← all systems · see it in The System
Supply and demand
In microeconomics, supply and demand is an economic model of price determination in a market. It postulates that, holding all else equal, the unit price for a particular good or other traded item in a perfectly competitive market, will vary until it settles at the market-clearing price, where the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied such that an economic equilibrium is achieved for price and quantity transacted. Walked as both the market behaviour (prices moving with what is wanted and what is offered) and the model economists hold of it.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | behaviour contested (C-728: biological markets far below rung 11; human exchange networks by ~33 ka per market.json, C-727); idea contested (C-2053): the Tirukkural at least 2000 years ago, the phrase 1767, the curves 1838 |
| born precision | behaviour: unknown; idea: a year for the phrase and the curves |
| boundary | Inside: the quantities buyers will take and sellers will offer for one good at each price, the price they meet at, and the adjustment that moves price when the two differ (in a market for goods, labour, money, or between animals trading grooming). Outside: the people and firms themselves (their wants, incomes, costs), the institution where offers meet (an auction, a stall, an order book), the state's rules, and other markets, held fixed in partial equilibrium ('the prices of all other products being held fixed'). Where a firm or buyer has market power the system's own model gives way to monopoly, oligopoly or monopsony models. |
| knockout | unsourced |
| nested level | Built from many buyers' and sellers' decisions (each a person or firm, or an animal in a biological market); part of a market (market.json floor 5, price formation); its model is a part of economics; runs on its traders' choices. |
| scale | social |
Measures (23) published science
| convergence to competitive equilibrium in experimental double auctions | several trading periods |
| time to trade a large order incrementally | as long as months time |
| cobweb production lag, strawberries | 1 year |
| beef cattle life cycle behind the cattle cycle (Rosen et al. 1994) | 3 years |
| Giffen field experiment subsidy duration (Hunan, Gansu) | 5 months |
| traders enough for a competitive equilibrium in experiments | 3 or 4 buyers and as many sellers agents |
| variance of the bid-ask spread explained by the zero-intelligence model (11 LSE stocks) | 96 % |
| variance of the price diffusion rate explained, one free parameter | 76 % |
| price elasticity of demand, subsidised fruit and vegetables (sales) | -0.59 (95% CI -1.04 to -0.13) dimensionless |
| price elasticity of demand, subsidised fruit and vegetables (consumption) | -0.17 (95% CI -0.49 to 0.15; not significant) dimensionless |
| price elasticity of demand, cigarettes (US, general) | -0.3 to -0.6 dimensionless |
| price elasticity of demand, car fuel (short run) | -0.09 dimensionless |
| price elasticity of demand, oil (world) | -0.4 dimensionless |
| reviews of price and demand (alcohol, tobacco, unhealthy food, sugary drinks) in the umbrella review | 50 from 5,185 records reviews |
| rice per capita per day, Hunan urban poor | 330 g |
| rice share of daily calories, Hunan urban poor | 64 % |
| China's urban poor (the population studied) | approximately 90 million people |
| experimental power market: interruptible share of peak retail demand | 16 % |
| experimental power market: 'must serve' share of peak demand | 84 % |
| grid reference frequency (Europe; US grids 60 Hz) | 50 Hz |
| grid frequency open database | 17 locations in 12 synchronous areas on three continents sites |
| aspartate model: flux share of reaction 2 vs its share of supply regulation | 9.4 % of flux, 45.5 % of regulation |
| Hunan and Gansu households relying on the staple for at least half their calories | 80 (Hunan), 75 (Gansu) % |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-723 Do market prices reflect all available information?
booked: The map records evidence both of prices taking in information and of departures such as bubbles, and keeps the strong efficient-markets view alongside.
the other reading: see research/CONTENTIONS.md C-723 - C-1994 Do farm prices cycle like a cobweb?
booked: The map books the cobweb as a lagged loop and keeps the critique beside it.
the other reading: Coase and Fowler (1935): farmers use several years of prices, so 'the cobweb cycle implied by Kaldor's model does not apply in practice'; Rosen et al. (1994): cattle cycles from a three-year life cycle even with rational expectations; Wellford (1989): in experiments the unstable case did not diverge - C-2016 Does the law of demand always hold?
