templating our proposal
One conserved, interchangeable module reused unchanged across systems.
Seen in 959 walked systems. Each sighting is our reading of that system's sourced walk, in that system's own terms; a shape that turns up everywhere is the finding, and how it differs from place to place is the detail.
Structural: the shape does the work here (559)
- 1 + 1 dimensional Minkowski spacetime
The same constant Minkowski form at n = 2 as at n = 4. - 2 + 1 dimensional Minkowski spacetime
The same constant Minkowski form at n = 3 as at n = 4. - 3-sphere (hypersphere)
Constant curvature 1/r^2: one local geometry recurring at every point of the closed slice. - 6D (2,0) superconformal field theory (projected model)
The torus's modular group copied into four-dimensional physics: on M4 x E the N = 4 coupling is E's tau and Montonen-Olive SL(2, Z) is the modular group. - Abbasid Caliphate (750-1258, with its ceremonial Cairo line to 1517)
The fine-silver dirham: a standardised, regionally interchangeable module; coins 'circulate in perpetuity and across the entire Caliphate'; mints cut output rather than debase; Offa of Mercia minted coins like Abbasid ones. Also Samarra's standardized decorative vocabulary copied in Ibn Tulun's mosq - Absolute elsewhere (spacelike region)
Every observer draws the same elsewhere at each event ('all observers will assign the same light cone to any given event, and thus will agree on this division'). - Acausal Cauchy hypersurface
Every level of a Cauchy time function is a copy of one kind: 'the levels of a Cauchy time function are necessarily acausal Cauchy hypersurfaces', all homeomorphic to S. - Acausal set
One relational test (J\Delta-arelation) recurs as the base of every slice kind: Cauchy hypersurfaces, partial Cauchy surfaces, time-function levels, stable Cauchy hypersurfaces. - Access control
The pin tumbler module kept for millennia ('The modern Yale lock is essentially a more developed version of the Egyptian lock'); Unix permission bits codified by POSIX and reused unchanged in Linux; the access matrix as the shared model of every system. - Accounting (the field and practice)
A shared format reused unchanged so independently kept books interoperate: the Heroninos estate's standard system 'followed by all its local farm managers'; GAAP; IFRS required in 166 jurisdictions; the four statements. - Achronal boundary
One form, dI+(S), recurs as cone boundaries, Cauchy-horizon holders and event horizons; 'every achronal boundary has this form for some S'. - Achronal set
One form for every achronal boundary: 'every achronal boundary has this form [dI+(S)] for some S'; each is a locally Lipschitz hypersurface, the Cauchy horizon among them. - Acid-base reaction
One template reused unchanged: HA + B -> BH+ + A- holds in water, liquid ammonia, gas and solid ('formally independent of any solvent'); the same bicarbonate buffer 'serves to regulate the pH of blood, and bicarbonate also acts as a buffer in the ocean'; and the otopetrin proton channels are 'evolut - Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter)
One wave law in every medium: v = sqrt(stiffness/density) from the quark-gluon plasma (c_s^2 = 0.241) through the photon-baryon fluid (> c/2) to air (343 m/s), water and steel. - Action potential (nerve impulse, spike)
The voltage-sensor 'paddle' is a conserved module, 'interchangeable across a wide variety of cells and species': an archaebacterial paddle in a rat potassium channel makes a fully functional channel. - Active galactic nucleus
The relativistic jet recurs wherever a disc surrounds a compact object: 'Massive central black holes in galaxies have the most powerful jets, but their structure and behaviours are similar to those of smaller galactic neutron stars and black holes' (microquasars); tidal disruptions of stars launch t - Adaptive immune system
The TCR is the topological equivalent of an antibody's antigen-binding fragment (both immunoglobulin superfamily); the MHC region is paralogous to the Ig/TCR region (a 'primordial immune complex' split by 2R). - Affine parameter
The same labelling rule recurs on every geodesic, timelike, null or spacelike: walking with the tangent parallel transported defines 'the parameter along the path' up to linear transformations. - Affine parameter of a null geodesic
The parameter rule of every geodesic recurs on null ones with one constant changed (epsilon = 0) and proper time removed. - Affine space
One flat skeleton recurs under every flat geometry: Euclidean spaces have 'affine properties' (lines, subspaces, parallelism), pseudo-Euclidean ones keep 'the affine structure ... unchanged', and Minkowski spacetime is 'an affine space when the origin is dropped'. - Age of Enlightenment (the 17th-18th-century intellectual movement: its ideas, its networks of salons, academies, letters and print, and its effects on states and revolutions)
Alphabetical order, 'the zero degree of taxonomy', reused by every encyclopedia and dictionary; Montesquieu's separation of powers reused in the US, Polish (1791) and Cadiz (1812) constitutions. - Alloy
One ordered module, the L12 structure, reused unchanged across alloy families: L12-Ni3Al in nickel superalloys, L12-Al3Sc in aluminium, Co3(Al,W) in cobalt superalloys, each coherent with its FCC matrix and each strengthening it (src:wang-2018-cca; src:wp:superalloy). A coherent precipitate takes it - Alphabet (one letter per phoneme)
One letter order recurring nearly unchanged: the Ugaritic ABCDE order (14th century BC) 'has continued with minor changes in Hebrew, Greek, Armenian, Gothic, Cyrillic, and Latin ... stable for at least 3000 years'; lexicographic order in mathematics generalises it. - American literature
the King James Bible's passages reused word for word across novels by white and black American writers (550 of over 1,200 shared passages); slave narratives 'quoting, and relying heavily upon each other' with one common plot - Amino acid
One conserved core (amine, carboxyl, alpha carbon) with a swappable side chain: 22 modules that all fit one backbone and 'combine to give a vast array of peptides and proteins'. - Ancient Greek art
one module reused unchanged across works: kouroi all stylistically similar, the orders, mould-made Tanagra figurines, Roman copies of Classical statues, a coin design canon 'followed ever since' - Ancient Greek philosophy
A module moved between systems and still working: the Socratic question-and-answer, copied by Athenian youths, reused in cognitive therapy where it predicts next-session symptom change; Stoic propositional logic 'still' in propositional calculus; the four qualities taken into Hippocratic medicine. - Angular momentum
One conservation law tied to one symmetry (rotational invariance), the same for particles, planets, stars and fields. - Angular velocity (the angular frequency vector)
One instantaneous axis for every rotation (Euler's theorem), whatever vectors are chosen. - Anti-de Sitter spacetime
One construction recurs for every constant-curvature space: a quasi-sphere in a flat space of one more dimension gives the hypersphere (q = 0), hyperbolic space (p = 0), de Sitter (q = 1) and anti-de Sitter (p = 1). - Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
One module, the split V-(D)-J-C layout with an RSS beside each segment, recurs unchanged in all seven human loci (IGH, IGK, IGL, TRA, TRB, TRG, TRD) and in every jawed vertebrate; one recombinase works on all of them. 'This feature is inherited by all the descendants of UrIg2 such as Ig and TCR.' - Antiquark
Six antiflavours repeat the quark's six one for one, with 'identical masses and decay lifetimes' (CPT): the quark's mass ladder is the template, each antiflavour a copy. - Archaeon (Archaea)
Asgard archaeal profilins and gelsolins change the behaviour of eukaryotic actin in vitro: an archaeal module that still works on the eukaryotic part. The information machinery (replication, transcription, translation) is shared in kind with eukaryotes. - Architecture
One module reused unchanged across buildings and regions: the five classical orders catalogued by Serlio, pattern-book features combined by housebuilders, pan-European Romanesque and Gothic carried by clerics and tradesmen, vernacular forms replicated once they worked. - Areal radius
One construction in every spherically symmetric spacetime (Schwarzschild r, FLRW a(t) r, Vaidya): 'This makes r and E natural variables to use, as has been rediscovered many times by different authors'. - Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them
Modus ponens and modus tollens are recognised as valid in Trobriand land courts as in WEIRD societies; the Stoics stated modus ponens with numbers in place of propositions; argumentation schemes are stereotypical patterns reused across law, science and everyday talk; Toulmin's layout reused in rheto - Aristotle
The syllogism is one form reused unchanged across contents ('universal systems of reasoning ... irrespective of the content'); later, Bekker's page numbers became the standard interface every edition and translation cites. - Art history (the field)
Modules swapped between systems and still working: Morelli's method came from medicine's reading of 'numerous symptoms', moved to Italian paintings, and was applied by others to Greek vases and the Persepolis reliefs 'with results that further confirmed its validity'; radiocarbon and synchrotron X-r - Art of ancient Egypt
one figure template (18 fists, composite view, fixed god forms) reused across three millennia and every medium, and carried by grids from wall to wall - Artificial intelligence
One module reused unchanged across tasks: DQN applied to seven Atari games 'with no adjustment of the architecture or learning algorithm'; one AlphaZero algorithm for chess, shogi and Go. - Asymptotic symmetry group
The Poincare template (Lorentz group in semidirect product with an abelian translation group) recurs with the translations widened into supertranslations: 'The BMS group also has a similar structure as the Poincare group'. - Atom
The valence configuration recurs down each column of the periodic table: 'rows are shell fillings, columns share valence counts'. Oxygen (shells 2, 6) and sulfur (six valence electrons, two short of a full shell) carry the same valence module one shell apart. - Atomic nucleus
The pairing theory written for superconducting metals (BCS, 1957) was carried over to nuclei and to neutron-star matter: like nucleons pair in time-reversed orbits, which is why even-even nuclei have a gap above their ground state that odd neighbours lack. - Attention
Conserved modules reused: the subcortical attention circuits (optic tectum, thalamus, striatum) 'highly conserved across vertebrate evolution'; theta-rhythmic sampling preserved in humans and macaques; the normalization computation reused from V1 to other cortical areas. - Authentication
One module reused unchanged across systems: an application adds authentication by calling the Kerberos library through GSS-API; the three-factor scheme and NIST's levels reused by agencies, banks and sites. - Averaged strong energy condition (ASEC)
One module recurs: integrate a pointwise condition's quantity along a whole geodesic (timelike for the ASEC and AWEC, null for the ANEC) and require the total to be non-negative; the Raychaudhuri equation integrated the same way underlies each. - Averaged weak energy condition (AWEC)
The averaging module recurs: the weak condition's energy density integrated along timelike curves, as the strong (ASEC) and null (ANEC) quantities are integrated along theirs. - Basal ganglia
One ancestral core unit (striatum, GPe, GPi, STN, SNc) present in the lamprey, conserved over 560 million years and reused as more modules; 61 cell types conserved across primates and mouse; enhancer viruses keep predicted activity across many mammals. - Bearing (mechanical)
One standard module reused unchanged across machines: ISO dimensions and numbering, ISO 281 ratings; Fischer's equal, round balls (1883) set up an independent industry; a bi-material plain bearing made interchangeable with linear ball bearings; the same bearing types from dental drills to the Mars r - Birkhoff's theorem (Birkhoff-Jebsen theorem)
One exterior for every spherical body: 'the exterior solution ... must be given by the Schwarzschild metric', so the planet's, the Sun's and a neutron star's outsides are one metric with different M. - Black hole
The jet recurs around compact objects at every scale: 'Massive central black holes in galaxies have the most powerful jets, but their structure and behaviours are similar to those of smaller galactic neutron stars and black holes'. - Black hole thermodynamics
The same four-law module (equilibrium, energy balance, non-decrease, unattainable zero) recurs on a horizon with area for entropy and surface gravity for temperature, and again on isolated horizons and in 2+1 dimensions (BTZ). - Black-hole event horizon
Locally the horizon copies the flat Rindler horizon (non-extremal case); settled, it copies the Killing-horizon form with constant surface gravity. - Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
Dennett: 'a Darwinian process, involving variation, selection and retention, as a generic algorithm that is substrate-neutral'; Traill counts four such systems: natural selection 'educates' DNA, the individual brain, the 'brain' of society including science, and the adaptive immune system. - Blood
One protease module reused by duplication: FIX, FX, protein C and protein Z share Gla - EGF - FXa inhibition - Trypsin; the EPO receptor and c-Mpl are homodimers of one receptor family with the growth hormone, G-CSF and prolactin receptors. - Blood pressure
One mechanosensor module, PIEZO2 (with PIEZO1), is reused for gentle touch, airway stretch, airway closure, bladder fullness, the baroreceptor reflex and now cardiac blood volume; the RAS template recurs as local systems in kidney, adrenal, heart, vessels and brain. - BMS (Bondi-Metzner-Sachs) group
The Poincare pattern (Lorentz group acting on an abelian translation group, semidirect product) is kept, with the four translations enlarged to infinitely many supertranslations. - Book
Every codex repeats one build: folded sheets nested into quires ('most commonly four bifolia'), sewn and bound; every modern book one layout (front matter, body copy) and one identifier scheme ('unique to every edition'). - Bosonic string theory (projected model; the original string theory)
The critical-dimension gate recurs: 'The existence of a critical dimension where the anomaly cancels is a general feature of all string theories' (26 here, 10 for superstrings). - Bosonic strings, closed, oriented (projected model)
The bosonic spectrum core recurs in all four kinds ('all four theories have a negative energy tachyon ... and a massless graviton'); this kind is the template the article works out. - Bosonic strings, closed, unoriented (projected model)
The bosonic spectrum core (tachyon, graviton) copied from the oriented kind through the parity filter. - Bosonic strings, open and closed, oriented (projected model)
The bosonic spectrum core (tachyon, graviton, dilaton) shared by all four bosonic theories; orientation adds B and the U(1) vector. - Bosonic strings, open and closed, unoriented (projected model)
The bosonic spectrum core (tachyon, graviton, dilaton) shared by all four bosonic theories; the Omega projection removes B and the photon, and recurs in type I. - Botnet
The same code module swapped between operators and still working: Mirai's released code and credential list (subsuming BASHLITE's) reused across variants; "multiple botnets typically use the same malware but are operated by different entities". - Bottom quark
The third generation repeats the first: 'the third bottom and top quarks', named by Harari to match up and down, 'the "up" and "down" component of a weak isospin doublet'. The bottom is the down quark's slot recopied a third time (the strange the second), its weak isospin, charge and colour the same - Bureaucracy
The same module swapped between systems and still working: the Chinese examination taken into the British (Northcote-Trevelyan 1854) and French civil services; 'The Ottomans adopted Persian bureaucratic traditions and culture'; the Aq Qoyunlu kept the previous structure with secretary families who ' - Business
The same business module copied and still working: the franchise ('entrepreneurs purchase the rights to open and run a business from a larger corporation'; 1 in 12 US retail businesses), interchangeable parts and standardisation (Whitney), and the company form itself carried into states' enterprises - Calcium atom
Doubly magic closed shells recur: helium-4, oxygen-16, calcium-40, calcium-48 and lead-208; 'Calcium is the only element with two primordial doubly magic isotopes'. - Canonical four-momentum
The same split, canonical (not gauge invariant) versus kinetic (gauge invariant), recurs for linear momentum (P = p + qA) and angular momentum (the kinetic form uses p - eA). - Casimir-Polder force
One dispersion-force module recurs at three scales: atom-atom (London-van der Waals), atom-surface (Casimir-Polder), plate-plate (Casimir). 'The fundamental principles leading to the London-van der Waals force, the Casimir force, and the Casimir-Polder force can be formulated on the same footing'; L - Catenary world line
One module, constant Frenet-Serret curvatures, recurs across all six stationary world lines; each is a Killing motion and a Born-rigid family. The catenary is the case kappa_1^2 > kappa_2^2, kappa_3 = 0. - Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface)
Every slice of the foliation is a copy of one topology: 'all Cauchy hypersurfaces are homeomorphic to S'. - Cauchy time (temporal) function
Every reading of the clock is a copy of one slice: levels are acausal Cauchy hypersurfaces, all homeomorphic ('all Cauchy hypersurfaces are homeomorphic to S'). - Causal (non-spacelike) curve
The same tangent test gives the same causal curves in every Lorentz frame. - Causal future (absolute future)
The same region, ordered the same way, at every event and for every observer ('All observers will agree ...'). - Causal past (absolute past)
The same region, ordered the same way, at every event and for every observer ('All observers will agree ...'). - Causal path (parametrised future-directed non-spacelike curve)
The same tangent test at every event and in every Lorentz frame sorts paths into causal and not. - Cave painting
one module, the hand stencil (a hand on the wall, pigment sprayed round it), reused unchanged across Sulawesi, Europe, Australia and South America and from 67.8 ka to about 550 BC - Celestial sphere (Riemann sphere of lines of sight)
One action, three builds: the same Moebius maps move the celestial sphere under boosts and rotations, act on spinors through SL(2, C), and classify Lorentz transformations by their fixed points on the sphere. - Cell
One code read by every cell: 'LUCA certainly had genes and a genetic code', and chemiosmosis is 'now ubiquitous in living cells'. - Cellular respiration
One currency for every fuel and every use: ATP (and the carriers NADH, FADH2, acetyl-CoA) lets sugar, fat, amino acids and lactate feed one chain and every ATPase; the c-subunit 'sequences are identical throughout almost all vertebrates'. - Central bank
Modules copied between central banks and still working: the Bank of England as "direct or indirect model for all subsequent central banks"; the League of Nations' EFO stamping out new central banks in Austria, Hungary, Danzig and Greece; inflation targeting copied from New Zealand (1990) to Canada, - Central processing unit
One module swapped and still working: System/360's architecture ran the same programs on a series of machines of different speeds; microprocessors were made instruction-set compatible with older hardware and software; the ISA is the template software is written to, independent of the build under it. - Charm quark
The second generation repeats the first: Bjorken and Glashow theorised charm to 'establish parallels between the leptons and the quarks' (four leptons, then three quarks); the charm is 'a second-generation up-type quark', the up quark's slot recopied with the strange quark as its partner, which the - Chemical element (the periodic table)
The proton count is a template that every atom of a kind copies: all oxygen atoms, wherever made, carry Z = 8 and so the same shell fill and chemistry. The table is the catalog of the templates. - Chemical elements (the set of atomic species, Z = 1 to 118)
One shell pattern stamped period after period: 'in the formation of each new shell the chemical periodicity is repeated' (Kossel), so oxygen, sulfur and selenium share a column and a chemistry. - Chemical equilibrium
The mass-action format is reused unchanged: Michaelis-Menten enzyme kinetics, Lotka-Volterra ecology and SIR epidemics are all written in it (o85, o86). The flux-force relation dG = -RT ln(J+/J-) is one module that unites Ussing's membrane flux ratio, Hill's catalytic cycles and Crooks' fluctuation - Chemical kinetics
The Arrhenius form is one module reused unchanged: it models 'diffusion coefficients, population of crystal vacancies, creep rates, and many other thermally induced processes' (o10), and the Boltzmann-Arrhenius form fits 87% of 1,072 biological thermal rises across microbes, plants and animals (o30) - Chemistry (the field: the practice of chemists and the structure of substances and their reactions it works on)
Functional groups are modules that show the same characteristic chemical properties in whatever compound carries them, and are what NMR spectra read; IUPAC names and CAS numbers are conserved identifiers reused across every paper and database. - Chinese art
one module reused unchanged: piece-mould sections reassembled; terracotta heads, arms, legs and torsos made separately (legs like drainage pipes) and at least ten face moulds; standard stamps pressed repeatedly into clay; Qin standard script and measures; the Six Ritual Jades - Chloroplast
The bacterial division ring reused: plastid division runs on 'the FtsZ ring, a single ring constructed from homologs of the bacterial fission protein'; and chloroplast genomes take foreign genes and express them at up to 10,000 copies per cell (transplastomic engineering). - Chronological future I+(x)
The same open set, built the same way, at every point; unchanged by conformal rescaling. - Chronological past I-(x)
The same open set, built the same way, at every point; unchanged by conformal rescaling. - Circular orbit
One rule at every radius: v = sqrt(mu/r) and T = 2 pi sqrt(r^3/mu) for the Newtonian circle; the same circular balance recurs in the Schwarzschild metric with r replaced by r - r_S, and in the Kerr spherical-orbit family at Q = 0. - Circular orbit in a stationary axisymmetric spacetime
One construction recurs in every stationary axisymmetric spacetime: Killing helices U = Gamma[d_t + zeta d_phi] measured against ZAMOs; Kerr, Schwarzschild and flat space are copies with different lapse and shift. - Closed string (projected model)
The massless trio G_mu-nu, B_mu-nu, Phi: 'These three massless fields are common to all string theories'; the superstring adds RR fields and gravitini inside the same graviton supermultiplet. - Cloud computing
One disk image or package is cloned unchanged onto many VMs or tasks ('cloning tasks onto multiple virtual machines at run-time'); the scheduler prefers machines that already hold the packages. - Coframe field
The flat Minkowski form recurs in every coframe at every point: eta_ab = gamma_a x gamma_b. - Columbian Exchange
The same crop module swapped into many systems and still working: the potato, tomato, chili or maize reused unchanged in Irish, Italian, Indian, Hungarian and Chinese farming and cooking; Iberian horses the founding stock of North American herds. - Combinatorics: the practice of counting, arranging and choosing finite structures (permutations, combinations, partitions, designs, graphs), the structures it studies, and the people and machines who work with them
The very same combinatorial objects (binomial coefficients, partitions, designs, Latin squares) reappear unchanged across the sciences, from statistical mechanics to experimental design to quantum codes. - Communication: the passing of messages between senders and receivers through a channel (and, on other readings, the making of meaning between them), and communication studies, the field that studies it
A shared code is the module both ends must hold: computers follow one protocol; turn-taking's no-overlap, minimal-gap pattern recurs in all 10 languages tested, 'a single shared infrastructure for language use'; Lasswell's five questions, built for mass communication, reused in other fields. - Competition for each baryon overdensity (photon pressure vs gravitational collapse)
Every overdensity runs the same contest at the same sound speed and stops at the same radius, so the shell recurs as one length: 'BAO matter clustering provides a "standard ruler" for length scale in cosmology', ~490 million light-years today, and the same scale sets the CMB peaks. - Compiler
One intermediate representation is the module every front end writes and every back end reads, swapped freely: GCC, Clang/LLVM and the Amsterdam Compiler Kit combine front ends for different languages with back ends for different CPUs. LLVM's SSA code is reused at compile, link, run and idle time. - Composition algebra
One doubling step repeated: R -> C -> H -> O, each by the Cayley-Dickson construction, each step losing a property (order, commutativity, associativity), and the ladder stopping at 8. - Computational physics (computer simulation of physical systems: the practice and the simulated systems it stands for)
One method moves between fields unchanged: density functional theory used the same way by solid-state physicists and chemists; Monte Carlo-like methods carried into epidemics, forest fires and social science. - Computer law
One module reused across legal systems: Ribicoff's 1977 'access' language in state definitions; the Budapest Convention as a guideline for national laws; the CMA a model for Canada and Ireland; the DMCA's intermediary exemption adopted by the EU (2000); the GDPR a model for Brazil, Japan, South Kore - Computer network
One module reused unchanged across systems and generations: Ethernet 'remains backwards compatible with the original standard' from 10 Mbit/s to 800 Gbit/s; one TCP 'spans a range from 800 Mbps Cray channels to 1200 bps packet radio links' (Jacobson); IP runs over any link below the hourglass waist. - Computer-aided design
One module reused unchanged: Sketchpad's masters instanced many times; geometric kernels (Romulus's line to Parasolid and ACIS; Hanratty's code supplied to McDonnell Douglas, Computervision and others) built into many CAD systems; neutral formats (IGES, STEP) as a shared interface; a family of capsc - Condensed matter physics
One module reused and still working: universality (long-distance physics independent of all but a handful of short-distance details, so one model serves magnets and fluids); quantum protectorates (crystal, superfluid, superconductor, band insulator, magnets, quantum Hall states) whose low-energy pro - Conformal boundary (conformal infinity)
