← all systems · see it in The System
New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides)
The New Caledonian crow is a medium-sized member of the family Corvidae, native to New Caledonia. It eats a wide range of food, including many types of invertebrates, eggs, nestlings, small mammals, snails, nuts and seeds.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | around 5 Ma |
| born precision | approximate (one source) |
| boundary | One crow's body (black plumage, straight bill with upturned lower mandible, laterally placed eyes, feet) inside, with the tool it holds as a carried object; the forest, deadwood, plants, prey, nests, other crows and people outside. |
| nested level | A passerine bird of the genus Corvus, endemic to Grande Terre and Maré in New Caledonia, living in family groups within multi-family communities. |
| scale | organism |
Measures (29) published science
| body length | 40 cm |
| clutch size | 2-3 eggs |
| characteristic clock: breeding season (eggs laid September to November) | 1 per year |
| time to adult tool proficiency | 1-2 years |
| hooked tool construction time (wild, one record) | 59 s |
| probing bout with one hooked tool (wild, one record) | 690 s |
| share of time in tool-related behaviour | 3 (19 of foraging) % |
| foraging and feeding share of activity | 17 + 7 % |
| larvae needed per day | a few larvae to meet daily energy requirements |
| foraging speed, hooked vs non-hooked tools | several times faster with hooks ratio (qualitative in abstract) |
| safekeeping between extractions | 84 (of 176 extractions; 74 underfoot, 26 in holes) % |
| pandanus tools documented | 5550 tools, 21 sites, 3 designs count |
| share of hooked tools from Desmanthus virgatus (farmland site) | 85 (23 of 27) % |
| distance between sites with different hook materials | 7 km |
| Maré area and distance from Grande Terre | 642 km2; 110 km east km2; km |
| crows genotyped | 136 (9 microsatellites) birds |
| separation from closest Corvus relative | about 5 Ma |
| share of artificial-nest predation events | 62.9 (rats 22.9) % |
| compound tool elements (maximum) | 3 and 4 elements |
| compound tool makers | 4 of 8 naive crows |
| compound tool solving time | less than 4-6 minutes of interaction with the parts |
| metatool solvers on first attempt | 6 of 7 birds |
| wire-bending in successful retrievals (Betty) | 9 of 10 retrievals |
| larva-fishing site surveillance | 1797 camera hours, 111 days, 317 visits, 14+ crows count |
| tools left in larva burrows | 193 tools |
| lateralised tool users | 5 left, 5 right (of 10) birds |
| association logs, tracked crows | 177,102 logs; 33 crows over 19 days count |
| associative neurons vs ostrich | twice as many, in a brain 2.5 times smaller ratio (crow species) |
| Hawaiian crow tool users (comparison) | 81 of 104 (about 90% adults, 40% juveniles) birds |
Open contentions (3) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: see registry C-413 - C-1362 Do New Caledonian crows plan ahead?
booked: The map records the test showing crows choose tools for a specific future task, tagged as disputed.
the other reading: Boeckle 2020: crows plan for specific future tool use (pre-registered); de Mahy et al. 2021 comment 'New test, old problems' (title only read): the reading is disputed; Boeckle 2020 itself: planning in non-human animals 'remains contentious' - C-1363 Do New Caledonian crows have tool culture that builds up over time?
booked: The map records that tool designs vary by place and last, and leaves open whether they are passed on and improved between birds.
