The Payment to Entropy our proposal
Whenever a system hands something on (energy, matter, a signal, value, attention), part of it arrives in a form the next holder cannot use, and the loss compounds along a chain of hand-offs: the second law of thermodynamics showing up wherever things are passed along.
Seen in 387 walked systems. Each sighting is our reading of that system's sourced walk, in that system's own terms; a shape that turns up everywhere is the finding, and how it differs from place to place is the detail.
Structural: the shape does the work here (162)
- Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter)
Every neighbour-to-neighbour hand-off of a sound wave pays: spreading thins it, viscous and thermal absorption turn its ordered motion into heat ('Acoustic waves can be absorbed'), and finite amplitude moves energy into harmonics until a shock dissipates energy 'proportional to the cube of the diffe - Algebra (the practice of solving for unknowns and transforming expressions, and the structures it works with)
Algebra's hand-offs pay a toll in two forms. Logical (information form): a step that is not invertible (multiplying both sides by an expression that can be zero, squaring, dividing by a variable) breaks the two-way chain of implications, so a solution is added (extraneous) or lost (missing); the tol - Alloy
Three forms. Thermal: a shape-memory element's heating and cooling transitions differ, and 'some of the mechanical energy is lost' in the hysteresis each cycle (src:wp:shape-memory-alloy); a turbine's efficiency is capped by how hot its alloys can run (src:smith-2016-superalloy). Material: making al - Ancient Greek philosophy
Record form. Each hand-off of the tradition loses most of what is sent: 'no complete work survives' of the Presocratics, only fragments relayed by compilers who used them selectively; Chrysippus wrote 'over 150 works, of which only fragments remain'; the only complete Stoic works are imperial. At He - Anthropocene
Trophic form: before fossil fuels the human energy harvest was bottlenecked because 'plants photosynthesize less than a percent of the solar energy' and animals 'retain only a tenth'; the deep-past fossil store broke the bottleneck. Material form: the technosphere keeps 'a growing residue layer' alo - Aristotle
Every hand-off of the corpus paid a toll. Material: rolls kept about 150 years in a cellar 'not ideal for document preservation'; the Anatomai drawings and the published dialogues lost; the comedy book of the Poetics lost. Signal: Apellicon filled unreadable gaps by 'best guesswork'. Chain yield: ab - Arithmetic (the practice of calculating, and the operations and laws it works with)
Every hand-off of a value pays a toll in three forms. Measurement (signal form): 'add the absolute uncertainties of each summand together', so the uncertainty grows with every addition in a chain. Machine rounding (material form: bits): a result needing more bits is rounded and the low-order bits 'a - Artificial intelligence
Two forms. Information, compounding along a chain of generations: 'indiscriminate use of model-generated content in training causes irreversible defects', the 'tails of the original content distribution disappear' first, and behaviour converges 'to a point estimate with very small variance' over gen - Atlantic slave trade
Every hand-off of a captive cost lives: 10-50% died on the march to the coast, about 14% on the Middle Passage, a third in seasoning; per-step survival about 0.5-0.9, 0.86 and 0.67, compounding to roughly 0.3-0.5 from capture to a seasoned worker (our arithmetic on sourced percentages). Crews paid t - Atmosphere of Earth
The air is a heat engine between warm and cold regions: only a tiny part of its potential energy becomes motion, and that motion is dissipated by viscosity. Each hand-off from sunlight to heat to wind pays its toll in heat. Not booked as a toll: the CO2 the ocean and land take (56%), which is a hand - Autonomic nervous system
Body heat is the toll on metabolism: "a by-product of the inefficiency of mitochondrial ATP production and of ATP utilization". Sympathetic drive to brown fat opens a UCP1 proton leak that pays the toll on purpose, turning the waste into the product (heat); cold defences are recruited cheapest first - Bacterium (bacterial cell)
Soil microbes pay a toll on every carbon hand-off: carbon use efficiency, growth over uptake, runs from 0.2 to 0.8, so between 20% and 80% of the carbon taken up never becomes biomass. Inside the cell the toll is paid twice over: ATP yield is not constant, part goes to maintenance, and bacteria spil - Bearing (mechanical)
Every turn pays a toll in heat: rolling friction about 0.005 for steel, viscous dissipation in the EHL film dominating rolling resistance, the oil as heat sink; at world scale about 20% (103 EJ) of energy use goes to overcome friction and 3% (16 EJ) to remanufacture worn parts. Hydrostatic pumps and - Black hole
At super-Eddington inflow the radiation is trapped and carried inward: a magnetically arrested flow shines at about 100 L_Edd but with a radiative efficiency below 1%, against about 10% for Eddington-limited growth. Form: the toll is paid into the horizon, and the hole gains mass faster by turning l - Blood
Material toll on the iron chain: each day 20-25 mg of iron is recycled from old red cells and 1-2 mg must be absorbed to cover losses (per-day recycling efficiency about 0.92-0.95); each red cell loses about 20% of its volume and 15% of its haemoglobin over its 100-120 days. Not booked as toll: red - Blood pressure
Thermal/viscous form: the heart's pressure energy is spent along the tree, 'mean blood pressure decreases ... due to viscous losses of energy', most of it in small arteries and arterioles; the heart pays to hold it: left-ventricle efficiency falls in larger mammals, and the giraffe's ventricle burns - Botnet
Every hand-off of spam pays a toll: of almost 350 million pharmacy mails, delivery, filters, clicks and checkout left 28 sales (well under 0.00001%). Form: value/attention. A second form, signal: IP counts lose the bot's identity at each DHCP re-assignment (6.83 IPs per bot). - Bureaucracy
Every pass through the administration pays a toll. In US health care, 34.2% of national health spending went on administration in 2017 against 17.0% in Canada (a per-pass share of about 0.66 reaching non-administrative use in the US, 0.83 in Canada, Lead's arithmetic), and the toll is undercounted b - Calculus (the practice of handling change and accumulation by limits, and the structures it works on)
Calculus pays at its hand-offs, in four forms. (1) Signal: a differentiator answers the rate of change but also amplifies high-frequency parts of its input, in machines and in cells ('a major obstacle of both technological and biological differentiators', Alexis et al. 2021). (2) Numerical: a comput - Cellular respiration
Thermal form, as a chain of hand-offs: fuel redox energy to NADH, NADH to the proton motive force, the pmf to ATP, ATP to work, and the work to heat. Each step pays: the 38 ATP 'maximum yield is never quite reached because of losses due to leaky membranes as well as the cost of moving pyruvate and A - Central processing unit
Thermal and signal forms at every hand-off. The Landauer floor is 2.85e-21 J per erased bit, yet chips dissipate 0.1-100 W; 30-60% of energy goes in wires and repeaters, 50-80% of gates are repeaters, and driving the clock can take over 30% of a big chip's power. Moving data to and from memory costs - Chaos and nonlinear dynamics (the practice, and the chaotic behaviour it studies)
Form: information (and through it, thermodynamic). Every hand-off of a chaotic state forward in time pays a toll in predictive worth: an initial error grows by a factor e every Lyapunov time, so a forecast is worthless after two or three of them (src:wp:chaos-theory); the toll is a rate, the Kolmogo - Chemical bond
Thermal form, at the moment a bond is born. H + H releases about 440 kJ/mol (4.50 eV), and the new bond keeps only if that excess is handed on: a grain takes 32-54% (graphene) or 45-65% (water ice), 40-50% leaves as the molecule's own motion; kept, it breaks the bond again. Every bond formed pays it - Chemical equilibrium
Thermal and catalytic forms. Every net turnover away from equilibrium dissipates its driving force as heat (Crooks: entropy production l dG for l net turnovers, o44). Near equilibrium the toll is paid in enzyme instead: at -1 kJ/mol about 40% of an enzyme's flux runs backwards and the net rate is ab - Chemical kinetics
Thermal form. Every exothermic step hands its excess energy to a third body that carries it off as heat ('M is an air molecule that removes excess energy from reaction intermediates by collisional dissipation', o50); in flames that heat is what drives the runaway (o40). Origin-of-life form: any self - Chemistry (the field: the practice of chemists and the structure of substances and their reactions it works on)
Every synthesis hands on less product than it takes in: the E-factor runs from under 0.1 kg waste per kg in oil refining to 25-100+ in pharmaceuticals, and the toll grows with the number of stages ('multi-stage reactions during which many by-products (waste) are generated'). Per-pass mass efficiency - Classical mechanics (Newtonian mechanics: bodies, forces and motion, and the practice of describing them)
Thermal form: friction converts the kinetic energy of a sliding body to heat ('The force due to friction is non-conservative'); each bounce keeps a fraction e^2 of the kinetic energy (superball on stone e = 0.9544, so about 0.911 per bounce, our arithmetic from Aguiar and Laudares) and the loss comp - Climate change
Thermal form. Earth absorbs low-entropy solar photons at about 6000 K and sends high-entropy infrared at about 255 K; the atmosphere works as a heat engine, with 1.5-2.9 W/m2 as mechanical work in reanalyses and only 'a tiny part of the potential energy of the atmosphere' convertible to mechanical e - Climate system (climate)
Thermal form. Sunlight absorbed (238 W/m2) is handed to the atmosphere's heat engine, and only about 0.8-1.3% comes out as wind (kinetic-energy dissipation); 'only a tiny part of the potential energy of the atmosphere can be converted to mechanical energy'. The rest leaves as infrared at the planet' - Cloud computing
Thermal form: nearly all server energy becomes heat; facility overhead takes half the power in an average US data centre (PUE 2.0: about 0.50 of grid power reaches IT, 0.83 at PUE 1.2, derived); idle servers draw about half full power; 1-9 L of water evaporate per kWh to carry the heat away. Chain y - Communication: the passing of messages between senders and receivers through a channel (and, on other readings, the making of meaning between them), and communication studies, the field that studies it
Every hand-off pays a toll. Shannon: send faster than capacity and 'Nature takes payment by requiring just that much uncertainty'; noise distorts the signal on the way. In chains of people, message content is gradually lost: messages get shorter, less accurate and more dissimilar with each transmiss - Complex analysis (the practice of working with functions of a complex variable, and the holomorphic structure it works on)
Every hand-off along a continuation pays in digits. Analytic continuation is ill-posed and only ill-conditioned once a bound is known; along a strip the accurate digits shrink exponentially (2 pi units along, 45,000 digits in for 3 out), and the classical chain of disks, recentring a series disk aft - Computational physics (computer simulation of physical systems: the practice and the simulated systems it stands for)
Thermal form: every irreversible operation pays at least of order kT as heat (Landauer), and the facility pays again: data centres draw 1.67 times the power their computers use, so about 0.60 of the power reaches computing (derived). The run's electricity leaves as heat and emissions. - Computer memory
Thermal and signal forms at every hand-off. Erasing a bit must shed at least kB T ln 2 (about 3e-21 J at 300 K; a one-bit memory's measured erasure heat 0.72 kB T in slow cycles). DRAM 'consumes energy even when it is not used' because charge leaks and must be refreshed, and refresh power 'rapidly b - Computer network
Every hand-off pays: signals attenuate with distance ('such signals weaken, or attenuate'); glass in 1966 lost 200 dB/km; noise corrupts bits and the CRC throws the frame away; repeaters regenerate but 'still require a small amount of time'; each packet pays headers (1460 of 1500 bytes carry data, e - Computer science (the field: the practice and the computation it studies)
Every logically irreversible step (erasing a bit, merging two paths) pays an entropy increase outside the information-bearing state, usually as heat; real machines pay 'macroscopic amounts of energy far in excess' of the minimum. A signal form too: Shannon's channel reproduces a message only 'exactl - Computer-aided design
Signal and material form at each hand-off of a model: translation between systems loses topology or makes files unusable, and the loss mounts with the number of exchanges (at least $1 billion a year in the US automotive chain, 86% of it spent repairing or re-entering files; about 2 months' delay). W - Condensed matter physics
Thermal form, with its zero case: in a normal conductor 'during each collision some of the energy carried by the current is absorbed by the lattice and converted into heat' (Joule heating); in a superconductor the toll is held at zero by the gap, and a current ran 28 years 7 months 27 days with no m - Corporation
Signal form, with a per-hand-off efficiency: in Buldyrev et al.'s hierarchical-tree model of a company, a decision taken at the head is followed at each level down only with probability Π, so its reach decays level by level (Π to the power of the number of levels); for the measured growth-rate expon - Cryptographic hash function
Thermal form: hashing turns electricity into heat; Bitcoin's proof-of-work alone 60-125 TWh a year (2020), and 'we cannot consume energy, but merely change its form from valuable (e.g., electricity) to less valuable (e.g., heat)'. Information form, loss by design (C-736): the hash maps any length to - Cryptography
Form: signal (photon loss). In quantum key distribution the secret key rate 'scales as the transmissivity in the fiber, which decays exponentially with distance', bounded at high loss by about 1.44 eta secret bits per channel use (Pirandola et al.), with standard fibre losing 0.2 dB per km: each han - Crystal
Mechanical/signal form, with a number: a quartz resonator stores energy and loses a fraction to mechanical friction each cycle; Q is stored over dissipated per cycle (src:wp:q-factor), and 10 MHz AT-cut resonators measure Q 6418 to 10,125 (src:wei-2022-qcm), so each cycle's hand-off loses 2*pi/Q = 6 - Data centre
Every watt handed through the facility pays a toll: transformers, UPS and distribution lose some, cooling and lighting take more, and nearly all of what reaches the servers leaves as heat. The toll is read as PUE: US average 1.4 in 2023 (IT share about 0.71), Google 1.12 in 2013 (about 0.89), tradit - Data structure
Every hand-off of data through the memory hierarchy pays: a DRAM access costs about 800 times an addition and data movement takes 62.7% of consumer-device energy; in space, a growing structure must waste about sqrt(n) words at some moment, and a doubly linked node spends two of three fields on links - Database
Signal form: each join hands an estimate to the next, and the error compounds: 'misestimates by a factor of 1000 or more', errors that 'grow exponentially' with the number of joins, systematically underestimated. Material form: replicas drift apart and need 'Anti-entropy using Merkle trees'; materia - Denial-of-service attack
