← all systems · see it in The System
Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems
'A set of results in general relativity that attempt to answer the question of when gravitation produces singularities': 'most versions state, roughly, that if there is a trapped null surface and the energy density is nonnegative, then there exist geodesics of finite length that cannot be extended'. The Penrose theorem's reading 'predicts a gravitational singularity in black hole formation'; the Hawking theorem 'is interpreted as a gravitational singularity in the Big Bang situation'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the forced ending of some light or matter paths at finite affine parameter or proper time, given (1) an energy condition, (2) a global-structure condition, (3) a trapped region. Outside: what kind of singularity it is (the theorems do not say), the singularity itself, whether it is hidden (cosmic censorship), and quantum physics at the end. |
| nested level | Built from trapped surfaces, focusing (Raychaudhuri) and the energy conditions on a causally well-behaved spacetime; feeds the singularity, black holes and the classical Big Bang. |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| first modern singularity theorem | 1965 (Penrose) year |
| Nobel Prize in Physics (half) to Penrose | 2020 year |
| ingredients of a singularity theorem | 3 (energy condition, global structure, trapping) count |
| kinds of singularity the theorems leave open | spacelike, timelike, null (and strong or weak) kinds |
| Raychaudhuri equation | d theta/d tau = -sigma_ab sigma^ab - theta^2/3 - R_mn X^m X^n (timelike, vorticity-free) equation |
| characteristic clock: focusing time | finite affine parameter or proper time after the family starts converging (no numerical bound given in the sources read) |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-082 Do real singularities exist inside black holes and at the Big Bang?
booked: The map uses the classical singularities of general relativity, and keeps the quantum-gravity theories that remove them alongside. The universe's starting time is a reference point, not necessarily a real event.
the other reading: quantum gravity removes them (the theorems then mark where GR stops)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
One conclusion, two builds: Penrose (null rays, null energy condition, forward into a black hole) and Hawking (timelike paths, strong energy condition, backward to the Big Bang). - smooth to sharp in finite time (structural)
A smooth converging family reaches infinite convergence at finite affine parameter: 'once it starts decreasing, will reach zero in a finite time'. - templating (partial)
Borrowed shape from Riemannian geometry: Bonnet-Myers (positive Ricci curvature makes geodesics reconverge, so the manifold is compact); 'Roger Penrose argued analogously in relativity'.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (10) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Causally easy spacetime via sys:gravitational-field · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems gain
- Optical (null) Raychaudhuri equation via sys:gravitational-field · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems gain
- Raychaudhuri equation via sys:gravitational-field · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems gain
- Big Bang via sys:gravitational-field · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems even
- Null energy condition (NEC) via sys:gravitational-field · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems gain
- Strong energy condition (SEC) via sys:gravitational-field · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems gain
- Trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems gain
- Gravitational singularity via sys:spacetime · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems even
- Geodesic focusing via sys:gravitational-field · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems gain
- Cosmic censorship hypothesis via sys:spacetime · Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Strong energy condition (SEC)
- Trapped surface
- Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface)
- Geodesic focusing
Sits inside / holds (4)
- Optical (null) Raychaudhuri equation
- Spacetime
- Einstein field equations
- Hawking singularity theorem, expanding-slice form (1966)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (19)
- Null geodesic congruence (light-ray bundle)
- Causally easy spacetime
- Irrotational geodesic congruence
- Optical (null) Raychaudhuri equation
- Raychaudhuri equation
- Black hole
- Big Bang
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Kerr spacetime
- Globally hyperbolic spacetime
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Strong energy condition (SEC)
- Trapped surface
- Null geodesic
- Cauchy surface (Cauchy hypersurface)
- Gravitational singularity
- Timelike geodesic
- Geodesic focusing
- Cosmic censorship hypothesis
represents (1)
Kinds (5)
- Penrose singularity theorem
- Hawking singularity theorem
- Hawking-Penrose singularity theorem (1970)
- Borde-Guth-Vilenkin theorem (2003)
- Raychaudhuri-Komar singularity theorem (1955)
Notes published science
- Spin does not save a collapsing star: in general relativity the extra angular momentum 'only pulls the star together more strongly', so once a horizon forms a singularity must form inside.
- Penrose borrowed the shape from Riemannian geometry (Bonnet-Myers): geodesics that keep bending toward each other must meet, so the space closes up; in spacetime, the future of a trapped region closes off instead.
- Even inflation does not escape: inflating universes are still past-incomplete and need some other physics at their start.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
focusing of matter and light (gravitational field)
- L1: Matter and radiation: 'all matter and energy is a source of gravitational attraction in general relativity'; the Ricci curvature 'is determined by the energy tensor'
- L2: Non-negative focusing: the null projection of the energy-momentum tensor 'is always non-negative'; 'the volume of a congruence of parallel null geodesics once it starts decreasing, will reach zero in a finite time'
- L3: Collapse wins over spin: 'the additional angular momentum only pulls the star together more strongly as it contracts'; outside it settles to a Kerr hole, inside it 'necessarily has a singularity somewhere'
singularity theorems (own: incompleteness forced on the spacetime manifold)
- L1: Families (congruences) of geodesics: null ones (light) for the Penrose version, timelike ones (matter) for the Hawking version
- L2: Focusing: d theta/d tau = -sigma_ab sigma^ab - theta^2/3 - R_mn X^m X^n; with the energy condition the divergence becomes infinite at finite parameter; every geodesic from a point gets a conjugate point
- L3: Three ingredients: an energy condition on the matter, a condition on the global structure (noncompact connected Cauchy surface; global hyperbolicity), and gravity strong enough to trap a region (a closed trapped null surface)
- L4: The contradiction: the boundary of the trapped surface's future is compact, but must map injectively onto a noncompact Cauchy surface; so some null geodesics are incomplete
- L5: Reach: incompleteness 'inside any black hole' once a horizon forms (Penrose); a classical Big Bang of infinite density (Hawking); inflationary cosmologies still past-incomplete
- L6: Limits: the proof 'does not say what type of singularity occurs, spacelike, timelike, null, orbifold, jump discontinuity'; incompleteness stands in for infinite curvature; 'the theory is not complete without a specification for what happens to matter that hits the singularity'
Who fills each layer
- L1: Hawking singularity theorem, Penrose singularity theorem
- L3: Causally easy spacetime, Hawking singularity theorem
- L4: Optical (null) Raychaudhuri equation, Penrose singularity theorem
- L5: Hawking singularity theorem, Penrose singularity theorem
- L6: Hawking singularity theorem