← all systems · see it in The System
Culture
Culture across the species that have it: behaviour and knowledge learned socially and held in common by a group. Master node over its kinds (human culture, animal cultures; orca culture to come), as Language is over the languages.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | unknown: possibly in invertebrates (insects); established in all major classes of vertebrates |
| born precision | no date in the sources read |
| boundary | Inside: behaviour and knowledge a learner acquires from others (or from their products) and that is passed on again, so that it persists as group-typical traditions. Outside: what each animal learns alone by trial and error, what genes or local ecology alone produce (the method of exclusion tries to rule these out), and behaviour that is shared but not socially learned. The line is drawn differently by each definition (C-1393): a minimal definition counts every socially learned skill; a population-level one counts only what varies between groups. |
| nested level | Runs on its carriers (social animals and humans), on their top floors (learned behaviour performed in shared space); built from social learning, transmission between individuals and the traditions it keeps; rides on the genetic inheritance system as a second inheritance system and feeds back into it. |
| scale | social |
| why | Jerry 2026-11-09 14:10: rename the walked Culture to Human Culture, leaving room for Orca Culture and a master Culture they are all part of |
Measures (20) published science
| time for a seeded technique to reach most of a population (characteristic clock) | 20 days of exposure to reach an average of 75% |
| learning-rate gain per unit of association (great tits) | 12.0 (95% CI 8.8-16.0) factor |
| population turnover across the tradition's persistence (great tits) | just 40% present the previous year fraction |
| tradition persistence (great tits) | two generations; 9 months between trials |
| share of naive observer bumblebees that learned the two-step box | a third fraction |
| naive bumblebees exposed without a demonstrator | up to 24 days, no box opened |
| orangutan cultural repertoire by counting socially learned skills vs method of exclusion | 195 and 122 variants (Suaq, Tuanan) vs 29 and 25 |
| orangutan peering events by adulthood | around 38,000 and 9000 events |
| chimpanzee behaviour categories habitual in some communities and absent in others | 39 of 65 categories |
| humpback song-type spread record | 11-year period across the western and central South Pacific years |
| song-learning window (white-crowned sparrow) | first 100 days of life |
| tandem-running leader speed (teaching cost) | ¼ of solo speed fraction |
| kelp gull lesions on whales | 2% to 99% (1974-2011) fraction of lesions |
| regent honeyeater males off the cultural norm | 27% (12% singing only other species' songs) fraction |
| reintroduced golden lion tamarin survival | 13% initially; offspring 70% fraction |
| migration knowledge regained by translocated ungulates (settling time) | multiple decades years |
| speed of cultural vs genetic transmission | days and hours vs many years of reproduction time |
| bluehead wrasse mating-site persistence | four generations |
| pigeon route gain over solo birds (fifth generation) | 0.99 km shorter (fixed pairs 0.87 km) |
| history of the study of animal culture | past 70 years |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1050 How does culture change over time?
booked: The map doesn't rule. It describes each process as the sources do (spread, invention, copying biases, cumulative build-up) and lists the theories alongside.
the other reading: memetics; dual inheritance theory - C-1054 What lets human culture build up over generations?
booked: The map follows the model finding that small gains in copying accuracy, and combining ideas, matter more than lone inventions, and keeps other drivers alongside.
the other reading: innovation-centred accounts - C-1363 Do New Caledonian crows have tool culture that builds up over time?
booked: The map records that tool designs vary by place and last, and leaves open whether they are passed on and improved between birds.
the other reading: cumulative crow tool culture; contested social transmission - C-1392 Are the abilities that let us learn culture themselves learned or inherited?
booked: Open: the map keeps both readings.
the other reading: mills culturally inherited (Heyes 2012); genetic adaptation for cultural learning - C-1393 What counts as culture in animals?
booked: No definition is ruled. The map keeps the broad one (all socially learned skills) and the group-difference one side by side.
the other reading: method of exclusion: geographic variation not explained by genes or ecology (Whiten 1999 tradition); minimal: every socially learned skill (Schuppli & van Schaik 2019 count 195 and 122 in orangutans); mechanism-driven: five cognitive capacities for transmission (Danchin 2018); partition variance instead of categories (Laland & Janik 2006) - C-1394 Is building culture up over generations unique to humans?
booked: The map records it where studies show it in other animals (pigeons, bumblebees) and doesn't rule human culture unique.
the other reading: human culture appears unique in that it is cumulative (Lewis & Laland 2012); animal culture can be cumulative; bees learn behaviour too complex to innovate alone (Bridges 2024; Sasaki & Biro 2017) - C-1402 Do apes copy cultural behaviours, or reinvent them?
booked: The map keeps both: reinvented with others setting how common they are, or copied.
