← all systems · see it in The System
Privacy
Privacy is the ability of an individual or group to seclude themselves or information about themselves, and thereby express themselves selectively (src:wp:privacy). In the information-privacy literature it is the claim of individuals, groups or institutions to determine for themselves when, how and to what extent information about them is communicated to others (Westin, quoted in src:wp:privacy); contextual integrity reads it as appropriate flows of information, judged by the norms of each context (src:wp:contextual-integrity); an evolutionary reading takes cultural concepts of privacy to reflect evolved mechanisms that regulate others' access to fitness-relevant information (src:klitgaard-2026-evolutionary-privacy). Walked as the whole claim and its practice: the person and information about them, the senses that tell a person they are watched or overheard, the barriers (walls, reserve, norms, encryption, noise), the judgement of what flow is appropriate, the rights and laws that hold privacy for everyone, and what privacy is said to protect (autonomy, intimacy, self-identity, democratic participation); together with what wears it away: surveillance, tracking, aggregation and re-identification.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | named by the 4th century BC in Aristotle's polis and oikos; as a legal right in the US from the 1890 article; as data protection from the 1973 FIPs report. Its roots in evolved information management are older and undated (Klitgaard and Fessler 2026). |
| born precision | era |
| boundary | Inside: a person (or group or organisation) and the information about them; the experiences of being seen, overheard, recorded or profiled; the barriers that limit access (physical: walls, clothes, retreat; behavioural: reserve, body language; normative: laws and social norms; technical: encryption, anonymity networks, noise added before release); the judgement of whether a flow of information is appropriate to its context; the person's weighing of concern against benefit before disclosing; the rights, laws and supervisory bodies that hold privacy for everyone; and what privacy is said to protect: autonomy, personhood, self-identity, intimacy and democratic participation. Outside, as neighbours: surveillance and tracking (the takers, queued as their own system), digital identity (the representation privacy limits), information security (protection of the data, overlapping), law (the general system the rights belong to), cryptography (the tools borrowed), and the markets that price personal data. |
| nested level | A claim and practice of people (rung 11), carried by persons, families, cultures and states; written into law (constitutions, treaties, data protection law); extended to digital records (rung 12). Overlaps information security; limits digital identity; shaped by culture. |
| scale | social |
Measures (22) published science
| characteristic clock: breach notification deadline (GDPR) | 72 hours |
| time to read every privacy policy a person meets | approximately 201 hours a year (about $3,534); point estimate for word-for-word reading 244 hours, about 40 minutes a day hours per year |
| national cost of reading privacy policies (US, 2008 estimate) | about $781 billion a year USD per year |
| uniqueness on ZIP, gender, date of birth | 87% (216 of 248 million) of the US population share |
| re-identification on 15 demographic attributes | 99.98% of Americans share |
| mobility traces singled out by 4 points | 95% of 1.5 million people (15 months of data); uniqueness decays about as the 1/10 power of resolution share |
| traits predicted from Facebook Likes | sexual orientation (men) 88%, African American vs Caucasian American 95%, Democrat vs Republican 85% (n over 58,000) share correctly discriminated |
| consent pop-ups meeting minimal legal requirements (UK top 10,000 sites, n=680) | 11.8% share |
| share of speech about one's own experience | 30-40% share of speech output |
| effect of removing the opt-out button from the first page | +22 to 23 percentage points consent |
| popular European websites showing cookie notices after GDPR | more than 60% share |
| chilling: drop in views of privacy-sensitive Wikipedia articles after June 2013 | just under 25% immediate drop (693,617 of 2,893,553 views), plus a lasting downward trend change share of views |
| felt lack of control (US adults, 2019) | 81% (companies), 84% (government) say very little or no control share |
| default effect on privacy valuation | 5 times more likely to reject cash for data when privacy protected by default; $10 anonymous vs $12 identified card ratio |
| read privacy policies all the way through (of those who ever read them) | 22%; 36% never read one share |
| concern about use of data (US adults, 2019) | 79% (companies), 64% (government) share |
| privacy paradox meta-analysis | 166 studies; small but significant relation between concern and behaviour |
| constitutions mentioning the right to privacy | over 185 constitutions |
| GDPR maximum fine | EUR 20 million or 4% of annual worldwide turnover, whichever is greater EUR / share of turnover |
| differential privacy composition | two (ε,0) mechanisms compose to (2ε,0); epsilons and deltas add up privacy loss |
| differential privacy real-world deployments | over 12 (US Census commuting 2008 ... 2020 Census redistricting data 2021) deployments |
| data brokers in apps | $350 billion digital industry USD |
Open contentions (9) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: see C-413 - C-414 Where do emotions come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the leading ones side by side and doesn't pick one.
