← all systems · see it in The System
Spacetime
In physics, spacetime, or the space-time continuum, is a mathematical model that fuses the three dimensions of space and the one dimension of time into a single four-dimensional continuum. In general relativity spacetime is curved by mass and energy; for physical reasons a spacetime continuum is mathematically defined as a four-dimensional, smooth, connected Lorentzian manifold, whose metric determines the geodesics of particles and light beams.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | ~10^-43 s after the Big Bang |
| born precision | order of magnitude |
| boundary | Inside: the four-dimensional continuum of events with its Lorentzian metric (intervals, proper time, light cones), its curvature, its dynamics as the geometry answers its contents (the field equations, waves at c, cosmic expansion), its global structure (horizons, trapped surfaces, singularities, asymptotic symmetry) and its action on everything in it (free bodies and light follow its geodesics, clocks tick its proper time). Outside: the contents themselves (matter, radiation, dark matter, vacuum energy), which enter as stress-energy. The 2026-10 walk drew the line between spacetime's kinematics and the gravitational field's dynamics (BMS: separable at null infinity); the metric postulates (Will 2014) and the field equations hold both on one object, so this re-walk books the field equations as a shared floor with sys:gravitational-field and keeps the seam as contention C-516 (gravity force or geometry) and C-1206 (geometry or dynamics). The expansion is intrinsic: the universe does not expand into anything. |
| nested level | The arena and an actor: in special relativity a flat, static background (Minkowski); in general relativity curved by its contents and acting on them ('Space-time tells matter how to move; matter tells space-time how to curve'). Every other system's events sit in it; the universe is its largest solution (FLRW). Below the Planck length its own structure is open (contentions C-1300, C-084). |
| scale | field |
Measures (48) published science
| end of the Planck epoch (Planck time) | approximately 10^-43 s |
| dimensions | 3 space + 1 time count |
| space-time scale factor c | nearly 300,000 km per second km/s |
| Poincare group dimension | 10 (3 boosts, 3 rotations, 4 translations) count |
| Minkowski's geometric interpretation | 1908 year |
| BMS asymptotic symmetry result | 1962 year |
| General relativity published | May 1916 date |
| black hole descriptors (no hair) | 11 parameters |
| time since scale factor zero (model-dependent) | 13.787 +/- 0.020 billion years |
| H0, Type Ia supernovae (Riess 2016) | 73.24 +/- 1.74 (km/s)/Mpc |
| H0, Planck 2018 CMB | 67.4 +/- 0.5 (km/s)/Mpc |
| Hubble's original constant, too large by | a factor of 7 ratio |
| inflation expansion | at least e^60 (about 10^26), ~10^-32 s after the Big Bang scale factor |
| radiation epoch scale factor growth | proportional to t^(1/2) law |
| matter epoch scale factor growth | proportional to t^(2/3) law |
| radiation-to-matter transition | about 50,000 years after the Big Bang |
| expansion began to accelerate | around 9.8 billion years after the Big Bang (4 billion years ago) time |
| dark energy began to dominate | around 3 billion years ago, at about 11 billion years time |
| inflection to dark-energy-dominated era (Chronology) | about five or six billion years ago time |
| dark energy share of mass-energy | 68 % |
| flatness (Planck) | within 1/2 percent |
| characteristic clock: proper time along a world line | the time a clock riding the world line reads; in the source's example a proper time of 5 metres (approximately 1.67e-8 s), read as 5.24 m (1.75e-8 s) by an observer when the clock moves at 0.3 c |
| characteristic clock: doubling time of distances under inflation | 10^-37 (expansion lasted at least 10^-35 s) |
| GW150914 peak strain | 1.0 x 10^-21 dimensionless |
| GW150914 energy radiated in gravitational waves | 3.0 +/- 0.5 (90% credible) solar masses x c^2 |
| GW150914 masses: initial 36 and 29, final 62 | 36, 29 -> 62 solar masses |
| GW150914 luminosity distance | 410 (+160/-180) Mpc |
| characteristic clock: GW150914's last inspiral cycles | 0.2 (about 8 cycles, 35 to 150 Hz) |
| speed of gravity minus speed of light (fraction of c) | between -3 x 10^-15 and +7 x 10^-16 dimensionless |
| characteristic clock: delay between GW170817 and its gamma-ray burst | 1.74 +/- 0.05 s |
| Gravity Probe B geodetic drift | -6,601.8 +/- 18.3 (GR: -6,606.1) mas/yr |
| Gravity Probe B frame-dragging drift | -37.2 +/- 7.2 (GR: -39.2) mas/yr |
| PSR B1913+16 orbital decay, observed / GR | 0.9983 +/- 0.0016 ratio |
