← all systems · see it in The System
Black hole
An astronomical body so compact that its gravity prevents anything, including light, from escaping; the boundary of no escape is called the event horizon. Generally defined as a region of spacetime from which no information-carrying signals or objects can escape; observationally, a compact object with a mass larger than three solar masses can only be a black hole.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | with the first massive stars (rung 4); the most distant supermassive hole known at z = 9.288, when the universe was 3% of its present age |
| born precision | redshift +/- 0.003 for the most distant |
| boundary | Inside: everything within the event horizon, 'a boundary in spacetime through which matter and light can pass only inward'; if an event occurs within it, 'information from that event cannot reach or affect an outside observer'. Ignoring quantum effects a central singularity (point, or ring if rotating) holds all the mass. Outside: the external geometry (plunging region, ISCO, photon sphere and shadow, ergosphere if rotating), accretion disk and jets, and a far field 'identical to that of any other body of the same mass'. Seen from outside only mass, angular momentum and electric charge remain. |
| nested level | Built from the collapsed core of a massive star (direct collapse, or fallback during a supernova), or from merged neutron stars, or a neutron star that accretes past its maximum mass. It is a solution of general relativity, so it is a structure of the gravitational field. Stellar black holes are embedded in binaries (X-ray binaries) and galaxies; supermassive ones sit at galactic centres and co-evolve with their host bulges (M-sigma relation). |
| scale | stellar |
Measures (85) published science
| Schwarzschild radius | r_s = 2GM/c^2, about 2.95 x (M / M_sun) km |
| stellar black hole mass / radius class | 2-150 / about 30 km solar masses |
| supermassive class | 10^6 - 10^9 (0.001-400 AU) solar masses |
| ultramassive class | 10^9 - 10^11 (> 1,000 AU) solar masses |
| minimum mass from stellar collapse | 2-4 solar masses |
| observational definition threshold | > 3 solar masses |
| maximum stellar black hole mass at formation (estimates) | 10-100 (higher for low-metallicity progenitors) solar masses |
| rough upper limit (disk instability) | 5 x 10^10 - 10^11 solar masses |
| TOV limit (nonrotating neutron star maximum) | about 2 solar masses |
| mass gap | roughly 2-5 solar masses |
| direct collapse without supernova | core mass > about 15 solar masses |
| ISCO (spin zero) | 3 r_s = 6GM/c^2 (retrograde up to about 4.5 r_s) radius |
| photon sphere (Schwarzschild) | 1.5 r_s |
| shadow radius | sqrt(27)/2 r_s, about 2.6 |
| accretion mass-to-energy conversion by the ISCO | 5.7 - 42 (spin-dependent) % |
| share of accretion energy released within 20 hole radii | about 90 % |
| jet speed | > 90 % of c |
| Hawking temperature, 1 solar mass | 62 nK |
| Hawking temperature, about 3 solar masses | about 10^-7 K |
| evaporation time | about 2.140 x 10^67 x (M / M_sun)^3 years |
| primordial black holes evaporated by now | < 10^12 (Hawking); survival bound 5.00 +/- 0.04 x 10^11 (2008) kg |
| mass needed for Hawking temperature above CMB | less than the Moon (diameter < 0.1 mm) mass |
| Sagittarius A* mass | 4.3 x 10^6 solar masses |
| Sagittarius A* spin | about 90% of maximum fraction |
| M87* rotational parameter | 0.90 +/- 0.05 a (dimensionless) |
| GRS 1915+105 spin | > 1,000 revolutions per second |
| Cygnus X-1 black hole / companion (2011) | 14.1 +/- 1.0 / 19.2 +/- 1.9 solar masses |
| GW150914 component masses (GW article) | 29 and 36 -> 62; 3 radiated solar masses |
| GW150914 component masses (BH article) | roughly 30 and 35 solar masses |
| GW150914 distance | 1.3 (GW article) / 1.4 (BH article) billion light-years |
| GW150914 detection confidence | 99.99994 % |
| average density of a 10^8 solar-mass hole | comparable to water density |
| microlensing yield | > 10,000 events, 23 candidates, 1 confirmed isolated black hole count |
| stellar black holes in the Milky Way (expected) | millions count |
| characteristic clock: soft X-ray transient outburst cycle | X-rays for only several months once every 10-50 years |
| no-hair test precision (GW150914 ringdown) | about 10 (mass and spin from ringdown vs full waveform); first overtone frequency agrees at about 20 % |
| GW150914 component and final masses (LIGO paper) | 36 (+5/-4) and 29 (+4/-4) -> 62 (+4/-4); final spin 0.67 (+0.05/-0.07); 3.0 +/- 0.5 radiated solar masses (radiated: solar masses x c^2) |
| GW150914 distance (LIGO paper) | 410 (+160/-180) Mpc |
| GW150914 peak gravitational-wave luminosity | 3.6 (+0.5/-0.4) x 10^56, equivalent to 200 (+30/-20) solar masses c^2 per second erg/s |
| horizon area change in GW150914 | Delta A >= 0 favoured; agreement with the area theorem at 97% (fundamental mode plus one overtone at the peak) and 95% (fundamental mode 3 ms after the peak) probability |
| ringdown settling: fundamental mode measured from 3 ms after the peak (GW150914) | 3 ms |
| black-hole entropy | S = A/4 (Planck units; G = c = hbar = k = 1) dimensionless |
| Hawking temperature (formula) | T = kappa / 2 pi (units with G = c = hbar = k = 1) temperature |
| time for horizon magnetic flux to saturate (MAD simulation) | about 6000 r_g / c |
| jet and wind energy efficiency, a = 0.99 (MAD simulation) | about 140 % of accreted rest-mass energy |
| jet and wind energy efficiency, a = 0.5 (MAD simulation) | about 30 % of accreted rest-mass energy |
| dynamically confirmed black-hole X-ray binaries (2006) | 20 (17 transient) count |
| Sagittarius A* mass (stellar orbits) | about 4 million within the pericentre of S2 (125 AU) solar masses |
| Sagittarius A* luminosity relative to Eddington | about 10^-8.5 L_Edd (L_Edd about 1.5 x 10^11 solar luminosities); about 10^-4.2 of 0.1 Mdot c^2 at the Bondi radius ratio |
| S2 pericentre and speed | 120 AU (about 1400 Schwarzschild radii); about 7650 km/s AU; km/s |
| S2 gravitational redshift plus transverse Doppler | z about 200 km/s / c redshift |
| TDE fallback time (characteristic clock) | t_fb = 0.11 yr x r*^(3/2) M6^(1/2) m*^(-1) (M6: hole mass in 10^6 solar masses; star radius and mass in solar units) years |
| S2 orbital period | 16 years |
| TDE rate | 10^-4 to 10^-5 per year per galaxy (up to 10^-3 in nucleated dwarfs and post-starburst galaxies) |
| TDE bound fraction | about half fraction of the star's mass |
| direct collapse threshold (low metallicity, single stars) | above about 40 initial solar masses form black holes directly; fallback holes from helium cores of about 8 (about 25 on the main sequence), direct collapse for helium cores over 15 (Fryer 1999, via Heger) |
| fallback time to turn a neutron star into a black hole | within one day days |
| galaxies with dynamically measured supermassive black holes (2013) | 87 count |
| black-hole to bulge mass ratio | 0.49% (+0.06/-0.05) for classical bulges and ellipticals (Kormendy & Ho); M_BH about 1.4 x 10^-3 M_gal (Fabian) ratio |
| M87* mass and ring (EHT) | (6.5 +/- 0.7) x 10^9 solar masses; ring diameter 42 +/- 3 microarcseconds solar masses; microarcseconds |
| cluster-core cooling without jet heating (A1835) | over 1000 solar masses per year |
| per-hand-off yield: GW150914 rest mass kept by the remnant | 62 of 36 + 29 = 65 (about 95%); about 3 radiated (about 5%) solar masses (ratio derived from the paper's values) |
| gravitational-wave compact-binary candidates (GWTC-3) | 90 with p_astro > 0.5 over three observing runs (35 from O3b); 1048 subthreshold O3b candidates count |
| Eddington e-folding time (characteristic growth clock) | about 50 Myr |
| time for a 100 solar-mass Pop III seed to reach 10^9 solar masses at the Eddington limit | about 0.8 Gyr |
| photon trapping sets in (trapping radius outside the horizon) | accretion rate above about 0.2 of the Eddington rate Eddington ratio |
| hyper-Eddington accretion becomes steady | Bondi rate above about 500 times the Eddington rate Eddington ratio |
| radiative efficiency of a super-Eddington magnetically arrested flow (simulation) | below 1% (luminosity about 100 L_Edd) fraction of rest mass |
| highest-redshift quasar hole in the review (ULAS J1342+0928) | 7.8 x 10^8 solar masses at z = 7.54 |
| massive (direct-collapse) seed mass | about 10^5 (supermassive star of 10^5-10^6) solar masses |
| spin of supermassive holes below 3 x 10^7 solar masses (X-ray reflection) | mostly a > 0.9 dimensionless spin |
| Kerr bound (rotational break-up) | |a| = 1 dimensionless spin |
| fraction of the hole's mass a superradiant boson cloud can extract (simulations) | up to about 10% fraction of mass |
| analogue Hawking temperature (Bose-Einstein condensate) | 1.2 nK |
| GN-z11 black hole mass (virial estimate) | log(M/M_sun) = 6.2 +/- 0.3, accreting at about 5 times the Eddington rate, z = 10.6 solar masses |
| GN-z11 outflow velocity | 800-1000 km/s |
| GW190521 component masses | 85 (+21/-14) and 66 (+17/-18) solar masses |
| GW190521 remnant mass | 142 (+28/-16) solar masses |
| GW190521-like merger rate | 0.13 (+0.30/-0.11) Gpc^-3 yr^-1 |
| GW250114 network signal-to-noise ratio | 80 |
| GW250114 component masses | 33.6 (+1.2/-0.8) and 32.2 (+0.8/-1.3), spins <= 0.26 solar masses |
| GW250114 ringdown test of Kerr | mode frequencies constrained to +/-30% of the Kerr spectrum |
| Sgr A* ring diameter (EHT 2017 data) | 51.8 +/- 2.3 microarcseconds |
| primordial-black-hole dark-matter windows left open | 10^16-10^17 g, 10^20-10^24 g, and 10-10^3 solar masses (the last contentious) |
| scrambling time of a black hole | of order r_s log S_BH (short against the evaporation time, of order r_s S_BH) |
Open contentions (10) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-016 How heavy must a black hole be to count as supermassive: 100,000 or a million times the Sun?
