← all systems · see it in The System
Computer law
Information technology law (IT law, cyberlaw): the legal regulation of information technology, its possibilities and the consequences of its use, including computing, software, AI and the internet (src:wp:information-technology-law). Not a separate branch of law but parts of criminal, contract, intellectual property, privacy and data protection law gathered around computing; walked as the field describes itself: conduct with computers, networks and data, how it comes before the law, the statutes it falls under (computer crime, data protection, copyright and patents, intermediary liability), how courts construe them, whose jurisdiction applies, law beside code, norms and markets (Lessig), and the rulings, fines, shields, design duties and models it sends back out.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | 1977-1978 (Ribicoff bill; Florida statute) |
| born precision | a few years |
| boundary | Inside: the statutes, regulations, treaties and case law about computers, data and networks (computer crime, data protection, software copyright and patents, intermediary liability, jurisdiction online), the courts, legislatures, data protection authorities and prosecutors as they apply them, and the scholarship that shapes them. Outside: the computers, networks and data themselves, the people and organisations whose conduct is regulated, law in general (its parent), and the other regulators of the same conduct (code, norms, markets). |
| nested level | A part of law (src:wp:information-technology-law: 'IT law does not constitute a separate area of law'), applied by states and, across borders, through treaties; one of four regulators of conduct online beside code, norms and markets (src:lessig-1999-law-of-the-horse). |
| scale | social |
Measures (22) published science
| first state computer crime statute | 1978 (Florida) year |
| last state computer crime statute | May 1999 (Vermont) date |
| time for all fifty US states to legislate | about 21 years (1978 to 1999) |
| GDPR maximum fine | EUR 20 million or 4% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is greater EUR / % turnover |
| breach notification clock | 72 hours |
| DMCA exemption rulemaking cycle | triennial every three years |
| GDPR adoption to application | 14 April 2016 to 25 May 2018 dates |
| typical GDPR fine range (sample) | about 400 to 163,000 EUR (n = 294 decisions) |
| fine decisions citing A5 or A6 | 67 % |
| EU websites with cookie consent notices after the GDPR | 62.1 (46.1 in January 2018) % |
| websites updating existing privacy policies near 25 May 2018 | 72.6 % |
| fewer tracker connections when the same sites are visited from the EU | 50.5 % |
| sites with any tracker connection (Germany vs Australia) | 44.6 vs 96.0 % |
| Van Buren vote | 6-3 justices |
| circuit split before Van Buren | 4-3 circuits |
| Budapest Convention ratifications (Aug 2025) | 81 states |
| Budapest Convention ratifications (as tabulated in 2022) | 66 (22 non-EU) states |
| UN cybercrime convention signatories (Oct 2026) | 95 signatories, 3 ratifications states |
| countries with comprehensive data protection laws | over 80 countries and territories |
| R v Gold and Schifreen fines (later quashed) | 750 and 600 GBP |
| bribe in Van Buren | around 5,000 USD |
| Stratton Oakmont to Section 230 | 1995 to 1996 years |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1740 How far do EU data rules reach beyond Europe?
booked: The map books a real but limited 'Brussels effect', with China's and the US's different responses kept alongside.
the other reading: Bradford / Siegmann and Anderljung: de facto and de jure effects of the GDPR; Li and Chen: China's PIPL is a 'gravity assist', not a straightforward Brussels effect; Yu et al.: a moderate effect; against US ad tech EU law acts mainly as a 'Brussels shield'; the encyclopedia: the framework is one-directional - C-1742 When is computer access 'unauthorized' under US law?
booked: The map books the Supreme Court's gates-up-or-down reading, and leaves open whether terms of service can close a gate.
the other reading: contract- and purpose-based readings (the government in Van Buren; four circuits before 2021); Kerr's code-based reading (only circumventing a code-based restriction counts); Van Buren did not go as far as to say only technical restrictions count (Xiao et al.) - C-1747 When did computer law begin?
booked: The map dates it to the first computer-crime bill and statute of 1977-78, with earlier prosecutions under property law alongside.
the other reading: early 1970s: harms recognised and prosecuted under property law (Kerr); 1977/1978: the first computer-specific bill and statute; 1984: the first federal computer crime law - C-1748 Is computer law its own field of law?
booked: The map books both readings: part of ordinary law, and a field with its own lesson about law's limits.
the other reading: Easterbrook (1996): no more a law of cyberspace than a law of the horse; study general rules; Lessig (1999): cyberlaw teaches a general point about law's limits as one regulator among four; the encyclopedia: IT law does not constitute a separate area of law - C-1750 Which international treaty governs cybercrime?
booked: The map books two competing treaties: the Budapest Convention and the newer UN convention.
the other reading: Budapest Convention (2001): 81 ratifications by August 2025; Russia refuses it on sovereignty grounds; UN Convention against Cybercrime (2024): proposed by Russia; criticised for widening surveillance without safeguards; 95 signatories, 3 ratifications by October 2026 - C-1751 Does cyberspace have its own law, or do national laws apply?
