← all systems · see it in The System
Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical)
'Cosmological natural selection, also called the fecund universes, is a hypothesis proposed by Lee Smolin intended as a scientific alternative to the anthropic principle': black-hole singularities bounce into new expanding universes whose parameters differ slightly from their parent's, so 'Each universe thus gives rise to as many new universes as it has black holes', and the ensemble comes to be dominated by universes near a local peak of black-hole production. Walked as a projected model (representation), not an observed system.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Cosmological natural selection |
| boundary | Inside: an ensemble of universes linked by descent, each a point in a landscape of parameters, reproducing through black-hole bounces with small random changes, plus the astrophysics in each that sets how many black holes it makes. Outside: anything not generated by black-hole bounces (eternal inflation's bubbles, if real, are a rival generator). As an idea, bounded by Smolin's 1992 papers, the 1997 book and later defences. |
| nested level | Built from black holes as reproductive sites, a landscape of parameters (standard-model parameters as the heritable trait) and the star-forming astrophysics that sets fitness. Embedded in a multiverse ensemble (hypothetical) and, as an idea, in sys:science. A kind of BVSR and a variant of the Big Bang's origin. Rung 0, hypothesised. |
| representation | True |
| scale | cosmological |
Measures (11) published science
| predicted upper mass limit of neutron stars (kaon-condensate stars) | about 1.6 (1992); later raised to 2.0 M_sun |
| well-measured neutron-star masses as of 2006 | 1.3 to 1.45 M_sun |
| pulsar mass discovered 2010 | 1.97 M_sun |
| PSR J0348+0432 mass (most massive well-constrained) | 2.01 +/- 0.04 M_sun |
| PSR J0740+6620 mass (2019) | 2.08 +/- 0.07 M_sun |
| PSR J0952-0607 mass (2022) | 2.35 +/- 0.17 M_sun |
| shortfall from maximal black-hole production (Silk's estimate) | about four orders of magnitude factor |
| published predictions | 3 count |
| first proposed | 1992 (book 1997) year |
| offspring per black hole per step | 1 universe |
| characteristic clock: one generation (bounce to the black holes it makes) | one step per black-hole formation; no duration given in the sources generation |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (partial)
The selecting step built from black holes: fitness is the number of black holes, where biology counts offspring and clonal selection counts antigen binding. - templating (partial)
The variation-selection-retention algorithm recurs on a cosmological substrate: the theory 'contains the evolutionary ideas of reproduction and mutation of universes, and so is formally analogous to models of population biology'. - seed (surface)
One parameter set unpacks into a whole universe's physics, and a black hole would carry it, slightly changed, into the next: the landscape point x 'mapped' to all low-energy parameters.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (8) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Star via sys:gravitational-field · Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) gain
- Neutron star via sys:gravitational-field · Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) mixed
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) gain
- Carbon atom via sys:electromagnetic-field · Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) gain
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:mental-representation · Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) mixed
- String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) even
- Multiverse (the hypothetical ensemble of universes; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) gain
- Competition over the ensemble of universes: black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation (projected contest) via sys:gravitational-field · Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) mixed
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (4)
- Black hole
- Standard Model of particle physics
- String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model)
- Competition over the ensemble of universes: black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation (projected contest)
Sits inside / holds (2)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Multiverse (the hypothetical ensemble of universes; walked as a projected model)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (14)
- Star
- Supernova
- Neutron star
- Black hole
- Molecular cloud
- Carbon atom
- Standard Model of particle physics
- Cosmic dust
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model)
- Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical)
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
- Multiverse (the hypothetical ensemble of universes; walked as a projected model)
- Competition over the ensemble of universes: black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation (projected contest)
represents (2)
- Big Bang
- the idea of Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical), as held by science
Kinds (7)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Big Bang
- Black hole cosmology (Schwarzschild cosmology; walked as a projected model)
- Multiverse (the hypothetical ensemble of universes; walked as a projected model)
- Universal darwinism
- Eternal inflation
- Anthropic principle (observation selection)
wired (1)
Notes published science
- Carbon as a black-hole factory part: CO cooling and carbon dust let giant clouds make the massive stars that become black holes, so the hypothesis explains 'why the universe is tuned so that there are stars and carbon chemistry' without using life.
