← all systems · see it in The System
Trapped region
'A trapped region of space-time M is a connected subset T of M such that for all p in T, there exists a trapped surface S' with p in S'. An extension T' of T is a trapped region with T subset T'. An inextendible trapped region is one with no extension.' (Hayward 1994), trapped surfaces being compact spatial 2-surfaces with theta+ theta- > 0.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: every event through which some closed trapped surface passes, in one connected four-dimensional set. Outside: events no trapped surface passes through. Its edge, for an inextendible region, is the trapping boundary: 'a connected component of the boundary of an inextendible trapped region'. |
| nested level | A region of a Lorentzian spacetime filled by trapped surfaces: inside black holes (future case) and white holes (past case), also in the 'cosmological' region of Carter's Lambda > 0 black holes. Field scale; epoch 1 with trapping geometries of tested GR. |
| scale | field |
Measures (4) published science
| dimension of the region | 4 (not 3) dimensions |
| types of marginal surface relevant to its closure | 4 (future or past, outer or inner) count |
| trapped-surface condition | theta+ theta- > 0 on a compact spatial 2-surface |
| characteristic clock: none of its own | changes only as the trapped surfaces it holds change (e.g. on merger) |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-027 Do black holes really have event horizons?
booked: The map follows general relativity: black holes have event horizons. Hawking's 2014 suggestion of apparent horizons only is kept alongside.
the other reading: B: collapse makes apparent (trapping) horizons but no event horizons (Hawking 2014); Hayward takes the future outer trapping horizon
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (8)
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Trapped region mixed
- de Sitter spacetime via sys:spacetime · Trapped region gain
- Apparent horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapped region even
- Trapped surface via sys:spacetime · Trapped region gain
- Trapping horizon via sys:spacetime · Trapped region gain
- Core of the trapped region (Z) via sys:spacetime · Trapped region gain
- Trapping boundary via sys:spacetime · Trapped region gain
- Future trapped region T via sys:spacetime · Trapped region gain
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (11)
- Photon
- Black hole
- de Sitter spacetime
- Apparent horizon
- Trapped surface
- Trapping horizon
- Core of the trapped region (Z)
- Trapping boundary
- Future trapped region T
- Past-trapped region
- Inextendible trapped region
represents (1)
Kinds (4)
wired (1)
Notes published science
- Penrose borrowed the shape from Riemannian geometry (Bonnet-Myers): geodesics that keep bending toward each other must meet, so the space closes up; in spacetime, the future of a trapped region closes off instead.
- In a closed dust universe the boundary of the trapped region is a single instant: the moment of maximum expansion, when the universe turns around and starts to fall back.
- When two black holes merge, Hayward expected the trapped regions to join and the boundary to change topology, leaving 'a ghostly trapping horizon' inside.
- In de Sitter space a trapped sphere passes through every point, so the whole universe is the trapped region and it has no boundary at all.
- In a closed dust universe the trapped region is exactly the contracting half, and its boundary is the instant of recollapse.
- When two black holes collide their trapped regions merge and the edge changes topology, but the old marginal surfaces carry on inside as a 'ghostly trapping horizon'.
- Hayward's trapped region is four-dimensional and needs no notion of inside and outside, unlike Hawking's apparent horizon, which needs a whole asymptotically flat spacetime.
- In a spinning or charged black hole with a positive cosmological constant, trapped surfaces turn up not only in the hole but also in the cosmological region near past infinity.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
signals from inside the trapped region (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Ingoing and outgoing light rays normal to each surface in T, 'both the ingoing and the outgoing light rays are converging' (future case)
- L2: 'all signals from the surface are trapped inside a shrinking region'
trapped region (own, points on closed trapped surfaces; spacetime)
- L1: Trapped surfaces: compact spatial 2-surfaces with theta+ theta- > 0, one through every point of T
- L2: Definition: a connected subset of M, four-dimensional, with trapped rather than outer trapped surfaces ('the inside and outside of a 2-surface cannot be distinguished in general') and no global assumptions
- L3: Time orientation: future trapped (theta+- < 0, black holes) or past trapped (theta+- > 0, white holes); future trapped surfaces exist 'not just in the black-hole region, but also in the cosmological region neighbouring past infinity' of Carter's Lambda > 0 black holes; in de Sitter every point has a marginal surface
- L4: Extension and edge: inextendible trapped regions; a trapping boundary is 'a connected component of the boundary of an inextendible trapped region'; 'In principle, a trapping boundary may not be smooth, and the trapped surfaces may be distributed chaotically near the boundary'
- L5: Marginal surfaces and the regular edge: 'a compact, future or past, outer or inner marginal surface lies in the closure of a trapped region' (Corollary); 'If the boundary of an inextendible trapped region is suitably regular, then it is a (possibly degenerate) trapping horizon'
- L6: Dynamics: 'when black holes collide, the trapped regions merge and the trapping boundary changes topology'; marginal surfaces 'continue into the trapped region, forming a ghostly trapping horizon'