← all systems · see it in The System
Tool
An object that can extend an individual's ability to modify features of the surrounding environment or accomplish a task; prototypically a solid, hand-operated, non-biological object with a single broad purpose (unlike machines or computers). In animal behaviour (Beck, as modified by Shumaker, Walkup and Beck): an unattached or manipulable environmental object, held and oriented by its user, used to alter more efficiently the form, position or condition of another object, another organism or the user itself.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | contested (C-3354): stone artefacts 3.3 Ma (Lomekwi 3), cut marks before 3.39 Myr (Dikika); perishable tools probably earlier |
| born precision | ~0.1 Myr |
| boundary | Inside: the tool body and its material (stone, wood, bone, metal), its working end (edge, tip, striking face) and its held end (handle, haft, the gripped face of a stone); in composite tools, the parts fastened together (microliths in a shaft). Outside: the user (hand, bill, trunk, paw) and the user's nervous system, the workpiece or target, the raw-material source, and the traditions that carry how it is made and used. On the line: the grip, where the user's force and the tool's vibrations cross, and the working edge, where the tool meets what it changes. |
| nested level | Built from a raw material shaped by percussion, pressure, casting or machining, sometimes from several parts (hafted, composite, multi-tools); used inside a user's action, where trained users take it into the body schema; one item in a toolkit and a technology, its design carried by traditions (cumulative culture). What a tool leaves (waste flakes, wear, discarded tools) becomes part of the archaeological record. |
| scale | technological |
Measures (26) published science
| probability of a viable flake per hit by learning condition | reverse engineering 0.03, imitation/emulation 0.04, basic teaching 0.06, gestural teaching 0.07, verbal teaching 0.10 probability |
| waste chips as a share of the original nodule (derived from Muller & Clarkson table 2 means) | pressure blade 16.9%, punch blade 19.5%, biface 21.5%, multiplatform 21.9%, bipolar 25.2%, discoidal 25.8%, Levallois 31.4%, prismatic blade 33.5% |
| tool use among bird families | at least 33 families |
| anvil rocks with visible use-wear (sea otters) | 77 of 421 (18.3%) rocks |
| DK quartzite flakes against expectation | 270% |
| oldest stone artefacts (Lomekwi 3) | 3.3 Myr ago |
| Oldowan stasis | 700,000 years |
| mussels pounded per year at one otter site | 1,916 to 5,748 mussels/yr |
| oldest Oldowan tools (Nyayanga) | ~2.9 Myr ago |
| vibration bandwidth read through a hand-held rod | about 10-1000 (first five modes) Hz |
| judged length of an unseen 60 cm rod | 56.5 (SEM 1.62) cm |
| characteristic clock: age at which nut cracking is learnt (Bossou chimpanzees) | by 7 years, often 3.5-5 |
| cutting edge per gram of core | bipolar 10.36, multiplatform 16.90, discoidal 17.69, biface 19.39, Levallois 21.83, prismatic blade 22.46, punch blade 22.95, pressure blade 25.91 (table; figure caption gives 25.49) mm/g |
| hammer strikes per nut in old age (Yo, Bossou) | +8 strikes per nut, +200% between 1999 and 2016 |
| procedural units, Neanderthal and Pleistocene modern human technologies | 9-13 (n = 6) and 8-15 (n = 11) procedural units |
| Acheulean first appearance | as early as 1.7 Myr ago |
| woodpecker finch prey taken with tools | up to half fraction |
| DK basalt flakes recovered against expectation | 60.2% (about 5.2 flakes per core against 8.67) |
| procedural units per manufacturing sequence | 3 (Lomekwi bipolar, ~3.3 Ma) to 19 (Sujala pressure blades, ~10 ka); 2-4 from 3.3 to 1.8 Ma; baseline without cumulative culture 6 procedural units |
| characteristic clock: knapping rate (viable flakes per minute, Oldowan-style learners) | 1.96 (reverse engineering) to 3.37 (verbal teaching) flakes/min |
| largest Lomekwi tool | 15 kg |
| flakes per core to exhaustion (Olduvai raw materials) | basalt 8.67, quartzite 9.60; experienced Oldowan knappers more than 70 flakes per core |
| training time to tool use (macaques) | rake: two weeks; complex pliers: 6-8 months time |
| oldest stone-tool cut marks (Dikika) | older than 3.39 (bracketed 3.42-3.24) Myr ago |
| per-hand-off yield: blanks mass over nodule mass (derived) | Levallois 68.6% to pressure blade 83.1% |
| aSMG tool-action region (conjunction) | 75 voxels |
Open contentions (8) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-520 Are 3.3-million-year-old stone flakes really tools made on purpose?
booked: The map reads them as early human tools, and keeps the point that monkeys make similar flakes by accident alongside.
the other reading: see research/CONTENTIONS.md C-520 - C-1054 What lets human culture build up over generations?
