EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Timelike membrane

A marginally trapped tube (a 3-manifold foliated by compact marginally trapped 2-surfaces, the expansion of one null normal zero and of the other negative) that is timelike. 'If it is time-like, it will be called time-like membrane. Since future directed causal curves can traverse time-like membranes in either direction, they are not good candidates to represent surfaces of black holes; therefore they are not referred to as horizons' (Ashtekar-Krishnan 2004).

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

boundaryInside: the timelike three-dimensional tube and its foliation by marginally trapped leaves, with its area behaviour. Outside: the trapped surfaces (which lie outside it in dynamical segments), the dust crossing it, the dynamical and isolated horizon segments it joins, the observers who cross it.
nested levelThe timelike case of a marginally trapped tube; built from marginally trapped surfaces; appears in collapse between isolated or dynamical horizon segments; the future inner part of a trapping horizon.
scalefield

Measures (6) published science

dimension and signature3, timelike count / type
leaf conditiontheta(l) = 0, theta(n) < 0 sign
jump example (dust cloud of 600 m_o around a hole of mass m_o)jump at tau ~ 3000m; new horizon at R ~ 1202 m (G = c = 1)
pair creations and destructions in Booth's Fig. 7 collapse4 DH/TLM pairs appear; 4 annihilations count
jump density thresholdsolar-mass hole: at least neutron-star density; galactic-mass hole: water density
characteristic clock: membrane lifetime between pair creation and annihilationset by the infall; the example jump comes at tau ~ 3000m (no general value) m (G = c = 1)

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (2)

Sits inside / holds (2)

Trades with (valence) (7)

floor filled by (12)

represents (1)

Kinds (1)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

infalling dust (stress-energy)

  1. L1: Dust shells falling through the tube (Oppenheimer-Snyder uniform shells; Tolman-Bondi radially non-homogeneous dust whose 'shells interact with each other only through the gravitational field')
  2. L2: Jump threshold: jumps occur 'when the infalling matter is dense relative to 1/A'; for a solar-mass hole only matter 'at least as dense as a neutron star', and only galactic-mass holes jump for 'matter with the density of water' (Booth)
  3. L3: Without inflow the tube is null and isolated; with it, timelike and shrinking (Oppenheimer-Snyder, Booth)

timelike membrane (own, timelike tube of marginally trapped surfaces)

  1. L1: A 3-manifold tau foliated by compact marginally trapped 2-surfaces S: the expansion of one null normal l vanishes and that of the other, n, is negative (Ashtekar-Krishnan); Booth Table 1: dimension 3, theta(n) < 0, timelike, 'foliated by MTSs'
  2. L2: Timelike signature: 'future directed causal curves can traverse time-like membranes in either direction'; membranes 'are not achronal either and so possible refoliations of them are not forbidden'; in dynamical Oppenheimer-Snyder segments delta_n theta(l) > 0, 'so that the trapped surfaces lie outside the TLM' (Booth)
  3. L3: Area: 'Timelike membranes/FITHs necessarily decrease in area' when the tangent V^a points forwards in time; with V^a oriented by a foliation parameter v that increases forwards on isolated sections, it points backwards on membrane sections and 'in all of our examples we have dA/dv >= 0' (Booth)
  4. L4: Place in collapse: Oppenheimer-Snyder shells, membranes connect isolated horizons to each other or to the central density singularity; Tolman-Bondi, new horizons form outside old ones and each DH/TLM pair appears on a surface of L_n theta(l) = 0; Vaidya, the unique spherical MTT is a dynamical horizon (no membrane); smooth perfect-fluid collapse, spherical MTT spacelike at late times; numerical neutron-star collapse and head-on mergers, the MTT 'quickly becomes space-like' (Ashtekar-Krishnan, Booth)
  5. L5: Not a horizon: observers may cross it and 'temporarily escape the trapped region but are always doomed to be recaptured'; if each leaf is the outermost MTS on its slice the tube 'can not be a time-like membrane' (Ashtekar-Krishnan); in Oppenheimer-Snyder the global timelike character 'is an artifact of the lack of this smoothness'

Sources (2) published science

Ashtekar, A. and Krishnan, B. Isolated and dynamical horizons and their applications, Living Reviews in Relativity 7, 10 (2004), arXiv gr-qc/0407042v3
Booth, I. Black hole boundaries (arXiv gr-qc/0508107, 2005) (behind its links)