One universal edge for every asymptotically flat spacetime: 'the conformal boundary and its structure are universal features among asymptotically flat space-times. The invariance group of this universal structure is exactly the BMS group'; spacetime's asymptotic floor carries the same BMS structure. - Congruence of world lines
One kinematical decomposition (expansion, shear, vorticity, acceleration) and one Raychaudhuri balance recur unchanged for fluid flows, free-fall clouds and light-ray bundles ('pure mathematics valid for any Lorentzian manifold'). - Connection on a principal bundle (gauge field)
The curvature formula recurs: 'Omega = d omega + 1/2 [omega wedge omega]' as the electromagnetic field strength (abelian, the bracket vanishes) and the gluon field strength (non-abelian, the commutator term). - Connection on a vector bundle
One definition (covariant derivative, transport, curvature 2-form) recurs on every bundle: the tangent bundle (Riemann tensor) and gauge bundles (Yang-Mills). - Contract
The standard form contract: one template written by one side (sometimes by an industry body and distributed to firms) reused unchanged for every buyer; the CISG's uniform rules incorporated automatically into contracts between contracting states. - Coriolis force
The same term -2m omega x v' recurs unchanged across scales: water wheels (Coriolis 1835), molecules (Coriolis coupling), insects, cyclones, ocean gyres, and trojans held at L4/L5. - Corporate law
Interchangeable modules reused across jurisdictions: model articles assumed when a constitution is silent; the MBCA adopted by 36 states; Cadbury's recommendations reused in OECD, EU, US and World Bank codes; the US benefit corporation dropped into Italian law. - Corporation
The Dutch arrangement (perpetual existence with transferable shares) was taken up unchanged by the EIC and other English chartered companies; the German GmbH (1892) 'inspired other countries to introduce corporations of this kind'. - Corpus Juris Civilis (Justinian's codification: Codex, Digest, Institutes, Novels)
One conserved scheme recurring: Gaius's persons, things, actions, carried by the Institutes, 'recognized in ... Blackstone's Commentaries ... the French Code civil and the German BGB'; the Napoleonic Code's categories 'not drawn from earlier French law'. - Cosmic rays
Diffusive shock acceleration recurs at every shock scale: the Parker equation is used 'to study the acceleration of cosmic rays at supernova remnant shocks, the acceleration and transport of solar energetic particles at shocks driven by coronal mass ejections, and ... at the solar wind termination s - Cosmic time
One clock setting repeated in every galaxy: 'All of these clocks synchronized at the single point in the past where the geodesics intersect'. - Cosmic topology
One cell repeated over the cover: 'a subgroup of isometries acting on the UC ... produces its tiling by these copies'; each copy shows the same sky. - Covalent bond
One module reused unchanged across all molecular matter: Lewis's electron pair, 'the quantum unit of chemical bonding'; covalent radii add up to bond lengths (Pauling: half the single-bond length); and life joins every backbone (peptide, phosphodiester, glycosidic) by the same dehydration condensati - Critical infrastructure
One module reused unchanged: the NIST Cybersecurity Framework, written as the 'Framework for Improving Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity', now used by any organisation with its six functions intact; the Purdue levels and standard automation protocols swap across makers and sectors. - Cryptographic hash function
One module reused unchanged: the Merkle-Damgard construction in MD5, SHA-1 and SHA-2; any iterative hash slotted into HMAC 'without modifications'; Argon2 runs over an arbitrary hash H (BLAKE2b in the RFC). - Cryptography
One conserved module reused unchanged: the five NIST modes are defined 'for use with an underlying symmetric key block cipher algorithm', so any approved block cipher (AES) plugs in without change; Kerckhoffs's rule makes the algorithm public and only the key varies. AES itself recurs unchanged acro - Crystallization (nucleation and crystal growth)
The lattice is the template: each new unit joins in 'the characteristic arrangement' (c44); a seed of the same salt starts crystallization (c60) and replicates material (c74); one seed, one large single crystal (c51). - Curriculum
A module swapped between systems and still working: Northwest Territories and Nunavut run Alberta's curriculum and tests; Common Core standards adopted 'in whole' by states so the same textbooks can serve across states; Roman curricula carried into medieval and Renaissance curricula - Cybercrime and its underground economy
The marketplace model (Tor hidden service, Bitcoin, escrow, mandatory feedback) swapped between operators and still working: Silk Road 2.0 set up by former admins and vendors, then numerous marketplaces 'following the same model'; affiliate programmes and as-a-service offers do the same for scams. - Cyberwarfare
One module swapped between systems and still working: the NSA's EternalBlue, leaked, ran inside WannaCry and inside NotPetya; Equation Group zero-days used before in 'fanny' reappear in Stuxnet. - d'Alembert operator (d'Alembertian, wave operator, box operator)
One operator recurs unchanged in three equations: the wave equation (Box u = 0), the vacuum electromagnetic wave equation (Box A^mu = 0) and the Klein-Gordon equation ((Box + m^2c^2/hbar^2) psi = 0). - Dark matter
One halo module recurring at every scale: the NFW profile 'works for a large variety of halo masses, spanning four orders of magnitude, from individual galaxies to the halos of galaxy clusters'. This walk's collapse floor (virialized halos, NFW/Einasto) is the module; the galaxy's halo well and the - Data centre
The same modules used unchanged across operators: the 19-inch rack, PUE as an ISO/IEC standard (30134-2:2016), the Uptime Tier Standard, Open Compute server and rack designs published for anyone to build. - Data structure
One module reused unchanged across systems: the same B-tree, hash table and linked list in compilers, databases, file systems and languages' standard libraries; one interface, many interchangeable implementations. - Degenerate matter
One Fermi-gas module (fill to the Fermi energy; pressure from density alone) recurs unchanged from nuclei to metals to white dwarfs to neutron stars. - Denial-of-service attack
Attack code reused unchanged across attackers: the 1996 Phrack SYN-flood code 'widely distributed and used', the Panix sample code reused against Sprint, EarthLink and E-Trade the next year; booter method menus offer the same named vectors (DNS, NTP, SNMP, LDAP) across services. - Developmental genetic toolkit (evo-devo gene toolkit)
Toolkit proteins are reused unchanged and are interchangeable across phyla (chicken Hoxb-1 rescues the fly labial null; mouse Pax6 makes eyes in a fly): a fixed shared interface, as the genetic code is for translation. - Differential equations (the practice of writing and solving laws of change, and the equations it works on)
One equation swapped between systems and still working: the wave equation for light, sound and pond waves; one diffusion equation for many diffusion processes; Lotka's 1910 equations for autocatalytic chemistry redeployed in 1925 for predator and prey; Turing's reaction-diffusion equations from 1952 - Differential form
One theorem, many copies: the generalized Stokes theorem has 'the fundamental theorem of calculus, the divergence theorem, Green's theorem, and Stokes' theorem as special cases'. - Digital forensics
One template reused unchanged: the forensic process model (collection, examination, analysis, reporting) is applied 'regardless of the need', from law enforcement to malware incidents; physical forensic science's hierarchy of propositions (source, activity, offence) and its principles are carried in - Digital identity
Modules swapped and still working: OpenID Connect laid 'on top of the OAuth 2.0 protocol'; any DID method plugs into the same DID document model; the IAL/AAL/FAL components chosen independently ('agencies should not assume they will be the same'). - Digital signatures and certificates
One module reused unchanged: the X.509 certificate (1988) serves HTTPS, code signing, S/MIME, timestamping and OCSP signing (one key-purpose list in RFC 5280); the same signature standard serves all. Swapped algorithms keep the same certificate frame. - Dirac operator
One operator form, the 'square root' of a Laplacian, recurs from Hamilton's quaternions (1847) to the electron (1928) to curved spin manifolds (with the spin connection). - Dirac spinor
One spinor construction for every charged elementary fermion: 'quarks and electrons'. - Discrete rotational symmetry (n-fold, C_n)
The same C_n module recurs in unrelated matter: water and formaldehyde (C2), ammonia (C3), benzene (C6), crystal classes. - Displacement four-vector
The same rule X' = Lambda X recurs for the displacement as for every four-vector. - DNA and genes
One pairing rule (A with T, C with G) serves as the template for copying (replication), for reading out (transcription) and for checking (mismatch repair tells new strand from old): 'the specific pairing we have postulated immediately suggests a possible copying mechanism'. - Drama (the literary form)
one plot module reused in new plays and still working: Seneca's Phaedra from Euripides' Hippolytus; Roman comedies all on Greek subjects; Restoration plotlines taken from French, Spanish and classical plays; Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet as Prokofiev's ballet - Einstein constraint equations
The same split in another field: 'the Maxwell equations for the electromagnetic field can be treated as a Cauchy problem subject to the constraints D . B = 0 and D . E = rho/eps0'; in both, constraints on a slice plus evolution equations, with the constraints carried forward by an identity. - Einstein equivalence principle
The same local physics recurs at every place and time ('independent of where and when'): every small freely falling laboratory runs special relativity. - Election
The Australian ballot's four components travelled as one module: Tasmania, Victoria and South Australia 1856, Britain 1872, Belgium 1877, Louisville and Massachusetts 1888, South Carolina 1950. Separately, Hotelling's spatial-competition model was reused for politics by Downs (1957). - Electrical grid
A standard frequency and voltage let any compliant machine or appliance plug in anywhere in the area; grids with the same frequency and standards can be joined directly. - Electrochemical gradient
One proton-driven rotary ATP synthase reused unchanged across life: 'essentially the same structure and activity of ATP synthase enzymes are present in all kingdoms of life', its gene order conserved since before LUCA; one sign convention in every bioenergetic membrane (import P to N spontaneous). - Electromagnetic four-potential
One Lorentz rule recurs for the potential at every event, as for every four-vector. - Electron
The first-generation doublet (nu_eL, e_L) is repeated by the muon and tau generations with the same weak isospin and hypercharge; couplings the same for each flavour (lepton universality). - Electron neutrino
The first-generation doublet (nu_eL, e_L) with T = 1/2 and Y_W = -1 recurs identically in the second and third generations, and couplings to every gauge boson are flavour-independent (lepton universality). - Elliptic orbit
Period set by a alone: every ellipse with the same semi-major axis keeps the circle's period, whatever its eccentricity. - Engine
One module reused unchanged: the turbine, in steam turbines (Parsons 1884), gas turbines and jets ('the key to a practical jet engine was the gas turbine') and turbochargers; the piston, cylinder and crank (al-Jazari's crank-conrod, 1206) under steam and internal combustion alike; Watt's horsepower - Engineering design process
One process template reused unchanged across fields and decades: Evans' 1959 ship-design spiral 'still in use after more than five decades in fields from naval architecture ... to software engineering'; the design-build-test loop reused in metabolic engineering as 'a widely employed engineering fram - English literature
the blank verse line (about 8 words) as a unit that shows up in speech-length modes across many playwrights (secondary modes at 16 and 24 words); the heroic couplet 'a standard form'; genre templates (detective fiction coherent 160-200 years) reused by independent authors and still working - Entropy
Shannon's H 'will be recognized as that of entropy as defined in certain formulations of statistical mechanics' (o25): one form reused across heat, phase space and messages (C-120). In built systems, approved hash functions are vetted conditioning modules swapped into any entropy source (o61). - Epic poetry
the formula: 'an expression that is regularly used, under the same metrical conditions'; metrically equal formulae swap (swift-footed Achilles / glancing-helmed Hector); type-scenes for arming and launching - Essay
the eight-legged essay's eight set sections and the five-paragraph format: one conserved module reused unchanged across writers, topics and years; successful essays printed as guides so the module is copied - Ethnic group
The Soviet nationality module (autonomous unit, one language, awareness of common origin) was stamped on Central Asian peoples and carried into China's nationality policy from the 1920s; the Dungans were made a nationality to that template. - Euclidean group
One symmetry at every place and orientation: the same group 'depends only on the dimension', and the same pair of conservation laws follows for every isolated system. - Euclidean line
The same line recurs in every Euclidean space of every dimension: each 'Euclidean subspace of dimension one' is isometric to it. - Euclidean metric (dot product)
The same form recurs at every tangent space of every Riemannian manifold ('a smoothly varying Euclidean metric on the tangent spaces'). - Euclidean n-space (n > 3)
One geometry per dimension, repeated up the ladder: every R^n with the dot product, every E(n) with n(n + 1)/2 parameters, every dimension with its regular polytopes. - Euclidean plane
The same plane recurs as every two-dimensional subspace of every higher Euclidean space and as the plane of every central-force orbit. - Euclidean space
The same flat module recurs at every point of every manifold: 'tangent spaces of differentiable manifolds are Euclidean vector spaces'; Riemannian manifolds 'behave locally like a Euclidean space that has been bent'. - Euclidean vector
One arrow algebra recurs for displacement, velocity, acceleration, force and momentum ('any quantity that has magnitude, has direction, and which adheres to the rules of vector addition'). - Euler equations (fluid dynamics)
The relativistic and classical Euler equations are one template: the classical law is what remains when gamma -> 1 and c -> infinity. - Event horizon
One local form recurs at every non-extremal horizon: 'locally any non-extremal black hole horizon is Rindler. So the Rindler spacetime gives the local properties of black holes and cosmological horizons'; the Unruh effect would be the near-horizon form of Hawking radiation. - Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea)
One module reused unchanged: the static Morris-Thorne wormhole with 'the usual shape function' b(r), multiplied by whatever conformal factor Omega(t) is chosen; swapping Omega gives Milne-like, bang-crunch, FRW, inflating and 'flash' wormholes. - Experiment, measurement and uncertainty (the physics lab as a practice: designing, measuring, estimating error)
One conserved procedure (the GUM's Type A / Type B evaluation and the law of propagation) reused unchanged across labs and fields, from chemistry to particle physics. - Exterior field of a compact star
The same exterior metric that corrects GPS clocks (r_s/R about 1e-9) weighs neutron stars (compactness 0.156): one formula, different M and R. - Exterior field of a neutron star
One exterior metric for every non-rotating spherical mass: the planet exterior (weak), the star exterior and this one (compactness 0.156) differ only in M and R. - Exterior field of a planet
One exterior metric for every spherical mass: Earth's r_s 8.9 mm, the Sun's 3.0 km; the planet's exterior is a copy at tiny r_s/R. - Exterior field of a white dwarf
The same exterior shift, z = Delta U / c^2 to first order, from 2 ppm at the Sun to about 170 ppm at a white dwarf. - Exterior field of an ordinary star (the Sun)
One metric with a tiny r_s/R for the Sun as for Earth; the same 2 ppm-scale clock shift and light bending in each, scaled by mass. - Extremely accelerated observers (first torsion zero)
The Iyer-Vishveshwara construction of the Frenet-Serret frame recurs on every circular orbit; this kind is one setting of its parameter (tau_1 = 0). - Extrinsic curvature (second fundamental form)
The same constraint pair (R + K^2 - K_ij K^ij = 16 pi E; D_j K^j_i - D_i K = 8 pi p_i) recurs on every slice of every 3+1 split. - Eye
Pax6 is reused unchanged across phyla: mouse Pax6 makes ectopic eyes on a fly's antennae, wings and legs; a chicken crystallin enhancer works in the fly. - Fermi normal coordinates
The same metric expansion recurs around every world line: g_tt = -[1 + 2a x + (a x)^2 + R_0c0d x x], g_ta = -(2/3) R_0cad x x, g_ab = delta_ab - (1/3) R_acbd x x; only a(t) and the Riemann components change. - Fermi-Walker tetrad
Fermi-Walker transport reduces to parallel transport when acceleration is zero: the same transport module recurs with correction terms added. - Fermi-Walker transport
One rule on every curve, reducing to the covariant derivative on geodesics: 'any system transforming with proper time is said to be undergoing Fermi-Walker transport'. - Financial statement
One statement form reused unchanged by every filer and read by every reader: IFRS's 'standardised way', a regulator's 187 coded lines, XBRL taxonomies that let any system read any firm's report. - Fishery
One harvest framework reused unchanged: MSY adopted as the primary goal by the IWC, IATTC, ICCAT, ICNAF and written into UNCLOS; B/BMSY and U/UMSY reference points used for 635 assessed stocks; ITQs used in New Zealand, Australia, Iceland, Canada and the United States (148 major fisheries by 2008). - Five-dimensional spacetime (Kaluza-Klein)
The Kaluza-Klein move recurs: a compact dimension yields a gauge field, U(1) for the circle and 'relatively straightforward to replace U(1) by a general Lie group' (Yang-Mills); string theory's compactification 'is a generalization of Kaluza-Klein theory'. - Flat metric (zero curvature)
The Pythagorean form recurs unchanged at every point, and at every event as the tangent-space model of curved spacetime. - Fluid solution (of the Einstein field equation)
The same SO(3) isotropy for every perfect fluid, and the same results in curved and flat spacetime (equivalence principle). - Flux energy condition (FEC)
The weak condition's test reused on another tensor: 'the FEC can be viewed as a variant of the WEC applied to the sign-reversed square of the stress-energy tensor', [-T^2]_ab V^a V^b >= 0. - Foliation (of spacetime by spacelike hypersurfaces)
One leaf construction repeated across the family: every Sigma_t is a level set of the same regular function, each spacelike, none intersecting. - Formal security policy model
One module reused unchanged across systems: TCSEC listed Bell-LaPadula as the representative model for B2-A1 products; any boolean-lattice implementation 'could support any other boolean policy, given enough width and the provision of a personality module'; the same model was interpreted for Multics - Four-acceleration
One fixed relation recurs on every world line: 'the four acceleration is orthogonal to the four velocity ... which is true for all world lines', because U's magnitude is fixed. - Four-force
'In general relativity the relation between four-force, and four-acceleration remains the same': one law F = m A carried from flat to curved spacetime, the covariant derivative replacing d/dtau. - Four-momentum (energy-momentum four-vector; the momentum operator p_mu)
One invariant, p . p = -m^2 c^2, computed alike by every observer. - Four-position
The same rule X' = Lambda X that every four-vector obeys recurs for an event's coordinates. - Four-vector
One transformation rule, X' = Lambda X, recurs for every four-vector; 'the vector itself (as opposed to its components in some coordinate system) is invariant'. - Four-velocity
One fixed module recurs in every massive body's tangent: 'the magnitude of the four-velocity for any object is always a fixed constant', the same -c^2 whatever the speed. - Four-wavevector
The four-vector rule X' = Lambda X recurs for waves; its time row is the Doppler formula. - Fourier analysis (the practice of splitting signals into waves and rebuilding them, and the structure it works on)
One standard basis (sines, complex exponentials) shared by every use from heat to JPEG to MRI; the five variants are one template for four kinds of input. Re-walk 11-13: Fourier's own words: "the same expression ... represents as well the motion of light in the atmosphere, as it determines the laws - Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
The same metric module recurs at every comoving point (cosmological principle), and the same family of solutions a proportional to t^(2/(3(w+1))) recurs for every fluid, 'labelled by w'. - Fruit fly (Drosophila melanogaster)
A human gene swapped into the fly still works: a fly mutant phenotype rescued by the wild-type human cDNA but not the patient variant; 65% of human disease genes have a functional fly homolog - Fullerenes (buckyballs and nanotubes)
One conserved module reused across a family: the half-C60 cap ('high symmetry ... hemispheres for C 60 -I h and other fullerenes ... are prerequisite end-caps for fullertubes'); the same cap closes nanotubes. - Function (mathematics): the assignment of exactly one output to each input, and the practice of defining, drawing, composing and using it
The concept 'one output for each input' and its notation f(x) are reused unchanged in calculus, programming, the lambda calculus, neural networks and a cell's response curve. - Future light cone (future null cone)
The same cone at every event, kept by every orthochronous Lorentz transformation. - Future set
The same closure rule, built the same way at every point, unchanged by conformal rescaling. - Galactic magnetic field
The dynamo recurs at three scales: 'a rotating, convecting, and electrically conducting fluid can maintain a magnetic field' in Earth's core, in the Sun (Babcock-Leighton) and in galactic discs (small-scale and alpha-Omega dynamos). - Galaxy
One halo profile at every scale: the NFW profile 'works for a large variety of halo masses, spanning four orders of magnitude, from individual galaxies to the halos of galaxy clusters'; the Milky Way follows the universal rotation curve of spirals. - Galaxy cluster
The same halo one scale up: the NFW profile works 'from individual galaxies to the halos of galaxy clusters', and the self-similar model treats clusters as 'scaled versions of each other'. - Gauge boson
One rule recurring across groups: 'there are as many gauge bosons as there are generators of the gauge field': one for U(1), eight for SU(3), three for SU(2). - Gear
The involute tooth is one module reused unchanged: its profile depends only on tooth count, pressure angle and pitch, so any two involute gears of one pressure angle and pitch mate whatever their sizes; standard modules and pitches exist for interchangeability. Stable double helical gears can be swa - General stationary world line
The stationary template with all three curvatures on; the boost and the rotation each recur as their own kinds. - Generalised Birkhoff theorem (Einstein-Maxwell)
The same uniqueness statement (spherical + asymptotically flat => static, one exterior) recurs with the Maxwell field added: Schwarzschild becomes Reissner-Nordstrom. - Generalized Minkowski spacetime (any number of dimensions)
One module re-used at any dimension: the same constant Minkowski form, 'easily extended or simplified ... in any number of dimensions'. - Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping)
One conserved table read unchanged across nearly all life, and a gene moved to another organism is still read ('Heterologous gene expression is used in many biotechnological applications'), slower where codon use differs. - Geodesic
One connection, one path for all: the Christoffel symbols 'are independent of the velocity or acceleration or other characteristics of a test particle'; every falling body copies the same geodesic. - Geodesic (free-fall) four-velocity field
Universality of free fall: every test particle at one place and time takes the same acceleration, whatever it is made of. - Geologic time scale (deep time)
One procedure reused unchanged for every boundary: the GSSP criteria (Hedberg 1976; Cowie 1986; Remane 1996; Harper 2022) and 'the attached proforma or standard document that will be utilized for all outstanding GSSPs and GSSAs'; the AWG 'followed these guidelines'. In the lab, the EARTHTIME tracers - Geology (the field)
The same module carried to another body unchanged and still working: 'By applying sound stratigraphic principles to the distribution of craters on the Moon ... Gene Shoemaker took the study of the Moon away from Lunar astronomers and gave it to Lunar geologists'; planetary geology 'relies on known g - Globalization
The standard container: 'international standardization in 1965' let one box move between ships, cranes, railways and trucks of different owners and countries; containerisation's cumulative effect on North-North trade was about 700% over 20 years, larger than GATT or free-trade agreements. - Glossators' reading method (gloss and commentary)
One reading rule recurs on different canons: Justinian's texts (glossators), Gratian's Decretum (decretists; it 'served the function of giving the canonists a text like that of the Corpus Iuris Civilis for the civilians or the bible for the theologians'), Lombard's Sentences (required commentaries). - Gluon jets (gluon-rich environments)
String breaking into colourless hadrons recurs: in the gluon jet's strings to each quark, in the quark jet's hadronization, and in cosmic-ray first interactions in air, where Sibyll models the colour flow as 'a closed colour loop between two gluons' giving two strings per scattering. - Graph theory: the practice of studying vertices joined by edges (problems, proofs, algorithms, its people and books) and the graphs it works on
One module reused unchanged: the vertex-edge graph with the same measures (degree, clustering, paths) applied to brains, genes, societies and the Web; the power law found 'independent of the system and the identity of its constituents'. - Gravitational wave
The in-spiral runaway recurs at every scale of compact pair: neutron-star pairs (GW170817), close white-dwarf pairs that 'cannot get much closer together than 10,000 km before they will merge', and supermassive pairs, 'potentially the loudest gravitational-wave signals', where at about 0.001 pc radi - Gravity