the other reading: see C-414 - C-736 When a system first throws away its excess energy and later learns to store it for reuse, is that one process that grew or two separate ones?
booked: The map keeps both readings side by side and rules neither. A few examples fit the 'one process that grew' reading, but it hasn't been tested.
the other reading: see C-736 - C-1636 Can data be made anonymous enough to share safely?
booked: The map books how often people were picked out again in the studies (87%, 95%, 99.98%) and keeps the release-and-forget practice as what is actually done.
the other reading: de-identified and sampled data are anonymous enough to release; even heavily sampled de-identified data are unlikely to meet GDPR's anonymisation standard (Rocher 2019) - C-1698 Does surveillance make people hold back?
booked: The map books one study's measured drop of just under 25% and keeps the view that chilling effects are hard to measure.
the other reading: surveillance chills access to information (Penney 2016); chilling effects are hard to establish or measure at all (the literature Penney cites); most people do not self-censor, desensitised to privacy (a view Penney quotes) - C-1728 Does tracking someone's location need a warrant?
booked: The map keeps both rulings: yes in the US (2012), and proportionate covert tracking allowed in Europe.
the other reading: location tracking needs a warrant (US); proportionate covert tracking is allowed (ECHR) - C-1729 Do people who say they value privacy still give it away?
booked: The map keeps the paradox as named, a meta-analysis finding a small real link, and the context reading.
the other reading: a real attitude-behaviour paradox; no paradox: concern and behaviour are related, only weakly (166-study meta-analysis); not a paradox but a context-dependent calculus (Herriger et al. 2025); a privacy dilemma: services that cannot exist without sharing (Belliger and Krieger, via the encyclopedia) - C-1730 What is privacy?
booked: The map keeps the many conceptions, each on the floor where it acts: being let alone, limited access, control, secrecy, appropriate flow and more.
the other reading: privacy as the right to be let alone (Warren and Brandeis 1890); privacy as limited access (Gavison, Bok); privacy as control over information (Westin, Fried); privacy as secrecy (Posner); privacy as appropriate flow (Nissenbaum); privacy as personhood and autonomy (Reiman, Benn); privacy as a collective good (Regan); privacy concepts as the product of evolved information-management mechanisms shaped by culture (Klitgaard and Fessler 2026) - C-1735 Do pictures of eyes make people behave better?
booked: The map books the body's response to being watched and keeps the behavioural effect contested after a failed replication.
the other reading: people behave more cooperatively when observed or shown eye images (the watching-eyes effect, as the replication paper summarises earlier work); a preregistered replication found no effect on giving, though public participants felt more observed (Rotella et al. 2021)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (7)
- Privacy barriers (physical, behavioural, normative)
- Contextual informational norms
- The right to privacy
- Privacy-enhancing techniques (encryption, anonymity networks, differential privacy)
- The privacy calculus (concerns weighed against benefits)
- Attributes, preferences, traits and footprints
- Fingerprinters and re-identifiers against users' anonymity
Sits inside / holds (3)
Trades with (valence) (18)
- Signals intelligence via sys:telephone-network · Privacy loss
- Journalism via sys:written-record · Privacy mixed
- Access control via sys:human-society · Privacy gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Privacy gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Privacy mixed
- Law (rules and law) via sys:human-society · Privacy gain
- Internet via sys:internet · Privacy mixed
- Democracy via sys:human-society · Privacy gain
- Insurance via sys:human-society · Privacy mixed
- Cryptography via sys:internet · Privacy gain
- Culture via sys:human-society · Privacy gain
- Information security via sys:organization · Privacy gain
- Insider threat via sys:organization · Privacy loss
- Organization via sys:organization · Privacy mixed
- Surveillance via sys:internet · Privacy loss
- Digital identity via sys:human-society · Privacy loss
- Computer ethics via sys:human-society · Privacy gain
- Computer law via sys:human-society · Privacy gain
expressed by (11)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Templating / Standardization
- Sensing/Scanning
- Evade Detection
- Quick Harm Avoidance
- Reactive Response
- Proactive Defense
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Enclave/Segregation
- Deterrence
floor filled by (16)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Law (rules and law)
- Internet
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Democracy
- Cryptography
- Culture
- Organization
- Privacy barriers (physical, behavioural, normative)
- Contextual informational norms
- The right to privacy
- The privacy calculus (concerns weighed against benefits)
- Differential privacy
- Surveillance
- Attributes, preferences, traits and footprints
represents (1)
Kinds (16)
- Information privacy
- Contextual informational norms
- Physical privacy
- Bodily integrity
- Organisational privacy (secrets, trade secrets, classified information)
- Sexual privacy
- Location privacy
- Solitude
- Intimacy
- Anonymity
- Reserve
- Right to be let alone (Warren and Brandeis 1890)
- Privacy as limited access
- Privacy as secrecy
- Privacy as a collective value and human right
- Information guarding in other animals
Notes published science
- People will pay to give their privacy away. Roughly a third of everything we say is about ourselves, talking about yourself lights up the brain's dopamine reward system, and people will give up money to do it (src:tamir-2012-self-disclosure).
