← all systems · see it in The System
Gross domestic product
Gross domestic product (GDP) is a monetary measure of the market value of all final goods and services produced in a country in a period (usually a quarter or a year). It is compiled by a national statistical agency under the international System of National Accounts in three ways that should agree: production (the sum of value added by every industry), income (compensation of employees, operating surplus, mixed income, taxes less subsidies) and expenditure (consumption + investment + government spending + exports - imports). Nominal GDP is converted to real GDP with the GDP deflator, divided by population for GDP per person, and adjusted by purchasing power parity for comparisons between countries. Its modern form comes from the national income estimates of the 1930s (Kuznets's 1934 report to the US Senate) and the 1941 British accounts; after 1944 it became the main measure of an economy. It measures production, not welfare: it leaves out unpaid household work, non-market and many informal activities, zero-price goods, the distribution of income and the depletion of natural capital. Walked as the measure and as the economy it reads, both booked.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | contested (C-2827): balances by Petty 1664; first official US national income estimate 1934 (for 1929-32); GDP as the main tool after 1944; GDP replaces GNP as the US headline in 1991 |
| born precision | n/a |
| boundary | Inside: the rules, data, compilation and published figure of the money value of final production by resident units in a period (the production, income and expenditure accounts, the deflator, per-person and PPP versions) and the readings made of it. Outside: the economy it reads (walked as sys:economy), unpaid household production, most non-market and some informal activity, zero-price goods, the stock of natural and other capital, and income distribution, which the accounts leave out by their own boundary. |
| nested level | Built from the value added of resident producers and from the components of final spending, compiled by a statistical agency under the SNA; the headline aggregate of the national accounts; a kind of measurement; runs on the economy's activity and on the agencies and people who compile and use it. |
| scale | social |
Measures (24) published science
| GDP release frequency | quarterly in most countries (usually also yearly) per quarter |
| first-release lag | the advance release in the first month after the quarter ends about one month |
| SNA revision interval | editions 1953, 1960, 1964, 1968, 1993, 2008, 2025 4-25 years between editions |
| US GDP per person growth rate, 1870-2014 | around 2 (1.76 in 1870-1929, 2.23 in 1929-2007) percent per year |
| US GDP per person, 1870 and 2014 | about 3,000 (1870) to more than 50,000 (2014); nearly 17-fold US dollars (as given in the source) |
| national income produced, fall 1929-1932 (US) | 53 (national income paid out: 40) percent |
| SNA adoption | more than 200 countries, territories and areas |
| margin of error by data grade (Penn World Table) | A 10, B 20, C 30, D 40 percent |
| change in average growth between two data versions (Penn World Table 6.1 to 6.2) | standard deviation 1.1 against a mean growth of 1.56 percent per year (1970-1999 averages) |
| overstatement of yearly GDP growth by autocracies | about 35 percent |
| Okun coefficient (US) | -0.4 to -0.5 (R2 about 0.8) points of unemployment per 1% of output |
| household production added to nominal GDP (US) | 39 (1965), 26 (2010) percent of GDP |
| nominal GDP growth with and without home production, 1965-2010 (US) | 6.9 without, 6.7 with percent per year |
| unpaid labour, Australia | over 50 percent of GDP (conservative estimates) |
| informal activity added to GDP | Italy +18% (since 1987); several European countries +3 to 7% (2014) percent of GDP |
| information sector share of nominal GDP (US) | about 4 to 5, unchanged 1981-2016 percent |
| median compensation to give up Facebook for a month (US, 2016) | 48.49 (37.76 in 2017) US dollars |
| median compensation to give up all search engines for a year (US, 2017) | 17,530 US dollars |
| primary power per dollar of accumulated world production | 9.7 +/- 0.3 milliwatts per inflation-adjusted 1990 US dollar |
| thermodynamic efficiency gains' share of GDP increase (UK) | 25 percent of observed GDP increase (Sakai et al. 2019, as summarised in the review) |
| needed fall in affluent countries' GDP (estimates) | 40 to 90 percent |
| SDG 8 growth aim | about 3 percent per year, global GDP |
| share of US citizens naming GDP the best indicator (2020 poll) | around 25 percent |
| nowcast panel | about 200 monthly series (US), in 36 releases a month |
Open contentions (4) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1063 Can economies grow while using fewer resources?
booked: The map records relative decoupling from 1945 to 2002 (materials per dollar fell from 2.5 to 1.5 kg) that then stalled, and keeps both the hope and the doubt about absolute cuts.