One coupling, reused unchanged by every material: titanium and platinum fall alike to an Eotvos ratio of [-1.5 +/- 2.3 +/- 1.5] x 10^-15; Newton's law fits from a 90 mg sphere to the planets. - Gross domestic product
One accounting module, the SNA, is swapped into more than 200 countries, territories and areas and still works, with local adaptations; China dropped its Marxist-inspired material accounting and took GDP in 1993. The figure's own floors follow measurement's template (measurand, instrument, indicatio - Group field theory (GFT; candidate quantum gravity, walked as a projected model)
The matrix-model route (glue triangles, sum topologies, tune to a phase transition for the continuum) is reused one dimension up in GFT. - Hadron
One colour-neutral recipe recurs across the kinds: 'a quark of one color and an antiquark of the corresponding anticolor, or three quarks of different colors'; exotics (tetraquarks, pentaquarks) repeat it with extra pairs, pentaquarks keeping B = 1 'since the extra quark's and antiquark's baryon num - Hair cell
Fly atonal and mouse Atoh1 rescue each other's mechanosensory development; POU-IV is needed for stereovilli in both sea anemones and mice; the same hair cell serves ear and lateral line. - Hamiltonian and Lagrangian mechanics (analytical mechanics: classical mechanics built from energy functions and the stationary action, and the practice of using them)
The action principle as a reused module across physics ('from classical mechanics through quantum mechanics, particle physics, and general relativity'), carried into ecology (Volterra 1937), statistics (HMC) and machine learning (HNN, LNN), each time unchanged in form: write one scalar, vary it. - Hard partons / jets
The same hadronization step recurs wherever a coloured parton leaves: string breaking into colourless hadrons in the jet's cone, in the gluon jet's strings, and in cosmic-ray first interactions in air ('mostly light mesons like pions and kaons'); 'the Lund string model is an example of a jet fragmen - Harmonic oscillator
One module reused unchanged: the quantum oscillator (H = sum of independent oscillators) is the unit for a resonator's field, a lumped LC circuit, a lattice's vibrations (Einstein 1907) and the field theories (quantum-mechanics walk); the same equation runs mechanical, rotational and electrical osci - Hawking radiation
One temperature law at every horizon: Hawking with surface gravity, Unruh with proper acceleration. - Heart
One cardiogenic transcription-factor set (tinman/Nkx2.5, pannier/GATA4, Tbx20, Tbx5, MEF2) promotes hearts in flies and vertebrates. - Helium atom
One pairing rule at two scales: the He-4 nucleus's charge falls off exponentially from the centre 'exactly as does the charge density of helium's own electron cloud', because nucleon pairs and electron pairs fill 1s orbitals the same way. - Heterotic E8 x E8 string theory (projected model)
The 496 of ten-dimensional anomaly cancellation recurs split in half: 248 vector multiplets on each wall of the eleven-dimensional interval, one E8 per wall. - Higgs boson
One rule, 'couples to mass' (strength of interaction proportional to the partner's mass), recurs at every massive partner: gluon fusion runs through the top loop because 'the coupling of particles to the Higgs boson is proportional to their mass', and the decay table follows the same ladder (b-bbar - Higgs field
One Yukawa coupling of the neutral component recurs for every quark and charged lepton; the vacuum value turns each into a mass term, mass proportional to coupling (top y_t ~ 1, electron 2 x 10^-6). - Historiography
One module reused unchanged: Sima Qian's annals-biography format became the standard for 24 to 26 dynastic histories, and Korean and Japanese histories were 'based on the existing Chinese model'; Historische Zeitschrift (1859) was the model for the Revue des questions historiques (1866) and others; - History of science (the field and the story it tells)
One frame reused unchanged across the field: the Scientific Revolution as 'master narrative and central organising principle' since the 1950s, built into teaching; Kuhn's 'paradigm shift' reused from physics to social science and politics ('a kind of intellectual virus'); Varro's nine arts became th - Horismos (the relation x -> y: lightlike separation)
The same lightlike relation at every event, unchanged by conformal rescaling. - Horizon (general relativity)
'Locally any non-extremal black hole horizon is Rindler. So the Rindler spacetime gives the local properties of black holes and cosmological horizons.' - Hubble's law (Hubble-Lemaitre law)
The same law for every observer: 'every observer in an expanding universe will see objects receding from them'; H0 'is the same throughout the universe for a given comoving time'. - Human anatomy
The vertebrate segment as a reused module: 'much of the human body maintains the ancient segmental pattern that is present in all vertebrates with basic units being repeated', clearest in the vertebral column and ribcage. Across 350 million years of tetrapods the number of segments diverged but 'com - Humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae)
A whole song type, built in one population, is taken up intact by the next and works there as the display: 'entire new songs from a neighbouring population can enter and spread through a population'; revolutions pass east across the South Pacific, about two years each - Humpback whale song
Themes behave as interchangeable modules: during revolutions singers splice complete themes from the revolutionary song into the current song, and the hybrid song still works as song; splices fall where both songs share 'similar sounds arranged in a similar pattern' - Hydrogen bond
One module, the backbone amide N-H...O=C hydrogen bond, is reused unchanged in every alpha helix (i+4 -> i), in beta sheets between strands, and in nylon between chains; Watson-Crick donor-acceptor patterns are reused across DNA and RNA; the base pair article: pairing specificity 'underlies the temp - Hyperbolic world line
Six stationary motions share one template, constant Frenet-Serret curvatures; all are Killing motions and Born rigid. Hyperbolic motion is the template with one curvature on. - Hyperspherical universe
Constant curvature on every slice: one local geometry recurring everywhere. - Hypersurface (codimension-one submanifold of spacetime)
The same classification by signature (spacelike, timelike, null) used for vectors, curves and hypersurfaces alike. - Ideal gas
One module reused across systems and still working: the same ideal-gas model describes air, mercury vapour, electrons in a metal (Drude, free electron model), a weakly ionized plasma (Saha equation), and as a Fermi gas nucleons, neutron-star neutrons and white-dwarf electrons. The gas laws themselve - Incident response
The same module reused unchanged across teams and still working: the NIST life cycle and its SOP elements, the CSIRT handbook's triage-handling-announcement-feedback functions, tracking-number schemes (CERT#, VU#), and the Incident Command System, which 'has acted as a pattern for similar approaches - Induced metric
One rule, the pull-back, gives the world line its proper time, the world sheet its area and the slice its 3-metric. - Infinite flat universe
Zero curvature at every point of an unbounded space: one local geometry recurring without end. - Instantaneous (momentarily comoving) rest frame
A Lorentz frame recurs at every instant of an accelerated path: 'an accelerated object is at any moment at rest in a momentary inertial frame'. - Insurance
Interchangeable modules reused across insurers: standard claim forms (ACORD), the York-Antwerp Rules for general average (first published 1890), life tables and age-based premium schedules, standard reinsurance provisions relying on industry practice. - International trade
Two templates: the MFN clause, one rule applied unchanged to every member pair ('Grant someone a special favor and you have to do the same for all'); and gravity's macro structure, which many different micro-models share unchanged ('the same macro-level predictions regarding the structure of bilater - Internet
One conserved module, IP, reused unchanged by every network: 'the sole common interface between many heterogeneous lower-layer technologies and many diverse higher-layer applications'. - Intrinsic magnetosphere
The same set of parts recurs at Mercury, Earth, Jupiter, Saturn and in miniature at Ganymede: bow shock, magnetosheath, magnetopause, two-lobed tail with a plasma sheet, belts. 'The structure of Jupiter's magnetotail is similar to Earth's.' - Intrusion detection system
One module reused unchanged across sites: a signature 'released by a vendor for all its products'; a Snort rule written once runs on any sensor; Denning's profiles 'initialized from templates'. - Invariant hyperbola
The same curve recurs at three places: as the clock-reading curve here, as hyperbolic space (the two-sheeted hyperboloid's upper sheet, the space of velocities) and as de Sitter spacetime (the one-sheeted hyperboloid). - Ionic compound (salt)
One structure module, the rock-salt lattice, is used unchanged by different chemistries: BaO 'has the NaCl structure and therefore the same Madelung constant', so its lattice energy differs only by charge; many inorganic compounds share the motifs the Braggs found in NaCl. - Irrotational geodesic congruence
The same focusing inequality theta-dot <= -theta^2/(D - n) recurs for timelike flows (D - 1) and light bundles (D - 2). - Islamic art
one module reused unchanged: five girih tiles whose edges dictate how they combine, pattern-books such as the 114-pattern Topkapi Scroll consulted by artisans, the arabesque as one design tiled without end, and the same motifs moved across tile, wood, metal, carpet and page - Isolated horizon
One equilibrium structure recurs unchanged across hosts: Killing horizons, the event horizons of every stationary black hole, white-hole, Cauchy and cosmological horizons all satisfy the same isolated-horizon conditions. - Israel's theorem
Uniqueness statements that fix an exterior by a few parameters recur: Birkhoff (spherical vacuum to Schwarzschild), Israel (static vacuum horizon to Schwarzschild), the generalised theorem (to Reissner-Nordstrom). - J/psi meson
The '-onium' level scheme recurs: charmonium is named 'by analogy with positronium, which also consists of a particle and its antiparticle'; the same spectroscopic ladder (1S, 1P, 2S, 1D, n^(2S+1)L_J) is filled for charmonium and bottomonium, and the source says toponium cannot form because top quar - Jacobi field (geodesic deviation)
One equation serves geometry and gravity: 'In differential geometry, the geodesic deviation equation is more commonly known as the Jacobi equation'; it also builds the thin light bundle of lensing. - Japanese tit (Parus minor)
One FD (alert-recruitment) call combination, in a rigid order, reused across nearly all tit and chickadee species, traced to an ancestor 11-26 Ma; a willow tit's recruitment call works in the Japanese tit's D slot - Journalism
One module reused unchanged across outlets: the four global agencies send a single objective feed to all subscribers, and online a quarter of stories are reproduced elsewhere in under 4 minutes. - Jupiter
'The physics governing Jupiter's radio emissions is similar to that of radio pulsars. They differ only in the scale': rotation-modulated, beamed, maser emission and collimated particle streams, the pulsar module at planetary scale. - Kepler orbit
One law about one centre: Kepler's 1618 table and modern data give the same a^3/T^2 (7.496 x 10^-6 AU^3/day^2) for every planet; 'alpha has the same value for all the planets'. - Killing horizon
The thermal rule T = kappa/2 pi is the same module wherever a bifurcate Killing horizon appears (Unruh, Hawking, de Sitter). - Killing vector field
One rule recurs wherever a symmetry exists: each Killing field hands free motion one conserved quantity (energy from time translation, angular momentum from rotation), as the Poincare group's ten generators give ten conservation laws. - Kinship
The kin module reused unchanged across relations it was not built from: kinship terms and obligations extended to economic and political partners (fictive kin), descent idiom extended to gods and totems, stepsons taken into a patriline; terminologies inherited whole down language families. - Klein-Gordon equation
'The components of all non-interacting spin fields satisfy the Klein-Gordon equation either directly or once appropriate constraints are imposed. This is a group theoretic consequence': one equation recurs under the Maxwell, Proca and Dirac fields. - Lanthanides (the 4f series, La-Lu; as an opacity source in kilonovae)
One trivalent ion swaps for another and the module still works: 'at least four different metals, La–Nd, are each able to confer activity' in XoxF; varying the metal 'typically has little effect on the complex (other than size)'. - Laplace operator
One operator at the core of many field laws: Laplace's and Poisson's equations (potentials), the diffusion equation (heat), the wave equation (via the d'Alembertian) and the Schrodinger equation. - Laplace's equation
One equation recurring across fields: the gravitational potential in empty space, the electric and magnetic scalar potentials in source-free regions, steady temperature, the velocity potential of steady incompressible irrotational flow, and the Weyl potential of static axisymmetric vacua in general - Large language model
One block repeated unchanged ('a stack of N = 6 identical layers'); whole pretrained modules reused in new systems: the CLIP encoder inside LLaVA, a text LLM's weights initialising AudioPaLM. - Lateral line
One hair-cell module reused unchanged: lateral line hair cells are 'essentially identical to inner ear vestibular hair cells', so much that mutations affecting them in fish also cause deafness in humans and the zebrafish line serves as a screen for human ototoxicity; electroreceptors reuse the hair - Law (rules and law)
One rule form, the casuistic 'if ... then' entry, runs from Ur-Nammu's code through Hammurabi into later codes; whole codes are swapped between systems and keep working (codes 'easy to export'; Japan imported mostly the German Civil Code, China then built on the Japanese model of German law). - Lepton (the class of six)
One weak doublet (nu_L, l_L), T = 1/2, Y_W = -1, recurs in three generations that differ only in flavour number and mass, with flavour-independent couplings (universality tested in lifetimes, Z widths and W decays). - Lexicon: the stock of words and word parts of a language, and as each person holds it (the mental lexicon), as linguistics and psychology describe it
A word works as a module swapped between languages and still working: 20% of 1,706 Kalahari roots are shared across three unrelated families, most traced to one donor family; nothing is taken away from the donor. - Life (the living world, as biology describes it)
One template for all cellular life: 'the universal genetic code, machinery for protein synthesis, shared chirality of the almost-universal set of 20 amino acids and use of ATP as a common energy currency' is the evidence for common ancestry. - Light cone (null cone)
One cone recurs identically at every event: 'all observers must arrive at the same angle of 45 degrees for their light cones', and the five classes 'hold true in any frame of reference'. - Light-travel distance
The same integral in metres and in years: d_T and the lookback time t_L differ only by c. - Lightlike (null) separation
Zero for every observer: 'the light events in all inertial frames belong to zero interval', and null geodesics stay null under conformal rescaling. - Limit (mathematics): the value a sequence or function approaches, and the practice of approaching, bounding and proving it
One module reused unchanged: the epsilon window. |a_n - L| < epsilon for real sequences becomes d(a, a_n) < epsilon in a metric space and a_n in every neighbourhood U in a topological space; the same shape defines function limits (delta for N), Cauchy sequences (pairs of terms) and uniform convergen - Linguistics (the field: the practice and the languages it studies)
The IPA as a conserved module reused unchanged across all languages and many trades (linguists, lexicographers, teachers, speech-language pathologists, singers, actors, translators); Grambank's one 195-feature questionnaire applied to every language. - Literature
Forms reused across works and centuries: verse lines and sound devices, the novel, the novella's 17,000-40,000 words, genres that set a formalist contract; a 'style of a time' shared by contemporaries. - LLM-based agent
One module swapped and still working: ACE's Generator, Reflector and Curator moved to a new model without changes to the algorithm; AGENTS.md spread between harnesses by imitation. - Local inertial (free-fall) frame
The Lorentz frame recurs in every small free-falling region: 'the general theory reduces to the special theory over sufficiently small regions'. - Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason
A rule of inference is one module valid for any content: modus ponens holds whatever p and q stand for; logic gates implement the same Boolean functions in any circuit. - Lorentz covariance
One transformation rule recurring through every relativistic law: interval, mass, field invariants and the wave operator are scalars; position, momentum, current and potential are four-vectors; the field tensor and metric are four-tensors; 'The Lorentz group expresses the fundamental symmetry ... of - Lorentz group representation
One label (m, n) fixes the rule for every object of that type: every four-momentum, current and potential goes by (1/2, 1/2). - Lorentz scalar
One contraction rule makes every invariant: the interval from the position vector, the rest mass from the four-momentum, c from the four-velocity, F . F from the field tensor, the Ricci scalar from the Riemann tensor. - Lorentzian metric
The Minkowski form recurs as the model of every tangent space. - Lymphatic system
The secondary lymphoid organ is one layout reused: Peyer's patches, tonsils, adenoids and NALT 'exhibit the same basic organization as LNs' (T and B zones, APCs, lymphoid chemokines, HEVs, lymphatics); the same signals build tertiary lymphoid organs in chronically inflamed tissue. - Lyric poetry
fixed forms and meters reused unchanged across poets, centuries and languages: the 14-line sonnet in Italian, Spanish, Portuguese, French, English; the ghazal's couplet rules in Arabic, Persian, Urdu, German; meters that 'arrive in the hands of a poet' with long histories, carrying their meanings wi - Machine
Modules swapped between machines and still working: the involute tooth as a standard gear with constant speed ratio; interchangeable parts from machine tools; standardised electric motors for industry. - Malware
One module reused unchanged: Mirai's released source became the base of dozens of competing variants; crypters ship a stub plus an encrypted blob for any payload; malware grows more standardised, in step with mainstream software engineering. - Management
The same management practices (38 binary practices; the WMS's 18) work when copied: firms spread them from treated plants to their other plants; Taylor's 'one best method' standardised for every worker. - Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
The same leaf (a MOTS) recurs in every quasilocal horizon; each kind adds one condition (theta(n) < 0, L_n theta(l) sign, signature). - Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
The same marginal leaf recurs as the cross-section of dynamical, isolated and trapping horizons: one conserved module, many tubes. - Mass media
One work, many identical copies: 'a single work could make money proportional to the number of copies sold'; print, record pressing and film duplication 'allowed the distribution of books, newspapers and movies at low prices to huge audiences'. - Mathematical logic: the field that studies logic within mathematics (model theory, proof theory, set theory, computability theory) and the formal systems, structures and limit results it works on
One module reused and still working: Cantor's 1891 diagonal argument is reused in Gödel's incompleteness, Tarski's undefinability, Church's and Turing's unsolvability; FOL's metatheory served as the template other logics copied. - Mathematical proof: the practice of showing that a statement follows from axioms and earlier theorems, how it is written, checked (by people and machines) and accepted, and the derivations it works on
The LCF design (a small trusted kernel behind an abstract type of theorems) is reused unchanged across the HOL family (HOL4, HOL Light, HOL Zero) and its descendants; proof methods (induction, contradiction) are templates reused across all fields. - Mathematics (the field: the practice and the structures it studies)
One module reused unchanged across systems: the same mathematical theory serves physics, cryptography, biology and economics (the Lotka-Volterra equations, group theory for the Rubik's Cube, RSA on prime factorization); Wigner's 'unreasonable effectiveness'. - Matrix (mathematics): the rectangular array of numbers and its algebra, determinants and eigenvalues, matrices as linear maps, their history, and their use in physics, graphics and machine learning; the practice and the structure both booked
One module reused unchanged across systems: the matrix multiply unit runs MLPs, CNNs and LSTMs (95% of the TPU workload); one 4 × 4 homogeneous matrix carries translation, rotation, scaling and projection; attention uses the same optimised matrix-multiply code; one notation A = [a_ij] since 1913. - Matter
Every material is built from the same three interchangeable modules: 'all the materials are made of same three components: electrons, protons and neutrons'; the variety is in their organisation, not their parts. Every electron is the same electron in rock, water and a person. - Maximizing null curve (maximizing lightlike geodesic)
The same achronal null module recurs as the edge of every future, every achronal boundary and every Cauchy horizon (Prop. 2.81; Cor. 3.25). - Maxwell's equations (classical electromagnetism as a codified law set)
One conserved form recurs identically: Heaviside's vector form 'has become standard'; unit systems 'yield the same physics'; Heaviside copied the template onto gravity in 1893 (gravitoelectromagnetism, 'confirmed by Gravity Probe B in 2005'). - Mechanical engineering (the field)
The hinged joint is one module reused unchanged: 'The bearings that form the fulcrum of a lever and that allow the wheel and axle and pulleys to rotate are examples of a kinematic pair called a hinged joint'; the sliding joint does the same for inclined plane and wedge; codes and accredited curricul - Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule)
One pattern across eukaryotes ('diverse eukaryotes share a common pattern'); the SC 'shows very little structural variability ... despite some significant protein differences'; RecA's orthologs do the same job in meiosis. - Metabolite pool (small molecules made, carried and turned over in a cell)
The same core module everywhere: the citric-acid-cycle intermediates 'are present in all known organisms', from E. coli to elephants; glycolysis and the cycle were in LUCA and kept because they produce 'their end products highly efficiently and in a minimal number of steps'. - Metaphysics (the branch of philosophy: its practice and the questions about reality it works on)
One module reused unchanged: OBO ontologies reuse relations from the Relations Ontology and sit on a shared upper ontology so independently built domain ontologies work together; ontologies failing the shared principles 'will not work together'. - Metric tensor
One local model recurring at every point: each tangent space of a pseudo-Riemannian manifold 'is a pseudo-Euclidean vector space', and Minkowski space is 'the local model of a Lorentzian manifold'. - Metric tree (real tree, R-tree; walked as an idea)
One four-point test, reused unchanged: Buneman's condition for trees (1974, metric properties of trees) is the delta = 0 case of Gromov's four-point definition of hyperbolicity and the test phylogenetics uses for tree metrics. - Middle English literature
The aa/ax alliterative line is the commonest pattern in both Gawain (1532 of 2010 lines) and Piers (4993 of 7003) by Oakden's counts: one module reused by two unrelated poets. - Mineral
One module swapped and still working: an aluminium tetrahedron takes a silicon tetrahedron's place and 'the tetrahedra form the same structures as do the unsubstituted tetrahedra, but their charge-balancing requirements are different'; more generally 'Chemical substitution will occur between ions of - Minkowski metric (inner product)
One form recurs identically at every point: the metric 'is in coordinates with the same symmetric matrix at every point of M', and every tangent space of a pseudo-Riemannian manifold 'is a pseudo-Euclidean vector space'. - Minkowski spacetime
One module recurs identically at every event: in the presence of gravity 'spacetime is described by a curved 4-dimensional manifold for which the tangent space to any point is a 4-dimensional Minkowski spacetime'; in flat spacetime the metric is 'the same symmetric matrix at every point'. - Mitochondrion
A mitochondrion moved into another cell joins its network and restores respiration in cells without working mtDNA: the module swapped and still working. - Moduli space of Riemann surfaces (moduli space of curves)
Inversion as the identifying move: the torus modular group's tau -> -1/tau, copied by T-duality's R -> alpha'/R ('The analog of S: tau -> -1/tau is to change the basis of the compactification lattice') and by Montonen-Olive duality of the four-dimensional theory read off the (2,0) theory on a torus. - Molecular chaperone
Hsp60/Hsp10 'structurally and functionally nearly identical to GroEL and GroES'; 'the general structure and mechanism are conserved' across the three domains. - Money of account (the unit of account: number applied to exchange)
One ratio set recurring across unrelated mints: L.S.D. 240:12:1 in France and England; 'The Florentine gold florin, the French franc and the electoral rheingulden all became pounds (240 denari) of account'; Roman names surviving as dinar, pound and peso. - Morphology (linguistics): how a language builds its words from smaller meaningful parts (roots, affixes, compounding, inflection and derivation), how languages differ in this, how speakers learn and use it, and the field that studies it
One regular pattern (plural -s, past -ed) is reused unchanged across thousands of stems and works on words never met (two wugs, older replacing elder). - Motor neuron
The motoneuron transcription-factor ensemble is conserved: the fly orthologs of Isl, Lim3, Hb9 and Nkx6 specify motoneuron subtypes as in vertebrates, and 'over-expression of vertebrate Olig2 partially rescues the walking defects of oli-deficient flies': the vertebrate module swapped into a fly stil - Movable type (reusable cast sorts x the alphabet; the European press)
