← all systems · see it in The System
Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
Culture is the 'information capable of affecting individuals' behavior that they acquire from other members of their species through teaching, imitation and other forms of social transmission'. Cumulative cultural evolution is a behavioural change, socially transferred, that improves performance and is repeated over time so that improvements build sequentially (the ratchet effect: modifications accumulate without reverting back to prior, less effective states).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the pool of socially learned variants (skills, tools, routes, songs, words, norms) held by a population's carriers and in their artefacts and records, plus the copying, teaching and biased-adoption processes that pass them on and keep improvements (the ratchet). Outside: the carriers' genomes and bodies (which constrain and are reshaped by it), individual (asocial) learning that feeds it new variants, the physical environment it adapts to and alters, and other populations it meets by contact. |
| nested level | A population-level inheritance system running on human (and, in its non-cumulative forms, animal) carriers: built from learners, teachers and models in social groups; carried by speech, gesture, demonstration, artefacts and writing; coevolving with the human gene pool. Animal traditions (chimpanzee tools, orca dialects, bird song, fish routes) are culture; only humans show open-ended accumulation, and pigeons and zebra finch song meet all four core criteria for a single trait. |
| scale | social |
Measures (23) published science
| characteristic clock: Oldowan stasis (period with little change) | about 700,000 years |
| characteristic clock: cultural vs genetic transmission | new behaviours learned in 'days and hours rather than the many years of reproduction' qualitative |
| characteristic clock: first-language acquisition in carriers | words at 12-18 months; near-adult speech from about 3-5 years age |
| characteristic clock: song-learning window (white-crowned sparrow) | first 100 days of life |
| earliest stone tools (Lomekwi) | 3.3 million years ago |
| earliest Oldowan tools (Nyayanga) | about 2.9 million years ago |
| earliest Acheulean | as early as 1.7 million years ago |
| extended juvenile social learning begins | as much as 2 million years ago |
| stepwise, culturally conservative tool change until | 50,000-40,000 years ago |
| Upper Palaeolithic blade industries | 50,000-10,000 years ago |
| oldest definitive fire making | about 400,000 years ago |
| lactase persistence selection coefficient (Scandinavian population) | 0.09-0.19 per generation |
| lactase production stopped after weaning everywhere until | around 7,500 years ago |
| digestibility gain of cooked carbohydrates | about 30 % |
| chewing time, US children vs chimpanzees | 7-8% of the day (1.68-1.92 h) vs more than 6 h hours per day |
| chimpanzee behaviours habitual in some communities, absent in others | 39 of 65 behaviour categories |
| chimpanzee observation pooled (Whiten et al. 1999) | 151 years |
| Oceanic societies compared (Kline & Boyd) | 10 societies |
| kelp gull lesions on whales, spread of a new foraging tradition | 2% to 99% (1974-2011) frequency |
| mtDNA nucleotide diversity in matrilineal whales vs other whales | about ten times lower ratio |
| cost of teaching: tandem-running leader ant speed | about 1/4 of solo speed fraction |
| gain from teaching: orca juveniles master stranding | more than a year earlier than non-taught peers years |
| living languages | around 7,500 languages |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (9) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- outside-to-inside (structural)
Reversed: digestion moves out of the body into culture. 'Marinating emulates the action of the stomach ... Food enters the body effectively partly digested', and the gut, teeth and jaw shrink. - same toolkit, independent builds (structural)
Vocal learning 'has evolved independently through evolutionary convergence' (humans, dolphins, bats, some birds); traditions recur in chimpanzees, orcas, rats, crows, fish. - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
Sign reversed: isolation lowers complexity. 'Larger populations will generate more complex cultural adaptations than smaller, isolated ones'; small populations lose complex traits to copying error. - borrowed-then-held (partial)
'Once culture became adaptive, genetic selection caused a refinement of the cognitive architecture that stores and transmits cultural information': a job first done socially is later partly held in the genome. - holding / entrainment (partial)
A cultural trait setting its carriers' count: prestige bias favours models who forgo reproduction (the demographic transition), as hypothesis. - same role, different builds (partial)
The four core criteria of cumulative culture are met by homing pigeons (route chains) and zebra finch song as well as by humans, with very different machinery; non-human cases reach 'a single trait up to a single, fixed optimum'. - seed (partial)
Open-ended accumulation (recombination across lineages, exaptation, niche construction) seen only in humans; discrete units ('memes') are debated, DIT does not assume replicators are needed. - who opens the door (partial)
Genes install the receivers: 'Genes may also endow individuals with certain types of transmission bias', the filters that decide which variant a learner takes in. - red-queen (surface)
Memes 'could well be in conflict with their biological host's genetic interests'; DIT models conflicts between cultural and genetic evolution (Boyd & Richerson 1985).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (24) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Social contagion via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Language (human language) via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- DNA and genes via sys:dna · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Primate social group via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Fire via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Religion via sys:electromagnetic-field · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Grammar (the structure of a language, as linguistics describes it) via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions) via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Internet protocol suite (TCP/IP): the layered datagram protocols every host and router runs, the RFC record that specifies them, and the community that keeps them via sys:written-record · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it) via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Music via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Dance via sys:electromagnetic-field · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Story (narrative) via sys:cumulative-culture · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Visual art (drawing, painting, sculpture) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Education via sys:sensory-environment · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring) via sys:cumulative-culture · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Evolution (biological evolution across time) via sys:ecosystem · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Human culture via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Human cultures (anthropology) via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Poetry via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