the other reading: green growth: sufficient decoupling possible; degrowth or post-growth: reductions given priority over GDP growth - C-2827 Where did national income accounting begin?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: GDP begins with Petty's political arithmetic (1664); GDP begins with the 1934 national income report; GDP as distinct from GNP is a 1990s measure (US 1991, China 1993) - C-2828 Does GDP measure welfare?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: GDP per person is a fair indicator of living standards (measured frequently, widely, consistently); GDP is a poor guide to welfare (Kuznets 1934, Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi, Easterlin); the happiness-income paradox does not hold (critics as reported) - C-2843 Is Okun's law stable?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: stable (Ball et al. 2013); unstable or breaking down (jobless recoveries; as reported)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (23) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Gross domestic product. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (structural)
The accounts' own boundary names the members left out and says how big they are: Kuznets in 1934 left out housewives' and family services, 'large enough to affect materially any estimate', and earnings from illegal pursuits; BEA's 2012 satellite account filled the first slot at 39% (1965) and 26% (2 - same role, different builds (structural)
One job, telling how big an economy is and how well it is doing, is done by different builds: market-value accounts (GDP), China's earlier Marxist-inspired accounts, night lights from orbit (a physical proxy), consumer-surplus experiments (GDP-B), composite indexes (HDI, GPI, Better Life, Gross Nati - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
One cross-border sale is entered with opposite signs: added as an export in the seller's GDP, subtracted as an import in the buyer's expenditure sum; and one sale of an existing building is a positive investment by the buyer and a negative one by the seller, netting to zero. One transaction, the sig - same toolkit, independent builds (structural)
In 1941, Meade and Stone's British White Paper, Gruenbaum's accounts for Palestine and Van Cleeff's Dutch national bookkeeping each set national income in an accounting framework: 'the idea was in the air and made its appearance in several guises at the same time' (Stone). Colin Clark and Kuznets ha - templating (structural)
One accounting module, the SNA, is swapped into more than 200 countries, territories and areas and still works, with local adaptations; China dropped its Marxist-inspired material accounting and took GDP in 1993. The figure's own floors follow measurement's template (measurand, instrument, indicatio - The carry (structural)
The wait and the lookahead. The wait: a quarter's figure cannot settle until its data arrive; the advance release comes in the first month after the quarter, and revisions keep arriving for years (the PWT revision). The lookahead: central banks nowcast the current quarter from about 200 monthly seri - The Payment to Entropy (structural)
Three forms. Material: depreciation (capital consumption) is the wear toll the stock pays each period; GDP is gross of it, and the economy can run down assets while recording high growth. Thermal: output is tightly coupled to useful exergy; primary energy decouples only as far as conversion to usefu - trade one property for another (structural)
Timeliness is bought with accuracy: early releases and soft surveys come fast and are revised; hard data come late and weigh more 'when we control for timeliness'. And GDP per person is used because it is measured 'frequently, widely, and consistently', paid for with what it does not cover (welfare, - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
GDP's channels take in only what has a market price inside the production boundary: zero-price digital goods (search valued at a median $17,530 a year), household production (26-39% of US GDP), barter, volunteer work, pollution and depleted natural capital fall outside. Night lights carve a differen - who opens the door (structural)
Every crossing into the account is a port set up ahead of time by the receiver: the statistical agency's surveys and the state's own records (private organisations have no access), and above all the market price, the door a transaction must pass to be counted. Goods with no price find no door; house - borrowed-then-held (partial)
The first official US estimate was made by the NBER, a private research bureau, under Kuznets (1931-34) for the Department of Commerce; the Department under Milton Gilbert then embedded the work in its own institutions. Borrowed from a private body, then held by the state; the hand-off is inside one - conservation law plus closure (partial)
Output = income = expenditure is an accounting identity (double-entry; Y = C + I + G + X - M) that fixes the total but predicts nothing; macroeconomics, developed 'in tandem', supplies the closure (aggregate demand, multipliers: 'deficit spending increases GDP in case of positive fiscal multipliers' - outside-to-inside (partial)
Things first left outside the account are brought in: informal activity (Italy 1987), prostitution and narcotics (Europe 2014), household production in a satellite account (2012). The outside phase comes first in each case (Kuznets 1934's exclusions). - red-queen (partial)
The measure keeps changing its conventions 'in an attempt to keep up with industrial advances', and still the information sector's share of GDP stood at 4-5% in 2016 as 35 years before while free digital goods spread: both sides move, the gap stays. A second race: autocracies' overstatement against - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (partial)