A positive-negative-positive copy chain: a right-reading steel punch strikes a negative copper matrix, which casts 'hundreds, or thousands, of identical sorts', each printing thousands of identical sheets. - Multiply connected universe
One cell, many copies: the cover is tiled by copies of the fundamental domain, and each object shows as 'an infinity of ghost images'. - Muon
The second-generation doublet (nu_muL, mu_L) repeats the first with the same weak isospin and hypercharge; the muon 'behaved like an electron, only with higher mass' and was recognised as 'a simple heavy electron'. - Muon neutrino
The second-generation doublet (nu_muL, mu_L) repeats the first with the same weak isospin and hypercharge and flavour-independent couplings (universality, tested in W decays to 0.9995 +/- 0.0045). - Muscular system
The actomyosin contractile module, from stem eukaryotes, reused unchanged in every myocyte type; striated MyHC already in unicellular relatives. - Museum
One museum model copied across countries and still working: the Louvre's national museum concept spread through Europe; American museums emulated European ones; Japan adopted the word hakubutsukan; ICOM's definition, AAM standards and EN 16893 applied everywhere - Nationalism
'The template of nationalism, as a method for mobilizing public opinion around a new state based on popular sovereignty' passed from Corsica (1755-1768) and the American Revolution to France, and on to postcolonial elites who 'borrow[ed] the rubric of nationalism'; the same module (school, flag, ant - Navier-Stokes equations
One flux law, flux = - coefficient x gradient, recurs for mass (Fick), heat (Fourier) and momentum (Newton's law of viscosity): 'these behaviors are all described by compact expressions, called constitutive relations'. - Neocortex (six-layered isocortex)
One six-layer column circuit repeated across the sheet: about 200 million minicolumns in humans, 'each contains the same types of neurons, connectivity, and firing properties'; columns 'proposed to be the canonical microcircuits for predictive coding, in which ... cognition is implemented through a - Neutrino
'There are three known types (flavors) of neutrinos: electron neutrino, muon neutrino, and tau neutrino, named after their partner leptons'; the same weak doublet recurs in three generations, and 'three light neutrino flavors couple to the Z'. - Neutron
The same neutron is the module reused unchanged in every nucleus past hydrogen-1: the neutron number alone sets the isotope, and in the s process each iron seed takes 'about 15 neutrons', one identical neutron at a time, to build half the heavy elements. - Neutron star crust
The liquid-drop balance of the nucleus (volume and surface attraction against the Coulomb term) recurs at the base of the crust as the pasta sequence: 'the competition between the forces leads to the formation of a variety of complex structures assembled from neutrons and protons'. - Neutron star superfluid interior
Every vortex carries the same circulation quantum and every flux tube the same flux quantum: one conserved module recurring identically. - Newspaper
One module reused unchanged across many papers: an agency's story sold to many subscribers and copied verbatim online (61.8% of articles carry external copy); fixed formats (broadsheet, tabloid, Berliner) and lettered sections. - Newton's law of universal gravitation
One inverse-square form for two forces: 'Newton's law of gravitation resembles Coulomb's law ... Both are inverse-square laws ... Coulomb's law has charge in place of mass and a different constant.' Its point solution reappears in Poisson's equation for electrostatics as Coulomb's law. - No-hair theorem
Whatever collapsed, every settled hole takes one standard form: matter-made and antimatter-made holes with the same three numbers are 'completely indistinguishable'. - Non-uniformly rotating frame
One law in every rotating frame; the uniform frame is the special case with the Euler term zero. - Nonspinning frame (Fermi-Walker)
One transport law recurs: with zero acceleration the Fermi-Walker derivative 'reduces to covariant derivatives' (parallel transport); the nonspinning frame and the nonspinning inertial frame carry the same rule. - Nonverbal communication
A shared gesture module: bonobos and chimpanzees share 88-96% of gesture forms and many meanings, probably from the Pan-Homo ancestor; tickle laughter homologous across great apes and humans - Normal mode
One form across media: a rope, air in a pipe, a building, a cavity's field, an atom's states and the Sun all have 'a set of normal modes and their natural frequencies that depend on its structure, materials and boundary conditions'. - Null curve (lightlike curve)
The same curve survives any conformal rescaling: 'A null geodesic remains a null geodesic under a conformal rescaling'; timelike and spacelike geodesics do not. - Null geodesic
One rule (the null geodesic equation) recurs as the generator of many surfaces: light cones, event horizons, Cauchy horizons, the boundary of any causal future. - Null geodesic congruence (light-ray bundle)
The same kinematic decomposition and focusing law as timelike congruences, re-used for light with a 2-dimensional screen instead of a 3-dimensional rest space: 'these three scalars can be defined for both timelike and null geodesic congruences in an identical spirit'. - Null hypersurface
One structure, many horizons: the degenerate surface ruled by light rays recurs as light cone, event horizon, Killing, Cauchy, non-expanding and isolated horizon (wp; Gourgoulhon-Jaramillo). - Null infinity (I+ and I-)
One universal boundary structure (invariance group BMS) recurs identically in every asymptotically flat spacetime; differences arise only at higher order. - Null world line
The null structure is copied identically into every frame: 'the light cones are the same for all observers at a given spacetime event', while simultaneity is not. - Observable universe
The same light-travel sphere recurs around every location: 'Every location in the universe has its own observable universe'. - Octahedral rotation group (~ S4)
One fixed set of 24 rotations recurs in unrelated carriers: a molecule (SF6), a complex ion ([Co(NH3)6]3+, 'octahedral' to chemists), and a crystal lattice (rock salt, each atom with six octahedral neighbours). - Old English literature
One verse scheme of five types, "any one of the five types can be used in any verse", inherited in "all of the older Germanic languages"; stock formulas reused unchanged in new lines (Hrothgar maþelode / Beowulf maþelode); scenes recur as themes (Beasts of Battle, the Hero on the Beach in twelve Old - Open-source software
Standard licence texts (GPL, MIT, BSD, Apache) are reused unchanged across thousands of projects; the Open Source Definition was itself adapted from the Debian Free Software Guidelines. - Operating system
One module reused unchanged: the System/360 line 'All of them ran the same operating system—OS/360'; POSIX APIs let one program work on many UNIX systems; device drivers swap in per device so the OS works 'without modification over different hardware'. - Optical (null) Raychaudhuri equation
The focusing law recurs with one coefficient changed: 1/(D - 2) for light bundles, 1/(D - 1) for free-fall flows. - Orbital elements
One six-slot template for every Kepler orbit: the same elements fix circle, ellipse, parabola and hyperbola ('The same elements used to describe closed orbits can also typically be used to represent open trajectories'), with slots going singular at the edges (a at e = 1, omega at e = 0, Omega at i = - Painting
an iconographic vocabulary and rule set reused across eight Pecos River murals and about four thousand years; a narrow-fingered stencil variant kept in Sulawesi from at least 67.8 ka to about 17 ka - Parabolic Moebius transformation (null rotation)
The translation of the plane recurs: a parabolic map is conjugate to z -> z + 1 ('a translation in the complex plane'), and the little group of a light-like momentum is isomorphic to E(2), the motions of the Euclidean plane. - Parabolic trajectory
One ratio at every radius: escape speed is sqrt 2 times the circular speed, so the parabola's speed copies the circle's law scaled. - Past light cone (past null cone)
The same cone at every event, kept by every orthochronous Lorentz transformation. - Past null infinity (I-)
'the conformal boundary and its structure are universal features among asymptotically flat space-times': every such spacetime carries the same I- at lowest order. - Patent specification (the enabling disclosure traded for a term-limited right to exclude, and its prior-art and improvement rules)
The 1474 core ('new and ingenious device, not previously made ... useful') recurs: 'the international patent experience of nearly 500 years has merely brought amendments or improvements upon the solid core established in Renaissance Venice'; Australia's Patents Act 1990 still tests 'a manner of manu - Petrov type D
One algebraic form recurs at every event of every isolated-body exterior: 'the Kerr vacuum is everywhere type D'; any spherically symmetric spacetime is type D or O. - Phishing
One kit, a complete phishing site in an easy-to-deploy format, swapped between phishers and brands and still working, configured by changing one line; 4,069 kits behind a year of attacks; playbooks largely unchanged since the mid-2000s; phishing-as-a-service clones login pages through templated infr - Phonetics: the study of speech sounds (how they are made, carried through the air and heard, and how they are recorded and transcribed) together with the speech sounds it studies
One module reused unchanged: the IPA's letter values, made uniform across languages in 1888, so the same 107 letters transcribe any oral language; the same source-filter model describes any voice and drives synthesis and analysis. - Photography
Maxwell's three-colour separation is reused unchanged as 'the foundation of virtually all practical color processes' (Autochrome screens, Kodachrome layers, the Bayer filter array); the negative-positive of Talbot is 'the basis of most modern chemical photography' - Photon-baryon fluid (partnership)
One length stamped everywhere: the sound horizon at freeze-out recurs as the baryon shell (the ~150 Mpc standard ruler today) and as the first acoustic peak angle in the CMB. - Photon-sphere family of quasinormal modes
Geometry dictates the sound: the eikonal formula 'is independent of the field equations and only assumes a stationary, spherically symmetric and asymptotically flat line element'; any such hole with a light ring rings this way. - Photosynthesis
One water-splitting machine, 'the same mechanism across all species', evolved once. - Plato
Two templates: the Forms are 'paradigmatic for the structure' of the sensible world, and the Timaeus' craftsman moulds it 'using simple geometrical patterns and harmonious arithmetic relations as building blocks'; and Stephanus' 1578 pagination, one module reused unchanged by every edition and trans - Poetry
Oral formulae are modules that fit a metrical slot and swap for one another: 'swift footed Achilles' 'is metrically equivalent to' 'glancing-helmed Hector'; formulas combine into type-scenes reused across the epic. - Poincare dodecahedral space
One cell recurring: 'One hundred twenty spherical dodecahedra tile the surface of a hypersphere'. - Poincare group of d-dimensional Minkowski space, IO(1, d-1)
'The Lie algebra retains its form' in every dimension; the same semidirect product as in d = 4. - Poisson's equation
One equation recurring across fields: the gravitational potential (nabla^2 phi = 4 pi G rho), the electrostatic potential (nabla^2 phi = -rho_f/epsilon), steady heat with a source (nabla^2 theta = -Phi/lambda) and the pressure of incompressible flow (Delta p = -rho div(v . grad v)). - Police
One module reused across countries: the Thames River Police 'inspired similar forces in other cities, notably, New York City, Dublin, and Sydney'; the Met 'became a model for the police forces in many countries'; British reforms spread to dominions that 'adopted similar founding principles, structur - Political party
The party model travelled as a module: its spread was accelerated by the 1848 revolutions, the Uganda National Congress took its name from the Indian National Congress, and parties of one ideology reuse colours and symbols across countries (red for socialism, green for green politics). - Polyakov action (projected model: the string worldsheet action)
Weyl invariance as the gate: classically the Polyakov action is Weyl invariant only for strings ('unless n = 1 ... another term breaking Weyl symmetry'); quantum mechanically the same symmetry survives only at D = 26, the bosonic theory's critical-dimension gate. - Positional (place-value) notation with zero
One rule reused unchanged across bases 2, 8, 10, 16, 20 and 60, and across clay, rods, knots and relays. - Positron (antielectron)
'For every lepton flavor, there is a corresponding type of antiparticle, known as an antilepton, that differs from the lepton only in that some of its properties have equal magnitude but opposite sign': the charged-lepton charge slot recurs, sign flipped, in every antilepton. - Precessing orbit
One law, three scales: Mercury (arcseconds per century), binary pulsars (degrees per year), S2 at the Galactic centre (arcminutes per orbit), all consistent with general relativity. - Privacy
Fair information practices named in 1973 reused as the core of the OECD Guidelines, the Council of Europe Convention and the EU Directive; the UK enacted a GDPR identical to the EU's, and several countries modelled laws on it. - Prograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr)
The same restoring well (a potential minimum, a stable radial oscillation) recurs on every circle of the family at every spin; only the edge moves. - Programming language
Front ends for different languages combine with back ends for different CPUs and still work: GCC, Clang (LLVM) and the Amsterdam Compiler Kit 'have multiple front-ends, shared optimizations and multiple back-ends'. - Proper coordinates with a rotating tetrad
One metric form, ds^2 = -[(1 + a.r)^2 - (omega x r)^2] dtau^2 + 2(omega x r) dtau dr + delta dx dx, recurs for every accelerated observer; Fermi coordinates are the copy with omega = 0, Born coordinates the copy with a fixed by circular motion. - Protein
The swap test passes: 'Because they are independently stable, domains can be "swapped" by genetic engineering between one protein and another to make chimeric proteins'; 'a domain may appear in a variety of different proteins'. - Protein domain (and the tertiary fold it builds)
The swap test passes: 'Because they are independently stable, domains can be "swapped" by genetic engineering between one protein and another to make chimeric proteins'; widespread modules (SH2, immunoglobulin, fibronectin type 3, kringle) recur across clotting, complement, matrix and receptor prote - Protein folding (a chain reaching its working shape)
A swapped module that still works: phage T4's gp31 'appears to be structurally and functionally homologous to E. coli chaperone protein GroES and able to substitute for it' with GroEL; and the same chaperonin kind (Group I) in bacteria, chloroplasts and mitochondria. - Proton
The same proton recurs as hydrogen's nucleus and as each of the Z units that set every nucleus's charge and element. - Pseudo-Euclidean space
One flat model recurs at every point of every pseudo-Riemannian manifold (R^{p,q} as each tangent space), as Euclidean space does for Riemannian ones. - Pseudo-Riemannian metric
R^(p,q) recurs as the model of every tangent space, as R^n does for Riemannian and Minkowski space for Lorentzian manifolds. - Psychological (perceptual) arrow of time
Time cells reuse the place-cell module: same theta-phase precession, same field-like firing ('Like place cells ... time cells reliably fire at specific and consistent moments'), offered as 'a unifying physiological mechanism for the representation of both spatial and temporal contexts'. Forward swee - Public opinion
The scientific poll travelled as a module: Jean Stoetzel founded IFOP in Paris in 1938 after meeting Gallup, the first European survey institute, and Gallup opened a UK subsidiary that called the 1945 election; the same sample-and-weight method is used by private firms and governments around the wor - Public speaking (oratory)
The canons and the speech's arrangement (exordium to peroration, now introduction, body, conclusion) reused unchanged across speeches, languages and centuries; Roman orators copied the Greek techniques; the TSST is a standard public-speaking module reused in over a thousand studies. - Public-key cryptography
The same modules are reused unchanged across protocols: RSA and elliptic-curve signatures in TLS, SSH, PGP, S/MIME and Bitcoin; a few standardised Diffie-Hellman groups used by millions of servers. The template's dark side is shown: 'performing precomputation for a single 1024-bit group would allow - Quantum field theory
'each type of particle had its corresponding quantum field': one field per type, so every electron is the same excitation of the same field. - Quantum field theory in curved spacetime (quantum matter on a fixed classical background; walked as a projected model)
'The Unruh temperature has the same form as the Hawking temperature T_H = hbar g / (2 pi c k_B)', with surface gravity in place of acceleration; 'sometimes called the Hawking-Unruh temperature'. - Quantum mechanics
One module reused: the quantum harmonic oscillator of the particle theory is the unit the field theory is built from; the free electromagnetic field was quantized 'by treating the electromagnetic field as a set of quantum harmonic oscillators' (1925-1926). - Quantum spin chain
One conserved module, the O(3) nonlinear sigma model, reused unchanged: integer spin chains 'can be related to the O(3) coupled rotor chain, or non-linear sigma model, and thus to the 2D classical Heisenberg model' (Haldane); large-S chains inherit its 'asymptotic freedom, implying that perturbation - Quark
One generation module (an up-type quark at +2/3 e and a down-type at -1/3 e, paired with two leptons) recurs three times, heavier and less stable each time; 'Each of the first three columns forms a generation of matter'. - Quasar
The relativistic jet recurs at every scale with a disc around a compact object: 'Massive central black holes in galaxies have the most powerful jets, but their structure and behaviours are similar to those of smaller galactic neutron stars and black holes' (microquasars), and in collapsing stars (ga - Radial trajectory
The conic classification copied without eccentricity: radial orbits sort into elliptic, parabolic and hyperbolic by the sign of w (energy), the same three-way split the parent makes by e. - Radio
One module reused across systems: OFDM is used unchanged in Wi-Fi, cellphones, digital television and DAB radio; the superheterodyne became 'the standard broadcast receiver architecture'; ITU band plans and call signs are one template every station fills. - Radioactive decay
One conserved module reused unchanged: every alpha emitter, from uranium-238 to bismuth-212, sends out the same piece, 'identical to the nucleus of a helium-4 atom, which consists of two protons and two neutrons'; the same helium nucleus is what accumulates as helium in rock and gas wells. - Raychaudhuri equation
One evolution law serves timelike and null congruences; only the coefficient (D - 1 vs D - 2) and the projector change. - Real number (the practice of measuring the continuum, and the complete ordered field)
The complete ordered field is unique up to a unique isomorphism, so any construction (cuts, Cauchy classes, decimals, Eudoxus reals) can be swapped in and analysis still works; mathematicians compute with reals without knowing which was used. - Recursion: defining or computing a thing in terms of smaller versions of itself, as computer science and mathematics describe it, with its base cases, call stack, recursive data, induction, and its sightings in language and nature
The same rule reused unchanged at every level of the nest (Martins: the same set of rules for every hierarchical level); the call stack is one module used by every recursive function and every language that supports recursion. - Redox
One module reused unchanged: a couple's standard potential is the same wherever measured, and one theory (Marcus) describes photosynthesis, corrosion, chemiluminescence and solar cells; coelenterazine is the same luciferin in 11 animal phyla, some getting it in their diet; NAD and NADP are the elect - Region reachable below light speed
One cone shape recurs at every speed: 'travel cones ... are just horizontally compressed versions of the light cones', and the delay table is 'very similar for travel at any speeds between 2% and 100% of c'. - Reinsurance
Reused modules: commonly used treaty provisions from industry practice (though 'there are not standard reinsurance contracts'); the cat bond kit (special-purpose reinsurer in Bermuda, Cayman or Ireland, Rule 144A, four cover types, two trigger types) reused for hurricanes, earthquakes, lottery jackp - Relativistic angular momentum
One Noether pattern: momentum conservation from translations, angular momentum from rotations; M supplies 6 and P 4 of the Poincare group's 10 generators. - Relativistic kinematic effect
One factor gamma recurs in every kind: times dilate and lengths contract by it, muon lifetimes stretch by it. - Religion
Canon, from a Greek word for "a cane used as a measuring instrument": "measure, standard, norm, rule"; ritual's restricted code and invariant choreography repeat the same form in every performance. - Renewable energy
One module reused unchanged across scales: the solar cell and panel serve a calculator, a rooftop and a gigawatt plant, aggregated 'with millions of others'; almost all large wind turbines share one three-bladed upwind design. IPCC: modular small units learned faster than large-scale technologies. - Resonance
One formula, omega_r = omega_0 sqrt(1 - 2 zeta^2), for the mass on a spring, the pendulum and the RLC capacitor voltage; the Lorentzian 'universal resonance curve' for lightly damped oscillators and particle resonances alike. - Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr)
The same restoring well (a potential minimum, a stable radial oscillation) recurs on every circle of the family at every spin; only the edge moves. - Ribosome
One core module everywhere: ribosomes of bacteria, archaea and eukaryotes 'share a core structure that reflects a common evolutionary origin'; mitoribosomes 'functionally resemble those in bacteria'; LUCA already translated on ribosomes. - Riemann normal coordinates
One construction (Synge's world function with a tetrad) builds both Riemann coordinates about a point and Fermi coordinates about a world line: x^a = -e^a sigma^alpha in both. - Rindler horizon
The flat Rindler horizon is the template every non-extremal horizon copies locally: 'locally any non-extremal black hole horizon is Rindler. So the Rindler spacetime gives the local properties of black holes and cosmological horizons'; the Unruh temperature has the same form as the Hawking temperatu - Rindler space (the Rindler wedge)
One flat-space shape recurs as the local form of curved horizons: 'locally any non-extremal black hole horizon is Rindler', and hovering observers outside a hole behave as Rindler observers do (acceleration diverging at the edge). - Ritual
One script reused unchanged across performances, places and even churches: formalism, invariance and a restricted code; the Byzantine Rite is used by Eastern Orthodox, Eastern Lutheran and Eastern Catholic churches; the sign of the cross kept since the 4th century. - Roman art
one module reused across works: plaster casts pointed into marble copies; standard sarcophagus subjects personalised by inscription; imperial portrait types sent to provincial basilicas; moulded sigillata and lamps; vermiculatum panels made off site and set in floors - Rotational Born-rigid motion (class B)
Every rotational rigid motion copies one template, the orbit of a one-parameter isometry group; the four Herglotz groups give the four kinds. - Rotational Killing vector field
One construction recurring for every symmetry: 'the metric product between the Killing vector and the geodesic tangent vector' is conserved; for the rotational field it is angular momentum, for the timelike field energy. - Scale factor (cosmology)
One factor stamps every comoving distance alike: r_ij(t) = a(t) r_ij(t0) for every pair. - School
A conserved module reused: 'Compulsory school attendance based on the Prussian model gradually spread to other countries'; 'most schools follow the missionary school model for tutoring, subject/syllabus, and governance, with minor changes'; the Thousand Character Classic used for more than a millenn - Schwarzschild geodesic
One orbit equation (constants E/m, h) for Mercury around the Sun, binary stars (M = m1 + m2) and light (E/m infinite). - Schwarzschild null geodesic
One orbit equation, (du/dphi)^2 = r_s u^3 - u^2 + 1/b^2, recurs for every ray past every spherical mass, scaling with r_s. - Schwarzschild spacetime
Birkhoff: 'the Schwarzschild metric is the most general spherically symmetric vacuum solution', so the same one-parameter exterior recurs around the Sun, Earth and non-rotating black holes. - Science (as a human social and cultural system)
One article form, one significance convention (p < 0.05) and shared reporting guidelines (CONSORT, EQUATOR) recur across journals and fields. - Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest)
The four journal functions set out in 1664-1665 (registration, certification, dissemination, archiving) recur unchanged across the journal population: journals 'nearly universally require peer review'. - Sculpture
a mould or matrix carries one design into many copies (several copies from one matrix; 10 base face forms across thousands of warriors; pointing copies of Greek statues) - Secure software development
One module reused unchanged across many systems: open-source components fill 70-90% of a typical codebase, so one flaw (Log4Shell) or one malicious update (SolarWinds, 18,000+ organisations) is copied into every product that takes it. Thompson's compiler shows the template at its sharpest: a Trojan - Security audit and compliance
The certification cycle is one module reused unchanged: two-stage initial audit, surveillance at least yearly, recertification within three years, used 'like certification to other ISO management system standards'; UN R155's CSMS certificate also runs three years. - Security awareness
One module reused unchanged: the October awareness month adopted by the US (2004), Australia and the EU; the same vendor course bought by many organisations (KnowBe4 at UCSD Health); NIST's programme guidance used by every federal agency. - Security information and event management (SIEM)
Sigma rules: one rule written once in a generic YAML format and converted unchanged into the queries of Splunk, Elasticsearch or QRadar's AQL (RuleGenie converted all 2,347 Sigma rules into AQL); syslog and Windows Event Log as shared formats every product reads. - Security policy and governance
