← all systems · see it in The System
Gravitational singularity
A gravitational singularity, spacetime singularity, or simply singularity, is a theoretical condition in which gravity is predicted to be so intense that spacetime itself would break down catastrophically; it is by definition no longer part of the regular spacetime and cannot be determined by 'where' or 'when'. In general relativity it can be defined by a scalar invariant curvature becoming infinite, or by a geodesic being incomplete.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the end of incomplete geodesics and the place where curvature invariants diverge (in Schwarzschild a point at r = 0 of zero volume where 'all of the mass of the black hole ends up'; in Kerr a ring; at the Big Bang the initial state). Outside: the regular spacetime manifold around it, the horizon that usually hides it, and the matter falling in. |
| nested level | An edge of spacetime, not a part of the manifold: 'the singularity is no longer part of the regular spacetime manifold'. Sits inside black holes (every one, in general relativity) and at the classical Big Bang; a part of the Schwarzschild, Kerr, Reissner-Nordstrom and Kerr-Newman solutions and of 'all cosmological solutions that do not have a scalar field energy or a cosmological constant'. |
| representation | True |
| scale | field |
Measures (9) published science
| Kretschmann invariant (Schwarzschild) | 12 r_s^2/r^6 = 48 G^2 M^2/(c^4 r^6), infinite at r = 0 1/length^4 |
| volume of the singular region (point or ring) | zero volume |
| radial tidal stretch on a body of length L | (r_s/r^3) c^2 L (perpendicular squeeze -(r_s/(2 r^3)) c^2 L) acceleration |
| Kerr horizon disappears (naked) when | J > GM^2/c (J > M^2 in Planck units) angular momentum |
| Reissner-Nordstrom horizon disappears (naked) when | Q/sqrt(4 pi eps0) > M sqrt(G) (Q > M in Planck units) charge |
| GRS 1915+105 spin parameter (closest to the naked limit) | 0.82-1.00 dimensionless |
| Penrose singularity theorem / weak cosmic censorship proposed | 1965 / 1969 year |
| Nobel Prize for 'black hole formation is a robust prediction of the general theory of relativity' | 2020 (Penrose, half) year |
| characteristic clock: proper time to reach the singularity after crossing the horizon | finite ('within a finite period of time'); no value read s |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-052 Is the inner horizon of a rotating or charged black hole stable?
booked: The map shows where that inner horizon sits and leaves open whether it survives; on the censorship page it follows the view that the horizon is unstable and a revised censorship holds.
the other reading: B: stable in some settings
Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Gravitational singularity. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- barrier-gates-complexity (surface)
The horizon seals the singularity off; outside it general relativity stays predictive (the reason naked singularities would 'cause foundational problems for general relativity'). - lightning (surface)
Runaway focusing: a congruence that starts converging must reach zero volume in finite time; nothing holds it (the Raychaudhuri theta^2 term). - same role, different builds (surface)
The same end of spacetime built as a point (Schwarzschild), a ring (Kerr), a null surface (Cauchy horizon) or the whole of space at t = 0 (Big Bang).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (23) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Inextensible future-directed timelike curve via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity gain
- Trapped surface via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity gain
- Initially singular no-boundary history (classical history of the no-boundary state that starts at a singularity; hypothetical) via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity even
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity gain
- Big Bang via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity even
- Schwarzschild spacetime via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity gain
- Event horizon via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity gain
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical) via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity loss
- Cauchy horizon via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity gain
- Geodesic via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity even
- Event horizon of a non-rotating black hole via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity gain
- Future Cauchy development D+(S) via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity gain
- Past Cauchy development D-(S) via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity gain
- Lightlike line via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity gain
- Penrose singularity theorem via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity gain
- Caustic (of a geodesic congruence; of light rays) via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity even
- Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity gain
- Naked singularity via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity even
- Terminal indecomposable future set (TIF) via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity even
- Future-trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Gravitational singularity gain
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS) via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity gain
- Future trapped region T via sys:gravitational-field · Gravitational singularity gain
- Infinity: the boundless or endless as mathematics and philosophy describe it (potential and actual infinity, Cantor's sizes of infinity, infinity in calculus, geometry, physics and computing) and the practice of the people who argue over it via sys:sensory-environment · Gravitational singularity even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
