← all systems · see it in The System
Police
A constituted body of people empowered by a state to enforce the law and protect public order and the public, with lawful powers of arrest and of force 'legitimized by the state's monopoly on violence' (src:wp:police). Uniformed officers answer calls for service and patrol between them; detectives investigate; specialist and tactical units handle particular crimes and dangerous situations (src:wp:police). Walked as the institution and its people: the call, the patrol, the investigation, the command, the law and the public consent it runs on, its kinds, its history from ancient prefects and the Medjay to the Metropolitan Police of 1829, and the research on what it does (hot spots, response time, procedural justice, body-worn cameras, officers' health).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | Egypt's fourth dynasty (an office 'Judge Commandant of the Police'); separate births in China, Mesopotamia and the Americas |
| born precision | centuries |
| boundary | Inside: the force itself: its sworn officers (uniformed patrol and response, detectives, specialist and tactical units, auxiliaries and volunteers), its civilian staff (call handlers, radio operators, analysts), its stations, vehicles, radios and records, its ranks and command, its internal affairs units, and the rules it holds (criminal procedure as applied, force policy, the graded response). Outside: the public it serves and acts on (callers, victims, witnesses, suspects, bystanders), offenders, the legislature and courts that make and test its powers, the government that funds and governs it, outside oversight bodies, other emergency services, private security and alarm companies, the military it may call on, the media and the research that evaluates it. |
| nested level | An organisation (rung 11) inside the state's apparatus beside the army, under law: the state 'claimed monopoly of legitimate force' is exercised 'by the police and the military' (src:wp:police). With courts and corrections it makes up law enforcement and the criminal justice system (src:wp:law-enforcement). Runs on people (its officers are Human systems) and on the society that consents to it (Peel's 'the police are the public and the public are the police', src:wp:peelian-principles). |
| scale | social |
Measures (37) published science
| characteristic clock: police response time (Greater Manchester, grade 1 and 2 calls) | median 17; mean more than 60 minutes |
| graded response targets | grade 1: 15; grade 2: 60 minutes |
| effect of response time on detection | -4.6 percentage points per 10% longer response |
| share of crimes detected (Greater Manchester sample of over 300,000 crimes) | about 38 % |
| detection with and without a named suspect | 65 vs 29 % |
| share of US crimes cleared | less than a quarter % |
| Met sanction detection rate | 7.3 (2022/23); 24 (2010-11) % |
| crimes screened out on the day reported (Met, 2017) | 34,164 crimes |
| sexual violence cases reported to law enforcement (estimate) | 23 per 1,000 cases |
| hot spots policing mean effect on crime | d = 0.132 (0.103 after trim-and-fill) standardised mean difference |
| diffusion of benefits to surrounding areas | d = 0.086 standardised mean difference |
| problem-oriented vs added traditional policing at hot spots | 0.164 vs 0.108 standardised mean difference |
| crime concentration | hot spots generate half of all criminal events share of crime |
| PCSO patrol cost-benefit (Peterborough) | 5.6-23 euros saved per euro spent ratio |
| police elasticity of the cost-weighted sum of crimes (US cities 1960-2010) | about -0.5 elasticity |
| procedural-justice training: crime incidents in PJ hot spots | -14 % relative |
| US police strength in the 1960s, as the source writes it | from about 160 to just over 250 officers per capita officers per capita (as written) |
| procedural-justice training: arrests by PJ officers | more than -60 % relative |
| body-worn cameras: complaints against officers | about -17 % relative |
| body-worn cameras: use of force (not significant) | -6.8 % relative |
| lifetime odds of being killed by police (US) | men 1 in 2,000; women 1 in 33,000; black men about 1 in 1,000 odds |
| PTSD in police officers | 7-19 (subsyndromal up to 34) % |
| police suicide proportionate mortality ratio (US) | 169 (95% CI 150-191) PMR |
| characteristic clock: the shift | 24/7 duties in shifts; alertness down after five consecutive night shifts |
| women among US officers (2013) | 11.6 % |
| medical and public-health calls (Philadelphia 2019) | 7.4% of calls, 8.6% of committed time |
| calls for service from the public (Philadelphia 2019) | 1.07 million; 6,584 sworn officers calls |
| activity not predictable from initial call type (public-health area) | about 20 % |
| detectives' share of personnel | 15-25 % |
| missing-person searches, UK police time (2012) | 14 % |
| Metropolitan Police workforce | 43,571 in total; 32,493 officers people |
| Metropolitan Police expenditure | £194,126 (1829/30) to £3.69 billion (2011/12) GBP |
| Greater Manchester Police | about 6,200 officers for 2.6 million people |
| Marine Police at founding (1798) | about 50 men for 33,000 river workers; £4,200 initial investment |
| Paris police at founding (1667) | 44 commissaires officers |
| Rome's vigiles under Augustus | seven squads of 1,000 men for 14 wards |
| Athens' Scythian Archers | about 300 men |
Open contentions (5) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1570 Which was the first modern police force?
