same toolkit, independent builds our proposal
Separate lineages build the same structure independently from the same parts.
Seen in 465 walked systems. Each sighting is our reading of that system's sourced walk, in that system's own terms; a shape that turns up everywhere is the finding, and how it differs from place to place is the detail.
Structural: the shape does the work here (149)
- Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter)
The eardrum, the receiver for airborne sound, 'appear[s] to have evolved independently three to six times'; early tetrapods 'likely did not possess eardrums', and in basal amniotes the stapes was a prop supporting the braincase. - Adaptive immune system
The adaptive immune system evolved exactly twice, in jawed and jawless vertebrates, with different receptors (Ig/TCR by RAG vs VLR by APOBEC gene conversion) but the same three-lineage division of labour (B, alpha/beta T, gamma/delta T), suggesting the common ancestor already had the split. - Averaged dominant energy condition (ADEC)
One recipe, many conditions: take a pointwise condition and integrate it along geodesics (ATCC/ASEC, ANCC/ANEC, AFEC, ADEC), so local violations can average out. - Aztec Empire (the Triple Alliance of Mexico-Tenochtitlan, Tetzcoco and Tlacopan, 1428-1521)
The Basin of Mexico's settlements, built with no contact with the Old World, follow the same population-area scaling (Aztec period exponent 0.764, near the networked 5/6) and increasing returns as modern cities: the same parts (people on foot, interaction, infrastructure), built independently. - Black hole
One result, a Kerr hole known by mass and spin, reached by separate routes from the same parts (gravity and collapse): prompt collapse, fallback, neutron-star accretion or merger, Population III remnants, direct-collapse seeds, mergers in dense clusters, and hypothetically primordial collapse. The s - Blood
High-altitude birds of separate lineages converge on higher haemoglobin-O2 affinity ('one of the most compelling examples of convergent biochemical adaptation'); enucleated red cells arose in mammals and again in five plethodontid salamander clades and Maurolicus fish; transglutaminase cross-linking - Bone
Biomineralisation 'evolved multiple times, independently', yet 'many elements of this toolkit are shared between phyla as diverse as corals, molluscs, and vertebrates'; molluscan nacre implanted in a human tooth 'was incorporated into the host bone matrix'. - Book
The codex was built twice: Mediterranean parchment quires, and Mesoamerican 'long folded strips of either fig bark (amatl) or plant fibers'; movable type twice: Bi Sheng's earthenware c. 1045 and Gutenberg's cast metal c. 1450, 'independently'. - Bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops)
S-cones lost in toothed whales and in seals, two distant orders, from the same cone set: 'convergent evolution'; vibrissal crypts turned into electroreceptors in Sotalia and in Tursiops; echolocation evolved twice in odontocetes - Brand
Marks, seals and stamps on goods arose independently in Africa, Asia and Europe at different times: Indus seals, Ur cylinder seals, Qin seals, Greek and Roman potters' marks. - BTZ black hole
The same black-hole kit (horizon, inner horizon, ergosphere, upper bound on spin, quarter-area entropy) built again in 2+1 dimensions from a different material: no local gravitational degrees of freedom, only a global identification of AdS3. - Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay)
One nucleation law built separately: the flat-space scalar bubble, the charged membrane of flux vacua (same R_c), and bubbles in an atomic superfluid matching 'instanton theory'. - Bureaucracy
Six primary states built in separate regions (Mesoamerica, Peru, Egypt, Mesopotamia, Indus, China) each show the first state institutions appearing as control passed a day's round trip; Shin et al. find polities 'diverge in socio-political features below the Information Threshold, but reconverge bey - Calculus (the practice of handling change and accumulation by limits, and the structures it works on)
Newton and Leibniz each built infinitesimal calculus from the same seventeenth-century parts (Cavalieri's infinitesimals, the calculus of finite differences), in different notations (fluxions; d and the integral sign); Liu Hui rediscovered exhaustion in China. The priority dispute is the dark twin o - Capuchin monkey (Cebus and Sapajus)
Hammer-and-anvil stone percussion built separately by capuchins (Sapajus, and Cebus on Jicarón), chimpanzees and long-tailed macaques from the same parts (stones, anvils, encased food); separate lineages, as the source lists the genera - Caustic (of a geodesic congruence; of light rays)
One envelope shape built by unconnected mechanisms: refraction in a water glass or raindrops, reflection in a mirror, gravity bending light around a binary star, and free-falling dust world lines focused by gravity. - Cell membrane
Shared ATP synthase, transcription and translation, but 'ion pumps and phospholipid membranes arose later and independently' in archaea and bacteria; animal and microbial rhodopsins 'convergently evolved' from retinal and seven helices. - Central processing unit
Brains (human and C. elegans) and VLSI circuits, one evolved by natural selection and one by 'commercially driven technology development', both obey Rent's rule, both are hierarchically modular ('modules within modules'), both are cost-efficiently but not minimally wired; the authors read it as conv - Cephalopods (octopus, squid, cuttlefish, nautilus)
Protocadherin expansions: 168 genes in octopus, mostly in tandem clusters, against 17-25 in other lophotrochozoans; 'both octopuses and vertebrates have independently evolved a diverse array of protocadherin genes' (tandem duplication here, a clustered locus with alternative promoters in vertebrates - Chaos and nonlinear dynamics (the practice, and the chaotic behaviour it studies)
The same result built twice from the same parts (nonlinear equations plus a computer): Lorenz (1961, digital) and Ueda (1961, analog) found chaos the same year; Feigenbaum (1975) and Coullet and Tresser (1978) found universality independently. - Chemical bond
Van der Waals forces as the shared toolkit for dry adhesion built again and again: 'the repeated, convergent evolution of dry adhesive microstructures in gecko, anoles, skinks, and insects'; adhesion set by tip size and shape, not surface chemistry. - Circulatory system
One conserved cardiac kernel (Nkx2.5/Tinman, GATA, Hand, Tbx5, Mef2c) builds pumping hearts in arthropods, molluscs and chordates; the cephalopod closed, endothelium-lined system 'probably developed in parallel' to the vertebrate one. - Civilization
Civilizations arose independently in six cradles (Fertile Crescent, Nile, Indo-Gangetic Plain, North China Plain, Andean coast, Mesoamerican Gulf Coast) from the same parts (domesticated crops, sedentary villages, surplus); societies in 'very different and unconnected' regions fall on one complexity - Columbian Exchange
Farming was built independently on each side from local wild plants and animals before 1492 (maize, potato, cassava and turkey in the Americas; wheat, rice, cattle and horses in Afro-Eurasia; African rice, Oryza glaberrima, domesticated independently in West Africa beside Asian rice); the exchange b - Combinatorics: the practice of counting, arranging and choosing finite structures (permutations, combinations, partitions, designs, graphs), the structures it studies, and the people and machines who work with them
The same counting theorem built twice from the same parts (Burnside's lemma): Redfield in 1927 and Polya in 1937; Ramsey's theorem 'rediscovered' by Erdos and Szekeres; combinatorics on words 'arose independently within several branches'. - Communication: the passing of messages between senders and receivers through a channel (and, on other readings, the making of meaning between them), and communication studies, the field that studies it
Vocal turn-taking was built twice: marmosets and humans as convergent evolution, perhaps under cooperative breeding, 'perhaps through the activation of a shared (homologous) neuronal network' (shared parts, independent builds). - Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA)
Specificity control of the converter: 'class III specificity regulation evolved independently from the mechanism in class I and II, although using some of the same structural components' (Lundin 2015); shared parts (loop 2), separate assemblies, same job (keeping the four dNTPs in balance). - Composition algebra
The same algebra-to-symmetry kit, sl(2, K) = so(n + 1, 1), builds the Lorentz group of four-dimensional spacetime from C and the ten-dimensional one used by superstrings from O. - Computer network
Packet switching 'was invented independently by Paul Baran ... and Donald Davies'; 'The first multiprotocol routers were independently created by staff researchers at MIT and Stanford in 1981 and both were also based on PDP-11s'; hot potato routing 'has been reinvented the usual number of times' (de - Computer-aided design
De Casteljau at Citroen (1959, kept secret until 1971) and Bezier at Renault (early 1960s) built the same curves from control points by completely different approaches, each unaware of the other; 1960s CAD developments were 'independent of one another and often not published until much later'. - Connection on a principal bundle (gauge field)
One construction, a Lie-algebra-valued connection form, built with U(1) (electromagnetic potential), SU(3) (gluon field) and, on the frame bundle, as spacetime's affine connection. - Connection on a vector bundle
Parallel transport by a connection read out in two unconnected media: a gyroscope spin carried round an orbit in curved spacetime (Gravity Probe B, Levi-Civita connection) and an electron phase carried round a solenoid (Aharonov-Bohm, the U(1) connection). - Cosmic string
One winding defect in unrelated media: 'Vortices in superfluids and pinned vortex tubes in type-II superconductors provide examples of circle-map type topological solitons ... More abstract examples include cosmic strings'; the world-sheet walk books the same Nambu-Goto regime for QCD and supercondu - Cryptographic hash function
SHA-2, BLAKE and Skein are all built from the same parts (modular addition, rotation, XOR) 'although neither is closely related to SHA-2'. - Cryptography
The same build made separately from the same parts, again and again: the rotor machine 'was invented simultaneously by four separate people, all amateurs' (Diffie and Hellman); public-key encryption and key exchange at GCHQ in 1973-1974 ('schemes essentially identical to RSA encryption and to Diffie - Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
Vocal learning 'has evolved independently through evolutionary convergence' (humans, dolphins, bats, some birds); traditions recur in chimpanzees, orcas, rats, crows, fish. - Database
From Codd's one paper, separate teams built relational systems: INGRES at Berkeley ('similar to System R in a number of ways'), System R at IBM, Mimer SQL at Uppsala, and Oracle from IBM's papers. - Desert ant (Cataglyphis)
Thermal scavenging (forage at midday near lethal limits, long legs, heat tolerance) evolved at least three times: Cataglyphis, Melophorus, Ocymyrmex - Diffeomorphism group with an L2 (weak) metric
One construction, a geodesic equation on a diffeomorphism group with a chosen metric, builds several physical flow laws: Euler (L2 on volume-preserving maps), Burgers (L2 on Diff(S^1), a turbulence model), Camassa-Holm (H1, shallow water waves). - Domain wall network
The same sheet defect in unconnected media: 'Ferromagnetic materials have regions of magnetic alignment separated by domain walls' (observed), and cosmic walls (hypothesised); the bubble wall of vacuum decay is a third build. - Domesticated germline (crop and livestock lines held and propagated by people)
The same rule struck in 'some 13 centres' (or 'perhaps more than 20'), often on the same genes: SH1 controls shattering 'in sorghum, rice, and maize/corn', GW2 grain weight 'in rice, wheat, maize/corn'; Fuller: convergent evolution and parallelism across 15 taxa. - Ear
The tympanic middle ear was built at least twice from the same pharyngeal tissues: on the lower-jaw side in mammals and the upper-jaw side in reptiles and birds (Edn1-Dlx5/6 cascade), and the detached mammalian middle ear may have been reached separately in monotremes and therians - Earth in the Cenozoic era
C4 carbon fixation 'has evolved in at least 62 independent occasions in 19 different families of plants, making it a prime example of convergent evolution', with many pathways to it whose first steps are 'not directly related to photosynthesis'. - Earth's core
Liquid metal, flow and field built a dynamo independently in the Earth and in the laboratory (Riga: 2 m3 of sodium, 200 kW; Karlsruhe 1.6 m3, 630 kW): the same parts, separate assemblies, the same self-excited field. - Economics (the field)
Marginal utility theory built separately by Jevons (England, 1862/1871), Menger (Austria, 1871) and Walras (Switzerland, 1874), with Lloyd's 1833 statement lost until others 'had independently developed and popularized the same insight'. - Election
The same counting tools built separately: STV devised by Andræ in Denmark (1855) and by Hare in Britain (1857); apportionment methods devised in the US and rediscovered in Europe (Jefferson = D'Hondt, Webster = Sainte-Laguë, Hamilton = Hare); the median voter theorem derived by Black (1948) and inde - Engine
Whittle (first patent filed 1930) and von Ohain (from 1935, 'initially unaware of Whittle's work') built turbojets from the same parts, compressor and turbine; Ferraris (1885) and Tesla (1887) each invented the induction motor; de Rivaz and the Niépce brothers tested internal combustion piston engin - Eukaryote
three-dimensional phototaxis built at least eight times independently from rhodopsin photoreceptors, a shading body and cilia; multicellularity at least 25 times from the shared eukaryotic toolkit - Euler equations (fluid dynamics)
One equation, the Euler-Arnold geodesic equation on a Lie group with a right-invariant metric, gives both the Euler equations of an ideal fluid (volume-preserving diffeomorphisms) and Euler's equations of rigid-body dynamics. - Eye
Box-jellyfish camera eyes use a vertebrate-like ciliary phototransduction cascade and melanin pathway, read as 'independent recruitment of orthologous genes'; box-jellyfish and vertebrate opsins converged on a similar counterion position; cephalopod and vertebrate camera eyes converged with reversed - Fish