booked: The map uses both lower limits where each source uses it: a million solar masses on the black hole page and 100,000 on the supermassive black hole page, until a review settles the convention.
the other reading: A: 10^5 (SMBH and intermediate-mass pages) - C-027 Do black holes really have event horizons?
booked: The map follows general relativity: black holes have event horizons. Hawking's 2014 suggestion of apparent horizons only is kept alongside.
the other reading: B: collapse makes apparent horizons but no event horizons (Hawking 2014) - C-074 Are black holes truly thermodynamic systems, or only look like them?
booked: The map treats them as thermodynamic, with entropy equal to a quarter of the horizon area, and keeps the 'only an analogy' view alongside.
the other reading: an analogy only - C-075 Can a collapsing star end in a naked singularity?
booked: The map follows weak cosmic censorship, under which naked singularities don't form in general, and keeps the cases where they do alongside.
the other reading: naked singularities form generically under some conditions - C-154 Could black holes from the early universe make up all of the dark matter?
booked: The map keeps both views side by side for now.
the other reading: windows open at 10^16-10^17 g, 10^20-10^24 g and 10-10^3 solar masses (the last contentious) vs dark matter as an elementary particle - C-1271 Is information destroyed when a black hole evaporates?
booked: The map doesn't rule and keeps both: information lost, or carried back out in the radiation.
the other reading: A: information is lost when a hole evaporates (semiclassical: a pure state becomes mixed; Wald 2001 reviews it); B: the radiation carries the information back out and the final state is nearly pure (Page 2005, who adds that 'one is not yet completely sure'); 2026-11-12: Almheiri et al. 2021 show a gravitational fine-grained entropy method that 'reveals large corrections needed for the entropy to be consistent with unitary black hole evaporation' (the Page curve), under the 'central dogma' that from outside a hole is an ordinary quantum system; still not ruled here - C-1287 What powers the jets shooting from black holes?
booked: The map keeps both sources: the black hole's spin, and the swirling disk of matter around it.
the other reading: A: spin energy through field lines threading the horizon (Blandford-Znajek; net extraction shown in MAD simulations, Tchekhovskoy et al. 2011); B: the accretion flow (Blandford-Payne), per EHT 2019 'either ... or' - C-1297 How do supermassive black holes and their galaxies stay in proportion?
booked: The map records the proportion without ruling how it arises, and keeps both feedback and merger-averaging explanations alongside.
the other reading: A: feedback regulates both and 'can account for the observed proportionality' (Fabian 2012); B: coevolution holds for classical bulges and ellipticals only, with no close coevolution for pseudobulges and dark halos, and merger averaging 'independent of any feedback physics' tightens the scatter (Kormendy & Ho 2013) - C-1343 Are black holes born spinning, or spun up by feeding?
booked: The map records that holes in high-mass binaries were born spinning, and leaves open whether those in low-mass binaries were born that way or spun up by what they swallowed.
the other reading: low-mass X-ray binary holes: spun up by accretion (Fragos & McClintock 2015, cited) or born spinning; Reynolds: 'it remains unclear whether the spin-up scenario is still viable' - C-1374 How did the first giant black holes grow so fast?
booked: No route is ruled: small seeds feeding very fast, large seeds from direct collapse, mergers, and primordial holes are all kept.
the other reading: A: light seeds (Population III remnants) with episodic super-Eddington growth; B: heavy direct-collapse seeds of about 10^5 solar masses; C: growth by mergers in dense clusters; D: primordial black holes as seeds. Inayoshi et al. 2020: 'Distinguishing between assembly mechanisms will be difficult'; GN-z11's hole fits A and B (Maiolino et al.).
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (18)
- Neutron star merger
- Star
- Gravitational field
- Supernova
- Neutron star
- Galaxy
- Supermassive black hole
- Competition for galactic gas (black hole vs star formation)
- Competition for a companion's envelope (binary mass transfer)
- Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution
- Gamma-ray burst
- Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical)
- Quasar
- Ultimate fate of the universe
- Gorkavyi's oscillating universe (black holes and gravitational waves; no dark matter, no dark energy)
- Black hole cosmology (Schwarzschild cosmology; walked as a projected model)
- Gravitational singularity
- Competition over black-hole production: astrophysical collapse vs nucleation in de Sitter space
Sits inside / holds (65)
- Gravitational field
- Galaxy
- X-ray binary
- Event horizon
- Apparent horizon
- Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model)
- Semiclassical gravity (quantum matter on classical curved spacetime; walked as a projected model)
- Spin foam (covariant loop quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
- Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model)
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
- Trapped surface
- Trapping horizon
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Black hole cosmology (Schwarzschild cosmology; walked as a projected model)
- Black-hole event horizon
- Photon sphere
- Ergosphere
- Ring singularity
- Gravitational singularity
- Stochastic semiclassical gravity (semiclassical gravity with fluctuations and decoherence; walked as a projected model)
- Event horizon of a non-rotating black hole
- Event horizon of a rotating black hole
- Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH)
- Timelike membrane
- Marginally trapped tube (MTT)
- Ergosurface (static limit)
- Unstable circular orbit
- Photon surface
- Prograde ISCO of a rotating hole
- Retrograde ISCO of a rotating hole
- Circular orbit around a compact object
- Marginally bound orbit
- Weakly isolated horizon
- Non-expanding horizon (NEH)
- Photon region of a rotating (Kerr) black hole
- Israel's theorem
- Stable circular orbit
- Prograde marginally bound orbit
- Retrograde marginally bound orbit
- Bound unstable circular orbit
- Unbound unstable circular orbit
- Plunging orbit
- Trapped region
- Black hole thermodynamics
- Innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO)
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS)
- Weakly trapped surface
- Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH)
- Trapping boundary
- Future trapped region T
- Prograde bound unstable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Retrograde bound unstable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Direct plunge orbit (capture with low angular momentum)
- Spiral-down plunge from the inner radius
- Intra-ISCO plunge (accretion-disc gas falling from the ISCO)
- Prograde circular photon orbit inside the inner horizon
- Light ray that leaves the horizon and falls back
- Spherical orbit (Kerr)
- Prograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Prograde unbound unstable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Retrograde unbound unstable circular orbit (Kerr)
- No-hair theorem
Trades with (valence) (123)
- Gravitational field via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Supernova via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Neutron star merger via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Dark matter via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole mixed
- Dark energy via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Neutron star via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Spacetime via sys:spacetime · Black hole gain
- Star via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Photon via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Interstellar medium via sys:interstellar-medium · Black hole mixed
- Cosmic microwave background via sys:electromagnetic-field · Black hole gain
- Galaxy via sys:interstellar-medium · Black hole gain
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state) via sys:spacetime · Black hole loss
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Black hole even
- Population III star via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Axion via sys:quantum-vacuum · Black hole loss
- Gravitational wave via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Entropy via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Star cluster (open and globular) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Supermassive black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Competition for galactic gas (black hole vs star formation) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Competition for a companion's envelope (binary mass transfer) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Magnetic monopoles (hypothetical relics) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines) via sys:spacetime · Black hole gain
- Dark matter constituent (unidentified; hypothesised WIMP or axion) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Intergalactic medium via sys:thermal-energy · Black hole even
- Degenerate matter via sys:degenerate-matter · Black hole gain
- Gamma-ray burst via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Anti-de Sitter spacetime via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Event horizon via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Apparent horizon via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Gravitational wave background (stochastic background) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Hawking radiation via sys:electromagnetic-field · Black hole loss
- Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Semiclassical gravity (quantum matter on classical curved spacetime; walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Black hole loss
- Spin foam (covariant loop quantum gravity; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Null energy condition (NEC) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Weak energy condition (WEC) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Dominant energy condition (DEC) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Ultimate fate of the universe via sys:spacetime · Black hole loss