booked: The map keeps the candidates and rules none.
the other reading: Edinburgh 1611; Paris 1667; London 1829 - C-1574 Does policing crime hot spots just push crime elsewhere?
booked: The map keeps the findings on displacement and on benefits spreading to nearby areas.
the other reading: crime moves around the corner (Blattman et al. 2017; Reppetto 1976, as cited) - C-1584 Did Robert Peel write the 'Peelian principles'?
booked: The map keeps the question open, as historians do.
the other reading: Peel's own principles (the usual attribution) - C-1585 When did policing begin?
booked: The map books the first police office in ancient Egypt, and keeps monkey and insect policing as older readings.
the other reading: the same system as conflict policing in animal societies, beginning with them; only the human institution; animals share the job, not the system - C-1586 What are police for?
booked: The map keeps the readings: order for everyone, and control serving those in power.
the other reading: order and crime prevention for all (Peelian principles); a repressive apparatus for a ruling class (Marxist theory)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (18)
- Police officers (constables, troopers, sheriffs' deputies)
- Uniformed patrol and response
- Detectives (criminal investigation)
- Specialist and tactical units
- Call handlers and radio operators (the control room)
- Computer-aided dispatch (CAD) records
- Police radio and mobile data terminals
- Police vehicles (cars, motorcycles, bicycles, boats, aircraft)
- Internal affairs and inspectorate units
- The rank hierarchy
- DDoS-for-hire services against law enforcement
- Burglars against the police for the burglar's liberty
- Police against offenders for order and safety at places
- Salaried public police against reward-paid thief-takers and private watchmen
- Police and army for the keeping of domestic order
- Botmasters against defenders for control of the bots
- Booter operators against police for the booter market
- Underground markets against law enforcement
Sits inside / holds (6)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Government
- Law (rules and law)
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- City
- Digital forensics
Trades with (valence) (24)
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Police mixed
- Domestic dog (Canis familiaris) via sys:sensory-environment · Police gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Police gain
- Government via sys:human-society · Police gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:law · Police mixed
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:human-society · Police mixed
- City via sys:human-society · Police gain
- Algorithm (the practice of step-by-step procedures and the structure they compute) via sys:computer-aided-dispatch · Police mixed
- Courts (the judiciary) via sys:law · Police mixed
- Military (professional soldiers and officers) via sys:human-society · Police mixed
- Physical security via sys:human-society · Police loss
- Security personnel via sys:human-society · Police gain
- Offenders via sys:human-society · Police mixed
- Incident response via sys:human-society · Police gain
- Threat actor via sys:law · Police mixed
- Botnet via sys:police · Police gain
- Denial-of-service attack via sys:human-society · Police mixed
- Insider threat via sys:human-society · Police gain
- Intruder (burglar and trespasser) via sys:human-society · Police mixed
- Cybercrime and its underground economy via sys:internet · Police mixed
- Cyber threat intelligence via sys:human-society · Police gain
- Digital forensics via sys:human-society · Police gain
- Surveillance via sys:human-society · Police gain
- Tax via sys:human-society · Police gain
expressed by (27)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Search/Foraging
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Speed
- Prepositioning & Latency
- Reactive Response
- Proactive Defense
- Technique-Based Identification (a.k.a. Technique-Based Detection)
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Deception
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Deterrence
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (22)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Law (rules and law)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Domestic dog (Canis familiaris)
- Government
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- City
- Algorithm (the practice of step-by-step procedures and the structure they compute)
- Taxation
- Physical security
- Uniformed patrol and response
- Detectives (criminal investigation)
- Specialist and tactical units
- Call handlers and radio operators (the control room)
- Computer-aided dispatch (CAD) records
- Police radio and mobile data terminals
- Internal affairs and inspectorate units
- The rank hierarchy
- Offenders
- Emergency telephone number (999, 911, 112)
- Digital forensics
- Computer law
Kinds (15)
- Organization
- Security personnel
- Uniformed patrol and response
- Detectives (criminal investigation)
- Specialist and tactical units
- Auxiliary, reserve and volunteer police (special constables)
- Gendarmerie (military units with civil policing)
- Military police (provosts)
- Religious police
- Secret police
- Sheriff (county office; from the shire-reeve)
- Federal and national agencies (marshals, Secret Service, federal police)
- Interpol (international police cooperation)
- Worker policing in insect societies
- Policing in primate groups (pigtailed macaques)
wired (5)
- Courts (the judiciary)
- Digital forensic examiners and first responders
- Online anonymous marketplaces (cryptomarkets)
- Central alarm station
- Digital forensic laboratories (crime labs, RCFLs, ICAC labs, corporate and private labs)
Notes published science
- Every minute counts in a measurable way: in Greater Manchester, a 10% slower police response cut the chance that a crime was solved by 4.6 percentage points, mostly because witnesses had not yet been found to name a suspect (src:blanes-kirchmaier-2015).