Electric organs evolved six times; independent lineages used similar transcription factors and pathways - Fluid dynamics (the flows of liquids and gases, and the practice of describing them)
Animal phyla needing macro-scale fluid transport 'have repeatedly and often independently converged on the use of jet flows': vortex rings in cardiac chambers and jet-propelled swimmers, tuned near the laboratory optimum L/D 3.5-4.5. - Force
Cells and climbing animals both adhere by van der Waals forces, built separately: integrin and cadherin contacts in cells, adhesive hairs on gecko feet ('both cells and climbing animals take advantage of van der Waals forces'). - Fourier analysis (the practice of splitting signals into waves and rebuilding them, and the structure it works on)
The same tool found more than once: Gauss's FFT (about 1805) and Cooley-Tukey (1965); Bessel's Fourier series (1819) unaware of Fourier's (src:wp:fourier-analysis). - Fullerenes (buckyballs and nanotubes)
The same parts (carbon) close into the same C60 by separate routes: laser vaporisation in helium (1985), the graphite arc (1990), sooty flames, lightning, carbon-rich stellar outflows, and the top-down shrinking of PAHs under UV; nanotubes likewise found independently at NEC and IBM in 1993. - Fungi (yeasts, molds and mushrooms: absorptive eukaryotes with chitin walls)
Mycorrhiza built again and again from the saprotroph toolkit: ectomycorrhiza 'developed independently ... in fungi, around 80 times', by 'convergent evolution of ectomycorrhizal fungi from white and brown-rot fungi, as well as from soil saprotrophs'; lichenization also arose independently 'multiple - Fuzzy sphere
The same su(2) matrix sphere built three ways: as a truncation of spherical harmonics (Madore/Hoppe), by D0-branes polarised by an RR field (Myers), and by electrons in the lowest Landau level around a monopole (Haldane sphere, Zhu et al.). - Goldstone boson (would-be, eaten; pions as pseudo-Goldstone)
Goldstone's theorem: one gapless mode per broken generator, built separately in unconnected systems: the would-be ones of the electroweak Higgs doublet, the pions (pseudo, chiral QCD), phonons (fluids, solids, superfluids) and magnons (magnets: a ferromagnet has 1, an antiferromagnet 2). - Graph theory: the practice of studying vertices joined by edges (problems, proofs, algorithms, its people and books) and the graphs it works on
The same random graph model built independently three times (Solomonoff and Rapoport; Erdős and Rényi; Gilbert); the abelian sandpile / chip-firing model 'discovered several times by researchers in different communities operating independently'. - Grassland
The C4 pump was built 17 to 18 times independently within the grass family from the same enzymes (PEP carboxylase, RuBisCO in a bundle sheath); the first transition in Chloridoideae 32-25 Mya. - Grey parrot (Psittacus erithacus)
Vocal learning built separately in parrots, songbirds and hummingbirds, each with seven cerebral song nuclei considered analogous, marked by the same genes (PVALB, FOXP1, SLIT1); entrainment to a beat found only in vocal mimics - Gross domestic product
In 1941, Meade and Stone's British White Paper, Gruenbaum's accounts for Palestine and Van Cleeff's Dutch national bookkeeping each set national income in an accounting framework: 'the idea was in the air and made its appearance in several guises at the same time' (Stone). Colin Clark and Kuznets ha - Hagihara observers (frame of stable circular orbits)
One recipe, two frames: 'boost our static frame ... by an undetermined parameter, compute the acceleration vector, and require that this vanish' gives Lemaitre observers (radial boost) and Hagihara observers (boost in e3). - Hair cell
Echolocating bats and toothed whales evolved biosonar independently, yet their prestin sequences converged so far that the dolphin clusters with microbats in the prestin gene tree. - Helical symmetry group (screw-axis isometry group)
One screw generator, built independently in crystals (screw axes), nucleic acids (D_1(q)), microtubules (C_1(q)), alpha helices, rifled bullets and charged particles in a magnetic field. - Higgs field
A condensate with a nonzero vacuum value breaks a symmetry, built separately in two places: the Higgs field (electroweak, ~10^-12 s) and the quark condensate (chiral, the final symmetry-breaking event). The Higgs mechanism page adds a third, non-relativistic build: 'The Higgs mechanism is a type of - Historiography
The 'telling of history has emerged independently in civilizations around the world': Greek and Chinese historiography built critical narrative history from shared parts (writing, court and civic records, annals) without contact; Roman historiography 'shared traits with Chinese historiography' (anna - History of science (the field and the story it tells)
Multiple discovery: calculus (Newton, Leibniz), oxygen (Scheele, Priestley, Lavoisier), natural selection (Darwin, Wallace), the blast furnace in China, Europe and Africa; 'analogous to convergent evolution'; Merton held multiples, not singletons, to be the common pattern. Communication made the sha - Human (Homo sapiens)
Agriculture began in Southwest Asia and "also occurred independently in Mesoamerica (about 6,000 years ago), China, Papua New Guinea, and the Sahel"; fire-making may have been found independently (fire drill in Africa, spark-striking by Neanderthals in Europe). - Human society (from local community up to societies)
Societies on different continents (Mississippi, China) evolved independently yet share one structure of social organisation (nine characteristics loading on one dimension). - Humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae)
Two lines built from shared parts, far apart: the humpback cortex carries large spindle cells 'similar in morphology and distribution to those described in hominids, suggesting a case of parallel evolution'; and whale song shows 'the same statistical structure that is a hallmark of human language', - Igneous rock
Basalt made separately on Earth, the Moon (maria, to 2,030 Ma), Mars, Venus (~80% of its plains) and asteroids (eucrites, at low pressure) from the same toolkit: partial melting of silicate mantle and fractional crystallisation, 'a pervasive process that probably affects primary magmas generated wit - Improved (Callan-Coleman-Jackiw) energy-momentum tensor
The same toolkit (add an identically conserved term) built twice: Belinfante uses rotation symmetry to make the tensor symmetric, Callan-Coleman-Jackiw use scale symmetry to make it traceless; 'much like using the Belinfante procedure'. - Insect (class Insecta)
Asynchronous flight muscle 'independently emerged in various insect groups which are not phylogenetically close to each other', and 'the resulting inventions are almost identical to each other'. - Institution (social)
Commons institutions built separately in forests in Maharashtra, Japanese irrigation districts, New Mexico acequias and inshore fisheries share the same parts (boundaries, monitors accountable to users, graduated sanctions, conflict arenas); 91 studies find the principles 'well supported'. - Intrinsic magnetosphere
Moon-loaded magnetospheres built twice from the same parts: Io at Jupiter (up to 1,000 kg/s) and Enceladus at Saturn (about 100 kg/s of ions), each ionised, forced to co-rotate, leaking out by interchange instability and escaping down the tail. - Islamic art
the same decagonal tile set with self-similar subdivision gives quasi-crystalline patterns at the Darb-i Imam (1453) and in Penrose's tilings (1973), five centuries apart; Islamic and Gothic designers each drew maximum diversity from small inventories of shapes - Laboratory dynamo (liquid-sodium dynamo experiments)
Shared parts (a moving conductor, a flow not 'too simple', Rm above critical), separate assemblies, same result (a self-made field): three lab builds reached it independently, Riga (single-scale helical, Ponomarenko), Karlsruhe (two-scale, 52 spin generators) and VKS (turbulent von Karman); the natu - Language (human language)
Creoles "display remarkable similarities in grammar" (SVO order, article use, movement rules) "even when creoles do not have any common language origins", built separately by child learners in each place; ISN built by deaf children with no conventional input. - Lemaitre observers (radially infalling free-fall frame)
The same boost-and-zero-acceleration recipe builds the Lemaitre frame (radial boost) and the Hagihara frame (boost in e3). - Limit (mathematics): the value a sequence or function approaches, and the practice of approaching, bounding and proving it
Inscribed polygons, the same parts, assembled into the same result independently: the circle's area by exhaustion in Greece (Antiphon, Eudoxus, Archimedes) and in China (Liu Hui, 3rd or 4th century AD; "independently invented"). - Linear algebra (the practice of solving, transforming and taking apart linear systems with vectors and matrices, and the structures it works with)
Elimination on arrays was built separately in ancient China (the Nine Chapters' 'Rectangular Arrays') and early modern Europe (Cardano 1545, Newton's notes 1669-1670), and Gauss-Jordan elimination was found independently by Jordan and Clasen in 1888: shared parts (arrays of coefficients, subtracting - Linguistics (the field: the practice and the languages it studies)
Separate lineages build the same grammatical features: the languages of the Americas do not form a separate cluster, read as enduring constraints giving 'convergent cultural evolution of grammatical features'. In the field's own history, Pāṇini (Sanskrit), Sibawayh (Arabic) and Warring States China - Magnetar magnetosphere
The same parts (a twisted, nearly force-free field rooted in a moving surface, plus plasma) build a corona and flares on the Sun and on a magnetar: 'The same equation describes the force-free solar corona'; flares 'similar to solar flares', plasmoids 'resembling coronal mass ejections from the sun'. - Mammal (class Mammalia)
The definite mammalian middle ear 'evolved independently at least three times in the ancestors of today's monotremes, marsupials and placentals', from the same jaw bones; free-floating postdentary bones 'occurred at least twice in the mammaliformes'. - Materials science (the field)
Copper metallurgy built more than once from the same parts (ore, fire, charcoal): the Carpatho-Balkan province 'emerged independently from centers of the Proto-Metal area' (Metallurgy encyclopedia page), and the Andes developed large-scale copper smelting with its own furnaces, recorded from ~700-50 - Mathematical logic: the field that studies logic within mathematics (model theory, proof theory, set theory, computability theory) and the formal systems, structures and limit results it works on
The same results reached separately with shared tools: Church and Turing (1936), Jaśkowski and Gentzen (natural deduction), Friedberg and Muchnik (Post's problem), Bertić and Boole, Novikov and Boone. - Mathematics (the field: the practice and the structures it studies)
Calculus 'introduced independently and simultaneously' by Newton and Leibniz from the same 17th-century toolkit (algebraic notation, Cartesian coordinates); written mathematics arose separately in Mesopotamia, Egypt, China and India. - Metamorphic rock
Japan's main islands show 'three distinct paired metamorphic belts, corresponding to different episodes of subduction': the same parts (a cold subducting slab beside a hot arc) assembled separately three times into the same paired structure. - Microbiology (the field)
Twelve populations from one E. coli ancestor, evolved separately since 1988, all showed rapid fitness gains that slowed, faster growth and larger cells: shared parts, separate runs, same result. - Milne universe (Milne model)
One flat spacetime, two re-labellings: the Milne patch (inside a light cone, expanding hyperbolic slices) and Rindler space (an accelerated frame); 'both are simple re-parameterizations of flat Minkowski space'. - Misner string
One construction on two media: a monopole charge forces a string singularity in its potential (Dirac string, electromagnetic; Misner string, gravitational), and in both a quantisation-type condition hides it (Dirac quantisation; Misner's time period 8 pi n). - Morphology (linguistics): how a language builds its words from smaller meaningful parts (roots, affixes, compounding, inflection and derivation), how languages differ in this, how speakers learn and use it, and the field that studies it
American and Israeli Sign Language, unrelated, built very similar simultaneous morphology from the same toolkit (hands in space, spatiotemporal cognition). - Muscular system
Striated muscle built twice from one pre-animal core set: cnidarians have striated muscle without troponin or titin genes, bilaterians with them. - Nervous system
Bilaterian lineages 'independently compacted their ancestral nerve nets' into cords 'using a similar set of ancestral transcription factors', and cephalisation produced brains separately in arthropods, cephalopods and vertebrates: one code snippet run several times. - Neutron
The s process (slow captures, low neutron density, along the valley of stability, in AGB and massive stars) and the r process (rapid captures far from stability, in mergers and rarer explosions) build the heavy isotopes from the same parts, iron-group seeds plus neutrons plus beta decay, by separate - NUT gravitational dyon
Electric-magnetic duality built twice: an electromagnetic dyon (electric plus magnetic charge) and a gravitational one (mass plus 'magnetic' mass); in both, test orbits lie on cones (J.r fixed). - Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it)
From the same revised atomic weights (Karlsruhe 1860), de Chancourtois, Newlands, Meyer and Mendeleev built periodic systems separately 'at about the same time'. - Phonetics: the study of speech sounds (how they are made, carried through the air and heard, and how they are recorded and transcribed) together with the speech sounds it studies
Vocal learning built independently in humans and song-learning birds from shared parts: convergent gene expression in a motor nucleus with a direct line to brainstem vocal neurons (human laryngeal motor cortex, songbird RA) and a striatal learning nucleus; also in cetaceans, pinnipeds, bats, elephan - Phonology: how languages organise the meaningless units their words are built from (phonemes in spoken languages; handshape, location and movement in signed ones), together with the field of linguistics that studies those systems
