← all systems · see it in The System
Surveillance
Surveillance is the systematic observation and monitoring of a person, population, or location, with the purpose of information-gathering, influencing, managing, or directing (src:wp:surveillance). Surveillance studies widen the dictionary sense of 'close observation, especially of a suspected person': much surveillance is applied categorically, to places, networks and categories of person, and the new surveillance is 'the use of technical means to extract or create personal data' (src:marx-2002-new-surveillance). Walked as the whole practice and its relation to the watched: the watchers (states, police and intelligence agencies, companies, health authorities, employers and peers), their channels (eyes and tails, informants, cameras, interception of calls, post and internet traffic, phone location, transaction records and data brokers, platforms' behavioural data, biometrics, disease reports), the files and databases they fill, the identification, analysis and sorting of people, the decisions taken under law and oversight, and what surveillance does: deters, intervenes, targets, notifies; together with the watched's side as the literature describes it: the felt watch, self-policing and chilling, and watching back (sousveillance, countersurveillance, leaks).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Surveillance and tracking (state and commercial) |
| born at | contested (C-1778): religious and wartime surveillance before electronics; UK state surveillance in public consciousness since the 19th century; CCTV 1942; the new surveillance in the late 20th century |
| born precision | era |
| boundary | Inside: the watchers (governments, police, intelligence agencies, corporations, data brokers, employers, health authorities, peers); their collection channels (human eyes, tails and stakeouts, informants and infiltrators, cameras, wiretaps and interception of post and internet traffic, phone location, transaction and public records, platforms' behavioural data, biometric capture, disease reports); the recordings, files and databases; identification and linking (facial recognition, record linkage, profiles); analysis and sorting (data mining, social network analysis, keyword triggers, risk sorting); decisions under law and oversight (warrants, courts, committees); the outputs (intervention, deterrence by visible watching, targeting, health notifications); and the watched's side the literature treats as part of surveillance: the feeling of being watched, self-policing, chilling of speech and reading, and watching back (sousveillance, countersurveillance, leaks). Outside, as neighbours: privacy (the withholding side, walked), signals intelligence (sibling: foreign intercept), espionage (covert, illegal to the observed party), digital identity (the credential surveillance reads), law and courts (which restrain it), the internet (carrier), cryptography (the tools of countersurveillance). |
| nested level | A practice of states, firms and people (rung 11), carried by institutions (police, intelligence agencies, corporations, health services) and by networks and devices (rung 12); restrained by law; running on the traces people give off in daily life. |
| scale | social |
Measures (26) published science
| characteristic clock: lifetime of the Stasi | 1950-1990 (founded 8 February 1950; files opened after reunification 1989-1991) years |
| characteristic clock: data retention (GCHQ) | up to 2 years |
| share of cameras in Asia (2016) | about 65 % |
| surveillance cameras worldwide (2016) | about 350 million cameras |
| CCTV cameras in China (2018) | over 170 million (400 million more expected in three years) cameras |
| cameras in the United Kingdom (2011, reliable estimate) | around 1.85 million (a 2002 figure of 4.2 million overstated) cameras |
| Stasi full-time staff and informants (1989) | 91,015 staff; 173,081 informants in the GDR; 1,553 in West Germany people |
| Stasi informants identified by 1995 | about 174,000, almost 2.5% of those aged 18-60 people |
| Stasi spy density by county (1980s) | 0.12 to 1.03, mean 0.38 % of population |
| points needed to single out a person in phone mobility data | 4 points identify 95% (hourly, antenna resolution; 1.5 million people, 15 months) spatio-temporal points |
| trust lost per one standard deviation of spy density | about 4 percentage points, from a 14% average |
| gender-classifier error rate, darker-skinned women vs lighter-skinned men | up to 34.7 vs at most 0.8 % error |
| uniqueness of mobility traces against resolution | about the 1/10 power of resolution exponent |
| hand hygiene compliance, overt vs covert observation | 78 vs 55 (31,522 opportunities) % compliance |
| NHS COVID-19 app use and notifications | 16.5 million users (28%); 1.7 million notifications; 4.2 per index case users / notifications |
| cases reduced per percentage point of app uptake | 0.8 (modelling) or 2.3 (statistics) % per percentage point |
| National Security Letters (2003-2005) | more than 140,000 letters |
| share of honeybee colony offspring from the queen | 100 (females), 99.9 (males), of up to 50,000 females that can lay eggs % |
| location data requests to one carrier | 8 million requests per year |
| contributions with an image of eyes vs control | nearly three times as much ratio |
| crime reduction with CCTV (2017 review) | 24-28 (streets and subways); none shown in parking facilities in that review % less crime |
| share of time a city CCTV system worked (Philadelphia, 2013) | 32 % of the time operational |
| NSA documents copied (estimate) | 50,000 to 200,000 documents |
| US fusion centres | 43 planned, $370 million centres |
| face scans deleted when Facebook shut face recognition (2021) | more than one billion users' face scans |
| mail opened in one CIA/FBI programme | more than 215,000 communications |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1522 Do security cameras cut crime?