booked: The map books it as holding widely, with the exceptions listed.
the other reading: aggregate failure: Sonnenschein-Mantel-Debreu: market-wide curves 'can theoretically take almost any shape'; no conditions on individuals guarantee a unique, stable equilibrium (Kirman 1992); reach limited by price-setting: post-Keynesians: administered mark-up prices not responsive to demand up to capacity; Sraffa's critique of partial equilibrium; labour markets: Fleetwood: evidence for labour supply and demand curves 'at best inconclusive and at worst casts doubt on their existence' - C-2028 Does raising the minimum wage cost jobs?
booked: The map books the reanalysis finding of a limited effect and keeps the textbook reading beside it.
the other reading: the competitive supply-and-demand reading: a price floor above the clearing wage creates a surplus of labour (unemployment), as Humphrey's ceilings-and-floors use of the diagram would predict; teen labour supply may itself be backward bending (Manning's own caution) - C-2044 How do prices actually adjust?
booked: The map keeps several mechanisms and rules none.
the other reading: Walrasian tâtonnement by an auctioneer: Smith: 'who makes price if all agents take price as given?' and such processes 'found to be so inefficient'; institution-driven: the double auction converges with 3-4 traders a side and private information; slow digestion: Bouchaud et al.: tâtonnement revisited, prices incorporate supply and demand slowly through long-memory order flow - C-2053 Who first described supply and demand?
booked: The map lists the early statements and rules none first.
the other reading: the curves: Cournot 1838 (Humphrey) vs the common association with Marshall ('Marshallian cross'), which Humphrey calls a misperception; the phrase: Steuart 1767 (encyclopedia) after Law's 'Demand' (1730s) and Hutcheson's 'Demand... and the Difficulty of acquiring' (1755)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (13) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Supply and demand. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- coordination-before-mapping (structural)
A competitive equilibrium forms from private information alone: experimental traders 'would not have a clue' how to solve the equations yet converge on them, and random 'zero-intelligence' order placement reproduces most of the spread. Coordination without any participant holding a map of the market - runaway from an unstable balance (structural)
The divergent cobweb: when supply responds more strongly than demand, 'each new outcome is successively further from the intersection'; competitive equilibria can be unstable. A balance point shown, and a push that feeds itself. - same role, different builds (structural)
Matching what is supplied to what is wanted is done by different builds: a double auction's cross of bids and asks, a vervet group's grooming rates, metabolic supply and demand blocks linked by one metabolite, a power grid's frequency, which 'indicates the balance of supply and demand'. - same toolkit, independent builds (structural)
The demand-and-supply diagram was built several times from the same parts (price, quantity, two curves): Cournot 1838; Rau 1841 'with no knowledge of its contents'; Dupuit 1844; Mangoldt 1863; Jenkin about 1870, an electrical engineer 'with no acquaintance with the work of Mangoldt or his predecesso - templating (structural)
The same module is reused across markets unchanged: the wage as price in labour markets, the interest rate in the money market; and borrowed by biochemists as supply and demand blocks with 'elasticity coefficients' defined, as in economics, by ratios of relative changes. - the whole sets the local reference (structural)
The market price is the reference every part measures against: each buyer compares a unit's marginal value, each firm its marginal cost, with the one price. In biological markets the reference does not close into one: 'the price need not be the same for all individuals' (Hammerstein & Noe). - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
Each participant takes in its own slice of one market: a buyer its wants, budget and the price; a firm its costs; those on the spot the news; no one the whole ('dispersed bits'). The channels here are that set; the price is the one shared field all read. - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
Enforceable contracts are the seal under the strict law: the Walrasian law of supply and demand assumes them, and in biological trade, where there are none, the strict law does not hold while supply and demand still move exchange rates (Hammerstein & Noe). The without-the-seal case is shown, but wha - causal ceiling (partial)
No participant can know the whole: the knowledge used 'never exists in concentrated or integrated form' (Hayek), and no conditions on individuals guarantee a unique, stable aggregate (Sonnenschein-Mantel-Debreu, Kirman). The limit comes from how the system is built (dispersed knowledge; aggregation) - conservation law plus closure (partial)
