EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)

Making variants without aiming at an answer, and keeping the ones that survive or work. Mutation plus selection across generations; inside one system, a blind repertoire filtered by what the world keeps (V(D)J receptors and clonal selection, trial and error, genetic algorithms).

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

akaJerry's name for it (2026-10-25 17:24): "I Throw Mud at the Wall, See What Sticks, and Look for the Patterns in It."
aliasesBlind Variation + Differential Survival (BVSR)
boundaryInside: the rule itself, three clauses: make variants without aiming at an answer, keep the ones that survive or work, hold what was kept. Outside: every medium that carries the variants (sequences, receptors, conjectures, cases, quantum states) and the systems it unpacks into. Campbell: 'a general model for quasiteleological processes for which organic evolution is but one instance'. No shell is sourced for the rule itself.
nested levelSits on the time pole right above the Big Bang (ORIGINATES_IN real:big-bang). Below life the filter is persistence (Wong et al.'s static and dynamic persistence; quantum Darwinism's pointer states); with copying it becomes evolution (sys:rna, seed:genetic-code). Built (graph) from Generation, Quality Control and Trail-Marking. Reflections nest inside it: seed:vdj-recombination with clonal selection, seed:scientific-method, seed:precedent.
scalefield

Measures (9) published science

characteristic clock: one variation-selection cycle (one copying generation in the copying form)set by the carrier (one generation; no single figure)
characteristic clock: in vitro self-replicating ribozyme setabout 1 hour per replication
peppered moth: time for dark moths to take over industrial Manchesterabout 50 (nearly all moths dark) years from the first dark moth caught
error threshold without error-correction enzymesabout 100 base pairs (maximum replicating molecule)
distinct antibody molecules a human can produce without antigenmore than 1 trillion molecules
E. coli gene-deletion screen: effect on growth80% negative, 20% positive fraction of mutations
mineral species count (persistence form)about 12 before the Solar System; 5413 officially recognized (November 2018) species
baryon excess that survived annihilationone part in 30 million (Big Bang article) vs about 1 in 1,630,000,000 (Baryogenesis article); 'one excess quark per billion quark-antiquark pairs' ratio
Campbell, Blind variation and selective retention in creative thought as in other knowledge processes1960, Psychological Review 67(6):380-400, doi:10.1037/h0040373 date of naming

Partners and parts published science

Sits inside / holds (5)

Trades with (valence) (9)

expressed by (1)

floor filled by (15)

originates in (1)

represents (1)

seed within (3)

Kinds (11)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

cell lineage: lymphocyte clones selected by antigen

  1. L1: 'Each lymphocyte bears a single type of receptor with a unique specificity (generated by V(D)J recombination)'
  2. L3: 'Receptor occupation is required for cell activation'; 'a specific antigen activates (i.e. selects) only its counter-specific cell'
  3. L4: The activated cell multiplies, 'producing identical clones'; effector cells 'bear receptors of identical specificity as the parent cell'
  4. L5: 'Those lymphocytes bearing receptors for self molecules ... are destroyed at an early stage'

electromagnetic field: the photon environment as witness to pointer states

  1. L1: 'The sea of photons in which all quantum systems are immersed'
  2. L2: Decoherence: interactions lead to 'the manifestation of the quantum system in a particular basis dictated by the nature of the interaction'
  3. L3: Einselection: 'the many possible quantum states are selected against in favor of a stable pointer state'
  4. L4: 'The recording of many redundant copies of information regarding its pointer states' in the environment
  5. L6: 'Environment as a Witness': the information 'is available to numerous observers able to achieve consensual agreement', giving 'the potential for objective knowledge'

mental representation: conjectures and ideas varied and refuted

  1. L1: Creative ideas as variants: Campbell (1960) drew 'a parallel between genetic evolution and the blind variation and selective retention of creative ideas'
  2. L4: Conjectures assembled with consequences: 'making conjectures (hypothetical explanations), predicting the logical consequences of hypothesis, then carrying out experiments'
  3. L5: Refutation as selective elimination: Popper's 'conjectures (blind variation) followed by the refutation (selective elimination) of those conjectures that are empirically falsified'; Ashby's recursive meta-levels of trial and error
  4. L7: Socio-cultural evolution (Campbell 1965): cultural variants, transmission mechanisms and selective pressures; 'information capable of affecting individuals' behavior that they acquire from other members of their species'