- Monkeys have police too: when researchers removed the few pigtailed macaques that break up fights, the whole group's grooming and play networks shrank and fragmented (src:flack-2006).
- Predictive policing can chase its own tail: a model that only learns from crimes found where it sent officers keeps sending them back to the same neighbourhoods, whatever the true crime rate (src:ensign-2018-runaway).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
police as criminologists and police historians describe them: incidents and people in a jurisdiction, up to the order the state keeps (reader's view)
- L1: The jurisdiction: people, places and events in a defined territory (crime, disorder, emergencies, traffic, missing people), half of crime in small hot spots, much of it never reported
- L2: Intake: calls for service to the emergency number, alarms, what officers see on patrol, reports and evidence
- L3: The control room: call handlers code and grade; radio operators and CAD route; two-way radio links officers
- L4: Response and investigation: uniformed officers attend, detectives and specialists investigate, decisions to stop, search, arrest or use force
- L5: Command and organisation: ranks and divisions; strategy (reactive, hot spots, problem-oriented, intelligence-led, evidence-based); resources tasked
- L6: Legitimacy, law and accountability: criminal procedure, policing by consent, procedural justice, internal and outside oversight
- L7: Purpose: the law enforced, order kept and crime prevented on the state's behalf, with force held as a last resort
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Response and investigation: radio operators assign response officers by judgment and availability; officers attend, question victims and witnesses, stop, search, arrest; detectives and specialist units investigate
- L5: Command and organisation: the rank hierarchy and its divisions; strategy chosen and resources tasked (reactive response, hot spots, problem-oriented, intelligence-led, evidence-based policing); centralised command since car, radio and telephone
- L6: Legitimacy, law and accountability: powers bounded by criminal procedure; public approval and cooperation (policing by consent); fair treatment (procedural justice); internal and outside oversight
- L7: Purpose: the law enforced and public order kept on the state's behalf; crime and disorder prevented ('the test of police efficiency is the absence of crime and disorder')
way in: Alarm signals from protected premises
- L1: Premises protected by alarm systems; an intruder, an animal, the weather or a fault trips a sensor
- L3: The 'Alarm' call type in dispatch, mostly false, sometimes a burglary in progress
way in: Calls for service (999, 911, 112 and non-emergency lines)
- L1: An event in the jurisdiction suffered or witnessed by someone who decides to call: a crime, a disturbance, an accident, a medical or mental-health crisis; much is never reported (the dark figure)
- L2: The emergency number and the operator or call handler who answers it (999 from 1937; 911 from 1968)
- L3: Coding, grading and the CAD record: the handler questions the caller, codes the call and grades it (grade 1 within 15 minutes, grade 2 within 60); caller location from address databases, towers or GPS; misclassification is common
way in: Crime records and analysis (where crime is, intelligence, prediction)
- L1: Recorded incidents across the city: half of all crime in small hot spots; reported incidents (from residents) and discovered incidents (found by officers sent there)
- L2: The CAD and crime databases (Philadelphia 2019: over 3.3 million entries)
- L3: Crime analysis and intelligence: information collected and analysed to guide operations; predictive models fitted to past incidents
- L4: Where to send police: hot-spot lists and predicted areas handed to command
way in: Evidence and witnesses (investigation)
- L1: Victims and witnesses who can name a suspect; physical traces at the scene
- L2: Detectives (15-25% of personnel), specialist units and detection dogs that take up the traces (a cadaver dog's nose for the volatile compounds of buried remains)
- L3: The case file: statements, exhibits and records shared across police, courts and corrections
way in: Funding and staffing (taxes, budgets, officers)
- L1: Taxes: police forces are public services funded through taxes (constables were the first tax-supported officials)
- L2: The budget (the Met: £194,126 in 1829/30; £4.43 billion now), cut or grown by government
- L3: Officers and staff on the books (the Met: 32,493 officers; US cities: from about 160 to over 250 per capita in the 1960s, as the source writes it)
- L4: Officers on shift: 24/7 duties in shifts