Hundreds of sign languages, many unrelated, build similar phonologies from the same parts (hands, face, body); the source explains the likeness by their youth and shared modality, not shared descent. - Photosynthesis
C4 has evolved 'in at least 62 independent occasions in 19 different families of plants'; in grasses 17 to 18 independent lineages, the first 32.0-25.0 Mya, linked to falling CO2 (Christin). - Pion (pi meson)
Spontaneous breaking of a continuous symmetry leaves light bosons: pions are 'loosely portrayed as Goldstone bosons of spontaneously broken chiral symmetry', the same theorem the goldstone-boson walk follows into the Higgs vacuum and condensed matter. - Placenta (eutherian, chorioallantoic)
'The placenta has evolved independently multiple times, probably starting in fish, where it originated multiple times, including the genus Poeciliopsis'; also some reptiles; and syncytins were captured independently in primates, murids, ruminants and others. - Police
Civilisations with no contact built police from the same parts (officers under a judge or magistrate with power to arrest, market patrols, night watches): Old Kingdom Egypt (guards of markets, temples and parks; trained baboons and dogs), China's prefects, Rome's vigiles, and in the Americas Maya tu - Positional (place-value) notation with zero
The same rule built separately with different bases and carriers: Babylon base 60 (c. 2000 BC), Chinese rods base 10, Mesoamerica base 20 with zero by 36 BC, India 1st-4th c., Inca quipu; Leibniz and Bouvet found the I Ching 'an independent, parallel invention of binary notation'; Kaktovik students - Pragmatics
'Huh?': unrelated languages built nearly the same repair word independently, its form constrained by 'selective pressures in a conversational environment that is essentially the same in all languages' (convergent evolution of linguistic items). Partial second sighting: marmoset and human turn-taking - Primate (order Primates)
Routine trichromacy built twice from the X-linked opsin gene: by a duplication at the base of the catarrhines (about 35 Ma) and again by 'a relatively recent gene duplication of the M/L gene' in howler monkeys. - Prime numbers (the practice of number theory that finds, proves and uses them, and the structure of the primes it works on)
The same parts (two large primes, modular arithmetic) built into public-key encryption twice, independently: Cocks at GCHQ in secret (1973) and Rivest, Shamir and Adleman in public (1977). And the bounded-gap method found independently by Maynard and by Tao. - Proton
Stars build helium-4 from the same four protons by two separate routes: the pp chain, and the CNO cycle where 'four protons fuse, using isotopes of carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen as catalysts ... re-generated in a later step'; the pp chain dominates at the Sun's core temperature, the CNO cycle in star - Public-key cryptography
From the same parts (modular exponentiation, primes, finite fields), GCHQ built non-secret encryption (Cocks 1973) and key exchange (Williamson 1974) in secret, and Stanford and MIT built Diffie-Hellman (1976) and RSA (1977) in the open, without contact. Elliptic curves were proposed independently b - QCD vacuum
Spontaneous symmetry breaking with Goldstone bosons, built twice in the source's own comparison: the ferromagnet ('a preferred direction') and the QCD vacuum (pions as Goldstone bosons); the dual superconductor repeats a type II superconductor with electric and magnetic roles swapped. Re-walk: the i - Quantum dominant energy condition (QDEC)
The same composition at two levels: classically DEC = WEC + FEC; semi-classically QDEC = QWEC + QFEC, 'Analogously with the classical energy conditions'. - Quantum flux energy condition (QFEC)
One recipe applied twice: take a classical condition and allow a violation no larger than the natural quantum scale hbar N/L^4. The QWEC bounds the density, the QFEC the flux; 'In a similar way, other quantum (semi-classical) energy conditions have been formulated.' - Quantum geometrodynamics (canonical quantum gravity in metric variables; walked as a projected model)
One set of classical constraints, two quantizations: metric variables (QGD) and holonomies (LQG/LQC). They agree at low curvature and part ways in the Planck regime (singularity vs bounce). - Quark condensate (chiral condensate)
Spontaneous symmetry breaking with Goldstone modes, 'analogous to magnetization and superconductivity in condensed matter': a ferromagnet below its transition, the Higgs vacuum, and the QCD vacuum each break a continuous symmetry and leave massless or light bosons. - Real number (the practice of measuring the continuum, and the complete ordered field)
Dedekind (cuts), Cantor and Heine (Cauchy sequences), Meray (fictitious limits) and Weierstrass (lectures) built the reals from the same rationals, independently, 1865-1872; Dedekind found Cantor's axiom agreed with his own. - Redox
Electron-bifurcating flavoproteins fall into four groups that evolved independently, all using bound FAD or FMN; bioluminescence evolved independently at least 94 times (or over 40, C-2809) using luciferin oxidation, with luciferins that vary little (coelenterazine in 11 phyla) and luciferases that - RNA
From the RNAi toolkit present in the last eukaryotic common ancestor (s39), 'miRNAs or miRNA-like RNAs have emerged independently in other diverse eukaryotic lineages, including land plants', green and brown algae, filamentous fungi and slime mould (s48). - Scale-invariant loop quantum cosmology (no minimum size, no bounce)
The same loop-quantization toolkit built two ways: with an area gap (LQC: a bounce at Planck density) and with scale invariance (no gap: no bounce, the Big Bang kept). - Semiconductor
CdS semiconductor nanocrystals are built by chemists and, independently, by bacteria (E. coli; Antarctic Rhodococcus, Pseudarthrobacter, Arthrobacter) from the same Cd and S, with band gaps set by how long they grow; the bacteria's UV-defence molecules probably seed them. Re-walk (M7), a clean case - Sign language (the natural signed languages)
Isolates with no shared ancestor (Nicaraguan, Al-Sayyid Bedouin, Kata Kolok) built from human learners and gesture each arrive at spatial grammar and systematic word order: 'Spatial modulations are the building blocks of all sign languages studied to date'; ABSL's word orders are its own. - SL(2, C) (Spin(1,3))
The same construction, SL(2, K) acting on 2 x 2 Hermitian matrices, builds the spin groups of 3-, 4-, 6- and 10-dimensional spacetime from R, C, H, O; SL(2, C) is the four-dimensional build. - Social change
Mississippi and China 'evolved independently on different continents', yet the structure of social organisation (nine complexity characteristics, one principal component at 77%) 'is broadly shared across all continents and historical eras'. - Social stratification
Old World and New World societies built rising wealth inequality independently from the same parts (domesticated plants), on the same trajectory until about 2,500 years after local domestication; draft animals then split them. - Social structure
Linear dominance hierarchies built from the same parts (pairwise aggressive encounters) in insects, reptiles, fish, birds and mammals including human children. Hadza and modern networks share degree skew, transitivity, reciprocity and homophily, but that may be one inherited build (the dark twin), n - Solution (chemistry)
Antifreeze proteins from insects, a bacterium and fish evolved separately, yet 'in spite of the independent evolutionary roots they all have flat ice-binding faces with one or more arrays of threonine side chains juxtaposed towards the solvent': the same parts, the same result in solutions that must - Songbird (oscines, suborder Passeri)
Shared genes, separate assemblies, same result: song-learning nuclei and human speech regions show convergent specialised expression of multiple genes (motor control, connectivity); songbirds and hummingbirds reached sugar taste through the same T1R1-T1R3 receptor - Sound
Birds and mammals both locate sound by arrival-time difference between the ears, but built the circuit 'from different populations of ancestral cells'; echolocation in bats, toothed whales, shrews, cave swiftlets and the oilbird - Spacelike geodesic
One equation, three kinds: the geodesic equation builds timelike, null and spacelike geodesics alike ('the only difference is an overall minus sign'), each keeping its character forever. - Speech (human spoken language)
Vocal learning evolved separately in songbirds and humans (separated over 310 million years), with convergent gene-expression specializations in the matching brain regions (bird song nuclei with human laryngeal motor cortex and striatum). The descended larynx evolved at least twice (humans and red a - Spiders (order Araneae)
Webs and sociality built again and again from the same silk and behaviour: 'Convergent evolution in web construction ... is rampant'; social behaviour 'independently developed' in several theridiid genera. - Stellar magnetic field
Dynamo action (conducting fluid + rotation + induction) is built separately in stars, planets (liquid iron) and galaxies (ionised gas): 'the conductive fluid in the geodynamo is liquid iron ... and in the solar dynamo is ionized gas'. - Stored-program principle (instructions held in the same memory as data)
The rule was struck separately: Turing (1936), Zuse's patent applications (1936), and Eckert and Mauchly (December 1943), who 'were not aware of Turing's work'. - Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter)
The same Z2 charges and fluxes assembled in physically distinct systems give one topological structure: the superconductor, the Ising gauge theory, the short-ranged RVB state, a bilayer quantum Hall system, a Z2 lattice gauge theory with a charge-2 scalar ('an example of topological universality'), - Supergravity (projected model: the gauge theory of local supersymmetry)
Two builds of one object: string theory's D-branes (Polchinski, from open-string boundary conditions) and supergravity's p-branes (classical BPS solutions) turned out to be the same: D-branes 'equate to stringy versions of the p-branes known in supergravity theories'. - Supply and demand
The demand-and-supply diagram was built several times from the same parts (price, quantity, two curves): Cournot 1838; Rau 1841 'with no knowledge of its contents'; Dupuit 1844; Mangoldt 1863; Jenkin about 1870, an electrical engineer 'with no acquaintance with the work of Mangoldt or his predecesso - Tax
An income tax built twice from the same parts (income reported to officials, audited, a share taken): Wang Mang's 10% tax on net earnings in 9 CE, with reports audited and evasion punished by a year's hard labour, and Pitt's graduated tax in Britain in 1799. - Telephone
Gray's caveat and Bell's application for a liquid-transmitter telephone reached the US Patent Office on the same day (14 February 1876); the carbon microphone was independently developed around 1878 by Hughes in England and Berliner and Edison in the US; Campbell found the loading coil independently - Television
Electronic television was built several times from the same parts (Braun's cathode-ray tube, photoelectric surfaces): Takayanagi's 1926 receiver in Japan, Dieckmann and Hell's 1925 image dissector application in Germany, Farnsworth's 1927 image dissector in the US, and Ardenne's 1931 all-CRT system. - Thomas precession
Holonomy: parallel transport round a closed loop turns a vector by the enclosed curvature, built in relativistic velocity space (Thomas precession), on the 2-sphere (the Foucault pendulum: 'The angle of rotation in both cases is determined by the area integral of curvature in agreement with the Gaus - Tool
Hawaiian and New Caledonian crows are only distantly related yet both use tools, "suggesting that their technical abilities arose convergently" on islands; capuchins striking stone produce flakes and cores with "the characteristics and morphology of intentionally produced hominin tools": the same pa - Turing machine: the abstract machine that reads and writes one symbol at a time on an unbounded tape by a finite table of rules, the model of computation of logic and computer science
Church (lambda calculus, published 15 April 1936), Turing (machines, received 28 May 1936) and Post (a worker moving room to room, fall 1936) built the same notion of computability independently, each with a formalism, a universal process and diagonalization: 'Church, Post and Turing each used more - Vertebrate (Vertebrata)
Jawed and jawless vertebrates built two recombinatorial adaptive immune systems about 500 Ma from different receptors (immunoglobulin V(D)J vs leucine-rich repeat VLRs) with the same T-like/B-like division of labour. - Wetland
Mangroves: 'taxonomically diverse due to convergent evolution in several plant families'. Separate plant lineages built the same salt-tolerant, aerial-rooted tidal tree from the shared plant toolkit. - Word: the unit of a language's lexicon (spoken, signed or written) as linguists describe it, and as it is held, learned and retrieved in each speaker's mental lexicon
From the same toolkit of speech sounds, unrelated languages across continents build the same sound-meaning links for basic words ('tongue' with l, 'nose' with n, 'small' with i), often independently rather than inherited or borrowed. - World population (human population)
Plant cultivation was invented independently in three places (wheat in the Middle East and Europe, rice in Southeast Asia, maize in Central America and Peru), from local wild plants, and each farming population grew past what hunting could support (the Neolithic Demographic Transition). - World sheet
One action, unrelated objects: Nambu-Goto governs fundamental strings, QCD flux tubes, superconductor flux tubes and cosmic strings alike, as long as the curvature scale is much greater than the width. - Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
'With each independent invention of writing, the ideographs used in proto-writing were decoupled from the direct representation of ideas, and gradually came to represent words instead. This occurred via application of the rebus principle': four separate inventions crossed by the same step. - Yang-Mills theory
One construction built twice with different groups: SU(3) gives a confining, asymptotically free field; SU(2) x U(1) gives fields that mix into massive W, Z and the massless photon.