the other reading: Hunt & Gray 2003: three pandanus designs from one origin by cumulative change; Jelbert 2018: 'this claim is contentious, in part because these birds do not appear to imitate'; template matching shown as a capacity; St Clair 2016: the relative importance of individual and social learning remains unknown; local availability may constrain materials; Gruber 2022: the higher efficiency of stepped tools was inferred from complexity; Kenward 2005: naive juveniles make tools without adults
Cross-scale patterns seen here (17) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
Getting grubs out of holes in wood: woodpeckers do it with the bill; this crow, on an island without woodpeckers, does it with tools; the crow's straight bill sits nearest the woodpecker's among Corvus yet differs in depth and its upturned lower mandible - trade one property for another (structural)
Hooked tools are costlier to procure (search and manufacture) but several times more efficient; non-hooked tools are abundant and need no modification. Hook making is geographically restricted; non-hooked use is widespread: sites settle at different points of the trade - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
The crow carves its slice of the shared light field around the tool tip: the widest binocular overlap known in birds, the tip raised into it by a straight bill, so the tool and the space it works in are seen without blind spots - who opens the door (structural)
At the burrow the door is opened by the receiver: the larva's own defensive bite on the tool is what lets the crow draw it out; the crow prepares only the tip at the mandibles - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Hooks borrowed from plants (pandanus barbs, vine thorns) and hooks the crow carves into twig nodes: the job a plant's form does is also done by the crow's own craft - cephalization (partial)
Sensing gathers at the leading end where new input arrives: the tool tip is the end that meets prey first, and the visual field's binocular sector is turned onto it - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (partial)
From New Caledonian crow work, researchers predicted in 2011 that the Hawaiian crow should be a tool user; tests confirmed it in 2016 - outside-to-inside (partial)
A tool's size first met outside (physical templates rewarded) is later reproduced from inside, with no template present (mental template matching) - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
Tool use in two island crows, the New Caledonian crow and the distantly related Hawaiian crow, read by the authors as convergent; both share the corvid kit (caching action patterns, inherited tool dispositions) - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (partial)
A bilaterally symmetric bird picks a side: near-exclusive individual laterality in tool use (5 left, 5 right), and a population bias for left pandanus edges - templating (partial)
One design reused unchanged across crows at a site: pandanus tool shapes highly standardised at sites and persisting for decades - The carry (partial)
The wait: a young crow takes 1-2 years to reach adult tool proficiency and stays with its parents at least to the next breeding season - The Payment to Entropy (partial)
Each pass of a tool between extractions risks losing it (dropped tools are costly to recover at height); safekeeping (84% of extractions) cuts the toll. Form: material - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
The site sets the reference each crow makes to: birds within a site converge on the same material, 7 km away another material - nested ladder (surface)
Tool use, then a tool used to get a tool (metatool), then several tools combined (compound tool): each a stronger form of the last - same shape, opposite sign (surface)
The same lateralised tool use run with the side reversed: five crows left, five right - seed (surface)
A small change of tool shape (the hook) strongly changes energy intake, read as a driver of technological advancement
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (13) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Biodiversity via sys:social-learning · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) even
- Culture via sys:sensory-environment · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) mixed
- Crow family group via sys:sensory-environment · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) mixed
- Multi-family crow community via sys:sensory-environment · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) mixed
- Longhorn (cerambycid) beetle larvae in deadwood (e.g. Agrianome fairmairei) via sys:mechanical-contact · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) gain
- Candlenut tree (Aleurites moluccana) via sys:sensory-environment · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) gain
- Screw pines (Pandanus spp.) via sys:mechanical-contact · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) gain
- Desmanthus virgatus (introduced shrub) via sys:mechanical-contact · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) gain
- Lantana camara (introduced vine) via sys:mechanical-contact · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) gain
- Nesting forest birds of New Caledonia (their eggs) via sys:mechanical-contact · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) gain
- Invasive rats (Rattus rattus, R. exulans) via sys:mechanical-contact · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) mixed
- Tool via sys:mechanical-contact · New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Eye
- New Caledonian crow brain
- Bill (straight, upturned lower mandible)
- Egg predation in a New Caledonian rainforest (crow and invasive rats)
- Crow against wood-boring larva (extraction by the larva's own bite)
- Tool-using birds and other extractive foragers competing for embedded prey
Sits inside / holds (4)
- Birds (Aves; the surviving dinosaurs, and the Neornithes radiation)
- Crow family group
- Multi-family crow community
- Forests of New Caledonia
expressed by (14)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Sensing/Scanning
- Search/Foraging
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Risk-managed Exploration
- Overcome Barrier
- Precision Attack
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Proactive Defense
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (12)
- Culture
- Pallium (the dorsal telencephalon of vertebrates)
- Eye
- New Caledonian crow brain
- Bill (straight, upturned lower mandible)
- Stick tool
- Crow family group
- Multi-family crow community
- Forests of New Caledonia
- Longhorn (cerambycid) beetle larvae in deadwood (e.g. Agrianome fairmairei)
- Screw pines (Pandanus spp.)
