← all systems · see it in The System
Trapped surface
A closed (compact, without boundary) spacelike two-surface, usually a topological sphere, on which both families of future-pointing null normals converge: theta(l) < 0 and theta(n) < 0, so 'their area tends to decrease locally along any possible future direction' (Penrose 1965). Past-trapped surfaces have both expansions positive; future and past trapped surfaces 'are associated with black and white holes respectively'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: one closed spacelike two-surface and the signs of the expansions of its two future null normals at every point. Outside: the trapped region T (the set of points through which such surfaces pass) and its boundary B, the horizons built from marginal cases, the matter whose energy conditions decide what follows, and the singularity it forces. |
| nested level | Built from null geodesics (its two normal families) on a slice of spacetime; the building block of apparent, trapping, dynamical and isolated horizons (their leaves are the marginal case); found inside every Kerr-Newman black hole and in de Sitter and contracting Robertson-Walker geometries. |
| scale | field |
Measures (7) published science
| dimension | 2 (closed spacelike surface; co-dimension two) count |
| trap condition (future) | theta(l) < 0 and theta(n) < 0; equivalently theta+ theta- > 0 with both negative inequality |
| year introduced | 1965 (Penrose) year |
| trapped region in flat spacetime | T empty (no closed trapped surfaces) set |
| trapped region in de Sitter spacetime | T = whole spacetime; B empty set |
| Vaidya example mass function | m(v) = 0 for v < 0; mu v for 0 <= v <= M/mu; M for v > M/mu function |
| characteristic clock: time from trapping to caustics | finite: caustics develop on every generator before a uniform bound in the affine parameter (no value given) |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Trapped surface. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
Two builds of one job (marking a black hole): a local surface that implies a singularity, and a global surface (event horizon) for which 'there is no corresponding theorem'; trapped surfaces 'actually preceded' event horizons. - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
Future-trapped (both expansions negative, black-hole type) and past-trapped (both positive, white-hole type) surfaces mirror each other.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (24) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Trapped surface gain
- de Sitter spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface gain
- Apparent horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Null energy condition (NEC) via sys:gravitational-field · Trapped surface mixed
- Minkowski spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Null geodesic via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Gravitational singularity via sys:gravitational-field · Trapped surface even
- Causal future of a set, J+[S] via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Achronal set via sys:gravitational-field · Trapped surface gain
- Null geodesic congruence (light-ray bundle) via sys:gravitational-field · Trapped surface gain
- Vaidya spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface gain
- Achronal boundary via sys:gravitational-field · Trapped surface even
- Trapped region via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface gain
- Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Future-trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Past-trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Weakly trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Untrapped surface via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface) via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface gain
- Trapping boundary via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
- Mean curvature vector via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface gain
- Areal radius via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface gain
- Lightlike ray (future or past) via sys:spacetime · Trapped surface even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Apparent horizon
- Null geodesic
- Trapping horizon
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Trapped region
- Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems
- Trapping boundary
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (37)
- Apparent horizon
- Photon
- Gravitational field
- Black hole
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- de Sitter spacetime
- Event horizon
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Minkowski spacetime
- Null geodesic
- Gravitational singularity
- Vaidya spacetime
- Geodesic focusing
- Past-trapped surface
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS)
- Trapping horizon
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Causal future of a set, J+[S]
- Null curve (lightlike curve)
- Achronal set
- Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH)
- Null geodesic congruence (light-ray bundle)
- Achronal boundary
- Trapped region
- Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems
- Naked singularity
- Cosmic censorship hypothesis
- Future-trapped surface
- Weakly trapped surface
- Untrapped surface
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface)
- Trapping boundary
- Mean curvature vector
- Areal radius
- Lightlike ray (future or past)
represents (1)
Kinds (6)
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface)
- Future-trapped surface
- Past-trapped surface
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS)
- Weakly trapped surface
wired (5)
Notes published science
- The future of a trapped surface cannot go on: its light-ray edge 'will end after a finite extension', and with a noncompact Cauchy surface that forces incomplete light paths.
- Trapped surfaces are 'clairvoyant': they can reach into a region of perfectly flat spacetime whose whole past is flat, in anticipation of energy crossing them elsewhere.
- De Sitter space has a trapped sphere through every single point, with no black hole anywhere.
- Trapped surfaces were defined (Penrose 1965) before event horizons, and unlike event horizons they guarantee a singularity.
