← all systems · see it in The System
Labour market
The labour market is where workers supply their labour and employers (firms, governments, other organisations) demand it, and wages and employment are set. Economists treat it like other markets, with supply and demand jointly determining the price (the wage rate) and the quantity (the number of people employed), but it differs: labour laws shape it, it may not clear, so unemployment persists, and similar workers earn persistently different pay. Since the 1970s the search and matching (Diamond-Mortensen-Pissarides) view describes it as costly, time-consuming meetings between job seekers and vacancies, with a matching function, a bargained split of each match's surplus and constant flows of hiring, job creation and job destruction. Its institutions are labour law, trade unions and collective bargaining, minimum wages and unemployment insurance; imperfect competition (monopsony), asymmetric information (signalling, efficiency wages) and discrimination are part of its standard description. Walked as that market; the worker-employer relation itself is wage labour, the study of it labour economics.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | contested (C-2592): wage disputes by 1152 BCE; mass wage labour with the Industrial Revolution |
| born precision | n/a |
| boundary | Inside: the meetings, bargains and contracts through which people's work is exchanged for pay (job search and recruitment, the matching of a worker to a vacancy, wage setting by individual or collective bargaining, the employment relation's start and end) and the stocks and flows this produces (employment, unemployment, vacancies). Outside: what goes on inside each firm once a worker is hired (internal labour markets are personnel economics' share, on the boundary), the households' other uses of time (the non-labour force), the goods markets and the state, which reach it through demand, law and policy. |
| nested level | Built from workers (households, the labour force) and employers (firms and other organisations), with intermediaries, unions and the rules of labour law; a kind of market (factor market for labour); part of the economy; runs on its people's choices (workers' and managers' decisions). |
| scale | social |
Measures (23) published science
| share of US work force in agriculture | 41 (1900) to 2 (2000) percent |
| monthly job finding probability (US, 1948-2007) | 45 (post-war average) percent per month |
| monthly employment exit probability (US, 1948-2007) | 3.4 percentage points per month |
| expected wait in unemployment implied by the job finding probability | about 2.2 (1 / 0.45) months |
| share of unemployment-rate fluctuations from the job finding probability | 75 (95 in the last two decades to 2007) percent |
| monthly job finding probability, job losers not on layoff vs other unemployed (1976-2007) | 31.7 vs 48.2 percent per month |
| average labour market concentration (HHI) | 3,157 (threshold for high concentration 2,500) HHI |
| people unemployed worldwide (ILO, 2018) | 172 million (5% of the reported global workforce) people |
| posted wage difference, 25th to 75th percentile concentration | -17 percent |
| New Jersey fast-food employment relative to Pennsylvania after the 1992 rise | +13 percent |
| minimum wage rise studied (New Jersey, 1 April 1992) | 4.25 to 5.05 US dollars per hour |
| household union income premium, US 1936- | 10 to 20 log points |
| own-wage elasticity of employment for minimum wages (median of 36 US studies) | -0.17 elasticity |
| relative wage response to immigration-driven supply (Borjas 2003) | -0.57 per 1% supply percent |
| Miami labour force increase after the Mariel boatlift (1980) | 7 percent in a few months |
| earnings premium per extra year of schooling | about 7 percent |
| major US strikes and lockouts per year | 381 (1970), 187 (1980), 11 (2010) count per year |
| symptom change after re-employment, between groups (SMD) | -0.27 (95% CI -0.35 to -0.20) Cohen's d |
| mental health symptoms, unemployed vs employed (SMD) | 0.19 (95% CI 0.08 to 0.30) Cohen's d |
| increase in death rates after job displacement (20 years) | 15-20 percent |
| implied life expectancy loss, worker displaced at 40 | about 1.5 years |
| women's labour force participation over the past century (many high-income countries) | more than tripled ratio |
| Ford's five-dollar day (1914) | wages doubled for most workers ratio |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-2028 Does raising the minimum wage cost jobs?
