← all systems · see it in The System
Hypercycle of RNA replicators
A hypercycle is an abstract model of organization of self-replicating molecules connected in a cyclic, autocatalytic manner: the information storing system (possibly RNA) produces an enzyme, which catalyzes the formation of another information system, in sequence until the product of the last aids in the formation of the first information system.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| asymmetry | Symmetric by construction (each member gives and gets one catalytic link); in the translation version the protein exists only through its template, so it depends wholly on the nucleic acid. Rate differences between links (k_i,i-1) are model parameters with no values in the sources read. |
| boundary | Inside: the closed catalytic loop, each member catalysing the formation of its successor (E_n catalysing I_1), plus each member's own self-replication, and the relative abundances the loop controls. Outside: the members' own chemistry (RNA, ribozymes, peptides), the monomer supply and dilution flux of the solution, rival cycles, parasitic branches, and any later membrane. |
| cheater | Parasitic branches: mutants recognised by a member that do not catalyse the next formation and so use the system for their own replication; Maynard Smith held that selection favours them. In a 2022 RNA experiment multiple host and parasite lineages coexisted in a replicator network. |
| drive | driven |
| enforcement | shared-fate |
| flips when | A mutant enters that is better recognised but does not better catalyse the next formation (a parasitic branch); the cycle reaches five or more members and one dies out stochastically; or the catalyst becomes a general polymerase, which 'leads to the death of the system'. |
| joint output | A single, integrated entity of several short information carriers whose combined information exceeds what one carrier below the ~100-base enzyme-free limit can hold, plus once-for-ever selection of one code and one chirality (model). |
| knockout | Without the secondary loop provided by catalysis, I chains would compete and select against each other instead of cooperating; and if one species dies out by stochastic events it breaks the positive feedback loop that sustains the hypercycle, and the extinction of the hypercycle then follows (src:wp:hypercycle-chemistry; model statements). |
| nested level | Built from short self-replicating information carriers (RNA, each below the ~100-base enzyme-free limit), in Eigen's original coupled to translated polypeptides; embedded in a prebiotic solution held at constant total concentration by a dilution flux. A proposed stage of abiogenesis, below the first fold (epoch 5): 'an intermediate state of self-organization, but not the final solution'. |
| obligate | obligate |
| partners | sys:rna, sys:rna, sys:protein |
| recurrence | Continuous in the model: every replication of each member is catalysed by its predecessor, round a closed loop, at equilibrium or with oscillating concentrations. Repeated rounds are observed in experiments (Mizuuchi et al., Vaidya et al.), but of other network kinds, not a hypercycle. |
| regime | Start: proposed from 1967; members selected from a quasispecies once a first primitive polymerase emerges and catalysed replication exceeds uncatalysed. End: extinction when a member is lost; displacement is unlikely (once-for-ever selection); or fusion, when a compartment allows genome integration, linking members into a single chain, the precursor of a genome, where the partnership ends as one unit. |
| saturation | Fewer than five members stay stable (Hofbauer and Sigmund), and a hypercycle of up to four is too small to cross the information threshold; in spiral-wave models rotation slows as members are added. |
| scale | molecular |
| separability | Medium: members are genetically non-identical sequences, each its own replicator with its own formation and hydrolysis, but drawn from one quasispecies ('a population of similar sequences') and all RNA in the ribozyme reading. In the translation version, polynucleotide and polypeptide are different kinds. No dissociation time is given. |
Measures (15) published science
| hypercycle introduced in ODE form (Eigen) | 1967 year |
| maximum chain length correctly reproduced in enzyme-free systems | about 100 bases |
| maximum size of a replicating molecule without error correction enzymes | about 100 base pairs |
| ribozyme mutation rate (relaxed error threshold, Kun et al. 2005) | on the order of 0.001 per base pair per replication |
| sequence length allowed by the relaxed error threshold | of the order of 7-8 thousand base pairs |
| stable hypercycle size (Hofbauer and Sigmund) | fewer than five members |
| RNA catalytic properties discovered | 1982 year |
| partial RNA polymerase ribozyme (2001): own length / chain it polymerised | 200 / about 14 nucleotides |
| smallest reported RNA-dependent polymerase ribozyme | 165 nucleotides |
| RNA ligase catalytic domain | 93 nucleotides |
| acyltransferase ribozyme | 82 nucleotides |
| smallest ribozyme, a transaminoacylator (2013) | 5 nucleotides |
| first experimental cooperative network among self-assembling ribozyme fragments | 2012 year |
| replicator network evolved from one RNA replicator (Mizuuchi et al. 2022) | 5 types of RNA |