Each hand-off of a flood pays a toll: the Internet's capacity attenuates an attack's throw weight, and the farther the target from the sources the less arrives across congested links; a premium booter delivered about 25% of the rate it advertised; past saturation a host's useful work falls (livelock - Differential equations (the practice of writing and solving laws of change, and the equations it works on)
Three forms. (1) Chain: each numerical step hands its error to the next; the Euler method's error per step goes as h^2 and at a given time as h, and rounding errors add up, expected total proportional to epsilon over root h, so shrinking the step to cut truncation raises the rounding toll ('the effe - Digital forensics
Every hand-off in the evidence chain pays a toll, in several forms. Material: after deletion an SSD's own garbage collection began within the first minute and none of 70 files came back with its original hash; live, mobile and remote acquisitions are 'acquired imperfectly'; copying a file can change - DNA and genes
Every hand-off of the sequence pays a toll. Copying: errors that escape base selection, proofreading and a more-than-100-fold mismatch-repair step still accumulate at 10^-6 to 10^-8 per cell per generation; reading out: transcription misincorporates about 4 x 10^-6 per site (per-hand-off efficiency - Earth's core
Every hand-off in the dynamo's energy chain pays a toll: heat out of the core does convective work only beyond what conduction carries down the adiabat (3-15 TW of a 5-15 TW flux, contested); the dynamo efficiency of heat at the boundary is about 0.1; only 'a fraction of this kinetic energy is conve - Economics (the field)
Every hand-off of data pays a toll. Signal form: in household surveys more than half of welfare dollars and nearly half of food stamp dollars are missed (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.5), and nonresponse rose (CPS 16 to 20%, NHIS 8 to 24%, 1997-2013). In the record: 22 of 67 published results repl - Election
Every hand-off from voter to office loses votes: in the US in 2000 the process lost 4 to 6 million presidential votes, 1.5 million of them at the equipment step; registration trouble kept about 3 million registered voters away, lines and hours about 1 million. Under first-past-the-post, lost votes ( - Electrical grid
Every hand-off from fuel to socket pays a heat toll: a coal plant turns 35-38% of the fuel's heat into electricity (nuclear 30-32%), and transmission and distribution lose about 5% more in the US; resistive losses grow with the square of current, which is why voltage is stepped up. Chain yield, coal - Electron
Electrons handed down the respiratory chain to oxygen: oxidative phosphorylation keeps about 42% of the energy (TCA cycle 30%), the rest leaves as heat. Form: thermal, per-hand-off efficiency 0.42. In a metal, collisions with atoms hold drift to millimetres per second (resistance, heat); Cooper pair - Energy
At every conversion a share leaves as heat that cannot come back: 'at each stage of a metabolic pathway, some chemical energy is converted into heat'; ocean phytoplankton lose about 58% of absorbed photons as heat; food chains pass on about 6% per level (1.5% on land); heat engines always lose waste - Engine
Thermal, material and signal forms. Every heat engine must reject heat to a cold sink (Carnot); real engines pay more again in friction (23% of world energy at tribological contacts; 30% of transport energy) and combustion losses. Chain yield is stated as a product: power production = prime mover x - Engineering (design)
Thermal form, with numbers. Cullen traces the world's energy chain from fuel to service: conversion devices turn on average only 11% of primary energy into useful energy, passive systems use only 27% of that to deliver services, 'the remaining energy is currently lost as low temperature heat to the - Entropy
Entropy is the toll's own currency, so the shape shows in every form the walk touched. Heat: dispersing energy from warmer to cooler always raises the total and leaves energy T_R S unable to do work. Information: erasing a bit pays at least k_B T ln 2 (about 3e-21 J at 300 K), more when done fast (l - Experiment, measurement and uncertainty (the physics lab as a practice: designing, measuring, estimating error)
Signal form, thermal at root: thermal agitation of charge carriers puts noise into every measuring circuit, drowning weak signals; the dissipation and the noise are one effect (fluctuation-dissipation), and experimenters pay to push it down by cooling receivers to cryogenic temperatures. Every instr - Eye
Signal form, measured: of 54-148 quanta at the cornea, at most 5-14 are absorbed by rods (chain yield about 0.1): 4% reflected at the cornea, about 50% absorbed by the media, at least 80% passing the retina unabsorbed; the eye's overall quantum efficiency about 30%. Thermal-metabolic form: the eye c - Fishery
Every hand-off pays a toll. Material: about a quarter of marine catch is bycatch, mostly thrown back to die (10.3 Mt a year discarded, 2000-2010; shrimp trawls catch five times their shrimp); 1.82% of all gear is lost each year and keeps ghost fishing. Economic: under open access the whole resource - Fluid dynamics (the flows of liquids and gases, and the practice of describing them)
Every flow pays viscosity: 'the dissipation term is always positive', and in turbulence the toll is paid at the end of a chain of hand-offs from big eddies to millimetre ones. The global atmosphere as a heat engine passes only about 1% of the absorbed sunlight (2.0-2.7 of about 238 W/m2, derived) th - Fossil fuel
Every hand-off pays a toll, in three forms. Thermal: a coal plant turns 25-50% of the fuel's heat into electricity, the rest leaves as waste heat. Material: 2.3% of US gas production leaks as methane on the way (2015), and over 20 years that leak warms as much as the CO2 from burning the gas; abando - Fourier analysis (the practice of splitting signals into waves and rebuilding them, and the structure it works on)
Forms, all information. (1) Measurement: X-ray diffraction loses the phases ('the phases of X-ray waves are lost as the X-ray diffraction is measured', src:hendrickson-2023) and the whole field of phasing exists to buy them back. (2) Sampling and windowing: aliases and leakage add components that we - Fruit fly (Drosophila melanogaster)
Thermal form, measured: flight muscle turns at most 10% of metabolic power into mechanical power, so about 90% leaves as heat at peak force; most of the mechanical power then goes to overcoming drag, not lift - Function (mathematics): the assignment of exactly one output to each input, and the practice of defining, drawing, composing and using it
A function that is not injective merges inputs that cannot be told apart afterwards (the square function sends -3 and 3 to one output), and Landauer's principle ties that logical merging to a physical toll: any logically irreversible step must be accompanied by an entropy increase in the surrounding - Fungi (yeasts, molds and mushrooms: absorptive eukaryotes with chitin walls)
Aerobic fermentation hands glucose on at a toll: '2 ATP vs. approximately 18 ATP per glucose' (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.11 of the respiring route, derived), and biomass yield falls from about 0.5 g/g to 'below 0.2 g/g'. The unusable part leaves as ethanol, and it is not all lost: 'The ethanol - Galaxy
Dust pays a thermal toll on starlight: visible light absorbed by dust grains leaves as far-infrared (form: thermal); a galaxy's light is degraded on its way out. - Gear
Every mesh pays a toll: friction in the meshing phase and fluid losses become heat that the lubrication system must carry off (thermal form). Worm meshes pay most (considerable sliding, low efficiency); an electric drivetrain including its gearbox delivers 59-77%. At the nanoscale the toll goes into - General relativity
thermal form, on the horizon: in equilibrium the hand-off of energy across a local horizon pays no toll (delta Q = T dS exactly; the equations 'time reversal invariant'); pushed out of equilibrium the balance gains an internal term, dS = delta Q / T + d_iS, which for pure GR is a horizon shear visco - Geology (the field)
Signal form, two hand-offs: from the outcrop to the notebook and from the notebook to print, part of what was seen does not arrive. In experiment 1 the experts would record only the 4 least variable of 10 strike arrays and publish only the 2 least variable; what is not recorded is 'effectively lost' - Globalization
Every crossing pays a toll. Material/transport form: shipping Rangoon rice to Europe cost 73.8% of its Rangoon price in 1882 and 18.1% in 1914 (eta about 0.58 to 0.85, derived); break-bulk handling lost cargo to 'the pilferage that always took place along the way'. Signal form: information frictions - Gravitational field
Every gravitational hand-off of energy here pays a heat toll: tides take 3.78 TW from Earth's spin and pass only about 1/30 (0.121 TW) to the Moon's orbit, the rest becoming heat in the oceans (eta about 0.03); a contracting gas cloud or planet radiates half of the gravitational energy it releases ( - Great Acceleration
Three forms. Trophic: before fossil fuels the energy harvest was bottlenecked because 'plants photosynthesize less than a percent of the solar energy' and animals 'retain only a tenth'; the fossil store (a deep-past subsidy) broke the bottleneck. Thermal/food: the industrial food system 'consumes ~1 - Gross domestic product
Three forms. Material: depreciation (capital consumption) is the wear toll the stock pays each period; GDP is gross of it, and the economy can run down assets while recording high growth. Thermal: output is tightly coupled to useful exergy; primary energy decouples only as far as conversion to usefu - Hamiltonian and Lagrangian mechanics (analytical mechanics: classical mechanics built from energy functions and the stationary action, and the practice of using them)
The lossless limit, with the toll bolted on: a Hamiltonian flow hands energy between kinetic and potential with no toll (phase volume kept, reversible in time); the toll enters only as add-ons: a dissipation function ('energy is not conserved when a dissipation function has effect'), friction as the - Harmonic oscillator
Every cycle pays a toll: Q is 2 pi times the energy stored over the energy lost per cycle; a test pendulum left unkicked loses about 1% of its speed per swing; a clock's escapement repays it from the weight each cycle; healthy walking recovers 68.1% of the swing energy per step and muscles pay the r - History of science (the field and the story it tells)
Material, signal and attention forms. Material: only a third of the Antikythera mechanism survives (82 fragments); Cicero's Latin translation of the Timaeus 'has not survived'; Greek learning 'deteriorated' in the Latin West; Chinese eclipse prediction 'was lost during the Ming dynasty'. Attention: - Human physiology
Thermal-metabolic form, the price of holding: each degree of fever costs 10-12.5% more metabolism; mental stress alone raises resting energy expenditure by about 9-67%; organs pay very different standing tolls (heart and kidneys 440 kcal/kg/day, fat 4.5); and the effectors are recruited in order of - International trade
Every hand-off of a good on its way abroad pays a toll, and the tolls multiply: transport x1.21, border x1.44, distribution x1.55 = 2.7 (170% ad valorem) for rich countries, higher for poor ones. Read as usable share per hand-off (derived): about 0.83, 0.69 and 0.65, end-to-end about 0.37. Trade the - Internet
Every hand-off pays a toll, in four forms here. Header (signal): a keystroke sent alone travels as 41 bytes for 1 byte of data, 'This 4000% overhead' (usable/sent about 0.024). Material (drops): 1988 gateways commonly dropped 10% of incoming packets (about 0.9 per such hop), and under collapse throu - Intrusion detection system
Signal form. Every hand-off up the stack pays a toll in usable signal: a million audit records a day reduce to one or two intrusions; at a false alarm rate of 1e-5 only about 58-66% of alarms are true (Axelsson); in the SOC an analyst puts it at 99% false; the human floor then loses about 10% of cor - Journalism
Signal form: a message handed along a chain arrives changed. Passed person to person, messages become shorter and gradually inaccurate (Moussaid); a university press release's exaggeration is carried into 58-86% of stories (Sumner), so distortion compounds across research -> release -> news. A loss - Life (the living world, as biology describes it)
Trophic form: 5.92% of energy passes up a feeding level on average (1.52% on land, 8.13% at sea), the product of ingestion, assimilation and production efficiencies; the rest leaves as heat and excreta. Thermal form: 29-30 ATP per glucose against a higher theoretical maximum (leaky membranes, transp - Limit (mathematics): the value a sequence or function approaches, and the practice of approaching, bounding and proving it
Taking a limit on a machine pays a toll at each hand-off: the difference quotient adds a small number to a big one and subtracts nearly equal numbers, so digits are lost to round-off while truncation error falls only as h falls; below about sqrt(eps) x the loss wins. Form: signal/information (digits - Linear algebra (the practice of solving, transforming and taking apart linear systems with vectors and matrices, and the structures it works with)
Linear algebra's hand-offs pay a toll in three forms. Signal (numerical): floating point cannot represent the reals, so each step can widen the gap between stored and true numbers; in elimination the entries handed from step to step can grow, and the growth factor, 'a key parameter in error estimate - Linguistics (the field: the practice and the languages it studies)
Signal and record form. Each hand-off of language data loses part of it: speech features 'not always recorded in writing' (phonological rules, sound changes, speech errors); grammars coded into databases arrive with gaps (Grambank 24% missing, WALS 84%: a usable share of about 0.76 against 0.16); th - Literature
Every hand-off of a work pays a toll. Material form: across the copying chain from the Middle Ages to today about 9% of manuscripts survive, and at most about half of chivalric texts are known (survival 0.53-0.59); losses by burning, fires and gradual forgetting. Signal form: oral singers swapped na - Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason
Thermal form: every logically irreversible step (erasing a bit; AND, NAND, OR, XOR) dissipates at least kB T ln 2 of heat per lost bit, about 3e-21 J at 300 K, measured on a one-bit colloidal memory; logically reversible steps can in principle be paid nothing (Bennett). Signal form: a complex argume - Machine
Thermal, material and signal forms at every hand-off. All real machines lose energy to friction as heat (efficiency below 1); about 23% of world energy goes to tribological contacts (20% friction, 3% remanufacturing worn parts). Chain: flume to wheel spills (10% modelled at Barbegal), wheel converts - Malware
Extortion hands on value with a large toll: victims' direct losses (lost data and systems, time to recover) run one to two orders of magnitude above the ransom revenue the operators receive, so per hand-off efficiency is about 0.01-0.1 (form: material/value). Worms pay in wasted probes: random scann - Marketing
Every advertising hand-off pays a toll: most paid-search spend reaches frequent users who would buy anyway, so incremental revenue was about 0.37 of spend (ROI -63%); brand-keyword clicks were bought for traffic that natural search delivered free; Wanamaker's 'half the money ... wasted'. Form: a sig - Mathematics (the field: the practice and the structures it studies)
Signal form. Each hand-off of a mathematical idea loses part of it: the 'huge expansion factor' from one head to another; one-to-one in minutes, an hour as a talk, 15-20 pages as a paper; in papers 'Writers translate their ideas into symbols and logic, and readers try to translate back'; most of a c - Mechanical engineering (the field)