One module reused unchanged across organisations: ISO/IEC 27001's generic requirements 'applicable to all organizations, regardless of type, size or nature' (more than 70,000 certificates in 150 countries); the CSF Core; the '-1' policy control repeated in every SP 800-53 family. - Semantics: meaning in language (the meanings of words and sentences, sense and reference, how meanings combine, how they are held in minds and brains and shared in a community) and the field of linguistics and philosophy that studies it
One conventional sign is reused unchanged by every speaker of a language, and the combining rules are reused for sentences never met before. - Semicubical parabola world line
The stationary template at its boundary point: the cusp sits exactly where the catenary condition (kappa_1 > kappa_2) turns into the rotation condition (kappa_2 > kappa_1). - Separation of powers
Modules copied and still working: Montesquieu's reading of the British constitution (Federalist 47: "what Homer has been to the didactic writers"); the US Constitution as the model for the Spanish American republics ("modeled their constitutions after that of the United States"); Kelsen's constituti - Sequential information (the order of units along a linear polymer)
One chain is the mould for the next ('one biopolymer's sequence is used as a template for the construction of another'); the same four letters, one reading direction and one code reused across nearly all life. - Series (mathematics): sums of infinitely many terms, and the practice of summing, testing and using them
The geometric series as an unchanged module: expanded inside Madhava's proof (the remainder of the geometric expansion neglected) and inside Leibniz's (1/(1+t^2) expanded by the geometric series), and used as the yardstick behind the ratio and root tests; Taylor's general method (1715) as one module - Set theory: the study of sets (collections taken as single objects), membership, Cantor's infinities and the axioms, and the practice of the people and machines who work with them
One module reused unchanged everywhere: structures from graphs to vector spaces are defined as sets with properties, the ordered pair as a set of sets, the function as a set of pairs. The diagonal move is a second reused module: the same construction proves the reals uncountable, proves Cantor's the - Shapiro time delay
Two equal halves (slowed clocks, stretched space) double both the Shapiro factor and the light deflection over the Newtonian value: one template, two observables. - Shell theorem (Newtonian gravity)
One statement for gravity and electrostatics alike, 'any other interaction whose force follows an inverse square law', and again in GR as Birkhoff's theorem. - Short story
One module reused across forms and settings: the same narrative arc (staging falling, plot progression rising, cognitive tension peaking midway) in 2092 short stories, 2523 novels, brief online stories and film dialogue (Boyd 2020); over 2000 tale types 'cross-culturally stable' across 200+ societie - Simple machine
One module reused unchanged: Reuleaux saw that lever, pulley and wheel and axle are 'in essence the same device: a body rotating about a hinge', and inclined plane, wedge and screw a block sliding on a plane; Galileo showed 'the underlying mathematical similarity of the machines as force amplifiers' - Simultaneous hyperplane
The same construction (orthogonal complement of the velocity) recurs for every observer; observers with equal velocity share one hyperplane. - Skeletal system
Segmental units repeated (vertebrae, ribs) under a Hox code conserved across vertebrates, with numbers varied (snakes over 300 vertebrae, lizards 65). - Skin
Scales, feathers and hairs all start from one anatomical placode with the same signals (Shh, β-catenin, Edar, Bmp) - Social engineering
The same module swapped between campaigns and still working: phishing kits and phishing-as-a-service platforms clone login pages and distribute links through templated infrastructure (Darcula impersonated more than 200 organisations in more than 100 countries). - Social structure
Roles and positions: one module (a role with its rights, duties and expectations) filled by one occupant after another and still working; 'A given position may belong to multiple individuals'. - Software
One module reused unchanged across programs: libraries and packages ('less than 17% of all required packages concentrate more than 80% of all reverse dependencies'); in the Linux call graph 'many regulators controlling a small set of generic functions', reuse being software's design principle. - Software engineering
Reusable components in families (McIlroy 1968) and standard process templates reused across teams (SWEBOK, the waterfall phases, Scrum's sprint): the same module swapped between projects and still working. - Software vulnerability
A conserved module reused unchanged across systems carries its flaw with it: OpenSSL's heartbeat code in a quarter to half of popular HTTPS sites and in Bitcoin software; npm packages in a median 30 releases. CVE identifiers are the same template on the record side. - Sorting algorithm
One module reused unchanged: insertion sort sits at the bottom of essentially every optimized quicksort and of Timsort; a library sort is reused by every program; pdqsort was made std::sort-compatible and dropped into Rust and Boost; AlphaDev's sort 3/4/5 are called many times by the larger libc++ s - Spacelike (smooth) Cauchy hypersurface
One slice kind recurs at every level of the foliation: 'each level at constant T, S_T, is a spacelike Cauchy hypersurface', and any two are diffeomorphic. - Spacelike hypersurface
The same slice test (positive-definite induced metric, timelike normal) builds the flat simultaneous hyperplane and the curved Cauchy surface. - Spacetime curve
One template (a one-parameter path with a tangent) recurs as histories, rods and light rays; the type is read off the same tangent test everywhere. - Spacetime event
The same light-cone structure recurs identically at every event: 'all observers must arrive at the same angle of 45 degrees', and the classes 'hold true in any frame of reference'. - Spacetime interval (Lorentz interval)
One invariant number per pair, the same in every inertial frame. - Speed of light
One constant recurring unchanged in every frame and every theory built on spacetime: 'Lorentz invariance is an almost universal assumption for modern physical theories, such as quantum electrodynamics, quantum chromodynamics, the Standard Model ... and general relativity'. - Spherical harmonics
One basis recurs: gravity fields and geoids, electrostatic multipoles, atomic orbitals, planetary and stellar magnetic fields, the CMB. - Spherical orbit (Kerr)
The constant-radius rule R(r) = dR/dr = 0 recurs across the family: at Q = 0 it gives the equatorial circles, at Q -> infinity the photon orbits, at large r the Schwarzschild circles. - Spherical timelike orbit
The prograde / polar / retrograde split by the sign of Phi recurs unchanged in the null limit (photon orbits prograde for r < r0, polar at r0, retrograde beyond). - Spi group
The same module at two infinities: an infinite-dimensional supertranslation family with a preferred 4-parameter translation subgroup whose Noether charge is energy-momentum, at spatial infinity (Spi) and null infinity (BMS). - Spinal cord
The spinal and brainstem motor infrastructure is the same module in lamprey and mammals after about 560 Myr apart: 'the neuronal networks and general motor infrastructure underlying the execution of the basic motor repertoire in the spinal cord, hindbrain and midbrain is organized in a similar way i - Spinor
One spinor structure recurs in every spin-1/2 particle: the electron (Pauli, Dirac) and the neutron (whose 4pi symmetry the interferometer reads). - Standard Model of particle physics
One coupling pattern stamped three times: between generations, particles differ by flavour and mass, 'but their electric and strong interactions are identical'. - Standard static spacetime
The same slice (S, g_S) recurs identically at every t: one conserved module copied along the whole time line. - Star
The kind's thermostat recurs unchanged in each instance; the Sun's core thermostat is the worked copy. - Static patch observer (static observers of other static spacetimes)
'Locally, every static spacetime looks like a standard static spacetime': the same observer family recurs in each static solution. - Static spacetime
The local form R x S with -beta dt^2 + g_S recurs in every static spacetime ('Locally, every static spacetime looks like a standard static spacetime'). - Stationary world line
One template, constant Frenet-Serret curvatures (equivalently a timelike Killing orbit), copied six ways by switching curvatures on and off; every copy is Born rigid. - Statistical mechanics
One model reused unchanged: the Ising/Heisenberg form describes magnets, the retina's ganglion cells and starling flocks; 'this is not an analogy, but a mathematical equivalence' (Bialek et al.). - Steel
Standard grades are interchangeable modules: SAE, ASTM (A36) and JIS grades, and ISO 15510's interchange table for stainless compositions across ISO, ASTM, EN, JIS and GB, so a grade from one maker swaps for another's and still works. In the lattice, martensite inherits its parent's neighbours. - Stellar magnetic field
One scaling, flux conserved as radius shrinks (B ~ R^-2), recurs from progenitor to white dwarf to neutron star. - Stellar remnant (compact star)
The same remnant shape recurs with one step changed: 'Like electrons, neutrons are fermions. They therefore provide neutron degeneracy pressure', and 'like the Chandrasekhar limit for white dwarfs, there is a limiting mass for neutron stars'. - Story (narrative)
Tale types and the narrative arc are reused across stories and cultures: over 2000 cross-culturally stable tale types; one arc (staging, plot progression, cognitive tension) across ~40,000 narratives; six core emotional arcs. - Strange quark
The second generation repeats the first: the s quark is the down-type member (charge -1/3, like d) of the doublet whose up-type partner is charm, and the weak force sees the rotated mixture d' = cos(theta_c) d + sin(theta_c) s; 'Along with the charm quark, it is part of the second generation of matt - SU(3) colour gauge group
'SU(3) has eight generators, corresponding to the eight gluons': the algebra's eight generators recur as the eight gauge fields. - Sun
The kind's thermostat (less energy lets the overlying mass compress the core and raise the fusion rate) recurs unchanged in the Sun's core. - Superconductivity
Landau's 1933 free-energy expansion, made for a wrong theory of superconductivity, became the template reused for water's critical point, liquid crystals, magnets and cosmic inflation; BCS seeded the Anderson-Higgs reading used to predict the Higgs boson - Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter)
Every vortex carries the same quantum of flux, h/(2e), in any superconductor, and the neutron-star walk's proton flux tubes carry the same kind of quantum (Phi0 = hc/|q|). - Supermassive black hole
The tidal radius is the Roche condition again: the tidal force exceeds the star's self-gravity, as the black-hole walk notes ('the same condition as the Roche limit'); the supermassive hole moves the condition outside its horizon for solar-type stars, so the tearing becomes visible. - Superstring theory (projected model; supersymmetric string theory)
The critical-dimension gate recurs from the bosonic string ('a general feature of all string theories'): 10 here, 26 there. - Supertranslation
Infinite supertranslations with a preferred 4-translation subgroup recur at null infinity (BMS) and spatial infinity (Spi). - Supply and demand
The same module is reused across markets unchanged: the wage as price in labour markets, the interest rate in the money market; and borrowed by biochemists as supply and demand blocks with 'elasticity coefficients' defined, as in economics, by ratios of relative changes. - Synge's world function
One construction (the world function with a tetrad) builds Riemann coordinates about a point and Fermi coordinates about a world line: x^a = -e^a sigma^alpha in both. - Syntax: how a language combines words into phrases and sentences (constituency and dependency, word order, agreement, recursion), how speakers build and parse it, how children learn it, how it differs across languages, and the field that studies it
One binding operation (merge) is applied again and again: two words into a phrase, the phrase with the next element, up to the sentence. - T-duality (target-space duality; projected model)
The inversion move recurs: the torus modulus tau -> -1/tau (moduli space of the torus), the radius R -> alpha'/R (T-duality; Ooguri-Yin: 'The analog of S: tau -> -1/tau is to change the basis of the compactification lattice'), and the Montonen-Olive tau -> -1/tau of the four-dimensional theory got f - Tachyon (string mode with imaginary mass; projected model)
Imaginary mass at a potential maximum, resolved by condensation: the string tachyon and the Higgs field ('Higgs field in the standard model at H = 0 is also a tachyon'); also ferromagnetism and BCS in the condensation article. - Tangent bundle
The same fibre recurs over every point: 'Each tangent space of an n-dimensional manifold is an n-dimensional vector space', glued into one bundle. - Tau lepton (tauon)
The third-generation doublet (nu_tauL, tau_L) repeats the first two with the same weak isospin and hypercharge; universality tested in W decays (R_W tau/mu 0.992 +/- 0.013) and in the tau/muon lifetime ratio. - Tau neutrino
The third-generation doublet (nu_tauL, tau_L) repeats the first two; universality holds to 0.992 +/- 0.013 in W decays. - Tax
The VAT as a module copied whole: first run in Ivory Coast in 1954, brought home to France, now in 175 of 193 UN members, all but Japan on the same invoice method; the OECD's numbered classification read the same way across countries. - Telephone
One module reused unchanged: the 64 kbit/s G.711 channel; E.164 numbers in one global address space so any telephone, whatever its technology, reaches any other; the GSM standard (6,000 pages at first) used by over 5 billion people; DTMF tones standardised in ITU-T Q.23; the SIM moved between handse - Television
Compatible colour: the colour signal was built so black-and-white sets could take the same transmission; the composite video format is the same module used by VCRs and CCTV cameras. - Theatre
Conserved modules reused across productions and centuries: Aristotle's six parts, the Natya Shastra's rules, stock characters (nayaka, vidusaka; commedia's masks), one mask for the whole chorus, Stanislavski's concepts used 'without knowing they do so'. - Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
One spectrum for every body: Planck's law depends only on temperature, so 'The blackbody temperature uniquely characterizes the intensity of the radiation at all wavelengths' for the CMB as for a hot metal or a star. - Thirteen Colonies
A module copied: South Carolina's 1696 slave code modelled on Barbados's 1661 code; Plymouth and Massachusetts Bay spawning other Puritan colonies; similar legal systems across thirteen separately run colonies. - Thorne-Hartle-Zhang coordinates
The FNC metric recurs here with one change: the same g_tt and g_ta, a diagonalised g_ab; and the same diagonal form recurs around every world line in vacuum, only a_a, E_ab and B_ab change. - Threat actor
One ransomware kit licensed unchanged to many affiliates, who 'purchase pre-developed ransomware tools'; booters and MaaS sell the same attack to anyone; ATT&CK describes behaviour as reusable techniques (96 at release). - Three-dimensional Euclidean space
One local module everywhere: every 3-manifold 'looks locally' like 3D space (each point of the 3-sphere has a neighbourhood homeomorphic to an open subset of it), and every flat universe's space is locally E3. - Three-torus universe
One cube repeated: 'All of the cubes in the image are the same cube, since light in the manifold wraps around'. - Thurston geometries
Homogeneity: each model looks the same at every point (transitive group action), the template every compact quotient copies. - Time orientation
The same two-class split recurs at every event and is carried continuously over the manifold. - Timelike Killing vector field
The conserved product of a Killing vector with a geodesic tangent recurs: energy from the timelike field, angular momentum from the rotational one. - Timelike separation (timelike interval)
Every observer orders every timelike pair the same way. - Tokamak
One cross-section reused unchanged across machines: JET chose the D-shape, Doublet III was redesigned into D-IIID, JT-60 took it, 'largely universal since then'. The ITER-like beryllium/tungsten wall was installed in JET to test ITER's module first. - Tool
Machine tools constrain the workpiece and guide the toolpath, are built against master flats, and made interchangeable parts economical: one module made to fit unchanged across many machines ("With these machine tools the decades-old objective of producing interchangeable parts was finally realized" - Top quark
Harari named top and bottom 'to match the names of the first generation of quarks (up and down), reflecting the fact that the two were the up and down component of a weak isospin doublet': the same doublet recurs in the third generation, predicted by Kobayashi and Maskawa in 1973. - Translations in time (R)
Time and space translations are the same abelian shift structure, one per dimension ('four degrees, one per dimension'); each yields one conserved charge kind (energy; momentum). - Transverse mass of a moving body (Lorentz, Einstein)
The same factor gamma = 1/sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2) recurs in transverse mass, relativistic mass and time dilation. - TRAPPIST-1 system
The Laplace relation p/P1 - (p+q)/P2 + q/P3 = 0 is one module reused unchanged across scales (moons, sub-Neptunes, Earths), with only (p, q) set differently; disc-driven migration into it was 'first studied in the context of the Galilean moons around Jupiter'. - Trigonometry (the practice of tying angles to lengths, and the structure it works on)
One module, the sine and cosine of an angle, is carried unchanged into other systems and still works there: Fourier series write any periodic function as a sum of them; wave models of sound and light use them; a language model's addition rotates them; a doctor's needle angle reads them off the same - Turing machine: the abstract machine that reads and writes one symbol at a time on an unbounded tape by a finite table of rules, the model of computation of logic and computer science
One description format reused unchanged for every machine (the standard description; the 5-tuple convention) and one machine reused across models: counter, register and random-access machines are 'basically all just multi-tape Turing machines with an arithmetic-like instruction set'. In Shapiro's mo - Two-sphere S^2 (the ordinary sphere)
Constant curvature 1/r^2 and every point an umbilic: one local geometry at every point. - Type I superstring theory (projected model)
The Green-Schwarz anomaly gate recurs in all three N = 1 theories (type I, heterotic SO(32), heterotic E8 x E8). - Unemployment
The ILO definition is a module swapped into national statistical systems and still working: the US CPS and Eurostat apply it, so counts interoperate; the 2013 and 2023 resolutions add the LU1-LU4 modules on the same base. - Unified interaction (fundamental forces merged into one at high energy)
'The electroweak theory became a template for further attempts at unifying forces'; the Georgi-Glashow GUT (1974) followed with the same plan, a larger group broken by a Higgs mechanism. - Uniform circular motion world line
Six stationary motions share one template, constant Frenet-Serret curvatures; uniform rotation is the member with kappa_2^2 > kappa_1^2 and kappa_3 = 0 (as booked on sys:hyperbolic-world-line). - Uniform translation (inertial straight world line)
Six stationary motions share one template, constant Frenet-Serret curvatures; uniform translation is the member with all three zero (as booked on sys:hyperbolic-world-line). - Universal (double) cover of the Poincare group, R^{1,3} x| SL(2, C)
The same semidirect pattern (translations x| homogeneous group) recurs with the homogeneous part swapped for its double cover; the Euclidean group has the same build. - Unruh effect (Fulling-Davies-Unruh effect)
One temperature law for horizons: Unruh T = hbar a / (2 pi c k_B) and Hawking T = hbar g / (2 pi c k_B), with the surface gravity in place of the acceleration ('the Hawking-Unruh temperature'). - Up quark
One fixed module reused unchanged: the same up quark (charge +2/3 e, colour, spin 1/2) sits in the proton (twice), the neutron, the pi+ and the Deltas, and their charges are sums of its fixed charge. - Upsilon meson (bottomonium)
One level scheme stamped on every heavy pair: the bottomonium table (eta_b, Upsilon, h_b, chi_b0,1,2 in 1S, 1P, 2S, ...) lines up term by term with charmonium's (eta_c, J/psi, h_c, chi_c0,1,2). - Vector calculus (the calculus of fields: gradient, divergence, curl; the practice and the structures it works on)
Heaviside's four-equation vector form became the template of electromagnetism ('has become standard') and Gibbs and Wilson's 1901 book fixed most of the notation and terms; the same del with dot, cross and nothing is copied across physics. - Vector space: sets whose elements can be added and scaled, as mathematics describes it, with bases and dimension, linear maps, inner products, and their use as the state spaces of physics and data
One module, the eight axioms, reused unchanged on arrows, tuples, functions, polynomials, wavefunctions and word vectors; every n-dimensional space over F is the same as F^n. - Velocity time dilation
One factor gamma(v) recurs in every clock build: light clocks, muon decay, canal-ray Doppler frequencies, caesium and optical clocks. - Vertebrate (Vertebrata)
Single-copy invertebrate SoxE (amphioxus, Drosophila) and amphioxus Tfap2a can induce or rescue vertebrate neural crest: interchangeable parts across phyla. - Vertebrate brain
One circuit template stamped out repeatedly: "most vertebrate species have a cerebellum and one or more cerebellum-like structures" (lateral-line nucleus, electrosensory nucleus, the tectal marginal layer in ray-finned fishes), each with granule cells, parallel fibres and Purkinje-like cells with mo - Voting
The same majority/threshold module is swapped between brains and insect colonies and still works: separate populations accumulate evidence to a threshold, with cross inhibition (stop signals) as in neurons. - Vulnerability management
CVE IDs (public since 1999) and CVSS (2005) are one shared format that scanners, feeds, EPSS, KEV and mandates (PCI above 4.0) all plug into. - W boson
The charged-current vertex recurs identically in each lepton generation: the leptonic branching ratios are approximately B(e nu) = B(mu nu) = B(tau nu) = 1/9 (measured 10.80 +/- 0.09% per flavour). - Wave equation (massless scalar field)
One equation recurs in unrelated media: sound and seismic waves in matter, light in empty space; only the speed c changes (c = sqrt(E/rho) in an elastic medium). - Wave vector
The space part of every four-wavevector: the same K = (omega/c, k) recurs for every wave. - Wave-particle duality
one relation (lambda = h/p) and one interferometer design (Talbot-Lau) reused unchanged from C70 to a polypeptide; matter waves from electrons to 25 kDa molecules - Weak field
The charged-current vertex recurs identically per lepton generation: W leptonic branching ratios are approximately B(e nu) = B(mu nu) = B(tau nu) = 1/9. - Weakly deflected light ray
One formula, 4GM/(c^2 b), bends light at the Sun, at a white dwarf (Stein 2051 B) and at galaxies (ESO 325-G004): the same weak-field ray recurs at every deflector. - Weakly isolated horizon
The Kerr horizon's mass formula recurs: the WIH horizon mass, derived from a Hamiltonian framework on the horizon alone, has 'the same' dependence on area and angular momentum 'as that in the Kerr space-time', and the zeroth law of Killing horizons (constant surface gravity) recurs without any space - Weyl tensor (Weyl curvature tensor)
The Riemann symmetries recur unchanged in the Weyl tensor ('the same symmetries as the Riemann tensor'), with one added condition (trace-free). - William Shakespeare
One module reused across playwrights: the blank verse line (about 8 words) is an underlying unit in speech length across the era; Latin taught on a text standardised by royal decree; blank verse his standard form. - Wireless network
Modules reused unchanged across systems: 48-bit MAC addresses and IEEE 802.2 shared with Ethernet so frames bridge between them; ALOHA random access reused in Ethernet, Wi-Fi and mobile phones; OFDM and the 4G/5G coding and modulation adopted in 802.11ax; Wi-Fi Alliance certification so any certifie - Word: the unit of a language's lexicon (spoken, signed or written) as linguists describe it, and as it is held, learned and retrieved in each speaker's mental lexicon
A word is a module reused unchanged across sentences and moved between languages where it still works: typhoon (from Chinese, 1588), origami (Japanese, 1880), robot (Czech, 1921). - World line
Every timelike world line carries the same local frame: 'Any timelike curve admits a comoving observer ... we can always find a local coordinate system in which lightcones are inclined at 45 degrees'. - World population (human population)
One module reused unchanged: the cohort-component method (age and sex broken down) has carried every global projection since Notestein's in 1945, by the UN (21 sets 1951–2008), the World Bank, IIASA–Wittgenstein and IHME; the demographic transition model is likewise applied country after country. - World tube
Whatever is inside the tube, the motion is the same: the MiSaTaQuWa equations 'apply to any sufficiently compact body of arbitrary internal structure'. - World tube of a small compact body
One module, the point-mass law of motion, recurs for every compact body whatever its interior: 'the MiSaTaQuWa equations apply to any sufficiently compact body of arbitrary internal structure'. - Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
One sign inventory re-used language to language: Sumerian cuneiform written for Akkadian, then Hittite, Elamite, Hurrian, Luwian, Urartian; Sumerograms kept their logographic value with a new reading (UDU 'sheep' read immerum in Akkadian). - Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules)
The casuistic form recurs code to code in four languages: Sumerian tukun-be 'if' (Lipit-Ishtar), Akkadian summa (Hammurabi; Eshnunna's 'summa awilum - If a man...' in 23 paragraphs), Hittite case laws ('If anyone tears off the ear ... 3 shekels'), and Exodus 21 (the goring ox, Hammurabi 250-252 and - Yang-Mills theory
'a generic term for the class of similar theories': the same Lagrangian -1/4 F^2 recurs for any compact Lie group, as the colour field and the electroweak fields. - Z boson
The neutrino doublet recurs identically per generation, and the Z counts the copies: its invisible width gives 2.9840 +/- 0.0082 light neutrino species, in agreement with the three observed flavours.