- False vacuum (metastable electroweak vacuum) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Trapped surface via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Trapping horizon via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Dynamical horizon via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Isolated horizon via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Einstein-Cartan-Sciama-Kibble bounce (spinor-torsion big bounce) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Baum-Frampton cyclic model (phantom energy; the universe comes back empty) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Gorkavyi's oscillating universe (black holes and gravitational waves; no dark matter, no dark energy) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole mixed
- Consistent discretizations (discrete space-time approach to quantum gravity; walked as a projected model) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Black hole loss
- BTZ black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Black hole cosmology (Schwarzschild cosmology; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Averaged dominant energy condition (ADEC) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi dust via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Kantowski-Sachs dust via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Static universe via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Hawking-Ellis type IV stress-energy via sys:quantum-vacuum · Black hole even
- Black-hole event horizon via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Photon sphere via sys:electromagnetic-field · Black hole gain
- Ring singularity via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Overextreme Kerr spacetime via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- String axion (projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Doplicher-Fredenhagen-Roberts quantum spacetime via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Gravitational singularity via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Interior Schwarzschild metric via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Quantum field theory in curved spacetime (quantum matter on a fixed classical background; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Stochastic semiclassical gravity (semiclassical gravity with fluctuations and decoherence; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole loss
- Algebraic (local) quantum field theory in curved spacetime (walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Quantum fluctuation via sys:electromagnetic-field · Black hole loss
- Virtual black hole via sys:spacetime · Black hole loss
- Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Geodesic via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- World tube via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Static observers (Schwarzschild) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- Event horizon of a non-rotating black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH) via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole gain
- Timelike membrane via sys:gravitational-field · Black hole even
- … 43 more
expressed by (10)
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Overcome Barrier
- Ranged Attack
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Leverage Host/Amplification
- Divide & Isolate
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
floor filled by (156)
- Gravitational field
- Supernova
- Neutron star merger
- Dark matter
- QCD matter (quark matter and its phase diagram)
- Neutron star
- Positron (antielectron)
- Spacetime
- Star
- Electron
- Photon
- Interstellar medium
- Cosmic microwave background
- Galaxy
- White dwarf
- Supermassive black hole
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Accretion disc
- Relativistic jets (radio-loud quasars)
- Direct collapse black hole (hypothetical heavy seed)
- Tidal disruption event
- Nuclear star cluster (fainter galaxies)
- Event horizon
- Spinning neutron-star gravitational waves
- Intracluster medium (ICM)
- Population III star
- Axion
- Gravitational wave
- Ergosphere
- Entropy
- Magnetically arrested disk (MAD)
- Stellar remnant (compact star)
- Competition for galactic gas (black hole vs star formation)
- Competition for a companion's envelope (binary mass transfer)
- Competition for the electrons that hold a degenerate core up
- Baryonic matter
- Star and interstellar medium matter cycle (stellar recycling)
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Dark matter constituent (unidentified; hypothesised WIMP or axion)
- Intergalactic medium
- Degenerate matter
- Gamma-ray burst
- Active galactic nucleus
- Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical)
- Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
- Kerr spacetime
- Anti-de Sitter spacetime
- Apparent horizon
- Hawking radiation
- Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical)
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
- Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model)
- Semiclassical gravity (quantum matter on classical curved spacetime; walked as a projected model)
- Spin foam (covariant loop quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
- Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model)
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Energy condition (the positivity conditions on stress-energy)
- Weak energy condition (WEC)
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Quasar
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
- Ultimate fate of the universe
- False vacuum (metastable electroweak vacuum)
- Trapped surface
- Trapping horizon
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Einstein-Cartan-Sciama-Kibble bounce (spinor-torsion big bounce)
- Baum-Frampton cyclic model (phantom energy; the universe comes back empty)
- Gorkavyi's oscillating universe (black holes and gravitational waves; no dark matter, no dark energy)
- Consistent discretizations (discrete space-time approach to quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
- Black hole cosmology (Schwarzschild cosmology; walked as a projected model)
- D-brane (projected model)
- Averaged dominant energy condition (ADEC)
- Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi dust
- Kantowski-Sachs dust
- Static universe
- Hawking-Ellis type IV stress-energy
- Black-hole event horizon
- … 76 more
represents (15)
- General relativity
- Analogue black hole (flowing condensate)
- Schwarzschild spacetime
- Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
- Kerr spacetime
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
- D-brane (projected model)
- Extremal Kerr spacetime
- Kerr-Newman spacetime
- Kerr-Vaidya null dust
- M5-brane (fivebrane of M-theory; projected model)
- AdS/CFT correspondence (projected model)
- Extremal Reissner-Nordstrom black hole
- Evolving wormhole (time-dependent Lorentzian wormhole; walked as an idea)
- the idea of a black hole, from Michell's 1784 'non-radiating bodies' to the solutions of general relativity, as held by science
Kinds (22)
- Stellar remnant (compact star)
- Compact object
- Supermassive black hole
- Intermediate-mass black hole
- Primordial black hole
- Direct collapse black hole (hypothetical heavy seed)
- Stellar-mass black hole
- Kerr spacetime
- BTZ black hole
- Planck star
- Virtual black hole
- Fuzzball
- Gravastar
- White hole
- MTZ black hole
- Giant black hole (about a billion light-years)
- Relic black holes (passed from cycle to cycle)
- Regular (nonsingular) black hole
- Micro black hole
- Hairy black hole
- Population III remnant (light seed) black hole
- Analogue black hole (flowing condensate)
wired (28)
- Star
- Neutron star
- Relativistic jets (radio-loud quasars)
- Closed universe (positive curvature)
- Gravitational wave background (stochastic background)
- String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model)
- Gravitational wave
- Galaxy
- Accretion disc
- D-brane (projected model)
- Unstable circular orbit
- Prograde ISCO of a rotating hole
- Retrograde ISCO of a rotating hole
- Marginally bound orbit
- Prograde marginally bound orbit
- Retrograde marginally bound orbit
- Plunging orbit
- Innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO)
- Prograde bound unstable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Retrograde bound unstable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Direct plunge orbit (capture with low angular momentum)
- Spiral-down plunge from the inner radius
- Intra-ISCO plunge (accretion-disc gas falling from the ISCO)
- Light ray that leaves the horizon and falls back
- Prograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Retrograde equatorial stable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Prograde unbound unstable circular orbit (Kerr)
- Retrograde unbound unstable circular orbit (Kerr)
Notes published science
- A black hole is the universe's most thorough entropy bin: when hot gas falls into Sagittarius A*, most of its heat 'vanishes without a trace' behind the horizon, which is why the Milky Way's central hole shines more than a hundred million times fainter than it could. A neutron star can't do this: it has a surface, so the heat has to come back out as light. (src:narayan-mcclintock-2008, src:genzel-2010)
- Stephen Hawking's rule that a black hole's surface area can never shrink was checked against a real merger: in GW150914 the area before (two holes) and after (one) were measured from different parts of the same signal, and the area grew, as predicted, with about 95-97% confidence. (src:isi-2021-area-law)
- A horizon can only hold so much magnetic field; the excess piles up outside, chokes the inflow, and lets a fast-spinning hole throw out about 140% of the energy that falls in, by spending its own spin. (src:tchekhovskoy-2011)
- One chain runs all the way down and back up: electron degeneracy (electron gravity:3) -> Chandrasekhar threshold (supernova:2) -> neutron degeneracy (neutron gravity:3) -> neutron star -> TOV limit -> black hole. Pauli exclusion is the gate at each step, until it fails.
- The loop's output rewrites the loop's own return channel: above 40 solar masses, low-metallicity stars collapse straight to a black hole (returning little), while metal-richer ones explode as type Ib/c supernovae. Enrichment changes how the next stars give back.
- If dark matter is ultralight bosons, it would feed on spinning black holes, building boson clouds from the holes' own rotation; fast-spinning black holes are used as evidence against it in some mass ranges.
- The quasar's parts read each other by light: the broad-line gas re-emits the disc's flickers, and 'reverberation mapping uses variability of these lines to measure the mass' of the hole. The same echo that makes the quasar's inner geometry legible is how astronomers weigh black holes billions of light-years away.
- You cannot zoom in past the Planck length by hitting harder: higher-energy collisions 'rather than splitting matter into finer pieces, would simply produce bigger black holes'. A balancing loop that may set the smallest measurable distance.
