← all systems · see it in The System
Horizon (general relativity)
A boundary in spacetime set by its causal structure that limits which events an observer can see or be affected by. 'The limit of observability in the universe is set by cosmological horizons which limit - based on various physical constraints - the extent to which information can be obtained about various events in the universe'; a more exact description distinguishes several kinds: event and apparent horizons, Cauchy and Killing horizons, photon spheres and ergospheres, particle and cosmological horizons, isolated and dynamical horizons.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the boundary surfaces the causal structure draws relative to an observer or a region: where signals can no longer reach, where trapped surfaces begin, where prediction from initial data stops, where a Killing field turns null. Outside: the observers and regions on either side, and the matter and fields whose light the boundary cuts off. |
| nested level | The parent kind of every horizon walked or queued (event, apparent, cosmological event, particle, Cauchy, Killing...). A part of spacetime's L4 global geometry; observer-dependent ('Every location in the universe has its own observable universe'). |
| scale | field |
Measures (7) published science
| kinds listed | event (absolute), apparent, Cauchy, Killing, photon sphere, ergosphere, particle, cosmological, isolated, dynamical list |
| observable universe radius (particle horizon) | about 14.26 gigaparsecs |
| cosmic event horizon, current distance | about 16 billion light-years |
| future visibility limit | 62 billion light-years (19 billion parsecs comoving) |
| galaxies ever observable over those now observable | 2.36 ratio |
| accelerated observer's horizon distance | c^2/a length |
| characteristic clock: age of the universe, which sets the particle horizon | about 14 billion years |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (4)
Trades with (valence) (8)
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Horizon (general relativity) even
- Spacetime via sys:spacetime · Horizon (general relativity) gain
- Cosmic microwave background via sys:electromagnetic-field · Horizon (general relativity) even
- Event horizon via sys:spacetime · Horizon (general relativity) even
- Light cone (null cone) via sys:spacetime · Horizon (general relativity) gain
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense) via sys:spacetime · Horizon (general relativity) even
- Cosmological horizon via sys:spacetime · Horizon (general relativity) even
- Accelerating observer (non-inertial frame; Rindler frame) via sys:spacetime · Horizon (general relativity) even
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (18)
- Photon
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- Event horizon
- Apparent horizon
- Unruh effect (Fulling-Davies-Unruh effect)
- Hawking radiation
- Light cone (null cone)
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense)
- Cauchy horizon
- Particle horizon
- Optical horizon
- Rindler horizon
- Killing horizon
- Cosmological event horizon
- Comoving frame (comoving observer)
- Accelerating observer (non-inertial frame; Rindler frame)
- Rindler space (the Rindler wedge)
- Trapping boundary
represents (1)
Kinds (15)
- Event horizon
- Apparent horizon
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Cauchy horizon
- De Sitter horizon
- Particle horizon
- Cosmological horizon
- Optical horizon
- Rindler horizon
- Killing horizon
- Ergosphere
- Cosmological event horizon
- Non-expanding horizon (NEH)
- Trapping boundary
Notes published science
- Every place in the universe has its own observable universe, with its own particle horizon, overlapping ours or not.
- The galaxies we could ever see (62 billion light-years) equal the ones we could still reach today (16 billion) plus the ones we see now (46 billion).
- A rocket accelerating forever carries a horizon behind it at distance c^2/a that it can never touch.
- Accelerate at about 9.5 m/s^2 (roughly Earth's gravity) and a horizon sits about one light-year behind you: nothing from beyond it can ever catch you while you keep going.
- The black-hole horizon is teleological: where it is today depends on what will fall in tomorrow; you would need the whole infinite future to draw it.
- Hawking's area law was checked with the loudest gravitational wave yet, GW250114 (signal-to-noise 80): the merged hole's horizon is bigger than the two it came from, even with the five strongest merger cycles cut from the analysis.
- Falling into a supermassive hole you would cross the horizon without noticing (above about 10,000 solar masses), while a rope lowered slowly toward the same horizon must snap.
- Determinism has a measured edge: the strongest form of strong cosmic censorship 'was disproven in 2018 by Mihalis Dafermos and Jonathan Luk' at the Kerr Cauchy horizon.
- Count the links that straddle a black-hole horizon and (in 2D) you get a number proportional to the area: entropy as a tally of nearest-neighbour bonds.