the other reading: zone of latent solutions (Tennie et al. 2020); copying social learning hypothesis (the predominant one, as Tennie et al. name it)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Social learning (imitation, emulation, teaching)
- Social network
- Tradition
- Cultural transmission (vertical, oblique, horizontal)
- Innovation
- Social learning strategies (selective biases)
Sits inside / holds (9)
- Ritual
- Painting
- Sculpture
- Humpback whale song
- Bird song culture
- DNA and genes
- Social groups and populations of animals (carriers: runsOn)
- Cave painting
- Kinship
Trades with (valence) (36)
- Ritual via sys:culture · Culture gain
- Play via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Bumblebee (Bombus) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Culture gain
- Painting via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Sculpture via sys:mental-representation · Culture gain
- Personality via sys:sensory-environment · Culture even
- DNA and genes via sys:dna · Culture gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture mixed
- Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Orca (killer whale, Orcinus orca) via sys:acoustic-wave · Culture gain
- Humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae) via sys:acoustic-wave · Culture gain
- Sperm whale (cachalot, Physeter macrocephalus) via sys:acoustic-wave · Culture gain
- New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Great tit (Parus major) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Bighorn sheep and moose (migration carriers) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Regent honeyeaters (a vocal culture in decline) via sys:acoustic-wave · Culture loss
- Homing pigeons (route chains) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Individual (asocial) learning via sys:mental-representation · Culture gain
- Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species (CMS) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Novel via sys:mental-representation · Culture gain
- Privacy via sys:human-society · Culture even
- Capuchin monkey (Cebus and Sapajus) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Institution (social) via sys:human-society · Culture gain
- Art history (the field) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture even
- World population (human population) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Ethnic group via sys:human-society · Culture gain
- Communication: the passing of messages between senders and receivers through a channel (and, on other readings, the making of meaning between them), and communication studies, the field that studies it via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Semantics: meaning in language (the meanings of words and sentences, sense and reference, how meanings combine, how they are held in minds and brains and shared in a community) and the field of linguistics and philosophy that studies it via sys:acoustic-wave · Culture gain
- Interpersonal communication via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Learning via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on) via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
- Social structure via sys:human-society · Culture gain
- Kinship via sys:human-society · Culture gain
- Social change via sys:sensory-environment · Culture mixed
- Intelligence via sys:social-network · Culture gain
- Child development via sys:sensory-environment · Culture gain
expressed by (10)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Navigation/Pathfinding
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
floor filled by (46)
- Ritual
- Play
- Painting
- Sculpture
- Architecture
- African elephant (genus Loxodonta: bush and forest elephants)
- Personality
- Social stratification
- Humpback whale song
- Bird song culture
- DNA and genes
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
- Social learning (imitation, emulation, teaching)
- Teaching
- Social network
- Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes)
- Cultural inheritance (dual inheritance)
- Cultural evolution
- Tradition
- White-crowned sparrow
- Orca (killer whale, Orcinus orca)
- Orangutan (Pongo)
- Humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae)
- Sperm whale (cachalot, Physeter macrocephalus)
- New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides)
- Social learning strategies (selective biases)
- Imitation
- Conformist transmission
- Social groups and populations of animals (carriers: runsOn)
- Great tit (Parus major)
- Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species (CMS)
- Privacy
- Bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops)
- Capuchin monkey (Cebus and Sapajus)
- Bumblebee colony
- World population (human population)
- Cave painting
- Ethnic group
- Communication: the passing of messages between senders and receivers through a channel (and, on other readings, the making of meaning between them), and communication studies, the field that studies it
- Interpersonal communication
- Learning
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
- Social structure
- Social change
- Child development
represents (1)
Kinds (8)
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
- Animal culture
- Chimpanzee cultural traditions
- Human culture
- Orca cultures (ecotype traditions and dialects)
- Human ethnolinguistic groups
- Bonobo traditions (group-specific behaviour)
- Orangutan cultures (population-specific tools and calls)
Notes published science
- Your mitochondria may run close to 50 C: in cultured human cells they measured more than 10 C hotter than the 38 C medium, and their respiratory enzymes worked best near 50 C. The authors themselves ask for independent checks (src:chretien-2018).
- Two trained great tits were enough: their way of opening a puzzle box spread to about three quarters of their neighbours, and a year later, with most of those birds dead and replaced, the new birds still opened it the same arbitrary way, because each bird copies whatever most others do (src:aplin-2015).
- Bumblebees learned from a trained bee to open a two-step box that no bee ever opened alone, even after 24 days of trying; the trainers could only get the first step going with a temporary reward, which the learners never needed (src:bridges-2024).