For the world as a whole GDP and GNI are the same; the cut is the national border with foreign ownership: GDP keeps location, GNI ownership (Japan's GNI above its GDP in 2020, Armenia's below in 2023). The US chose location in 1991. - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Each country's figure is read against a reference set by the whole: a base year or chain for volumes, a common basket for PPP; local readings depend on the basket chosen and different baskets give different values, so they need not close into one frame. - causal ceiling (surface)
No one holds the whole: the number is a patchwork no private body can assemble, since only the state holds some of the data. A limit set by access, which the catalog's dark twin warns is practical, not structural. - coordination-before-mapping (surface)
Economies coordinated production and exchange for millennia before any national map of them; Petty (1664) and King (1688) drew the first balances, and the modern measure dates from 1934. The coordination belongs to the economy; GDP is the later map. - lightning (surface)
The Great Depression's collapse (US national income produced down 53% 1929-32) made the measure: Senate Resolution 220 asked for it and Kuznets's 1934 report answered. The discharge is the economy's; for GDP it is the birth event, so surface here. - nested ladder (surface)
GDP at factor cost, at producer prices, at market prices; gross to net (less depreciation); domestic to national (plus net income from abroad): a ladder of adjustments, each from the last. Ordered by adjustment, not by implication, so surface. - partner-becomes-part (surface)
GDP, a rival reading of progress, became a part of the HDI (its standard-of-living term is a log of GDP at PPP), and GDP minus environmental and social costs is the GPI. Parts borrowed by a new index, without a gain/gain loop shown. - runaway from an unstable balance (surface)
Growth imperatives: growth is a necessity for many actors, with 'social and economic instability in the absence of it'. A balance point at zero growth is implied, not shown with its runaway. - seed (surface)
Seed check, maybe: the 1930s measure came 'in tandem' with macroeconomics and spread to more than 200 countries, but no source read shows it opening new combinatorics rather than one widely copied module (templating).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (15) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Unemployment via sys:labour-market · Gross domestic product even
- Inflation (economics) via sys:market · Gross domestic product mixed
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Gross domestic product gain
- Government via sys:human-society · Gross domestic product gain
- Money via sys:written-record · Gross domestic product gain
- Household via sys:human-society · Gross domestic product even
- Market and trade via sys:human-society · Gross domestic product gain
- World trade web via sys:world-trade-web · Gross domestic product mixed
- Firm (the economic unit) via sys:market · Gross domestic product gain
- Energy via sys:stress-energy · Gross domestic product gain
- Central bank via sys:economy · Gross domestic product gain
- Economy via sys:economy · Gross domestic product gain
- Earth observation satellite via sys:electromagnetic-field · Gross domestic product gain
- Economics (the field) via sys:mental-representation · Gross domestic product gain
- Natural environment via sys:earth · Gross domestic product even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Government
- Household
- World trade web
- Gross value added
- Investment (I)
- System of National Accounts
- Statistical agency
- Which number steers: GDP against GNP/GNI and the 'beyond GDP' indicators
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (17)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Multi-Scale Data Fusion / Triangulation
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Surprise / Change-Point Detection
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (13)
- Economics (the field)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Government
- Household
- Firm (the economic unit)
- National accounts and GDP
- Central bank
- Economy
- Inflation (economics)
- Gross value added
- System of National Accounts
- Statistical agency
- Recession
Kinds (7)
- Nominal GDP
- Real GDP
- GDP per capita
- GDP at purchasing power parity
- Gross domestic income (GDP by the income approach)
- GDP-B
- Measurement (the practice of comparing a quantity with a unit, and the units and standards it uses)
Notes published science
- In 1688-95 Gregory King drew up national accounts for England, France and Holland, projected them forward and concluded the war could not be continued past 1698; the war ended in 1697. (src:stone-1984-nobel-lecture)
- Kuznets's very first report to the US Senate in 1934 already warned that 'the welfare of a nation can, therefore, scarcely be inferred' from the number he had just built, and left housewives' work out while noting it was big enough to change the total; when the US Bureau of Economic Analysis put it back in 2012, it added 39% to 1965 GDP. (src:kuznets-1934-national-income, src:bridgman-2012-household-production)
- Lights at night seen from space are a second ruler for GDP: authoritarian governments report about 35% more yearly growth than their lights show, and for countries with the worst statistics the best estimate of growth is half official accounts, half satellite lights. (src:martinez-2022-dictators-gdp, src:henderson-storeygard-weil-2009-lights)
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
GDP as national accountants describe it: an economy's transactions to one number acted on (reader's view)