- Wald's framing: could a mad scientist with finite resources destroy the universe? Weak cosmic censorship says whatever singularity he makes stays behind a horizon, so distant observers 'can live out their lives in their entirety'.
- Throwing charge into a nearly extremal hole looks like it should break the horizon (Hubeny); twenty years later the second-order self-force bookkeeping showed nature always refuses (Sorce-Wald).
- Every freely falling observer in a de Sitter universe feels the same warm bath, T = 1/(2 pi l): the horizon makes empty space look hot.
- Putting mass inside a de Sitter universe shrinks its cosmic horizon: the black-hole horizon grows and the cosmic one closes in until they meet at the largest possible black hole.
- Its entropy is 'the entropy of the stuff behind the horizon which we can't observe', and nobody yet knows where the microstates live.
- In a universe with a cosmological constant there is a biggest possible black hole: push its mass up and its horizon meets the cosmological horizon; at that Nariai limit the singularity 'runs off to infinity' and the two horizons become mirror images.
- Spin one horizon of Nariai space and the other spins the opposite way: the page calls it 'a manifestation of Mach's principle in self-contained causal patches'.
- Every Schwarzschild-de Sitter hole evaporates, big or small: near the limit the hole is the hotter horizon and loses the radiation exchange with the sky.
- 'An event horizon may well be developing in the room you are now sitting in anticipation of a gravitational collapse ... a million years from now'; the dynamical horizon only appears where spacetime is actually curved.
- Earth's whole gravitational field, in general relativity, is fixed by one length: 8.9 mm, the size Earth would have to be squeezed to for a horizon.
- Far from an evaporating black hole the vacuum's own stress-energy is of a type no classical matter has ever shown, and between that region and the near-horizon region there must sit a type II shell of zero thickness.
- Accelerate at a comfortable 1 light-year per year squared (about 9.5 m/s^2, close to Earth's g) and a horizon forms one light-year behind you, beyond which no signal can ever reach you while you keep accelerating.
- Spin it up fully and the prograde ISCO, the marginally bound orbit and the photon sphere all crowd down onto the horizon radius, 'still logically and locally distinguishable though'.
- Your black hole can be in perfect equilibrium today and still not be "the" black hole: if a shell falls in a million years from now, the event horizon was always slightly outside it.
- For black holes, the first law is not just thermodynamics: with an isolated-horizon boundary, time evolution is Hamiltonian exactly when the first law holds.
- A spinning black hole's own quadrupole (read off its horizon) differs from the quadrupole seen far away, and the gap grows as the spin nears the Kerr limit.
- An infalling observer at the horizon of the outgoing Kerr-Vaidya hole meets diverging energy density and flux: a classical firewall (Dahal).
- A Killing horizon is defined without the Einstein equations at all, yet wherever a bifurcate one exists, quantum fields come out thermal at kappa/2 pi: geometry alone sets a temperature.
- The Rindler horizon was found long before black-hole horizons were understood: Kottler's 'border plane' (1914) and Bollert's 'horizon of the observer' (1922), in flat spacetime, just from accelerating.
- Jacobson turned it around: demand that heat across every tiny Rindler horizon obeys dQ = T dS, and Einstein's field equation falls out, like the wave equation for sound from a gas.
- Whether general relativity is a deterministic theory comes down to a race inside black holes: how fast ripples outside die away against how hard they are blueshifted at the inner horizon.
- Dafermos and Luk proved the strongest version false for rotating holes, yet in a way that rescues the spirit: spacetime does continue past the inner horizon, but only as a crushed, weakly singular edge where no observer's fate stays predictable.
- Trapped surfaces were defined (Penrose 1965) before event horizons, and unlike event horizons they guarantee a singularity.
- Horizon jumps: a solar-mass hole only jumps outward if neutron-star-density matter falls in, but a galactic-mass hole can jump for matter as dense as water.
- Hayward's point: no mortal observer can find an event horizon, but a future outer trapping horizon is an operational definition, detectable from inside a finite region.
- The same marginal-surface rule that defines black-hole horizons also catches the cosmological horizons of an expanding universe (as inner trapping horizons).
- Determinism has a shape: the Cauchy development is exactly the region of spacetime that data on one set fix, and its edge is a horizon made of light rays.