The clearing condition (quantity demanded = quantity supplied) leaves the price open until both behavioural laws are given: Marshall's scissors, neither blade alone. In estimation the same slot shows as the identification problem: price and quantity are both endogenous and outside variables are need - holding / entrainment (partial)
The clearing price sets the number of firms: in the long run firms enter or exit until price meets long-run cost, so the whole (the market price) sets the count of its supplying parts. - seed (partial)
The cross diagram unpacks a whole toolkit: elasticity, stability, multiple equilibria, comparative statics, consumer and producer surplus, tax incidence, deadweight loss, monopoly's inefficiency 'all find expression in early expositions of the diagram'. Partial: an idea with many uses, with no shell - The Payment to Entropy (partial)
A tax hand-off pays a toll: part of the gains from trade goes to nobody, the deadweight-welfare-loss triangle Dupuit defined in 1844; the price rises by less than the tax unless demand is vertical, so the tax splits and some trades vanish. No per-hand-off efficiency number read here (market.json boo
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (16) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Labour market via sys:market · Supply and demand gain
- Firm (the economic unit) via sys:market · Supply and demand gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:market · Supply and demand gain
- Government via sys:law · Supply and demand mixed
- Human brain via sys:human · Supply and demand gain
- Metabolism via sys:economics · Supply and demand even
- Electrical grid via sys:electricity · Supply and demand even
- Money via sys:money · Supply and demand gain
- Market and trade via sys:market · Supply and demand gain
- Economy via sys:market · Supply and demand even
- Vervet monkey (Chlorocebus pygerythrus) via sys:primate-social-group · Supply and demand even
- Economics (the field) via sys:economics · Supply and demand gain
- Golden snub-nosed monkey (infant-handling market) via sys:primate-social-group · Supply and demand even
- Great Depression via sys:market · Supply and demand loss
- Consumer via sys:market · Supply and demand gain
- Business via sys:market · Supply and demand gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Money
- Order book and double auction (market institution)
- Firm (the economic unit)
- Buyers competing for a limited supply
- Sellers competing for buyers
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (11)
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Multi-Scale Data Fusion / Triangulation
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Self-Monitoring
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
floor filled by (10)
- Market and trade
- Labour market
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Government
- Money
- Order book and double auction (market institution)
- Firm (the economic unit)
- Price system
- Vervet monkey (Chlorocebus pygerythrus)
- Economics (the field)
represents (1)
Kinds (7)
- Labour market
- Biological market
- Money market
- Aggregate demand and aggregate supply
- Cobweb model
- General equilibrium
- Metabolic supply and demand (the molecular economy)
Notes published science
- Economists predicted an upside-down demand curve in 1895 and waited 113 years to see it: when researchers subsidised rice for very poor families in Hunan, China, the families bought less rice, because the money saved let them buy a little meat. (src:jensen-miller-2008)
- The supply-and-demand diagram everyone calls 'Marshall's' was drawn at least four times before him by people who had never seen each other's work, one of them an electrical engineer with no training in economics. (src:humphrey-1992)
- Monkeys pay market prices too: when a second vervet monkey learned to open the food box, the first one's 'price' in grooming from her groupmates dropped. (src:fruteau-2009)
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
supply and demand as economists model it
- L1: Price and quantity data from markets
- L2: Estimation: simultaneous equations; the identification problem
- L3: The diagram: demand and supply curves (Cournot 1838, Rau 1841, Dupuit 1844, Mangoldt 1863, Jenkin 1870, Marshall 1890)
- L4: Elasticities: the response of quantity to price, the tool for comparing goods (Marshall 1890)
- L5: Comparative statics: shifts in the curves traced to a new equilibrium
- L6: Uses: tax incidence, price ceilings and floors, welfare (surplus, deadweight loss), monopoly
- L7: Critique and limits: Sraffa; administered prices; the Sonnenschein-Mantel-Debreu result; where the model gives way to monopoly or monopsony models
supply and demand: wants and costs meeting in a price (reader's view)
- L1: Buyers and sellers with wants, incomes and costs; the knowledge of them dispersed among the people who have it
