← all systems · see it in The System
Entrepreneurship
Entrepreneurship is the discovery and pursuit of opportunities to create or extract economic value by founding and growing new ventures, under uncertainty that cannot be measured in advance (src:wp:entrepreneurship; Knight 1921). Economists describe the entrepreneur's role in four classic ways that are still argued over: Cantillon's buyer at a certain price who resells at an uncertain one, Knight's bearer of unmeasurable uncertainty, Schumpeter's innovator whose new combinations replace the old (creative destruction), and Kirzner's alert arbitrageur who discovers what others missed. Management research studies who becomes an entrepreneur, how opportunities are found, judged and organised, and how ventures are financed, tested, grow or fail; growth economics studies its effects on jobs, productivity and innovation. Walked here as the practice together with the people who do it and the ventures they found.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | contested (C-2397): as old as trade for gain; the word in a French commercial dictionary in 1723; the role defined by Cantillon (Essai, 1755) |
| born precision | centuries |
| boundary | Inside: the entrepreneur (or founding team), the opportunity they pursue, the judgement and decisions taken under uncertainty, the people, money and things they assemble, and the venture while it is being made and grown. Outside: the market the venture enters, the incumbents it competes with, the investors and lenders, the labour market, the state and its rules, family and peers, and the wider economy that its entries and exits reshape. The line shifts as a venture matures: once it runs an existing product for an existing market it reads as an ordinary business (src:hurst-pugsley-2011-small-business). |
| nested level | Built from people (entrepreneurs, nascent and serial founders, teams), opportunities and the resources they recombine; carried out through new ventures (startups, new small businesses) and inside existing firms (intrapreneurship); embedded in markets, financial markets and the economy, and in the law that allows or limits entry. It runs on people: their judgement, confidence and actions. |
| scale | social |
Measures (20) published science
| relative odds of upper-tail growth, founder aged 50 vs 30 | 1.8 ratio |
| characteristic clock: the up-or-out window of young firms | about the first ten years |
| mean founder age, all US founders 2007-2014 who hired | 41.9 years |
| ten-year survival of private firms | about 34 percent |
| mean founder age, top 0.1% growth new ventures | 45.0 years |
| share of VC-backed startups terminated at a loss (US, first rounds 1985-2009) | about 55 percent |
| failure rate: VC-backed vs matched non-VC ventures | 75 vs 66 percent |
| probability of entrepreneurship by number of prior roles (Stanford alumni) | 3 (fewer than three roles) to 29 (over 16 roles) percent |
| gross return share of the top 6% of VC-backed startups | about 50 percent |
| effect of parental entrepreneurship on children's (Sweden) | about +60 percent |
| variance explained by a polygenic index | 0.2 percent |
| twin-study heritability of entrepreneurship | around 50 percent |
| new businesses founded mainly for non-pecuniary reasons (Kauffman Firm Survey) | over 50 percent |
| household concentration of private equity | about 75 percent of private equity held by households for whom it is at least half of net worth |
| ADHD-likely share, established entrepreneurs (China survey) | 8 (13 of 173) percent |
| 90-50 employment growth differential, US firms 1999 | about 31 percent |
| lifetime self-employment among US men | about half have a year or more by retirement share of working men |
| VC fund management fee | 1.0-2.5 per year (plus carried interest up to 20% of profits) percent |
| tax sensitivity of entry (US states) | a 50-point cut in the top rate for a 1% change percentage points |
| self-employment rate 2021 (OECD table) | 6.3 (USA) to 53.1 (Colombia) percent of employment |