- If you read every privacy policy you agree to, it would take about 201 hours a year, roughly 40 minutes a day. In 2008 that came to about $781 billion of Americans' time each year (src:mcdonald-cranor-2008-reading-cost).
- Your skin and heart notice when you're being watched, but only if you believe it. Sweat and heart-rate responses to another person's direct gaze appeared only when people thought that person could actually see them, and not when the face was a recording (src:chen-2024-watching-eyes-autonomic).
- Codebreaking gave us the computer: the ten Colossi built to break German codes were the first programmable electronic computers, made by a Bletchley team that was 75% women (src:wp:signals-intelligence, src:wp:bletchley-park). And after the June 2013 revelations, views of privacy-sensitive Wikipedia articles dropped by over 30% at once (src:penney-2016-chilling-effects).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
privacy as privacy scholars describe it: a person and the information about them, up to the autonomy, intimacy and self it protects (reader's view)
- L1: A person (or group) and the information about them: body, home, conversations, records and data traces
- L2: Access and flows: who can see, hear, collect, aggregate and pass on (observation, collection, gossip, tracking)
- L3: Barriers: reserve, physical, behavioural and normative barriers; encryption, anonymity networks, noise
- L4: Context norms: whether a flow is appropriate to its context (contextual integrity)
- L5: Regulation of the boundary: the person weighs concerns against benefits and opens or closes (privacy calculus; Westin's control over information)
- L6: Rights and law: constitutions, UDHR Art. 12, ECHR Art. 8, data protection law and its authorities; privacy as a collective value
- L7: Purpose: personhood and autonomy, self-identity, intimacy, democratic participation
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The person's boundary regulation: concerns (perceived risks) weighed against expected benefits before disclosing or withholding; the weighing is sensitive to defaults and order (endowment), and its link to behaviour is small but real
- L5: The judgement of appropriateness: whether a flow fits the norms of its context (subject, sender, recipient, information type, transmission principle), and how it was acquired and how far it spread
- L6: Rights, law and the collective value: privacy held for everyone by constitutions, treaties, data protection law and their authorities; a collective good that cannot be divided
- L7: What privacy is for: personhood and autonomy (a self that controls its boundaries), self-identity and growth, intimacy and differentiated relationships, democratic participation
way in: Being overheard (conversations, smart speakers, wiretaps)
- L1: One's voice in shared air or on a line
- L2: Captured by a device or a third party (smart speakers, operators)
- L3: A line without a listener sold as private: the dial telephone needed no operator
- L4: Uncertainty about who can overhear (port)
way in: Being seen (others' eyes, cameras, visitors at the glass)
- L1: Another's gaze, a camera or a crowd of onlookers in view
- L2: Gaze direction and the presence of eyes picked up (in starlings as in people)
- L3: Autonomic arousal: skin conductance up and heart rate slowed to direct gaze, only when the person believes they are seen
- L4: The experience of being watched (port): felt observation; in zoo primates fewer social acts and more aggression in view of visitors
way in: Cultural norms of what is private (learned from the group)
- L1: The group's interdependence, size and mobility
- L2: Taught by the social ritual of respecting barriers, through which a child learns it owns its body
- L3: Settled into equilibria: sexual modesty, the walled home
- L4: Held as a norm most cultures share: some of life kept out of public view (port)
way in: Data traces (clicks, Likes, locations, purchases, device features) collected and combined
- L1: Activity online and on phones leaves records: browsing, search, location, purchases
- L2: Collected by tracking libraries, cookies, identifiers and fingerprints; data brokers inside apps
- L3: Aggregated and used to infer traits never disclosed (Likes predict orientation 88%, politics 85%)
- L4: Identification (port): a record tied back to one person; 4 points single out 95%, 15 attributes 99.98%
way in: Felt intrusion, unease and the sense of lost control
- L1: Affective state; where emotions come from is contested (C-414)
- L2: The sense of lost control: about eight in ten feel little or no control over data collected about them
- L3: Concern: 79% concerned about companies' use of their data
- L4: Stress of being watched without retreat (shown in zoo animals: lower cortisol with a choice of where to be)
