases percent |
| Sindhi genomes sampled | 13 individuals |
| per-hand-off yield of people (migration) | about 0.81 (14.5 million in / 17.9 million out) ratio |
| per-hand-off yield of land (Punjab) | about 0.70 by area (47 / 67 lakh acres); about 0.30 for irrigated land (13 / 43 lakh acres) ratio |
Open contentions (11) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-2170 Who was responsible for the Direct Action Day killings?
booked: The map keeps the readings side by side.
the other reading: both communities equally, leaders' calculations and followers' savagery (Tuker, the dominant British view); the League and Suhrawardy (the Congress version) - C-2182 Why was Gurdaspur given to India?
booked: The map keeps the readings of the boundary award.
the other reading: Mountbatten, at Nehru's behest, pressed Radcliffe to give Gurdaspur to India for road access to Kashmir (Lamb, Wolpert, Roberts, Anderson; Pakistani view); Kashmir was 'not in anybody's mind'; the land route lay in Pathankot anyway (Ilahi); Ferozepur: Indian historians now accept Mountbatten probably influenced it; the record is closed (Mountbatten papers) - C-2195 Who won the 1947-48 Kashmir war?
booked: The map keeps the outcome contested.
the other reading: a stalemate; an Indian victory (most of the contested territory) - C-2215 Why was India partitioned?
booked: The map lists the causes and rules none.
the other reading: British divide and rule (rejected by Dhulipala; Talbot and Singh: not its inevitable end); the two-nation theory and the League's demand; Pakistan popularly imagined as a 'New Medina' (Dhulipala); Congress's rejection of the Cabinet Mission groupings (Nehru's 10 July 1946 speech 'effectively torpedoed' it); communal violence making partition necessary (Mountbatten; Patel's 'de facto Pakistan'); British strategic interest in a north-western base (The Shadow of the Great Game); not inevitable (Talbot and Singh) - C-2216 How many died in the Partition of India?
booked: The map keeps the ranges.
the other reading: about 200,000 (Mountbatten's partisans, as Lawrence James reports it); 500,000 Muslims entering West Punjab alone (governor Mudie); 800,000 total (British High Commissioner); about 1 million (most scholars, per the encyclopedia); about two million (Tanveer et al. 2024); 2.3-3.2 million Punjab population losses, deaths or unrecorded migration (Hill et al. 2008); 3.4 million 'missing' between outflows and inflows (Bharadwaj, Khwaja and Mian 2008) - C-2217 How many were displaced by Partition?
booked: The map keeps the counts.
the other reading: 14.5 million inflows, 17.9 million outflows (Bharadwaj, Khwaja and Mian); nearly 17 million (Bharadwaj and Mirza); 14 million (Tanveer et al.); about 14.5 million in the 1951 censuses (7.2 + 7.3 million) - C-2218 Should Partition's violence be called genocide?
booked: The map keeps the term contested.
the other reading: 'genocidal tendencies' though some question the term (Talbot and Singh); retributive genocide (Brass, in Punjab); strategic ethnic cleansing for political control (Jha and Wilkinson) - C-2219 Did haste make Partition more violent?
booked: The map keeps it contested.
the other reading: British haste caused the scale of slaughter (Wolpert); the British were forced by events; no alternative but to 'cut and run' (Lawrence James) - C-2220 How much ill health can be traced to Partition?
booked: The map keeps it open.
the other reading: infant and under-five mortality rose after partition because of it (Tanveer et al. 2024); several events ran together: the 1943 Bengal famine, the Kashmir war, the exchange rate (Gupta 2024) - C-2221 When did Partition begin and end?
booked: The map keeps the spans side by side.