- Gravity and light raced from GW170817, about 130 million light-years, and arrived 1.74 s apart, pinning the speed of gravity to light's within a few parts in 10^16 to 10^15. And a merger's recoil kick, up to 4000 km/s, can fling a supermassive black hole out of its own galaxy, dragging gas along as a 'naked quasar'.
- Every remaining loop in the far future runs away or runs down; none restores. Phantom energy feeds itself, dynamical relaxation speeds up as galaxies shrink, black holes evaporate faster as they get smaller, and star formation starves on its own leftovers. The only cycle (the Big Bounce) is the one loop whose return step has no mechanism in the sources.
- The hole knows the bulge but not the disc: black hole masses track classical bulges and ellipticals tightly, yet barely track pseudobulges, disks or dark halos, and some bulgeless galaxies still have big holes.
- You can slice the Schwarzschild black hole so that it never has an apparent horizon at all, though its event horizon is certainly there.
- Messages through the Big Bang: Hawking points would be the last breath of supermassive black holes from before our Big Bang, 3 to 4 degrees across on our sky; Gurzadyan and Penrose even discussed the CMB as a channel for 'information transfer from one aeon to another'.
- Carbon as a black-hole factory part: CO cooling and carbon dust let giant clouds make the massive stars that become black holes, so the hypothesis explains 'why the universe is tuned so that there are stars and carbon chemistry' without using life.
- The best thought-detector imaginable, Jupiter's mass at 100% efficiency hugging a neutron star, would catch one graviton every ten years, and the shield needed to block neutrinos would itself collapse into a black hole.
- If gravitons had mass, their Compton wavelength would be at least 1.6 light-years: the waves from colliding black holes already pin that.
- LQG gives the only derivation of S = A/4 'from a fundamental theory, for the case of generic non singular black holes' without tuning the Immirzi parameter (Bianchi 2012).
- The Sun is about 700,000 km across in radius but would need to fit inside 3 km to become a black hole.
- A theory of five-dimensional black holes predicted how sticky the quark-gluon plasma would be; RHIC confirmed the ratio in 2008.
- The hard problem of the quark-gluon plasma (made at about two trillion kelvin, like the universe 10^-11 s after the Big Bang) was attacked by treating the plasma as a black hole in five dimensions, giving eta/s ~ hbar/(4 pi k).
- In three dimensions empty gravity has no waves at all, yet black holes still exist, made by cutting and gluing AdS3 instead of by curving space.
- A black hole can break the dominant condition point by point and still obey the Penrose inequality, as long as the violations average out over the slice.
- In Casadio's quantum black hole the answer flips at a core radius of R_s = 0.18: just below it the Penrose inequality holds, just above it is reversed.
- From outside you cannot tell a black hole from a doorway to a new universe: 'The exteriors of both solutions with the same mass are indistinguishable for observers.'
- If our parent black hole spun, we might inherit its axis: about two thirds of 200-odd early JWST galaxies spin the same way.
- A black hole the mass of the Sun is at 62 billionths of a kelvin, colder than the 2.7 K sky, so it gains more from the microwave background than it radiates: no stellar black hole can evaporate today.
- Black holes have negative heat capacity: feed one and it gets colder; let it radiate and it gets hotter, running away to a final burst; it can only sit in equilibrium inside a closed reflecting box.
- A black hole where gravity has nothing to wiggle: in 2+1 dimensions vacuum gravity has 'no local degrees of freedom', yet a single identification of anti-de Sitter space makes a hole with horizons, an ergosphere and a temperature.
- Empty anti-de Sitter space sits one full unit of mass below the lightest black hole, as a 'bound state' that cannot be smoothly reached from it.
- Crash two gravitational plane waves together and, in principle, you can rebuild a patch of a rotating black hole's interior in the lab of the universe: the Kerr metric article's "experimenter" idea.
- The simplest Ernst function that makes the Kerr black hole also makes two impulsive waves colliding, just by swapping which symmetry is timelike.
- Vilenkin's black holes would take about R x 10^61 to appear even once; Smolin notes the ratio of that wait to the age of the universe equals the ratio of the age of the universe to the Planck time.
- On the complexified Schwarzschild solution there is a real slice where the black hole's central singularity simply is not there: r = 0 does not belong to the Riemannian section.
- A solar-mass black hole would be a mixed state (off-diagonal 10^-28) from clock imperfection alone before it could evaporate: the information paradox 'unobservable in practice'.
- Putting mass inside a de Sitter universe shrinks its cosmic horizon: the black-hole horizon grows and the cosmic one closes in until they meet at the largest possible black hole.
- In a universe with a cosmological constant there is a biggest possible black hole: push its mass up and its horizon meets the cosmological horizon; at that Nariai limit the singularity 'runs off to infinity' and the two horizons become mirror images.
- Gravitational-wave energy has a clean, gauge-invariant meaning right at a growing black hole, where waves can no longer be pictured as ripples on flat spacetime.
- It is still open whether a newborn black hole can briefly spin faster than the Kerr limit before settling down.
- Our Big Bang as the far side of a black hole: the contraction before the bounce 'may correspond to the dynamics of matter inside a collapsing black hole existing in another universe'.
- For a spinning uncharged (Kerr) black hole the whole energy sits inside it; add charge (Kerr-Newman) and part of the energy lives outside, in the field.
- Every stationary, axisymmetric vacuum spacetime, the Kerr black hole included, is one solution of a single complex equation, and the equation is integrable like a soliton equation.
- Schwarzschild's round black hole is, in Weyl's coordinates, the field of a Newtonian rod of length 2M: the shape of the potential's source tells you nothing about the shape of the body.
- The 'interior Schwarzschild solution' names two different things: the inside of a black hole in one article and the inside of a fluid ball in another.
- A maximally spinning black hole is at absolute zero yet keeps an entropy of 2 pi J / hbar: Kerr/CFT counts those states as a 2D conformal field theory with central charge 12J/hbar, about 2 x 10^79 for GRS 1915+105.
- Any number of extreme charged black holes can float in perfect balance: gravity and electric repulsion cancel exactly (Majumdar-Papapetrou), a stationary many-body solution Newton's gravity never had.
- A black hole vacuum that breaks the dominant condition (Boulware) still passes this one.
- Hold your arms out while orbiting a spinning black hole at rest against the stars and you start to spin the opposite way: your 'non-rotating' frame counter-rotates relative to the hole (the ice-skater picture).
- A small black hole falling into a million-solar-mass one is off its geodesic by only one part in 10^5 per orbit, but over about 10^5 orbits that adds up to the plunge (Poisson, Pound, Vega).
- A universe that breathes by gravitational waves: merging black holes shed about 5% of their mass as ripples, the whole gets lighter and springs outward; the holes later drink the ripples back and it falls in again.
- A singularity 'cannot be determined by where or when': it is not a place in spacetime but a hole in it, and a black hole's one 'at no time can it be objectively said to have formed' for anyone outside.
- Around an evaporating black hole the vacuum's stress-energy changes type with distance: type I near the horizon, type IV far away, and exactly type II on one sphere in between.
- Far from an evaporating black hole the vacuum's own stress-energy is of a type no classical matter has ever shown, and between that region and the near-horizon region there must sit a type II shell of zero thickness.
- That edge is a spin gauge: astronomers have measured the spins of ten stellar black holes, from about 0 to above 0.95, by fitting where the disk stops.
- Your black hole can be in perfect equilibrium today and still not be "the" black hole: if a shell falls in a million years from now, the event horizon was always slightly outside it.
- For black holes, the first law is not just thermodynamics: with an isolated-horizon boundary, time evolution is Hamiltonian exactly when the first law holds.
- A spinning black hole's own quadrupole (read off its horizon) differs from the quadrupole seen far away, and the gap grows as the spin nears the Kerr limit.
- A Kantowski-Sachs universe has the shape of the inside of a black hole: homogeneous, with spheres strung along a line, which is why it is the guess for the geometry of a black hole that bounces into a new universe.
- A charged spinning black hole has the electron's gyromagnetic ratio, g = 2, from pure geometry: Carter's remark that launched classical 'black hole electron' models.
- Put the electron's numbers into Kerr-Newman and there is no horizon: a 'black hole electron' would be a naked spinning ring singularity with time loops next to it.
- Bondi predicted in 1947 how a black hole forms from collapsing cosmic dust, decades before the name black hole.
- Wrap fivebranes inside a Calabi-Yau and count their states: you get the entropy of an extremal black hole, right down to the one-loop correction.
- A magnetic black hole the mass of the Earth would be wrapped in a few millimetres of space where the Higgs field is switched off and electroweak symmetry is restored, with an asymmetric 'electroweak corona' around it.
- The same mathematical object measures the length of a road on a map and the time ticked by a clock falling into a black hole: only the signature changes.