Every machine hands power along a chain of contacts and each pays a toll: 'All real machines have friction, which causes some of the input power to be dissipated as heat'; 'the efficiency of a compound machine is also the product of the efficiencies of the series of simple machines that form it'. Wo - Memory
Signal form at every hand-off: about 12 items in the sensory store, 3 to 5 chunks pass into working memory; savings fall from 0.58 at 20 min to 0.21 at 31 days (Ebbinghaus); retrieval reopens a memory to misinformation. Energy form: forming protein-synthesis long-term memory costs flies desiccation - Mental health
Form here: attrition along a care chain. Of people with 12-month major depression, 56.7% recognise need, 71.1% of those visit a provider, 41.0% of the treated get minimally adequate treatment: 0.567 x 0.711 x 0.410 = 0.165, the source's own 16.5% end to end. The chain yield is the product of the han - Metamorphic rock
Reactions run only downhill ('a metamorphic reaction will take place only if it lowers the total Gibbs free energy'); prograde rock pays its volatiles out (blueschist 5.4 wt% water to eclogite 0 wt%), so the reverse is uncommon; grains coarsen to shed surface energy. A signal form too: each metamorp - Middle English literature
Every hand-off of the text pays a toll. Signal: seventeen B-text copies of one Piers line, no two identical; Chaucer (if the verses are his) must 'rub and scrape' his scribe's copies made in 'negligence and haste'; Caxton, hurrying, carried French words over untranslated. Material: a birth girdle wo - Mitochondrion
Every pass from fuel to ATP pays heat: about 70% of the proton current makes ATP in hepatocytes, up to 90% elsewhere, the rest leaks; ~0.15% of respiration leaves as H2O2; respiring mitochondria run more than 10 C warmer. In brown fat the toll is the job (heat, near-zero coupling): loss by design. - Molecule
Every photon a molecule takes in is handed on with a toll: higher excited states fall to the lowest one in under a picosecond and 'the ultrafast relaxation of higher excited states dissipates energy that is no longer available for photochemical reactions'. In the eye, retinal in rhodopsin turns an a - Museum
Every hand-off of an object, a label or a visitor's attention pays a toll: climate control uses up to 70% of a museum's energy; labels lost to humidity, rats and cockroaches; a dodo eaten by moths; hand transcription 93.34% correct (AI 96.85%); interest falling as displays accumulate - Natural environment
Every step up a food chain pays a toll: energy transfer averages 5.92% per trophic step (marine 8.13%, freshwater 5.53%, terrestrial 1.52%), the rest going to respiratory metabolism or excreted carbon; warmer water sends more to respiration. Form: trophic. Chain yield falls step by step from sunligh - Neutrino
The neutrino is the toll the weak force takes at every hand-off. Escape form: fusion's weak steps send about 2% of the Sun's energy out (src:wp:sun) as neutrinos that nothing downstream uses; a fission reactor loses about 4.5% (about 9 of 200 MeV per fission) to antineutrinos; in a collapsing star t - Newspaper
Material form: newsprint fibre is lost in every recycling pass and survives only about five passes, so virgin fibre must keep entering. Signal form: what an outlet hands on arrives mostly as copy (only 32.5% of French online content original), and a press release's exaggerations pass into the story - Nuclear fusion
Every hand-off in a fusion power chain pays a toll: for indirect-drive laser fusion the wall plug to laser light keeps 0.1, light to fuel 0.009, the hot spot 0.7 and heat to electricity 0.4 (Wurzel & Hsu); for magnetic confinement 0.7, 0.9 and 0.4. In the plasma, bremsstrahlung beats alpha heating b - Nursing (the field: the practice and the care it gives)
Every hand-off of a patient pays a toll in information. Simulated handover: purely verbal, all data lost after three cycles; note-taking, 31% transferred correctly after five (about 79% kept per hand-off if equal); with a typed sheet, minimal loss (the stash face, C-736). Nightingale's records shed - Old English literature
Every hand-off of the text pays a toll. Material: of the Exeter Book's 130 or 131 leaves the first 8 are lost (yield about 0.94 of the leaves, our arithmetic); the 1731 fire destroyed 13 Cotton manuscripts and seriously damaged some 200, burning Maldon's only manuscript; rebinding that saved Beowulf - Operating system
Every hand-off between programs, or between a program and the kernel, pays a toll: mode switches have a 'direct cost' plus 'the indirect pollution of important processor structures (like CPU caches, the instruction pipeline...)'; an interrupt per character costs 'a significant amount of CPU time'; l - Optics (light's behaviour: reflection, refraction, interference, lenses and instruments)
every optical hand-off pays a toll: about 4% of the light reflected at each bare glass surface (signal form), about 0.14 dB lost per km of silica fibre so the yield falls with every km (about 96.8% per km, computed), and only about 6% of single photons sent to the eye in one experiment gave a signal - Organism (the living thing, as biology describes it)
Trophic form: an organism handed on as food delivers on average 5.92% of its energy to the eater (1.52% on land, 8.13% at sea), against the textbook 10%. Material/thermal form: soil microbes build 0.2-0.8 of the carbon they take up into biomass and respire the rest. Production efficiency also falls - Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it)
Filling the bottom row pays a toll at every hand-off: evaporation residues 'about 11 orders of magnitude' below capture (fission and quasi-fission take the rest); separator transmission about 40%; transport into the detector 62%; the end-to-end yield one atom a month for oganesson. Per-hand-off effi - Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
Record and signal form. Each hand-off of a tradition loses part of it: whole schools' literature lost (Charvaka's Barhaspatya sutras; the Ajivika scriptures 'probably lost'); African philosophers before the 20th century transmitted orally, 'whose names have been lost to history'. In x-phi's hand-off - Phishing
Every hand-off in the chain pays a toll: of simulated lures sent, 5.67% are clicked, and 73.13% of clicks go on to the dangerous act (Lain et al.); at least 7.42% of real visitors end in fraud (Oest et al.); only 24.8% of phished passwords still match the victim's account (Thomas et al.). At the lev - Photosynthesis
Thermal form, chained: each hand-off from sunlight to sugar pays a toll and the tolls multiply: at most 4.6% (C3) or 6% (C4) of sunlight ends as biomass (Zhu); in the open ocean about 58% of absorbed photons go to heat, 7% to fluorescence, 35% to photochemistry (Falkowski). Material form: photorespi - Physics (the field)
Thermal-information form at its floor, measured. Landauer's principle: 'any logically irreversible transformation of classical information is necessarily accompanied by the dissipation of at least kB T ln 2 of heat per lost bit', about 3e-21 J at 300 K; Berut et al. built a one-bit memory from one c - Plate tectonics
The plate engine pays a toll at each hand-off: of the heat lost by cooling ocean plates, 1/3-1/2 becomes gravitational potential energy; when slabs sink, about 86% of that gravitational energy becomes heat by viscous dissipation (about 14% comes back as gravitational energy by adiabatic expansion). - Plato
Every hand-off of the teaching pays a toll. Signal: the Phaedrus' written word is only an aid to memory of a discussion held, and the Seventh Letter says the deepest matters are not written; Socrates' own teaching reaches us only through Plato's and others' pens (the Socratic problem 'perhaps unsolv - Police
Signal form: each hand-off from event to outcome loses part of what was sent. Of crime that happens, only part is reported (sexual violence: an estimated 23 of 1,000 cases); of calls, the dispatcher's type often misclassifies (about 20% of public-health activity not predictable from the initial call - Pollution
Pollution is the toll itself, in three forms. Material: of 6300 Mt of plastic waste only 9% was recycled and only 10% of that more than once, so a second pass keeps about 0.9% (derived); "Recycling delays, rather than avoids, final disposal"; 79% accumulated. Thermal: waste heat in cooling water war - Probability: weighing chances, in brains and in people's mathematics, and the structure it works on
Form: signal (information). Along a Markov chain X → Y → Z no processing of Y, 'deterministic or random', can increase what it carries about X: I(X;Y) ≥ I(X;Z). Each hand-off can only keep or lose information about the source, so the loss compounds along a chain. No per-hand-off efficiency is given - Programming language
Every translation layer between source and machine pays a toll: compiled 120 J, virtual-machine 576 J, interpreted 2365 J per solution on average (Pereira et al.); interpreters run 10 to 100 times slower; a collector needs five times the memory; JIT pays 'the additional overhead of compiling and lin - Proton
Fusing protons into helium hands energy on, and part of it leaves as neutrinos that do not heat the star: 'Their energy is lost'. Per hand-off usable fraction 0.980 (ppI), 0.960 (ppII), 0.717 (ppIII): the longer branches through 7Be and 8B pay more. Form: an escaping carrier (neutrinos). - Quantum entanglement
signal form, compounding along the chain: fibre loss is per km (0.16-0.2 dB/km; 8 dB/km in the Delft test), so 2 x 600 km of fibre would turn a 10 MHz source into 1e-17 pairs a second; the satellite's two downlinks lose 64-82 dB, 5.9 million pairs a second in, 1.1 a second out (~1.9e-7 usable per pa - Quantum mechanics
Signal form, measured on a chain. A heralded photon on its way to a human rod pays at each hand-off: heralding about 20%, fibre coupling about 40%, and only about 6% of post-selected events produce a light-induced signal in the eye (Tinsley 2016). In the Bell test each photon loses 8 dB per km of fi - Quantum spin chain
Signal form: a qubit sent down an unmodulated chain arrives with a fidelity that falls with chain length (better than the classical 2/3 only up to 80 spins). Built chains pay a photon toll: 1.1 photons scattered per microsecond across the array, target state reached with 54(4)% probability, detectio - Quark
A cosmic-ray collision hands its energy to quark-antiquark pairs (pions) that cascade on: 'The energy of the primary particle rapidly degrades into a large number of secondaries', and about 10-20% leaves as 'invisible energy' with neutrinos and high-energy muons. Per hand-off usable fraction for the - Radio
Thermal and signal forms, with numbers: a deployed base-station power amplifier turns only 5-20% of its AC input into radio-frequency power (80-90% of the PA's input leaves as heat that then needs air conditioning); the radiated wave spreads so its intensity falls with the inverse square of distance - Radioactive decay
Every decay hands energy on, and part of it arrives where it cannot be used. Signal/escape form: of each uranium or thorium chain's total energy the antineutrinos 'take away about 5%' and leave the planet almost untouched, so about 0.95 stays as Earth's heat (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.95, Bore - Real number (the practice of measuring the continuum, and the complete ordered field)
Signal form: every floating-point operation hands on a value rounded to the format, paying a relative error of at most u = 2^-53 in binary64; along a chain of n additions the worst-case toll grows to (n-1)u, and the order of the chain changes the result. Measurement pays the same toll at the instrum - Redox
Material and signal forms. On the way to water, O2 takes one electron at a time and some electrons go astray: in liver 2-3% of oxygen uptake ends as H2O2 (per hand-off, about 2-3% diverted), from up to 11 sites in mitochondria. Thermal form: combustion hands its free energy to heat (242 kJ/mol for h - Renewable energy
Every conversion pays a toll, and the chain compounds it. Wind: of 175,000 TW of sunlight at the top of the atmosphere about 45,000 TW becomes differential heating, about 900 TW becomes wind, about 450 TW is dissipated near the surface, about 112 TW over usable land, and at most about 60% of what a - RNA
Every copy pays a toll in errors, and the toll compounds with length: transcription misincorporates about 4 x 10^-6 per site (s52), RNA viruses 10^-6 to 10^-4 per nucleotide per infection (s54), so RNA virus genomes have 'a maximum upper size limit' beyond which errors 'render the virus useless' (s5 - Sculpture
every hand-off of a figure costs part of it: material carved away; wax lost in casting; most ancient paint lost; lacquer curls in 15 s on excavation; acid rain flakes stone to gypsum; bronze melted for scrap keeps a tiny fraction of its value - Security awareness
Every hand-off of training loses some of what is sent: of users shown embedded training, over half close it within 10 seconds and under 24% complete it; the lesson reaches only those who fail (a median 10% per exercise); what is learned fades by six months; annual training shows no measurable trace - Sedimentary rock
Two forms. Signal: each hand-off from event to bed to section loses time; only 3-30% of a section's time is recorded, burrowing destroys primary structures, and erosion removes most sediment soon after deposition (chain yield 0.03-0.3). Material: the grain hand-off from source to basin weathers away - Series (mathematics): sums of infinitely many terms, and the practice of summing, testing and using them
Every floating-point addition in a sum pays a toll: the parent's error is its children's errors, slightly perturbed, plus a new local error proportional to the partial sum, so loss compounds along the chain; a sequential sum's chain is n - 1 additions deep. Recovery by changing the route: pairwise s - Simple machine
Thermal and material forms at every hand-off: 'All real machines have friction, which causes some of the input power to be dissipated as heat'; wear and deformation too. Per hand-off efficiency: jack screw 0.15-0.20, chain or belt drive 0.95. Chain yield sourced directly: the efficiency of a compoun - Society as sociologists see it (sociology's object: social structure and social action)
Every person-to-person hand-off pays a toll: messages passed along 10-person chains become shorter and gradually inaccurate, and network clustering fades within about three degrees ('social friction'; 'Like waves spreading out from a stone dropped into a still pond'). The chain yield falls with the - Software
Every translation layer pays a toll: an interpreter runs 10 to 100 times slower than compiled code; on the same benchmark problems C used 57 J and Python 4390 J (about 1.3% as much work per joule, the walker's arithmetic); garbage collection 'may take a significant proportion of a program's total pr - Software engineering
Every hand-off pays a toll: communication paths grow as about n^2/2, so each added person spends more time finding out what everyone else is doing (Brooks's law); code shipped expediently pays interest on technical debt; complexity rises unless work is spent to reduce it (Lehman law 2). Form: coordi - Software vulnerability
Signal form: a fix handed from vendor to operator arrives partly unused, and the loss compounds along the chain: patch (plateau, 3% still vulnerable at two months) -> certificate replaced (10% of sites still vulnerable at 48 h) -> key changed (86% of those) gives an end-to-end yield of about 0.086; - Sorting algorithm
Every executed step pays heat: logically irreversible computations necessarily produce a minimum amount of heat, entropy production is positive even for reversible ones, and the mismatch-cost bound for bubble sort rises with repeated entries; measured CPU energy follows the number of operations (ove - Special relativity