booked: The map keeps the readings that they help in some places, such as car parks, and little elsewhere, and rules none.
the other reading: - C-1698 Does surveillance make people hold back?
booked: The map books one study's measured drop of just under 25% and keeps the view that chilling effects are hard to measure.
the other reading: - C-1728 Does tracking someone's location need a warrant?
booked: The map keeps both rulings: yes in the US (2012), and proportionate covert tracking allowed in Europe.
the other reading: - C-1735 Do pictures of eyes make people behave better?
booked: The map books the body's response to being watched and keeps the behavioural effect contested after a failed replication.
the other reading: - C-1763 If you've done nothing wrong, does surveillance harm you?
booked: The map keeps both: 'nothing to fear', and the critics' view that surveillance is about power and harms everyone.
the other reading: the law-abiding suffer no harm from surveillance; surveillance harms everyone through power, chilling and future policies - C-1778 Is surveillance ancient or modern?
booked: The map dates watching and informants as old, and the technical form as modern.
the other reading: surveillance as a modern, bureaucratic and electronic practice (the new surveillance; state surveillance in the UK from the 19th century; CCTV from 1942); older: watching and sanctioning others before states (worker policing in insects as a shape, not a birth) - C-1779 What counts as surveillance?
booked: The map keeps both: close watching of a suspect, and the technical gathering of personal data to manage people.
the other reading: close observation, especially of a suspected person (dictionary, as Marx quotes it); the use of technical means to extract or create personal data (Marx); systematic monitoring to gather information, influence, manage or direct (encyclopedia, after Lyon)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (22) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Surveillance. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- borrowed-then-held (structural)
Agencies first borrow companies' data (AT&T's call records, requested without a warrant), then hold it: the FBI stores all information received in its own databases; fusion centres consolidate state, hospital, school and bank records in a central database. - lightning (structural)
June 2013: thousands of stored NSA documents released at once to journalists; afterwards fewer views of terrorism-related Wikipedia articles, phones built to resist taps, and a national debate. Also the storming of Stasi offices in 1989 and the opening of the files. - outside-to-inside (structural)
The panopticon's guard watches from outside; inmates who cannot tell when they are watched come to act as though always watched, so the watch moves inside them (self-policing). Lateral surveillance carries government strategies into the private sphere, internalised. - same role, different builds (structural)
One job, watching members of a group and sanctioning those who break its rules, done by unrelated builds: a tail, an informant network, a camera with face recognition, a wiretap, a data broker's profile; and in honeybee colonies by nestmates who eat worker-laid eggs (worker policing), which keeps mo - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
Sousveillance is the same act, a camera recording people at work, pointed the other way: from the watched at the watchers (citizens photographing police; wearable cameras on front-line surveillance workers). Mann calls it holding up a mirror. - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
Each watcher reads its own slice of the same lives: eyes and tails see movements, informants hear confidences, cameras take light, taps take calls, towers take radio timing, brokers take transactions, platforms take clicks, scanners take bodies, health services take disease; and the new surveillance - who opens the door (structural)
Ports opened ahead of time: CALEA requires carriers to build lawful-intercept capability into their networks before any wiretap; an IMSI catcher uses the door every phone keeps open for towers. The listener is installed by the receiver (law-built port) or exploits the sender's own port. - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
Concealment is the watcher's seal: covert observation sees 55% hand hygiene where overt observation sees 78%; without the screen the watcher measures a performance. It gates validity rather than complexity. - partner-becomes-part (partial)
Citizens recruited as informants become parts of the apparatus (unofficial collaborators; 2,000 fully employed); companies work under contract with agencies. No fusion with inheritance is shown. - red-queen (partial)