Partial: part of the shape (243)
- Acid-base reaction
With the same toolkit (natural proton gradients, Na+/H+ antiporters), 'ion pumps and phospholipid membranes arose later and independently in separate populations' in archaea and bacteria (Sojo 2014 model). - African elephant (genus Loxodonta: bush and forest elephants)
A very large, highly convoluted neocortex shared with humans, apes and some dolphins; the encyclopedia reads the neuron count as convergent evolution. Herculano-Houzel 2014 counts only 5.6 billion cortical neurons, a third of the human count, so the shared part is size and folding, not neuron number - Alloy
Many principal elements in near-equal parts: defined twice in 2004-2005, by Cantor and by Yeh, as separate works (src:wp:high-entropy-alloy); cobalt's gamma/gamma prime was found again in 2006 after nickel's (src:wp:superalloy). Independence of the early bronzes across regions is not shown in the so - Alphabet (one letter per phoneme)
The letter-per-phoneme rule struck again apart from the Phoenician line: Hangul (1443-1446), designed at Sejong's court, is the 'notable exception' to Phoenician descent, with letter shapes 'based on those of human speech organs'. - Animal (kingdom Animalia, Metazoa)
Labial pits evolved multiple times in boas and pythons (and loreal pits in pit vipers) from the same TRPA1/trigeminal toolkit. - Annelid (segmented worm; phylum Annelida)
Mushroom bodies and pallium: one reading 'deep homology' from shared molecular coordinates (Tomer 2010); another, 'convergent recruitment of the same genes into patterning of non-homologous organs' in nemerteans and annelids (Gasiorowski 2021). Either way the same gene set is used to build higher br - Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
Antibodies with no light chain, built twice from the same Ig parts: shark IgNAR 'is believed to have never had an associated light chain', while camelid heavy-chain-only antibodies 'may have lost their light chain partners through evolution'. Partial: the two builds start from different places (neve - Archaeon (Archaea)
Rod shapes from actin-family filaments in archaea as in bacteria ('a conserved function for these proteins in the regulation of cell shape'), with crenactin and MreB in different archaea; the shared parts may be inherited (the dark twin), so partial. - Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them
Greek and Indian traditions both built theories of fallacies from debating practice, serving similar purposes (Indian theories of fallacies alongside Aristotle's Sophistical Refutations). - Art history (the field)
Writing a canon of worthy artists arose in Greece and, 'similar, though independent', in 6th-century China: shared parts (writing, a ranked list of makers, principles of painting) in separate builds with the same result. - Asymptotic symmetry group
Asymptotic symmetries matching soft theorems are 'not specific to gravitation alone, but ... a general property of gauge theories including electromagnetism'. - Attention
Insects and vertebrates show the same four components (salience filters, competitive selection, top-down sensitivity control, working memory) built from neurons by 'different mechanisms'; whether independent or inherited is not settled in the abstract read. - Authentication
Next door, not in the human practice: two African bird families parasitized by different cuckoos both raised the information content of their egg signatures, mainly by uncoupling the same egg traits (colour, pattern, luminance). In the human practice, seals appear in Mesopotamia, Egypt, the Aegean a - Bearing (mechanical)
Wood and bronze rolling bearings appear about 2000 years ago in separate places: the Nemi ships (ball, cylindrical and taper-roller forms), a Celtic cart hub from Jutland (bronze collars with wooden rollers), and rival Chinese claims; early American cultures built neither. - Biology (the field)
Two forms. In the living world: the eyes of insects, vertebrates and cephalopods, 'long thought to have evolved separately', are controlled by similar toolkit genes. In the practice: Darwin and Wallace built natural selection from the same parts (Malthus, biogeography, natural observations) independ - Bird song culture
Learned song evolved separately in songbirds, parrots and hummingbirds with similar song systems; FoxP2, needed for human speech, is needed in zebra finch Area X for accurate imitation - Birkhoff's theorem (Birkhoff-Jebsen theorem)
Deser and Franklin derive Birkhoff's theorem as 'constancy of the mass' and illustrate it by 'a parallel derivation of the Coulomb field and constancy of electric charge, in electrodynamics'; the Newtonian shell theorem is the same statement in the Newtonian limit. - Blood pressure
Giraffes and sauropods each built very long necks on the vertebrate heart and hit the same pressure wall; and 'the hydrostatic pressure at the base of the neck of the largest giraffe has never been exceeded by the largest theropod and ornithopod dinosaurs, or in the largest extinct mammals, Mammuthu - Bosonic strings, closed, unoriented (projected model)
Gauging orientation reversal is one move used in two families: the bosonic unoriented strings and Type I superstrings (the orientifold of IIB). - Botnet
Independent operators build their own botnets from the same public toolkit (IRC, DNS, Tor, P2P protocols) for the same result; but most named botnets share code ancestry (one malware, many operators), the dark twin. - Bumblebee (Bombus)
Advanced eusociality arose twice among the corbiculate bees (after the split from bumblebees, on the honeybee and stingless-bee lines); one-origin trees read it as once - Bumblebee colony
Corbiculate eusociality: on the dual-origin reading, advanced eusociality arose separately on the honeybee and stingless-bee lines from shared corbiculate parts, with the primitively eusocial bumblebee near the stingless bees. - Business
Shares, pooled capital, profit-sharing and delegated management were assembled into large ventures in Song China (the douniu) and in Europe (Bazacle c. 1350, the East India companies 1600-1602). Partial: the sources read do not say whether the builds were independent or linked through trade. - Carbon bonding (tetravalence and catenation)
Silicon carries the same tetravalent, tetrahedral toolkit ('Tetrahedral coordination is a major structural motif in silicon chemistry just as it is for carbon chemistry'; diamond 'has the same cubic structure as silicon and germanium'), but its diffuse 3p orbitals hybridise poorly and Si-Si is weak, - Caustic of a timelike congruence (crossing of free-falling matter world lines)
The same focusing ends in crossings for free-falling matter (this caustic; dark matter in structure formation) and for light rays (lens caustics, the caustic walk's other stack). - Cave painting
hand stencils and figurative animals with the same parts (hand, ochre, spray) at opposite ends of Eurasia by about 40 ka and in Australia and South America; whether independent or one inheritance from Africa is open - Cell
Bacterial ion channels: their study 'has provided fundamental insights into the structural basis of neuronal signalling'; in biofilms they 'conduct long-range electrical signals... through spatially propagating waves of potassium', 'a prokaryotic paradigm for active, long-range electrical signalling - Chemical equilibrium
Ideas, at rung 11: the law of mass action built by Guldberg and Waage (1864) and independently by van 't Hoff (1877); the moderation principle by Le Chatelier (1884) and independently by Braun (1887) (o24). Shared parts: affinity, rates, the van 't Hoff relation. - Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes)
Stone hammers cracking encased food in chimpanzees, bearded capuchins (Brazil) and long-tailed macaques (Thailand) - Chinese art
Yangtze traditions with high relief without the leiwen ground 'suggesting that they represent independent developments' from the same piece-mould toolkit; highly radiogenic lead taken from multiple sources across China (one reading) - Classical conditioning
UAL evolved in arthropods and vertebrates in the middle Cambrian and in molluscs about 250 million years later, each with its own structures; invertebrates use 'many of the same mechanisms' (cAMP, adenylyl cyclase); ciliates carry calmodulin and MAP kinases. Partial: shared ancestry versus independe - Clifton-Pohl torus
Two Lorentzian counterexamples built the same way, by dividing a two-dimensional Lorentzian surface by a discrete group of its isometries: Misner space by a boost (giving closed null curves and a non-curvature singularity), the Clifton-Pohl torus by a homothety (giving a compact surface with incompl - Cloud computing
Several providers built clouds from the same commodity servers, Linux and virtualization; open-source projects rebuilt them from outside: 'Hadoop and Hypertable are efforts to recreate the Google infrastructure, and Eucalyptus recreates important aspects of the EC2 API'. Shared ideas make the indepe - Color confinement
Confinement recurs outside four-dimensional QCD: the two-dimensional Schwinger model, compact Abelian gauge theories in 2 and 3 dimensions, and spinons in magnetic systems. - Compiler
Many compilers for one language are built independently from the same parts (the language standard, lexer and parser theory, SSA) and must give the same outputs: differential testing and diverse double-compiling rely on it. How independent the builds are (shared ancestry) is not settled in the sourc - Complex analysis (the practice of working with functions of a complex variable, and the holomorphic structure it works on)
The complex plane was described by Wessel (1799) and independently by Argand (1806) and others; phase plots 'have been invented independently by a number of people'; the Nyquist criterion was found independently by Strecker (1930) and Nyquist (1932). - Complex hyperbolic space
Three generalisations of the hyperbolic plane built from different number systems: real hyperbolic space (constant curvature), complex hyperbolic space (curvature pinched -1 to -1/4) and SL_n(R)/SO_n(R) (higher rank); all three 'for n = 2 again coincide with the hyperbolic plane'. - Computer ethics
84 issuers in many countries built principle lists from the same parts and converged on five (transparency 73/84, justice and fairness 68, non-maleficence 60, responsibility 60, privacy 47). Dark twin flagged: Mittelstadt reads the convergence as resembling medicine's four principles, so shared ance - Computer hardware
Anticipating carriage built twice from the same parts (propagate and generate signals): designed by Babbage in the mid-1800s, built by Zuse in the Z1 in the 1930s; later Kogge-Stone and Brent-Kung layouts in silicon. - Computer memory
The Williams tube (Manchester) and the Selectron (RCA) both 'originated in 1946, both using electron beams in glass tubes as means of storage'; different builds (Williams thousands of bits, Selectron 256). The sources do not say the two were independent. - Computer science (the field: the practice and the computation it studies)
Church's effective calculability and Turing's computability reached the same class from different definitions; NP-completeness posed by Cook and by Levin in the early 1970s. - Contract
Partner choice and sanctions, the toolkit of self-stabilising biological 'contracts', built independently in unrelated mutualisms (rhizobia-legume, mycorrhizal fungi and plants, cleaner fish and clients, yucca and yucca moth). Partial: the independence of the builds is read from the spread of exampl - Corporate law
By about 1900 every major commercial jurisdiction had a standard form with the same five features; whether built independently or by transplant (French code abroad; borrowed laws as 'irritants') is not separated in the sources. - Corporation
Legal personhood with property, contract and suit was built in ancient India (srenis, as early as 800 BC) and in Rome (collegia, publicani). Partial: independence of the two builds is not argued in the sources read. - Cortical folding (gyrification: the cerebral cortex folds into gyri and sulci)
Higher orders of folding built again and again along divergent mammal lineages, from shared progenitor machinery (bRGCs ancestral to therians); similar GPR56 regulation in primates, carnivores and cetaceans read as convergent - Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy)
The same vacuum-energy build (p = -rho, de Sitter expansion) appears twice: early as inflation ('a negative pressure field, similar in concept to dark energy') and late as the cosmological constant, at energy densities far apart; 'It is unclear what relation, if any, exists' between them. - Covalent bond
The same peptide bond is built by two separate machines from the same parts: ribosomes for proteins, and enzymes for nonribosomal peptides ('Organisms use enzymes to produce nonribosomal peptides, and ribosomes to produce proteins'). Shared ancestry not ruled out in the sources read. - Cretaceous-Paleogene (K-Pg) extinction event and the radiation it released
Ratites 'convergently developed flightlessness at least three to six times', filling the large-herbivore niches dinosaurs left; arboreal crown birds re-emerged 'through repeated convergent shifts' from ground-dwelling survivors. - Crystallization (nucleation and crystal growth)
Biomineralization evolved multiple times, independently (c120), with an organic matrix directing crystal deposition (c119). - Ctenophore (Ctenophora, comb jelly)
Ctenophore and cnidarian peptidergic cells express the vast majority of the bilaterian neuropeptide machinery (common origin of peptidergic systems), while the classical transmitter pathways are absent or not expressed in ctenophore neurons and the nerve net is a syncytium: shared parts, differently - Culture
Vocal learning circuitry built independently in humans, dolphins, bats and some birds, with no common ancestor that had it - Curriculum
Mass elementary curricula very similar across the world; science and maths entered national curricula roughly simultaneously and before international organizations - Cyanobacterium (Cyanobacteria, phylum Cyanobacteriota)
Chlorophyll b without phycobilisomes in Prochloron, Prochlorococcus and Prochlorothrix: they 'appear to have developed in several different lines of cyanobacteria'. - Cyber threat intelligence
Vendors with the same parts (sensors, telemetry, analysts) build separate taxonomies that name the same groups (Fancy Bear, APT-28, Sofacy, STRONTIUM ...); vendors also recycle each other's data, so independence is partial. - Cyberwarfare
About 120 countries build cyber forces from the same parts (exploits, malware, DDoS, propaganda) into separate national forces; independence not shown (copying is likely), so partial. - Dark energy
A negative-pressure vacuum term built twice at scales ~27 orders of energy apart: 'Inflation postulates that some repulsive force, qualitatively similar to dark energy, resulted in an enormous and exponential expansion'; 'it is unclear what relation, if any, exists between them'. - Data centre
Hyperscalers built their own facility designs separately from the same commodity parts (Facebook's Prineville servers, Google's 48 V rack), later shared through the Open Compute Project. - Data structure
Hashing arose independently in different places in the early 1950s (Luhn at IBM; Amdahl, McGraw, Rochester and Samuel); stacks independently in Turing's bury/unbury, Zuse's Z4 and Samelson-Bauer's cellar. - Denial-of-service attack
Separate booter services build their attacks from the same shared pool of public reflectors and the same protocols; seizing one front end leaves the reflectors 'utilized by third parties'. Partial: whether the booters are independent builds or copies is not shown. - Digestive system (the gut and its accessory organs)
the same signalling pathways used again and again across endoderm development (Wnt, FGF, BMP, RA) - Digital forensics
Disk imaging tools were built separately in the US (IMDUMP, SafeBack), the UK (DIBS) and Australia (Fixed Disk Image) around 1989-1991 for the same result: an exact copy to work on. - Digital identity
Signed claims checked against a public key are the shared parts of X.509 certificates, federation assertions and verifiable credentials; the assemblies differ (CA hierarchy, IdP, ledger) for the same result, but the builds share lineage, so independence is not shown. - Digital signatures and certificates
From the same parts (signatures over public keys), key-to-name binding was built as a top-down hierarchy (X.509, 1988) and as a web of trust (PGP, 1992), 'in a format that performs a similar function'. Shared ancestry in public-key cryptography is likely, so independence is partial. - Dinosaurs (Dinosauria)