Open contentions (5) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-3011 What is the entrepreneur's role in an economy?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Schumpeter: the entrepreneur did not bear risk, the capitalist did; Knight: uncertainty-bearing is the entrepreneur's income; Kirzner: most innovations are incremental and need no special qualities; Say: moving resources to higher productivity - C-3012 Does entrepreneurship drive economic growth?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: the link is an interpretation of the growth residual and still debated; most small businesses neither innovate nor want to grow (Hurst and Pugsley); innovations mostly incremental (Kirzner) - C-3013 Is entrepreneurship inherited or learned?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: mostly heritable (Nicolaou et al., via Heller et al.); mostly upbringing and role models (Lindquist et al.); learned skill: serial founders exit less - C-3014 Does starting a business pay off for the founder?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: non-pecuniary benefits, a taste for skewness or overoptimism explain entry; measuring 'entrepreneurs' as all self-employed hides the incorporated who do earn more; experimentation explains lower average earnings (Manso, via Kerr et al.) - C-3026 Are business opportunities discovered or made?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: discovery: gaps exist and alert people find them; creation: goals and opportunities emerge from means and action; realist: opportunities as propensities, known only after exploitation
Cross-scale patterns seen here (19) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Entrepreneurship. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- nested ladder (structural)
Knight's risk, ambiguity and true uncertainty: each a stronger form of not knowing the jar's contents (known ratio, unknown white balls, wholly unknown), each implying the ones below. - same role, different builds (structural)
The job 'bear unmeasurable uncertainty to try something new' is done by unrelated structures: a lone founder's savings, a VC fund's portfolio of staged equity, a corporation's intrapreneurship unit, a cooperative or social enterprise, a state's grant programme. - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (structural)
Yin et al.: agents who start similar split at a critical threshold into stagnation or progression after failure; the cut is named (the critical point in the share of past attempts reused). - trade one property for another (structural)
Bootstrapping keeps ownership and control at the cost of capital and speed; outside equity buys capital and growth (VC-backed employment +364% vs +67%) at the cost of ownership and control ('a windfall for the investors and a huge loss for the entrepreneur'). Ventures settle at different points of t - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
Each entrepreneur carves a different slice of the same market: opportunities are seen by those with the relevant experience and access ('preferential access ... or the ability to recognize information about opportunities'); entrepreneurs perceive less uncertainty than others in the same situation. - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Serial founders: skills and patterns first borrowed from employers' industries and parents (Azoulay; 75% of male founders in their father's industry), then held as their own experience across ventures (owners with a prior business exit less). Both phases shown at the person level, not the practice's - coordination-before-mapping (partial)
Effectuation: start from means at hand and let goals emerge, coordinating partners' commitments without a prior plan or prediction of the market ('predictions are not possible'). - holding / entrainment (partial)
VC funds set the clock of their ventures: staged rounds decide when a venture continues or dies; investors' continuation decisions are made 'before a new idea even has a chance to compete in a market'. - lightning (partial)
The gale of creative destruction: a new combination released into a market that then is not the same (old industries destroyed, new ones made). Schumpeter describes it as incessant mutation rather than a single stored discharge, so partial. - red-queen (partial)
Escape competition: neck-and-neck firms innovate to get ahead of each other; Aghion et al.'s steady state has both sides innovating, with leadership changing hands. Both sides improve; whether neither gains ground over the long run is a model result, not a measured stalemate, so partial. - runaway from an unstable balance (partial)
Near Yin et al.'s critical point, small differences in how much is reused from past attempts run away into success or stagnation. - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
One competition mechanism with its sign reversed by sector: more product-market competition raises innovation in neck-and-neck sectors (escape competition) and lowers it for laggards (Schumpeterian effect), giving the inverted U. - seed (partial)
A venture idea: a small packet (a new combination) whose arrival can open new industries, products and business models (the horseless carriage became the auto industry by incremental improvements). The combinatorics unpacked are sourced as new industries, not counted, so partial. - templating (partial)