- Christodoulou proved that scalar-field collapse can expose a singularity, then proved that the tiniest nudge to the starting data turns it into a black hole instead: the first true cosmic censorship theorem.
- Spin a disk of dust ever more relativistic at fixed angular momentum and it cannot exceed M^2 = J: at mu0 = 4.62966184 it disappears into an extreme Kerr black hole, and from inside the disk sits in its own endless universe.
- At 1.5 Schwarzschild radii light can circle a black hole forever, but the smallest nudge sends it either into the hole or out to infinity.
- Spin a black hole past J = GM^2/c and it stops being a black hole: same metric, no horizon, the ring singularity in plain view.
- A superspinar could turn up to 100% of accreted rest mass into radiation, against 42% for the fastest black hole and 6% for a non-spinning one.
- At the Planck temperature a heat bath runs backwards: add energy and it may get colder, because the energy goes into bigger black holes, and bigger black holes are cooler.
- The quantum dominant condition is built the same way as the classical one, a density half plus a flux half, but the two halves fare differently: the flux half survives near a black hole (Boulware) while the density half breaks.
- The same formula, hbar times an acceleration over 2 pi c k_B, gives the temperature of an accelerating thermometer and of a black hole.
- For a black hole the right yardstick is L = 2m: with it, all three standard vacua (Boulware, Hartle-Hawking, Unruh) pass the quantum flux test, even where the quantum weak test fails.
- String theory may fill the sky with axions, roughly one per decade of mass all the way down to the Hubble scale: an 'axiverse' that would show up as a twist in the CMB polarization, steps in how matter clumps, and black holes losing their spin.
- Spinning black holes as particle detectors: an axion cloud feeding on the spin of LMC X-1 already limits the QCD axion.
- Whether general relativity is a deterministic theory comes down to a race inside black holes: how fast ripples outside die away against how hard they are blueshifted at the inner horizon.
- Classically, the electron's own field is a superextremal Reissner-Nordstrom geometry: its charge outweighs its mass by about 10^21 in these units, so a 'black hole electron' would be a naked singularity.
- Below q/M = sqrt(3) the naked singularity still hides inside a photon sphere and lenses like a black hole; above it there is no photon sphere and no relativistic images.
- Black holes act as the judges: a theory with a global symmetry fails because a black hole can swallow the charge and evaporate without giving it back.
- The trace-of-square condition is a tripwire for the strangest kind of stress-energy: only type IV, with complex eigenvalues, can break it, and the one example found is the vacuum far from an evaporating black hole.
- De Sitter space has a trapped sphere through every single point, with no black hole anywhere.
- Maldacena, Milekhin and Popov's 2018 wormhole is a pair of entangled near-extremal black holes held open by charged massless fermions, small enough to embed in the Standard Model.
- Its black holes are messengers from eleven dimensions: Townsend read IIA's charged extreme black holes as Kaluza-Klein modes of 11D supergravity, and its sixbranes as Kaluza-Klein monopoles.
- Squeeze the infinite dust cylinder down to a ring and you get the Kerr black hole, time loops included.
- Hawking's picture: every macroscopic black hole ends by shrinking to the Planck size and dissolving into a sea of virtual ones, about one per Planck volume.
- A virtual black hole could swallow two quarks of a proton and give back an antiquark and a lepton: proton decay by spacetime foam (lifetime of order 10^64 years).
- Inside the tube anything goes: the same equations hold for 'any sufficiently compact body of arbitrary internal structure', a small black hole or a neutron star alike.
- The lapse and shift are pure freedom: they say how to stack the slices of spacetime, and any choice gives the same physics; but a bad choice inside a black hole can let coordinate ripples leak out faster than light.
- Until 2005 every computer run of two orbiting black holes crashed before completing a single orbit; 2005 was called the annus mirabilis of numerical relativity, 100 years after Einstein's.
- Inside a rotating or charged black hole the development of everything outside ends at the inner horizon; past it, 'to predict the future requires additional data about what comes out of the singularity'.
- A black hole and a neutron star move the same way: at first order 'an extended body behaves just as a point mass', whatever is inside its tube.
- Outside a spinning black hole there is a surface where space itself is swept round at light speed: just inside it nothing can hold still, yet things can still fly back out. For M87* (spin about 0.90) it bulges out to the full Schwarzschild radius at the equator.
- Earth's whole mass squeezed into a black hole would be about 8.9 mm across, and the relativistic correction at the surface is one part in a billion, yet ignoring it would walk GPS positions off by about 11.4 km a day.
- Hayward's black hole is defined by when trapping starts, not by what happens at infinity: 'black holes can be characterized not by the mere existence of future trapped surfaces, but by the onset of their formation' - and in a lumpy dust collapse an observer's horizon can jump outward four times as new FOTHs form outside old ones (Booth).
- A black hole's event horizon is defined from i+: it is the past light cone of future timelike infinity, so drawing it needs the whole future of the spacetime.
- A black hole's event horizon is a horismos set: the past null cone of future timelike infinity.
- Hover closer and closer to a black hole and the push needed to stay put grows without bound at the horizon, where the geometry looks exactly like the flat-space Rindler horizon.
- Around a spinning black hole there is no single sphere where light circles; there is a thick shell where light winds around on tilted, non-planar paths, from about one hole-mass out (riding with the spin) to four (fighting it).
- The black holes in the simulations behind gravitational-wave templates are not event horizons at all: codes track the outermost MOTS on each slice, because the event horizon can only be found 'retroactively after a simulation is complete'.
- A black hole can be in equilibrium with matter and radiation right next to it: the NEH only forbids flux across itself, and its 4-metric need not be stationary at all (Robinson-Trautman examples).
- A spacetime can keep its past in step but not its future: Minguzzi notes that the standard picture of an evaporating black hole is past reflecting but not future reflecting.
- The cosmological apparent horizon obeys the same 'second law' as a black hole's trapping horizon (Hayward's theorem covers future outer and past inner horizons alike).
- A black hole rings like a struck wine glass, and the ringing is a fingerprint: two numbers, mass and spin, set every tone; GW250114 heard the fundamental and its first overtone at SNR 80.
- The flat-space corner you see while accelerating is the same shape as the edge of every ordinary black hole up close.
- Every black hole in a universe with a cosmological constant sits inside its own cosmological horizon: one formula, f(r) = 1 - 2a/r - b r^2, makes both walls, and you live between them.
- Einstein's correction is a third force in the orbit equation: an extra inverse-cube attraction that is tiny for Mercury but wins outright close to a black hole, where no circular orbit survives below 1.5 Schwarzschild radii.
- When two black holes merge, Hayward expected the trapped regions to join and the boundary to change topology, leaving 'a ghostly trapping horizon' inside.
- A black hole can be in perfect equilibrium while the spacetime right outside it is still churning with radiation: the definition only looks at the horizon's own geometry.
- De Sitter space has trapped spheres through every single point, yet no black hole.
- In Weyl's coordinates a Schwarzschild black hole looks like the Newtonian field of a thin rod, mass M and length 2M, lying on the axis.
- In empty space the Weyl equations are linear, so you can add solutions: put a rod and a ring together and you get a black hole distorted by its surroundings.
- A Schwarzschild black hole, in Weyl's coordinates, is the field of a Newtonian rod of length 2M with uniform density 1/2: the shape of the potential's 'source' says nothing about the shape of the body.
- Sunlight-to-biomass on Earth runs at about 1% or less, though thermodynamics allows about 12% for photosynthesis; solar panels hit about 20% largely because they skip the heat-engine step (src:kleidon-2020-earth-whole-system).
- Merging black holes might briefly brew true-vacuum bubbles whose debris would evaporate as Hawking radiation in the last 10 milliseconds before the merger: a proposed test.
- Every black hole we know of is colder than the 2.7 K microwave background, so today they all drink in more heat than they give out; to evaporate, a hole must have less than 0.8% of Earth's mass, which only primordial holes could.
- A black hole heats up as it shrinks: the smaller it gets the hotter and brighter it burns, ending (if the theory holds) in a burst of gamma rays; Fermi has watched for those flashes since 2008 and seen none.