- L1: The economy's activity in a territory and period: resident producers making final goods and services, households, firms, government and the rest of the world buying them, incomes paid
- L2: Source data: a patchwork of business surveys and company records, income records, household spending, government accounts, trade and price data, gathered by a national statistical agency
- L3: Classification and valuation: industries and sectors, final against intermediate use, market prices, the residency boundary (location, not ownership), the production boundary (market activity in, household services out)
- L4: The three approaches: production (sum of gross value added), income (compensation of employees + operating surplus + mixed income + taxes less subsidies), expenditure (C + I + G + X - M)
- L5: The account: one figure reconciled from the three, held in double-entry national accounts; nominal and real (deflator, chained dollars), per person, at PPP; quarterly, then revised
- L6: Meaning: the number read as an economy's size and growth, its cycle (recession), its standard of living and its rank among countries; and the readings warned against (welfare, distribution, what is not priced)
- L7: Use: monetary and fiscal policy, growth targets, ratios and rules built on it, comparisons that steer aid and standing; acted back on the economy
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The account: one figure reconciled from the three approaches in double-entry national accounts; nominal and real, per person, at PPP; first released a month after the quarter, then revised
- L6: Meaning: size and growth, recession, standard of living, rank; and the warnings: not welfare, not distribution, not what is unpriced
- L7: Use: policy decided on current and forecast GDP, growth targets, ratios and rules, comparisons acted on
way in: Concepts and rules (what counts)
- L1: Ideas of what to count: early efforts by Colin Clark and Simon Kuznets; Kuznets's choices of what to leave out
- L2: Written into an international standard (SNA 1953; revisions 1960, 1964, 1968, 1993, 2008, 2025)
- L3: Adopted nationally, with local adaptations
- L4: Rules and procedures the compilers apply
way in: Cross-border trade (net exports, X - M)
- L1: Exports: goods and services produced for other nations
- L2: Imports subtracted
- L3: The residency boundary: location, not ownership
- L4: Net exports NX
way in: Government accounts (G, taxes and subsidies)
- L1: Government spending on final goods and services
- L2: Transfers (social security, unemployment benefits) left out
- L3: Data only the state holds, so a government agency compiles
- L4: G in the expenditure sum; taxes less subsidies take factor cost to market prices
way in: Household spending (consumption, C)
- L1: Households buying final goods and services: food, rent, fuel, medical care
- L2: Purchases counted as the measure of what was produced
- L3: Final uses kept, intermediate purchases dropped
- L4: C in the expenditure sum, at purchasers' prices
way in: Incomes paid (income approach)
- L1: Incomes firms pay households for the factors they hire
- L2: Incomes sorted into categories (US: wages and supplements, corporate profits, interest, proprietors' and housing income, business transfers)
- L3: Summed to net domestic income at factor cost
- L4: Gross domestic income: add taxes less subsidies on production and imports and depreciation
way in: New capital (investment, I)
- L1: New mines, software, machinery, new houses
- L2: Purchases of financial claims left out (saving, not investment)
- L3: Sales of existing assets net to zero
- L4: I in the expenditure sum
way in: Night lights seen from orbit (outside check)
- L1: Outdoor and indoor light at night, rising with income
- L2: Satellite sensors record it (DMSP-OLS nighttime lights series)
- L3: Lights growth set against income growth through an elasticity
- L4: A composite estimate: lights and accounts weighted by each one's error
way in: Population (per person)
- L1: The resident population, which changes over time
- L4: The divisor: GDP per person
way in: Prices (deflator, chained dollars, PPP)
- L1: Market prices of the period
- L2: Price change across all domestic output, investment and government services included
- L3: Quality adjustment (hedonic indexes) for fast-changing goods
- L4: Chained-dollar volumes; a common basket for PPP
way in: Producers' output (production approach)
- L1: Resident enterprises of every class producing goods and services in the period
- L2: Output measured from company records of gross sales and inventories, or output times market price
- L3: Activities classified into industries and sectors; intermediate consumption (materials, supplies, services used up) set against output
- L4: Gross value added per industry, summed: GDP at factor cost, plus taxes less subsidies on products
way out: Comparisons and rankings across countries
- L1: Countries compared since King's 1688/1695 table of England, France and Holland
- L6: GDP per person at PPP compared between nations; built into composite indexes
way out: Growth targets and the push to grow
- L1: Consumption and production expanded; resource use and emissions follow
- L6: Incentives on politicians and actors to show growth
- L7: Growth set as a goal (SDG 8: about 3% a year)
way out: Monetary and fiscal policy
- L1: Deficit spending and rates act on demand; GDP moves
- L6: A recession read from a broad decline normally visible in real GDP
- L7: Policy chosen on current-quarter estimates
way out: The published figure (advance release, then revisions)
- L1: The series kept and read: news, markets, researchers, long historical tables
- L5: The advance release in the first month of the next quarter, later revised