← all systems · see it in The System
Trapping horizon
'A trapping horizon is the closure of a 3-surface foliated by marginal surfaces on which theta- != 0 and L- theta+ != 0'; a marginal surface is a spatial two-surface on which one null expansion vanishes (theta+ = 0). It is outer if L- theta+ < 0, inner if L- theta+ > 0, future if theta- < 0 and past if theta- > 0 (Hayward). 'The future outer trapping horizon provides the definition of a black hole.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: a three-dimensional hypersurface and its foliation by marginal surfaces (one null expansion zero), with the signs of the other expansion and of its derivative across the horizon. Outside: the trapped and untrapped regions on either side, the event horizon, the slicing (it needs none), and the matter flux whose energy conditions set its signature and area law. |
| nested level | Built from marginal surfaces (the marginal case of trapped surfaces) and null geodesics; a kind of apparent horizon freed from the slicing ('something similar to an apparent horizon'); parent class of dynamical horizons (spacelike future outer) and, when null, of non-expanding / isolated horizons. |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| dimension | 3 (hypersurface foliated by 2-dimensional marginal surfaces) count |
| types | 4 non-degenerate: future/past x outer/inner count |
| outer marginal surface topology (dominant energy condition) | spherical (chi = 2) or planar (chi = 1) Euler characteristic |
| signature | null only when instantaneously stationary; outer spatial, inner Lorentzian type |
| jump threshold | infalling matter dense relative to 1/A: at least neutron-star density for a solar-mass hole; water density only for galactic-mass holes |
| characteristic clock: time to a jump in a dust-shell example | 'a jump at tau ~ 3000m as a new horizon forms at R ~ 1202 around the old' (geometric units of the hole's mass m) m (G = c = 1) |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (23)
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Trapping horizon gain
- Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- de Sitter spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon even
- Event horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon even
- Apparent horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon even
- Null energy condition (NEC) via sys:stress-energy · Trapping horizon mixed
- Dominant energy condition (DEC) via sys:stress-energy · Trapping horizon mixed
- Dynamical horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon even
- Isolated horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon even
- Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH) via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Timelike membrane via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon even
- Trapped region via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Past-trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS) via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Untrapped surface via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface) via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH) via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon even
- Past inner trapping horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Trapping boundary via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon even
- Surface gravity (of a horizon) via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT) via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
- Misner-Sharp(-Hernandez) mass via sys:spacetime · Trapping horizon gain
floor filled by (32)
- Photon
- Black hole
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- Event horizon
- Apparent horizon
- Null energy condition (NEC)
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Trapped surface
- Null geodesic
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Cauchy horizon
- Cosmological horizon
- Timelike membrane
- Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH)
- Future inner trapping horizon (FITH)
- Past outer trapping horizon
- Past inner trapping horizon
- Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH)
- Trapped region
- Past-trapped surface
- Marginally trapped surface (MTS)
- Marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS)
- Untrapped surface
- Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface)
- Trapping boundary
- Mean curvature vector
- Areal radius
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
- Misner-Sharp(-Hernandez) mass
represents (1)
Kinds (8)
- Apparent horizon
- Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT)
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH)
- Future inner trapping horizon (FITH)
- Past outer trapping horizon
- Past inner trapping horizon
Notes published science
- Horizon jumps: a solar-mass hole only jumps outward if neutron-star-density matter falls in, but a galactic-mass hole can jump for matter as dense as water.
- Hayward's point: no mortal observer can find an event horizon, but a future outer trapping horizon is an operational definition, detectable from inside a finite region.
- The same marginal-surface rule that defines black-hole horizons also catches the cosmological horizons of an expanding universe (as inner trapping horizons).
- The cosmological apparent horizon obeys the same 'second law' as a black hole's trapping horizon (Hayward's theorem covers future outer and past inner horizons alike).
- In the simplest collapse model (Vaidya) the whole r = 2GM(v) surface is one future outer trapping horizon: spacelike while matter falls in, null once it stops.
- When two black holes merge, Hayward expected the trapped regions to join and the boundary to change topology, leaving 'a ghostly trapping horizon' inside.
- Two papers, two routes, one answer: Hayward's theorem says inner trapping horizons are Lorentzian (timelike) when the null energy condition holds; Faraoni's FLRW formula says the cosmological apparent horizon is timelike for -1 < w < 1/3. Our dust-plus-Lambda universe sits inside both.
- When two black holes collide their trapped regions merge and the edge changes topology, but the old marginal surfaces carry on inside as a 'ghostly trapping horizon'.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
energy flux into the horizon (stress-energy)
- L1: Energy flux across the horizon: 'the variation of the area form along an outer trapping horizon is determined by the trapping gravity and an energy flux'
- L2: Energy conditions as gates: null energy condition for the second law; dominant energy condition for the topology law
light at the horizon (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Ingoing and outgoing light rays normal to the marginal surfaces
- L2: On a future outer trapping horizon 'the ingoing light rays should be converging, the outgoing light rays should be instantaneously parallel on the horizon, and diverging just outside the horizon and converging just inside'
trapping horizon (own, foliated by marginal surfaces)
- L1: Double-null foliation: 'two foliations of null 3-surfaces intersecting in spatial 2-surfaces', with expansions theta+-, shears, inaffinities and twist of the two null normals
- L2: Marginal surfaces: 'a spatial 2-surface S on which one null expansion vanishes, theta+ = 0'
- L3: The horizon: a 3-surface foliated by marginal surfaces with theta- != 0 and L- theta+ != 0; four types, future or past (sign of theta-), outer or inner (sign of L- theta+); 'requires no global assumptions'
- L4: Signature and topology: 'Trapping horizons are null only in the instantaneously stationary case, and otherwise outer trapping horizons are spatial and inner trapping horizons are Lorentzian'; outer marginal surfaces 'have spherical or planar topology' (dominant energy condition)
- L5: Laws of black-hole dynamics: second law, the area form of a future outer trapping horizon is non-decreasing (null energy condition), constant only in the null case; zeroth law, total trapping gravity of a compact outer marginal surface has an upper bound, attained iff trapping gravity is constant; first law, area variation set by trapping gravity and an energy flux
- L6: Placement in hosts and history: Reissner-Nordstrom event horizon FOTH, Cauchy horizon FITH, white-hole horizons past; Robertson-Walker cosmological horizons are inner trapping horizons; in dust collapse new horizons form outside old ones ('jumps'), a DH/TLM (FOTH/FITH) pair appearing, the FOTH growing and the FITH shrinking (Booth)
Who fills each layer
- L1: Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH)
- L2: Closed spacelike surface (compact spacelike two-surface), Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH), Marginally trapped surface (MTS), Misner-Sharp(-Hernandez) mass
- L3: Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH), Marginally outer trapped tube (MOTT), Past inner trapping horizon, Trapped region, Past-trapped surface, Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH), Trapping boundary, Untrapped surface
- L4: Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH), Space-like future outer horizon (SFOTH), Timelike membrane
- L5: Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH), Past inner trapping horizon, Timelike membrane
- L6: Future outer trapping horizon (FOTH), Past-trapped surface