← all systems · see it in The System
Trapping boundary
'A trapping boundary is a connected component of the boundary of an inextendible trapped region', a trapped region being a connected set in which every point lies on some trapped surface (Hayward 1994, Appendix A). Senovilla: the boundary B = dT of the future-trapped region T, the set of points lying on closed future-trapped surfaces; 'a very natural candidate for the surface of a BH, as it defines a frontier beyond which MTTs and general trapped surfaces cannot be placed'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the boundary hypersurface of the region swept by closed trapped surfaces, with its symmetry and placement. Outside: the trapped surfaces themselves, the trapped region, the infalling matter that moves it, and the other candidate black-hole surfaces (apparent, trapping and event horizons). |
| nested level | The edge of a region built from trapped surfaces; a global, foliation-independent candidate for a black hole's surface, between the apparent horizon and the event horizon; a trapping horizon only under Hayward's regularity assumptions. |
| scale | field |
Measures (5) published science
| dimension | 3 (boundary of a 4-dimensional region) count |
| Schwarzschild location | r - 2M = 0 (B = AH = EH) areal radius, G = c = 1 |
| closed Robertson-Walker dust (Lambda = 0) | T covers half the spacetime; B at the recollapse time region |
| marginal-surface types in a regular trapping boundary | 4 (future or past, outer or inner) count |
| characteristic clock: none intrinsic | global: set by the whole future evolution (teleological, like the event horizon); no value |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (14)
- Trapped region via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary gain
- Core of the trapped region (Z) via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary gain
- Weakly trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary even
- Schwarzschild spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary gain
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary gain
- de Sitter spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary loss
- Event horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary even
- Apparent horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary even
- Trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary gain
- Trapping horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary even
- Marginally trapped tube (MTT) via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary even
- Vaidya spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary gain
- Kodama vector field via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary gain
- Minimal surface via sys:spacetime · Trapping boundary even
floor filled by (17)
- Trapped region
- Core of the trapped region (Z)
- Weakly trapped surface
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Schwarzschild spacetime
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- de Sitter spacetime
- Event horizon
- Horizon (general relativity)
- Apparent horizon
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Trapped surface
- Trapping horizon
- Marginally trapped tube (MTT)
- Vaidya spacetime
- Kodama vector field
- Minimal surface
represents (1)
Kinds (1)
Notes published science
- Closed trapped surfaces are 'clairvoyant': they can reach into a region of spacetime whose whole past is flat, because of energy that will cross them elsewhere later. The boundary they draw knows the future, like an event horizon.
- In a closed dust universe the boundary of the trapped region is a single instant: the moment of maximum expansion, when the universe turns around and starts to fall back.
- When two black holes merge, Hayward expected the trapped regions to join and the boundary to change topology, leaving 'a ghostly trapping horizon' inside.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
inflowing matter and radiation (stress-energy)
- L1: Matter and radiation flowing inward across the apparent horizon, measured by G_mn k^m k^n on AH (non-zero where energy crosses)
- L2: Where the flux is non-zero, closed f-trapped surfaces penetrate both sides of AH (Theorem 6.1), with arbitrarily small portions outside r = 2m (Theorem 6.3)
- L3: B then lies to the future of the initial slice and bends down in Kodama time where it is locally to the past of T (Proposition 10.2), outside AH except on isolated (no-flux) parts
trapping boundary (own, boundary of the trapped region)
- L1: Trapped surfaces filling a region: T, the points lying on some closed future-trapped surface; Hayward's trapped regions are connected, inextendible and '4-dimensional rather than 3-dimensional, for maximal generality', with 'no additional global assumptions, such as regular predictability'
- L2: The boundary B = dT (Senovilla), a connected component of the boundary of an inextendible trapped region (Hayward); invariant under the spacetime's isometries (Proposition 4.1); in spherical symmetry 'a spherically symmetric hypersurface without boundary' (Proposition 4.2); 'manifestly independent of any foliation'
- L3: Hayward's regular case: where the boundary is foliated by limit sections, theta+ theta- = 0 and neither theta- nor L- theta+ changes sign, so its marginal surfaces fall into four types (future/past, outer/inner) and it is 'a (possibly degenerate) trapping horizon' (Theorem 7); when black holes collide 'the trapped regions merge and the trapping boundary changes topology', marginal surfaces continuing inside as 'a ghostly trapping horizon'
- L4: Where it actually sits: B is not an MTT ('cannot be a marginally trapped tube, let alone a dynamical horizon') and holds no non-minimal closed weakly f-trapped surface (Theorem 10.1); B != AH with inflowing matter (closed f-trapped surfaces cross AH, Theorem 6.1); EH != B in general (Ben-Dov, null shell); B1 'must merge with, or approach asymptotically, Sigma, AH1 and EH' and cannot be non-spacelike everywhere (Corollary 10.1)
- L5: Instances by host: Minkowski, T empty and no B; de Sitter, T is everything and B is empty; closed Robertson-Walker dust (Lambda = 0), B is the recollapse time, a maximal hypersurface; Schwarzschild, AH = EH = B at r = 2M; Vaidya, B lies outside AH and differs from EH (Senovilla)
- L6: Global reach and the core: B is 'unreasonably global' because closed trapped surfaces are 'clairvoyant', even entering flat portions 'in clairvoyance of energy that crosses them elsewhere'; the core Z, 'a minimal region which is indispensable to sustain the existence of closed trapped surfaces', has in spherical symmetry the unique boundary dZ = AH (Senovilla section 11)