The VC limited-partnership template (general partner, limited partners, 1-2.5% fee, up to 20% carry) emerged once and is reused unchanged across funds; accelerator cohorts copied the Y Combinator format (none in 2004, over 40 by 2013). - The carry (partial)
Overflow passed on: when a venture needs more capital than its owners can hold ('Many businesses need more capital than can be provided by the owners themselves'), the excess need is passed to outside finance (angels, VC, debt), round after round; each stage waits for the experiment's signal before - The Payment to Entropy (partial)
Every hand-off of investors' money to ventures pays a toll: limited partners pay 1.0-2.5% a year in fees plus up to 20% carried interest; of the money passed on, about 55% of VC-backed startups end at a loss. Form: financial. The loss to limited partners is partly a hand-off to the fund managers (da - who opens the door (partial)
Entry into a trade: in German crafts the state opened or closed the door (the Meister certificate required 1935 and 1953, not required in 1908-era rules); in VC the investor's term sheet is a port built before the venture arrives. - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (surface)
Knight's three kinds of uncertainty (risk, ambiguity, true uncertainty) as a ladder where the empty slot (true uncertainty) is where entrepreneurship sits; the structure names the kind before cases are sorted into it. A typology more than a map with predicted members, so surface. - not-diluting wins (surface)
Skewed returns: the top 6% of VC-backed startups (returning more than five times) take about half the gross return while the rest thin out to losses. A winner by growth, not by not-diluting, so surface (dark twin noted).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (14) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Small business via sys:market · Entrepreneurship gain
- Startup company via sys:market · Entrepreneurship gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Entrepreneurship gain
- Prefrontal cortex via sys:electrochemical-gradient · Entrepreneurship gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:law · Entrepreneurship mixed
- Family (the human family as a system) via sys:human-society · Entrepreneurship gain
- Financial market (hierarchical tree of stocks) via sys:financial-market · Entrepreneurship gain
- Social network via sys:human-society · Entrepreneurship gain
- Market and trade via sys:human-society · Entrepreneurship gain
- Labour market via sys:human-society · Entrepreneurship gain
- Technology via sys:mental-representation · Entrepreneurship gain
- Economy via sys:human-society · Entrepreneurship gain
- Incumbent firm via sys:market · Entrepreneurship gain
- Venture capital via sys:financial-market · Entrepreneurship gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
Sits inside / holds (4)
expressed by (19)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Search/Foraging
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Risk-managed Exploration
- Intrinsic Motivation / Curiosity-Driven Sampling
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Hypothesis Portfolio / Multiple Hypothesis Tracking
- Optimal Stopping & Patch-Switching
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Resilience & Repair
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
floor filled by (13)
- Business
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Prefrontal cortex
- Law (rules and law)
- Family (the human family as a system)
- Market and trade
- Labour market
- Technology
- Economy
- Small business
- Startup company
- Venture capital
- Creative destruction
Kinds (18)
- Small business
- Startup company
- Social entrepreneurship
- Intrapreneurship
- Serial entrepreneurship
- Project-based entrepreneurship
- Portfolio entrepreneurship
- Nascent entrepreneurship
- Necessity entrepreneurship
- Cultural entrepreneurship
- Ethnic entrepreneurship
- Institutional entrepreneurship
- Political entrepreneurship
- Incorporated self-employed (entrepreneurs in the Levine-Rubinstein sense)
- Darwinian founder
- Communitarian founder
- Missionary founder
- Business
Notes published science
- The most successful startup founders are not young: across 2.7 million US founders who hired between 2007 and 2014, the founders of the fastest-growing 1 in 1,000 new firms were 45 on average, and a 50-year-old founder was 1.8 times as likely as a 30-year-old to build one (src:azoulay-2018-age-entrepreneurship).
- Venture investors can't pick winners in advance: about 55% of US venture-backed startups (first funded 1985-2009) were shut down at a loss, while the best 6% brought in about half of all the money returned (src:kerr-2014-experimentation).