relativistic charges bent in a ring hand part of their energy to radiation every pass (power with a gamma^4 factor; electrons about 10^13 times protons), and 'additional energy must be supplied to the beam'; form: radiative, a toll per turn Re-walk (11-13) adds the numbers and two more forms. Radiat - Statistical mechanics
Here the toll is derived, not only observed: switching a parameter at any finite rate costs work that on average exceeds the free-energy change, and the excess is dissipated (Jarzynski); drag turns motion into heat and the bath answers with Brownian kicks (fluctuation-dissipation); experimenters can - Statistics: the practice of collecting and reasoning from data, the intuitive statistics it grows from, and the structure (samples, distributions, estimators) it works on
Signal form. Every hand-off from data to summary to conclusion can only keep or lose information about the population ('post-processing cannot increase information'); only a sufficient statistic passes the parameter's information on whole (η = 1). Format is a toll too: the same screening evidence is - Steel
Three forms. Thermal: an EAF uses about 440 kWh to melt a tonne of scrap against a theoretical minimum of 300 kWh, so about 0.68 of the electricity does the melting (computed here from src:wp:electric-arc-furnace and src:wp:steel); electrical steel exists to cut the core's hysteresis and eddy losses - Superconductivity
inside the condensate a DC hand-off pays no resistive toll; the toll is paid outside instead, at the refrigerator: cooling 1 W at 4.2 K costs about 360 W (net efficiency 0.0028), about 1 kW at 1.8 K; Carnot alone asks 68.4 W/W at 4.2 K. Form: thermal, moved from the wire to the wall plug - Tax
Every pass from liability to treasury pays a toll: deadweight loss (trades that never happen, a loss to everyone), the tax gap (US net compliance 83.7%; UK gap 6.4%), compliance and administration costs, and VAT churn where benefits indexed to prices hand back part of the revenue. - Telephone
Signal form: every metre of line takes a toll (attenuation rising with frequency; crosstalk, hum, a signal-to-noise ratio of about 30 dB), compounding with distance until repeaters (carbon microphones, then vacuum tubes) and loading coils every mile were needed; hybrids leak, and leakage plus delay - Television
Conversion form: the iconoscope turned only about 5% of what it could into signal (EMI's analysis), and better tubes were 10-15 times more sensitive. Energy form: in streaming, data centres use only 6-12% of their electricity for computation and end devices take 72% of the energy. Signal form: analo - The archive and the historical record
Every hand-off in the record's life pays a toll. Material: each reading spends part of the paper (text-bearing pieces missing after ~55 to ~450 years of average use); thermal: cellulose degrades at an Arrhenius rate. Chain: of medieval narrative manuscripts about 9% survive (eta ~0.09 over the centu - Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
Thermal energy is where the toll lands. Every channel in is a hand-off that ends as heat: friction (o2), sound against a wall (o32), an erased bit at no less than kT ln 2, about 3e-21 J at 300 K (o38, o39). The way out to work pays again: the atmosphere's heat engine turns under 1% of incoming sunli - Thermodynamics
Here the shape is the law itself, in its home field. Every hand-off pays: a heat engine hands heat to work and must reject the rest to a cold body (Kelvin-Planck), with per-hand-off efficiencies measured in power plants from 0.16 (Larderello geothermal) to 0.40 (Heysham nuclear) against Carnot caps - Tool
Three forms. Material: every knapping hand-off leaves waste; in Muller & Clarkson's experiments waste chips are about 17-34% of the nodule (pressure blades least, prismatic blades most) and blanks 67-83% (derived); experts waste less; cutting edge per gram rose from 10.4 (bipolar) to 25.9 mm/g (pres - Trigonometry (the practice of tying angles to lengths, and the structure it works on)
Trigonometry's hand-offs pay a toll in the signal form, and the toll compounds along a chain. (1) A sine table built by recurrence: each entry is computed from the one before, rounding stays in the next, and the error grows with the length of the table (O(εN) for the plain recurrence, O(ε√N) on aver - Turing machine: the abstract machine that reads and writes one symbol at a time on an unbounded tape by a finite table of rules, the model of computation of logic and computer science
Thermal form: a built machine pays at least kT ln 2 per erased bit, and a universal machine's expected heat is infinite; logically reversible steps can in principle avoid it, which is why Shapiro's molecular design keeps a trace polymer of every step instead of erasing. - Universe
Thermal and gravitational forms: the generalised second law (total entropy, horizons included, never falls); reheating raised entropy 'by many orders of magnitude'; black holes now hold most of it; each photon pays energy to the stretch as the bath cools; GW150914 paid 3.0 of 65 solar masses to grav - Urinary system
Form: metabolic, along a chain. Reclaiming 99.5% of filtered sodium costs about 7 kJ per mol, about 1 mol/h, 7% of the body's oxygen; and each later segment pays more per sodium: 0.36, 1.4, 2.7, 4.6 calories per mEq from proximal tubule to collecting duct. The countercurrent exchangers must work to - Vector calculus (the calculus of fields: gradient, divergence, curl; the practice and the structures it works on)
Vector calculus is where the toll is written as a law, and the practice pays its own tolls. (1) Thermal, the law itself: in a flow system the local entropy production, the time change plus the divergence of the entropy flux, 'cannot be negative locally (at least over a minimum time scale) at any loc - Water pollution
Material form, along a chain of hand-offs: of 359.4 billion m3 of wastewater a year, 63% is collected and 52% treated, so the chain from produced to treated keeps 0.52 (collection 0.63, then treatment of the collected 0.83; derived); the rest is released untreated. Treatment itself pays a toll: adva - William Shakespeare
Every hand-off of the text pays a toll. Material: quartos 'read until worn out or repurposed as wrapping paper'; of perhaps 750 Folios 235 remain (yield about 0.31 over four centuries). Signal: 'bad quartos' garbled, perhaps reconstructed from memory; five compositors of differing competence, about - Wireless network
Every hand-off on the air pays a toll. Signal form: radio power weakens with distance (inverse square), walls absorb (foil insulation costs 10 dB, a tenth getting through), multipath cancels in places; random access pays in channel time (pure ALOHA keeps at most 0.186 of the channel, 'roughly one si
Partial: part of the shape (209)
- Access control
Each level handed up pays in reliability ('progressively more complex and less reliable'); each copy of a capability or a passed-on card loses accountability for who holds access. Signal form, no efficiencies given. - Accounting (the field and practice)
Every pass of the books pays a toll: Section 404 compliance cost an average 0.036% of revenue (2007; 0.043% in 2006); every reporting pass loses timeliness (6-10 months); summarising sub-accounts into one yearly account drops detail. No source gives the toll per hand-off along a chain. - Advocacy group (interest group)
Influence pays a toll at each hand-off. Form: material (rent). The US sugar quota bought 2,261 jobs for a $1.162 billion welfare loss (over $500,000 per job); capture is 'a net loss for society'; large trade organisations 'became harder to control, often leading to lackluster results' (a signal toll - African elephant (genus Loxodonta: bush and forest elephants)
Signal form: each hop of a rumble through the ground loses its higher frequencies (the ground 'acts as a low pass filter'); trophic form: about 150 kg of vegetation and 230 L of water a day pass through a hindgut fermenter, seeds passing out unused. No per-hand-off efficiency in the sources read - Air pollution
Combustion's toll: burning fuel for energy leaves CO (a product of incomplete combustion), soot and gases in the air. A second form on another chain: pollution reduces the sunlight reaching solar panels and dirties them, a loss on the sunlight-to-electricity hand-off. No per-hand-off efficiency is g - American literature
signal tolls at hand-offs: Picuris oral histories carry 'gaps' after generations of retelling; speech written down in 'mediated, vernacular form' loses what tools can tag; of over six thousand slave narratives about 150 became books (selection, not booked as loss). Dark twin noted: pirated reprints - Ancient Greek art
material and signal tolls along the hand-offs: paint fades and is cleaned off (only microscopic traces survive), bronze is melted, not one famous panel painting survives, and Roman copies of paintings are 'loose adaptations' with figures added, poses altered and colours changed; failed Egyptian blue - Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
Every join the locus makes pays in DNA: the stretch between the joined segments is deleted and 'eliminated as an excision circle', and an out-of-frame join ends the cell (a40). Light-chain editing spends segments round after round (upstream V to downstream J, then Kde deletes C and enhancers); in fi - Archaeon (Archaea)
Methylotrophic methanogenesis pays a toll in its own currency: about a quarter of the methyl groups are oxidised to CO2 to supply the reducing equivalents for turning the other three quarters into methane (yield about 0.75 methane per methyl). The ruminant's lost 6% of ingested energy is the dark tw - Architecture
Thermal and material forms: heat gained or lost through the envelope (read by infrared cameras); operational energy 40x higher in modernised dwellings; embodied carbon carried in from cement (laterite brick's footprint is 'basically due to the cement content'; less plaster lowered the house's total) - Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them
Beliefs handed along chains pay a toll: deference-based influence vanishes after at most three steps; when an argument from expertise replaces first-hand evidence deference drops significantly; most who deferred do not pass on the grounds. Form: testimony/signal. Logical arguments, recreated at each - Art history (the field)
Material form: a work handed down through time arrives altered; The Night Watch 'embodies four centuries of material history' with 'numerous chemical and mechanical alterations'; arsenic pigments have turned to mimetite, a 'greyish haze'. Attention form, with a number: in a six-painting room visitor - Art of ancient Egypt
material form: salt crystals in pores turn stone to powder; wood mostly lost to decay or burned as fuel; only works in dry places survive - Atom
A beam passing through a gas hands its photons to atoms, which re-emit them 'in a random direction', so the beam arrives with dark lines; the emission is irreversible because the field offers infinitely more directions than the atom ('the apparent irreversible decay'). The energy is kept; the beam's - Attention
Upstream of every hand-off: the brain's fixed energy budget and the cost of spikes let only a small fraction of the machinery work at once, the field's physiological reason attention exists. At each hand-off the unattended part is attenuated or inhibited: loss by design (C-736's third case), not a t - Authentication
Signal form: assurance does not survive the hand-off. A Kerberos check covers 'only the initiation of the connection'; sessions must be re-authenticated (12 h, 30 min idle); a password handed out implies authenticity 'but not guaranteed'. Effort form: a minute a day spent on phishing advice would co - Biology (the field)
Along the chain from a published finding to its replication part of the claim does not arrive: only 50 of 193 planned replications could be completed (26%), and for positive effects the replicated effect size was a median 85% smaller (92% smaller than the original). Leeuwenhoek's letters show the ol - Bird song culture
Each copy from tutor to pupil pays a toll: about 1.85% of syllables are copied with errors per learning event; where the singer pool shrinks, songs lose material (the regent honeyeater's clipped song has half the syllables; models predict simplification after bottlenecks) - Bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops)
Signal toll on the dolphin-to-fisher hand-off: of the dolphins' cues, some are misread (11.7% of all events cast too late or too far) or not answered (8.6%), so only 45.8% of events are synchronous, yet those give 86% of mullet caught. Material toll: a sponge loses its protective value and is droppe - Brand
Signal form: what the owner sends (identity) does not arrive whole as what the buyer holds (image), and the image gains attributes the owner never sent; and the stored distinctiveness leaks away through dilution and genericide. No per-hand-off efficiency is given by the sources. - Bumblebee (Bombus)
Each hand-off of a technique loses learners: 60% of caged observers learned string pulling, a third learned the two-step box; and fanning to cool the nest 'inevitably produces heat as a result of mechanical work' - Bumblebee colony
Thermal form: collective thermoregulation 'incurs significant energetic costs' at both low and high temperature; at 35 C fanning is paid and nothing comes back. Material form at the flower-to-crop hand-off: queens' porous tongues retain less nectar per sip than workers'. - Business
Every exchange pays a toll in resources used up making it: 'the gains from specialization and the division of labor are not a free lunch'. Wallis and North measure the private transaction sector at about 18% of US GNP in 1870 and 41% in 1970. Inside the firm the toll is organisational slack ('Leiben - Business continuity
Each hand-off of data to a backup and back loses what changed since the last copy (the RPO); tier 1 accepts several days to weeks of data loss, tier 6 little or none; after recovery Kigogo's micro-enterprises ran at 0.46 of their former mean sales. Form: material (data) and value. - Capuchin monkey (Cebus and Sapajus)
Every strike pays: at CVNP a third or so of high-resistance cracking events yield a kernel (33-39%), at 3.9-7.7 strikes per success; at Ubajara 12-43% success at 15-30 strikes. The leftovers are not lost but scrounged by juveniles (the dark twin: a hand-off to another user, booked as the exchange wi - Cave painting
every pass of the image down the millennia pays a toll: the oldest stencil survives as a 14 x 10 cm faded patch; at Lascaux 'many images are too faint to discern'; salts, sulphur, fungi and breath each take part; form: material; plus the thermal toll of the light (a torch burns at 633 °C to give 21. - Cell membrane
Holding the gradient against leak is paid continuously: the sodium pump can take up to three-fourths of a neuron's energy; a toxin pore spends the held protonmotive force at once. No per-hand-off efficiency in the sources read. Form: electrochemical (leak back down the gradient). - Central bank
Every hand-off of the policy rate pays a toll: about 30% of a market-rate change reaches retail bank rates within a month and 15-76% after a year (euro area); prices fall at most 0.9% after a 1 pp rate rise, after about 29 months. Chain yield falls along policy rate, money-market rate, retail rate, - Chemical element (the periodic table)
Each hand-off up the chain of elements pays out energy or loses matter to the surroundings: fusion pays out energy up to the iron peak, after which it absorbs energy; the accelerator route spends over 500 days of beam time for a handful of atoms, with a cross section that falls quickly as Z rises. E - Child development
Signal loss on a hand-off: the same Mandarin input handed over by television or audiotape arrives unusable (no learning), handed over live it is learned. A form in a system not read as thermodynamic; no efficiency number sourced. - Chinese art