Partial: part of the shape (318)
- Accelerating observer (non-inertial frame; Rindler frame)
The near-horizon region of every non-extremal black hole is the same Rindler geometry: one module recurring at every horizon ('locally any non-extremal black hole horizon is Rindler'). - ADM mass
Gauss's law reused: the enclosed charge read as a flux through a far surface becomes the enclosed mass-energy read as a flux of the metric's fall-off ('similar to the way that Gauss's law defines the charge enclosed'). - AdS x S product spacetimes
The quasi-sphere geometry reused twice in one background: an AdS factor and a sphere factor, the two signs of one construction, joined in a product. - AdS3 (three-dimensional anti-de Sitter space)
One slice copied along time: every cross section of the cylinder is the same hyperbolic disk. - Advocacy group (interest group)
The tobacco playbook as a module: 'the same political practices are used by gambling, alcohol, and UPF industries'; global groups reuse one structure in over 30 countries. Whether the swapped module 'still works' is not measured in the sources read. - Affine connection
One idea, two physical uses: the connection on the tangent bundle (gravity's free fall) and, through Weyl, the gauge covariant derivative of gauge theory ('the ideas of Weyl were taken up by physicists in the form of gauge theory'). - Air pollution
One chemical module reused across places and eras: aqueous oxidation of SO2 by NO2 made sulfate in the 1952 London Fog (in cloud) and in Chinese haze (on wet particles), "widespread" across polluted environments. - Air shower (extensive air shower; secondary cosmic rays)
Showers share a universal shape: the shower age parameter s is 'introduced to compare showers with different starting depths and different primary energies to highlight their universal features, as for example at the shower maximum s = 1'; the same Gaisser-Hillas and NKG functions fit them all. - Algebraic (local) quantum field theory in curved spacetime (walked as a projected model)
One functor, the same local construction recurring in every spacetime; the flat Haag-Kastler net is one copy. - Alpha particle (helium-4 nucleus)
Alphas are the same whatever their source (Rutherford 1906), and the alpha is the repeated module of the alpha ladder: alpha elements' most abundant isotopes are integer multiples of four. - Ammonia
'Like water, liquid ammonia undergoes molecular autoionisation': 2 NH3 <-> NH4+ + NH2- (K = 1e-30) repeats water's 2 H2O <-> H3O+ + OH- (Kw = 1e-14), the same proton hand-off module on a different hydride. - Amygdala
one basic plan (pallial plus subpallial parts, ventrolateral caudal telencephalon, hypothalamic projections) reused across tetrapods: 'This basic plan is shared by reptiles, birds, and also by anuran amphibians' - Ancient Rome
One module copied and still working elsewhere: Rome's aqueduct model was emulated by cities across the Empire; Roman law, rediscovered in Bologna, became the basis of continental European legal practice. - Animal (kingdom Animalia, Metazoa)
6,331 gene groups shared by all living animals, from one ancestor about 650 Mya; opsins and TRP channels reused across phyla. - Anthropocene
The GSSP ('golden spike') template is reused for every boundary; the Anthropocene base was fitted to it ('much like the moment of asteroid impact at the end of the Cretaceous nominally marks the onset of the Cenozoic'). Whether the template fits a 70-year record is contested. - Bacteriophage
Capsids converge on one geometry: 'a regular icosahedron is the optimum way of forming a closed shell from identical subunits', and the jelly-roll capsid fold is shared by RNA and DNA viruses across all three domains. - Baum-Frampton cyclic model (phantom energy; the universe comes back empty)
Each of the 1/f^3 patches contracts 'as a separate universe', a copy of the same construction. - Belinfante-Rosenfeld stress-energy tensor
The bound-current template recurs: the added term 'is an analogue of the J_bound = curl M bound current associated with a magnetization density'; bound plus free sources the magnetic field, bound plus free energy-momentum sources gravity. - BFSS matrix model (projected model: M-theory as matrix quantum mechanics)
Coordinates replaced by finite matrices: BFSS's nine N x N matrices and the fuzzy sphere's 'finite matrix algebras' in noncommutative geometry. - Bianchi identities
The second identity D Omega = 0 'is valid more generally for any connection in a principal bundle': one identity for the Riemann curvature of spacetime and for every bundle curvature. - Bird song culture
Song modules swapped across species still work: a linnet learned a skylark's song (encyclopedia); chaffinches raised by canaries sing canary elements (in chaffinch timing) - Bonobo (Pan paniscus)
Genomes swapped between Pan species still work: bonobo-chimpanzee hybrids born in captivity, and ancient gene flow from bonobos into chimpanzee ancestors (less than 1% of central chimpanzee genomes) - Bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops)
One module reused unchanged: a whistle contour copied to address its owner; the sponging technique copied down a matriline; tail-walking copied across generations from one female - Brand
One brand template swapped onto many products and still working: the Virgin logo across airlines, balloons, telecoms and healthcare; Arm & Hammer across baking-soda products; licensed marks made by third parties. - Bumblebee (Bombus)
One generic associative mechanism serves both social and asocial learning, and is common to social and solitary species - Bumblebee colony
Farnesol is used as a pheromone by several bee lineages (honeybees, mining bees, bumblebees). - Business continuity
One management-system standard (ISO 22301) meant for any organisation regardless of type and size, and one plan structure reused across hospitals, mines, governments and micro-enterprises; whether it still works when swapped is shown only as milder perceived impact with a BCP. - Calculus (the practice of handling change and accumulation by limits, and the structures it works on)
The derivative and the integral are one module carried unchanged into physics, engineering, economics, biology and medicine ('used in every branch of the physical sciences ...'), and integral feedback is one controller found in engineering and in a bacterium (Yi et al. 2000). Booked partial: the sou - Canonical (Noether) stress-energy tensor
One recipe, T = dL/d(d phi) d phi - delta L, is stamped onto every translation-invariant field theory. - Capuchin monkey (Cebus and Sapajus)
One module, hammer on nut on anvil, reused unchanged across nuts, crabs, shellfish, cashews and seeds and across populations from Brazil to Panama - Carbon bonding (tetravalence and catenation)
Functional groups: 'The same functional group will undergo the same or similar chemical reactions regardless of the rest of the molecule's composition'; the same amine and carboxyl groups recur in amino acids and nitrogen chemistry. - Causal dynamical triangulation (CDT; walked as a projected model)
One fixed interface rule (agreeing time arrows at every joint) makes identical flat units fit into a causal spacetime; without it earlier triangulations gave jumbled universes. - Causal relation (the kind)
One generator, its closure: the causal relation is 'the smallest transitive extension of the horismos relation'; the horismos is generated by null geodesic congruences. - Cell membrane
A module reused unchanged: polar head groups 'globally shared in the three domains of life'; the positive-inside rule in membrane proteins of every genome studied (M. jannaschii possibly excepted); the same bilayer in plasma and organelle membranes. - Chandrasekhar-Ferrari colliding plane wave vacuum
One Ernst function, two worlds: the simplest linear one gives Kerr in the stationary axisymmetric case and Nutku-Halil here. - Chaos and nonlinear dynamics (the practice, and the chaotic behaviour it studies)
Universality: the same period-doubling cascade and constants in dripping faucets, populations, convection and paced heart cells; one module (the shape of a map with a single hump) reused across unrelated systems. Ubiquity booked as the finding; its forms vary (period doubling, period tripling with d - Chemical bond
Typical bond lengths and energies: a C-H bond is about 109 pm and 413 kJ/mol across organic molecules; the peptide bond links every amino acid along every protein chain. Tabulated as typical values, so the module is near-template rather than unchanged. - Chirality
Life fixed one convention out of two: L amino acids and D sugars throughout, and 'organisms that consume a chiral compound usually can metabolize only one of its enantiomers'. - Chordate (Chordata)
Lancelets, tunicates and vertebrates 'may share some elements of a common molecular framework for the generic specification of motoneurons', elaborated in vertebrates into more subtypes, while tunicates make 'only a handful of MNs' and may no longer need hedgehog for them (src:fritzsch-glover-2024-c - Christoffel symbols
One formula from any metric: the symbols follow from requiring the metric's covariant derivative to vanish, the same construction as the Levi-Civita connection's. - Chromatin
One conserved unit everywhere: histones 'among the most highly conserved proteins in eukaryotes', binding DNA 'non-specifically'; and modified histones 'may act as templates' for the new histones around them. - Chronological future of S relative to T, I+[S;T]
The same restricted-future probe I+(q, U) recurs in every neighbourhood of every edge point (Minguzzi Def. 2.130): one module, copied at each point tested. - Classical mechanics (Newtonian mechanics: bodies, forces and motion, and the practice of describing them)
One module reused unchanged: any force law (gravitation, Hooke, friction) is substituted into the same second law to give an equation of motion, and the same laws run from protein atoms in femtosecond steps to planets over 100 Myr. Booked partial: the second law is the slot all force laws fit, but ' - CNO cycle (carbon-nitrogen-oxygen cycle)
'There are various alternative paths and catalysts involved in the CNO cycles, but all these cycles have the same net result': one ring shape (capture, capture, decay, capture, capture, decay, close) recurs in CNO-I to IV, in the hot cycles, and in the neon-sodium and magnesium-aluminium cycles. - Compact extra dimensions
The same standing-wave ladder recurs in another compactified direction: compactifying Euclidean time in thermal field theory 'leads to the Matsubara frequencies and thus to a discretized thermal energy spectrum', as a compact space dimension gives the Kaluza-Klein tower. - Compactified complexified Minkowski space
One complex space, three real copies: the compactifications of E4, E3,1 and E2,2 occur as real four-dimensional slices, each with its own real conformal group (Spin(5,1), Spin(4,2), Spin(3,3)) inside one SL(4,C). - Competition for cloud gas (competitive accretion and stellar feedback)
One instability recurs down three scales: gas-layer gravitational instability assembles clouds ('Those regions with more gas will exert a greater gravitational force on their neighboring regions'), the cloud collapses, and 'breaks into smaller and smaller pieces in a hierarchical manner, until the f - Competition for the electrons that hold a degenerate core up
The contest repeats one level down: after electron degeneracy fails, 'neutron degeneracy pressure tries to halt the collapse', and it too has a ceiling ('If the core mass is more than about 15 solar masses then neutron degeneracy is insufficient'). - Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity)
The same law twice: 'the Hubble parameter is also thought to be constant [during inflation], so the expansion law of the dark energy-dominated era also holds for the inflationary prequel of the big bang'. The early contest (sys:competition-inflationary-dilution) and this one end in the same exponent - Competition: inflationary dilution
The same contest twice: an energy density that stays constant (inflaton false vacuum 'much like a cosmological constant'; later dark energy) takes over from components that thin with volume; the dark-energy walk's contest ends in the same exponential expansion. - Complex network (scale-free growth, preferential attachment, small worlds; walked as an idea)
One statistic across systems: 'independent of the system and the identity of its constituents' P(k) is a power law (BA); metabolism 'identical for all living organisms ... a common blueprint' (Jeong). - Complexified Minkowski spacetime
The Minkowski module recurs unchanged as the real part, and its symmetry is copied over: 'The usual Lorentz group representation on Minkowski space is linearly extended to M_c.' - Computer ethics
One module reused: the Belmont Report's three principles (1979, biomedical research) restated for ICT research by the Menlo Report (2012) with a fourth added; medicine's four principles reappear in AI guidelines (HLEG: autonomy, prevention of harm, fairness, explicability). The module is adapted, no - Computer memory
One cell design tiled across billions of cells; words of fixed length (1 to 128 bits); the page as 'the unit of storage and transfer' since Atlas; refresh within 64 ms 'as defined by the JEDEC standard', so modules from any maker work in any standard system (no source here tests a swap directly). - Computer science (the field: the practice and the computation it studies)
The same three control structures (sequence, selection, repetition) are reused unchanged across languages; the brain's code network even tells 'for' from 'if'. The universal machine runs any standard description. - Computer security
Shared, reusable modules across organisations: CVE identifiers for flaws; the CIA triad (1977); the CSF's six Functions used as a common language. - Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical)
Every aeon is the same construction (an open FLRW spacetime from Big Bang to infinite expansion), repeated through a countable sequence. - Conformal group of spacetime C(1,3)
The Lorentz algebra recurs one step up: conf(p,q) ~ so(p+1,q+1), the Lorentz algebra with one more space and one more time dimension. - Consciousness
One system for every content: emotional and perceptual experience 'regardless of their content, arise from one system' (LeDoux and Brown); and across life one response to anaesthetics 'within a relatively narrow 10-fold' range, from bacteria to people (Kelz and Mashour). - Contracted Bianchi identities
One identity in three dresses: the Ricci form, the Einstein-tensor form, and the conservation law it forces, each booked by a different walk. - Core of the trapped region (Z)
Clairvoyance carries over: 'trapped regions and their cores are global concepts, and in that sense they share the teleological and/or clairvoyant properties of EH and of trapped surfaces'. - Cosmic dust
Stardust keeps its maker's 'extreme isotopic compositions' unchanged across billions of years, so 'the source stars can be identified' (s-process SiC from AGB stars, 44Ca from live 44Ti in supernova grains): the grain carries a fixed copy of one star's nucleosynthesis. - Cosmic microwave background
The same pattern recurs in a second channel: the E-mode polarisation 'supplements the temperature data as they are correlated'. - Cosmic neutrino background
Decoupling by dilution recurs: here annihilation reactions stopped 'because expansion left the neutrinos too far apart'; in the photon-baryon fluid the expansion lowers the scattering rate until it equals the expansion rate. Same module, two carriers, two times. - Cosmological horizon
One room recurs for every messenger: a decoupling (the messenger stops interacting) and then free streaming sets a practical horizon. Photons at last scattering, neutrinos at one second, gravitational waves at the Planck scale; the same boundary built three times at three depths. - Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical)
The variation-selection-retention algorithm recurs on a cosmological substrate: the theory 'contains the evolutionary ideas of reproduction and mutation of universes, and so is formally analogous to models of population biology'. - Cotangent bundle
Locally trivial: the same fibre over every point, so the symplectic form 'need only be checked on R^n x R^n'. - Cotangent space
The same vector space recurs at every point of a connected manifold: 'All cotangent spaces at points on a connected manifold have the same dimension, equal to the dimension of the manifold'. - Covariant derivative
One operator recurs on the tangent bundle (general relativity) and on the bundles of gauge theory: 'The covariant derivative generalizes straightforwardly to a notion of differentiation associated to a connection on a vector bundle'. - Crystal
A seed crystal templates one larger single crystal, and a parent crystal's splinters seed more of its own structure: one module copied on unchanged. - Culture
One shared format copied across members: every male in a population sings the current song type; social learning reuses ancient associative learning across species - Cyber threat intelligence
STIX objects and ATT&CK techniques are one module carried between vendors and tools; ontologies stay 'non-interoperable', so swaps do not always work. - Cyclic model (Steinhardt-Turok, periodic brane collisions; hypothetical)
The same cycle repeats identically ('the cycles can continue indefinitely into the past and the future'), each one a copy of the last on an attractor. - Dance
Codified forms reused across places: all Indian classical dances share the Natyashastra's mudras and positions; the World Dance Council's standard dances; a score restages Petipa's ballets outside Russia. - Database
SQL as the shared module: an ANSI and ISO standard 'supported (with varying degrees of conformance) by all mainstream commercial relational DBMSs'; ODBC as a database-independent API. But 'A database built with one DBMS is not portable to another DBMS', so the swap only partly works. - Desert ant (Cataglyphis)
The sky-compass pathway to the central complex is a highly conserved module, the same in locust, bee, dung beetle, monarch butterfly and the ant - Diffeomorphism group with an L2 (weak) metric
General covariance: one form of each law in every coordinate system ('takes the same mathematical form in all coordinate systems'), written with tensor fields. - Dijkgraaf-Witten model (topological gauge theory with a finite gauge group; walked as an idea)
The toric code is the simplest quantum double; the same (G, alpha) recipe runs from Z2 to D4 and across dimensions. - Dilaton (projected model; hypothetical scalar)
One scalar in the same role across theories: Kaluza-Klein radion, Brans-Dicke scalar, string dilaton; 'the dilaton in type IIA string theory parallels the radion of M-theory compactified over a circle'. - Discrete symmetry
The same discrete group pattern labels components at two levels: {1, P, T, PT} picks the Lorentz group's four pieces, and the reflection coset picks the Euclidean group's two. - Domestic dog (Canis familiaris)
The same locus does the same job in two species: structural variants in GTF2I and GTF2IRD1, the genes behind hypersocial behaviour in human Williams-Beuren syndrome, contribute to extreme sociability in dogs - Down quark
To the strong interaction a d and a u are interchangeable modules ('gives the same result when an up quark and an otherwise identical down quark are swapped'): nucleons and the four Deltas (uuu to ddd) are the same build with modules swapped, at nearly the same mass (~1232 MeV for the Deltas). - Drainage basin (watershed)
One branching module reused at every scale: Optimal Channel Networks are 'statistically indistinguishable from real-life river networks', subbasins repeat the statistics of the whole (self-affine, 'statistically similar fluvial landforms across scales'), and Horton's and Hack's laws hold across basi - Dual graviton (hypothetical)
The electric-magnetic duality of Maxwell theory (E -> B, B -> -E) reused for the spin-2 field; the dual photon is the spin-1 copy. - Early childhood education
One module reused: at least 30% of Head Start programmes are based on Perry/HighScope; the kindergarten carried by Froebel-trained women across Europe and the world - Economics (the field)
One module reused across systems: economics' trade models carried into biology (mycorrhizal trade modelled 'in the tradition of Cournot'; Ricardo's comparative advantage), and Becker's maximising approach applied to crime, the family and war. Biologists find Walrasian markets 'of limited relevance', - Education
A module moved between systems: policy borrowing carries a policy from one country's system to another, but its success 'can depend to a large degree on the social and cultural context'; standardized curricula and tests are shared templates - Einstein tensor
Trace reversal recurs: G = R_mu-nu - (1/2) g R, and the field equations' own 'trace-reversed form' (R_mu-nu written against T minus half its trace), each undone by reversing the trace again. - Electric circuit
one equation set reused unchanged: Kirchhoff's current law with Ohm's law is the harmonic-function problem of a random walk, so effective conductance is an escape probability; the current law applies to any lumped network 'irrespective of the nature of the network' - Electromagnetic stress-energy tensor
The flat-space Minkowski form (1907) is reused unchanged in curved spacetime with eta replaced by g: the source-free field's Hilbert tensor. - Endocrine system
The axis module recurs: a hypothalamic releasing hormone, a pituitary tropic hormone, a peripheral gland hormone that feeds back (TRH - TSH - T3/T4; GnRH - LH/FSH - sex hormones; CRH - ACTH - cortisol). - Endoplasmic reticulum
The Sec channel is one module across life: Sec61 in the ER, SecYEG in the bacterial plasma membrane, 'a key component of the protein translocation pathway in all organisms'. - Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy)
One generic condition stands in for 'the innumerable substances which could be introduced into spacetime' (Geroch and Horowitz): the same test is applied to every content's tensor. - English language: a West Germanic language of the Indo-European family, from its Old English beginnings to its varieties and its use as a global lingua franca, as linguistics and its history describe it
The Latin alphabet reused as a module for English (with thorn and wynn added); English itself as the template for Airspeak and Seaspeak. - Entrepreneurship
The VC limited-partnership template (general partner, limited partners, 1-2.5% fee, up to 20% carry) emerged once and is reused unchanged across funds; accelerator cohorts copied the Y Combinator format (none in 2004, over 40 by 2013). - Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies)
A module reused unchanged: NEPA's analysis mandate echoed by state laws; the Keeling-curve design (one reference site, standard methods, a long record) proposed for contaminants of emerging concern - Ernst vacuum
One equation, two physical readings: with one timelike and one spacelike Killing vector it gives Kerr and Schwarzschild; with two spacelike ones the same simplest Ernst function gives the colliding-wave analogues (Nutku-Halil, Khan-Penrose). - Ethics (moral philosophy: the study and the morality it studies)
One set of principles reused across systems: Belmont's three principles the foundational reference for frameworks worldwide; Helsinki's prior review operationalised in more than 100 countries. Partial: national frameworks adapt, not copy unchanged. - Euclidean space form
One local model (E^n) folded by a group; flat crystals in cosmology repeat the crystallographer's move (classification motivated by crystallography). - Eukaryote
conserved modules recur unchanged across the domain: the ninefold centriole and axoneme in all major groups, TORC1 everywhere, most GPCR families since LECA - Extracellular matrix
Many matrix proteins carry the RGD motif that one receptor family reads, 'a primary switch by which ECM exerts its effects on cell behaviour'. - False vacuum (metastable electroweak vacuum)
One vacuum, one set of constants: 'in the new vacuum there are new constants of nature', so the present constants recur wherever this vacuum holds. - Finite-volume hyperbolic universe
Cosmic crystallography: the cosmos is the unit cell and the cover the crystal (Luminet); the same move in every multiply connected universe. - Firewall (computing)
The same module reused: packet filtering built into most operating systems and routing devices; the web application firewall used as the model for a firewall layer in front of LLM applications. - Firm (the economic unit)
A chain grows by repeating its store; firms are scored on one set of 18 management practices that travel across firms and countries. The template is shown as researchers' yardstick and as chain expansion, not as a module swapped between firms, so partial. - Fish
One module, the hair cell, used in the lateral line, the hearing ear and the balance organ - Fish school (shoal)
The same two rules, repulsion near and attraction far, are found in a fossil Eocene shoal and in living fishes; zebrafish adults use the larvae's attraction rule. - Fluid dynamics (the flows of liquids and gases, and the practice of describing them)
The onset of turbulence in channel flow carries 'four critical exponents, a universal scaling function and a scaling relation, all in agreement with the (2+1)-dimensional directed percolation universality class', the same class as an ecosystem on the edge of extinction (predator-prey model). One cri - Fold (geology)
One fold shape from microscopic crinkles to lithospheric plates, in sediment, metamorphic rock, igneous flow, rock salt and glacier ice. - Fossil fuel
The heat engine is a module that takes any of the three fuels: coal gasified to syngas 'is burned in a gas turbine to produce electricity (just like natural gas is burned in a turbine)'; furnaces and boilers swap fuels (the 1970s shocks moved users to coal). - Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
One local module recurs identically at every event: 'Minkowski space with the flat Minkowski metric is the local model of a Lorentzian manifold', every tangent space is a pseudo-Euclidean vector space, and the signature cannot change across a connected manifold. - Frame field (tetrad, vierbein)
The flat Lorentz metric recurs identically in every tangent space: NSI frames are 'as close as we can get in a curved Lorentzian manifold to the Lorentz frames used in special relativity'. - Free will
One module reused: the leaky stochastic accumulator-to-bound model, used for perceptual decisions, fits human EEG before self-initiated movement and rodent M2 ramping activity alike. - Fungi (yeasts, molds and mushrooms: absorptive eukaryotes with chitin walls)
One receptor fold, swapped ligands: Gpr1-type sugar receptors in nematode-trapping fungi 'have diversified their ligand spectrum and recognize the nematode hormone ascaroside', and 'at least GprC still binds glucose'; the same receptors resemble the prey's own SRBC-66, 'suggesting a common ancestral - Future trapped region T
T inherits the clairvoyance of its surfaces: 'The clairvoyance property of trapped surfaces is inherited by everything based on them, such as marginally trapped tubes including dynamical horizons'. - G2 manifold (Joyce manifold)
One template sets every member: holonomy in G2 forces a parallel 3-form and 4-form and Ricci-flatness on all G2 manifolds; the same special-holonomy logic recurs in Calabi-Yau (six dimensions) and Spin(7) (eight). - Galilean reference frame (Newtonian inertial frame)
The same mechanics recurs in every uniformly moving frame (Corollary V). - Gastrulation (the embryo's cell sheet folds and moves into two or three germ layers)
The organizer is a conserved module: transplanted from one newt species (Triturus cristatus) into another (T. taeniatus) it still induces a whole secondary embryo; conserved among Cnidaria, Ctenophora and Bilateria - Gender
The gender binary and its assignment rule (genital appearance at birth) as a template reused across most cultures; the same 'hegemonic myths' (girls vulnerable, boys strong) carried by schools, parents, media and peers in 15 countries on five continents. - genealogy (descent as a medium)
Every link copies by template: DNA 'passed down relatively unchanged from early ancestors', so a segment is the same text in all who share it. - General relativity
one module, the PPN framework with ten parameters, reused unchanged to test every metric theory against every solar-system experiment - Geodetic effect
The same parallel-transport rule recurs from GP-B gyroscopes (Earth) to the Earth-Moon orbit (Sun) to pulsar B (a neutron-star companion). - Globally hyperbolic spacetime
Every spacetime is locally like this class: 'any p and any neighborhood U' admit 'arbitrarily small globally hyperbolic neighborhoods of p' (Theorem 2.14, Remark 2.15), so the global condition is the local module extended everywhere. - Gorkavyi's oscillating universe (black holes and gravitational waves; no dark matter, no dark energy)
Each cycle repeats the same merge-radiate-expand, absorb-compress construction. - Grammar (the structure of a language, as linguistics describes it)
Dionysius Thrax's Art of Grammar: 'The Romans based their grammatical writings on it and its basic format remains the basis for grammar guides in many languages even today.' - Grand unification epoch
The breaking at ~10^-36 s is the same kind of step the electroweak epoch takes at ~10^-12 s: a hot bath cools through a phase transition that splits one gauge interaction into two (the epoch article: 'The strong force separated from the other fundamental forces'; the chronology: 'a thermodynamic eff - Gravitational wave horizon
Same room as the optical and neutrino horizons: a messenger stops interacting when its rate drops below the Hubble rate, then streams freely, and the last-interaction surface becomes its horizon. Here the rate is gravitational, so the surface sits at the Planck scale. - Gravitino (superpartner of the graviton; hypothetical)
'the gravitino is the fermion mediating supergravity interactions, just as the photon is mediating electromagnetism, and the graviton is presumably mediating gravitation': the gauge-mediator pattern reused for a fermionic symmetry. - Graviton (hypothetical quantum of gravity)
The quantum-of-a-field module recurs: the same Planck-Einstein relation that ties a photon's energy to its wavelength ties the graviton's mass to its Compton wavelength ('the same formula that relates electromagnetic wavelength to photon energy'). - Great Acceleration