mineral surfaces: mineral species kept or lost by stability

  1. L1: About a dozen 'ur-minerals' in interstellar grains before the Solar System; diamond 'probably the first mineral to form'
  2. L3: Persistence filter: some mineral-forming processes no longer occur, producing minerals 'that are unstable on Earth in its oxidized state'; a lost mineral 'could emerge again if suitable environmental conditions were re-established'
  3. L4: Species count rising: about 12 before the Solar System, about 250, about 1500, then 5413 officially recognized species (November 2018), over two-thirds owing to life

sequential information: variants as sequences under copying and selection

  1. L1: Strings of base pairs or 'digits' whose 'order is a code that directs how the molecule interacts with its environment'
  2. L2: Variation: 'each digit has a certain probability of being replaced by some other digit'; in lymphocytes V, D and J are rearranged 'in a nearly random fashion' and TdT adds N nucleotides, 'mostly random'
  3. L3: Selection at the sequence: different replication outputs raise or lower frequency; an out-of-frame V(D)J product means 'the cell will not survive to maturity'
  4. L4: Retention: 'knowledge of well-adapted genomes accumulates simply by virtue of them being able to reproduce'; a fit neighbourhood of sequences forms a quasispecies that supports longer sequences
  5. L5: Limits on the rule: without error-correction enzymes the maximum replicating molecule is about 100 base pairs (Eigen 1971); mutation itself is biased, 'non-random in a way that benefits the plant'

written record: case law kept and overruled under stare decisis

  1. L1: A judicial decision 'that serves as an authority for courts when deciding subsequent identical or similar cases'; past decisions serve as case law
  2. L3: Stare decisis: 'Vertical stare decisis binds lower courts to strictly follow the decisions of higher courts within the same jurisdiction'
  3. L5: Overruling: a decision is overruled 'if the same or higher courts ... found the principles underpinning the previous decision erroneous in law'; the US Supreme Court needs a 'special justification'

Sources (21) published science

Donald T. Campbell (Wikipedia via Wikimedia Enterprise, rev 1372252886)
Natural selection (Wikipedia via Wikimedia Enterprise, rev 1381515893) (behind its links)
RNA world (Wikipedia, rev 1378837125, 2026-10-06) (behind its links)
Error threshold (evolution) (Wikipedia, rev 1177192156, 2023-09-26) (behind its links)
Adaptive immune system (Wikipedia, rev 1378627319, 2026-10-05) (behind its links)
Mutation (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Mineral evolution (Wikipedia, rev 1378722004, via Wikimedia Enterprise; lead and stage 6-8 sections read) (behind its links)
Baryogenesis (Wikipedia, rev 1381407459, 2026-10-22) (behind its links)
Cultural evolution (Wikipedia, rev 1378620452, 2026-10-05) (behind its links)
Clonal selection (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Meiosis (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Universal Darwinism (Wikipedia via Wikimedia Enterprise, rev 1366843201, 2026-07-30; article flagged "more citations needed") (behind its links)
Wong, Cleland, Arend, Bartlett, Cleaves, Demarest, Prabhu, Lunine & Hazen 2023, On the roles of function and selection in evolving systems, PNAS 120(43) e2310223120, doi:10.1073/pnas.2310223120 (CC BY 4.0; abstract read via the Caltech Authors record) (behind its links)
Self-replication (Wikipedia via Wikimedia Enterprise, rev 1346493019) (behind its links)
Trial and error (Wikipedia via Wikimedia Enterprise, rev 1379606848) (behind its links)
Quantum Darwinism (Wikipedia via Wikimedia Enterprise, rev 1372775360, 2026-09-02) (behind its links)
Precedent (Wikipedia, rev 1381027500, 2026-10-19, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Sequence space (evolution) (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Genetic code (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
V(D)J recombination (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Scientific method (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)