the other reading: 3 June to 15 August 1947 (the decision and transfer); 16 August 1946 to the 1951 censuses (killing to resettlement); to 1973 (migration from East Pakistan); 1971 (Bangladesh, 'a later partition of Pakistan') - C-2223 Was the population exchange a policy?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: a full exchange would have prevented later conflict (Ambedkar, Patel; proponents today); a forced transfer would cause immense suffering; secular coexistence (Nehru, Gandhi)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (24) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Partition of India (1947). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- runaway from an unstable balance (structural)
Mixed districts lived in a balance where 'religious minorities were expected to stay put'. From Direct Action Day (16 August 1946) attacks fed reprisals elsewhere (Bihar, Noakhali, Garhmukteshwar, Rawalpindi), refugees' stories fed new killings (Jammu), and each flight sparked riots where the refuge - The carry (structural)
Two faces. The wait: the Punjab Mental Hospital's partition 'dragged out over several years as there was nowhere to transfer patients' until the Amritsar asylum was built (1949). Overflow passed on: of 450 patients Amritsar received in 1950, 282 were kept 'with the remainder being sent on to Ranchi' - The Payment to Entropy (structural)
Every hand-off of the partition paid a toll. People: 17.9 million left, 14.5 million arrived (about 0.81 arriving, computed from Bharadwaj, Khwaja and Mian's figures; 3.4 million 'missing'). Land: 67 lakh acres abandoned in West Pakistan by Hindu-Sikh owners, 47 lakh available in East Punjab (about - who opens the door (structural)
At the princes' crossing into the new states, the receiving system built the door ahead of time: the States Department (Patel, Menon) drafted the Standstill Agreement and the Instrument of Accession before 15 August, and 'the vast majority of states signed Instruments of Accession' by then. At the r - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Borrowed: 'The Government of India Act 1935 was adapted to provide a legal framework for the new dominions.' Held: India's own constitution as a republic (1950), Pakistan's as an Islamic Republic (1956). - conservation law plus closure (partial)
The commissions' rule, 'contiguous majority areas of Muslims and non-Muslims', left a slot open, closed by a second rule nobody defined: 'In doing so, it will take into account other factors.' The second rule moved the line at Gurdaspur and Ferozepur (canal headwaters, an arms depot). - coordination-before-mapping (partial)
The line was coordinated among parties, commissions and two governments without a survey of the ground: 'Nor was there time to gather the survey and regional information'; Radcliffe 'had never visited India'. The successor governments mapped the consequences afterwards (camp counts, the 1951 censuse - holding / entrainment (partial)
One clock, set by the whole, ran every part: the transfer date (advanced to 15 August) fixed when the commissions had to finish ('all parties were insistent that the line be finished by the 15 August British withdrawal'), when the assets were split and when the princes had to sign. - lightning (partial)
Direct Action Day (16 August 1946): a stored difference released in three days of killing (about 4,000 dead), 'the first to display elements of "ethnic cleansing"', after which violence spread and 'the riots opened the way to a partition of Bengal'. - outside-to-inside (partial)
A partition first drawn from outside by the Raj's administration (Curzon's 1905 partition of Bengal by religious majority; separate electorates granted by the Crown) became a partition held inside the subcontinent's own politics (the Lahore Resolution, the 1946 vote) and then inside its districts (' - partner-becomes-part (partial)
The princely states, partners of the Crown under subsidiary alliances, acceded and were transformed 'until, by 1956, there was little difference between the territories that had been part of British India and those that had been princely states'. - red-queen (partial)
India and Pakistan fought in 1947-48, 1965, 1971 and at Kargil (1999); 'After two further wars in 1965 and 1971, only minor changes in the ground situation had been effected' in Kashmir. The stalemate is shown; each side's improvement is not. - same role, different builds (partial)
One job, resettling refugees on land, built two ways: on the north-western border 'organized and swift' with the standard acre and graded cuts; on the eastern border 'disorganized and protracted', with a deliberate policy to avoid an exchange and no land compensation. - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
One process, expelling a district's minority across the line, run in both directions at once in Punjab: 'the Muslim population of East Punjab was forcibly expelled like the Hindu/Sikh population in West Punjab' ('retributive ethnic cleansing on both sides'). - smooth to sharp in finite time (partial)
A smooth gradient of religious majorities across Punjab (Amritsar 46.5% Muslim, Gurdaspur 51.1%) became a sharp line in five weeks, and the mixed districts became homogeneous within months ('a dramatic religious homogenization at the district level'). Not a singularity in the mathematical sense: par - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (partial)
Gurdaspur, a near-even district (51.1% Muslim in the notional line; 50.2% by the Radcliffe page), was cut at a named line: three tehsils to India, Shakargarh to Pakistan. The direction chosen set what followed (the land route toward Kashmir, contested). - templating (partial)
