← all systems · see it in The System
Timelike membrane
A marginally trapped tube (a 3-manifold foliated by compact marginally trapped 2-surfaces, the expansion of one null normal zero and of the other negative) that is timelike. 'If it is time-like, it will be called time-like membrane. Since future directed causal curves can traverse time-like membranes in either direction, they are not good candidates to represent surfaces of black holes; therefore they are not referred to as horizons' (Ashtekar-Krishnan 2004).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the timelike three-dimensional tube and its foliation by marginally trapped leaves, with its area behaviour. Outside: the trapped surfaces (which lie outside it in dynamical segments), the dust crossing it, the dynamical and isolated horizon segments it joins, the observers who cross it. |
| nested level | The timelike case of a marginally trapped tube; built from marginally trapped surfaces; appears in collapse between isolated or dynamical horizon segments; the future inner part of a trapping horizon. |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| dimension and signature | 3, timelike count / type |
| leaf condition | theta(l) = 0, theta(n) < 0 sign |
| jump example (dust cloud of 600 m_o around a hole of mass m_o) | jump at tau ~ 3000m; new horizon at R ~ 1202 m (G = c = 1) |
| pair creations and destructions in Booth's Fig. 7 collapse | 4 DH/TLM pairs appear; 4 annihilations count |
| jump density threshold | solar-mass hole: at least neutron-star density; galactic-mass hole: water density |
| characteristic clock: membrane lifetime between pair creation and annihilation | set by the infall; the example jump comes at tau ~ 3000m (no general value) m (G = c = 1) |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (7)
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Timelike membrane even
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature) via sys:stress-energy · Timelike membrane gain
- Trapping horizon via sys:spacetime · Timelike membrane even
- Dynamical horizon via sys:spacetime · Timelike membrane mixed
- Isolated horizon via sys:spacetime · Timelike membrane mixed
- Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi dust via sys:spacetime · Timelike membrane gain
- Marginally trapped tube (MTT) via sys:spacetime · Timelike membrane even
floor filled by (12)
- Trapping horizon
- Black hole
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi dust
- Gravitational singularity
- Marginally trapped tube (MTT)
- Timelike geodesic
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- Oppenheimer-Snyder collapse
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
represents (1)
Kinds (1)
Notes published science
- A membrane cannot be used as an escape hatch: an observer can slip out of the trapped region through it, but is always recaptured.
- Horizons can be born in pairs: when dense dust falls onto a hole, a new horizon forms outside the old one and a shrinking timelike membrane runs backwards in time to join them.
- If a numerical code always tracks the outermost marginally trapped surface on each slice, it can never see a membrane.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
infalling dust (stress-energy)
- L1: Dust shells falling through the tube (Oppenheimer-Snyder uniform shells; Tolman-Bondi radially non-homogeneous dust whose 'shells interact with each other only through the gravitational field')
- L2: Jump threshold: jumps occur 'when the infalling matter is dense relative to 1/A'; for a solar-mass hole only matter 'at least as dense as a neutron star', and only galactic-mass holes jump for 'matter with the density of water' (Booth)
- L3: Without inflow the tube is null and isolated; with it, timelike and shrinking (Oppenheimer-Snyder, Booth)
timelike membrane (own, timelike tube of marginally trapped surfaces)
- L1: A 3-manifold tau foliated by compact marginally trapped 2-surfaces S: the expansion of one null normal l vanishes and that of the other, n, is negative (Ashtekar-Krishnan); Booth Table 1: dimension 3, theta(n) < 0, timelike, 'foliated by MTSs'
- L2: Timelike signature: 'future directed causal curves can traverse time-like membranes in either direction'; membranes 'are not achronal either and so possible refoliations of them are not forbidden'; in dynamical Oppenheimer-Snyder segments delta_n theta(l) > 0, 'so that the trapped surfaces lie outside the TLM' (Booth)
- L3: Area: 'Timelike membranes/FITHs necessarily decrease in area' when the tangent V^a points forwards in time; with V^a oriented by a foliation parameter v that increases forwards on isolated sections, it points backwards on membrane sections and 'in all of our examples we have dA/dv >= 0' (Booth)
- L4: Place in collapse: Oppenheimer-Snyder shells, membranes connect isolated horizons to each other or to the central density singularity; Tolman-Bondi, new horizons form outside old ones and each DH/TLM pair appears on a surface of L_n theta(l) = 0; Vaidya, the unique spherical MTT is a dynamical horizon (no membrane); smooth perfect-fluid collapse, spherical MTT spacelike at late times; numerical neutron-star collapse and head-on mergers, the MTT 'quickly becomes space-like' (Ashtekar-Krishnan, Booth)
- L5: Not a horizon: observers may cross it and 'temporarily escape the trapped region but are always doomed to be recaptured'; if each leaf is the outermost MTS on its slice the tube 'can not be a time-like membrane' (Ashtekar-Krishnan); in Oppenheimer-Snyder the global timelike character 'is an artifact of the lack of this smoothness'
Sources (2) published science
Booth, I. Black hole boundaries (arXiv gr-qc/0508107, 2005) (behind its links)