Closed-mouth calls (cooing, hooting, booming by inflating the oesophagus or tracheal pouches) 'evolved independently in extant archosaurs numerous times, following increases in body size'. - Domestic dog (Canis familiaris)
Voice areas in dog and human temporal cortex, lineages split 90-100 Mya; 'parallel evolution cannot be excluded' - Doplicher-Fredenhagen-Roberts quantum spacetime
The same commutation relations appear for charged particles in constant electromagnetic fields: 'our commutation relations occur in the theory of charged particles is constant electromagnetic fields' (also the fuzzy-sphere and Landau-level construction). - Drainage basin (watershed)
Branching trees that gather or distribute flow: river networks, (biological) trees, and animal respiratory and circulatory systems share the same Strahler numbers, and catchment 'blue metabolism' is described by analogy to blood vessels. Shared parts (branching, a scaling of size with flow), indepen - Drama (the literary form)
Greek and Sanskrit drama both built from dialogue, chorus or music, dance, stock types and masks or make-up; India shows no archaeological trace of earlier theatre (independence contested) - Ecological succession
A sere is 'a repeatable sequence of community changes specific to particular environmental circumstances': separate sites with similar species pools build the same sequence. - Education
Writing (the shared toolkit) and schools arose in Mesopotamia, Egypt, the Indus Valley and China - Electrical grid
Britain, France, the United States and China each built synchronised AC grids from the same parts (generators, transformers, three-phase AC); AEG and Westinghouse settled on 50 and 60 Hz separately. - Electromagnetic field
A weak leftover force between neutral composites, built twice: the residual strong force is 'much weaker between neutrons and protons, because it is mostly neutralized within them, in the same way that electromagnetic forces between neutral atoms (van der Waals forces) are much weaker' than those ho - Electromagnetic radiation
depigmented skin evolved independently in European and East Asian populations, both answering lower UV-B (src:raczyk-carlberg-2026); the shared parts are not itemised in the source read - Electroweak epoch
Symmetry breaking as the bath cools, twice: electroweak symmetry breaking was 'the penultimate symmetry breaking event ... the final one being chiral symmetry breaking in the quark sector'; both end an epoch's symmetric phase in a crossover. - End-Ordovician (Late Ordovician) mass extinction, with the Silurian recovery it released
'Parallel, endemic radiations of jawed and related jawless vertebrates (gnathostomes) in isolated refugia': the same vertebrate body plan radiating separately in unconnected places after the crisis. - Endocrine system
Neurosecretory cells are shared by all animals with nerves, but their gathering into a central forerunner of the pituitary 'occurred in several phyla independently' (possible, per Hartenstein): insect PI/PL over CC/CA, vertebrate hypothalamus over pituitary. - English language: a West Germanic language of the Indo-European family, from its Old English beginnings to its varieties and its use as a global lingua franca, as linguistics and its history describe it
Separate colonies built from the same mix of British dialects levelled into similar koine forms: South African, Australian and New Zealand English, each other's closest relatives, all non-rhotic. - Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies)
The same toolkit (long-term monitoring feeding legislation) built separately in Scandinavia and in the USA for acid rain - Epic poetry
formula, metre and episode build long sung hero tales in the Balkans, Homer, Old English, the Sakha Olonko and the Mande Sundiata; independence against shared descent not settled - Epistemology (the theory of knowledge: the study and the knowing it studies)
Gettier-type cases built from the same parts (justified belief, true by luck) by Dharmottara in India, Peter of Mantua in medieval Europe, Russell and Gettier; reliabilist theories by Gangesa (14th-century India) and Goldman (20th century). Independence is read from the encyclopedia's history, not s - Essay
short, loosely connected personal prose written 'at will' with the pen: the Japanese zuihitsu (Pillow Book c. 1000, Tsurezuregusa 1330) and Montaigne's essais (1580); Kenko described his writings 'similarly to Montaigne'; independence implied by time and distance, not stated - Eternal Emergent Universe
The emergent potential (B = 1) is 'identical up to an overall rescaling' to the Einstein-frame potential of R^2-driven inflation: one plateau shape reached from a closed static start and from higher-derivative gravity. - Ethics (moral philosophy: the study and the morality it studies)
Ethical teachings arise in ancient Egypt, India, China and Greece, each building duty, virtue or harmony; independence is not shown in the sources read (contacts not examined). - Ethnic group
Three São Tomé and Príncipe communities (Forros, Principenses, Angolares) built from shared Gulf of Guinea and Angolan sources each became a distinct group with its own creole language. - Euclidean group
Three groups, one recipe: translations semidirect with a point-fixing group (O(n) here, the Lorentz group in the Poincare group, rotations plus boosts in the Galilean group). - Extremal Kerr spacetime
The extreme rotating throat 'is similar to the AdS2 x S2 geometry arising in the near horizon limit of extreme charged black holes': extremality by spin and by charge build the same kind of throat. - Extremal Reissner-Nordstrom black hole
Extremality by charge (AdS2 x S2) and by spin (the extreme Kerr throat) build the same kind of near-horizon throat with a timelike boundary. - f(R) gravity (modified gravity; walked as a projected model)
The chameleon screening (density-dependent mass) is found in scalar dark-energy models and again in metric f(R). - Finsler manifold
The Randers form (a quadratic metric plus a one-form) is built independently by a boat in a current (Zermelo navigation), by wind acting on physical systems, and by a charged particle in an electromagnetic potential. - Fish school (shoal)
Fish schools, starling flocks, krill swarms and human crowds build collective motion from the same few local rules (attraction, alignment, repulsion; a small informed minority guiding the rest); schooling was lost independently in several cave populations. - Fishery
Anchored rafts that draw pelagic fish built in Island Southeast Asia (payao), Japan and Malta for centuries; whether these share an origin is not stated. - Fossil fuel
Shared parts (dead organic matter, burial out of oxygen, crustal heat), separate assemblies, the same result (a buried hydrocarbon fuel): plankton and algae through type I-II kerogen to oil; woody plants through peat to coal, or type III kerogen to gas. Partial: the builds are branches of one proces - Galaxy
Spiral arms from the same disc ingredients by three separate routes: quasi-stationary density waves, swing-amplified local instabilities, and tidal interactions. - Gear
Cuticle built into intermeshing teeth twice, in two insect orders and on different body parts (Issus nymph trochantera, Hemiptera; horned beetle mandibles, Coleoptera; the gear-like structure found in all 22 Dynastinae and none of 16 other beetles), alongside people's bronze, iron and wooden gears. - Glacier
A solid that flows under its own weight is built on three worlds from different ices: water ice on Earth and Mars (where ablation is solely sublimation and debris insulates the ice as on Earth), and nitrogen ice on Pluto, flowing into and out of Sputnik Planitia. - Globalization
The air network and the cargo-ship network were built separately for different uses, yet 'both networks exhibit striking statistical similarities despite significant differences in topology and connectivity', each segregating into two classes of nodes and links. - Grammar (the structure of a language, as linguistics describes it)
Creoles built separately share features: default past reference, pre-verbal tense-aspect-mood auxiliaries, questions by intonation (Bickerton). - Great tit (Parus major)
Conformity in foraging traditions shown in a wild bird after vervet monkeys: social learning built in separate lineages (the shared parts are not named in the sources read) - Group field theory (GFT; candidate quantum gravity, walked as a projected model)
Glued simplices summed in a path integral, built in GFT, in causal dynamical triangulation and in Regge calculus; GFT is where they converge. - Hamiltonian and Lagrangian mechanics (analytical mechanics: classical mechanics built from energy functions and the stationary action, and the practice of using them)
The Kepler-splitting symplectic integrator was built twice in 1991, by Wisdom and Holman and 'independently' by Kinoshita et al., from the same parts (Kepler motion plus small tugs, operator splitting). Dark twin to watch: both groups read the same celestial-mechanics literature (shared ancestry of - Heart
Birds and mammals, evolving separately from ectotherms, have 'highly similar conduction systems' that may have evolved independently with endothermy; the alligator has an AV bundle but no Purkinje network. - Higgs boson
Same parts (gauge theory, a scalar with a vacuum value, Goldstone's and Anderson's results), separate builds, same result: Englert and Brout (June 1964), Higgs (July and August 1964), Guralnik, Hagen and Kibble (October 1964), and in isolation Migdal and Polyakov ('completely independent of the deve - Human culture
Bastian: all societies share 'elementary ideas'; each culture is a local modification; cultural universals (music in every society observed). Dark twin noted by the source itself: outside influence could explain some universals, so shared ancestry or diffusion may be read as independence. - Humpback whale song
Whale song and human language, in 'two evolutionarily distant species', both carry statistically coherent parts with power-law frequencies; the shared toolkit is learning and cultural transmission - Hydrogen bond
The same amide N-H...O=C hydrogen bond links protein strands in beta sheets and links nylon chains, built separately by evolution and by chemists ('In nylon, hydrogen bonds between carbonyl and the amide NH effectively link adjacent chains, which gives the material mechanical strength'). - Ideal gas
The idea of the gas was built twice, three times over from the same parts: Boyle (1662) and Mariotte (1679) the pressure-volume law; Kronig (1856) and Clausius (1857) the ideal gas law from kinetic theory, 'independently'; Sackur and Tetrode the absolute entropy (1912), 'independently'. Seen in the - Infinity: the boundless or endless as mathematics and philosophy describe it (potential and actual infinity, Cantor's sizes of infinity, infinity in calculus, geometry, physics and computing) and the practice of the people who argue over it
Newton and Leibniz, co-inventors, each built an infinitesimal calculus with infinite series and infinitely small quantities. - Inflation (economics)
Hyperinflations built again and again from the same parts, fiat paper money plus a deficit financed by new money (at least 25 of Bernholz's 29), in Germany, Hungary, Zimbabwe, Venezuela, each ending in the same way. Whether each build was independent (no shared ancestry) is not shown. - Information warfare
Organised manipulation in 70 countries built from the same parts (bots, human accounts, cyborgs, hacked accounts) by governments and parties; independence of the builds not shown. - Insider threat
Sabotage and espionage, two separate kinds of betrayal, build the same path from the same parts (predispositions, stressors, concerning behaviour, unanswered violations, weak access controls); the team first thought one model for both nearly impossible. - Insurance
Risk spreading and transfer appear among Chinese and Indian traders, in Babylonian law, Greek marine loans and Genoese contracts, and in Maasai and religious communities; the sources do not show whether these were independent. - Intrusion detection system
Statistics plus rules, built again and again in the early labs: IDES (SRI), W&S (Los Alamos), ISOA, ComputerWatch (AT&T), NADIR. Partial: several drew on Denning's model (NADIR was 'heavily influenced by the work of Denning and Lunt'). - Japanese macaque (Macaca fuscata)
Food washing built separately by Japanese macaques at Koshima (1953) and long-tailed macaques at Koram Island (recently, spontaneously): shared parts (hands, water, an aversion to sand), separate inventions, same result; stone handling likewise in four macaque species - Japanese tit (Parus minor)
Compositional call combination (two meaningful calls into one compound) argued to have evolved independently in birds and in human language; the authors: it 'may have evolved independently in animals' - Kinship
Terminologies built from the same few distinctions (generation, sex, side, crossness) converge on a handful of types in separate families: the patterning 'displays widespread typological convergence', while each family's terms track its own tree. - Labour market
Withdrawing labour to press a claim over pay was built separately in pharaonic Egypt (Deir el-Medina, 1152 BCE, over late wages) and in republican Rome (the plebeians' secession, which Wells called the invention of the strike), and again in industrial Britain: shared parts (collective withdrawal), s - Laplace operator
The same operator reached by different routes: as the divergence of the gradient, as the limit of a local average's deviation, as the stationarity condition of the Dirichlet energy, and as the generator of Brownian motion. - Laplace's equation
The boundary-fixes-interior property reached by two builds: the maximum principle of the equation, and Brownian motion's exit distribution (harmonic measure), which gives 'short proofs of ... the maximum principle, and uniqueness for the Dirichlet problem'. - Lateral line
After electroreception was lost in the neopterygian ancestor it 'subsequently evolved independently at least twice' in teleosts (catfishes, knifefishes, elephantnose fishes), within the lateral line system and innervated by lateral line nerves; one hypothesis is that these were built by modifying ne - Lexicon: the stock of words and word parts of a language, and as each person holds it (the mental lexicon), as linguistics and psychology describe it
Written word lists (the parts: a script and a list of words with glosses) were built into dictionaries in Mesopotamia, China, India and the Arab world, each in its own order. - Life (the living world, as biology describes it)
In volvocine algae multicellularity evolved independently in two families and cellular differentiation at least four times, from one shared algal kit - Literacy
Script, and so literacy, was invented independently at least five times (Mesopotamia, Egypt, Indus, Mesoamerica, China); and each literate brain builds its reading network from the same ventral visual stream, at a reproducible site. - LLM-based agent
Three harnesses from opposite philosophies converged on one middle form. Dark twin flagged by the source itself: 'We therefore do not claim independent invention' (diffusion and literal reuse). - Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason
Logic developed independently in Greece, India and China from shared parts (language, debate, excluded middle and non-contradiction, quantifiers in Mohist texts) into different builds (syllogistic, five-membered inference, analogical disputation). - Lymphatic system
The avian lymph heart is skeletal muscle (no cardiac markers) yet beats by intrinsic action potentials using 'similar molecular mechanisms' to cardiac pacemaker cells: one rhythm toolkit, two separately built organs in one animal. - Lyric poetry
short fixed lyric forms built in separate traditions from the same parts (a line count, one rhyme or refrain, a syllable or mora count, a break): the Japanese haiku, the Persian ghazal, the Italian sonnet; 'The structural requirements of ghazal are similar in stringency to those of the Petrarchan so - Machine
Intermeshing toothed gears built by engineers (Antikythera; gear trains) and, separately, by evolution in the planthopper Issus, whose cuticular gears 'have never been reported to intermesh and rotate functionally like mechanical gears' in other animals. - Magnetically charged Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