- Push a horizon out of balance and it behaves like a viscous fluid: a shearing horizon produces entropy through a viscosity of exactly 1/16 pi G, and that dissipated energy turns out to be the same 'tidal heating' Hartle and Hawking had worked out for black holes. Its ratio to entropy matches the value string theorists found for the most perfect fluids. (src:eling-guedens-jacobson-2006; src:chirco-liberati-2010; src:kovtun-son-starinets-2005)
- A spinning black hole can be turned into a bomb: put a mirror around it and any wave that grazes its spinning edge comes back stronger, bounces, grows again, until the pressure breaks the mirror. Physicists say a cloud of a very light, still-undiscovered particle would do the same thing naturally, spinning the hole down by up to a tenth of its mass, and the cloud would obey the same equation as the electron in a hydrogen atom. (src:brito-cardoso-pani-2020)
- Hawking radiation has been seen, but not from a black hole: in a sliver of ultracold atoms flowing faster than sound, sound plays the part of light, and pairs of 'Hawking' sound particles appeared across the edge, entangled, at 1.2 billionths of a degree above absolute zero. A real stellar hole's version is far too faint to ever detect. (src:steinhauer-2016)
- Black holes grow on a speed limit: feeding as fast as their own glare allows, a hole grows about 2.7-fold every 50 million years, so a first-star seed would need almost the whole first billion years of the universe, eating non-stop, to reach a billion suns. Yet such monsters already existed, which is why astronomers think some got a head start as giant 100,000-sun seeds or broke the limit by swallowing their own light. (src:inayoshi-visbal-haiman-2020)
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
a black hole and its surroundings, horizon to host galaxy (reader's view)
- L1: The surroundings the hole touches: gas, stars, light, other compact objects, and the curved spacetime they move in
- L2: The reach: from afar a body like any other of its mass; closer in, the capture radii (Bondi radius, tidal radius, photon sphere) inside which gas, stars and light are taken
- L3: The near-hole geometry: accretion disk or hot flow down to the innermost stable orbit, the photon ring and shadow, the ergosphere of a spinning hole
- L4: The event horizon: the one-way surface, the defining property of a black hole
- L5: The state: mass and spin (charge near zero), with horizon area read as entropy
- L6: Growth: mass and spin change by accretion and merger; horizon area never decreases; spin energy can be extracted; evaporation predicted for isolated small holes
- L7: Action on the world: pull, gravitational waves, jets, winds and light that heat or clear the host's gas; supermassive holes in nearly all galaxy centres, linked to their hosts
electromagnetic field
- L1: Photons and the EM field around the hole; the hole itself emits none except predicted Hawking radiation
- L2: Charge: approximately neutral (Sgr A* at least ten orders below maximum); a charged hole is neutralised by opposite-sign infall; a spinning hole in a magnetic field creates an electric field
- L3: Accretion disk: angular momentum transported outward, gravitational energy to heat; thousands to millions of kelvin; radiates across the spectrum, mainly X-rays; 5.7-42% of mass converted by the ISCO, about 90% of it within 20 hole radii
- L4: What observers receive: shadow (EHT images of M87* 2019 and Sgr A* 2022), gravitational redshift and fading of infalling matter, lensing and microlensing, spin read from redshifted X-ray lines and the ISCO edge
- L5: Relativistic jets (> 90% of c, up to millions of light-years) powered by the disk or by spin (Blandford-Znajek); quasars, AGN, microquasars; winds that compress or blow out galactic gas; Eddington limit on inflow
- L6: Hawking radiation (predicted 1974): black-body at a temperature proportional to surface gravity, 62 nK for one solar mass, below the 2.7 K CMB; not detected
gravitational field
- L1: Spacetime curvature; general relativity predicts any sufficiently compact mass forms a black hole
- L2: Three parameters only: mass, angular momentum, electric charge (Kerr-Newman), bounded by Q^2/(4 pi eps0) + c^2 J^2/(G M^2) <= G M^2; extremal holes sit at the bound
- L3: External geometry: plunging region; ISCO at 3 r_s for spin zero (prograde down to the horizon, retrograde out to about 4.5 r_s); photon sphere 1.5 r_s; ergosphere with frame dragging around rotating holes
- L4: Event horizon: one-way boundary; zeroth to third laws of black hole mechanics (surface gravity constant on the horizon; area never decreases on its own); interior singularity hidden
- L5: Response: growth by accretion and merger; inspiral, merger and ringdown emit gravitational waves; Penrose process extracts rotational energy and slows the spin
- L6: Galactic scale: supermassive holes at the centre of nearly every large galaxy; M-sigma relation; supermassive binaries stall near one parsec (final parsec problem)
pressure that holds a dense core up, and its failure (degenerate matter)
- L1: Every active star evolves to a point where the outward radiation pressure from fusion in its interior can no longer counteract its own gravity
- L2: Electron degeneracy pressure resists collapse; above the Chandrasekhar limit it is insufficient to balance the core's self-gravity
- L3: Supernova and gravitational collapse compress the core past white-dwarf density to that of atomic nuclei: a neutron star
- L4: Neutron stars below the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit are stable through neutron degeneracy pressure; equations of state through electron and neutron degeneracy found nothing that would invalidate the TOV limit
- L5: Past it the star material rapidly collapses inward; seen from afar the collapse slows and appears frozen at the Schwarzschild radius
radiation pressure pushing back on infall (electromagnetic field)
- L3: Infalling disk matter turns gravitational energy into heat and radiation; absent an explosive event, the radiation pressure limits the accretion rate
- L4: Disks accreting beyond the Eddington limit become thick and toroidal ('polish donuts')
- L5: A massive hole has a high Eddington luminosity; a disk below the limit may be too weak to trigger the feedback behind the M-sigma relation
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: The event horizon: a one-way surface; everything every channel brings crosses it and is cut off from the outside; heat carried in vanishes behind it
- L5: The hole's state: mass and spin (charge near zero); everything that crossed is kept only as these numbers and as horizon area, read as entropy A/4
- L6: Growth and change of state: accretion and mergers add mass and change spin; horizon area never decreases (classically); spin can be spent on jets; evaporation is predicted to shrink isolated holes
- L7: The hole acting on its surroundings: its pull on stars and light, gravitational waves, jets, winds and accretion light, and the heating or clearing of its host's gas; supermassive holes and their hosts are linked (how closely is contested)
tidal field across an extended star (gravitational field)
- L2: Below the tidal radius the tidal force on the star exceeds its self-gravity (the same condition as the Roche limit)
- L3: The tidal force at the horizon is inversely proportional to the square of the hole's mass; for a solar-mass star, holes above about 10^8 solar masses swallow it before it is torn apart
- L4: The star undergoes spaghettification into a tidal stream looping around the hole; about half of the debris stays bound
- L5: The bound debris accretes into a luminous disk; the flare can reveal a dormant hole in a normal galaxy
way in: A compact partner (binary inspiral and merger)
- L1: Another black hole or neutron star bound in a binary (90 candidate mergers by GWTC-3, including the first neutron star-black hole pairs); for supermassive pairs, the host's stars
- L2: Inspiral: the orbit shrinks as gravitational waves carry energy away; supermassive pairs may stall when the stars that would carry off their energy are slung away
- L3: Merger: one common horizon forms; the remnant rings down
way in: Gas infall (accretion)
- L1: Gas around the hole: the host's interstellar gas, a companion star's envelope, debris; Sgr A* is fed by hot, tenuous gas
- L2: Capture: gas inside the hole's reach (the Bondi radius around Sgr A*; Roche-lobe overflow from a companion in X-ray binaries) is drawn in
- L3: The accretion flow: angular momentum carried outward, gravitational energy turned to heat down to the innermost stable orbit; a thin, radiating disk near Eddington, or below a few per cent of Eddington a hot advection-dominated flow whose heat crosses the horizon
way in: Light falling in (radiation and the cosmic microwave background)
- L1: The radiation field around the hole: disk light, starlight, the cosmic microwave background; stellar-mass and larger holes take in more from the CMB than they radiate
- L2: The photon sphere: rays inside the critical impact parameter are captured, outside they escape, at it they orbit (the photon ring)
- L3: Photon capture makes the dark shadow against a transparent glow (M87* 2019, Sgr A* 2022)
way in: Magnetic flux carried in
- L1: Magnetic field frozen into the accreting plasma
- L2: Flux piles up near the hole; the horizon takes as much as accretion can push in (limiting flux proportional to the accretion rate); the excess stays outside and arrests the disk
- L3: Field lines threading the horizon, twisted by the spinning hole (frame dragging in the ergosphere)
way in: Passing stars (tidal disruption)
- L1: Stars of the nuclear cluster scattered onto orbits that pass close (the 'loss cone'); a dormant hole receives a sudden influx of gas