Surveillance and countersurveillance both improve: phones encrypt after Snowden, law enforcement must break codes; countersurveillance grew in scope and complexity as databases and drones did. The sources show both sides moving, not a measured stalemate. - runaway from an unstable balance (partial)
In the dissent model an initially moderate authority escalates or not depending on the population's early willingness to withstand punishment: a small early push decides between suppression and a deterred authority. - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
Policing of reproduction by nestmates is reported in honeybees and stingless bees, in ants, in social wasps and in a termite, built from the same parts (detecting and removing eggs, aggression toward fertile workers) in lineages that became social separately; the termite and wasp papers were found b - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (partial)
Mann sets surveillance against a 'traditional commons notion of observability' in which people see each other alike; the panopticon breaks it at a named cut, one who sees without being seen. - templating (partial)
One module reused across carriers and countries: the lawful-intercept requirement in every US telephone and VoIP system; China's Golden Shield credited to US and UK systems as its inspiration. - The carry (partial)
Human investigators can hold only so much: too much internet data for them to search, so machines sift it and pass the suspicious on; speech-to-text and keyword search decide whether a call gets a human agent. Face: overflow passed on, with trigger words as a lookahead that skips the wait. - The Payment to Entropy (partial)
Each hand-off in the watching chain pays a toll in usable signal: a $15 million camera system worked 32% of the time; overt watching overstates compliance by 23 points (78% vs 55%); acontextual data is not necessarily more valid; gender classifiers err up to 34.7% for darker-skinned women. Form: sig - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
What counts as a search is set by society's reasonable expectation of privacy, read by the courts: data handed to third parties fell outside it (Miller), until Carpenter set a new reference for cell-site records. - trade one property for another (partial)
Privacy traded for security: the 'nothing to hide' argument balances privacy compromised against national security interests; democracies settle with legal limits, authoritarian governments with few. Contested (C-1763). - causal ceiling (surface)
The panopticon's single guard cannot watch every cell at once; the limit is set by the building and is turned into control by uncertainty. A practical limit as much as a structural one. - cephalization (surface)
Sensors placed where new input arrives first: fingerprints taken at entry (US-VISIT), cameras where illegal activity concentrates (stations, red-light districts). No input-first reason given in the sources. - holding / entrainment (surface)
In the donor, the colony's policing holds workers' reproduction (100% of females from the queen). In human surveillance the hold is on conduct, not on division or count. - seed (surface)
The electronic record: once transactions leave electronic trails, high-volume aggregation becomes possible at far lower cost, and a handful of points opens a person's whole profile. A trigger more than a combinatorial unpacking.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (16) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Signals intelligence via sys:electromagnetic-field · Surveillance gain
- Privacy via sys:internet · Surveillance gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Surveillance gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Surveillance gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:law · Surveillance mixed
- Internet via sys:internet · Surveillance gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:human-society · Surveillance gain
- Mass media via sys:human-society · Surveillance loss
- Police via sys:human-society · Surveillance gain
- Cryptography via sys:internet · Surveillance loss
- Mobile phones via sys:electromagnetic-field · Surveillance gain
- Organization via sys:human-society · Surveillance gain
- Video surveillance (CCTV) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Surveillance gain
- Digital identity via sys:human-society · Surveillance gain
- Attributes, preferences, traits and footprints via sys:written-record · Surveillance gain
- Public health surveillance via sys:written-record · Surveillance gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (10)
- Something one is (biometrics)
- Video surveillance (CCTV)
- Collection channels (eyes, informants, cameras, interception, location, records, biometrics)
- Informants and infiltrators
- Files and databases (dossiers, fusion centres, biometric databases)