A partition template reused: the Greece-Turkey exchange (1923) cited as precedent; economists list Cyprus (1974), Bosnia (1995) and Sudan (2011) as the same kind; the 1935 Act reused as both dominions' frame. - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Whether a place counted as 'Muslim-majority' depended on the unit the whole chose: by district, Gurdaspur was Muslim; by tehsil, Pathankot was not; Zafarullah Khan argued the tehsil as unit would have given Pakistan more and made Amritsar an enclave. Local readings did not close into one line. - trade one property for another (partial)
Speed bought with preparation: Mountbatten 'advanced the date'; outside experts and the UN were left out 'to avoid delay'; the award was kept secret 'to avoid disputes and delays' and published after independence. Wolpert reads the price as the scale of slaughter; others say there was no alternative - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (partial)
Each party read its own slice of the same population: the census (Lahore about two-thirds Muslim), 1945 ration cards (54%, per Hindu and Sikh politicians), land revenue (Muslims paid 35% in Gurdaspur), shops and factories (67% and 80% Hindu- and Sikh-owned in Lahore). - causal ceiling (surface)
Dark twin: what Radcliffe weighed is unknowable because he 'destroyed all his papers', and the Mountbatten papers on Kashmir 'are closed to scholars': a practical limit on the record, not a structural one. - nested ladder (surface)
Units of division nested by size (district, tehsil, thana, village), each finer than the last; Zafarullah Khan says Radcliffe used all four. Ordered by size, not by implication (the dark twin): surface. - same toolkit, independent builds (surface)
Two states built from one divided toolkit (army, civil service, railways, treasury, the 1935 Act). Shared ancestry, one build split in two (the dark twin): surface. - seed (surface)
The name Pakistan (1933) and the two-nation idea preceded a state; a small cause with a large effect, but no source shows combinatorics unpacking (the dark twin): surface.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (22) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Nationalism via sys:nationalism · Partition of India (1947) gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Partition of India (1947) gain
- Collective memory via sys:collective-memory · Partition of India (1947) gain
- Census via sys:census · Partition of India (1947) gain
- World War II (1939-1945) via sys:international-system · Partition of India (1947) gain
- United Nations via sys:international-system · Partition of India (1947) even
- Green Revolution via sys:human-society · Partition of India (1947) even
- Mughal Empire (from Babur's victory at Panipat, 1526, to the deposition of Bahadur Shah Zafar, 1857) via sys:collective-memory · Partition of India (1947) gain
- British Empire via sys:international-system · Partition of India (1947) gain
- Indian National Congress via sys:human-society · Partition of India (1947) gain
- All-India Muslim League via sys:human-society · Partition of India (1947) gain
- Princely state (562) via sys:state · Partition of India (1947) gain
- India (Dominion, then Republic) via sys:state · Partition of India (1947) gain
carried through it: Partition refugees (loss): 12 to 20 million displaced; about 1 million died in the violence - Pakistan (Dominion, then Islamic Republic) via sys:state · Partition of India (1947) gain
carried through it: Partition refugees (loss): 12 to 20 million displaced; about 1 million died in the violence - Bangladesh (East Bengal, East Pakistan to 1971) via sys:state · Partition of India (1947) gain
- The Indus rivers and canals via sys:indus-river · Partition of India (1947) gain
- Jute (raw fibre and mills) via sys:market · Partition of India (1947) even
- Decolonization (the end of colonial empires, especially 1945-1975) via sys:territory · Partition of India (1947) mixed
- Colonialism via sys:human-society · Partition of India (1947) gain
- British Raj via sys:state · Partition of India (1947) gain
- Sikhism and the Sikh community via sys:human-society · Partition of India (1947) even
- Human migration via sys:human-society · Partition of India (1947) loss
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Indian National Congress
- All-India Muslim League
- Sikh political leadership (Shiromani Akali Dal, Master Tara Singh)
- Attlee's Labour government
- Punjab and Bengal Boundary Commissions
- Partition Council
- British Raj
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Decolonization (the end of colonial empires, especially 1945-1975)
- Colonialism
- The Indian subcontinent
expressed by (17)
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Mapping/Modeling
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Speed
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Battlespace Shaping
- Divide & Isolate
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Delay/Redirection Tactics
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Enclave/Segregation
- Resilience & Repair
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
floor filled by (20)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Collective memory
- Map (maps and map-making)
- Census
- Nationalism
- Rail transport (railways)
- Indian National Congress
- All-India Muslim League
- Punjab and Bengal Boundary Commissions
- Partition Council
- Princely state (562)
- India (Dominion, then Republic)
- Pakistan (Dominion, then Islamic Republic)
- The Indus rivers and canals
- Jute (raw fibre and mills)
- Decolonization (the end of colonial empires, especially 1945-1975)
- British Raj
- Two-nation theory
- Separate electorates
Kinds (2)
Notes published science
- When a Lahore mental hospital had to be split by religion, the patients waited years because there was nowhere to send them; when the Amritsar asylum was finally built, it took 450 in 1950, kept 282 and sent the rest on to Ranchi. Manto turned the exchange into 'Toba Tek Singh' (src:jokinen-assadullah-2022).