booked: The map books the reanalysis finding of a limited effect and keeps the textbook reading beside it.
the other reading: a higher minimum wage reduces employment substantially (textbook model, pre-1990 time series); small or no employment effects (Card and Krueger; Dube 2019 summary) - C-2282 Does immigration lower wages?
booked: The map keeps the findings side by side.
the other reading: negligible; negative for some skill groups - C-2592 When did a labour market first exist?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a labour market only with mass free wage labour (industrial era); wage labour, and markets for it, in the ancient world - C-2598 How much power do employers have over wages?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: labour markets close to competitive; monopsony power widespread - C-2608 Does lower unemployment mean higher inflation in the long run?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a stable exploitable trade-off (as many read Phillips after 1958); short-run only; a natural rate in the long run - C-2619 What causes unemployment?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: the market clears; unemployment is frictional and voluntary; involuntary unemployment from deficient demand or rigid wages - C-2620 Is wage labour a fair exchange or something else?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a voluntary exchange of a service; 'wage slavery'
Cross-scale patterns seen here (24) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Labour market. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- conservation law plus closure (structural)
The flow balance (inflow to unemployment equals outflow) fixes only a curve, the Beveridge curve, not a point on it; the job creation condition (free entry of vacancies) and a wage rule (Nash bargaining, 'compatible with other wage-setting rules') close it. - same role, different builds (structural)
One job, putting people's work to the tasks that need doing, is met by different builds: a market where workers sell labour for a wage; assignment by political authority, serfdom, indenture and forced labour (the wage-labour page's list of how labour is traded); and in ant colonies, distributed task - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
Monopsony is monopoly with the sign flipped at the level of one rule: the monopolist's markup and the monopsonist's markdown are both the reciprocal of the elasticity the firm faces, of product demand for one and of labour supply for the other; the 'rate of exploitation' 'equals the reciprocal of th - The carry (structural)
Two faces. The wait: a searcher waits for a match at a monthly job finding probability of about 45 percent (an implied mean wait near two months, longer for job losers at 31.7 percent), and Ford's above-market wage built queues. Overflow passed on: when Mariel added 7 percent to Miami's labour force - the whole sets the local reference (structural)
Each worker-firm pair bargains against threat points the whole market sets (each side's value on separation depends on tightness), and each searcher reads offers against the market's distribution; the local wages read true pair by pair but need not close into one market price: the law of one price n - trade one property for another (structural)
Each worker buys income with leisure under a time constraint and settles at a point on the trade (income and substitution effects; the curve can bend back). A second form: Goldin's wage penalty for jobs flexible enough for the on-call parent, flexibility paid for in pay, with workers sorted along it - who opens the door (structural)
The vacancy is a port: the firm opens it ahead of any applicant, and only while it pays (free entry). At the institutional level the state opens and shuts doors: Le Chapelier (1791) and the Combination Act (1799) shut collective bargaining, the 1824 repeal and the US 1935 legalisation opened it, and - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
Behind the employer's boundary an internal labour market grows (promotion ladders, incentive systems, long relations), unlike the external market where 'firms do not have significant discretion over wage setting'. The without-the-boundary case is the external market itself, compared not tested: part - coordination-before-mapping (partial)
Searchers coordinate with firms holding only the distribution of offers, not a map of who pays what; in the cross-domain donor, ant colonies allocate tasks by local interactions 'so there is no need for each individual to be informed about the state of the whole system'. Partial: the searcher holds - holding / entrainment (partial)
The market's tightness sets how many vacancies firms open (free entry until the value of a vacancy is zero) and the rate at which matches are born and destroyed; seasonal unemployment is a shared driver (the dark twin) and is kept apart. - lightning (partial)
A mass layoff is a sudden discharge that reroutes a life: 'what should be short-term career shocks... can have large and persistent effects', death rates highest right after displacement, then 15-20% higher for 20 years. The Mariel inflow was a discharge the Miami market absorbed with no measured wa - outside-to-inside (partial)