- Data mining and profiling
- Law, warrants and oversight
- Trackers and data brokers against the people whose traces they collect
- Re-identification against de-identification
- Interception against encryption and countersurveillance
Sits inside / holds (3)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Organization
expressed by (20)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Multi-Scale Data Fusion / Triangulation
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Surprise / Change-Point Detection
- Frontier Outposts / Sensing Extension
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Evade Detection
- Overcome Barrier
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Prepositioning & Latency
- Divide & Isolate
- Technique-Based Identification (a.k.a. Technique-Based Detection)
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Deterrence
floor filled by (18)
- Privacy
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Law (rules and law)
- Internet
- Mass media
- Machine learning
- Mobile phones
- Something one is (biometrics)
- Organization
- Video surveillance (CCTV)
- Digital identity
- Attributes, preferences, traits and footprints
- Informants and infiltrators
- Files and databases (dossiers, fusion centres, biometric databases)
- Data mining and profiling
- Public health surveillance
- IMSI catcher
Kinds (14)
- Mass surveillance
- Targeted surveillance (tails, stakeouts, warranted taps)
- Corporate surveillance
- Surveillance capitalism
- Public health surveillance
- Lateral (peer-to-peer) surveillance
- Biometric surveillance
- Computer and network surveillance
- Sousveillance (inverse surveillance)
- Countersurveillance
- Self-surveillance
- Participatory surveillance
- Vertical surveillance
- Horizontal surveillance
Notes published science
- Hospital staff washed their hands 78% of the time when they knew someone was watching, and 55% when the watcher was hidden: being watched changes what the watcher sees (src:wu-2018-hawthorne).
- In a phone company's records for 1.5 million people, four place-and-hour points were enough to pick out 95% of them, and making the data coarser barely helped (src:demontjoye-2013-unique-crowd).
- East German counties that had more Stasi informers in the 1980s still showed lower trust, fewer patents and more unemployment decades after the Wall fell (src:lichter-2015-stasi-costs). Honeybees have their own version: every worker can lay eggs, but nestmates eat the eggs workers lay, so all the colony's females are the queen's (src:ratnieks-helantera-2009-enforced-altruism).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
surveillance as surveillance studies describe it: people's lives and the traces they give off, up to the managing, influencing and directing of conduct (reader's view)
- L1: People, populations and places, and the traces they give off: movements, speech, transactions, bodies
- L2: Collection: human eyes and informants, cameras, taps, phone location, records, biometric capture; the new surveillance extends the senses
- L3: Recording, transmission and storage: footage, transcripts, location records, files and databases
- L4: Identification and linking: biometric matches, mobility traces and records tied to one person; profiles
- L5: Analysis and sorting: filtering, data mining, social network analysis, categories of interest; the watched's felt watch
- L6: The institution's decision under law and oversight
- L7: Influencing, managing and directing conduct; self-policing
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: Analysis and sorting: automated filtering hands the 'interesting or suspicious' to human analysts; data mining and profiling; social network analysis; sorting people into categories of interest and risk (social sorting)
- L5: The watched person's regulation: the feeling of always being watched and self-policing; chilling of reading and speech; behaviour changed under overt observation (the Hawthorne effect)
- L6: The watching institution's decision under law and oversight: agencies decide to act; laws, warrants, courts and committees restrain them; leaks and public debate feed back
- L7: What surveillance is for: influencing, managing and directing conduct (security, order, profit, health), and, on the watched side, conduct that polices itself
way in: Being watched (the watched person's channel)
- L1: A visible camera, a guard, an image of eyes
- L2: Eyes and gaze picked up; even an image of eyes counts
- L3: Skin conductance up and heart slowed to direct gaze, only when believed watched
- L4: The experience of being watched (port)
way in: Bodies as identifiers (face, fingerprint, DNA, gait, voice)
- L1: Fingerprints, DNA, faces, gait and voice
- L2: Scanners and cameras; face recognition needs the least cooperation