booked: The map books national law as applied in practice, and keeps the separate-cyberspace view as a contending position.
the other reading: Johnson and Post (1996): cyberspace as a distinct place with its own law; territorial sovereigns should defer; the encyclopedia: courts have consistently applied existing national laws to internet activity; Lessig: the norms of two communities apply to one person in both places at once
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (14)
- Legislatures and statutes
- Courts (the judiciary)
- Computer Fraud and Abuse Act
- General Data Protection Regulation
- Computer Misuse Act 1990 (UK)
- State computer crime statutes (US, 1978-1999)
- Digital Millennium Copyright Act (US, 1998)
- Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act (US, 1996)
- Budapest Convention on Cybercrime (2001; Protocols 2003/2006, 2021)
- UN Convention against Cybercrime (2024; Hanoi 2025)
- Personal Information Protection Law (China, 2021)
- Data protection authorities
- Cyberlaw scholarship
- Which treaty governs cybercrime cooperation
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (15)
- Cybercrime and its underground economy via sys:internet · Computer law gain
- Security audit and compliance via sys:organization · Computer law gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Computer law gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Computer law gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:human-society · Computer law gain
- Software via sys:software · Computer law gain
- Internet via sys:internet · Computer law mixed
- Computer via sys:computer · Computer law gain
- Market and trade via sys:human-society · Computer law gain
- Computer security via sys:electromagnetic-field · Computer law mixed
- Social media platforms via sys:internet · Computer law mixed
- Phishing via sys:internet · Computer law gain
- Organization via sys:organization · Computer law gain
- Privacy via sys:human-society · Computer law gain
- Computer ethics via sys:human-society · Computer law gain
expressed by (17)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Leverage Host/Amplification
- Reactive Response
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Deterrence
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (18)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Law (rules and law)
- Legislatures and statutes
- Software
- Computer
- Courts (the judiciary)
- Market and trade
- Police
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Organization
- Computer ethics
- Attributes, preferences, traits and footprints
- Computer Fraud and Abuse Act
- General Data Protection Regulation
- Budapest Convention on Cybercrime (2001; Protocols 2003/2006, 2021)
- Data protection authorities
- Cyberlaw scholarship
Kinds (6)
- Computer crime law
- Data protection (information privacy) law
- Software copyright
- Software patent law
- Intermediary liability law (Section 230, DMCA 512, EU E-Commerce Directive, Digital Services Act)
- Internet jurisdiction and conflict of laws
Notes published science
- The break-in that forced Britain to write its computer crime law used the password 1234. In 1984-85 two men got into British Telecom's Prestel service after one of them saw an engineer's login (username 22222222) at a trade show; they were convicted under a forgery law, acquitted on appeal, and the gap their acquittal exposed led to the Computer Misuse Act 1990, which Canada and Ireland then copied (src:wp:computer-misuse-act-1990).
- Law changes the code, and you can measure it: the same 525 popular websites open about half as many tracker connections (50.5% fewer) when visited from an EU country as from elsewhere, and only 44.6% of popular German sites connect to any tracker against 96.0% of Australian ones. The authors call EU law mostly a 'Brussels shield' rather than a rule the whole web adopts (src:yu-2026-web-tracking).
- A law professor's 2003 article found its way into the Supreme Court 18 years later: Orin Kerr argued that computer crime laws should only cover getting past a real gate in the code, the Court cited his brief when it ruled 6-3 in 2021 that 'exceeds authorized access' is a gates-up-or-down question, and the Justice Department then said it would not charge good-faith security research (src:kerr-2003-cybercrimes-scope; src:scotus-2021-van-buren; src:xiao-2025-anti-fraud-research).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
computer law as IT-law scholars and courts describe it: conduct with computers, networks and data, up to the legal order sent back onto them (reader's view)
- L1: Conduct with computers, networks and data: access, processing, copying, posting
- L2: Coming before the law: victims' reports, complaints, breach notifications, rights holders' notices, suits
- L3: The rule it falls under: computer crime statutes, data protection, copyright and patent, intermediary liability
- L4: Doctrine: courts construe the terms ('access', 'authorization', 'publisher')
- L5: Jurisdiction and enforcement: which law applies, who enforces, how states cooperate
- L6: The regulatory mix: law beside code, norms and markets; the field's debates about itself
- L7: The legal order sent back: rulings, sanctions, safe harbours, design duties, models for others
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Doctrine: statutes, regulations and case law construed: what 'access', 'authorization', 'personal data' and 'publisher' mean
- L5: Jurisdiction and enforcement: which sovereign's law applies, who enforces (prosecutors, data protection authorities, courts), cooperation across borders