- L2: The tidal radius: inside it the tidal force beats the star's self-gravity; for a Sun-like star the disruption happens outside the horizon only for holes below about 10^8 solar masses
- L3: Spaghettification into a stream; half the debris stays bound, falls back and circularises into a disk
way in: The progenitor's collapse (birth)
- L1: A massive star's core at the end of fusion; above about 40 solar masses at low metallicity stars form holes directly
- L2: Degeneracy pressure (electrons, then neutrons) holds the core up to its limits
- L3: Past the last limit the core collapses: promptly, or by fallback onto a new neutron star within a day
way in: The quantum vacuum at the horizon (Hawking)
- L1: The quantum fields' ground state around the hole
- L2: Particle creation: the hole radiates all species with a perfect black-body spectrum at T = kappa / 2 pi (predicted, not detected)
- L3: The thermal atmosphere near the horizon, whose entanglement with the inside gives an entropy of order the horizon area
way in: Waves scattering off a spinning hole (superradiance)
- L1: Bosonic waves near a spinning hole: light, gravitational waves and, hypothetically, massive (ultralight) boson fields; the source names massive fields, magnetic fields and anti-de Sitter boundaries among the things that can confine them
- L2: The ergoregion: superradiance needs friction, and for a black hole the ergoregion provides it; waves co-rotating slower than the horizon are amplified
- L3: Amplification: energy, charge and angular momentum drawn out of the hole's rotation into the scattered wave, while the negative-energy states fall through the horizon
way out: Accretion light (X-rays to radio)
- L1: What it acts on: the radiation field; X-ray states (thermal, hard, steep power law) seen from X-ray binaries; observers' instruments
- L3: The disk and hot flow radiate; the ring around M87* is brighter on the side beamed toward us
- L5: The state sets the light: spin sets the innermost stable orbit and so the 5.7-42% conversion of mass to energy
way out: Gravitational waves (inspiral, merger, ringdown)
- L1: What it acts on: spacetime itself, as ripples reaching detectors 410 Mpc away
- L6: Ringdown: superposed damped sinusoids, the quasinormal modes of the final Kerr hole, as it settles to a stationary state
- L7: Merger output: GW150914 radiated about 3 solar masses of energy as gravitational waves
way out: Gravity (the pull on stars and light)
- L1: What it acts on: stars of the nuclear cluster, companions, passing light
- L3: Close in: orbits and redshift; S2 at 120 AU (about 1400 Schwarzschild radii) moves at about 7650 km/s and its light is gravitationally redshifted; lensing of background light
- L7: The hole's mass acting outward: from afar its field is that of any body of the same mass
way out: Hawking radiation (predicted)
- L1: What it acts on: radiation to infinity; for stellar and larger holes far colder than the CMB, so the net flow is inward; not detected
- L5: Temperature set by surface gravity, inversely proportional to mass: large holes radiate less than small ones (62 nK for one solar mass)
way out: Jets (spin energy out along the axis)
- L1: What it acts on: hot gas in halos and cluster cores, heated so that cooling stays held back
- L3: Field-line bundles escape quasi-periodically from near the hole
- L6: Power: field lines threading the horizon extract spin energy (Blandford-Znajek) or the accretion flow drives them (Blandford-Payne); in MAD simulations jets and winds carry 30% (a = 0.5) to about 140% (a = 0.99) of the accreted rest-mass energy
- L7: Kinetic (radio, maintenance) mode: jets that blow bubbles in the hot gas of cluster cores
way out: Spin drawn into a boson cloud (predicted)
- L1: What it acts on: spacetime, as the cloud dissipates slowly by emitting gravitational waves; the hole is left spun down
- L3: The cloud: in the non-relativistic limit governed by an equation formally equivalent to Schrodinger's equation with a Coulomb potential (a 'gravitational atom'); the hairy solutions oscillate at a frequency set by the horizon's rotation
- L6: If an ultralight boson exists (hypothetical), superradiance grows a cloud around a spinning hole that draws out energy and angular momentum until superradiance stops; up to about 10% of the hole's mass can be extracted
way out: Winds and radiation pressure (radiative mode)
- L1: What it acts on: the host's interstellar gas, ejected or heated; star formation can end and the hole's own supply is stifled
- L6: Radiative (quasar, wind) mode near the Eddington limit; the energy of the hole's growth exceeds the bulge's binding energy by a large factor
- L7: Winds from rapid accretion
Who fills each layer
- L1: Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical), Supermassive black hole, Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical), Anti-de Sitter spacetime, Black hole cosmology (Schwarzschild cosmology; walked as a projected model), Gorkavyi's oscillating universe (black holes and gravitational waves; no dark matter, no dark energy), Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi dust, Ring singularity
- L2: Supermassive black hole, Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime, BTZ black hole, Isolated horizon, Kerr-Newman spacetime, Overextreme Kerr spacetime, Israel's theorem, Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS), No-hair theorem
- L3: Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution, Quasar, Supermassive black hole, Active galactic nucleus, Kerr spacetime, Schwarzschild spacetime, Black-hole event horizon, Geodesic, Gravitational singularity, Innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO), Plunging orbit, Prograde marginally bound orbit
- L4: Spacetime, Cosmological natural selection (fecund universes; hypothetical), Dominant energy condition (DEC), Event horizon, Supermassive black hole, Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical), Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model), Stellar remnant (compact star), Kerr spacetime, Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model), Null energy condition (NEC), Spin foam (covariant loop quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
- L5: Quasar, Supermassive black hole, Active galactic nucleus, Neutron star merger, Kerr spacetime, Black-hole event horizon, Dynamical horizon, Extremal Kerr spacetime, Interior Schwarzschild metric, Trapped region, Negative-energy orbit (in the ergosphere), Timelike membrane
- L6: Event horizon, Supermassive black hole, Virtual black hole, Hawking radiation
Sources (129) published science
Neutron star (Wikipedia, rev 1381535165, 2026-10-23) (behind its links)
Supernova (Wikipedia, rev 1381286413, 2026-10-21) (behind its links)
Hawking radiation (Wikipedia, rev 1373783158, 2026-09-07) (behind its links)
Gravitational wave (Wikipedia, rev 1378726587, 2026-10-05) (behind its links)
Isi, Giesler, Farr, Scheel & Teukolsky 2019, Testing the No-Hair Theorem with GW150914, PRL 123, 111102, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.123.111102 (behind its links)
Abbott BP et al. (LIGO/Virgo) 2016, Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger, PRL 116, 061102, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.116.061102 (behind its links)
Isi, Farr, Giesler, Scheel & Teukolsky 2021, Testing the Black-Hole Area Law with GW150914, PRL 127, 011103, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.127.011103 (behind its links)
Wald, R. M. (2001) The thermodynamics of black holes, Living Rev. Relativ. 4:6, arXiv:gr-qc/9912119 (sections 2-6 read) (behind its links)
Remillard & McClintock 2006, X-ray Properties of Black-Hole Binaries, ARA&A 44, 49, doi:10.1146/annurev.astro.44.051905.092532 (behind its links)
Genzel, Eisenhauer & Gillessen 2010, The Galactic Center Massive Black Hole and Nuclear Star Cluster, Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 3121, doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.82.3121 (behind its links)
Gezari 2021, Tidal Disruption Events, ARA&A 59, 21, doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-111720-030029 (behind its links)
Heger, Fryer, Woosley, Langer & Hartmann 2003, How Massive Single Stars End Their Life, ApJ 591, 288, doi:10.1086/375341 (behind its links)
Kormendy J., Ho L. C. (2013) Coevolution (or not) of supermassive black holes and host galaxies, doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-082708-101811, arXiv:1304.7762 (behind its links)
Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration (2019) First M87 Event Horizon Telescope results. I. The shadow of the supermassive black hole, ApJL 875:L1, arXiv:1906.11238 (behind its links)
Fabian 2012, Observational Evidence of AGN Feedback, ARA&A 50, 455, doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-081811-125521 (behind its links)
Inayoshi, Visbal & Haiman 2020, The Assembly of the First Massive Black Holes, ARA&A 58, 27, doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-120419-014455 (arXiv:1911.05791) (behind its links)
Reynolds 2021, Observational Constraints on Black Hole Spin, ARA&A 59, doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-112420-035022 (arXiv:2011.08948) (behind its links)
Brito, Cardoso & Pani 2020, Superradiance: the 2020 Edition, Lecture Notes in Physics 971, doi:10.1007/978-3-030-46622-0 (arXiv:1501.06570) (behind its links)
Steinhauer 2016, Observation of quantum Hawking radiation and its entanglement in an analogue black hole, Nature Phys. 12, 959, doi:10.1038/nphys3863 (arXiv:1510.00621) (behind its links)
Maiolino et al. 2024, A small and vigorous black hole in the early Universe (GN-z11, JWST NIRSpec), arXiv:2305.12492 (behind its links)
LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Collaboration (Abac et al.) 2025, GW250114: testing Hawking's area law and the Kerr nature of black holes, doi:10.1103/kw5g-d732 (arXiv:2509.08054) (behind its links)