- It gave physics its first 'landscape of parameters', borrowed from biology's fitness landscapes, years before the string landscape.
- The hypothesis staked itself on a neutron-star mass: heavier pulsars since 2010 (up to 2.35 +/- 0.17 M_sun) now sit on its record.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
black-hole bounce and reproduction (gravitational field)
- L1: Black holes form in a universe (astrophysical collapse of massive stars; in some models primordial black holes from density fluctuations); fitness f(p) is 'the average number of black holes produced by a universe initiated in such a bounce transition'.
- L2: Hypothesis I: 'Black hole singularities bounce and evolve to initial states of expanding universes'; 'the formation of a black hole causes the emergence of a new universe on the other side'; theoretical evidence that black-hole and cosmological singularities bounce 'strengthened greatly since ... 1992'.
- L3: Reproduction step: 'in each steps one new universe is created for each black hole in an existing universe'; 'Each universe thus gives rise to as many new universes as it has black holes.'
- L4: Ensemble convergence: 'Under very mild assumptions for the fitness function one can show that after many steps the ensemble converges to one in which almost every member is near a local extrema of f(p)'; 'the population is dominated by universes whose parameters drive the production of black holes to a local peak in the landscape'.
black-hole yield through massive stars and carbon chemistry (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Cooling of giant molecular clouds: 'the dominant cooling mechanism in the giant molecular clouds where massive stars appear to form is radiation from molecular vibrations of CO'.
- L2: Shielding: 'the giant molecular clouds require shielding from uv light from the massive stars which is provided by carbon dust and ice'.
- L3: Massive stars and supernovas make astrophysical black holes; CNS also 'explains' that 'the Fermi constant is in the narrow range required for supernovas to work'.
- L4: Threshold for collapse: CNS predicts neutron stars are kaon-condensate stars with an upper mass limit near 1.6 solar masses, 'because the strange quark mass can be varied to raise and lower M_uml without strongly affecting the processes that lead to massive star formation and supernovas' (later raised to 2.0 solar masses).
inherited parameters on the landscape (quantum vacuum; proposed heredity medium)
- L1: Each universe is a point x in a fundamental landscape L, mapped by I to low-energy parameters p in P (masses of elementary particles, Planck constant, elementary charge 'and so forth'); 'This was the first use of the notion of a landscape of parameters in physics.'
- L2: Hypothesis II: 'At each such creation event there is a small change in x leading to a small random change of x in P. Small here means compared to the step size under which f(p) changes appreciably.'
- L3: Master prediction M: 'Almost every small change in p from its present value either leads f(p) unchanged or leads to a decrease in f(p)'; it refers only to local changes and to observed low-energy parameters, not to the fundamental landscape.
mental representation: the hypothesis as proposed, predicted, tested and held
- L1: Proposed: 'Smolin first proposed the idea in 1992 and summarized it in a book aimed at a lay audience called The Life of the Cosmos, published in 1997'; 'intended as a scientific alternative to the anthropic principle'.
- L2: Predictions: three published: neutron-star upper mass near 1.6 solar masses; inflation governed by a single parameter (delta-rho/rho anti-correlated with the number of e-folds); little early star formation (no excess of high-redshift supernovas).
- L3: Tests and objections: in 2006 'all the well measured neutron stars have masses between 1.3 and 1.45 solar masses'; later a 1.97-solar-mass pulsar (2010), PSR J0740+6620 at 2.08 +/- 0.07 (2019) and PSR J0952-0607 at 2.35 +/- 0.17 (2022); Susskind's information objection, Silk's 'about four orders of magnitude' short of maximal black-hole production, Polkinghorne's multiversal-time objection, Vilenkin's 2006 nucleation argument.
- L4: Standing: the author holds that it 'has survived falsification in spite of being vulnerable to it' and that its predictions are 'the only predictions, falsifiable with current observations, that have ever been made from a landscape theory' (2006); the encyclopedia records the heavier neutron stars since.
Who fills each layer
- L1: Competition over the ensemble of universes: black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation (projected contest)
- L3: Competition over the ensemble of universes: black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation (projected contest), Multiverse (the hypothetical ensemble of universes; walked as a projected model)