- The partition lost people in transit like a leaky pipe: about 17.9 million left their districts but only about 14.5 million were counted arriving, leaving 3.4 million 'missing' (src:bharadwaj-khwaja-mian-2008). Land leaked too: Hindu and Sikh owners left 67 lakh acres in West Pakistan, but only 47 lakh acres were free in East Punjab, and claims were then cut by 25% to 95% (src:kataria-2016, src:bharadwaj-mirza-2019).
- The places that took in the most refugees ended up ahead: from 1957 to 2009 their wheat yields were 9.4% higher and they used far more tractors, as if the upheaval had seeded the Green Revolution (src:bharadwaj-mirza-2019).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Partition of India: the subcontinent's peoples and lands, through census, ballot, street and survey, to parties, the Raj and the boundary commissions, to the line, the exodus and the successor states (reader's view; historians' periods in `periods`)
- L1: The lands and peoples of British India: about 390 million people, Punjab and Bengal mixed by faith, five rivers and their canals, railways, the princely states
- L2: What comes in: the census of religion, election returns, riot reports, land and revenue records, rulers' choices, refugees' arrival
- L3: Routing: parties, press and slogans; governors' reports; counsel before the commissions; railways and caravans; refugees' stories
- L4: Integration: the contiguous-majority reading, the notional division, 'other factors', the deadline
- L5: Institutions: parties, the Raj, the Partition Council and boundary commissions, the two dominion governments
- L6: Meaning: two nations or one; the rules of division; later, memory and trauma
- L7: The transfer and division: two dominions at midnight on 14-15 August 1947, the line, the exodus, the successor states' acts
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The parties and their leaders: Congress (Nehru, Patel, Gandhi), the League (Jinnah), the Sikhs (Tara Singh), the Hindu Mahasabha
- L5: The Raj's government: Viceroy (Wavell, then Mountbatten), governors, the Labour cabinet and its missions
- L5: The Partition Council and the Punjab and Bengal Boundary Commissions (two Congress and two League judges each, Radcliffe chairing)
- L5: The two dominion governments: States Department, relief and rehabilitation ministries, armies
- L6: The rules of division: assemblies vote on partition, referendums in NWFP and Sylhet, contiguous majority areas plus 'other factors', no independent Bengal
- L6: Meaning: two nations or one; a Muslim homeland (popularly imagined by many as a 'New Medina') or a secular India
- L6: Memory and trauma: intergenerational trauma, competing memories of victimhood, historiography
- L7: The decision and its execution: to divide and transfer power (3 June Plan, Indian Independence Act, the Award), and the successor states' acts
way in: Britain's means and will
- L1: An exchequer exhausted by the war; a public unwilling to pay for distant involvements
- L2: The July 1945 general election: Labour, long supportive of Indian self-rule
- L3: Cabinet, India Office and the Cabinet Mission carry it to India
- L4: A deadline: power transferred no later than June 1948
way in: Elections and separate electorates
- L1: Voters, a narrow franchise widened to 35 million in 1935
- L2: Separate electorates and reserved Muslim seats (Minto-Morley 1909, Lucknow Pact 1916)
- L3: Campaigns and party organisation: the League's 1937 showing in minority provinces; Congress contested 58 of 482 Muslim seats
- L4: Results read as mandates: 1946, Congress 91% of non-Muslim votes, the League the Muslim seats
way in: Ideas of nationhood (the two-nation theory and its opponents)
- L1: Communities of faith with their own histories and memories, including the former Muslim ruling class's sense of distinctness
- L2: Texts: Savarkar's Essentials of Hindutva (1923), Lajpat Rai (1924), Rahmat Ali's Now or Never (1933)
- L3: Sessions, slogans and the press: the Lahore Resolution (March 1940); Bande Mataram
- L4: The demand formulated: grouped independent states in the Muslim-majority zones
- L5: Parties carrying the ideas: the League (with the Hindu Mahasabha and RSS also holding a two-nation view); Congress for one nation
way in: Land, water and lines of communication ('other factors')
- L1: The five rivers and their doabs; canal headworks; road and rail; landholdings
- L2: Land-revenue records, ration cards, ownership claims (Gurdaspur's 35% of land revenue; Lahore's 67% of shops)