Pay and allocation done by the external market are taken inside firms (internal labour markets, personnel economics). The sources contrast the two; they do not show the external phase first: partial. - partner-becomes-part (partial)
The labour market is where a partner becomes a part: a worker and a firm in a gain/gain match (a surplus split by the wage) join, the worker becoming part of the firm under its direction. No inheritance: partial. - runaway from an unstable balance (partial)
Diamond (1982b): with a thick market externality, search begets search and a model has multiple steady states, so demand management can steer to the better one; cyclical unemployment 'can boomerang back and exacerbate' its causes. The runaway path between steady states is argued, not shown: partial. - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
Withdrawing labour to press a claim over pay was built separately in pharaonic Egypt (Deir el-Medina, 1152 BCE, over late wages) and in republican Rome (the plebeians' secession, which Wells called the invention of the strike), and again in industrial Britain: shared parts (collective withdrawal), s - smooth to sharp in finite time (partial)
The Diamond paradox: any search cost above zero, however small, jumps the equilibrium from the competitive price to the monopoly price; a discontinuity at a finite parameter value, not a singularity in time: partial. - templating (partial)
One definition reused unchanged across countries: national statistical agencies increasingly adopt the ILO's definition of unemployment, so the module (not working, available, actively searching) swaps between national surveys. Partial: differences remain. - The Payment to Entropy (partial)
Every hand-off of labour pays a toll in search: 'costly and time-consuming transactions are pervasive', vacancies carry a flow cost, and time spent unmatched is output lost to both sides; the market is judged 'constrained efficient' at best, given a friction 'the economy cannot avoid'. Form: a frict - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (partial)
One shared world of work, read in different slices: the searcher reads the offer distribution and her reservation wage; the firm reads marginal revenue product; the statistician reads households through the ILO's four-part definition; the policymaker reads the unemployment rate against inflation. Ea - borrowed-then-held (surface)
Wage floors were first set by unions among their members, the state recognising the unions, then held in statute as national minimum wages (New Zealand 1894, Australia 1896, the UK 1909). The job moves between parts of the market, not from surroundings to the system: surface. - causal ceiling (surface)
The employer cannot see effort or ability directly ('does not necessarily know how hard workers are working'); framed as an information cost met by signals and efficiency wages, not as a limit set by the system's structure: surface. - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (surface)
The market-structure grid (one or few sellers: monopoly, oligopoly) had empty mirror slots on the buyer side; Robinson filled 'monopsony' in 1933 (the term coined for her by Hallward), oligopsony beside it. The slot is predicted by symmetry; its properties (lower wage and employment) follow. Surface - seed (surface)
Search and matching theory as a packet that unpacked well beyond labour: consumer theory, money, industrial organisation, housing, family economics. This is the idea (rung 11 idea role), not the market: surface. - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (surface)
In the shirking model workers are identical ex ante; in equilibrium some are employed and some unemployed, the cut being whom the market happens to match. The cut is not named as a direction that sets later structure: surface.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (31) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Social network via sys:human-society · Labour market gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Labour market gain
- Government via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Industrial Revolution (the first, c. 1760 to c. 1840) via sys:human-society · Labour market gain
- Computer via sys:economy · Labour market mixed
- Education via sys:human-society · Labour market gain
- Market and trade via sys:human-society · Labour market gain
- Firm (the economic unit) via sys:market · Labour market gain
- Supply and demand via sys:market · Labour market gain
- Trade unions, friendly societies, cooperatives via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Economy via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Consumer via sys:market · Labour market gain
- Human migration via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Social class via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Central bank via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Open-source software via sys:human-society · Labour market gain