- Culture can write itself into genes: beluga whales on the two sides of Hudson Bay meet and mate every winter, yet their mothers' migration traditions have kept two separate sets of mitochondrial DNA since the ice age (src:whitehead-2019).
- Codes of ethics may not change what programmers do: when 105 experienced developers and 63 graduate students were given 11 real ethical dilemmas, half of them after reading the ACM's code of ethics, there was no statistically significant difference in any of their answers. Codes seem to work only when a workplace builds them into its culture and enforces them (src:hagendorff-2020-ethics quoting McNamara et al.; src:ncsu-2018-acm-code-study; src:mittelstadt-2019-principles).
- Most of the planet's microbes have never been grown in a lab: about 81% of all microbial cells on Earth (around 7.3 x 10^29) belong to genera with no cultured member, and a quarter belong to whole phyla nobody has cultured. The one big exception is the human body, where most of the microbes have been grown (src:lloyd-2018).
- Across 651 rituals from 74 cultures, the rarer a rite, the more intense it is (rho -0.40): daily prayers are calm, once-in-a-lifetime initiations are terrifying. Joy and terror turn out to be separate dials, not two ends of one (src:kapitany-2020).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
culture: from others' acts to a lineage's inherited ways (reader's view)
- L1: Others' acts, sounds, smells and products in a shared place: what a learner can observe or interact with
- L2: The learner's senses and attention turned on others: peering, watching, listening, often in a sensitive window
- L3: Social learning processes: local and stimulus enhancement, observational conditioning, emulation, imitation; teaching when the model helps
- L4: Selective biases decide what is adopted: conformity to the majority, payoff, whom to copy (social learning strategies)
- L5: The pool: socially learned variants held across a group's members and carried on its network ties
- L6: Traditions and their change: group-typical patterns that persist across generations, change by drift, sweeps and selection, and may accumulate
- L7: A second inheritance system acting back on its carriers: survival and breeding, routes and sites, population structure and genes
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The pool: information or behaviours shared within a group, held across its members and carried on its network ties
- L6: Traditions: group-typical behaviour that appears generation after generation, stable despite turnover, differing between neighbouring groups
- L6: Cultural evolution: variants change, sweep, are kept or abandoned by selective biases, and sometimes accumulate (the ratchet)
- L7: A second inheritance system on the shoulders of the genetic one, acting back on its carriers' survival, movements, population structure and genes
way in: Ecological change and human disturbance
- L1: Stable or variable surroundings: predators, food, other stimuli
- L2: Anthropogenic change as a challenge culture can answer or be lost to
way in: Genes: the first inheritance system
- L1: The primary genetic inheritance system culture is built on
- L2: Ancient associative learning (classical and operant conditioning) most social learning relies on
- L3: Genetic predispositions as a source of between-population differences that can mimic culture
way in: Guided by contact and opportunity (teaching)
- L1: The model's body and what it provides: a tandem-running leader, a meerkat's disabled prey, an orca pushing its calf up the beach
- L2: The naive learner's touch: the follower ant taps the leader's body
- L3: Teaching: the model changes its behaviour only for a naive observer, at a cost, and the learner learns faster
way in: New variants from individual learning (innovation)
- L1: Individual trial and error: reliable but costly
- L2: Innovations in response to novel challenges and opportunities
- L3: Reinnovation cued by others (zone of latent solutions) versus copied form
way in: Newcomers and naive young: residents' knowledge taken up
- L1: Naive young, dispersers and translocated animals arrive
- L2: Resident knowledge that transients cannot exploit unless they learn from residents
- L3: Newcomers learn traditional routes and sites from residents (French grunts)
- L4: The most frequent local variant adopted when first learning
way in: Others' acts and products, seen
- L1: Light from a demonstrator's actions and the products it leaves (opened boxes, tools, hammers left in the nest)
- L2: Peering: attentive, sustained close-range watching by immatures
- L3: Local and stimulus enhancement, emulation, imitation (fidelity rising from first to last)
- L4: Conformist transmission: the majority variant adopted disproportionately
way in: Smells and tastes carried from others (food preferences)
- L1: Odour-bearing particles from the mother's diet (in utero, in milk) and on other rats' breath, fur and whiskers
- L2: Smell of food on others
- L3: Food preference learned (strong preference for foods others ate)
way in: Songs, calls and codas heard (vocal learning)
- L1: Song in air or water: bird song, humpback song types