booked: The map follows the model finding that small gains in copying accuracy, and combining ideas, matter more than lone inventions, and keeps other drivers alongside.
the other reading: see research/CONTENTIONS.md C-1054 - C-3321 Are humans unique in how they use tools?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: other species' tool use explained by affordances and associative learning; aSMG may have arisen with Homo habilis or erectus (Oldowan or Acheulean); animals make tools too (crows, chimpanzees, elephants) - C-3323 Were early humans hunters or scavengers?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: "man the hunter" as the catalyst for hominin change (questioned); percussive tools for marrow and flakes to scavenge meat (Paige & Perreault, citing others); persistent hunting after ~2 Mya - C-3351 What counts as a tool?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Finn et al. 2009: an object carried or maintained for future use (the octopus's coconut shell); Jones & Kamil 1973: physical objects other than the body extending the animal's influence; Hauser 2000: an object used or modified to change the environment toward a target goal; protective gear debated; social tools (ant bridges, weaver ants) and bread-baiting herons disputed; Iriki & Taoka: the classical hand-held definition is too narrow (sensory and symbolic tools) - C-3352 Does a tool become part of the body?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: the mechanisms are not fully understood (Body schema article); it is often claimed but its computation was untested before Miller et al. 2023; whether a tool is then part of the user's cognitive system (compare C-400, the spider's web) - C-3354 Who made the first tools?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: first routine tool use before the chimpanzee-human divergence (widely assumed); organic tools in all probability before the Oldowan, not preserved; Oldowan from ~2.9 Ma (Nyayanga) as the first standardised industry - C-3355 Do only humans use tools to make tools?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: humans are considered the only species that uses tools to make other tools (body text); many animals use tools to make other tools (the same article's lead)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
- Metals (astronomy: elements heavier than helium)
- Rock
- Working end (edge, tip, striking face)
- Handle or haft
- Bronze against iron for tools and weapons
Sits inside / holds (5)
- Alloy
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
- Technology
- Archaeological record
Trades with (valence) (15)
- Engine via sys:mechanical-work · Tool gain
- Alloy via sys:matter · Tool gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:mechanical-work · Tool gain
- Language (human language) via sys:mental-representation · Tool gain
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) via sys:mental-representation · Tool gain
- Rock via sys:rock · Tool gain
- Human brain via sys:mechanical-contact · Tool even
- Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes) via sys:mechanical-work · Tool even
- Technology via sys:sensory-environment · Tool even
- New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides) via sys:mechanical-contact · Tool even
- Sea otter via sys:mechanical-work · Tool even
- Capuchin monkey (Cebus and Sapajus) via sys:mechanical-work · Tool even
- Machine via sys:mechanical-work · Tool gain
- Steel via sys:matter · Tool gain
- Stone Age via sys:rock · Tool even
expressed by (8)
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Frontier Outposts / Sensing Extension
- Overcome Barrier
- Ranged Attack
floor filled by (14)
- Alloy
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Language (human language)
- Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
- Metals (astronomy: elements heavier than helium)
- Rock
- Human brain
- Technology
- Simple machine
- Working end (edge, tip, striking face)
- Handle or haft
- Anvil (portable, chest, emergent)
- Human hand
- Workpiece
represents (1)
Kinds (12)
- Stone tool industries (Oldowan to microliths)
- Machine tools
- Hand tool
- Multi-tool
- Composite (hafted) tool
- Animal tool (non-human tool use)
- Sensory and measuring tool
- Weapon
- Cutting and edge tools
- Moving and force-concentrating tools
- Fastening tools
- Shaping tools (molds, jigs, trowels)
Notes published science
- When you tap something with a stick, the stick itself feels nothing, but its vibrations carry a pattern that says where it was hit, and your brain locates the hit on the stick with the same arithmetic it uses for touches on your arm: blindfolded people holding a 60 cm rod they had never seen judged its tip at about 56.5 cm (src:miller-2023-trilateration).
- For about 1.5 million years after the first stone tools, making one took only 2-4 steps; tools only beat the 6-step ceiling of a chimpanzee's termite probe after about 600,000 years ago, and by 10,000 years ago a Finnish pressure-blade technology took 19 steps (src:paige-perreault-2024).
- Sea otters use the same shoreline rocks as anvils so often that 77 of 421 rocks at one California site carry visible wear and piles of mussel shells all broken the same way: an otter "archaeological site" that could outlast the otters (src:haslam-2019-otters).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: The tool's form at work: wedge, lever, percussor, anvil, probe; force concentrated on a narrow face, multiplied by leverage, held still by an anvil, or reach extended. Grip, workpiece, making, material and upkeep meet here.
- L5: Hand and tool as one effector in the user's body schema: intraparietal bimodal neurons extend their visual fields along a rake after training, touch on a tool is localised as on a limb, and in humans the left anterior supramarginal gyrus is devoted to tool actions. Held in the user's brain.