- L2: Individual demand and supply schedules: how much each buyer will take and each seller will offer at each price (in people, and in animals working for food)
- L3: Market demand and market supply: individual curves added horizontally
- L4: Price adjustment: a shortage drives price up, a surplus drives it down (Walrasian), or production moves toward where demand price meets supply price (Marshallian); in real markets through the rules of an institution
- L5: Equilibrium: the market-clearing price and quantity, where the curves cross
- L6: Price as a signal: a few pointers that carry what changed to everyone who uses the good
- L7: Allocation: how much is produced and who gets it (and who goes without at that price); gains from trade as consumer and producer surplus
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: Market clearing: the price where quantity demanded equals quantity supplied; reached by an institution's rules, by price or quantity adjustment, or not at all (unstable or multiple equilibria)
- L6: The price as information: a few pointers registering change for everyone who uses the good; most processed information comes from supply and demand itself
- L7: Allocation: the quantity produced and consumed at the clearing price; who is served and who is priced out; consumer and producer surplus
way in: Costs: sellers' marginal cost of supplying
- L1: Prices of inputs including wages, technology, expectations, number of suppliers
- L2: Marginal cost: produce while extra output costs less than the price
- L3: The firm's supply schedule, valid only for a price-taker
- L4: Offers (asks) entered, ordered from lowest to highest
way in: Expectations and lags: last season's price, futures, the time to produce
- L1: Producers expect prices from previous prices
- L2: Planting chosen for next year from this year's price (strawberries)
- L3: The production lag: planting to harvest; the gestation of hogs; averaging several years smooths it
- L4: Futures: estimates of coming harvests and world consumption enter today's price
way in: Money and income: the budget a price draws on
- L1: Money: prices are written in it; in the money market the interest rate is the price
- L2: A price rise drains a poor household's budget when the good is a large share of it
- L3: Substitution and income (wealth) effects: the Slutsky decomposition, weighted by budget share
- L4: The quantity demanded of the staple: down with price as a rule; up for a Giffen good
way in: Orders in the meeting place (market microstructure)
- L1: Traders place orders; even random 'minimally intelligent' placement reproduces much of the statistics
- L2: The institution's rules of message exchange and contract; a competitive equilibrium forms out of them without complete information
- L3: Revealed supply and demand accumulates in the book; the spread
- L4: Large orders split and traded over days to months: order flow a long-memory process
way in: Rules: taxes, price ceilings and floors, minimum wages
- L1: The state lays a per-unit tax, a ceiling, a floor or a minimum wage
- L2: The tax adds to each unit's cost: the supply curve shifts up by the tax
- L3: Incidence: how the tax splits between buyers and sellers depends on elasticities
- L4: In labour markets, minimum wages raise wages with an elusive employment effect
way in: Shifts: news and events that move the curves
- L1: A new use or a lost source somewhere (tin); a bad harvest (strawberries); an invention (wheat)
- L2: Those on the spot know and switch resources
- L3: A non-price determinant changes: a shift of the curve, not a movement along it
- L4: The new curve: at each price more (or less) is wanted or offered
way in: Wants: buyers' willingness and ability to pay
- L1: Buyers' needs, incomes, tastes, the prices of substitutes and complements, expectations, numbers, advertising
- L2: A buyer sees the product and then its price; product preference and an excessive price register before the decision
- L3: Willingness to pay computed: the most a buyer will give up for the good; buy while marginal value exceeds price
- L4: The individual demand schedule entered as bids; the bids ordered from highest to lowest
way out: Buyers take the quantity (or go without)
- L1: Buyers consume along the demand curve: more at a lower price, less at a higher one
- L7: The equilibrium quantity transacted
way out: Production adjusts (sellers make more or less)
- L1: Goods made (or not): crops planted, output brought to market
- L4: In the long run firms enter or exit and all inputs adjust
- L7: The volume of production adjusting itself to the market
way out: Shortages and surpluses when price is held off the clearing level
- L1: Unmet demand (shortage) or unsold supply (surplus)
- L5: A ceiling below or a floor above the clearing price
way out: The price broadcast back to all who use the good
- L1: Tens of thousands use the good more sparingly (or more freely) without knowing why
- L6: The price moves