- Management via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Institution (social) via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Numeracy via sys:human-society · Labour market gain
- Early childhood education via sys:human-society · Labour market gain
- Business via sys:labour-market · Labour market mixed
- Small business via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Financial statement via sys:human-society · Labour market gain
- Startup company via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Unemployment via sys:labour-market · Labour market mixed
- Gender via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Inflation (economics) via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Entrepreneurship via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- Corporate law via sys:human-society · Labour market mixed
- International trade via sys:human-society · Labour market loss
- Tax via sys:human-society · Labour market loss
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (16)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Firm (the economic unit)
- Trade unions, friendly societies, cooperatives
- Labour law
- Labour force surveys and statistics
- Employment contract
- Competition for jobs in a recession
- Natives and immigrants in the labour market
- Applicants competing for jobs judged through class cues in speech
- Employers competing for workers (and colluding by concentration)
- Competition for jobs and housing read as economic threat
- Startups competing for skilled employees
- Small and large firms competing for workers
- Workers against firms over relative prices (inflation as conflict)
- Workers, capital owners and consumers over who bears a tax
- Whose interests the corporation is run for
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (11)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Search/Foraging
- Optimal Stopping & Patch-Switching
- Self-Monitoring
- Deterrence
floor filled by (29)
- Social network
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Government
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Firm (the economic unit)
- Supply and demand
- Trade unions, friendly societies, cooperatives
- Economy
- Labour law
- Labour force surveys and statistics
- Unemployment
- Employment agency (labour hired through an intermediary)
- Employment contract
- Minimum wage
- Job match
- International Labour Organization
- Social class
- Social stratification
- Great Depression
- Open-source software
- Numeracy
- Early childhood education
- Business
- Financial statement
- Gender
- Inflation (economics)
- Entrepreneurship
- International trade
- Tax
Kinds (6)
- Market and trade
- Supply and demand
- Gig economy
- Monopsonistic and oligopsonistic labour market
- Internal labour market
- Competitive labour market (the textbook model)
Notes published science
- Losing a job in a mass layoff raises a worker's death rate by 15-20% for the next 20 years, about a year and a half of life expectancy for someone laid off at 40. (src:sullivan-vonwachter-2007-mortality)
- In a wild lemur-like primate, males pay for mating with grooming, and the 'price' shifts with the season, the same supply-and-demand bargaining that sets a wage. (src:norscia-2009-biological-market)
- The first strike we can date is 14 November 1152 BCE: artisans building royal tombs at Deir el-Medina walked off the job because Ramesses III's government paid them late and short. (src:wp:strike-action)
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The market's state: unemployment, vacancies and tightness; monthly flows in and out of jobs; the Beveridge curve where inflow equals outflow
- L6: The rules of the game: labour law, unions and collective agreements, minimum wages, unemployment benefits, international labour standards, and policy reading the market
- L7: Allocation: who works, where and at what pay; the wage distribution, inequality and the gender gap; reallocation across occupations and places
the labour market as economists describe it: people's time and firms' work to jobs and wages (reader's view)
- L1: Workers and employers within reach of each other: the working-age population (the labour force, employed or actively looking, and those outside it) and firms and other organisations with work to be done
- L2: Labour supply and labour demand: each worker's choice between leisure and income (income and substitution effects, a supply curve that may bend back) and each firm's derived demand, hiring while the marginal revenue product exceeds marginal cost
- L3: Search and matching: unemployed workers search with a reservation wage, firms post vacancies, and a matching function turns searchers and vacancies into new hires; transactions are costly and take time
- L4: Wage setting: the bargain that splits each match's surplus (Nash bargaining with each side's outside option as threat point), collective bargaining, employers' wage-setting power (monopsony, oligopsony), efficiency wages paid above the clearing wage, and statutory minimum wages