material tolls along the hand-offs: lacquer under the paint flakes four minutes after excavation so the colours are lost, wood perishes so architecture is known from models, Tang wooden sculpture mostly gone, mural surfaces taken by microbes; and a signal toll in copies of copies (a 12th-century rem - City
Hand-offs inside the city pay a toll: electrical resistive losses scale with city size to the 1.11 power (faster than the city), so the bigger the grid the larger the share lost as heat; water networks lose 3% (Tokyo leakage) to over 70% (Sao Paulo, Buenos Aires non-revenue water), where part of the - Classroom
Signal form: speech handed from teacher to class loses intelligibility in the room (reverberation 'amplifies both sound and noise'; children 'much more impaired by noise'); attention handed through a lesson decays like a vigilance task. Material form: the room's air fills with occupants' CO2 and bio - Columbian Exchange
The crossing as a toll: a passage of more than a month under severe conditions did not favour the survival of the sick, so a short-lived infection like yellow fever arrived only by another carrier (the mosquito, whose eggs resist drying); what crosses is what survives the hand-off. A human toll comp - Combinatorics: the practice of counting, arranging and choosing finite structures (permutations, combinations, partitions, designs, graphs), the structures it studies, and the people and machines who work with them
Combinatorics supplies the count behind the physical toll: Boltzmann's entropy is the logarithm of the number of arrangements that look the same from outside. Within the practice, most candidates are paid away: incorrect programs are discarded and the worst half of islands reset. - Compiler
Every translation pays a toll. Information: compilation loses 'variable names, comments, and aspects of the original source-level structure', which no decompiler gets back. Energy: interpretation pays more per run than compiled code (2365 J against 120 J per solution on average). Early automatic cod - Computer ethics
Form: signal (principle to practice). Each hand-off from principle to guideline to code to practitioner loses force: AI principles 'promise to be action-guiding' but give few specific recommendations; codes are followed in letter rather than spirit; showing developers the ACM code made no significan - Computer law
Form: signal (law in the books to law in action). The 1995 data protection directive, enforced unevenly, was 'a paper tiger'; under the GDPR authorities' 'resources remain scarce'; most fines are small (about 400 to 163,000 euros) against breach losses in the hundreds of millions. Cross-border evide - Computer security
Value form: crime hands value from victims to criminals at a steep toll, the social cost far above the gain: a spam campaign's externalities are 'more than 10× the direct dollar gain'; ad fraud costs advertisers $2-5 per fraudster dollar (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.2-0.5); a minute a day of use - Consciousness
Signal form along the chain from senses to behaviour: one eye's cones carry ~1.6 gigabits/s, a single central neuron ~10 bits/s, behaviour ~10 bits/s: about 10^-8 of what is gathered reaches use. The authors read it as an unexplained gulf, not as heat; much of it is selection (loss by design, C-736) - Continent
Carbon form: silicate weathering on land takes up 94-143 MtC a year, but only 47-72 MtC a year ends up in the lithosphere as marine carbonate (about half; our reading of the two ranges), and rock organic carbon oxidation in the same uplifted rock sends about 68 MtC a year back. Material form: the cr - Contract
Every contracted hand-off pays a toll: transaction costs ('planning, deciding, changing plans, resolving disputes, and after-sales'), arranging costs that, past a limit, let free-riders win (Han et al.), and shading, a deadweight loss when a party is aggrieved (Hart). Form: a fee and a loss per exch - Corporate law
Every delegation pays a toll: monitoring expenditures, bonding expenditures and a residual loss, since 'it is generally impossible ... at zero cost' to make an agent act as the principal would. Form: value lost per hand-off of control (shareholders to board to managers); compounding along the chain - Cosmic microwave background
Hand-offs along the background's history each pay a toll, in several forms. Thermal: the plasma's sound waves 'dissipate part of their energy because of diffusion damping', and the heat (Delta rho/rho ~ 3.9 x 10^-8 for n_S = 1) goes into the photon gas as a small mu distortion (Chluba and Sunyaev). - Covalent bond
Making a backbone bond in a cell pays a toll: 'cells expend four ATP to generate a peptide bond even though one ATP would suffice'; the excess buys the sequence's information and irreversibility, and pyrophosphatases dissipate PPi as the ratchet's pawl. Per-bond efficiency against the minimum 1/4 (i - Culture
Form: signal (information) loss per hand-off. Lewis & Laland model 'information transmission and loss of traits' and show small changes in transmission fidelity decide whether culture accumulates; collective memory decays (a year's mention halves in 10-32 years); small Oceanic populations kept less - Curriculum
Signal form: each hand-off from intended to implemented to achieved curriculum loses or alters part of what was sent ('altered through a range of complex classroom interactions'); no per-hand-off efficiency sourced - Cyber threat intelligence
Signal toll at each hand-off: a SOC aims to filter half of what it collects (per-hand-off yield about 0.5); automated analysis yields false positives analysts must check; a frequent sharing source is filtered and ignored; indicators age out. Compounding along a chain is not measured. - Cybercrime and its underground economy
Every hand-off of value pays a toll, here in money and in loss to society: a spam botnet earned about $3m a year while causing about a hundred times that in cost (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.01 from victims' and defenders' losses to criminal revenue); the market takes its commission on each sale - Cyberwarfare
Form here: a secrecy toll. Each use of a cyber weapon hands part of its value to the defender: use makes the exploit visible ('and thus simultaneously make visible'), defenders patch, and the capability is gone; leaked weapons pay a further toll as effects land far from any target (WannaCry on the N - Desert ant (Cataglyphis)
Signal form: each step of path integration adds error, and errors accumulate with distance, so the home vector loses accuracy with the length of the trip; landmarks and odours pay it back near the nest - Digital identity
Signal form: an identity signal carried from day to day pays a toll; 45.52% of browser fingerprints change within a day, so about 54.48% arrive unchanged and the linker must recover the rest, holding a device for 51.8 days on average. Each linking hop also costs the subject: hours spent resolving th - Digital signatures and certificates
Two forms. Loss by design: signing the condensed digest drops distinctions on purpose, and the dropped part returns as collisions (two certificates, one MD5 digest, one valid signature). A deployment toll per hand-off: of hosts with port 443 open only 67% completed a TLS handshake, and 12.7% of host - Domestic dog (Canis familiaris)
Form: genetic (founder sampling). Each hand-off of the lineage to a new founding group passes on only part of its variation: two bottlenecks, domestication then breed formation, compound along the chain; downstream, the Pug's smell-receptor repertoire degenerates under relaxed selection. No per-hand - Drainage basin (watershed)
Every hand-off down the network pays: the network's own form is set by the energy it dissipates as water drops (Q·Δz summed over the tree, thermal form), and a signal carried down it decays ('eDNA undergoes selective decay' as it is transported), so the reading at the outlet has lost part of what wa - Drama (the literary form)
every hand-off of a play down the centuries loses texts: only a small fraction of five Greek dramatists' work survives; no plays by Livius Andronicus or Naevius; of early Roman tragedy none (material/textual form; no per-copy efficiency given) - Early childhood education
Hand-offs pay a toll: Head Start's budget may spend up to 15% on administration (hand-off efficiency at least 0.85); effects shrink from proof-of-concept trials to larger-scale programmes, a loss per hand-off from founders to scaled programmes (value and signal forms) - Education
Signal form: each transmission loses some of what is passed; transmission fidelity 'measured by the loss rate of a belief or practice' matters more than innovation for cumulative culture; what is learned is then forgotten along the forgetting curve - Endocrine system
Insulin handed from the islets to the body pays a toll at the liver: 50-80% is degraded on first pass and about 25% more on the second, so systemic insulin is one third of portal (chain yield about 0.33); half-life 4-6 min. Dark twin present: the liver is also insulin's first target and degrades it - Engineering design process
Form: signal and effort. In face-to-face brainstorming each turn loses ideas ('other participants might forget the idea they were going to contribute'), so groups yield fewer than nominal groups; each iteration pays duration and cost ('it also increases duration and cost of a project'); in gated DBT - English language: a West Germanic language of the Indo-European family, from its Old English beginnings to its varieties and its use as a global lingua franca, as linguistics and its history describe it
Each hand-off of knowledge across the English boundary pays a toll: non-native scientists spend a median 90.8% more time reading an English paper, and face 2.5-2.6 times more language rejections; knowledge not in English (35.6% of conservation documents) is often lost to the global record. - English literature
every hand-off down the copying chain loses works: about 400 Old English manuscripts survive; medieval narratives lost (unseen-species estimates); a 4,000-novel digital corpus held about a third of 1770-1830 titles and around 10% of later 19th-century ones (the published > archive > corpus 'Russian - Entrepreneurship
Every hand-off of investors' money to ventures pays a toll: limited partners pay 1.0-2.5% a year in fees plus up to 20% carried interest; of the money passed on, about 55% of VC-backed startups end at a loss. Form: financial. The loss to limited partners is partly a hand-off to the fund managers (da - Epic poetry
material and signal forms: about 2/3 of the Standard Babylonian Gilgamesh survives the chain from Nineveh to now; Beowulf's single copy damaged by fire in 1731; scribes copying the Song of Roland make small modifications or mistakes - Erosion
Material and carbon forms: attrition wears the carried load down as particles 'hit each other and the cliffs'; displaced soil carbon 'can be mineralized during transport and preserved in depositional sites with different degrees of efficiency' (part of what is handed on arrives as CO2). In the Yello - Ethics (moral philosophy: the study and the morality it studies)
Signal form along a chain from argument to act: of the students taught, agreement rose 17 points (37 to 54%), 39% pledged, and meat's share of purchases fell 7 points (30 to 23%); for professional ethicists the hand-off from reflection to voting shows no measured gain. Each hand-off delivers less th - Financial statement
Each hand-off loses usable information: of expected Russian filings only 44.1% arrive (5.5% more rebuilt from the next year); of those, about 5% do not articulate; the statements' value added covers only 40-50% of national GDP; a 10-K lags the year by 60-90 days. Form: signal and record loss, with a - Firewall (computing)
Each pass through a firewall pays a toll: time (a proxy spends much more time per packet; a web application firewall up to 4x latency) and lost good traffic (blocked ICMP makes black holes for Path MTU Discovery; the GFW's filter would block about 0.6% of normal connections; 41K innocuous domains ov - Firm (the economic unit)
Every market hand-off pays a toll: prices to discover, contracts to draw, inspections, disputes (Coase's transaction costs); the firm exists to pay less of it, and pays its own toll in diminishing returns to management. Specific assets lose productive value when redeployed. No per-hand-off efficienc - Fish
Trophic form: transfer efficiency between nodes compounds along the food chain fish sit in; thermal form: the opah's gill heat exchangers cut the heat toll; schools lower the swimming toll by 8.8-19.4% - Fish school (shoal)
Thermal/mechanical form: every swimmer pays a toll into its wake; in a school part of that toll is a hand-off, not a loss, because followers pick it up (dark twin: one holder's waste is another's thrust). Per-hand-off efficiency on the wake: goldfish followers realise about 15% of the possible savin - Formal security policy model
Assurance pays a toll at each hand-off down the chain model, specification, code, machine: TCSEC A1 shows the FTLS consistent with the model formally only 'where possible' and the implementation consistent with the FTLS only informally; verification tools needed 'manual stubs, drivers, and artful co - Fraction (parts of a whole): the ratio sense, the practice of fractions, and the rational numbers they name
Form: signal. In iterated rhythm reproduction each hand-off loses part of the seed rhythm and the copy drifts to the listener's prior; after enough hand-offs the copy is 'indistinguishable from a sample from the prior' (the seed's detail fully paid away). No per-hand-off efficiency is given. Dark tw - Fullerenes (buckyballs and nanotubes)
A UV photon of several eV is absorbed and handed back as many IR photons ('absorb ultraviolet (UV) photons and re-emit their energy in the IR'): the energy arrives downgraded at each hand-off; under strong UV each shrinking step also pays a C2 unit. No per-step efficiency in the sources read. - Grammar (the structure of a language, as linguistics describes it)
Signal form: each pass of a language to a new learner loses part of it ('the incomplete exposure of each participant to the language'; about half the meaning-signal pairs unseen), within a sentence 'once the original input is lost, there is no way for the language system to recover', and across cent - Graph theory: the practice of studying vertices joined by edges (problems, proofs, algorithms, its people and books) and the graphs it works on
Form: signal (a message handed on). Most of Milgram's letters were lost; about a quarter arrived after about six hand-offs, about 0.79 delivered per hand-off (derived). - Grassland
Two tolls. Water: to fix one CO2, C3 grasses lose ~833 water molecules and C4 grasses 277 (per-hand-off cost of carbon in water, a third for C4). Trophic and material: grass eaten by ruminants is fermented, 'Much of the embodied carbon is released as CO2 through animal respiration or CH4 through ent - Great tit (Parus major)
Thermal form: in red-cell mitochondria, part of respiration only counters proton leak and comes out as heat, not ATP; in winter great tits raise this uncoupling, so the toll is the heat they want (the dumped excess turned to use: C-736) - Hair cell
Signal form: thermal noise agitates the bundle (about 2 nm rms), roughly ten times more than threshold sound, and channels 'clatter' stochastically. Energy form: a standing 'silent' current flows into OHCs at rest, the stria spends metabolism to keep the battery (lost in anoxia), and the amplifier i - Higgs boson
Form: signal (the record). Of about 9 million bosons made in ATLAS in Run 2, only about 0.3% are experimentally accessible (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.003 from production to analysable record); the trigger keeps about 1 kHz of 40 MHz crossings. Dark-twin check: the other 99.7% still decay into - Hippocampus (memory)