- Tool via sys:mental-representation · Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (7)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- Social learning (imitation, emulation, teaching)
- Teaching
- Stone tool industries (Oldowan to microliths)
- Competition among cultural variants for learners
- Competition between a cultural trait and genetic fitness for carriers' reproduction
Sits inside / holds (14)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Language (human language)
- Earth
- Primate social group
- Religion
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Money of account (the unit of account: number applied to exchange)
- Positional (place-value) notation with zero
- Music
- Dance
- Story (narrative)
- Visual art (drawing, painting, sculpture)
- Book
- Tool
expressed by (21)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Search/Foraging
- Navigation/Pathfinding
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Intrinsic Motivation / Curiosity-Driven Sampling
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Offline Simulation & Replay-Guided Planning
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (19)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Language (human language)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Grammar (the structure of a language, as linguistics describes it)
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)
- Internet protocol suite (TCP/IP): the layered datagram protocols every host and router runs, the RFC record that specifies them, and the community that keeps them
- Positional (place-value) notation with zero
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Music
- City
- Dance
- Story (narrative)
- Visual art (drawing, painting, sculpture)
- Civilization
- Human culture
- Human cultures (anthropology)
- Culture
- Poetry
- Tool
Kinds (2)
wired (1)
Notes published science
- Pigeons ratchet: in homing-pigeon replacement chains, routes got shorter across 'generations' of birds, one of only two non-human cases meeting all four criteria of cumulative culture (Sasaki & Biro 2017).
- Culture moved digestion outside the body: cooking and marinating 'emulate the action of the stomach', and humans now chew 1.7-1.9 h a day versus more than 6 h for chimpanzees.
- Oldowan tools stayed largely unchanged for about 700,000 years; in knapping chains, imitation did not help, teaching did, and language helped most (Morgan et al. 2015).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
food energy (processing and cooking as culture)
- L1: Food: plants, meat, seeds; later milk and crops
- L2: Food processing as tradition: pounding, marinating, cooking (cooked carbohydrates about 30% more digestible)
- L3: Smaller digestive organs, teeth and jaws; chewing 7-8% of the day vs more than 6 hours in chimpanzees
- L4: Energy and time freed for brain tissue and for hunting
genes (gene-culture coevolution)
- L1: Genes encode the information needed to form the human brain and constrain its ability to acquire and store culture
- L2: Genetic predispositions endow transmission biases (content biases from genetic preferences for sugary or fatty foods)
- L3: Culture-set selection: dairying selects lactase persistence (selection coefficient 0.09-0.19); agriculture selects starch digestion
- L4: Refinement of the cognitive architecture that stores and transmits cultural information; brain enlargement in feedback with social learning
light: watching demonstrations, artefacts and marks
- L1: Light from a demonstrating model, an artefact or a mark
- L2: Observation of a model's action and its result (naive meerkats used the method shown by the demonstrator)
- L3: Imitation (copying the method toward a goal) vs emulation; low-fidelity for knapping without teaching (Morgan et al. 2015)
- L4: Artefacts as held culture: learnt instructions (i-culture) resulting in material artefacts (m-culture) such as wheels; stone-tool modes
- L5: Marks and writing: engravings, cave scenes, cuneiform; printed media pass ideas with substantially less mutation
mental representation: beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions
- L5: Transmission biases decide what is adopted: content bias, model-based (prestige, skill, success, similarity) and frequency-dependent (conformity, rarity) biases
- L6: Social learning takes a variant in: imitation (most common in animals), emulation, teaching (highest fidelity); vertical, oblique and horizontal transmission
- L7: Population-level traditions: selection of variants, drift (strongest in small populations), conformity keeping between-group variation, cultural group selection
speech and calls between model and learner (sound)
- L1: Speech and calls as sound between model and learner: the verbal channel of "verbal, visual, or written methods of teaching"
- L2: The learner's ear decodes the model's speech; children acquire the language around them
- L4: Variants build on variants: functional dependence, recombination across lineages, exaptation (Mesoudi & Thornton's extended criteria)
written and printed record (marks, script, print)
- L1: Marks and writing kept outside the body: engravings, cave scenes, cuneiform, printed media
- L3: Printed media pass ideas "with substantially less mutation" than speech
- L6: Printing "rapidly increased the speed of communication and became the main spring of cultural evolution"
Who fills each layer
- L3: Science (as a human social and cultural system), Internet protocol suite (TCP/IP): the layered datagram protocols every host and router runs, the RFC record that specifies them, and the community that keeps them
- L5: Social contagion
- L6: Corpus Juris Civilis (Justinian's codification: Codex, Digest, Institutes, Novels), Domesticated germline (crop and livestock lines held and propagated by people), Money of account (the unit of account: number applied to exchange), Glossators' reading method (gloss and commentary), Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)