- Hayward's black hole is defined by when trapping starts, not by what happens at infinity: 'black holes can be characterized not by the mere existence of future trapped surfaces, but by the onset of their formation' - and in a lumpy dust collapse an observer's horizon can jump outward four times as new FOTHs form outside old ones (Booth).
- Closed future-trapped surfaces are 'clairvoyant': in a Vaidya collapse a single trapped surface can have a piece in a flat region whose whole past is flat, 'aware of things that happen elsewhere, far away, with no causal connection' (Senovilla) - which is why the boundary of the trapped region is as non-local as the event horizon.
- By the Penrose inequality the size of a marginally trapped surface reads as the mass inside it, so a growing leaf means energy fell in.
- We live inside a sea of past-trapped surfaces: any sphere around us bigger than the Hubble radius has both its inward and outward light fronts growing.
- If a numerical code always tracks the outermost marginally trapped surface on each slice, it can never see a membrane.
- Closed trapped surfaces are 'clairvoyant': they can reach into a region of spacetime whose whole past is flat, because of energy that will cross them elsewhere later. The boundary they draw knows the future, like an event horizon.
- Horizon finders use untrapped surfaces as one wall of a vice: a MOTS is guaranteed to exist between an outer trapped surface and an outer untrapped one.
- Trapped surfaces are 'clairvoyant': in an imploding Vaidya spacetime they reach down into the flat region.
- A stationary spacetime cannot hold a weakly trapped surface unless it is minimal: a timelike Killing field on the surface forbids it. Trapping needs change.
- No weakly trapped surface can hide entirely in the past of a regular dynamical horizon, so a spacetime can never be filled with dynamical horizons like the pages of a book.
- Penrose's theorem in one line: focusing says no such ray can leave a trapped surface; a non-compact Cauchy surface says one must; so some light ray ends.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
focusing to a singularity (gravitational field)
- L1: With non-negative energy density, the null Raychaudhuri equation makes both families of null rays from the surface 'encounter caustics'
- L2: The boundary of the future of the surface is compact, contradicting a non-compact Cauchy surface: 'the spacetime has incomplete null geodesics'
light rays from the surface (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Ingoing and outgoing light flashes leaving the surface orthogonally
- L2: 'Both the ingoing and the outgoing light rays are converging, so that all signals from the surface are trapped inside a shrinking region'
trapped surface (own, closed spacelike two-surface)
- L1: A closed (compact, no boundary) spacelike two-surface with two forward-in-time null normal directions l and n, cross-normalised l.n = -1, and induced two-metric
- L2: Expansions theta(l) and theta(n), the traces of the two second fundamental forms; for a two-sphere in Minkowski space 'the ingoing set of null rays would focus while the outgoing set would expand'
- L3: The trap: theta(l) < 0 and theta(n) < 0 (theta+ theta- > 0, Penrose); 'the strong curvature of spacetime means that any causal evolution of the two-surface will be a contraction'
- L4: Kinds by the signs: future or past; marginally trapped (one expansion zero); weakly trapped (both non-positive); outer (only the outgoing sign matters, MOTS); 'only these four types of marginal surface' (future or past, outer or inner) bear on black or white holes (Hayward)
- L5: Consequences: inside a black hole (with energy conditions and null infinity); sealed off by a constant-area spacelike three-surface (Israel, weak energy condition); 'sufficient to imply the existence of a singularity'; 'they even imply the existence of event horizons in spacetimes with the appropriate causal structure'
- L6: Global reach: the trapped region T and its boundary B; closed trapped surfaces 'may penetrate flat regions of the spacetime ... They are clairvoyant'; absent in flat and globally stationary spacetimes; the core of a trapped region, 'a minimal region which is indispensable to sustain the existence of closed trapped surfaces'
Who fills each layer
- L1: Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface), Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS), Marginally trapped surface (MTS), Past-trapped surface
- L2: Achronal set, Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface), Achronal boundary, Trapped region, Untrapped surface, Weakly trapped surface, Areal radius
- L3: Future-trapped surface, Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS), Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- L4: Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface), Dynamical horizon, Isolated horizon, Trapping horizon, Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS), Marginally trapped surface (MTS), Past-trapped surface, Untrapped surface, Weakly trapped surface
- L5: Gravitational singularity, Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems
- L6: Future-trapped surface, Trapped region, Trapping boundary