- New Caledonian crow tool traditions
Kinds (4)
Notes published science
- The crow does not drag the grub out by force: it touches the sensitive spot by the grub's jaws, waits for the grub to bite the stick in self-defence, and pulls it out by its own bite (src:matsui-2016, src:wp:tool-use-by-animals).
- Two crow groups only about 7 km apart make their hook tools from different plants; one group mostly uses a shrub that people brought to the island after the mid-1800s, so its hook-making habit may be younger than about 150 years (src:st-clair-2016).
- Its eyes have the widest binocular overlap of any bird measured, and its unusually straight bill lifts the tool tip right into that overlap: the body is built around watching the tool (src:troscianko-2012).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The brain: a relatively large mesopallium, striatopallidal complex, septum and tegmentum; many associative pallial neurons; perineuronal glial clusters in the telencephalon
- L6: Meanings: mental representations of sub-goals and goals, out-of-sight tools, templates of tool size, the functional hook
- L6: Feelings and evaluations: optimism after tool use; hooked tools valued and kept safer; apparent frustration when a tool is dropped
- L7: Intention: choosing the right tool for a specific future task (contested as planning); compound tools built conditionally on where food is
the crow's island forest world through its senses (reader's view)
- L1: The island forest world its senses touch: deadwood and bark with hidden larvae, candlenut logs, pandanus leaves, forked stems of shrubs and vines, snails and rocks, eggs in nests, other crows and their tools and calls
- L2: The senses and the gripping bill: laterally placed eyes with the widest binocular overlap known in birds; a straight bill with an upturned, strengthened lower mandible holding the tool
- L4: Integration: the tool tip held in the binocular sector of the visual field, so the crow sees the tool and the space it works in
- L5: The brain: a relatively large mesopallium, striatopallidal complex, septum and tegmentum (association and motor learning); many associative pallial neurons
- L6: Meaning: mental representations of out-of-sight tools and goals; remembered templates of tool size; the hook prized over other features; hooked tools valued and kept safer
- L7: Intention and action back on the world: hooked stick tools, pandanus tools, compound tools and metatool sequences; tools chosen for a task set up ahead (contested as planning); tools kept safe; snails dropped; family life and site traditions
way in: Emotion (inner)
- L1: Events that change mood: using a tool; dropping one
- L6: Optimism after tool use (a positive affective state)
way in: Hearing (calls)
- L1: Calls of other crows: soft waa-waa or wak-wak, hoarse qua-qua
way in: Sight (tool-watching binocular vision)
- L1: Light from crevices, bark, the working tool and its tip, prey, nests and other crows
- L2: Eyes placed laterally, with a visual field whose binocular overlap is the largest known in birds
- L4: The tool tip raised into the binocular sector by the straight bill; shaft bending may centre the hook in view
way in: Thought (inner)
- L1: Where a thought comes from (contested; positions in C-413, none ruled); here: out-of-sight tools and goals kept in mind
- L6: Remembered templates guiding manufacture with no template in view
way in: Touch through the bill and the held tool
- L1: The tool against the larva in its burrow: the larva bites the tool tip in defence
- L2: The bill's strong precision grip on the tool (straight cutting edge, strengthened upturned lower mandible)
- L4: The tip held at the grub's mandibles until it bites, then the extraction
way out: Bill and feet on tools (make, use, keep)
- L1: Forked stems detached and crafted into hooks, strips torn from pandanus, tools probed into holes and trapped underfoot or stored in holes between uses
- L6: The design and material of the site: hooked tools from local stems, standardised pandanus shapes
- L7: A tool chosen or made for the task at hand; parts combined into a compound tool
way out: Calls
- L1: Soft waa-waa or wak-wak, hoarse qua-qua or waaaark
way out: Feeding the young
- L1: Insects and small prey fed to chicks on the nest and to begging juveniles
way out: Flight and carrying
- L1: Stick inserted into an object and both carried away
- L7: Carrying a stem to a perch to make a tool, then flying back to the foraging spot