A layered electroweak structure around a magnetic core: here the restored-symmetry region and corona around a black hole; in the GUT monopole a GUT core, electroweak region and confinement shell. Maldacena: 'we get the same corona for a large Q Dirac monopole'. - Management
Fayol and colleagues built a general theory of administration independently of Taylor's scientific management, from the same industrial setting; both are counted founders of modern management. Shared parts not itemised in sources read: partial. - Mantle (geology): Earth's mantle
Silicate mantles were built separately by density differentiation in Mercury, Venus, Mars, the Moon, Io, Europa, Ganymede and Vesta, each its own thickness and share of mass. - Massive graviton (the spin-2 quantum of massive gravity; hypothetical)
Vainshtein screening is 'at play not just in massive gravity, but also in related theories of modified gravity such as DGP and certain scalar-tensor theories'. - Mathematical proof: the practice of showing that a statement follows from axioms and earlier theorems, how it is written, checked (by people and machines) and accepted, and the derivations it works on
One theorem gets independent proofs (other proofs of the geometrization theorem for Haken manifolds); risks are reduced by 'multiple independent approaches and programs' built on the same mathematics; HOL Light's kernel proof re-verified in HOL Zero and HOL4. - Matrix (mathematics): the rectangular array of numbers and its algebra, determinants and eigenvalues, matrices as linear maps, their history, and their use in physics, graphics and machine learning; the practice and the structure both booked
Array methods for simultaneous equations in China (the Nine Chapters), Europe (Cardano 1545) and Japan (Seki 1683); determinants proper arose separately with Seki (1683) and Leibniz (1693). Transmission between them is not shown in the sources read. - Maxwell's equations (classical electromagnetism as a codified law set)
Induction was found twice ('Independently, Joseph Henry made similar observations in 1832'); Heaviside 'independently developed vector calculus' and 'independently discovered the Poynting vector'; FitzGerald, Lorentz and Poincaré each pointed toward relativity. - Mechanical engineering (the field)
Meshing gear teeth were built by evolution in planthopper nymphs and, separately, by people (the Antikythera Mechanism, 2nd century BC; Ma Jun's differential chariot; Su Song's escapement and chain drive); the wheel may have been invented independently in Mesopotamia and Eastern Europe (contested, C - Metaphysics (the branch of philosophy: its practice and the questions about reality it works on)
Object permanence (Stages 4-5) reported in primates, birds, ungulates, marine mammals, dogs and cats; whether birds and mammals built it separately is not shown in the source read. - Methane (CH4)
Methane is made by three independent routes the sources sort apart: biogenic (methanogenesis, only in some Archaea), thermogenic (heat breaking organic matter at depth) and abiotic (magmatic or serpentinization), plus grain-mantle chemistry in space. - Middle English literature
Four nearly complete play cycles (York, Chester, Towneley, N-Town) built in different towns from the same biblical material, creation to Last Judgment. How independent they were is not shown in the sources read. - Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time)
The same igneous processes on separate bodies reach the same count: 'In a volatile-poor body such as Mercury and the Moon, the above processes give rise to about 350 mineral species.' Shared parts (one nebula's elements, the same melting and crystallisation), separate builds, same result. Partial: t - Mitochondrion
Internal energy membranes (endomembranes) evolved several times, mostly for energy (cyanobacterial thylakoids), from shared respiratory and photosynthetic parts; cristae are one such build. - Moduli (moduli fields; projected model)
The same oscillate-then-decay-and-reheat build as the inflaton: a scalar holds energy, comes to dominate, then decays into a hot bath. - Money of account (the unit of account: number applied to exchange)
Coins were struck separately in India, China and the Aegean in the 7th century BC: 'The different forms and metallurgical processes imply a separate development'; paper money arose in Song China and again in Sweden in 1661. - Motivation
The biogenic amines, all made from tyrosine, modulate reward-seeking in nematodes, flatworms, molluscs, vertebrates and (as octopamine) arthropods; yet the review judges a true homology of brain reward systems unlikely: shared parts, separately assembled. Conservation against convergence left open. - Movable type (reusable cast sorts x the alphabet; the European press)
Metal movable type struck in Korea (1234; Jikji 1377), 'extremely similar to Gutenberg's' (Martin), and again at Mainz; whether any report reached Europe is disputed: Gies 'almost certain' against McDermott 'No text indicates the presence or knowledge of any kind of Asian movable type ... in Europe - Neocortex (six-layered isocortex)
Upper-layer (II/III) neurons from a subventricular zone in mammals, and layer II/III-like neurons in birds: 'an example of parallel evolution' from a reptile-like ancestor that lacks a pallial SVZ. - Neutron star magnetosphere
The pair-discharge kit (an unscreened E.B, photons, pairs, screening, repeat) is built on open field lines driven by rotation in pulsars and on twisted closed field lines driven by crust motion in magnetars ('similar one-dimensional PIC simulations of pair creation in the twisted closed magnetospher - New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides)
Tool use in two island crows, the New Caledonian crow and the distantly related Hawaiian crow, read by the authors as convergent; both share the corvid kit (caching action patterns, inherited tool dispositions) - Non-CFL quark liquid (dense quark matter phases other than colour-flavour locking)
Crystalline (LOFF) pairing, 'first proposed in condensed matter physics' (Fulde-Ferrell 1964, Larkin-Ovchinnikov 1965), is predicted again in quark matter and sought in cold trapped atoms: three unrelated fermion systems, same parts (attraction plus mismatched Fermi surfaces), same proposed answer. - Noncommutative torus
The same twisted pair of translations built twice in unconnected settings: compact dimensions of Matrix theory with a constant three-form (CDS) and an electron lattice threaded by magnetic flux (Bellissard et al.). - Nonverbal communication
Dogs evolved a human-directed eyebrow movement from the facial muscle toolkit shared with wolves (LAOM present in dogs, scant in wolves): a new build of the face-to-eye channel humans use, in a separate lineage - Novel
shared parts (urbanisation, printed books, readers in towns, lending libraries) assembled separately in Ming China, Edo Japan and early modern Europe, each ending in a long vernacular prose fiction. Partial: the routes are separate in the sources, but full independence (no borrowing) is not shown; Y - Number and counting (the number sense, the practice of counting, and the structure it works on)
Tuned, log-scaled number detectors appear in monkey cortex, crow NCL and, from local filtering and pooling units alone, in deep networks trained on objects (9.6% of the final layer) or never trained; 'virtually identical' to real number neurons. Dark twin noted: the networks were biologically inspir - Old English literature
Formulaic verse found in Homer and in Old English: Parry and Lord showed "the density of metrical formulas in Ancient Greek, and observed the same feature in the Old English alliterative line"; the Hero on the Beach turns up in Greek poetry "a tradition without known connection to the Germanic". Dar - Open-source software
Free Unix-like systems built from the same toolkit (Unix's design, C) by separate lineages: GNU with Linux, and the BSDs; BSD descends from Unix code, so independence is partial. - Operating system
UNIX ideas (fork from Berkeley's time-sharing system, I/O calls and Shell from Multics) rebuilt in new code: MINIX 'inspired' Linux, written fresh with 'UNIX System V syntax'; Windows NT rebuilt VAX/VMS features. Shared ancestry is close (dark twin), so partial. - Orca (killer whale, Orcinus orca)
Vocal imitation evolved independently in a few distant bird and mammal lineages; long post-reproductive life spans in humans and several toothed whales - Organization
Written records, appointed officials and offices supervising offices assembled in Sumer, Qin China and Rome; the same layer sizes in armies, hunter-gatherer clans, business communities of practice and online game alliances. Independence of the builds is not stated by the sources. - Painting
iron-mineral reds and yellows and manganese blacks in Pecos River murals (Americas), and ochre, hematite, manganese oxide and charcoal in Old World caves; independence of the traditions not tested in the sources (shared deep ancestry of pigment use possible) - Pallium (the dorsal telencephalon of vertebrates)
Birds and mammals: 'four convergently evolved neural features' (many associative pallial neurons, a PFC-like area, dense dopamine innervation, working-memory dynamics), the avian NCL as 'the functional equivalent of the mammalian PFC'. In worms: nemertean cerebral organs and annelid mushroom bodies - Pancreas
Same cells, two assembly routes: 'studies in zebrafish embryos have indicated islet formation by fusion, whereas our studies in mice and studies in carp and humans suggest formation by fission'. Dark-twin caution: the lineages share the islet by descent, so this is two builds of one inherited struct - Perception
Pigeons (a basal bird lineage), corvids and monkeys all represent number on a logarithmic scale; the authors read it as brains selecting the optimal coding by convergent evolution (their hypothesis). - Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
Jaspers' Axial Age: universalizing thought in Persia, India, China, the Levant and Greece 'without any obvious admixture'; a shared toolkit (writing as external memory, or affluence) proposed; disputed, and Seshat data place the traits earlier and less bunched. - Phishing
The same parts, a copy of a reply signal the prey trusts plus a capture step, assembled in lineages that share no build: katydids, Photuris fireflies and people. Partial because Moser et al. suggest human deception of each other may itself descend from deceiving prey, a shared origin within the huma - Photography
Photography was worked out independently from the same parts (silver salts, the camera obscura) by Niépce/Daguerre in France, Talbot in England, Florence in Brazil, Bayard in France and Kobell and Steinheil in Munich - Physics (the field)
Two collaborations, ATLAS and CMS, built separate detectors from the same kinds of parts (trackers, calorimeters, muon systems) on the same collider, and reached the same Higgs mass: 'The measured masses from the individual channels and the two experiments are found to be consistent among themselves - Planet
Bodies that never shared a build sort themselves the same way: planets, dwarf planets, large moons and the asteroid Vesta all differentiate into dense core and lighter mantle ('similar to that of Venus, Earth, and Mars'). - Plant (kingdom Plantae)
Plants and animals 'share common mechanisms for gravity sensing, e.g., an actin cytoskeleton and mechanosensitive ion channels', while 'animals evolved unique systems for gravisensing as exemplified by the transcriptional coactivator YAP/TAZ'. The source itself compares amyloplast sedimentation with - Plant seed
Double fertilization in Gnetales and angiosperms 'arose independently' on the gne-pine phylogeny: the same two-sperm parts, built twice. - Plasma
Screening by mobile charges, built twice: in a plasma 'charges naturally screen out electric fields ... With each Debye length ... the electric potential decreases in magnitude by e'; in a QGP 'the color charge of the quarks and gluons is screened', Q -> Q e^(-r/alpha), with dissimilarities 'because - Plato
Several Socratics (Xenophon, Aeschines, Antisthenes, Aristippus, Eucleides, Phaedo and others) built Socratic dialogues from the same parts (Socrates as speaker, question and answer). Dark twin: one teacher behind them all, so the builds share ancestry. - Play
The encyclopedia says play 'has arisen independently' in mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians, fish and invertebrates; Dona finds bee play 'akin to play in other animals'. Shared ancestry versus independent origin is not settled in the sources read. - Political party
Party systems were built from factions in several places: Britain (Whigs and Tories), Sweden (called the first party system), the United States (1790s); later many decolonised countries built parties from independence movements (though some copied the Indian National Congress: shared ancestry there) - Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies)
Democratic peace: the logic (shared decisions restrain leaders' fights) found in human states and, in evolutionary game models, in animal groups without human institutions. Crisis warning: the same rise in variance and correlation before crisis in societies, mice, trees, grasses and markets. - Prairie dog (Cynomys)
Plague resistance in prairie dogs and in great gerbils: different genes from the same gene classes (transmembrane proteins, protocadherins, Kazusa-protein-binding genes); ICOS also selected in humans in the Black Death - Programming language
The Hindley-Milner type system was 'first described by J. Roger Hindley and later rediscovered by Robin Milner'. Thompson and Ritchie once wrote 'the same 20-line assembly language program' and found the sources 'matched character-for-character'. Whether the rediscovery was fully independent is not - Protein domain (and the tertiary fold it builds)
On one reading the TIM barrel was built more than once from the same parts: 'a stable TIM-barrel structure has evolved through convergent evolution'; 'some proteins may converge towards these folds'. The other reading is one ancestor diverging (C-239). - Public opinion
In 1936 Gallup, Crossley and Roper each built far smaller, scientifically based samples and all three called the result the 2.3-million-postcard Literary Digest got wrong. Partial: shared statistical toolkit, contemporaries; independence of the builds not documented in the source read. - Pulsar wind nebula
Particles accelerated at a shock: pairs to Lorentz factors of 1e6 at the PWN's termination shock, cosmic-ray nuclei by first-order Fermi acceleration at supernova-remnant shocks. - QCD matter (quark matter and its phase diagram)
Lossless charge transport by condensed Cooper pairs: colour superconductivity carries colour charge without loss, 'analogous to the way conventional superconductors can carry electric charge without loss'; quarks near the Fermi surface pair and condense. Unlike the electrical case it comes in many v - Quadratic quasinormal mode
Sum tones of a nonlinear oscillator: frequencies add (omega_1 + omega_2) as in any second-order nonlinearity; here built by GR's own nonlinearity on a black hole. - Quantum field theory
Renormalization built more than once from the same parts (bare mass and charge replaced by measured ones): Tomonaga, Schwinger and Feynman around 1950, and Stueckelberg in 1947, who 'independently developed a complete renormalization procedure' that was 'not understood and recognized'. Plus the diag - Quantum mechanics
Matrix mechanics (Heisenberg, Born, Jordan) and wave mechanics (Schroedinger) were built 'almost simultaneously' and separately, and in May 1926 were shown to make the same predictions with 'an underlying common form'. Shared toolkit: both built on the old quantum theory and classical mechanics, so - Quantum spin chain
The same parts, Cu2+ spin-1/2 ions bridged by oxygen or other ligands, assemble chains independently in unrelated crystals: azurite and linarite in nature, copper sulphate, KCuF3 and SrCuO2 in the laboratory; 'the magnetic couplings can vary strongly in magnitude and sign depending on the geometry' - Quark epoch
The chiral crossover that ends the quark epoch is 'the final' symmetry breaking after electroweak breaking, 'the penultimate'; both close an epoch's symmetric phase in a lattice-located crossover (159.5 GeV, 156.5 MeV). - Quark–gluon plasma
Charge screening by mobile charges: in a plasma 'charges are screened due to the presence of other mobile charges', Coulomb's law becomes Q -> Q e^{-r/alpha}; 'in a QGP, the color charge of the quarks and gluons is screened'. Shuryak named it from 'an analogy with electromagnetic plasma' (1978). Dis - Quasinormal mode