- L3: Each side's counsel before the commission, 'with no liberty to bargain'
- L4: 'Other factors': natural boundaries, communications, watercourses and irrigation
way in: Memory: survivors' stories, silence, literature, archives
- L1: Survivors' experience of violence, separation and loss
- L2: Family telling and its 'selective silence'
- L3: Literature: Manto's 'Toba Tek Singh' (1954), Khushwant Singh's Train to Pakistan (1956), films
- L4: Archives and museums: the 1947 Partition Archive (about 9,700 interviews by 2021), the Partition Museum in Amritsar (2017)
- L5: Community narratives and historiography (each group's account of who suffered most; the History Project's two readings)
way in: Refugees arriving and their stories
- L1: About 14.5 million crossing: caravans, trains, ships; 12 million across Punjab, 3.3 million across Bengal
- L2: Camps and registration: 85 relief camps in East Punjab holding 721,396 by December 1948; Kingsway Camp
- L3: Relief and rehabilitation ministries; claims for abandoned land; refugees' stories carried to the next district
- L4: The censuses of displaced persons (1951): 7,226,600 in Pakistan, 7,295,870 in India
way in: The census: religion counted by district
- L1: The population of British India by faith, mixed in Punjab (55.7% Muslim) and Bengal (54.4% Muslim)
- L2: The decennial census, from 1871 counting Muslim-majority regions
- L3: District and tehsil tables carried into memoranda (Ambedkar's 16 western and 13 eastern districts; the Menon-Rau note)
- L4: The tables read as 'contiguous majority areas' and a notional division by district majorities
way in: The princely states' choices
- L1: 562 princely states under the Crown's suzerainty, released by the Act
- L2: The ruler decides (Hyderabad and Kashmir choose independence; Junagadh accedes to Pakistan)
- L3: The States Department (Patel, Menon) and Mountbatten negotiate; Standstill Agreement and Instrument of Accession
- L4: Most sign before 15 August; holdouts read as threats
way in: The street: riots and killings reported
- L1: Violence on the ground: Calcutta (16 August 1946), Noakhali, Bihar, Garhmukteshwar, Rawalpindi
- L2: Official accounts and counts (about 4,000 dead in Calcutta)
- L3: Governors, the army and the press carry it to Delhi and London
- L4: Read as looming civil war and as 'de facto Pakistan'
way out: Division of the common institutions
- L1: Railways truncated; Pakistan without most workshops and junctions
- L5: The Partition Council allocates
- L7: Decision to divide the institutions
way out: Killing and expulsion
- L1: Massacres, mutilation, abduction; most killings rural
- L5: Organisation: armed bands, veterans, princely state forces with logistics
- L7: Strategic aims: local political control through cleansing and co-ethnic immigration (Jha and Wilkinson's reading)
way out: Recovery of abducted women
- L1: Many refused to return, fearing their families' rejection
- L5: Claims and recoveries: 20,728 and 9,032 by 1954
- L7: Mutual promise to restore abducted women
way out: Relief, resettlement and land
- L1: Fields and cities changed: Delhi from 917,939 (1941) to 1,744,072 (1951); higher yields where refugees settled
- L3: Camps converted to housing; new colonies and townships (Lajpat Nagar, Ulhasnagar)
- L5: The standard acre and graded cuts (25% to 95%)
- L7: Rehabilitation as policy: education, jobs, loans; land for land on the north-west border
way out: The line: plan, Act, Award, flags
- L1: Districts change hands (Murshidabad, Malda, Gurdaspur, Chittagong Hill Tracts)
- L3: Radio announcement; flags changed
- L5: The award drawn in five weeks, kept secret, given to the two sides for two hours
- L7: The 3 June Plan accepted; the Act passed (18 July)
way out: Transfer of populations
- L1: 12 million across Punjab, 3.3 million across Bengal; districts homogenised
- L5: Columns, trains and ships (80,000 Meos in one column; Sindhi Hindus by ship or train)
- L7: No transfer planned; organised only for Punjab
way out: Treaties between the successor states
- L1: Rivers allocated: India about 20% of the flow, Pakistan 80%
- L7: The Indus Waters Treaty, mediated by the World Bank (1960)
way out: War over the princely states
- L1: Ceasefire line, later the Line of Control: two-thirds and one-third
- L5: Blockades: supplies cut to Junagadh and Kashmir
- L7: Pakistan launches tribal lashkars into Kashmir; India accepts accession and airlifts troops