- L6: The regulatory mix and the field's own meaning: law beside code, norms and markets; whether cyberlaw is a field at all
- L7: The legal order of computing sent back out: rulings, sanctions, safe harbours, design duties, and models other states copy
way in: Computer misuse: intrusions and unauthorized access
- L1: An intrusion into someone else's system: Gold and Schifreen in Prestel (1984-85, engineer's password 1234); a police sergeant's paid licence-plate search (Van Buren)
- L2: Noticed by the system owner and passed on: monitors on the suspect accounts, the police told; an FBI sting in Van Buren
- L3: Charged: first under borrowed property and forgery law, later under computer crime statutes keyed to 'unauthorized access'
way in: Copying, circumvention and software as protected work
- L1: Copying of software and digital works; circumvention of access controls; free and open source licences that run on copyright
- L2: Rights holders' notices to online service providers; providers qualify for the safe harbour only if they meet its requirements
- L3: 17 U.S.C. 512 (safe harbour) and 1201 (anti-circumvention); software patents handled radically differently by jurisdiction
way in: Legal scholarship and amicus briefs
- L1: Articles and books on cyberlaw (Johnson and Post 1996; Easterbrook 1996; Lessig 1999; Kerr 2003)
- L2: Conferences and debate: the Chicago 'Law of Cyberspace' conference, the law-of-the-horse challenge
- L3: Proposals: limit access statutes to circumventing code-based restrictions
- L4: Carried to the courts as amicus briefs (Kerr's brief cited in Van Buren)
- L5: Frames for the field's jurisdiction: cyberspace as a place of its own (Johnson and Post) against territorial law
way in: New technology outrunning existing law
- L1: New capabilities: the personal computer's automatic dialing (cited from the film WarGames, 1983), the internet, AI
- L2: Existing law fits badly: prosecutors reach for trespass, burglary and theft law
- L3: Bills drafted: Ribicoff 1977; Florida 1978; the federal law 1984, broadened 1986
way in: Other states' laws, requests and evidence across borders
- L1: Conduct, servers and evidence spread across territories; privacy laws are local while the web is global
- L2: Requests for electronic evidence held by providers abroad
- L3: Treaties and harmonised offences: the Budapest Convention (2001; Protocol II 2021); the UN convention (2024)
- L4: Conflict of laws: one transaction under at least three jurisdictions
way in: Processing of personal data: complaints and breach notifications
- L1: Processing of personal data by controllers and processors, whether manual or automated, wherever it takes place
- L2: Complaints by data subjects and breach notifications to supervisory authorities within 72 hours
- L3: The articles referenced: A5 principles, A6 lawfulness, A32 security of processing
way in: Security and AI research that probes systems
- L1: Penetration testing, web scraping, sock puppets, audits of AI systems
- L2: Legal threat noticed: researchers report a chilling effect
- L3: Exemptions sought: statutory exemptions 1201(f),(g),(j); the triennial rulemaking; calls for a safe harbor (none in the CFAA)
way in: The code's own gates (architecture as a regulator)
- L1: Gates built into the code by the system's owner: passwords, login screens, access controls; the boundary of screens and passwords
- L2: A bypass: the gate is circumvented (or a user with valid access uses it for another purpose)
- L3: Statutes keyed to the gate: 'without authorization', 'exceeds authorized access', technological measures under 1201
way in: Third-party content on online services
- L1: Content authored by third parties on bulletin boards and platforms
- L2: Defamation suits against the services: Cubby v. CompuServe (1991), Stratton Oakmont v. Prodigy (1995)
- L3: The publisher/distributor rule; a service that filters is treated as the publisher of all of it (Stratton Oakmont), then Section 230(c)
way out: Duties written into the code
- L1: Websites change: cookie notices on 62.1% of EU sites; half the trackers when visited from the EU
- L3: GDPR and the ePrivacy Directive require consent and transparency
- L7: Law directs the architecture (consent, data protection by design)
way out: Fines and sentences
- L1: Paid by the organisation; deal-making shifts (Chinese digital acquisitions in the EU fall)
- L5: Imposed by a data protection authority (A58, A83) or a court
- L7: A sanction decided: fines up to EUR 20 million or 4% of worldwide turnover; criminal penalties
way out: Immunities, safe harbours and exemptions
- L1: Services host and moderate third-party content without publisher liability; researchers test under exemptions
- L3: The rule: no provider is treated as the publisher of another's content
- L7: A shield granted: Section 230 (1996), the DMCA safe harbour (1998), 1201 exemptions
way out: Models other legislatures copy
- L1: Global firms comply everywhere (de facto effect) or geofence (a Brussels shield)
- L5: Other legislatures adopt or adapt it: Brazil, Japan, South Korea; the UK CMA in Canada and Ireland; China's PIPL as a gravity assist
- L7: A law becomes a model: EU regulation spreads beyond its borders
way out: Rulings that draw the line of what is a crime
- L1: Conduct: improper purpose with valid access is no longer a federal computer crime
- L2: Prosecutors adjust: the 2022 policy not to charge good-faith security research
- L4: The construction binds lower courts: gates-up-or-down
- L7: A ruling: Van Buren, 6-3, June 2021