- Schwarzschild spacetime
- Initially singular no-boundary history (classical history of the no-boundary state that starts at a singularity; hypothetical)
- Black hole
- Geodesic
- Naked singularity
Sits inside / holds (4)
floor filled by (39)
- Schwarzschild spacetime
- Inextensible future-directed timelike curve
- Trapped surface
- Null geodesic
- Causal future of a set, J+[S]
- Terminal indecomposable past set (TIP)
- Cauchy horizon
- Quasi-de Sitter spacetime
- De Sitter-Schwarzschild spacetime
- Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi dust
- Initially singular no-boundary history (classical history of the no-boundary state that starts at a singularity; hypothetical)
- Chandrasekhar-Ferrari colliding plane wave vacuum
- Clifton-Pohl torus
- Gravitational field
- Event horizon
- Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model)
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Strong energy condition (SEC)
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
- Ring singularity
- Geodesic
- Fuzzball
- Point singularity
- Conical singularity
- Geodesic focusing
- Naked singularity
- Cosmic censorship hypothesis
- Event horizon of a non-rotating black hole
- Timelike membrane
- Static Weyl vacuum
- Future Cauchy development D+(S)
- Past Cauchy development D-(S)
- Unbound unstable circular orbit
- Lightlike line
- Penrose singularity theorem
- Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems
- Terminal indecomposable future set (TIF)
- Future-trapped surface
- Future trapped region T
represents (1)
Kinds (11)
- Ring singularity
- Point singularity
- Spacelike singularity
- Timelike singularity
- Null singularity
- Weak singularity
- Strong singularity
- Conical singularity
- BKL (oscillatory) singularity
- Naked singularity
- Big Bang singularity
wired (4)
- Schwarzschild spacetime
- Event horizon
- Trapped surface
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
Notes published science
- A singularity 'cannot be determined by where or when': it is not a place in spacetime but a hole in it, and a black hole's one 'at no time can it be objectively said to have formed' for anyone outside.
- Spin does not save a collapsing star: 'the additional angular momentum only pulls the star together more strongly' (all energy gravitates), the result Penrose's half of the 2020 Nobel Prize recognised.
- Near the centre of a real (perturbed) hole space does not crush smoothly: it oscillates chaotically, the squeeze axis flipping again and again (BKL), a drum roll at the end of spacetime.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
gravitational singularity (own, where spacetime ends)
- L1: Geodesics running in: freely falling particles and light rays that reach it in finite proper time or affine parameter and cannot be continued ('geodesic incompleteness, in which either some light-path or some particle-path cannot be extended beyond a certain proper time or affine parameter')
- L2: Curvature that will not go away: diffeomorphism-invariant scalars become infinite (Kretschmann 12 r_s^2/r^6 = 48 G^2 M^2/(c^4 r^6) at r = 0), unlike a coordinate singularity such as the Schwarzschild horizon, which a change to Kruskal coordinates removes
- L3: Kinds by causal character and strength: spacelike (Big Bang, Schwarzschild), timelike (charged or rotating solutions, the Kerr ring), null (Cauchy horizons); strong (tidal forces infinite) or weak; conical or curvature
- L4: Forced by trapping: a theorem's three ingredients, an energy condition, a global-structure condition, and 'gravity is strong enough (somewhere) to trap a region'; the Raychaudhuri equation makes congruence volume reach zero in finite time; Penrose (1965) for collapse, Hawking for the Big Bang (strong energy condition)
- L5: Hidden or naked: a black-hole singularity 'is covered by an event horizon'; weak cosmic censorship (Penrose 1969) 'posits that no naked singularity is visible from infinity'; Shapiro and Teukolsky (1991) simulations of a rotating dust plane suggested naked ones; Kerr with J > GM^2/c or Reissner-Nordstrom with Q > M (Planck units) loses its horizon
- L6: Breakdown: 'general relativity cannot make predictions about the evolution of spacetime near a singularity'; one 'cannot predict what might come out of a big-bang singularity'; quantum mechanics 'does not permit particles to inhabit a space smaller than their Compton wavelengths'; loop quantum gravity proposes curvature 'large, but not infinite'
mass and tides at the singularity (gravitational field)
- L1: Matter falling in past the horizon of a non-rotating hole; the tidal stretch on a body of length L grows as (r_s/r^3) c^2 L radially, with squeeze -(r_s/(2r^3)) c^2 L across
- L2: Spaghettification: observers 'will be torn apart by the growing tidal forces in a process sometimes referred to as spaghettification or the noodle effect'
- L3: The perturbed approach: infalling matter or radiation makes space 'oscillate chaotically near the singularity'; tidal forces 'rapidly changing in direction' (BKL); in charged or rotating holes the singularity can be avoided and the extended solutions open a hypothetical wormhole, which 'any perturbation would destroy'
- L4: Mass at zero volume: 'All of the mass of the black hole ends up in the singularity'; 'the singular region has zero volume', so infinite density; objects are 'crushed into an infinitely small point'
Who fills each layer
- L1: Inextensible future-directed timelike curve
- L3: Cosmic string, Big Bang singularity
- L4: Future-trapped surface, Future Cauchy development D+(S), Lightlike line, Past Cauchy development D-(S), Inextensible future-directed timelike curve, Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems
- L6: Big Bang singularity