One development pathway reused: 'urbanisation trends in Asia appear to be following the North American model'; the post-World War II OECD pathway 'which has driven the Great Acceleration' as the template others may or may not follow. - Helium hydride ion (HeH+)
One two-electron bond, two builds: HeH+ 'is isoelectronic with molecular hydrogen (H2)'; the same electron count recurs with a different nucleus pair, which gives HeH+ a permanent dipole that H2 lacks. - Hilbert stress-energy tensor (metric energy-momentum tensor)
One rule (differentiate the matter action by the metric) is stamped onto every matter sector; the electromagnetic tensor is its worked instance. - Homogeneous Galilean group (rotations and boosts, no translations)
The same abstract group R^3 x| SO(3) appears twice: as rigid motions of space (Euclidean group) and as rotations plus uniform motions (homogeneous Galilean group); velocity space takes the place of position space. - Honeybee (western honey bee, Apis mellifera)
One dance module across contexts (food, water, nest sites) and across species with dialects; a mixed colony of A. cerana and A. mellifera came to understand each other's dialects - Human physiology
One controller-Plant module reused for every regulated variable (sensor, comparison with a reference, signal, flows), and one cell-autonomous clock loop in the SCN and in peripheral cells. - Human voice
One source-filter template across mammals: human voice 'obeys the same acoustic principles as vocal production in other animals'; Fant's theory describes 'how humans and most mammals produce sound'; a macaque's vocal tract could make an adequate range of speech sounds (Fitch 2016). Partial: the modu - Hydrogen atom
The hydrogen level code is the template the other atoms are read from: 'all other atoms can be roughly understood by knowing in detail about this simplest atomic structure', and the formulas carry over to hydrogen-like atoms (one electron, any nucleus). - Hydrogen sulfide
Sulfide repeats water's acid-base and proton-exchange module one row down the chalcogens: 'H2S and H2O exchange protons rapidly' (Girdler process), pKa about 7 against water's Kw 1e-14. - Hydrogen-bond network (water)
The one Dn-H...Ac bond recurs, unchanged in kind, as water's network, DNA base pairs ('the double helical structure of DNA is due largely to hydrogen bonding between its base pairs') and protein secondary structure (i to i+4 alpha helix, beta sheets). - Hydrophobic effect
One push reused across builds: the same burial of nonpolar surface drives oil-water separation, micelles, bilayers, protein cores and DNA tertiary structure. Partial: the module is a force, not a swappable part. - Hyperbolic manifold
One local model (hyperbolic space) recurs at every point of every hyperbolic manifold; each is H^n folded by a different group, as spherical and flat space forms are S^n and E^n folded. - Ideal clock
Every ideal clock reads the same quantity, the proper-time arclength of its world line, whatever it is made of. - Infinity: the boundless or endless as mathematics and philosophy describe it (potential and actual infinity, Cantor's sizes of infinity, infinity in calculus, geometry, physics and computing) and the practice of the people who argue over it
One machine value, IEEE 754 +∞ and −∞, is reused unchanged as a constant across programming languages and algorithms. - Inflation (economics)
Inflation targeting as one module (a public numerical target, an institutional commitment, transparency) adopted from New Zealand (1990) by Canada (1991), the UK (1992), Sweden and Finland (1993) and on to 45 countries and the euro area. - Information security
The CIA triad is a module copied unchanged across ISO standards, US federal law and other national standards, and controls catalogues (ISO 27002, NIST's 20 families) are reused by any organisation; national schemes (Cyber Essentials, Essential Eight) restate it. - Information warfare
Manipulation techniques are modules reused across content: inoculation against a technique works 'without prior knowledge of specific misleading content'; industrial production leaves a signature that carries across months, countries and platforms. - Inhomogeneous wave equation (wave equation with a source)
One Green's function, convolved with any source, gives every sourced solution (Duhamel's principle); the same construction is used 'both for the homogeneous and the inhomogeneous case'. - Insect (class Insecta)
'The MEKRE93 pathway appears conserved in extant metamorphosing insects', likely operative in the Pterygota last common ancestor. - Instanton (QCD vacuum tunnelling)
The same tunnelling calculation recurs from atoms in chemical reactions to the decay of the universe's vacuum. - Institution (social)
One uniform choice reused by all; organisations copying each other's practices (mimetic isomorphism). The dark-twin edge is in the sources: open-access institutions transplanted into limited-access orders 'face limited success'. - Internet protocol suite (TCP/IP): the layered datagram protocols every host and router runs, the RFC record that specifies them, and the community that keeps them
BVSR's vary-select-retain run on specifications: anyone may submit an Internet Draft (variation); 'multiple, working, useful, interoperable implementations', promotion of experiments that 'work well' and 'Historic' for the superseded (selection); never-modified RFCs (retention). EvoArch models the s - Interstellar medium
Phases as the temperatures where heating and cooling reach a stable equilibrium, with runaway cooling between them: the same phase-making module in the ISM and in intergalactic gas (warm and warm-hot phases). - Intonation
A conserved module reused: speaker-normalised relative-pitch encoding is shared across Mandarin and English listeners and tuned per language; and the ToBI framework was carried to Japanese, Dutch and British dialects with adaptations (our describers' template, not the world's). - Intrinsically disordered protein (no single fold)
Short linear motifs recur across many proteins, and 'many viruses mimick/hijack linear motifs to efficiently recode infected cells': a host module copied into another system and still working. - Invariant hyperbola of timelike separation
The same hyperbola recurs in spacetime (equal proper time) and on the energy-momentum diagram (equal invariant mass). - Invariant mass (rest mass, proper mass)
One invariant read the same in every frame recurs at every scale: a particle (rest mass), a bound bottle of gas, unbound decay products, a box of photons. - Kaluza-Klein theory (projected model: five-dimensional gravity with a compact circle)
The same construction copied with bigger symmetry groups: U(1) replaced 'by a general Lie group' (Yang-Mills), then extended to eleven dimensions (supergravity) and to strings. - Kodama vector field
One conserved current built the same way wherever there is spherical symmetry: J = G K, conserved without any Killing symmetry; its charge reappears as the Misner-Sharp-Hernandez energy in FLRW and in collapse. - Komar mass
The Gauss-law flux template from electromagnetism reused for mass: 'similar to the way that Gauss's law defines the charge enclosed by a surface'; F_ab plays 'a role similar to the Faraday tensor'. - Labour market
One definition reused unchanged across countries: national statistical agencies increasingly adopt the ILO's definition of unemployment, so the module (not working, available, actively searching) swaps between national surveys. Partial: differences remain. - Lemaitre observers (radially infalling free-fall frame)
The flat Euclidean frame recurs in the slices of the infalling family: 'their spatial triad looks exactly like the frame for three-dimensional euclidean space'. - Levi-Civita connection
One formula recurs for every metric, positive-definite or Lorentzian: 'the fundamental theorem of Riemannian geometry is true of all pseudo-Riemannian manifolds'. - Lipid (amphiphile)
The bilayer recurs as one module: vesicle membranes are 'a lamellar phase, similar to that of the plasma membrane' and fuse with it (o85); every cell membrane uses it (o2). - Literacy
One script module is reused across many languages: Devanagari is used for over 100 languages other than Hindi; and the reading network recruits the ventral visual stream's existing object-recognition machinery (inheriting its biases). - Liver
One unit repeated across the organ: the lobule ('Hepatic lobules are the functional units of the liver'), each about 15 cell layers with the same zones. Partial: a repeated module inside one organ, not one module swapped between systems. - Local position invariance
The same constants everywhere and always: a natural reactor two billion years ago ran on nuclear reactions 'similar to ones we observe today'. - Lorentz frame (inertial frame of special relativity)
The Lorentz frame recurs as the local pattern of every nonspinning inertial frame: NSI frames are 'as close as we can get in a curved Lorentzian manifold to the Lorentz frames used in special relativity'. - Lorentz group (homogeneous Lorentz group, O(1,3))
One group shared by every fundamental law listed (special relativity, local GR, Maxwell, Dirac, Standard Model). - Lorentz group of (n+1)-dimensional Minkowski space, O(n,1)
One construction recurs in every dimension: four components, an SO(n) bundle over hyperbolic space, conformal action on the celestial sphere; and the same group reappears as the whole symmetry of de Sitter space. - Luminosity distance
A standard candle: every Type Ia, standardised, is the same template of peak light, so its faintness is a distance. - M-theory (projected model; conjectured eleven-dimensional theory behind the superstring theories)
Kaluza-Klein recurs: a fifth dimension curled into a circle (Klein, radius ~10^-30 cm) is the template for every later compactification, here a membrane on a small circle read as a string. - M2-brane (membrane of M-theory; projected model)
One ansatz, many branes: the p-brane ansatz (Poincare-invariant hyperplanes, harmonic function, BPS charge) gives the M2, the M5 and the D-branes. - Magnetic monopoles (hypothetical relics)
Dirac: if any monopole exists anywhere, all electric charge everywhere must be quantized; one unit shared by every charged particle. - Marketing
The 4 Ps framework is reused across firms, B2B and B2C, and extended to 7 Ps for services; Keith's production-sales-marketing eras were copied into 21 of 25 textbooks despite critiques calling them a myth (the module reused unchanged, error included). - Mass (the central generator M)
The same central-label role recurs: M in the centre of the Bargmann algebra labels Galilei particles, and mass indexes the Poincare representations; one quantity labels the particle in both symmetry groups. - Materials science (the field)
A module moved unchanged in design: nacre's brick-and-mortar layout copied into alumina with polymer (PMMA) or metallic-glass mortar and still toughening (Wat 2019); the tetrahedron reused as the frame for new 'tetrahedra' for AI research (Zhang 2026). - Maximally symmetric spacetime
One quasi-sphere construction in a flat space of one more dimension gives every nonzero-curvature member, Lorentzian and Riemannian alike (sphere, hyperbolic space, de Sitter, anti-de Sitter). - Measurement (the practice of comparing a quantity with a unit, and the units and standards it uses)
Western Eurasian weight systems consistent with origin from a single unit, copied from Mesopotamia to Europe; the SI definition copied into every realization. - Meson
The same quark-antiquark colour-singlet module recurs across about 140 types: 'combinations of one u, d, or s quark and one u, d, or s antiquark in J^P = 0- configuration form a nonet', and the J^P = 1- combinations 'also form a nonet'. - Mind–body problem (how mental states relate to physical states)
Functionalism's multiple realizability: a mental state is a role 'like a valve' that can be made of plastic or metal; the same mental role swapped into neurons or silicon and still working, if functionalism is right (contested by IIT, C-434). - Mirror symmetry (string theory; projected model)
T-duality on a circle is copied onto every fibre of a torus fibration to build the mirror (SYZ): one module recurring across the whole manifold. - Molecular cloud
Collapse-and-fragment repeats down the scales: the cloud 'breaks into smaller and smaller pieces in a hierarchical manner, until the fragments reach stellar mass', and supercritical filaments carry evenly spaced chains of cores (0.15 pc, about the filament width). - Molecule
Identical molecules everywhere: microwave lines measured in the laboratory are matched to emissions from interstellar space, and 241 species have been identified that way; a pure substance is molecules of one average structure. - Momentum constraint
Gauss's law in electromagnetism plays the same part (D . E = rho/eps0 as a constraint on a slice, sourced by the charge density, as the momentum constraint is sourced by the momentum density). - Music
Music uses the same reward module as food, sex and drugs (ventral striatum, midbrain, amygdala, orbitofrontal cortex); its emotions come 'through mechanisms that are not unique to music'. - Neutrino mass eigenstates (nu1, nu2, nu3)
The same flavour-versus-mass basis mismatch, a unitary 3x3 mixing matrix with three angles and a phase, recurs in quarks (CKM) and leptons (PMNS); the idea first came from neutral kaon mixing. The module is the same; its angles are not (lepton angles two large and one small, quark angles all small a - New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides)
One design reused unchanged across crows at a site: pandanus tool shapes highly standardised at sites and persisting for decades - Novel
the genre module swapped between authors and still working: popular novels written to 'the expectations for the particular genre', branded series (Sherlock Holmes); detective and science fiction coherent for 160-200 years; Poe as a template is argued - Nuclear matter
Every nucleus interior shares one saturation density and one bulk binding per nucleon: the volume term is proportional to A and independent of Z because each interior nucleon has a certain number of other nucleons in contact. - Number and counting (the number sense, the practice of counting, and the structure it works on)
The Hindu-Arabic system displaced Roman numerals in Europe and 'remains the most common system for representing numbers in the world today': one module, swapped in across languages, still works. - Numeracy
One shared approximate number system in adults, infants, preschoolers and non-human animals, with the same intraparietal response at 4 and in adults. - Nursing (the field: the practice and the care it gives)
One method reused across every problem and specialty: the nursing process (assess, diagnose, plan, implement, evaluate), the same five steps for a wound and for depression; Nightingale's school model reproduced across Europe and North America after 1870. - Nutrition (food and nutrition: how bodies take in and use food)
Gut neuropod cells pass their signal on with vesicular glutamate, the same transmitter photoreceptors, auditory hair cells, Merkel cells and olfactory receptor cells use - Open string (projected model)
The straight Regge line J ~ alpha' M^2 recurs: the open-string tower and the meson/baryon spectra ('Some examples involving rho-mesons'). - Orangutan (Pongo)
Sumatran-Bornean hybrid orangutans live and are studied in zoos: the two species' genomes still work together (99.68% identical); 48 chromosomes shared with gorillas and chimpanzees - Organization
One module reused across systems: the bureaucratic elements make 'a bureaucratic agency in the case of the state and bureaucratic enterprises in the private sector'; the Qin form was reused by later dynasties. - Oscillating universe (Friedmann 1922; Einstein 1930; Tolman 1934)
Each oscillation is the same construction (bang, expansion, recollapse, crunch) repeated. - Outer trapped surface (OTS)
One sign test on the null expansions sorts every closed spacelike surface; the outer test reuses it on one expansion only. - Pallium (the dorsal telencephalon of vertebrates)
Cell type 'families' shared by lamprey and jawed vertebrates 'were already present in the brain of the last common ancestor of jawless and jawed vertebrates'; 'the interneuron classes known in mammals already existed in the common ancestor of all amniotes'. - Parallel transport along curves
One rule recurs from the sphere's loop (twist proportional to area) to Earth-orbiting gyroscopes (GP-B) to orbits round the Sun (de Sitter 1916, Earth-Moon) and gauge fields (curve lifting in principal bundles). - Pauli-Lubanski pseudovector
One label set for every particle: 'all elementary particles fall in representations of this group', labelled by P^2 and W^2; the same Casimir recurs as the spin label of every massive particle and the helicity of every massless one. - Penetration testing
Reused modules: Metasploit's exploit library and payloads, distributions like Kali that pre-package tools, OWASP checklists maintained in-house; yet interviewees named neither ATT&CK nor PTES, and an earlier study found methodology recommendations not taken up. - Penrose singularity theorem
Borrowed from Riemannian geometry: Bonnet-Myers (positive Ricci curvature, geodesics reconverge, compactness); 'Roger Penrose argued analogously in relativity'. - Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems
Borrowed shape from Riemannian geometry: Bonnet-Myers (positive Ricci curvature makes geodesics reconverge, so the manifold is compact); 'Roger Penrose argued analogously in relativity'. - Perception
The Weber-Fechner logarithmic scale recurs across modalities and species (monkeys, corvids, pigeons for numerosity); receptive fields as the shared unit across visual, auditory and somatosensory systems. - Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it)
The idea copies the shell rule of the thing it is about: Kossel, 'in the formation of each new shell the chemical periodicity is repeated'; the table stamps one group pattern per period. - Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
One module reused across systems and still working: the trolley case, from moral philosophy to moral psychology's focal paradigm and the Moral Machine built for self-driving cars; thought experiments used in physics, mathematics, biology, computer science and economics. - Phonology: how languages organise the meaningless units their words are built from (phonemes in spoken languages; handshape, location and movement in signed ones), together with the field of linguistics that studies those systems
The same analytic modules carried unchanged across modalities: phonological principles applied to sign languages; the Hand Tier model built in the spirit of feature geometry for speech; OT faithfulness and markedness rankings used for handshape inventories. - Phosphorus atom
One module recurring: the phosphate tetrahedron (a central P with four O) is the backbone link of DNA and RNA and the energy-carrying chain of ATP ('organophosphates (DNA, RNA, ATP, phospholipids)'). - Photon
one interchangeable quantum serves every exchange from nuclei to photopigments: identical bosons, two helicities, E = h nu - Physical security
One design template reused across very different places: deter, detect, delay, respond with concentric perimeters at a nuclear site, a bank vault, a hosting centre ('A modern hosting centre might follow the same strategy'); 'the principles are similar' from prison to home. The template is adapted, n - Picard horn
One cell recurs in every copy of the cover: the eigenmodes are automorphic, psi(gamma q) = psi(q); the same move as every space form (H3, E3, S3 folded by a group). - Planck epoch (Planck era)
One step of the unification ladder that recurs at each epoch boundary: a force separates as the universe cools (gravity here; the strong force at the GUT epoch; the weak force at the electroweak epoch). - Play
A game swapped between species and still working: rats learn to play hide-and-seek with a human, and their prefrontal states follow the game's phases; animals of different species reared together exchange play roles. - Poincare group (inhomogeneous Lorentz group; full symmetry of special relativity)
Every elementary particle is one representation of the same group: one rule, every particle's label. - Pragmatics
Three basic repair initiator types make up 92% of repair in all 12 languages (spoken and signed), used in the same situations; 'Huh?' reused across languages. Swap test not shown. - Prairie dog (Cynomys)
One call-to-escape mapping held across a colony: playbacks give the same escapes as the predators; within 30 km colonies share call structure (dialects beyond) - Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases)
BVSR's vary-select-retain run on rulings: new facts vary, appeal and overruling select, reports retain; the court itself calls it 'the process of trial and error, so fruitful in the physical sciences'. Partial: variation is sighted and biased ('a judge's objective diverges from efficiency because of - Primate (order Primates)
One neuron format reused across brain sizes: 'in primates the neuron densities and average neuron sizes remain the same', unlike non-primates whose neurons get bigger. - Prime numbers (the practice of number theory that finds, proves and uses them, and the structure of the primes it works on)
One template reused across systems: the prime idea carried unchanged into prime elements and prime ideals; the Riemann hypothesis's template proved for curves over finite fields (Weil); zero spacings of whole families of L-functions conjectured to follow one universal random-matrix law. - Primordial gravitational waves (inflationary tensor modes)
One module, a quantum fluctuation stretched past the horizon and frozen, makes both the scalar (density) and the tensor (gravitational-wave) perturbations; the ratio between the two copies is the tensor-to-scalar ratio, 'the other free parameter'. - Principle of relativity
Laws as templates that recur unchanged in every frame: 'Whatever remains constant for different observers is a candidate for a physical law'; Maxwell's equations 'have the same form in all inertial frames'. - Probability: weighing chances, in brains and in people's mathematics, and the structure it works on
Odds as a template copied by selective imitation: house advantages converged on a band (mostly 5-30%) across games in premodern China, 'design without a designer'. - Prograde circular photon orbit inside the inner horizon
The same equatorial circular light orbit (a root of the constant-radius condition, unstable) recurs three times in Kerr, once below the horizons: r_1 inside, r_2 and r_3 outside. - Projective space
The same construction (lines through the origin, up to scale) recurs over every field and division ring: RP^n, CP^n, HP^n, PG(n, q); Veblen-Young makes it the only kind in dimension three and up. - Proper reference frame
The proper frame strings together momentary inertial frames: 'a successive application of Lorentz transformations', the same transformation recurring at each instant. - Protein secondary structure (alpha helices, beta sheets, turns)
One module recurring: the heptad repeat of coiled coils in keratin, myosin and kinesin stalks and dimerising proteins; a four-helix bundle 'very common'; nucleic acids 'also possess characteristic secondary structures'. - Pseudo-Riemannian (semi-Riemannian) manifold
Every tangent space is a pseudo-Euclidean vector space of the same signature; the model space R^{p,q} recurs at every point. - Pseudovector (axial vector)
One transformation rule recurs in every axial quantity: magnetic field, angular momentum, spin, magnetic moment, the four-dimensional Pauli-Lubanski vector. - Pulsar wind nebula
Wind, standing termination shock and a bubble of shocked wind: the pulsar's version of the Sun's wind ending at its termination shock (about 94 AU) inside the heliosphere; the PWN article lists stellar and solar winds and stellar-wind bubbles as kin. - QCD vacuum
One module reused unchanged: the BPST instanton, the same finite-action Euclidean solution, appears in QCD, in two-dimensional sigma models, in electroweak theory and in supersymmetric QCD (Schaefer and Shuryak review it in each). Partial: reuse across theories (models of the world), with QCD's latt - Quantum entanglement
the singlet as the interchangeable unit: pure states convert to singlets and back by LOCC 'with a yield m/n approaching E(Υ)', and the same unit is spent in teleportation, purification and key distribution on photons, spins or atoms alike (the ebit) - Quantum fluctuation
One mechanism in every field: 'all quantum fields have zero-point energies and vacuum fluctuations' (electromagnetic, W and Z, gluon, the inflaton, and, hypothesised, the metric). - Quantum null energy condition (QNEC)
Null quantization reduces any kinematic problem on the plane to many identical copies of one module, the free chiral scalar CFT in 1+1 dimensions. - Quark condensate (chiral condensate)
One vacuum value stamps the same constituent mass into every light quark, so baryon masses come out approximately as sums of constituent masses. - Quarks and antiquarks for survival out of the early-universe plasma (the baryon asymmetry)
The same annihilation-with-remainder runs twice in the cooling universe: quarks and hadrons with their antiparticles (to about 7 x 10^-5 s), then leptons and antileptons about 10 s after, 'leaving a small residue of leptons'. One step recurring with a different species. - Quark–gluon plasma
One statistical-hadronisation module with one temperature fits every species over nine orders of magnitude, is reused unchanged for charm ('with thermal weights as discussed above for the light quarks'), and gives freeze-out parameters in high-multiplicity pp 'remarkably similar' to p-Pb. - Quasinormal mode
Every remnant rings with a spectrum fixed by two numbers (mass, spin): GW250114's modes match the Kerr spectrum within +/-30%; Pretorius's 2005 simulated remnant 'is estimated to be a Kerr black hole with angular momentum parameter a~0.70'. - Ratio and proportion: comparing two quantities by how many times one contains the other, the practice of keeping proportions, and the structure it works on
One form, a:b = c:x (the missing-value problem, the rule of three), reused unchanged for recipes, juice and berries, concrete, map scale and compounds' masses. - Relativistic precession
The same periapsis law recurs from Mercury (arcsec per century) to binary pulsars (degrees per year), scaled by r^-5/2. - Reproductive system (human, as physiology describes it)
One axis module in both builds: 'In males, the production of GnRH, LH, and FSH are similar, but the effects of these hormones are different.' - Retina (eye and retina)
one plan reused across vertebrates: five major neuronal classes with Muller glia, in stereotyped layers - Rhetoric (speech and argument)
The speech template (exordium, argument or proof, peroration) shows in Enheduanna's hymn (c. 2285-2250 BCE) long before Greece codified it, and the same canons serve political, forensic and ceremonial speeches; Renaissance music borrowed rhetoric's figures ('little difference between music and the n - Riemannian manifold (positive-definite geometry; space at one time)
One local module at every point: Euclidean space is the local model, and 'Any two Riemannian manifolds of the same constant curvature are locally isometric'. - Risk management
The risk matrix and the identify-assess-treat-monitor process are carried unchanged across healthcare, critical infrastructure, construction and devices, reflected in ISO 31000 and ISO 22301; whether the module still works when swapped is contested (C-1678). - River
One scale-invariant network form recurs in every river basin (optimal channel networks); copies at every scale from headwater to mainstem. - RNA
Recurring tertiary motifs 'serve as molecular building blocks'; a tetraloop and its receptor covary so 'the same type of tertiary contact can be made with different isoforms'. - S-duality (strong-weak duality; projected model)
A classical symmetry (Maxwell's E-B interchange) recurs at every level: Montonen-Olive in N = 4 gauge theory, Seiberg duality ('Like Montonen-Olive duality, Seiberg duality generalizes the symmetry of Maxwell's equations'), and the string S-dualities. - Security operations center (SOC)
One tier model and one playbook form reused across SOCs (the tiered model drawn after Zimmerman in several studies; MSSPs keep a playbook per customer). - Sign language (the natural signed languages)
One language capacity reused unchanged across modalities: babbling 'is tied to the abstract linguistic structure of language' in hands or voice, and the modality of the first language 'does not affect the white matter microstructure between crucial language regions'. - Signals intelligence
One model reused across agencies: the intelligence cycle, invented in 1948, 'the most popular working theory of intelligence management today'; a UK SIGINT analysis tool is built to support its five phases. - Silk Road
One module reused unchanged across many societies: the Sogdian language as a lingua franca, silk bolts and Sasanian coins as currency, the Buddhist monastery as a haven in city after city. - Small business
Franchising swaps one module (a brand and its system) into many small owners' firms, and it often works; the UK record (36% of 1984 franchisors still there in 1998) shows the module doesn't always take. Partial. - Smooth (differentiable) manifold
One local model recurs in every chart: 'a manifold is a space that is locally approximated by Euclidean spaces'; 'tangent spaces of differentiable manifolds are Euclidean vector spaces'. - SO(3)-invariant photon surface
The static photon sphere at r = 3m1 is the template; Example 10 carries the same surface back through the collapsing dust as a dynamic copy that ends on a null hypersurface. - Social change
Modules swapped between societies and still working: money and writing adopted from larger societies 'because they may be useful in dealing with larger societies'; modernity diffused as one world culture. - Social class
The class schema is a template reused across countries: the same EGP categories harmonised for Mexico, Chile, Uruguay, Spain, Sweden, the UK and Germany and still fitting (constant social fluidity models improve fit everywhere). - Social contagion
The epidemic model's classes reused for rumours ('Their role is exactly the same of the susceptible, infected, recovered agents'), with one term changed (stopping when contacts already know), and 'similar models' used for pathogens, knowledge and innovation. - Social network
The same community-finding method, built on centrality, was tested on social graphs and then run on a collaboration network and a food web and still found informative divisions; the graph template moves between social, biological and technological networks. - Social norm