signal form: at single CA1 synapses more than half the arriving impulses fail to evoke a response (probabilistic release); and the copy to cortex is not literal (Squire & Wixted), so each hand-off keeps only part. Dark-twin caution: unreliable release may be a working feature rather than waste; book - Historiography
Signal form. Transmission chains lose reliability per hand-off, and the method models it: hadith science's 'weakest-link chain evaluation' with 'corroboration through independent chains'; a work's citing decays with a 14-year half-life; Zhu Xi's digest cut 249 chapters to 59 (a chosen compression, n - Honeybee (western honey bee, Apis mellifera)
Signal form: each waggle run carries ±10-15 degrees of error, sleep loss and a missing audience add more, information 'may quickly degrade and become obsolete', and above about 30 degrees the dance no longer helps; thermal form: heating the brood is paid in flight-muscle work and honey; material for - Human anatomy
Every hand-off from body to record loses part of the body. Fixing tissue for slides collapses the fluid-filled interstitial spaces ('almost completely collapsed'), so the record lost a body-wide space until tissue was frozen before fixation; making the Visible Human slices was 'entirely destructive - Human culture
Form: signal (information) loss per hand-off. Lewis & Laland model 'information transmission and loss of traits' and show small changes in transmission fidelity decide whether culture accumulates; collective memory decays (a year's mention halves in 10-32 years); small Oceanic populations kept less - Human cultures (anthropology)
Each generation's hand-off of a culture is imperfect: small, isolated populations lose technology, transmission fidelity sets innovation rates, and languages not handed to children go to sleep (at least one a month). Signal form; no per-hand-off efficiency figure in the sources read. - Human voice
Each hand-off pays: the larynx turns aerodynamic power into acoustic power at an efficiency reported in parts per million; voice qualities lose energy in different places ('Falsetto mainly due to its voice source characteristics, Sobbing due to energy loss in the vocal tract'); the folds pay in mate - Humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae)
Tolls seen on several hand-offs: signal (song attenuated and inaudible when the singer surfaces to breathe), cultural (revolutions bring 'rapid loss of song material'; whaling erased knowledge of whole grounds), energetic (months of fasting on stored fat). The nitrogen released in the tropics is boo - Humpback whale song
Signal form: each hand-off of the song pays a toll. In the water noise masks song and shrinks its range (singers pay with louder units); in learning, a theme heard once has a 0.006 chance per learning epoch of being deleted (model), and copying errors creep in. The copying errors are also the supply - Hydrogen bond
Thermal form: an infrared excitation of the O-H stretch is passed through the hydrogen-bond network and redistributed within about 50 fs ('the efficiency of energy redistribution within the hydrogen-bonded network'): the absorbed energy ends as heat. Its dark twin also shows: a protein's hydrogen bo - Ideal gas
Form: thermal. Throttling 'is a fundamentally irreversible process', and in machines 'the throttling due to the flow resistance in supply lines, heat exchangers, regenerators, and other components of (thermal) machines is a source of losses that limits their performance'. Mixing two different gases - Igneous rock
Material form: weathering hands base cations and alkalinity from basalt to rivers, and on the way 69-90% of dissolved Ca, Mg and Si is retained (as secondary clays and carbonates), so the export step's yield is about 0.10-0.31; alkalinity export from basaltic catchments is attenuated. Thermal form: - Incident response
Every hand-off pays a toll in signal: millions of signs a day reduce to a handful of incidents, and one analyst puts the unusable share of alarms at 99% (usable out per alarm sent in about 1 in 100); at each handoff between people, shifts or teams information is lost ('Cyber incident handling errors - Inflation (economics)
Each holding and each hand-off of money under inflation pays a toll in value: taxes levied and collected later arrive as 'a small fraction' of their real value (Olivera-Tanzi); shoe-leather and menu costs and blurred relative price signals are pure losses. Measure: the welfare cost of 2% inflation, - Information security
Each layer of protection pays a toll that never fully converts into security: investment buys security 'at a decreasing rate' (GL), indirect costs 'may exceed the direct cost of the control' (NIST), users pay in effort (Herley). Anderson names the thermodynamic form for defenders: 'Paddy has thermod - Information warfare
Signal form: of what is sent, little arrives usable. 786,634 IRA posts reached a panel's timelines, but exposure concentrated in 1% of users and no measurable change in attitudes followed; trolls bore 'very small influence' on virality; jamming noise spilled onto untargeted stations; surrender leafl - Insider threat
Signal form: warnings handed from where they arise to where they are acted on lose most of themselves. Only 35% of employees reported an unambiguous adversary approach (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.35); in 27 of 28 sabotage cases technical indicators were never discovered; over-surveillance adds - Institution (social)
Value form: an institution turns contributions into incentives at efficiency rho; in the model an inefficient institution returns 1/3 of what it receives as incentive (an efficient one 3, a gain by leverage); leakage by bribery and second-order free-riding drains the pool. - Insurance
Every hand-off of the premium dollar pays a toll that never reaches a claimant as indemnity: loading for issuing, adjusting and capital ('For small losses, these latter costs may be several times the size of the expected cost of losses'); claims-overpayment leakage and fraud; about $20 billion a yea - Internet protocol suite (TCP/IP): the layered datagram protocols every host and router runs, the RFC record that specifies them, and the community that keeps them
Every hand-off down the stack pays a packaging toll: each layer adds its header, so at TCP's default send size 536 of every 576 octets are payload (0.93 per IP+TCP hand-off, derived from RFC 9293's '536 (576 - 40)'), and the link adds its own frame on top. On the path the toll is loss: in 1988 gatew - Interpersonal communication
Signal form: each hand-off loses some of what was sent; messages are interpreted, understood or misunderstood; mediated messages lose eye contact, posture and feedback; only 47% of lies are classified as deceptive. No per-hand-off efficiency is sourced - Ionic compound (salt)
Thermal form: making a salt from its elements hands the lattice energy to the surroundings as heat (-786 kJ/mol for NaCl from gaseous ions), and getting the elements back by electrolysis costs more than that ('the high energy consumption of the electrolysis'); NaCl even dissolves uphill in enthalpy - Islamic art
material and yield tolls: in a 16th-century potter's words hardly six good lustre pieces out of a hundred (η ≈ 0.06 per firing); base glass worsened as decoration grew; lichens and moisture biodeteriorate brick; leather bindings lose cohesion; early carpets and silks survive only rarely - Japanese macaque (Macaca fuscata)
Thermal form: body heat lost to winter air; huddles 'minimise heat loss and, in general, reduce energy expenditure' (Herbrich 2025) and hot spring access may reduce energy spent and heat lost (Takeshita 2018). Material form: sand on food wears teeth, and washing pays less of that toll. In wheat wash - Kinship
Signal form: genetic relatedness halves at each parent-child hand-off (Haldane's 'two brothers or eight cousins'; the close-kin threshold 0.125 at first cousins), so the share of a common line compounds downward along the chain; kinship terms and descent groups carry the tie past the point where sha - Labour market
Every hand-off of labour pays a toll in search: 'costly and time-consuming transactions are pervasive', vacancies carry a flow cost, and time spent unmatched is output lost to both sides; the market is judged 'constrained efficient' at best, given a friction 'the economy cannot avoid'. Form: a frict - Language (human language)
Signal form: some hand-offs between speakers arrive unusable (not heard or not understood) and are re-sent through repair about once every 1.4 minutes; the cost of the fix is split between listener and sender. Across generations, a language whose transmission to children fails is lost (37% endangere - Lateral line
Signal form: each transmission spends the ribbon synapse's ready vesicles, so gain falls with use and is restored only by rest; the canal pays away steady flow and slow oscillations to its filter. No per-hand-off efficiency is given in the sources read. - Learning a second language (second-language acquisition)
A signal toll at each hand-off of the computational model: input, then 'some of this intake' into long-term knowledge; not all that is heard becomes intake and not all intake becomes knowledge. No source read gives the per-step efficiency. Attrition is not booked here: the L2's lost functions are ha - Lexicon: the stock of words and word parts of a language, and as each person holds it (the mental lexicon), as linguistics and psychology describe it
Signal form: each generation's hand-off of words changes them until, after 5,000-9,000 years, most no longer carry evidence of their ancestry; the hand-off from the lexicon to its record loses most rare words (52% undocumented). Per-hand-off efficiency is not given by the sources. - Literacy
The hand-off from schooling to literacy loses much of what is sent: two years of primary school leave up to 90% of second graders unable to read a word (Malawi); about 1 in 10 Nigerian women who completed Grade 6 can read a sentence (yield about 0.1 per hand-off). - Liver
Material form: each enterohepatic pass returns about 95% of bile acids, so the hand-off efficiency is about 0.95 and the 5% lost is replaced by new synthesis (and is the body's main cholesterol exit: a loss by design, Fleishman: sequestrants work by 'shunting it into BA synthesis'). Thermal/metaboli - Lymphatic system
Material form, partly: leaky collecting lymphatics lose chyle into the surrounding tissue on the way (Prox1+/- mice), where it feeds fat growth; the 'remainder' of capillary filtrate is the dark twin, a hand-off to another holder (booked as the blood exchange), not a loss. No per-hand-off efficiency - Lyric poetry
material and copy tolls on the hand-on of lyric: Sappho's poems 'filled nine papyrus rolls' and only one survives intact; the earliest Sicilian sonnets survive only in Tuscan translation; language models recognise canonical ghazal verses far better than they complete them exactly. Form: material and - Management
Two forms. Signal: every problem handed up costs the manager a communication cost h, so the hierarchy pays per hand-off. Upkeep: management capital depreciates about 12-13% a year and practices slip when the plant manager leaves, so keeping it costs continual investment. Mismatch: CEOs mismatched to - Mantle (geology): Earth's mantle
Material form: plume outflow loses its enriched pyroxenite by melting along the way to the drilled latitude; signal form: the mantle's geoneutrino count is read only after the nearby crust's emission is modelled away. No per-hand-off efficiency sourced here. - Materials science (the field)
Material and thermal forms. Material: smelting pays a toll of metal to the air (Illimani copper enrichment highest, 16.4, in the late 20th century with large-scale production; Eichler 2017) and metal life cycles have 'rates of recycling and loss' (Graedel 2015); corrosion returns metal toward the ox - Mathematical logic: the field that studies logic within mathematics (model theory, proof theory, set theory, computability theory) and the formal systems, structures and limit results it works on
On the machines that carry logic, every logically irreversible step (erasing a bit, merging two computation paths) must pay entropy into the apparatus or its surroundings; reversible steps need not. The toll is set by a logical property of the operation. Partial: it falls on the carrier, not on deri - Mathematical proof: the practice of showing that a statement follows from axioms and earlier theorems, how it is written, checked (by people and machines) and accepted, and the derivations it works on
Every hand-off of a proof loses something: ideas 'evaporate' when translated into formal definitions, papers carry 'fewer and poorer figures' than heads, an idea passed in minutes needs a 15-20 page paper, and across generations formalism takes over from other modes; errors enter the written record - Matrix (mathematics): the rectangular array of numbers and its algebra, determinants and eigenvalues, matrices as linear maps, their history, and their use in physics, graphics and machine learning; the practice and the structure both booked
Each hand-off of entries costs: reading a large SRAM uses more power than the arithmetic (so the TPU passes data cell to cell instead); on active cycles only about half the 65,536 MACs hold useful weights in one network (efficiency about 0.5); inverting through the adjugate loses precision to roundi - Metaphysics (the branch of philosophy: its practice and the questions about reality it works on)
Signal form: theology handed to lay believers arrives partly unused ('not fully penetrated by theological differences'); thermal form: an agent learning causal relations pays in dissipated power ('error rate is minimised when the dissipated power is minimised'). No per-hand-off efficiency in the sou - Mineral
Material form, with a number: carbon handed from air to weathering minerals is held as bicarbonate, and when it precipitates as carbonate '2 mol of CO 2 are consumed and 1 mol of CO 2 is released' (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.5 for that step; src:haque-2023-weathering). And the thermal form at f - Morphology (linguistics): how a language builds its words from smaller meaningful parts (roots, affixes, compounding, inflection and derivation), how languages differ in this, how speakers learn and use it, and the field that studies it
Each hand-off of English to a new period lost part of its irregular verbs (0.82 of them kept Old to Middle English, 0.68 Middle English to today), and features hard for adult learners are passed on less. Partial: the meaning is not lost but carried by the regular rule (the dark twin: a hand-off to a - Motivation
Signal form: value handed back from a reward to the cue that predicts it arrives 'with slightly less intensity', and so on to earlier cues; homeostatic motivation is framed as counteracting the body's 'self-entropy'; and every pursuit pays an effort cost. - Native peoples of North America (Indigenous peoples of North America, across time)
Signal form, in the record that carries these peoples' deep past: the radiocarbon record pays a toll that grows with age (taphonomic loss, deep burial of older sites), so each older slice arrives thinner; and the language hand-off from generation to generation lost speakers under colonization ('decl - Neutron star magnetosphere
Each hand-off of the spin-down energy pays a share: of the Poynting flux, about 2.5% (perpendicular) to 20% (aligned) is dissipated within two light-cylinder radii, more than 50% when plasma supply is cut; twisted magnetar fields are dissipated ohmically as they untwist. Form: electromagnetic dissip - New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides)