- Entrepreneurship runs in families, but mostly through upbringing, not birth: in Swedish adoption records, adoptive parents who ran businesses passed it on about twice as strongly as the biological parents did. Twin studies point the other way (heritability around 50%), so the question stays open (src:lindquist-2012-entrepreneurial-parents, src:heller-2022-genetics-entrepreneurship).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
entrepreneurship as economists and management scholars describe it: market change to new ventures that replace the old (reader's view)
- L1: The changing market world: prices, wants, technologies and rivals, continually throwing up new information about where resources would earn more
- L2: Opportunities noticed: chances to recombine resources for profit, seen by some before others (Kirzner's alertness; Schumpeter's first movers)
- L3: The entrepreneur: the person (or team) with the access, experience and traits that let them see and act on this opportunity; middle-aged, industry-experienced, balanced skills in the evidence
- L4: Judgement under true uncertainty: deciding whether to exploit, with no statistics to guide it (Knight); explore-or-exploit choices; effectuation's start from means at hand
- L5: Organising: raising money, hiring people, acquiring equipment, forming a legal entity; moving resources to higher-yield use (Say)
- L6: The venture as an experiment: a new firm, product or business model put to the market, continued or abandoned as signals come in
- L7: Purpose and action on the world: profit (and the owner's own reasons) pursued through new combinations that replace old products, firms and methods: creative destruction
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Judgement and decision under true uncertainty: whether to exploit an opportunity, explore or exploit; effectuation's means-first reasoning
- L5: Organising: money raised, people hired, equipment bought, a legal entity formed, a team built
- L6: The venture as an experiment: continued, changed or abandoned as signals come in
- L7: Purpose: profit (and the founder's own reasons) pursued through new combinations that replace the old
way in: Capital: own savings, debt, venture and angel equity
- L1: Money available: owners' savings, bank loans, angel and venture funds, grants
- L2: Bootstrapping first: methods to keep outside money to a minimum
- L3: The founder's own wealth staked, undiversified
way in: Emotion: confidence, venturesomeness, fear of failure
- L1: Feeling about an uncertain venture
- L2: Perceived uncertainty lower than others perceive it
- L3: Overconfidence and its opposite: distrust, which in one study went with survival
way in: Knowledge and invention: technologies, ideas, industry experience
- L1: Inventions and technologies that could become products and services
- L2: New combinations seen: existing inputs put together a new way (steam engine plus wagon-making makes the horseless carriage)
- L3: Experience carried in: prior employment in the sector, variety of roles held
way in: Market signals: unmet wants, prices, gaps
- L1: Market change: shifts in wants, prices and technologies that leave resources in lower-yield use
- L2: Alertness: price gaps and unmet needs noticed (Kirzner's alert arbitrageur; Cantillon's buy-certain, sell-uncertain)
- L3: The noticing person: biased toward seeing new possibilities and unmet needs
way in: People: family, peers, role models, networks
- L1: Family and peers who have founded firms
- L2: Seeing others go out on their own
- L3: Carried into the person: parental entrepreneurship and its industry, by upbringing more than birth in adoptee data (contested against twin studies)
way in: Rivals: incumbents and other entrants
- L1: Incumbents and other entrants in the same market
- L2: Competition felt: neck-and-neck rivals push to innovate to get ahead
way in: Rules: entry law, licences, taxes
- L1: The state's rules for who may start what, and taxes
- L2: Rules met at entry: licences and certificates
- L3: Weighed by the would-be founder; taxes move entry only a little
way in: Test results: customers' and investors' answers to the venture
- L1: The market and investors respond to what the venture puts out
- L2: A signal from the experiment: positive or not
- L3: Read as learning from failure: each attempt built on earlier ones, or not
way in: The founder's body and wellbeing: stress, motivation, autonomy
- L1: The founder's own state under the venture's uncertainty
- L2: Symptoms and traits felt and reported: attention, stress
- L3: Wellbeing and the non-pecuniary pull: being one's own boss, flexibility; lower wellbeing while nascent
way in: Thought: the venture idea
- L1: An idea of a possible venture, arriving from experience, information or elsewhere (origin contested)
- L2: Whether opportunities are found or made is argued: they can only be identified after exploitation
- L3: An opportunity belief held by the person
way out: Displacement: old products, firms and methods replaced
- L1: Incumbents' products and rents displaced
- L7: New combinations replace the old
way out: Exit: abandon, sell, list or close
- L1: Returns to investors: most lost, a few very large
- L6: Continue or stop the experiment
way out: Founding: a new firm and its product put on the market
- L1: A new venture offering its product to buyers
- L5: Organise: facilities, finance, legal entity, team
- L7: Purpose: pursue the opportunity for profit
way out: Hiring: jobs created (and destroyed on exit)
- L1: Jobs created by young firms, and destroyed when they exit
- L5: Hiring people
way out: Pitching and communicating: vision to team, investors and partners
- L1: Spoken and written to investors, partners and staff
- L6: A vision of the venture