- L6: The know-how and design: the operational sequence (chaîne opératoire) from raw material to use and abandonment, chained procedural units, held in makers and passed on in traditions
- L7: The task done: the form, position or condition of another object, organism or the user changed, toward a goal the user holds
the tool as archaeologists, anthropologists and engineers describe it: the world at its two ends, up to the task done (reader's view)
- L1: The world at the tool's two ends: the user's hand (or bill, trunk, paw), the target or workpiece (shell, hide, carcass, wood, metal), and the raw material it is made from
- L2: The contact surfaces: the working end (edge, tip, striking face) and the held end (handle, haft, gripped face)
- L3: The body and its material: a rigid piece of hard, brittle, silica-rich stone, bone, wood or metal, sometimes several parts hafted together; it carries force forward and vibration back
- L4: The mechanics: wedge, lever, percussor, anvil, probe (force concentrated, multiplied, held, or reach extended)
- L5: Incorporation: the hand-and-tool as one effector in the user's body schema and its tool-use areas
- L6: Know-how and design: the operational sequence from raw material to use and discard, chained procedural units, passed on by teaching and held in traditions
- L7: Purpose: the form, position or condition of another object, organism or the user changed for a goal the user holds
way in: Contact read back (where the tool struck, carried as vibration to the hand)
- L1: A contact somewhere along the tool
- L2: Vibration modes whose relative weights mark the hit location (a feature space isomorphic with the tool)
- L3: The hand's mechanoreceptors take the vibrations the tool cannot sense itself
- L4: Somatosensory cortex localises the touch on the tool by trilateration from handle and tip, as on a limb
way in: Grip (the user's hand, bill, trunk or paw: force and motion in)
- L1: The user holding, orienting and moving the tool (hand, bill, trunk, paw)
- L2: The held end: handle, haft, or the gripped face of a stone, taken in forceful pinch and power grips
- L3: The rigid body carrying the push, blow or twist to the working end (as torque in a screwdriver)
way in: Know-how in (demonstration, gesture and words from other makers)
- L1: A skilled maker's demonstration, gestures and words; the fast strike hides the subtle parts
- L2: The learner's sight and hearing take in products, actions, gestures or speech (five mechanisms tested)
- L3: Teaching and language carry what observation misses (platform edge and angle)
- L4: Trial and error in the learner's hands
- L5: Skill held in the hand and brain: decades for full control
way in: Making (the maker's blows and pressure that give it its form)
- L1: A blow from a hammerstone (or soft hammer, punch, pressure tool) on the core
- L2: The striking platform: its edge and angle decide whether a flake comes
- L3: Conchoidal fracture: a flake detaches and leaves the edge (lithic reduction)
way in: Raw material (stone, wood, bone, copper, bronze, iron)
- L1: The source: river cobbles, outcrops, native copper
- L2: The material chosen: hard, brittle, silica-rich stone; later copper-tin alloys
- L3: What the material allows: sharpness, durability, how it fractures, how many flakes a core yields
way in: Upkeep (the edge's own state: dulling, sharpening, retouch)
- L1: The edge deformed by use and sharpened
- L2: Retouch scars on the edge
- L3: A smaller, renewed tool; wide flakes can be renewed more often
way in: Workpiece (what the tool acts on, pushing back: shell, hide, bone, wood, metal)
- L1: The target: hard-shelled food, hide, carcass, wood, a metal blank
- L2: The working end: edge, tip or striking face (a wedge producing shear along a narrow face)
- L3: Hardness against hardness at the edge: a softer edge dulls
way out: Discard into the archaeological record
- L1: Tools and flakes left where they were made: refits
- L6: The operational sequence ends in abandonment
way out: Tools built into the surroundings (the human-made niche)
- L1: Tools as part of the environment people then live in
- L7: Habitats improved by making and using tools
way out: Waste (debitage, chips, rejected rough-outs)
- L1: Piles of waste flakes and rejects on the ground
- L3: Fracture detaches waste flakes (in pressure flaking a narrow flake off the edge)
- L4: Reduction removes mass to make the form; experts waste less
way out: Wear (dulled edges, use-wear on tools and anvils)
- L1: Use-wear visible on anvil rocks
- L2: The edge dulled by use
- L4: Repeated contact at the working surface
way out: What the hand feels back (vibration and resistance through the tool)
- L1: The user's hand (Human touch and proprioception channels)
- L2: Vibration modes at the handle
- L5: The body schema expects the tool's vibrations
way out: Work on the workpiece (cut, pound, pry, probe, pierce)
- L1: The target changed: flesh cut from bone, marrow opened
- L2: The edge meets the target: shear along a narrow face
- L4: The form at work: wedge, lever, percussor
- L7: The task chosen by the user