Each pass of a tool between extractions risks losing it (dropped tools are costly to recover at height); safekeeping (84% of extractions) cuts the toll. Form: material - Nonverbal communication
Every hand-off of a nonverbal signal arrives partly unusable: facial configurations co-occur with the target emotion only weakly (r = .32, proportion .19), friends are told from strangers at 53-67% by laughter, and the bee's dance direction carries a 10-15 degree error. Form: signal. The bee case fl - Novel
material and attention tolls along the copying chain: about 9% of medieval manuscripts survive; Genji's original is lost and its 300+ copies vary in reliability; a translation whose source is lost can no longer be seen as one; circulating libraries were left with dead stock when bestsellers went out - Number and counting (the number sense, the practice of counting, and the structure it works on)
Handing quantity on loses some of it. Sense to code: number units 'exhibited approximate tuning that decreased in precision with increasing numbers' (in networks as in real neurons), so the larger the set, the more of it arrives blurred. Speaker to listener: 'Communication is not perfectly informati - Numeracy
Skill handed on from school to adulthood loses part of itself unless used: below-average users lose numeracy with age, above-average users gain. - Open-source software
Form: knowledge. Each hand-off of a project loses what only its few main authors knew (65% of 133 projects have truck factor ≤ 2); newcomers to newly open-sourced projects mostly leave; projects die when the main contributor's time or interest runs out. No per-hand-off efficiency is sourced. - Orangutan (Pongo)
Signal form: calls degrade acoustically with distance through a habitat adverse to sound, yet no loss of caller, context or population information is detected, so the toll is paid in the waveform and not in the message. Thermal form, inferred: an energy budget run lower than nearly any eutherian mam - Orca (killer whale, Orcinus orca)
Signal form: a click's level falls with one-way transmission loss, the echo returns weaker still, and rain noise shortens the detection range to about 40 m; trophic form: an apex predator eating 227 kg a day - Organization
Signal form: messages passed person to person 'tend to become shorter, gradually inaccurate' (experimental chains of ten). Market form: each transaction pays to discover prices and to negotiate and write contracts; the firm exists where its own toll is lower (Coase). Inside: gathering information 'i - Painting
the image handed to each later viewer pays a toll: the oldest stencil survives as a 14 x 10 cm faded patch; salt spalling, light- and damp-driven pigment change and microbes take part of the film at each pass; form: material/chemical - Penetration testing
Effort paid at each hand-off arrives partly unusable: tools run redundantly and merged by hand; bounty programs receive invalid or duplicate reports (only the first valid report is paid); each found bug lowers the chance of the next faster than the payoff rises; stealth costs time. Form: effort and - Perception
Signal form, measured: one eye's cones carry about 1.6 Gb/s, the optic nerve about 100 Mb/s (at least tenfold dropped in the retina), behaviour about 10 bits/s. Metabolic form: more than half the brain processes sensory input and the brain uses about a quarter of the body's metabolism. Dark twin ope - Personal finance (how a household earns, spends, saves, borrows and plans)
Every hand-off of household money pays a toll: sending $200 abroad cost 6.65% on average in Q2 2024 (per-hand-off efficiency 0.9335); payday loans $15-$320 per $100; fees and trading cost US investors about $100 billion a year; cash held 2013-2025 kept about 0.74 of its buying power. Dark-twin check - Phonetics: the study of speech sounds (how they are made, carried through the air and heard, and how they are recorded and transcribed) together with the speech sounds it studies
Every hand-off along the speech chain loses something: only part of the lungs' aerodynamic work becomes sound (vocal membranes raise vocal efficiency and cut the onset pressure in a model from 1238 to 488 Pa), the signal degrades with distance (whistles degrade less than spoken or shouted speech) an - Phonology: how languages organise the meaningless units their words are built from (phonemes in spoken languages; handshape, location and movement in signed ones), together with the field of linguistics that studies those systems
Contrast is the currency and each generation's hand-off can lose some: low-load contrasts merge (Wedel); a new language's signs vary across boundaries until conventionalised. Dark-twin check: some of what one subsystem loses is handed to another (contrast flows from vowel length to the following con - Photography
Each hand-off of light pays a toll: film turns about 2% of incident light into image, a CCD about 70%; interline masking halves fill factor; photon shot noise is permanent; demosaicing invents 2/3 of the colour values; copying a daguerreotype meant rephotographing it - Physical security
Each hand-off along the alarm chain loses usable signal to noise: 94-99 percent of activations false, about 1% of police alarm calls involving a crime; one crime solved per 1000 cameras in London (2008); watchers' detection decays across a watch. Form: signal. A chain yield across sensor, station an - Poetry
Signal form: each oral hand-off runs through 'fallible memory', and poetic devices 'crystallized to help them remember words'; writing later stored verse 'in a format relatively difficult to tamper with'. The helper pays its own toll: full metre slows retrieval by hundreds of ms. No per-hand-off eff - Political party
Hand-offs lose part of what is sent: votes for small parties under plurality arrive as few or no seats (the mechanical effect), and campaign money past a threshold buys little more; reductions in partisan animosity fade within two weeks. No per-hand-off efficiency is booked (no denominators read). - Pragmatics
Signal form: every pass of talk risks arriving unusable (not heard, not understood) about once every 1.4 minutes, and the fix costs about the trouble turn's length again (1.2:1). Per-pass yield not given; the loss is not compounding along a chain in the sources. - Prefrontal cortex
signal form: fragile representations lose to noise and distraction; alpha-2A buys signal and D1 cuts noise, and maturing inhibition raises the signal-to-noise ratio; a larger store would be 'biologically expensive' (Cowan). No efficiency number in the sources read - Prime numbers (the practice of number theory that finds, proves and uses them, and the structure of the primes it works on)
Signal form, on a chain of machine steps: each Lucas-Lehmer run passes a number through millions of squarings in floating point; round-off and hardware faults leave about 1.5% of runs wrong (50% when a serious error was reported). The toll is paid with checks every 128 iterations, Jacobi checks, and - Privacy
Each release of statistics pays a toll in accuracy (noise added) and spends part of the privacy budget, and the losses add up over releases ('the epsilons and the deltas add up'); the toll is paid on purpose (loss by design, C-736). Also a toll in attention: reading each policy costs time, about 201 - Psychology (the mind and behaviour as psychology describes them)
Signal form along memory's chain: 12 letters held, about 4 reported (η about 0.33 at the hand-off to report); savings fall from 0.582 at 20 min to 0.211 at 31 days; serial reproduction 'amplifies shared perceptual biases by compounding systematic errors' across people. Dark twin kept in view: what t - Public opinion
Every hand-off from population to published number pays a toll: response rates are down to about 10% (a yield of about 0.1 from contact to answer), the rest is replaced by weighting with varying success, and a biased return (Landon voters keener to mail postcards) cost the Literary Digest its 1936 c - Public speaking (oratory)
Form: signal and attention. Each hand-off from speaker to audience loses some: attention decrements over the first 25 minutes of a lecture and note-taking falls as it proceeds; models of communication add 'communication noise'; a fluent lecture is felt as learning that is not all there. No per-hand- - Quantum field theory
Form: signal, loss by design. The trigger hands on about 1 kHz of up to 40 MHz of collisions (kept fraction ~0.0025 at the first level, ~0.01 at the second, ~2.5 x 10^-5 end to end, derived from the sourced rates); the rest is not stored. A second form, thermal: the analogue horizon pays out 'an app - Quark–gluon plasma
Thermal form, paid once at the start: two nuclei with essentially zero entropy become up to ~30,000 particles, and 'most of this entropy is produced quickly, in the initial moments after the collision'; afterwards the fireball's evolution 'has to be close to isentropic'. A second hand-off, a jet's e - Recursion: defining or computing a thing in terms of smaller versions of itself, as computer science and mathematics describe it, with its base cases, call stack, recursive data, induction, and its sightings in language and nature
Each call pays a toll in time and stack space: in languages that favour loops the recursive version can be orders of magnitude slower, and stack use can reach the sum of all input sizes; the toll compounds with depth until overflow. Not a thermal loss here; a cost in memory and time per hand-off. - Reinsurance
Each hand-off keeps a margin: ceding commissions, fronting fees, brokers; over 2014-2016 property catastrophe reinsurers paid back 67.9% of premiums as claims (a yield of about 0.68 per hand-off in claims terms, primary non-life 73.5%); the 1746 Act was aimed at the traffic in premium differences, e - Reproductive system (human, as physiology describes it)
Hand-offs along the gamete chains lose most of what is sent: 'substantial loss of potential sperm from degeneration of spermatocytes'; of the ejaculate 'only a minority ... actually enter the cervix' and 'a few thousand' reach the tubes; of the follicle stock about 450 ovulate in a lifetime (roughly - Rhetoric (speech and argument)
Every persuasive hand-off pays a toll: 'average effects of persuasive messages are small'. A presidential ad moved candidate favorability by 0.05 points on a 5-point scale and vote choice by 0.7 points (59 experiments, 34,000 people); a YouTube inoculation video seen by millions raised technique rec - Risk management
Value form: each transfer pays a fee, and the risk may revert anyway; a chain of transfers (insurer to reinsurer) raises premiums and lowers capacity when loss expectations are not shared. Signal form: a risk squeezed into a matrix's fixed classes loses its bandwidth (the classic matrix cannot depic - Ritual
Form here: loss by design (C-736's third case). Sacrifice usually destroys the offering; costly signalling makes the cost itself the signal (a ritual must be costly enough to keep free-riders out); ordeals spend energy and pain. The loss is the rite's job, not a toll on a hand-off; no per-hand-off e - Rock cycle
Two forms. Thermal: the cycle runs on heat leaving the planet, 47 ± 2 TW out through the surface, a one-way flow it cannot get back (Davies 2010; Lourenço 2026's heat engine). Material: of the particles weathering frees, only part reaches the sea at each hand-off: river bottom load 3-14% to the sea - Roman art
material form: calcining limestone into quicklime and slaking it pays heat (hot mixing releases it, over 200 C in hot spots), and copies and veneers wear and are stripped; read with C-736's possibility (labelled Jerry's, not ruled): the excess quicklime is not only dumped as heat but stashed as lime - School
Every hand-off of a lesson pays a toll. Forms: signal (the eduba student's copy 'usually more sloppily written' than the teacher's extract, erased and rewritten); conversion (the 'correlation between the level of access to education in a country and the skills of its student population is weak'); a - Secure software development
Signal form: each hand-off from a checker to a person loses most of what is sent: at least 76% of SAST warnings in vulnerable functions are irrelevant (usable at most ~24%), and 22% of vulnerable commits pass unwarned; review loses defects too (formal inspection finds 60-65%, testing ~30%). Checking - Security audit and compliance
Assurance pays a toll at each hand-off of a delegated check (form: signal/assurance). Council to approved scanner: 0 of 6 scanners fully compliant; scanner to merchant certificate to acquirer: 86% of 1,203 sites carried a disqualifying violation, so about 14% of claims survive an independent re-chec - Security information and event management (SIEM)
Signal form: from events to alerts to alarms to true attacks the yield falls (0.01% of alerts tied to true attacks at one SOC), and agentless collection pays extra network transfer for the same data. Most of the drop is filtering by design (benign triggers, failed attempts, unneeded fields), the dar - Security operations center (SOC)
Signal form: each hand-off of alerts to people pays a toll in attention. Of the alerts handed to analysts, about 0.01% carry a true attack (per-hand-off efficiency about 0.0001); at Target in 2013 a true alarm passed from the Bangalore SOC to the Minneapolis SOC and was ignored there. Part of the "l - Security policy and governance
Signal form: each hand-off down the policy chain loses part of what is sent. Distribution gives 'no guarantee that individuals who received the policy will actually read it'; a long document goes unread; a violation 'may be unintentional', from lack of knowledge. No per-hand-off efficiency is given - Semantics: meaning in language (the meanings of words and sentences, sense and reference, how meanings combine, how they are held in minds and brains and shared in a community) and the field of linguistics and philosophy that studies it
Compressing ideas into words loses accuracy: efficient colour-naming systems leave large regions of colour space inconsistently named, with soft boundaries (a signal toll, kept small by efficiency). - Separation of powers
Each hand-off between branches drops some of what is passed: Sartori's "messy and wasteful confusion of power"; gridlock when veto players are not aligned; of 2,599 vetoed US bills only 112 returned as law by override. No source gives a per-hand-off efficiency for the whole chain, so the measure is - Set theory: the study of sets (collections taken as single objects), membership, Cantor's infinities and the axioms, and the practice of the people and machines who work with them
Hand-offs that drop information: forming a set forgets order and repetition ({a,a,b} = {a,b}); the visual system's ensemble keeps a set's mean and drops the individuals. The lost part is named (order, multiplicity, individual detail); no efficiency number is given and the loss is a chosen abstractio - Sign language (the natural signed languages)
Signal form: a visual language handed to touch arrives partly unusable: ASL handshapes for seven and eight 'are practically identical, even visually' and 'even harder to distinguish when trying to feel these productions'; protactile rebuilt the forms. Transmission form: the parent-to-child hand-off - Signals intelligence
Each hand-off loses most of what was handed on: of some hundreds of thousands of Venona texts, under 3,000 were decrypted; Tempora keeps content three days; analysts read about half the reports (about a fifth with triage); traffic analysis keeps only lower-quality information. Form: signal and atten - Silk Road
Relay trade pays a toll at each hand-off: goods change hands many times, nomad powers take tariffs, bandits take goods; sea carriage cost about a fifth of overland transport, so the overland chain paid more per unit carried. Form: value (fees, tariffs, losses) rather than heat. No per-hand-off effic - Small business