- L2: Hearing in a sensitive window: white-crowned sparrows learn in the first 100 days, only their own species' song
- L3: Vocal learning circuitry, evolved independently in humans, dolphins, bats and some birds
- L4: Conformity to the current song type
way in: Who meets whom: social network and density
- L1: Repeated foraging associations forming social networks
- L2: Ties predict acquisition: learning rate x12.0 per unit of association
- L3: Population density: at low density young males lack tutors
- L4: Turnover: just 40% of birds present the year before
way out: Moving along inherited routes and to traditional sites
- L1: Animals moving over the landscape surfing green waves of forage
- L6: Traditional routes, mating sites and migratory routes
- L7: Migration and site use as inherited knowledge
way out: Performing the learned behaviour where others can see it
- L1: The behaviour performed at the shared place: 58,975 solutions by 508 birds
- L6: The local tradition chosen (the majority variant)
way out: Shaping the carriers' genes and lineages
- L1: Mitochondrial and nuclear DNA patterns: low diversity, distinct haplotypes, population-specific genes
- L6: Song dialects and migration cultures segregating populations
- L7: Culturally mediated migration, assortative mating and hitchhiking
way out: Singing the current song type
- L1: Song in water across a population, heard by others
- L6: Current song type of the population
way out: Teaching: the model changes its behaviour for a naive learner
- L1: Contact and provision: slowed tandem run, disabled prey, a calf pushed up the beach
- L3: Changes its behaviour only in the presence of a naive observer, at a cost
- L6: A tradition held by an experienced animal
Who fills each layer
Sources (51) published science
Social learning in animals (Wikipedia, rev 1378620350, 2026-10-05) (behind its links)
Animal culture (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Schuppli C, van Schaik CP 2019. Animal cultures: how we've only seen the tip of the iceberg. Evol Hum Sci 1:e2. doi:10.1017/ehs.2019.1 (behind its links)
Sasaki T, Biro D 2017. Cumulative culture can emerge from collective intelligence in animal groups. Nat Commun 8:15049. doi:10.1038/ncomms15049 (behind its links)
Whitehead H, Laland KN, Rendell L, Thorogood R, Whiten A 2019. The reach of gene-culture coevolution in animals. Nat Commun 10:2405. doi:10.1038/s41467-019-10293-y (behind its links)
Whiten A 2017. A second inheritance system: the extension of biology through culture. Interface Focus 7:20160142. doi:10.1098/rsfs.2016.0142 (behind its links)
Ritual (Wikipedia, rev 1376020223, 2026-09-21) (behind its links)
d'Errico F et al. 2023. A 36,200-year-old carving from Grotte des Gorges, Amange, Jura, France. Sci Rep. doi:10.1038/s41598-023-39897-7 (behind its links)
Garland EC, Corkeron P, Noad MJ et al. 2025. Culture and conservation in baleen whales. Phil Trans R Soc B 380:20240133. doi:10.1098/rstb.2024.0133 (CC BY) (behind its links)
Bird vocalization (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Passmore S, Barth W, Greenhill SJ, Quinn K et al. 2023. Kinbank: a global database of kinship terminology. PLoS ONE 18:e0283218. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0283218 (behind its links)
Lewis HM, Laland KN 2012. Transmission fidelity is the key to the build-up of cumulative culture. Phil Trans R Soc B 367:2171-2180. doi:10.1098/rstb.2012.0119 (behind its links)
Rossano MJ (2012) The essential role of ritual in the transmission and reinforcement of social norms. Psychol Bull 138:529-549. doi:10.1037/a0027038 (behind its links)
Play (activity) (Wikipedia, rev 1381836613, 2026-10-25) (behind its links)
Perry S (2011) Social traditions and social learning in capuchin monkeys (Cebus). Phil Trans R Soc B 366. doi:10.1098/rstb.2010.0317 (behind its links)
Wikipedia: Institution (behind its links)
Art history (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01, revision 1381999302) (behind its links)
Lesthaeghe R (2014) The second demographic transition: a concise overview of its development. PNAS 111:18112-18115. doi:10.1073/pnas.1420441111 (behind its links)
Communication (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Semantics (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Interpersonal communication (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot, rev 1382229574; tagged by editors as partly AI-generated text) (behind its links)
African philosophy (encyclopedia article, WME snapshot) (behind its links)
Social structure (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Burkart JM, Schubiger MN, van Schaik CP (2017) The evolution of general intelligence. Behav Brain Sci 40:e195. doi:10.1017/S0140525X16000959 (PMID 27464851) (behind its links)
Wikipedia: Child development (behind its links)
Hersh et al. 2022, Evidence from sperm whale clans of symbolic marking in non-human cultures, PNAS, doi:10.1073/pnas.2201692119 (behind its links)
Samuni L, Wegdell F, Surbeck M (2020) Behavioural diversity of bonobo prey preference as a potential cultural trait. eLife. doi:10.7554/eLife.59191 (PMC7462605) (behind its links)
Heyes C 2012. Grist and mills: on the cultural origins of cultural learning. Phil Trans R Soc B 367:2181-2191. doi:10.1098/rstb.2012.0120 (behind its links)