way in: Law and the courts (powers given and tested)
- L1: Legislatures and courts that make and test police powers
- L2: Rulings and acts: Miranda, Terry v. Ohio (1968), PACE 1984
- L3: Applied case by case: warrants on probable cause and their four exceptions
- L4: Powers held by rank: every constable's arrest powers, more for inspectors and superintendents
- L5: Oversight: internal affairs units and outside bodies (Independent Office for Police Conduct, ombudsmen, Ontario's SIU)
way in: Officers' own bodies under the work (stress, trauma, sleep)
- L1: Officers exposed to shift work, long hours, trauma and organisational stress; long-term night work lowers waking cortisol
- L2: Symptoms: PTSD in 7-19% of officers, subsyndromal up to 34%; alertness down after five night shifts
- L3: What the force sees of it: sick leave, errors, injuries, absenteeism, suicide (PMR 169)
way in: Officers' own eyes and ears on patrol (discovered incidents)
- L1: The beat: streets, places and people an officer passes between calls
- L3: Radio, notebook and the mobile data terminal: what the officer sees is reported, checked and logged (background checks in seconds)
way in: Other forces and agencies (mutual aid, the military, Interpol)
- L1: Other police forces worldwide and their international body (Interpol, 1923)
- L2: Requests and aid: police may call on the military (SAS at the Iranian Embassy, 1980)
way in: Research evidence (field experiments and reviews)
- L1: Field experiments in forces (Kansas City preventive patrol, Minneapolis hot spots, procedural justice trials)
- L2: Controlled evaluation: evidence-based policing
- L3: Systematic reviews and meta-analyses (65 hot-spot studies; 30 body-worn camera studies)
- L4: Endorsed by police institutions (the Police Foundation, the UK College of Policing)
way in: The public's consent, cooperation and complaint
- L1: The public whose approval the police depend on ('the police are the public and the public are the police')
- L2: Complaints, surveys, protest and calls for change (2020: calls to defund or abolish)
- L3: Recorded encounters: body-worn cameras and bystanders' video as evidence for review
- L4: Community outreach, community policing and civilian commissions that bring local concerns in
- L5: Imposed reform: Justice Department suits, consent decrees, outside monitoring
way in: The state's mandate and governance
- L1: The state, holding the monopoly on the legitimate use of force
- L2: The founding statute and its object (Metropolitan Police Act 1829; Peel made 'prevention of crime' the principal object)
- L3: The governing body (for the Met, the Mayor's Office for Policing and Crime and the Home Office)
- L4: The chief officer appointed (the Commissioner; first held jointly by Rowan and Mayne)
way out: Arrest, search and force
- L1: The person acted on: detained, injured or killed (US lifetime odds of being killed by police about 1 in 2,000 for men)
- L2: Restraint and weapons: handcuffs, batons, less-lethal weapons, firearms (not carried as a matter of course in some countries)
- L4: The decision to stop, search, arrest or use force, bounded by law and policy
way out: Cases passed to prosecution and courts
- L2: Handed on: apprehend criminals for the courts to process
- L4: Crimes detected: suspects charged or summonsed (sanction detection)
way out: Problem-solving at places (changing the conditions)
- L1: The place changed so the problem stops recurring
- L5: Problem-oriented policing chosen
way out: Published crime statistics and outcome rates
- L1: Read by the public and government (detection rates falling as recorded crime rises)
- L5: Monthly 'positive outcome' rates published
way out: Reform: training, policy and technology changes
- L5: New training and kit rolled out (procedural justice training; body-worn cameras, adopted by half of agencies by the mid-2010s)
- L6: Reform decided after scrutiny (consent decrees, oversight)
way out: Response: officers sent to the scene
- L1: Arrival at the scene: seen and heard (marked cars, sirens, uniform)
- L3: Driven there with sirens and lights, right of way in traffic
- L4: A response officer assigned; grade 1 within 15 minutes
way out: Talk: advice, warning, persuasion and fair treatment
- L1: The person treated fairly or not, and what they then think of the police
- L4: Procedural justice in the encounter: voice, neutrality, respect, trustworthy motives
- L6: Force only when persuasion, advice and warning fail
way out: Visible presence and patrol (deterrence)
- L1: The street seen with police on it (Colquhoun's 'permanent presence')
- L4: Presence and enforcement raised to deter
- L5: Patrol tasked to places: directed patrol at hot spots