| per-round incubation in water-in-oil droplets (Mizuuchi et al.) | 37 C for 5 hours, then diluted to one-fifth per round |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (1) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Hypercycle of RNA replicators. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- who opens the door (structural)
a port installed ahead of time: the specific polymerase or enhancer
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (7) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Sequential information (the order of units along a linear polymer) via sys:sequential-information · Hypercycle of RNA replicators mixed
- RNA via sys:sequential-information · Hypercycle of RNA replicators gain
- Ribozyme via sys:sequential-information · Hypercycle of RNA replicators gain
- Protein via sys:sequential-information · Hypercycle of RNA replicators gain
- Nucleotide via sys:aqueous-solution · Hypercycle of RNA replicators gain
- Empty or low-phospholipid vesicle (losing taker) via sys:aqueous-solution · Hypercycle of RNA replicators mixed
- Parasitic branch (parasitic RNA) via sys:sequential-information · Hypercycle of RNA replicators loss
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
- RNA
- Ribozyme
- Protein
- Competition between hypercycles (once-for-ever selection)
- Parasitic branches on a hypercycle
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (6)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Templating / Standardization
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Resource Denial/Attrition
floor filled by (1)
formed against (1)
same pair (1)
slides to (2)
Notes published science
- Once-for-ever selection: in the model the first hypercycle to win cannot be displaced even by a better one, which the source offers as the reason there is one genetic code and one chirality. A lock-in that froze a convention for all later life.
- The size trap: below ~100 bases one replicator cannot hold enough information, but a cycle of five or more members falls apart when one dies out, and four is too few. The partnership's own stability caps its joint output.
- Space rescues it: in cellular-automaton models the cycle forms rotating spiral waves (scroll waves in 3D) that survive parasites away from the core, and in one model the travelling waves are made by the parasites and replicases together.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
copying errors against stored information (sequential information: error threshold)
- L1: Molecules are strings of digits whose order is a code; in replication each digit has some probability of being replaced
- L3: A sequence whose neighbours are also fit forms a quasispecies and can support longer lengths than a fit sequence with few fit neighbours
- L5: The error threshold (Eigen 1971): a limit on the number of base pairs a self-replicating molecule may have before mutation destroys the information in later generations
- L6: Eigen's paradox: the threshold limits self-replicators to perhaps a few hundred digits, yet life needs much longer molecules; the hypercycle was proposed as a solution
covalent joining of RNA fragments (electromagnetic field: covalent chemistry)
- L1: The phosphodiester linkage C-O-PO2-O-C that joins nucleotides into an RNA strand, with a 5' phosphate end and a 3' hydroxyl end
- L2: Ribozymes' most common activities are cleavage or ligation of RNA and DNA, and peptide bond formation
- L4: In the Azoarcus ribozyme experiments, cooperative genotypes recognise target sequences of other ribozymes and promote their covalent binding; selfish genotypes only self-assemble
- L5: Ribozymes formed catalytic cycles and networks able to grow by incorporating new members, with advantages over self-replicating cycles (Vaidya and colleagues, 2012)
prebiotic solution under a dilution flux (aqueous solution)
- L1: Templates and monomers in solution; a dilution flux phi guarantees that the total concentration is constant
- L2: Formation by self-replication (f_i) against degradation, usually by hydrolysis (d_i)
- L3: Competition between cycles with quadratic growth, dC_l/dt = q_l C_l^2 - C_l phi/C: selection is very sharp and the incumbent is hard to replace
- L4: Spatial self-structuring (partial differential equations, cellular automata): rotating spiral waves, and in three dimensions scroll waves, survive parasites that appear at some distance from the wave core
- L5: Enveloping in a membrane: compartments keep local concentration high, keep mutations local and block UV
sequence information carried round the catalytic loop
- L1: Several information carriers, each storing a small piece of information, short enough to stay below the ~100-base enzyme-free limit; selected from a quasispecies population
- L2: Recognition: a new carrier must be better recognized by one of the members than the chain previously recognized; the catalyst is a specific polymerase or enhancer (a general polymerase leads to the death of the system)
- L3: Catalysed formation of the successor: I_i reproduces itself and builds E_i, and E_i (or ribozyme I_i) supports formation of I_i+1
- L4: Closure: E_n must catalyse I_1 formation, a positive feedback loop of catalytic actions; mutual control of constituent abundances
- L5: Joint output: the chains behave as a single, integrated entity with increased information capacity and once-for-ever selection of a code and a chirality