- L3: Biometric databases (an FBI database of $1 billion)
- L4: A match, with errors up to 34.7% for darker-skinned women in gender classifiers (port: the match)
way in: Cameras (CCTV)
- L1: An area, its people and vehicles, in view
- L2: Surveillance cameras: about 350 million worldwide in 2016
- L3: Recording device or IP network, watched by a guard or officer
- L4: Automated software that makes footage a searchable database; facial recognition (port: the video analytics)
way in: Disease reports and contact records
- L1: Disease and conditions in a territory
- L2: Facilities' reports; app proximity records between users
- L3: Continuous, systematic collection of health data
- L4: A positive case linked to its recent contacts (port: the index case)
way in: Informants and infiltrators
- L1: What members of a group say and do among themselves
- L2: Infiltrators and members pressed to inform; in the GDR 173,081 unofficial informants in 1989
- L3: Reports to officers; tens of thousands of unofficial collaborators
- L4: Personal files on millions of citizens (port: the file)
way in: Interception of calls, post and internet traffic
- L1: Phone calls, VoIP, email, web traffic and post
- L2: Taps built into carriers by law; mail opened (215,000 communications in one programme)
- L3: Speech turned to machine text and stored for automated analysis
- L4: Traffic flagged by trigger words, sites and contacts (port: the selector)
way in: Law, courts and oversight bodies
- L1: Constitutional limits on search
- L2: Courts hear challenges (Riley 2014, Carpenter 2018)
- L3: Rulings: historical cell-site records need a warrant
- L4: Agencies' procedure changed (port: the warrant requirement)
- L5: Legislative inquiry weighs the programmes (Church Committee)
way in: Phone location
- L1: A phone's signals to nearby towers, even when not in use
- L2: Towers, or an IMSI catcher posing as one
- L3: Carriers' location records, requested 8 million times in a year from one carrier
- L4: A mobility trace tied to one person: four points single out 95% (port: the trace)
way in: Platforms' behavioural data and public posts
- L1: What people post, like, search and whom they link to
- L2: Platforms log behaviour; personal data used to target consumers
- L3: Massive data sets analysed to reduce uncertainty
- L4: Maps of social networks (port: the network map)
way in: The watched watching back (sousveillance, leaks, journalism)
- L1: Police and surveillance workers at work
- L2: Citizens' cameras and wearable devices; insiders
- L3: Recordings and documents (50,000 to 200,000 NSA documents copied)
- L4: Journalists receive them (port: the press)
- L5: Public debate about civil liberties
way in: Transaction and public records, bought or compelled
- L1: Bank machine, card, phone, library and rental transactions
- L2: Electronic records, cheap to collect and store
- L3: Gathered from third parties by request, subpoena or purchase; pooled in fusion centres
- L4: A detailed profile of one person (port: the profile)
way in: Watchers' eyes (tails, stakeouts, guards)
- L1: The watched person, their movements and contacts, in view
- L2: A tail or a stakeout team watching covertly
- L3: Report on the movements and contacts
- L4: Evidence on a person of interest (port: the case file)
way out: Countersurveillance and watching back (the watched's outlet)
- L1: Intercepted content arrives as 'gibberish'; police recorded from below
- L3: Encrypted messengers, privacy coins; phones built to resist taps
- L5: Decide to avoid or hinder the watch
way out: Covert disruption (Zersetzung) and removing network nodes
- L1: The person withdraws from activity
- L3: Psychological harassment to 'switch off' perceived enemies
- L6: Choose targets: 'hostile-negative' persons or important nodes
way out: Health notifications and isolation
- L1: Contacts isolate; about one case averted per consenting case
- L4: Exposure notifications sent (about 1.7 million)
- L7: Plan and evaluate public health action
way out: Intervening on people (arrest, stop, remove)
- L1: The person stopped, arrested or removed
- L3: Police directed to the person; arrests (19 with warrants found at Super Bowl XXXV; about 250,000 arrests with informants' help in the GDR)
- L6: Decide to act on a person flagged
way out: Self-censorship (the watched's outlet)
- L1: Fewer views of sensitive articles; dissent unspoken
- L3: Reading and speech withheld
- L5: Self-policing under the felt watch
way out: Targeting (ads, prediction products, content)
- L1: The targeted ad or offer on a person's screen
- L4: Personal data used to target consumers more precisely
- L7: Sell predictions of behaviour
way out: Watching made visible (cameras, signs, eyes)
- L1: The camera or eyes seen by the watched
- L2: Visible cameras and resources
- L7: Show the watch to deter and reassure