One unstable orbit read two ways: the photon sphere makes the black-hole shadow in light and sets the eikonal ringing in gravitational waves (Lyapunov exponent). - Radio
Marconi, Popov, Lodge, Bose and Tesla built signalling devices from the same parts (spark gaps, coherers, crystal detectors) in the same years (1894-1898); the builds were partly independent (Popov's was 'an improved version of coherer-based design by Oliver Lodge'), which is why priority stayed dis - Radioactive decay
Four decay chains, sorted by mass number modulo four, never exchange members, yet each is built from the same two steps (alpha and beta) and each ends at a stable lead (or thallium/bismuth for the extinct neptunium series). Partial: the chains do not share ancestry, but whether their 'same result' i - Radius (volume) modulus (projected model)
A scalar displaced from its minimum oscillates, dominates as matter and decays to reheat, as the inflaton does. - Recursion: defining or computing a thing in terms of smaller versions of itself, as computer science and mathematics describe it, with its base cases, call stack, recursive data, induction, and its sightings in language and nature
Center-embedded sequence production in crows with an independently evolved telencephalon (divergence over 320 million years) and in macaques and humans. - Reinsurance
Three sovereign catastrophe risk pools built regionally and separately (Caribbean, Africa, Pacific) from the same parts: pooling, joint reserves, parametric covers and an excess transfer to the reinsurance market; independence of design stated as regional, shared advice (World Bank) not excluded. - Religion
Organized religion traces its roots to the Neolithic Revolution in the Near East "but may have occurred independently in several other locations"; virtually all state societies and chiefdoms justify political power through divine authority. - Reproductive system (human, as physiology describes it)
Menstruation arose 'at least 4' times independently among eutherian mammals, all on the shared eutherian female tract. - Respiratory system
Unidirectional airflow by aerodynamic valves in birds, crocodilians and monitor lizards: either evolved independently or once in ancestral diapsids (the paper leaves both open). - Rho meson
Massive vector bosons from a broken gauge symmetry: the rhos 'can be thought of as the gauge bosons of a spontaneously broken gauge symmetry whose local character is emergent' (hidden local symmetry), the build the Higgs mechanism uses for W and Z with a fundamental gauge symmetry. - Ritual
Separate traditions build rites with the same features (stereotypy, repetition, causal opacity, goal demotion) from one shared cognitive toolkit, the Precaution System that cultural rituals mimic; ethologists build signals from the same parts (walking, fighting) by simplification, exaggeration, repe - School
Shared parts, separate assemblies: a teacher, a group of pupils, a body of text and copying or recitation, assembled in Egypt (Kheti), Mesopotamia (eduba), China (Xia/Han academies), India (Vedic and Buddhist), and Mesoamerica (the Aztec Triple Alliance's universal compulsory education) - Science (as a human social and cultural system)
"Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace independently proposed the theory of evolution by natural selection in 1858"; and "Science has no single origin ... taking different forms around the world". - Sculpture
monumental and figurative sculpture built separately in many regions from the same kit (stone, clay, wood, ivory; carving and modelling): Egypt, China (Buddhism brought figure sculpture, Sanxingdui), Mesoamerica, Rapa Nui, West Africa (Nok) - Secure software development
Twenty-eight secure development methodologies from industry, government and academia build from the same practices (threat modelling, code review, testing, response), and NIST maps the SSDF onto many of them. Whether the builds are independent or copied from each other is not settled in the sources - Security audit and compliance
Separate frameworks (SOC 2's Trust Services Criteria, NIST SP 800-53, GDPR articles, ISO/IEC 27001) built from overlapping controls and mappable onto each other; organisations adopt 'consolidated and harmonized sets of compliance controls'. Shared ancestry (COSO behind TSC) makes some builds less in - Security awareness
Attackers and awareness campaigns draw on one toolkit, the principles of persuasion: lures use urgency, scarcity, authority, reciprocity and liking; campaigns use fear, humour, expertise and repetition, the 'language of persuasion'. - Security information and event management (SIEM)
Many vendors (22 in the 2020 vendor map) and open-source projects build the same blocks (collection, parsing normalisation, rule engine, storage, monitoring) into separate products. Partial: shared lineage through syslog, Gartner's category and acquisitions may make some builds less independent than - Sedimentary rock
Calcium carbonate skeletons built by corals, molluscs and foraminifera all end as limestone; silica skeletons of radiolaria and diatoms as chert. Partial: the sources read do not say whether the skeleton-building was independent in each lineage. - Separation of powers
Polybius: Lycurgus built Sparta's mixed constitution by reasoning; the Romans reached "the same final result" not by reasoning but "by the discipline of many struggles and troubles". Same parts (one, few, many), separate builds. Independence rests on Polybius's account alone. - Series (mathematics): sums of infinitely many terms, and the practice of summing, testing and using them
The sine, cosine and arctangent series found in Kerala (Madhava, c. 1340-1425) and again in 17th-century Europe (Gregory, Newton, Leibniz), from the same toolkit (geometric expansion, sums of powers); independence is contested (C-2962). Earlier: exhaustion by Archimedes and independently by Liu Hui. - Short story
The first true collections appeared 1810-1830 'in several countries' from the same parts (tales, print, periodicals); Goyet finds one 'nearly universal' classic structure across French, Russian, Italian, English and Japanese writers. Influence between them is documented (Poe on Quiroga, Maupassant o - Signals intelligence
Rival states built SIGINT from the same parts (receivers, direction finding, traffic analysis, cryptanalysis): German SIGINT was vital to Rommel's early successes as British SIGINT was to the Atlantic. How independent the builds were is not shown. - Silicon atom
Silicon carries carbon's tetravalent, tetrahedral toolkit ('Tetrahedral coordination is a major structural motif in silicon chemistry just as it is for carbon chemistry'), but its diffuse 3p orbitals and weak Si-Si bond send the same rule into silicate minerals, which 'have a structural complexity u - Small business
Each country builds its own 'small business' from the same parts (employees, turnover, assets, sector): India by investment and turnover, Bangladesh by fixed assets, staff and turnover, South Africa by five categories. Partial: the builds may share ancestry (the EU and World Bank definitions travel) - Social norm
Conformist transmission, the same toolkit (copy the local majority) built in separate lineages: wild great tits hold arbitrary traditions by conformity and movers switch to the local variant (71%), while 'cultural conformity is thought to be a key factor in the evolution of complex culture in humans - Sorting algorithm
Takaoka and Barbay and Navarro independently discovered the same run-adaptive mergesort (find runs, Huffman merge order); Floyd (1964) and the 2014 SAT search reach the same 25-comparator optimum by different routes. - Special unitary group SU(n)
The same construction (a Yang-Mills gauge theory with an SU(n) group) built twice with different n: colour SU(3) confines and is asymptotically free; SU(2)_L acts only on left-chiral fermions and is broken by the Higgs field. - Spectral triple
The same distance formula built twice: Connes' sup over ||[D, a]|| <= 1 and Kantorovich's sup over Lip(f) <= 1 for transport between probability measures; 'This analogy is more than formal'. - Sperm whale (cachalot, Physeter macrocephalus)
Matrilineal societies with allocare in sperm whales and elephants; biosonar buzzes in whales and bats - Spin foam cosmology (spinfoam cosmology; walked as a projected model)
Two independent builds reach the same Friedmann dynamics: LQC (reduce, then quantize) and spinfoam cosmology (quantize, then approximate), 'two converging attempts'. - Spinor
The same Clifford-algebra construction gives Pauli's two-component spinors in 3 dimensions and Dirac's four-component spinors in 3+1 ('In dimension 3, defining the gamma matrices to be the Pauli sigma matrices ... Likewise using the 4 x 4 Dirac gamma matrices'). - Sprinkled causal set (Poisson sprinkling into a Lorentzian manifold)
The same Poisson toolkit discretises Euclidean space (symmetry kept only on average) and Lorentzian spacetime (symmetry kept in every realisation): one tool, two outcomes set by the geometry's signature. - Standard Model of particle physics
Glashow (1961), Salam and Ward (1964) and Weinberg (1967) reached SU(2) x U(1) separately: 'with these fermionic ingredients, just one generation of leptons, there is no other group you can be led to'. Also Higgs and Englert-Brout (1964) and Gross-Wilczek and Politzer (1973) independently. Dark-twin - Statistical mechanics
One toolkit (an averaged field standing in for the neighbours), built again and again for separate systems: van der Waals for fluids, Weiss for magnets, Bragg and Williams for alloys, up to BCS superconductivity: 'Literally dozens of such theories were defined.' Partial: built by people who knew the - Steel
Iron, carbon and heat were built into steel by different routes in different places: bloomery steel in Anatolia (about 1800 BC), crucible wootz in South India and Sri Lanka (mid-1st millennium BCE), co-fusion of cast and wrought iron in China (the 'core divergence' of East and West before the 14th c - String axion (projected model)
A light pseudoscalar kept light by a shift symmetry: the string axion (from the C4 gauge redundancy) and the field-theory QCD axion (pseudo-Goldstone of Peccei-Quinn). - Strong (colour) field
A weak leftover force between neutral composites: the residual strong force is 'much weaker between neutrons and protons, because it is mostly neutralized within them, in the same way that electromagnetic forces between neutral atoms (van der Waals forces) are much weaker' than those binding electro - SU(3) colour gauge group
One group read twice: 'an exact gauge symmetry mediated by the gluons' (colour) and 'an approximate symmetry of the vacuum of QCD' (flavour), 'an accidental consequence of the small mass of the three lightest quarks'. - Superconductivity
separate material families (cuprates 1986, iron pnictides 2008, organics, heavy fermions) each build the same phase diagram: a superconducting dome that appears once magnetism is suppressed by doping or pressure. Shared parts (layers, suppressed magnetic order), separate assemblies (copper-oxygen pl - Supply chain security
Each ecosystem built its own package manager with name resolution across public and private registries; the same dependency-confusion weakness turned up independently in Maven, npm, pip, NuGet and Composer (not Go or Cargo). - Surveillance
Policing of reproduction by nestmates is reported in honeybees and stingless bees, in ants, in social wasps and in a termite, built from the same parts (detecting and removing eggs, aggression toward fertile workers) in lineages that became social separately; the termite and wasp papers were found b - Syntax: how a language combines words into phrases and sentences (constituency and dependency, word order, agreement, recursion), how speakers build and parse it, how children learn it, how it differs across languages, and the field that studies it
Compositional order with a compound meaning built twice: in human syntax and, independently, in Japanese tit calls (C-1555); and parse trees recovered by language models trained only on prediction. - Terbium (Tb, Z = 65)
Neutron capture then beta decay makes terbium in stars (the s-process step: 'a seed nucleus undergoes neutron capture ... if unstable it beta-decays') and in a research reactor ('(161)Tb was produced by irradiation of (160)Gd targets with neutrons ... After neutron capture, the short-lived (161)Gd d - Threat actor
Hacktivists, criminals and state-nexus groups share toolsets and methods yet are separate builds; Hesperus finds 'common tools and infrastructure' merging clusters that should stay apart. - Trigonometry (the practice of tying angles to lengths, and the structure it works on)
The same toolkit (sinusoids of one angle, added as vectors) is built separately: by people as tables and identities (rung 11), by the insect central complex (Δ7 neurons reshape any bump into a sinusoid and columnar neurons add them), by primate motor-cortex cells tuned as cosines of direction, and b - Truth
Two-level truth built in several traditions: Buddhist conventional and ultimate truth, Jain relative and absolute truth, the doctrine of double truth in the Abrahamic philosophies. - Tunneling wave function (Vilenkin; universe from nothing; hypothetical)
Vilenkin builds universe nucleation on the outgoing-wave condition of bubble nucleation in a false vacuum, 'in many ways analogous to the nucleation of universes'. - Type IIA superstring theory (projected model)
IIA and IIB are built from the same worldsheet with different GSO projections: 'On the worldsheet, they differ only in the choice of GSO projection', and give a non-chiral and a chiral theory. - Upsilon meson (bottomonium)
The '-onium' build: a particle bound to its own antiparticle, neutral, its own antiparticle and short-lived through annihilation. Quarkonium is named by analogy with positronium (electron and anti-electron, bound electromagnetically); bottomonium and charmonium repeat it with colour. - Urinary system
Malpighian tubules are analogous to nephrons yet 'express homologous human genes', so fly tubules are used to study human kidney disorders: shared parts, separately built organs. - Vascular plants (tracheophytes)
Megaphylls 'originated four times independently: in the ferns, horsetails, progymnosperms and seed plants', each from 'groups of branches' (the shared parts), all in the Late Devonian to Early Carboniferous as CO2 fell. - Vertebrate brain
An analogous cerebellum-like structure in cephalopods with well-developed brains; vertebrates and cephalopods both enlarged brains, argued to rest on different randomising mechanisms (RNA capsules vs one gene making several proteins). - Vervet monkey (Chlorocebus pygerythrus)
Conformity in foraging traditions in vervets (splinter groups keep the parent group's food preference) and in wild great tits: social learning in separate lineages; the shared parts are not named - Voting
Shared parts (members' signals, a count, a threshold), separate assemblies: wild dogs (sneezes), baboons (movement), honeybees (dances) and humans (ballots) reach consensus with the same parts, not inherited one from another. - Weathering
Plants, mycorrhizal fungi, lichens and bacteria each weather minerals with the same kit (protons, organic acids, chelating molecules, CO2), built in separate lineages. - Weyl spinor (two-component chiral spinor)
The Weyl equation describes candidate elementary fermions (the massless-neutrino model) and, independently, electron quasiparticles in TaAs crystals and excitations in photonic crystals. - William Shakespeare
The same parts (an actor-author of modest schooling, no manuscripts, later adulation) assembled twice into an authorship doubt: Shakespeare from 1848, Molière from 1919 (Louÿs for Corneille); attribution methods answered both the same way. Whether the Molière case borrowed its build from the Shakesp
Surface: a resemblance (71)
- 't Hooft-Polyakov monopole
The same point defect built in a laboratory quantum field: isolated monopoles created in spin-1 Bose-Einstein condensates, decaying into a Dirac monopole configuration (2017). - 4-simplex (5-cell, pentachoron)
The same simplex toolkit used separately by Regge calculus (fixed triangulation, varying edge lengths) and by CDT (fixed edge lengths, varying triangulation): '(C)DT quantum gravity operates with a variable lattice topology and fixed edge lengths, while classical and quantum Regge calculus operate w - Access control