One structure reused across norm domains: empirical plus normative expectations, a reference group and sanctions make a gender norm, a political norm, a cooperation norm in a lab game and a convention; institutions are 'composed of multiple norms', reused as modules. Interchangeability shown for con - Social stratification
The class template is reused at another scale: 'like a stratified class system within a nation' the world economy has core, semi-periphery and periphery classes; within a nation each class repeats an upper, middle and lower stratum. - Socialization
A family module swapped into a child's life still works: abandoned children moved to foster families did better than those left in institutions, most for the youngest placed - Solution (chemistry)
In the dilute limit any solute particle counts the same toward the colligative properties ('not on the nature of the chemical species present'), and organic osmolytes are called 'compatible solutes', 'implying interchangeability', though Yancey shows the swap does not always work. - Songbird (oscines, suborder Passeri)
A song model copied from an older bird works in the young bird's own song system; the learned module passes between individuals and still works - Spacetime
One local module at every event: 'Locally, as expressed in the equivalence principle, spacetime is Minkowskian'; the manifold walk books the same template at its metric floor. - Special Euclidean group SE(n) (rigid motions)
The same split recurs one rung up: Lorentz transformations split into proper and improper by det +-1, and the proper orthochronous part is the connected one, as SE(n) is in E(n). - Special relativity
Lorentz invariance is one module carried unchanged into every modern theory ('an organic part of all modern physical theories'); the mSME gathers every way to break it into one template for testing - Special unitary group SU(2)
One group, two physical jobs: SU(2) rotates the spin of every spin-1/2 particle ('the spin of fundamental particles such as electrons') and, as SU(2)_L, acts on every left-chiral fermion doublet as weak isospin. - Special unitary group SU(n)
One family, reused: the n = 2 member rotates every spin-1/2 field and is weak isospin; the n = 3 member is colour; 'In physics the special unitary group is used to represent fermionic symmetries'. - Speech (human spoken language)
One stored motor program per frequent sound, reused unchanged in every word that contains it (the speech sound map). - Sperm whale (cachalot, Physeter macrocephalus)
Shared coda types (1+1+3, 5R1) reused unchanged across all Dominica units for at least 30 years; clan dialects copied across generations - Startup company
One module reused unchanged across ecosystems: Y Combinator's 2005 accelerator model (fixed terms plus a bootcamp) copied around the world and now 'key organizations of any Startup ecosystem'; the standard sequence of rounds and terms. Partial: reuse shown, no swap test. - State of matter
The same liberation shape recurs at two levels: a plasma frees electrons from atoms, and the quark-gluon plasma frees quarks from hadrons; the source: 'This is analogous to the liberation of electrons from atoms in a plasma.' Partial: the copy differs (QGP flows like a liquid, plasma like a gas). - Static spherically symmetric perfect fluid
One structure equation (TOV) for every static round body; only the equation of state changes between white dwarfs and neutron stars. - Static Weyl vacuum
The flat-space Laplace equation of Newtonian gravity recurs as the equation for U, so every Newtonian axisymmetric potential generates a static vacuum; but 'no correspondence between the geometry of the physical source and the geometry of the Newtonian source'. - Stationary spacetime
Two-potential pattern: the stationary vacuum is written with a mass potential and an angular-momentum potential, 'analogous to a static electromagnetic field where one has two sets of potentials, electric and magnetic'. - Statistics: the practice of collecting and reasoning from data, the intuitive statistics it grows from, and the structure (samples, distributions, estimators) it works on
1853: a congress 'to unify measurement in statistical research'; UN definitions for censuses worldwide. - Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
One symmetric order-2 form recurs for every source: isolated particle, perfect fluid, electromagnetic field, scalar field, vacuum. - String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
One unit, many identities: 'there is only one kind of string ... and it can vibrate in different ways', each way a particle with its own mass and charge. - Strongly causal spacetime
'any spacetime (M,g) is locally strongly causal, as any point p admits an arbitrarily small strongly causal neighborhood': the condition is the local module every spacetime already has, required here globally. - Supergravity (projected model: the gauge theory of local supersymmetry)
Kaluza and Klein's 1919 five-dimensional theory reduced on a circle recurs as the template for supergravity's reductions: 'The resulting theories were sometimes referred to as Kaluza-Klein theories'; again in M-theory's circle and in superstring theory's six hidden dimensions. - Supersymmetry (projected model)
One algebra stamps the same partner pattern onto every particle: every multiplet repeats the boson-fermion pairing with spins one half apart. - Supply chain security
The manufacturing bill of materials carried over to software as the SBOM, and the 'supply chain' itself named by analogy with physical goods. - Surveillance
One module reused across carriers and countries: the lawful-intercept requirement in every US telephone and VoIP system; China's Golden Shield credited to US and UK systems as its inspiration. - Tangent space
The same n-dimensional vector space recurs at every point of a connected manifold; in Minkowski spacetime every tangent space is canonically identified with the spacetime itself. - Taub region
Misner space repeats the Taub region's edge in 1+1 dimensions: a region bounded by a null surface past which time loops appear ('A simplified 1+1-dimensional version'). - Teacher
The normal school as a template: model classrooms teaching model practices to 'set the norm for the profession', copied from Reims (1685) to Sombor (1778), Concord (1823), Massachusetts (1839) and Shanghai (1895) - Thalamus
One method in every nucleus ('What unites the thalamus is not its functions ... but its method'): relay neurons with tonic and burst modes on T-type channels, a current also found in C. elegans, Drosophila and Trichoplax. - The archive and the historical record
One description standard reused across countries: ISAD(G) as the basis of national standards (DACS in the US, RAD in Canada); respect des fonds spread through Europe after about 1840. Adapted, not unchanged, so partial. - The world through the senses (sensory environment)
Moonlight reproduces the sunlit light field's shape (sky/ground ratio, elevation profile, spectral balance) at five to six orders of magnitude less: the sun and moon are nearly the same size and both make blue skylight by scattering - Theory of everything (projected model; final theory)
Unification as a repeated move: terrestrial and celestial gravity (Newton), electricity and magnetism (Maxwell), space and time (Einstein), electromagnetism and the weak force (1967-1968), each reused as the plan for the next. - Thermodynamic arrow of time
One boundary condition read out by many arrows: the thermodynamic arrow 'seems to be related to all other arrows of time and arguably underlies some of them' (radiative, causal, quantum, psychological). - Thermodynamics
The four-law module carried unchanged onto another system and still working: the laws of black-hole mechanics read 'as physically corresponding to the ordinary laws of thermodynamcs' once Hawking radiation gives the hole a temperature. Three of the four slot in; the third law does not ('is broken by - Time reversal T and T-symmetry
One broken symmetry seen in three places by the CPT link: kaon mixing (1964, 1998), B mesons (2001, 2012) and the matter excess of the universe. - Transport theorem
One operator, [(d/dt)_r + Omega x], applied to every vector: to position it gives v_i = v_r + Omega x r, to velocity the accelerations and the three fictitious terms. - Truth
One fixed module reused unchanged: the T-sentence form '"S" is true in L if and only if p' applied to every sentence; the two truth values reused in logic, truth tables, Boolean code and (as the ends 0 and 1) probability. - Twistor space
The conformal group recurs unchanged as linear maps of C^4: 'Conformal symmetry becomes very simple to understand, with conformal transformations given by linear transformations of C^4.' - Type I (spherically symmetric) weakly isolated horizon
One horizon geometry recurs identically in unrelated hosts: Robinson-Trautman horizons have 'intrinsic geometry ... isomorphic to that of the Schwarzschild isolated horizons' while radiation sits arbitrarily close; the settled Vaidya horizon is the same spherical NEH. - Type IIA superstring theory (projected model)
One p-form rule recurs: each p-form gauge field couples to an object with a p-dimensional worldvolume, giving the whole ladder D0, D2, D4, D6, F1, NS5. - Ultracool dwarf
One dynamo scaling (field set by the convective energy flux, Christensen et al. 2009) used unchanged for planets, brown dwarfs and stars; 'the underlying magnetic dynamos of giant planets, brown dwarfs and very-low mass stars may be very similar'. Form: the same rule, the field read off a different - Universal cover of anti-de Sitter space
Unrolling recurs: the pseudosphere 'curls around on itself although the hyperbolic plane does not', just as the AdS quasi-sphere curls in time and its cover does not; in both, straight lines that closed on the curled version run on forever on the cover. - Universe
One acoustic scale reused unchanged: the sound horizon set at recombination shows as the CMB's acoustic peaks and as the 100 h^-1 Mpc peak in the galaxies, a standard ruler across 0.35 < z < 1089. - Urinary system
The nephron is one module repeated about a million times per human kidney, and 'genes that are involved in the formation of one form of kidney are reused in the formation of the next one' (pronephros, mesonephros, metanephros). - Vector bundle
One construction recurs over every base and in every physical use: local trivializations glued by transition functions, with fibrewise operations that 'extend straightforwardly to pairs of vector bundles' (tangent, cotangent, spinor bundles). - Velocity
The same Kepler relation (transverse speed inversely proportional to distance at constant angular momentum) recurs in every central-force orbit. - Virtual black hole
The gravitational analog of virtual electron-positron pairs: the same virtual-loop shape at the Planck scale ('black holes appearing and disappearing in pairs, like other virtual particles'). - Water molecule
Every water molecule offers the same two-donor, two-acceptor interface, so any one joins any network; in living membranes the aquaporin pore keeps its NPA region and ar/R filter 'highly preserved in AQPs' across the family. Identity of a species is the dark twin's edge, hence partial. - Water pollution
Chlorination, first used in England in 1897, was taken up unchanged by Jersey City and Chicago in 1915 and then other cities; effluent standards use one parameter set (oxygen demand, solids, nitrogen, coliforms) across plants. - Wave
One equation reused across media: 'This same differential equation describes the behavior of mechanical vibrations and electromagnetic fields in a homogeneous isotropic non-conducting solid'; the same reaction-diffusion maths describes Cdk1 waves, allele spread and the spread of farming across Europ - Weakly outer trapped surface (WOTS)
The same sign test, applied with equality allowed, groups OTS, MOTS and weakly trapped surfaces into one class. - Weakly past-trapped surface
The causal orientation of one vector, H, sorts every closed surface; the past test copies the future one with the arrow reversed. - Weather
Weather on other planets 'follows many of the same physical principles' in other gases and scales: methane rain on Titan, a 300-year anticyclone on Jupiter; and the solar wind's 'space weather' has pressure and wind analogues. - Weathering
One module, crystal growth fed by capillary films, works unchanged for ice and for salt: 'As with ice segregation, the surfaces of the salt grains draw in additional dissolved salts through capillary action'. - Wetland
Constructed wetlands copy the wetland's working module (vegetation, soil, organisms) into engineered treatment beds, and it still works: they 'use the natural functions of vegetation, soil, and organisms to provide secondary treatment to wastewater' and 'also act as a biofilter'. Partial: the module - Weyl solution
The Newtonian potential reused: psi obeys Laplace's equation like Phi_N obeys Poisson's, and 'the similarities ... inspire people to find out the Newtonian analogue of psi'. - White dwarf
A ceiling fixed by constants (M_Pl^3/m_H^2) makes every Type Ia explode at nearly the same mass, so the light curves recur almost identically (standard candles, M_V about -19.3, sigma <= 0.3). - Wound healing
The wound re-uses modules: eATP through P2X receptors closes epithelial wounds in a cnidarian and in vertebrates ('an evolutionarily ancient strategy'); purse-string and lamellipodial closure recur from embryos to adult corneas and zebrafish skin; regenerating Acomys follicles 're-deploy molecular p - X boson (X and Y bosons; hypothetical GUT gauge bosons)
One field, many states: the photon, W, Z, gluon and X are 'different states of a single particle field', and 'all currently known matter particles fit perfectly into three copies of the smallest group representations of SU(5)'.
Candidate (2)
- Neutron star
Electron capture (electrons driven into protons to make neutrons) recurs as the same room in four buildings: the massive star's core collapse, the supernova's neutronisation, the O-Ne-Mg white dwarf's collapse threshold, and the neutron star's ground floor. Found while applying the accretion-induced - Neutron star merger
The merger's ejecta stack repeats the supernova's: ejecta at a fraction of c, a sweep-up that 'creates a supernova-remnant-like bubble holding a lethal dose of cosmic rays', then enrichment of the gas. Now both land on the same ISM floors (injection L2, enrichment L4). Found after the ISM re-point.
Surface: a resemblance (79)
- 4-simplex (5-cell, pentachoron)
One flat block, in two causal orientations, recurs throughout every CDT configuration; geometry comes only from how copies are glued. - African elephant (genus Loxodonta: bush and forest elephants)
After poaching, daughters took over their mothers' network positions and the network's shape held: the role worked with a new holder - Barrett-Crane model (spin-foam model of 4d quantum gravity; projected model)
One unique intertwiner (Reisenberger's uniqueness proof) stamped on every tetrahedron. - BF theory (topological gauge theory; walked as a projected model)
One state-sum recipe in every dimension: label dual faces by representations, dual edges by intertwiners, multiply amplitudes, sum (6j in 3d, 15j in 4d). - Bianchi dust (spatially homogeneous dust cosmologies)
One module recurs: the Kasner (Bianchi I) regime reappears as each period of the approach to the singularity in the general types, and as the early limit of Kasner dust. - Casimir effect
'Any medium supporting oscillations has an analogue of the Casimir effect': beads on a string, plates in turbulent water or gas, liquid crystals. - Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes)
A human module used by another species: Arabic numerals 1-19 and colour/object/number keys work for chimpanzees (Ai: red + pencil + 5) - City
The grid plan, a fixed street-and-plot module, recurs for millennia across Asia, Europe and the Americas (Mohenjo-daro, Harappa, Priene) and still works. - Classical Hamiltonian constraint
The same shape in the simplest system: a parametrized clock and pendulum gives C = p_t + p^2/2m + m omega^2 x^2/2 = 0, 'our Hamiltonian constraint', the condition of constancy of energy; GR's constraint is the non-trivial case. - Classroom
The monitorial hall as a module copied across systems: Bell's Madras system adopted at the Royal Military School and the Royal Hibernian Military School - Climate change
One module, the heat engine, is used unchanged at two scales: the whole atmosphere read as a heat engine whose work is the circulation, and a mature hurricane read as a Carnot engine with efficiency near one third. The reuse is in the scientists' model; whether the system itself reuses a module is n - Conformal Killing vector field
One equation, L_X g = lambda g, grades isometries, homotheties and conformal motions, recurring in every metric from flat spacetime to curved ones. - Cortical folding (gyrification: the cerebral cortex folds into gyri and sulci)
Most major convolutions recur between individuals and across species ('conserved between individuals and are also found across species') - Cosmic string
'all these apparently different types of string are just the same object as it appears in different regions of parameter space' (string dualities): one string recurring as F-string, D-string and wrapped brane (idea at 11; surface here). - CP symmetry (and its violation)
The same repair move twice: when P failed, C was combined with it to restore a symmetry (CP); when CP failed, T was combined (CPT, exact). - CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical)
Pair creation at the largest scale: the same particle-antiparticle pair template the vacuum uses for electron-positron pairs, applied to a whole universe. - Dark energy
One parametrization, CPL w(a) = w0 + wa(1 - a), stands in for "a variety of scalar field models", the module the field reuses to compare models; the QCD reading has to be translated into it for an apples-to-apples comparison. - de Sitter group SO(4,1) (isometry group of de Sitter spacetime)
A ladder of symmetries, each the limit of the one above: de Sitter -> Poincare (R -> infinity) -> Galilean (c -> infinity); generators are renamed with a scale and the scale sent away. - Earth in the Paleozoic era (Cambrian to Permian)
The GOBE 'established the marine ecological template for the remainder of the Paleozoic'; the word is the source's, the recurrence is of a community structure, not a conserved module. - Earth in the Proterozoic eon (2500 to 538.8 Ma)
The same cycle recurring: 'tectonic processes of the Proterozoic Eon resemble greatly the evidence of tectonic activity, such as orogenic belts or ophiolite complexes, we see today'. - Earth's core
The same induction equation and Lorentz-force physics run unchanged in the core, the Sun and liquid-sodium experiments; models tested in one are used for the others. Surface: a shared law, not a module swapped between systems. - Epistemology (the theory of knowledge: the study and the knowing it studies)
One set of sources reused across schools: perception, inference and testimony 'discussed by most schools' of Indian epistemology; the JTB analysis as the reference template every repair modifies. - Equivalence principle
One response to gravity copied into every body regardless of what it is made of: the same trajectory for a feather, a hammer, titanium and platinum. - Frenet-Serret (TNB) frame
One module recurring by dimension: three legs (1847/1851), n legs (Jordan 1874), four legs on a world line. - Frenet-Serret tetrad (comoving tetrad of a world line)
One module recurring by dimension: the 1847/1851 three-leg formulas for space curves, Jordan's n-dimensional form (1874), and the four-leg spacetime form 'adapted to Minkowski spacetime'. - Galilean group (symmetry of Newtonian absolute space and time; low-speed limit of the Poincare group)
Every slow frame relates to every other by the same composition of rotation, translation and uniform motion. - Geodesic focusing
One equation, two copies: the timelike and the optical Raychaudhuri equations differ only in the theta^2 coefficient and the projector. - Gravitational constant G
One number recurs identically in every gravitational coupling: Newton's force, Kepler's periods, the field equations' kappa, the horizon radius 2GM/c^2. - Great tit (Parus major)
Neuronal non-CpG methylation patterns like mammals', read as a universal role in neuronal epigenetic regulation - Group of spacetime translations (R^4 under addition)
The same abelian normal subgroup R^4 sits under the Poincare and Galilean groups; only what acts on it (Lorentz or homogeneous Galilean) differs. - Hawking-Ellis type I stress-energy
One diagonal form recurs in fluids, dust, radiation and non-null fields: rho plus three pressures in a rest frame. - Hawking-Ellis type II stress-energy
The null-dust form T = f k k recurs wherever radiation is coherent: the same rank-one null tensor as light's propagation. - Hawking-Ellis type II0 stress-energy (pure null radiation)
One subtraction recipe ('from type II subtract out as much of type I as possible') yields a core for each of types II, III and IV, each with simple algebra (nilpotent of order 2 and 3 for II0 and III0). - Hawking-Ellis type III stress-energy
III0 squares into the II0 form (null radiation): the nilpotent ladder II0 (order 2) and III0 (order 3) repeats one null-vector module one step higher. - Holonomy (parallel transport round closed loops; its trace is the Wilson loop)
The Mandelstam identities of Wilson loops in gauge theory recur in LQG's intersecting loops, removed there by the spin-network basis. - Human culture
A cultural norm 'serves as a template for expectations in a social group': one shared form members reuse in every situation it covers. - Human society (from local community up to societies)
Army units repeat the factor-of-three nesting of everyday groups (sections ~10-12, platoons ~35, companies ~120-150); the authors ask whether armies copied natural groupings. - Improper rotation (rotoreflection, rotoinversion)
One operation (rotation then perpendicular mirror) recurs as a symmetry element in unrelated molecules (SiF4, ethane, allene, methane) and in crystals (rotoinversion axes). - Insider threat
One programme template (22 best practices mapped to NIST, ISO and NITTF standards) offered across sectors and sizes; the swap working unchanged is not shown. - Intruder (burglar and trespasser)
One legal crime type reused with new methods slotted in: car thefts by relay attack 'are still car thefts'; the crime type is the module, the method changes. - Kaon (K meson)
Strangeness is a conserved label the strong force cannot change: strange particles are always made in pairs (associated production) and the lightest ones must wait for the weak force, the same template that keeps charm and bottom hadrons long-lived. - KKL model (EPRL spin foams on arbitrary 2-cell complexes; projected model)
The EPRL vertex as a conserved module, copied at vertices of any valence. - Labelled 2-complex (the cell structure a spin foam lives on)
The same rule one dimension up: 'this definition is exactly like that of a spin network, but with everything one dimension higher! This is why a generic slice of a spin foam is a spin network.' - Late Devonian mass extinction (Kellwasser and Hangenberg events), with the Carboniferous radiation it released
A bottleneck as a template-setter: 'those few species that survived the bottleneck were the evolutionary starting point for all vertebrates', and traits like five-digit limbs 'may have been set by this early common ancestor'. Convergence by loss, not a module copied, so surface. - Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model)
One labelled-graph format (spin networks) is the basis for every quantum state of space, and the boundary of every spin-foam history is again a spin network. - Loxodromic Moebius transformation (boost with rotation about the boost axis)
The logarithmic spiral of a constant-bearing (rhumb-line) course recurs as the flow of a loxodromic map on the Riemann sphere and as the sky seen by a boosting, spinning observer. - Metamorphic rock
Pseudomorphs keep a replaced crystal's shape ('quartz after coesite'); the shape outlasts the mineral. Surface: a kept outline, not a module reused across systems. - Misner space
The Misner region recurs as a module: in Taub-NUT (its 3+1 parent), and inside the Gott two-string spacetime (generalized Misner space, Grant; Laurence built the isometries). - Motivation
One valuation module serves many rewards: cocaine, sex, food and money all activate the ventral pallidum in humans; the temporal-difference teaching term from machine learning matches dopamine responses. - Multiverse (the hypothetical ensemble of universes; walked as a projected model)
Level I: the same laws in every Hubble volume, configurations recurring identically ('an entire Hubble volume identical to ours'); Level II breaks the template between bubbles. - Natural environment
Life in the natural environment shares one form: 'a carbon- and water-based cellular form with complex organization and heritable genetic information' across plants, animals, fungi, protists, archaea and bacteria. Owned by life; seen here. - Neutron star magnetosphere
Michel's split-monopole wind is reused as the wind zone of the dipole: 'the wind from the dipole rotator is similar to that from a split monopole with equal open magnetic flux'. - Nuclear fission
The liquid-drop fissility (Coulomb against twice the surface energy) is carried unchanged from nuclei to metal clusters, where the cluster papers speak of a fission barrier and fissilities in the nuclear words. Surface: the module reused is a description physicists carry over, not a part swapped bet - Ocean currents (the ocean circulation)
One Ekman mechanism reused in three wind settings (along coasts, at the equator's trade-wind divergence, in open-ocean gyres) to make upwelling or downwelling. - Orca (killer whale, Orcinus orca)
Discrete stereotyped calls repeated and handed on unchanged across generations - Pauli exclusion principle
One rule, identical in nuclei (proton and neutron gases), atoms, metals and stars. - Penrose transform
The same two-stage construction (pull back, push down) recurs for every spin n/2 and, in general form, for every double fibration G/H1 <- G/(H1 n H2) -> G/H2. - Photon sphere
Each extra half-orbit makes a self-similar copy of the ring, exponentially narrower and weaker, image after image (spacing ratio e^(2 pi)). - Planet
One formation process 'now thought to be at work throughout the universe': disk, planetesimals, embryos, planets, from the Solar System to exoplanets. - Plant seed
'This seed model is shared by basically all gymnosperms': one build reused across a whole group. - Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies)
Electoral systems and constitutional designs copied across countries and still working; booked surface (the sources read name the rules, not a swap test). - Pollution
The Air Convention's frame-plus-protocols module reused unchanged for sulphur, nitrogen, VOCs, POPs and heavy metals (Table 1 of Grennfelt 2020). - Ponzano-Regge model (state sum for 3d quantum gravity; projected model)
The same 6j block at every tetrahedron of every triangulation; discretization independence means the answer does not depend on how the blocks are laid. - Proteostasis (the cell's network that makes, folds, repairs and clears its proteins)
The core chaperone machineries are 'already present in prokaryotes' and the UPR is 'conserved between mammalian species, as well as yeast and worms'; the heat shock response is 'universal'. - Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
One fundamental string whose different oscillation modes appear as all the particles, one of them always a graviton. - Region of the causal subdivision about an event
The same four-way subdivision recurs about every event; the causal structure is that template laid down everywhere. - Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
Electric and magnetic charge enter the metric identically: Q^2 -> Q^2 + P^2. - Rotation group SO(3) (the 3D rotation group)
The same three-parameter rotation group is the rotation part of the Euclidean, Galilean and Lorentz groups. - SE(3): the group of rigid motions of three-dimensional space
The screw (rotation with proportional slide) recurs as the displacement of any rigid body, as crystal screw axes, as the helical axis of joint motion, and as rifling twist. - Spin (intrinsic angular momentum)
'All elementary particles of a given kind have the same magnitude of spin angular momentum'; one value per particle type everywhere. - Spin foam (covariant loop quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
The same labelled-graph unit recurs one dimension down at every boundary: every spin foam is bounded by spin networks, as an n-manifold is bounded by an (n-1)-manifold. - Spin network (labelled graph; a state of quantum geometry)
The same labelled-graph rule recurs one dimension up: a spin foam is labelled 'exactly like that of a spin network, but with everything one dimension higher'. - Spin-statistics theorem
One count rule for every composite: baryons, nuclei and atoms are fermions or bosons by the parity of their fermion count. - Star cluster (open and globular)
Members carry one composition and one age, so 'Various properties of all the stars in a cluster are a function only of mass'; open clusters are single populations to 0.02-0.05 dex. The shared template is the natal gas. - Strong equivalence principle
The test particle's free fall is copied into bodies made largely of their own gravity: a pulsar falls like its white-dwarf companion, the Earth like the Moon. - Translations in space (R^3)
The same abelian normal subgroup of translations sits under E(3) and, joined with time, under the Poincare and Galilean groups. - Twistor spaces of hyperkähler manifolds
Twistor theory's incidence relation (a point is a line in twistor space) recurs on curved quaternionic bases: points of a hyperkähler manifold are rational curves in its twistor space. - Water cycle (hydrologic cycle)
The precipitationshed is defined 'in much the same way that a watershed is defined': the same catchment idea applied to the air. - Weak equivalence principle (universality of free fall)
One free-fall response is copied into every uncharged body whatever it is made of: a feather and a hammer, titanium and platinum, lead balls of different mass.
Maybe (1)
- Classical sequential growth (CSG) dynamics
Cosmic renormalisation: whatever the first couplings, each bounce (post) pulls the next epoch's dynamics toward one template, transitive percolation.