way in: Gossip and reputation (others passing on what they know)
- L1: Talk about absent others: everywhere in human societies
- L2: Reputation: the aggregated beliefs others hold about a person
- L3: Read for cost: where the hearer sits in shared networks stands in for the cost of spread
- L4: Judged as a privacy matter by how it was acquired and how far it travelled (port)
way in: Knowing one is surveilled (revelations, news, stories)
- L1: Revelations: the 2013 global surveillance disclosures
- L2: Belief in being tracked: 56% of Americans think the government tracks some of their activities
- L3: Models of watching that cannot be checked: the Panopticon, Orwell's Big Brother
- L4: Perceived risk of being seen reading or saying something (port)
way in: Law: rights, statutes and court rulings
- L1: A practice brought before the law: warrantless GPS tracking, covert surveillance
- L2: Sources: UDHR Article 12 (1948), ECHR Article 8, ICCPR Article 17, over 185 constitutions
- L3: Texts: Prosser's four torts (1960); fair information practices (1973) carried into the OECD Guidelines, the Council of Europe Convention, the EU Directive and the GDPR
- L4: Interpretation in courts: US v. Jones (2012) against Uzun v. Germany (2010)
- L5: Enforcement and compliance: supervisory authorities, data protection officers, 72-hour breach reports, protection by design
way in: New recording and spreading technologies (press, photography, telephone, internet)
- L1: A new technology arrives: printing presses, instant photographs, the telephone, the internet
- L2: New flows become possible: more ability to share means new ways to breach
- L3: Old expectations broken: the internet stores and searches what people shared without expecting it to be kept
- L4: A claim made in answer (port): Warren and Brandeis 1890, written mainly against newspapers and photographs
way in: Privacy notices and consent prompts (policies, cookie banners, permission dialogs)
- L1: Notices shown: more than 60% of popular European sites display cookie consent notices
- L2: Read or not: reading every policy would take about 201 hours a year; 22% of readers read to the end
- L3: Framed: dark patterns and nudges; only 11.8% of pop-ups meet minimal legal requirements
- L4: The choice offered (port): position, binary or granular, defaults
way in: The urge to tell (one's own thoughts and feelings pressing to be shared)
- L1: One's own experiences and thoughts; where thoughts come from is contested (C-413)
- L2: Reward: self-disclosure engages the mesolimbic dopamine system (nucleus accumbens, VTA)
- L3: Weighed against money: people forgo money to disclose
- L4: The value placed on self-referential thought and on sharing itself (port)
way out: Chilled conduct (not reading, searching or saying)
- L1: Fewer views of privacy-sensitive articles: an immediate drop of just under 25% after June 2013 and a lower trend after
- L5: Hold back for fear of being seen
way out: Consent choices (accept, reject, ask app not to track)
- L1: Tracking on or off: ATT stopped IDFA collection, yet tracking libraries stayed about the same
- L3: Clicked in the dialog as designed: removing the opt-out button from the first page raises consent 22-23 points
- L5: Accept or refuse tracking
way out: Release with protection (de-identification; differential privacy's calibrated noise)
- L1: Published: the 2020 US redistricting data released with differential privacy
- L3: Noise calibrated to one person's influence; losses add up across releases; or identifiers removed (contested)
- L4: The promise made measurable: a privacy loss bounded by epsilon
- L6: Promise to the data subject
way out: Rights exercised and enforced (complaints, erasure, access, fines, rulings)
- L1: Practices changed: data erased, warrants required, protection designed in
- L4: Sanction: fines up to EUR 20 million or 4% of worldwide turnover
- L6: A right invoked
way out: Selective disclosure (speech, posts, confiding)
- L1: Into others' ears and records; in intimacy, privacy does not apply between the partners
- L3: Spoken or posted: 30-40% of speech is about one's own experience
- L5: Decide what to share with whom
way out: Technical protection (encryption, anonymity networks, private browsing)
- L1: IP address and location hidden from the ISP (not from third-party data mining)
- L3: Layered relays: each onion router knows only its predecessor and successor; perfect forward secrecy
- L5: Choose to encrypt or anonymise
way out: Withholding and withdrawing (seclusion, walls, clothes, reserve, retreat)
- L1: Out of view: the animal retreats, the orangutan covers its head, the home is fenced
- L3: Barriers raised: physical (walls, doors), behavioural (personal space, body language, clothing), normative
- L5: Decide to withhold or withdraw