One matrix stored two ways: by columns as access control lists, by rows as capabilities ('sometimes known as tickets'); the two builds share the toolkit but are not shown to be independent lineages. - Advocacy group (interest group)
The same parts (a department or committee, its client groups, legislators) assemble as the US iron triangle and as Britain's neo-pluralist policy communities 'organised around a government department and its network of client groups'; independence of the two builds is not shown. - American literature
white and black novelists draw on the same toolkit (the King James Bible) and build different scenes with it; the results differ, so this is the toolkit half only - Architecture
Building with local mud, stone and wood is practised on all seven continents; whether these traditions arose independently is not stated by the sources read. - Aristotle
The heart-centred view of mind is found in Egypt, Greece (Aristotle) and China: three traditions building the same model; whether independently is not shown by the source. - Art of ancient Egypt
one blue toolkit (copper, quartz, lime, flux) gives two production groups of Egyptian blue on the same shabtis - Averaged null energy condition (ANEC)
Two independent derivations of the same inequality in QFT: relative entropy (Faulkner et al.) and microcausality (Hartman et al.); 'It is intriguing that causality and information-theoretic inequalities lead to overlapping constraints'. - Belinfante-Rosenfeld stress-energy tensor
Belinfante and Rosenfeld 'published independently in 1940' the same tensor; and the canonical-plus-spin route and the metric-variation (Hilbert) route arrive at one symmetric tensor. - Business continuity
COOP (government), BCP (business) and ISCP (each information system) are built from the same parts (impact analysis, alternate sites, tests) for the same result; independence not shown (shared lineage likely). - Catenary world line
The same curve built twice, by unrelated physics: a hanging chain under gravity, and a relativistic charge in a uniform electric field ('our curve is (half of) that, and of course rotated by ninety degrees'). - Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface)
The same two-expansion test is run on surfaces in unrelated hosts (Minkowski, Schwarzschild, de Sitter, Robertson-Walker) and gives different kinds by the host's curvature alone. - Condensed matter physics
One toolkit (scattering, order parameters, renormalization) used to build the same answers in unrelated matter: magnets and fluids share critical exponents; cold atoms in laser lattices rebuild Hubbard physics. Surface: one shared theory applied, not independent assemblies. - Consciousness
One reading on the shelf has consciousness emerging 'independently in mammals and birds' from shared vertebrate parts; booked surface: the source lists it as one of four origin claims, untested here. - Critical infrastructure
Countries build protection programmes from the same parts (sector lists, lead agencies, operator plans, information sharing); independence not shown (the US programme came first, 1996), so surface. - Crystal
Calcium carbonate gravity sensors built as calcite otoconia in mammals, reptiles and birds and as aragonite otoliths in many fish; conodonts mineralised their own apatite elements. - Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0)
The same pressureless form models very different things: cold dark matter, galaxies as particles in toy universes, and finite rotating disks of dust grains. - Early childhood education
Similar builds from similar parts (prepared environment, child-chosen activity, adult as facilitator) in Rome (1907) and Reggio Emilia (after WWII); a shared lineage (Rousseau, Pestalozzi) is not ruled out - Einstein equivalence principle
Local position invariance is tested two independent ways: in space by clocks in a potential (GP-A 1976) and in time by the fundamental constants (Oklo). - Engineering design process
Analysis, synthesis and evaluation prescribed by several early authors (Marples 1961, Jones 1963, Archer 1965); the spiral in ship design (Evans) and software (Boehm). Independence of these builds is not shown. - FLRW dust (matter-dominated Friedmann models)
The same dust equations from two builds: Friedmann from general relativity (1922) and McCrea and Milne from Newtonian dynamics (1934). - Formal security policy model
Different groups built different policies from the same parts (subjects, objects, labels, simple security and *-property rules): Clark-Wilson, Brewer-Nash (who adopted Bell-LaPadula's concepts on purpose) and Bell's boolean lattice. Shared ancestry is visible, so this is the dark twin's risk: surfac - Gastrulation (the embryo's cell sheet folds and moves into two or three germ layers)
Myo-II-dependent curving of a multicellular sheet by flow in a bilaterian, a cnidarian and a choanoflagellate: either conserved from pre-Metazoa or 'arose and was selected independently ... convergent-evolution' - Gender
Third-gender roles built from the same parts (a sex binary plus a recognised middle role) in South Asia, North America, Hawaii, Oaxaca and Sulawesi. - General relativity
the same parts (horizon entropy, Unruh temperature, the Clausius relation, the equivalence principle) assembled into the Einstein equations along separate routes: equation of state (Jacobson 1995), entanglement equilibrium of geodesic balls (Jacobson 2016), entropic force (Verlinde 2011), relative e - Incident response
Fire services (ICS, from 1970s wildfires) and computer incident response (CERT/CC, 1988) assembled the same parts (one number to call, an incident commander, escalation, after-action learning). Surface: the builds are not independent; the CSIRT handbook draws on the fire analogy and NIMS frames both - Information security
Many national and sector bodies build their own schemes from the same parts (controls, CIA, risk): NIST CSF, UK Cyber Essentials, Australia's Essential Eight, PCI DSS, IEC 62443. - Internet protocol suite (TCP/IP): the layered datagram protocols every host and router runs, the RFC record that specifies them, and the community that keeps them
Packet switching built separately by Baran (RAND) and Davies (NPL) from the same idea of small blocks. - Intonation
Dog brains separate words (left) from intonation (right) as human brains do, a capacity that 'can evolve in the absence of language'; shared mammalian ancestry may make this one build inherited twice (the dark twin), so surface. - Journalism
News bulletins in Han China, Venetian avvisi, privately published news in Ming China (1582) and the Strasbourg Relation (1605); the sources date them but do not show independence or a shared toolkit. - k-essence (kinetic quintessence; hypothesised)
The non-canonical kinetic toolkit was built first for inflation (k-inflation) and reused for late-time dark energy. - Klein-Gordon equation
The same equation was derived independently in 1925-1926 by Schrodinger, Klein, Fock, de Broglie, Gordon, De Donder and van den Dungen, and Pauli ('the equation with many fathers'): independent builds of one structure, held at rung 11. - Marketing
The University of Michigan and the University of Illinois both began marketing coursework in 1902; independence of the two builds is not shown. - Mind–body problem (how mental states relate to physical states)
Mind-body dualisms arise separately in Zoroastrian, Gnostic, Platonic and Cartesian traditions; interdependence views in the Buddha and Aristotle. Shared ancestry not ruled out (Gnostic ideas 'later seem to have been incorporated' into Galen and Avicenna), so independence is only partly shown. - Mineral
Biomineralization arose separately in phyla from pre-existing developmental programmes, each co-opting its own scaffold network. Surface: the builds are independent, but the sources show different toolkits (distinct GRNs and scaffolds), not one shared set of parts. - Museum
Labels, rooms and collected objects assembled into museums in Ur (c. 530 BC), Alexandria (c. 280 BC) and Renaissance Europe - Neugebauer-Meinel dust (rigidly rotating disk of dust)
The inverse scattering method, invented in 1967 for the Korteweg-de Vries water-wave equation, solves the rotating-disk problem of general relativity: one toolkit across shallow water and spacetime. - Newspaper
Paper, ink and printing were used to make government news sheets in Tang China (block-printed) and Joseon Korea and periodical papers in Europe; whether the European build shares ancestry with the East Asian toolkit is not shown here. - Non-imprisoning spacetime
Two sufficient conditions reach distinction from different sides: strong causality (local causal convexity) and non-partial imprisonment (escape from compact sets); Minguzzi notes reflectivity likewise needs a distinguishing condition added to reach a rung. - Nursing (the field: the practice and the care it gives)
Hospitals and nursing orders arose in Buddhist India (Ashoka), Byzantium, the Islamic world (Rufaida, the bimaristan) and Christian Europe. - Orangutan (Pongo)
Active wound treatment with plants seen in chimpanzees and now a wild orangutan; same toolkit (bioactive plants applied to wounds) in two great-ape lineages - Penetration testing
A friendly team playing the adversary appears in the military (RAND, OPFOR), computer security (tiger teams), aviation security (FAA after Lockerbie) and AI (red-teaming language models), but the sources show borrowing (AI red teaming from cybersecurity) and shared roots (RAND), so the builds are no - Placozoan (Placozoa, Trichoplax)
If the lack of neurons and muscles is original and placozoans are sister to cnidarians, nervous systems and muscles evolved three times (ctenophores, cnidarians, bilaterians). - Pollution
Europe and North America built acid-rain policy from the same parts (monitoring, field experiments, deposition models; Hubbard Brook, Solling, Lake Gardsjon) into different instruments, both cutting sulphur. - Protein folding (a chain reaching its working shape)
Two chaperonin groups: Group I in bacteria and organelles, Group II (TCP-1, the thermosome) in archaea and the eukaryotic cytosol. - Public speaking (oratory)
Chinese and Greek traditions built speaking arts from the same parts (a speaker, an audience, ethics and credibility) with different audiences (rulers vs the public). Independence not established in the sources read. - Quantum Einstein gravity (walked as a projected model)
Four dimensions at large distances and two at short ones, found in QEG's effective spacetimes and in causal dynamical triangulations. - Quantum entanglement
two quantum networks built swapping and teleportation from the same parts (an entangled-pair source, a Bell-state measurement, classical feed-forward): photons through space (Micius, Ren 2017) and NV spins with memories in Delft (Pompili 2021). Surface: separate labs, not independent lineages, and t - Regge calculus (classical and quantum)
The piecewise-flat toolkit built separately as classical numerical relativity, quantum Regge calculus (vary lengths), CDT (vary triangulations) and as the classical limit of spin foams. - Renewable energy
Water mills in ancient China and Persia; windmills in Iran (700-900 CE) and Europe. Surface: the sources do not say whether the builds were independent or diffused. - Reuter fixed point (non-Gaussian UV fixed point of gravity)
Short-distance dimension 2 found independently in the fixed-point regime of QEG and in CDT Monte Carlo simulations. - Risk management
Seven integrated safety-and-security risk assessment methods built from the same parts in two orders (sequential and non-sequential); PMI, NIST, actuarial societies and ISO each developed standards. Independence of the builds is not shown. - Security operations center (SOC)
Watch rooms built from the same parts for different jobs: rows of desks facing a wall of alarms and incidents (NOC), status boards (AT&T 1962), multiple screens and night shifts (SOC). Shared ancestry is not ruled out, so surface. - Security policy and governance
NIST's CSF and ISO's 27001 are separate builds from shared parts (control catalogues mapped as informative references; IT governance from TQM and ISO 9001). Dark-twin caution: BS 7799 to ISO 27001 is one lineage, and shared ancestry may be read as independence. - Set theory: the study of sets (collections taken as single objects), membership, Cantor's infinities and the axioms, and the practice of the people and machines who work with them
Russell (May 1901) and Zermelo (by 1902, possibly 1899) built the same paradox independently from the same naive toolkit; in 1908 two different repairs (types, axioms) came from it. - Simple machine
'The wedge was first used by early humans in different parts of the world': the same stone wedge from the same material in several places. - Social engineering
Surface: the same influence principles run through street hustles and phishing, but phishing descends from the con (one lineage), so it is not independent. - Social network
The study of networks was built in the 1930s by several groups in psychology, anthropology and mathematics working independently, reaching the same relational picture (sociograms, network fieldwork, graph theory). A sighting in the field that studies the network, not in the network itself. - Software engineering
Iterative and incremental methods arise in several places (1957 onward; Scrum, XP, Crystal, DSDM, FDD in the 1990s); independence is not shown and the practitioners met and merged at Snowbird. - Software vulnerability
Heartbleed found independently by Google and Codenomicon within days; secret stockpiles rediscovered by others (5.7% to 21.9% a year). - Spacetime
Five programmes recover Einstein's equation from entropy plus horizon area: thermodynamics on local horizons (Jacobson 1995), vacuum entanglement equilibrium (Jacobson 2016), the holographic entanglement first law (Faulkner et al. 2014), Hilbert-space entanglement (Cao-Carroll-Michalakis 2017), modu - Startup company
Ecosystems built in many places from the same parts (research universities, technology parks, venture capital, accelerators): Silicon Valley, Boston, Berlin, Silicon Wadi, Inovallée, Trieste. Surface: the later ones are deliberate attempts to copy, the dark twin (one build inherited many times). - Static Weyl vacuum
The image trick 'commonly used in Newtonian galactic dynamics' (reflect a point-mass potential in a plane to get a disk) reused to build relativistic counter-rotating disks. - Synapse
In the sponge Spongilla, presynaptic-type (secretory) modules sit in neuroid cells and postsynaptic-type scaffolds in choanocytes; the authors read this as 'possible parallel routes toward neuron evolution'. - The archive and the historical record
Archives well developed by the ancient Chinese, Greeks and Romans from shared parts (writing, storage, registers); independence not shown in the sources read. - Timelike geodesic
One law reached by three routes in the source: the equivalence principle (Weinberg), parallel transport, and an action principle (stationary interval); all give the same geodesic equation. - Twistor spaces of hyperkähler manifolds
The same hyperkähler geometry turns up separately as vacuum gravitational instantons and as moduli spaces of gauge-theory solutions (instantons, monopoles, Hitchin, Nahm). - Van Stockum dust
The same solution found twice, independently: Lanczos (1924) and van Stockum (1937); the same azimuthal-curve test (L(r) < 0) finds CTCs in every stationary axisymmetric case. - Wheeler-DeWitt equation (the Hamiltonian constraint of quantum geometrodynamics; walked as a projected model)
Quantized volume twice: spin-network nodes as quanta of volume (LQG) and, independently, the discrete Regge Wheeler-DeWitt wave functional with 'peaks corresponding to integer multiples of a fundamental unit of volume'. - Wireless network
Frequency hopping spread spectrum built more than once from the same parts: a 1932 patent (Broertjes), the secret SIGSALY system, Lamarr and Antheil's 1942 torpedo-guidance patent synchronised by player-piano rolls; whether each was independent of the others is not shown.
Structural (same mathematics, no physical link claimed) (2)
- 3-sphere (hypersphere)
One manifold in two roles: the group of unit quaternions, 'isomorphic to SU(2)', is the SU(2) factor of the electroweak symmetry (rung 2) and the space of a closed universe (rung 1). - Two-sphere S^2 (the ordinary sphere)
One S^2 in two physical places: the angular factor of the Schwarzschild spacetime (gravity) and the celestial sphere of lines of sight on which Lorentz transformations act as Mobius maps (light).