- Inside a rotating or charged black hole the development of everything outside ends at the inner horizon; past it, 'to predict the future requires additional data about what comes out of the singularity'.
- Black-hole horizons can never shrink (classically) because their light rays never form a caustic before reaching infinity.
- Conformal time is the universe's horizon in disguise: multiply the conformal time since the Big Bang by c and you get the comoving radius of everything we can possibly see.
- In conformal time the expanding universe draws like flat spacetime: light cones go back to 45 degrees, which is why the horizon problem is drawn this way.
- Past and future horizons are one integral read two ways: from 0 to now gives the particle horizon, from now to the end gives the event horizon.
- The chart has an edge set by the acceleration: where 1 + a.r reaches zero (for a uniformly accelerated observer this edge is the Rindler horizon).
- Accelerate steadily at about 9.5 m/s^2 (one light-year per year squared) and a horizon forms about one light-year behind you; stop, and the light that was held back catches up.
- No real observer can have a true event horizon from acceleration alone: it would take acceleration forever, with arbitrarily much energy and an arbitrarily large machine.
- The horizon always seems to stay the same distance behind; the observer never reaches the place where it appeared to be.
- Hayward's black hole is defined by when trapping starts, not by what happens at infinity: 'black holes can be characterized not by the mere existence of future trapped surfaces, but by the onset of their formation' - and in a lumpy dust collapse an observer's horizon can jump outward four times as new FOTHs form outside old ones (Booth).
- A black hole's event horizon is defined from i+: it is the past light cone of future timelike infinity, so drawing it needs the whole future of the spacetime.
- Closed future-trapped surfaces are 'clairvoyant': in a Vaidya collapse a single trapped surface can have a piece in a flat region whose whole past is flat, 'aware of things that happen elsewhere, far away, with no causal connection' (Senovilla) - which is why the boundary of the trapped region is as non-local as the event horizon.
- A black hole's event horizon is a horismos set: the past null cone of future timelike infinity.
- Hover closer and closer to a black hole and the push needed to stay put grows without bound at the horizon, where the geometry looks exactly like the flat-space Rindler horizon.
- Every mass in our universe sits inside its own cosmological horizon: with Lambda > 0, f(r) has a second zero far out, and if the mass grows the two horizons approach until they meet (Nariai limit).
- The black holes in the simulations behind gravitational-wave templates are not event horizons at all: codes track the outermost MOTS on each slice, because the event horizon can only be found 'retroactively after a simulation is complete'.
- Pretorius 2005 weighed the merged hole by its horizon area and spin alone (Smarr formula): about 1.9 M0, so about 5% of the mass left as waves.
- In Tolman-Bondi dust collapse a marginally trapped tube can turn timelike and run backward in time, which may be what simulations see as an apparent horizon 'jumping' outward.
- In Vaidya collapse the event horizon starts in the flat region before anything falls in, while the dynamical horizon exists only where spacetime is already curved.
- The trick has a hard ceiling: the hole's horizon area can never shrink, so at most M - M_irr (29% of the mass for an uncharged hole) can ever be taken.
- After GW150914 merged, the remnant rang down with a decay time of about 4 ms toward this kind of equilibrium horizon.
- A horizon's area can only grow because its light rays never meet a caustic before reaching null infinity: the area law is a statement about a null congruence.
- The cosmological apparent horizon obeys the same 'second law' as a black hole's trapping horizon (Hayward's theorem covers future outer and past inner horizons alike).
- Spin does not save a collapsing star: in general relativity the extra angular momentum 'only pulls the star together more strongly', so once a horizon forms a singularity must form inside.
- At maximal spin the prograde ISCO, the marginally bound orbit, the photon orbit and the horizon all crowd onto r = GM/c^2, yet stay 'logically and locally distinguishable'.
- Whether a charged hole's inner (Cauchy) horizon survives depends on how fast the outside rings down; one family of modes is tied to the far-off de Sitter horizon (Cardoso et al. 2018).
- A rigid rocket must push its tail harder than its nose; follow that back far enough and the needed push becomes infinite: that is where the horizon sits, c^2/a behind you.
- Spin is capped: once J c exceeds G M^2 the horizon has no real root and the ring singularity would be naked.