A chain over time, not a hand-off: of new establishments, each year only some of the survivors survive again (79.6, 85.6, 89.0, 89.6, 91.4% in years 1-5) and the yield multiplies to 49.6% at five years; of the jobs startups create, about 40% are gone by exit within five years. Tolls on money hand-of - Social change
Every hand-off of a social order pays a toll. Form here: a transition cost in welfare and coordination (miscoordination while some have switched and others not: 'beneficial norm change is often hindered by a desire to avoid the costs associated with transitioning'), destruction paid for creation ('c - Social class
Each hand-off of advantage between generations pays a toll: origin and destination are associated but not identical, and lifestyle adjustment removes about half the SEP gap in inflammation; hunter-gatherer transmission is low to moderate. Form: social (regression toward the mean in class transmissio - Social engineering
Signal form, as a conversion funnel: of 117,864 simulated phishes sent, 5.67% were clicked, and 73.13% of clicks went on to a dangerous action (per-hand-off yields 0.0567 and 0.7313; chain yield about 0.041). Read as a toll only partly: the unclicked lures are a cost to the attacker, not something p - Social network
Signal form: hand-offs along a chain lose what they carry. Milgram's letters: 232 of 296 never arrived (end-to-end yield 64/296 = 0.22 for chains of about six); happiness's influence falls with each degree and is gone beyond three, and decays with time and distance. Per-hand-off efficiency is not gi - Social norm
A signal toll on the hand-off of conduct: when peers' compliance and violations are both passed on by observation, only the violations arrive usable ('participants only conform to observed norm violations of their peers while ignoring norm compliance'), so compliance erodes with each pass; known soc - Social stratification
Form: signal (advantage handed down). Each generation hands on only part of a household's wealth position: (1−β) is lost to regression to the mean (β 0.37 material, 0.12 embodied, 0.19 relational), and over a chain the correlation falls (0.47 parent-child, 0.18 grandparent, 0.06 great-grandparent in - Social structure
Signal form: influence passed tie to tie loses strength at each hop and with time and distance; happiness reaches three degrees, cooperative similarity two, neural similarity falls with network distance; cascades 'decay well before reaching the whole network'. Per-hop values are in the papers' figur - Socialization
Signal form: each hand-off loses part of the message. Two-thirds of newspaper readers do not know their paper's position and most media stories are quickly forgotten; family influence on political orientation is reduced over time; adoptive siblings' correlations hover near zero - Solution (chemistry)
Form: material/chemical. A concentration difference is usable (it can raise an osmotic pressure across a membrane), but mixing without a membrane spends it as entropy of mixing, 'the diffusive expansion of each material into a final volume not initially accessible to it', and the difference cannot b - Speech (human spoken language)
Signal form: each pass of the speech chain loses something. Feedback is noisy, delayed and sometimes masked; noise masks speech for the listener and the speaker pays in vocal effort to restore the signal-to-noise ratio; listeners fill in what was lost (phonemic restoration). No per-hand-off efficien - Sperm whale (cachalot, Physeter macrocephalus)
Metabolic toll: daily energy use 412-620 MJ, 1.6-2.4 times a land mammal's basal rate; Southern Ocean whales respire 2 × 10^5 t C a year. The dark twin is here too: the iron in faeces is not lost but handed to phytoplankton, which export 4 × 10^5 t C - Standard Model of particle physics
Each collider hand-off drops most of what it is offered: the trigger keeps about 1 kHz of events of interest from up to 40 MHz of collisions (per-hand-off efficiency about 2.5e-5). The drop is the trigger's job, the third case booked under C-736 (loss by design), not a failure; the Higgs needed 30 t - Startup company
Two tolls on the hand-offs: money passing from limited partners through a fund to startups pays an annual 1.0-2.5% fee and up to 20% of profits, and about 55% of VC-backed startups end at a loss; jobs created by a startup cohort lose about 40% (or 47%) to exits within five years, a per-hand-off job - Stress (biology)
Form: metabolic and structural. Each stress response spends energy and resources ('consuming energy and natural resources'); with every repetition part of the spending is not recovered and accumulates as wear and tear (allostatic load, 'cumulative effects of stressors on the body'), with the body's - Supply and demand
A tax hand-off pays a toll: part of the gains from trade goes to nobody, the deadweight-welfare-loss triangle Dupuit defined in 1844; the price rises by less than the tax unless demand is vertical, so the tax splits and some trades vanish. No per-hand-off efficiency number read here (market.json boo - Supply chain security
Signal form: a fix handed down a dependency chain arrives at fewer than half the dependents (more than half still affected after the fix); material form: theft and shrinkage anywhere along the logistics chain. Per-hand-off yield booked below 0.5 for the fix. - Surveillance
Each hand-off in the watching chain pays a toll in usable signal: a $15 million camera system worked 32% of the time; overt watching overstates compliance by 23 points (78% vs 55%); acontextual data is not necessarily more valid; gender classifiers err up to 34.7% for darker-skinned women. Form: sig - Sustainability
Two forms seen. Material: land use takes more than it harvests, since HANPP counts 'both the harvesting and the elimination or alteration (mostly reduction) of potential natural NPP' (production that never happens, usable by no one). Value: as global GDP more than doubled (2000-2022), deprivation fe - Teacher
Two forms: material wear on the instrument of every hand-off (teachers' voice disorders rise with dose of teaching, HR 2.56 school vs 1.44 college) and a leaky workforce chain (primary attrition 9.06% a year, about 0.91 retained per year, and many leave after the first post); also the fade-out of te - Thalamus
Signal form: at each relay the content can be passed with fidelity (tonic) or not (burst: 'does not reflect the activity of its inputs with any fidelity'); in sleep the specific inputs are blocked. Material form in disease: when energy fails (infant hypoxia-ischaemia) inhibition collapses first and - Theatre
Form: material (the record across time). Of more than a thousand tragedies performed in 5th-century Athens, 32 survive: the hand-off from performance to text to later readers kept under 3.2% (Greek masks too, 'made of organic materials and not considered permanent objects'). Second form, signal: at - Truth
Signal form: each hand-off of a claim delivers part of it false. In science the share of claimed findings that are true falls with small studies, small effects and bias (Ioannidis); in US courts perjury or false accusation is a factor in 64.7% of exonerations; corrections themselves decay over time. - Unemployment
At the hand-off between jobs part of a worker's value arrives unusable: displaced men lose 1.4-2.8 years of earnings in present value; skills rust in long spells; the economy's output lost (Okun). Form: human and match capital lost per hand-off, larger when the hand-off happens in a slump. - Vagus nerve
Signal form, made by people: implanted VNS spends its stimulus on every fibre around the electrode, so effect leaks to non-targeted organs (cough, throat pain; a heart-failure device stopped by laryngeal side effects). No per-hand-off efficiency number in the sources read. - Vector space: sets whose elements can be added and scaled, as mathematics describes it, with bases and dimension, linear maps, inner products, and their use as the state spaces of physics and data
Each projection to fewer dimensions (PCA, random projection) hands on the data with some distance or variance lost; PCA is built to minimise the loss, Johnson-Lindenstrauss bounds it at (1 +/- eps). - Vervet monkey (Chlorocebus pygerythrus)
Signal form: a call hands on only part of what the caller saw; chutters and rraups from fights and from predators overlap, so classification drops from 98.7% to 71.4% when aggression calls are added, and listeners must recover the rest from context - Voting
Votes handed on lose part of what was sent: wasted votes elect no one; under ranked choice, ballot exhaustion makes 52.5% of 182 US RCV elections end without a majority of all ballots. Form: signal (votes dropped at the count). No per-hand-off efficiency booked (no totals read). - Vulnerability management
Each hand-off loses part of the effort: a CVSS 7+ rule spends 2,773 fixes to cover 173 exploited flaws (efficiency 6.2%); along the chain from disclosure to installed patch, about 65% of operators take no action (Rescorla) and Heartbleed patching plateaued at two weeks with 3% left. Dark twin kept i - Wave
Three forms in one kind. (1) Passive waves pay a thermal toll at every step: lossy media 'remove energy from a wave, usually converting it into heat', and diffusion 'dampens signal'. (2) Active waves repay the toll locally: chemical and excitable waves 'maintain their amplitude' because each neighbo - Weathering
Weathering's alkalinity pays a toll at each hand-off from soil to groundwater to river: secondary clays and carbonates take up 30-67% of Ca, 45-81% of Mg and 90-95% of Si in Icelandic catchments (export efficiency about 0.33-0.70 for Ca), and marine calcification hands one of the two CO2 back. Form: - Wetland
Form: material (decay). Of the carbon hydrophytes fix, only 'a varying fraction' is buried in anoxic sediment; the rest is respired back as CO2 or CH4. Anoxia lowers the toll (decay slows, peat builds at ~1 mm/yr); drainage raises it (drained peat becomes a source). No per-step efficiency is given. - Word: the unit of a language's lexicon (spoken, signed or written) as linguists describe it, and as it is held, learned and retrieved in each speaker's mental lexicon
Every hand-off of a new word pays a toll: most lexical innovations soon fall into disuse; in retrieval, transmission between meaning and sound can momentarily fail (the tip-of-the-tongue state). Form: signal and attention; no per-hand-off efficiency given. - Wound healing
Each repair pays a toll in material form: the rebuilt dermis confers only up to 80% of the old strength (η ≤ 0.8 in tensile strength), with follicles, sweat glands and nerves not rebuilt; in chronic wounds proteases degrade the growth factors sent (a signal toll). A wound re-injured repays the toll - Writing system (a script plus the rules binding it to a language)
Each hand-off of the code loses something: copying sheds graphic detail ('lose unnecessary graphic features ... as they are repeatedly remembered, reproduced, and transmitted'); an asynchronous message cannot be repaired ('limits possibilities for repair'); spellings stranded by sound change make th
Surface: a resemblance (16)
- Acid-base reaction
Every acid dissociation pays an entropy toll: 'the entropy contribution is always unfavourable (ΔS⊖ < 0) in these reactions' because the new ions order the water around them; that toll is part of what makes weak acids weak (ΔG⊖ ≈ 5.708 pKa kJ/mol). Form: thermodynamic (ordering of the solvent), not - Age of Enlightenment (the 17th-18th-century intellectual movement: its ideas, its networks of salons, academies, letters and print, and its effects on states and revolutions)
Each hand-off of knowledge paid a toll: Mokyr's access costs (the marginal cost of getting knowledge someone else has); intercepted letters; the Quarto still cost 26 weeks' wages; many more read the Encyclopedie than owned it. No per-hand-off efficiency is sourced. - Basal ganglia
Holding every programme under tonic inhibition costs constant firing (10-70 Hz); Redgrave reads connection count as metabolic cost ('neural activity incurs a high metabolic debt'), the reason to prefer a central switch. No efficiency number per hand-off is given. - Biodiversity
Trophic hand-offs among the kinds biodiversity holds pass on 5.92% of energy on average (1.52% on land); the toll is steeper for plant-eaters, endotherms and higher trophic levels, so which kinds are present sets how much each pass pays. - Critical infrastructure
Signal form: the operators' view degraded as it passed from field to screen, refresh stretching from 1-3 s to 59 s, with the state estimator ineffective from inaccurate input; per hand-off the view arrived late. Service form: disruption costs firms and households in LMICs at least $390 billion a yea - Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies)
Material form, as the field reads it in what it studies: lead added to petrol leaves as aerosols into air and soil instead of staying in use; signal form inside the field: research effort spent on well-studied chemicals 'detracts from the societal needs' for the unstudied ones. No efficiency numbers - Eukaryote
chains of hand-offs: phagotrophs add steps to the food chain and digest prey to monomers; eukaryotic biomass-production efficiency falls with cell volume - Free will
Signal form: a message lowers belief in free will but no downstream behaviour change arrives across 145 experiments; part of what is handed on does not arrive usable at the next holder. Also W reports rest on recall of a clock position, a lossy relay. - Intonation
Declination: as the exhalation runs down, intensity drops and pitch drifts lower, a running down of the breath's energy across the phrase. A loss over time within one hand-off rather than a toll per hand-off; book as surface. - Japanese tit (Parus minor)
Signal form: a message handed on loses part of itself at each hand-off. The full ABC-D compound reaches conspecifics; coal tits take only the snake part; other species within 10 m did not differ by call type in which species came, and 'chicka' drew them only to a distance - Matter
Two dark-twin sightings, booked as what they are. (1) Hand-off, not loss: in fusion and annihilation the baryon count passes unchanged while mass is paid out ('the total amount of mass is not conserved'), but that mass goes to energy as radiation and heat, a hand-off to another user (energy's ledger - Mind–body problem (how mental states relate to physical states)
Form: signal. Each hand-off from experience to evidence loses part of it: experience to report (sleepwalkers act, dreamers report only on waking), report to survey count (a five-point scale), and the observable brain as classical bits from quantum states, bound by Holevo's theorem (Georgiev). No per - Play
Play is paid for: more energy spent and more injury and predation risk than resting; fur seal pups at play are killed more by sea lions. No per-hand-off efficiency is sourced; it reads more as a cost than a toll on a chain. - Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies)
Signal form: in the research record, low power (median about 10%) and publication bias mean each published estimate arrives inflated (median exaggeration 1.9); the hand-off from test to literature pays in distortion, not loss of size. Booked as a signal toll. - Prairie dog (Cynomys)
Trophic: grassland energy passes through prairie dogs to ferrets, raptors, badgers and coyotes; thermal: winter torpor costs 20% of body weight. No per-hand-off efficiency in the sources read; the burrow-air and alarm-call hand-offs show no named loss - Syntax: how a language combines words into phrases and sentences (constituency and dependency, word order, agreement, recursion), how speakers build and parse it, how children learn it, how it differs across languages, and the field that studies it
Each hand-off of a sentence from speaker to hearer risks ambiguity; grammars are tuned so the loss stays low at a cost in complexity. Signal form; no efficiency number in the sources read.