- L5: The market's state: stocks of employment, unemployment and vacancies, tightness (vacancies per searcher), the monthly flows in and out of jobs, and the Beveridge curve where inflow equals outflow
- L6: Institutions: labour law (individual and collective), trade unions and collective agreements, minimum wages, unemployment benefits, international labour standards, and policy that reads the market (the Phillips curve, aggregate demand management)
- L7: Allocation: who works, where, in which occupation and at what pay; equilibrium wages and employment, the wage distribution and inequality, the gender gap, and the reallocation of work across sectors over time
way in: Demand for goods: the business cycle
- L1: Aggregate demand for goods and services
- L2: Aggregate shocks transmitted to the labour market
- L3: Job creation and job destruction flows
way in: Employers: firms' derived demand for labour
- L1: Firms producing goods and services; hiring labour because it helps produce output
- L2: The marginal revenue product of labour set against marginal cost
- L3: Vacancies posted while it pays (free entry); hiring directly or through intermediaries
- L4: The wage offer and the bargain: threat points are each side's payoff on separation
way in: Law and policy: the state's rules
- L1: Legislatures, courts and agencies making and enforcing labour law; it arose with the factory
- L2: Statutes: minimum wage laws (New Zealand 1894 onward; New Jersey's 1992 rise), bans and legalisations of unions (Le Chapelier 1791, Combination Act 1799, repeal 1824)
- L4: A binding wage floor raises wage costs
way in: People arriving and leaving: demography and migration
- L1: Flows into and out of the labour force: population growth, immigration, new entrants, retirements; women's participation over development
- L2: A sudden inflow: the Mariel boatlift added 7 percent to Miami's labour force
- L3: Adjustment: other migrants redirect; the industry mix absorbs
- L4: Relative wages of the groups affected (contested: negligible, or -0.57% per 1% of supply)
way in: Signals of ability and effort
- L1: Effort and ability, hidden from the employer
- L2: Signals: education read as a sign of ability
- L3: Screening fails: average pay drives out the able (adverse selection)
- L4: Efficiency wages: pay above the clearing wage to buy effort and keep workers
way in: Technology: machines and tasks
- L1: Machines and computers able to do codifiable tasks
- L2: Routine tasks, those following an exhaustive set of rules, taken over
- L3: Employment polarisation: high-wage and low-wage jobs grow, the middle shrinks
- L4: Relative wages: demand for skill outruns its supply
way in: The market reading itself: labour force statistics
- L1: Households sampled by labour force surveys, the preferred method
- L2: The ILO definition: not working, willing, available, actively searching
- L3: Monthly series: the US Current Population Survey since 1948
- L4: The unemployment rate: unemployed over labour force
way in: Workers organised: unions and collective bargaining
- L1: Workers associating to maintain or improve their conditions and bargaining power
- L2: Membership: union density, highest in the Nordic countries
- L3: Collective bargaining (the term from Beatrice Webb, 1891)
- L4: The agreement: a union premium of ten to twenty log points, compressed pay within the union
way in: Workers: people offering their time
- L1: Working-age people: the labour force (employed or actively looking) and those outside it
- L2: Participation and hours: utility over income and leisure; income and substitution effects; a supply curve that can bend back
- L3: Job search: offers sampled one after another, accepted above the reservation wage; harder search helps employers (thick market externality)
- L4: The contact with a vacancy: meetings governed by the matching function
way out: Job loss and unemployment
- L1: A person without work: more symptoms of depression, anxiety and distress; higher death rates for years after displacement
- L3: Inflows to unemployment: people who lose their jobs and look for new ones
- L7: Job destruction and separations decided
way out: Jobs filled and wages paid
- L1: A person working for money under a contract; with the pay come time structure, contact, purpose, status and activity
- L3: The match formed: a new hire
- L4: The wage agreed in the bargain
- L7: Allocation: equilibrium wage and employment
way out: Strikes and lockouts
- L1: Production stopped: the sailors who 'struck' the sails crippled the ships
- L4: The strike: workers walk off the job over pay
- L6: Bargaining breaks down under the rules in force
way out: Wage costs into prices
- L1: Prices: inflation and unemployment together
- L4: Money wage growth
- L5: Unemployment low or high
way out: Workers moving between jobs, occupations and places
- L1: The economy's job mix changes: US agriculture from 41 percent of the work force in 1900 to 2 percent in 2000
- L3: Job-to-job moves and on-the-job search
- L7: Reallocation decided: who moves where
Who fills each layer
- L5: Unemployment