- Every black hole in a universe with a cosmological constant sits inside its own cosmological horizon: one formula, f(r) = 1 - 2a/r - b r^2, makes both walls, and you live between them.
- You can lower a rope toward the horizon but never touch it: the tension diverges and the rope must break somewhere the person holding it can still see.
- Shrink Earth to the size of a marble (about 9 mm) and it has a horizon.
- Unlike an event horizon, this black-hole surface cannot form in flat spacetime and grows only when energy actually falls across it.
- In the simplest collapse model (Vaidya) the whole r = 2GM(v) surface is one future outer trapping horizon: spacelike while matter falls in, null once it stops.
- The set of all events at one fixed distance from you is a path a rocket could actually fly: a rocket at constant acceleration traces exactly this hyperbola, and its asymptotes are the horizon beyond which it never hears from anyone.
- The thrust needed to hover, (m/r^2)/sqrt(1 - 2m/r), runs to infinity at the horizon: no rocket can hold still at r = 2m.
- Horizons can be born in pairs: when dense dust falls onto a hole, a new horizon forms outside the old one and a shrinking timelike membrane runs backwards in time to join them.
- Closed trapped surfaces are 'clairvoyant': they can reach into a region of spacetime whose whole past is flat, because of energy that will cross them elsewhere later. The boundary they draw knows the future, like an event horizon.
- When two black holes merge, Hayward expected the trapped regions to join and the boundary to change topology, leaving 'a ghostly trapping horizon' inside.
- Spin a hole up to the maximum and the prograde marginally bound orbit, the photon orbit and the ISCO all slide down to the horizon radius itself.
- Horizon finders use untrapped surfaces as one wall of a vice: a MOTS is guaranteed to exist between an outer trapped surface and an outer untrapped one.
- In Vaidya collapse the event horizon forms in flat, empty spacetime before any radiation arrives, 'in anticipation of the null fluid'.
- A black hole can be in perfect equilibrium while the spacetime right outside it is still churning with radiation: the definition only looks at the horizon's own geometry.
- The zeroth law (constant surface gravity) turns out to be exactly the condition that makes the standard action principle for gravity well defined when a horizon is an inner boundary.
- The horizon mass that numerical relativists read off a settled hole is the starting mass minus everything the gravitational waves carried away to infinity.
- No weakly trapped surface can hide entirely in the past of a regular dynamical horizon, so a spacetime can never be filled with dynamical horizons like the pages of a book.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
horizon (own, on the causal structure)
- L1: Light cones: signals limited by the speed of light; 'curvature of spacetime tips the light cones'
- L2: Kinds of boundary drawn by the causal structure: global (event, defined by the infinite future), local or quasi-local (apparent, trapping, isolated, dynamical, defined by trapped surfaces), predictability (Cauchy), symmetry (Killing)
- L3: Observer dependence: 'Every location in the universe has its own observable universe'; a uniformly accelerated particle has a boundary behind it at c^2/a; 'varying the observer's acceleration may cause the horizon to appear to move'
- L4: Cosmological horizons: particle horizon (light emitted in the past), event horizon (light emitted now), optical horizon at last scattering and its neutrino and gravitational-wave analogues
- L5: Quantum response: horizons 'possess a temperature and so emit radiation' (Hawking for black holes, Unruh for accelerated observers); 'locally any non-extremal black hole horizon is Rindler'
limits on light received (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Light emitted by distant sources travelling toward an observer
- L2: Particle horizon: 'objects which emit light but which exist too far away for that light to have reached Earth are beyond the particle horizon'; observable universe radius about 14.26 gigaparsecs (46 billion light-years)
- L3: Optical horizon at the surface of last scattering: nothing earlier is seen in light
- L4: Future limits: cosmic event horizon about 16 billion light-years now; future visibility limit 62 billion light-years (19 gigaparsecs comoving), 2.36 times the galaxies now observable
Who fills each layer
- L1: Particle horizon
- L2: Apparent horizon, Dynamical horizon, Particle horizon, Trapping horizon, Trapping boundary
- L3: Accelerating observer (non-inertial frame; Rindler frame), Cosmological horizon
- L4: Cosmological horizon
Sources (7) published science
Observable universe (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Booth, I. Black hole boundaries (arXiv gr-qc/0508107, 2005) (behind its links)
Unruh effect (Wikipedia, rev 1362559748, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)