| characteristic clock: PSR B1913+16 orbital period decay (intrinsic) | (-2.398 +/- 0.004) x 10^-12 s/s |
| Cassini Shapiro-delay test, gamma - 1 | (2.1 +/- 2.3) x 10^-5 dimensionless |
| M87* emission ring diameter | 42 +/- 3 microarcseconds |
| M87* central mass | (6.5 +/- 0.7) x 10^9 solar masses |
| fractional frequency uncertainty between two regions of a millimetre-scale strontium sample | 7.6 x 10^-21 dimensionless |
| GPS constant clock-rate correction (gravitational plus second-order Doppler) | -4.4647 x 10^-10 (about 38.6 microseconds a day: our arithmetic, x 86,400 s) fractional rate |
| holographic information bound per area | 1.4 x 10^69 bits per square metre |
| linear Lorentz-violation scale from GRB 090510 | M_QG,1 / M_Planck >= several (Planck mass energy about 1.22 x 10^19 GeV) ratio |
| H0, Planck 2018 (paper) | 67.4 +/- 0.5 km/s/Mpc |
| matter density parameter, Planck 2018 | 0.315 +/- 0.007 dimensionless |
| CMB energy kept per photon since decoupling | about 1/1,089 (~0.09%) fraction |
| characteristic clock: time cells in the human hippocampus mark moments within a task | time fields within a trial (no single number given in the abstract read) |
| linear Lorentz-violation scale from GRB 221009A (LHAASO) | > 10 (95% CL) Planck energies (E_QG,1 / E_Pl) |
| quadratic Lorentz-violation scale from GRB 221009A (LHAASO) | > 6 x 10^-8 (95% CL) Planck energies (E_QG,2 / E_Pl) |
| gravitational coupling relative to the fine-structure constant | about 10^-43 (43 orders of magnitude smaller) ratio |
Open contentions (12) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-031 Is the cosmological constant the energy of empty space, or a separate constant of nature?
booked: The map includes the cosmological constant but leaves its origin open, listing both ideas.
the other reading: vacuum zero-point energy / an independent constant - C-046 Does the energy carried by gravitational waves itself create gravity?
booked: The map counts gravity's own energy as a source of gravity, as the lunar laser tests support, and keeps the opposite assumption alongside.
the other reading: it does / it does not, as in the registry - C-062 How fast is the universe expanding: 67.4 or about 74 km/s/Mpc?
booked: The map uses the Planck 2018 value of 67.4 km/s/Mpc and its age of 13.8 billion years, and keeps the distance-ladder value of about 74 alongside.
the other reading: the other value - C-516 Is gravity a force, or the shape of spacetime?
booked: The map lists gravity among the forces, as Newton described it, and keeps general relativity's view that it is curved spacetime alongside.
the other reading: gravity as a force (Newton's reading, kept in the force walk) - C-884 Is gravity quantum or classical?
booked: The map describes gravity with classical general relativity, which agrees with every test so far, and notes that no feasible lab test of quantum gravity exists yet.
the other reading: quantum: a field that mediates entanglement must be quantum (Marletto-Vedral 2017; Bose 2017 test proposed) / classical with stochastic coupling, testable by the decoherence-diffusion trade-off, part of its parameter space already excluded (Oppenheim 2018, 2023) - C-1190 Is Lorentz invariance an exact law of nature?
booked: The map treats it as exact as far as tested, with no violation found, and notes theoretical suggestions that it could fail near the Planck energy.
the other reading: not exact at the Planck scale; LHAASO 2024: linear violation scale beyond 10 E_Pl, quadratic beyond 6 x 10^-8 E_Pl - C-1206 Is special relativity about the geometry of spacetime or the forces in rods and clocks?
booked: The map lists both readings and rules neither.
the other reading: either alone - C-1271 Is information destroyed when a black hole evaporates?
booked: The map doesn't rule and keeps both: information lost, or carried back out in the radiation.
the other reading: newer: the island and replica-wormhole calculation gives a Page curve consistent with unitary evaporation (Almheiri et al. 2021 review), adding weight to reading B in these models - C-1299 Could spacetime itself emerge from quantum entanglement?
booked: The map lists the proposals and notes that the question remains open.
the other reading: spacetime and time as fundamental, entanglement living in them; most of the derivations work in anti-de Sitter models or at first order around the vacuum, and assume the area-entropy law (Dorau-Much: 'Under the assumption of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy-area formula') - C-1300 Is spacetime fundamental or does it emerge from something deeper?
booked: The map doesn't rule. It describes classical spacetime as tested from millimetres to billions of light-years, noting quantum effects are expected at the Planck length.