Carr & Kuhnel 2020, Primordial Black Holes as Dark Matter: Recent Developments, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 70, doi:10.1146/annurev-nucl-050520-125911 (arXiv:2006.02838) (behind its links)
Almheiri, Hartman, Maldacena, Shaghoulian & Tajdini 2021, The entropy of Hawking radiation, Rev. Mod. Phys. 93, 035002, doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.93.035002 (arXiv:2006.06872) (behind its links)
No-hair theorem (Wikipedia, rev 1380995827, 2026-10-19) (behind its links)
Supermassive black hole (Wikipedia, 2026-10-24) (behind its links)
Gamma-ray burst (Wikipedia, rev 1381033607, 2026-10-19, via Wikimedia Enterprise; history, classification, energetics, progenitors, emission, effects read) (behind its links)
Smolin, L. (2006). The status of cosmological natural selection (arXiv:hep-th/0612185) (behind its links)
Quasar (Wikipedia, rev 1382263223, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Future of an expanding universe (Wikipedia, rev 1381370483, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched paced 2026-10-27) (behind its links)
Cyclic model (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Black hole cosmology (Wikipedia, rev 1374767377, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched paced 2026-10-28) (behind its links)
Gravitational singularity (Wikipedia, rev 1382046027, 2026-10-26; via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
General relativity (Wikipedia, rev 1380898628, 2026-10-18) (behind its links)
Apparent horizon (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Loop quantum gravity (Wikipedia, rev 1378660994, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Semiclassical gravity (Wikipedia, rev 1314551340, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Quantum gravity (Wikipedia, rev 1375223127, 2026-09-16) (behind its links)
Booth, I. Black hole boundaries (arXiv gr-qc/0508107, 2005) (behind its links)
Hayward, S. A. General laws of black-hole dynamics (arXiv gr-qc/9303006v3, revised 6 April 1994) (behind its links)
Ashtekar, A. and Krishnan, B. Isolated and dynamical horizons and their applications, Living Reviews in Relativity 7, 10 (2004), arXiv gr-qc/0407042v3 (behind its links)
Ergosphere (Wikipedia, rev 1380664703, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Hu and Verdaguer, Stochastic Gravity: Theory and Applications (doi:10.12942/lrr-2008-3) (behind its links)
Schwarzschild metric (Wikipedia), lead, formulation, history, singularities, orbits, symmetries, curvatures (behind its links)
Event horizon (Wikipedia), accelerated particle and beyond-GR sections (behind its links)
Kerr metric (Wikipedia), overview, frame dragging, surfaces, ergosphere, features, symmetries, extensions, relations, open problems (behind its links)
Innermost stable circular orbit (Wikipedia, rev 1369736456, 2026-08-16; via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Claudel, C.-M., Virbhadra, K. S. and Ellis, G. F. R. (2001) The geometry of photon surfaces, J. Math. Phys. 42:818, arXiv:gr-qc/0005050 (behind its links)
Perlick, V. and Tsupko, O. Yu. (2022) Calculating black hole shadows: review of analytical studies, Phys. Rep. 947:1-39, arXiv:2105.07101 (behind its links)
Schwarzschild geodesics (Wikipedia, rev 1362106585, 2026-07-01; via Wikimedia Enterprise cache): circular orbits and their stability, precession (behind its links)
Senovilla, J. M. M. Trapped surfaces, International Journal of Modern Physics D 20, 2139-2168 (2011), arXiv 1107.1344 (behind its links)
Photon sphere (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Baiotti and Rezzolla, Binary neutron-star mergers: a review of Einstein's richest laboratory, arXiv:1607.03540 (read through the fetch tool, Sections I-V; preprint) (behind its links)
Dark matter (Wikipedia, rev 1380661687, 2026-10-17) (behind its links)
Dark energy (Wikipedia, 2026-10-21) (behind its links)
Sagittarius A* (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched 2026-10-28) (behind its links)
M–sigma relation (rev 1375969779, 2026-09-21) (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
X-ray binary (rev 1380919051, 2026-10-18) (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Magnetic monopole (Wikipedia, rev 1376022905, 2026-09-21, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Causal structure (Wikipedia, rev 1375920903, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Warm-hot intergalactic medium (Wikipedia, rev 1373455838, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Vacuum energy (Wikipedia, rev 1373140630, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Gravitational wave background (Wikipedia, rev 1376285522, 2026-09-23) (behind its links)
Quantum field theory in curved spacetime (Wikipedia, rev 1380114773, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Curiel E. (2017) A Primer on Energy Conditions, in Towards a Theory of Spacetime Theories, Einstein Studies 13, 43-104, doi:10.1007/978-1-4939-3210-8_3 (arXiv:1405.0403) (behind its links)
Energy condition (Wikipedia, rev 1374864845, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Black hole information paradox (Wikipedia, rev 1369270449, 2026-08-13) (behind its links)
False vacuum (Wikipedia, rev 1380014664, 2026-10-13) (behind its links)
Popławski, N. J. Cosmology with torsion: An alternative to cosmic inflation, Phys. Lett. B 694, 181 (2010), arXiv:1007.0587 (behind its links)
Baum and Frampton (2007) Turnaround in Cyclic Cosmology, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 071301 (behind its links)
Gorkavyi and Vasilkov (2016) A repulsive force in the Einstein theory, MNRAS 461, 2929-2933 (behind its links)
Gambini and Pullin 2005, Discrete space-time (review of the consistent discretization approach; arXiv gr-qc/0505023) (behind its links)
Hafemann E., Kontou E.-A. (2025) Penrose inequality for integral energy conditions, arXiv:2504.19794v2 [gr-qc] (behind its links)
Solomons, D., Dunsby, P. K. S. and Ellis, G. F. R. (2006) Bounce behaviour in Kantowski-Sachs and Bianchi cosmologies, Class. Quantum Grav. 23, 6585; arXiv:gr-qc/0103087 (behind its links)
Static universe (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Jacobson, T., Sotiriou, T.P. (2009) Over-spinning a black hole with a test body, arXiv:0907.4146 (behind its links)
Arvanitaki, Dimopoulos, Dubovsky, Kaloper, March-Russell, String axiverse, arXiv:0905.4720 (2009), abstract (behind its links)
Interior Schwarzschild metric (Wikipedia, rev 1312881777, 2025-09-23; via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Hawking, S. W. (1996) Virtual Black Holes, Phys. Rev. D 53, 3099; arXiv:hep-th/9510029 (behind its links)
Swampland (physics) (Wikipedia, rev 1361592059, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache): distance conjecture (behind its links)
Frame fields in general relativity (Wikipedia, rev 1362630966, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Lense-Thirring precession (Wikipedia, WME on-demand fetch 2026-10-28) (behind its links)
Rout, S. K., Vadawale, S. and Mendez, M. (2020) A retrograde spin of the black hole in MAXI J1659-152, ApJ Letters, doi:10.3847/2041-8213/ab629e (arXiv:2001.06859) (behind its links)
Wald, R. M. (1997) Gravitational collapse and cosmic censorship, arXiv:gr-qc/9710068 (behind its links)
Joshi, P. S., Malafarina, D. (2011) Recent developments in gravitational collapse and spacetime singularities, arXiv:1201.3660 (secs. 1-3, 7) (behind its links)
Ryu S, Takayanagi T 2006, Holographic Derivation of Entanglement Entropy from AdS/CFT, PRL 96, 181602 (doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.96.181602) (behind its links)
Egan & Lineweaver, A larger estimate of the entropy of the universe (ApJ 710, 1825; arXiv:0909.3983) (behind its links)
Compact object (Wikipedia, 2026-10-17) (behind its links)
Chandrasekhar limit (rev 1379127080, 2026-10-08) (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Tidal disruption event (Wikipedia, WME cache) (behind its links)
Narayan & McClintock 2008, Advection-Dominated Accretion and the Black Hole Event Horizon, New Astron. Rev. 51, 733, doi:10.1016/j.newar.2008.03.002 (behind its links)
Gravity (Wikipedia, rev 1374741444, 2026-09-13) (behind its links)
Black hole thermodynamics (Wikipedia, rev 1379821427, 2026-10-12; via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Philbin, Kuklewicz, Robertson, Hill, Konig & Leonhardt 2008, Fiber-optical analogue of the event horizon, Science 319, 1367, doi:10.1126/science.1153625 (arXiv:0711.4796) (behind its links)
BTZ black hole (Wikipedia, rev 1355182101, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Gorkavyi and Tyul'bashev (2021) Black Holes and Neutron Stars in an Oscillating Universe (arXiv) (behind its links)
Steinhauer J. (2016) Observation of quantum Hawking radiation and its entanglement in an analogue black hole. Nature Physics 12:959; arXiv:1510.00621 (behind its links)
String theory (Wikipedia, rev 1380903411, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
D-brane (Wikipedia, rev 1356193747, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache); tachyon-condensation passage (behind its links)
Guica, M., Hartman, T., Song, W., Strominger, A. (2008) The Kerr/CFT correspondence, arXiv:0809.4266 (behind its links)
Kerr-Newman metric (Wikipedia, WME cache): history, limiting cases, irreducible mass, surfaces, extremal solutions, Dirac-Kerr-Newman electron model (behind its links)
Dahal, P.K. (2021) Properties of space-time in the vicinity of trapped regions (MRes thesis, Macquarie; Kerr-Vaidya metrics), arXiv:2101.03948 (behind its links)
Maldacena, Strominger and Witten 1997, Black hole entropy in M-theory (arXiv hep-th/9711053) (behind its links)
AdS/CFT correspondence (Wikipedia, rev 1376834326, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Hayward, S. A. (1999) Dynamic wormholes, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 8, 373-382; arXiv:gr-qc/9805019 (abstract read) (behind its links)