the other reading: fundamental and quantised (loop quantum gravity, spin foams, causal sets: C-084) / emergent from entanglement in a non-perturbative quantum gravity (Van Raamsdonk 2010; the holographic bound, Bousso 2002) / continuous to beyond the Planck scale at first order (GRB 090510 limit) / (newer, 2014-2026) the field equation as an equation of state of underlying degrees of freedom, not to be quantised directly (Jacobson 1995; C-1655) / discrete at root with Lorentz invariance kept (causal sets, Surya 2019) or a Planckian regime reached by computation (CDT, Loll 2019) / spacetime kept fundamentally classical with stochastic coupling to quantum matter (Oppenheim 2018; C-884). Tests: LHAASO 2024 pushes the linear energy-dependent light-speed limit past 10 Planck energies (no graininess seen); the gravity-induced entanglement test (Bose 2017, Marletto-Vedral 2017) is proposed, not yet run - C-1301 Is spacetime a thing in its own right, or just relations between events?
booked: The map doesn't rule. It records what spacetime does and lists the views alongside.
the other reading: substantivalism (spacetime a thing in its own right; target of the revived hole argument, Earman and Norton 1987) / relationism (only relations among events and contents) / the argument blocked by mathematical practice (Weatherall) - C-1658 Is gravity a fundamental force, or does it emerge the way pressure emerges from a gas?
booked: The map rules neither: Einstein's equation as the basic law of gravity, and as an equation of state from horizon thermodynamics (Jacobson 1995, Dorau & Much 2026).
the other reading: either alone; the derivations assume the area-entropy law and work at first order or in model spacetimes, so whether the equation is fundamental or emergent is not settled by them
Cross-scale patterns seen here (12) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Spacetime. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- causal ceiling (structural)
Horizons cap what any observer can reach: a black hole's interior, and with a cosmological constant a cosmic event horizon beyond which 'many systems exist whose light can never reach us'. Set by the causal structure, not by instruments. - conservation law plus closure (structural)
The field equations (with energy-momentum conserved) leave the contents open; cosmology 'requires Einstein's field equations together with a way of calculating the density', an equation of state, before it predicts the expansion. Turned the other way by Jacobson 1995: the Einstein equation itself re - nested ladder (structural)
The causal ladder: the conditions a spacetime can meet, from chronological up to globally hyperbolic, form 'a hierarchy of causality conditions, each one of which is strictly stronger than the previous'; the full ladder constructed by Minguzzi and Sanchez. - not-diluting wins (structural)
Dark energy keeps its density while matter thins: 'when the volume doubles, dark matter density halves while dark energy density is nearly unchanged'; the thinning of matter reduces its ability to decelerate the expansion, and dark energy, 'a constant factor', comes to dominate (loop 4). - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
One spacetime, sliced differently by each observer: in special relativity 'how different observers perceive where and when events occur' differs, and each clock reads its own proper time (GPS clocks beat 4.4647 x 10^-10 fast against ground clocks). The human brain carves its own slice too: place cel - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (partial)
The geometry's own equations predicted members found later: gravitational waves ('the first direct detection', 2015) and the shadow of a horizon ('consistent with expectations for the shadow of a Kerr black hole as predicted by general relativity', 2019). - same role, different builds (partial)
A horizon that glows thermally, built three ways: by a black hole (Hawking: 'black holes emit Hawking radiation with a perfect thermal spectrum'), by acceleration through empty space (Unruh: an accelerating observer 'will perceive a thermal bath'), and by the local Rindler horizons through every poi - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
A black hole's horizon and the inflating patch's horizon: 'the spacetime is like an inside-out Schwarzschild black hole: each object is surrounded by a spherical event horizon'. One traps from outside in, the other cuts each object off from outside. - templating (partial)
One local module at every event: 'Locally, as expressed in the equivalence principle, spacetime is Minkowskian'; the manifold walk books the same template at its metric floor. - trade one property for another (partial)
If spacetime is classical and quantum matter couples to it, 'a trade-off between the rate of this decoherence and the degree of diffusion' holds: 'long coherence times require strong diffusion in phase-space'. Theories settle at points along the dial; experiments squeeze the dial from both ends ('pa - who opens the door (partial)
Every crossing into spacetime is open field: in this walk's routes curvature responds to any stress-energy with nothing addressed, light follows whatever null geodesics the geometry offers, and a horizon traps whatever crosses (listeners booked 'none: open field'). The only prepared doors are on the - same toolkit, independent builds (surface)
Five programmes recover Einstein's equation from entropy plus horizon area: thermodynamics on local horizons (Jacobson 1995), vacuum entanglement equilibrium (Jacobson 2016), the holographic entanglement first law (Faulkner et al. 2014), Hilbert-space entanglement (Cao-Carroll-Michalakis 2017), modu
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (84) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Photon via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch) via sys:gravitational-field · Spacetime gain
- Dark energy via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Inflaton field via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Gravitational field via sys:gravitational-field · Spacetime even
- Neutron star via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Black hole via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Galaxy via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Big Bang via sys:gravitational-field · Spacetime even
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Special relativity via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Gravitational wave via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Quantum entanglement via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- General relativity via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Gravity via sys:gravitational-field · Spacetime even
- Standard Model of particle physics via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Magnetic monopoles (hypothetical relics) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Quintessence field (hypothesised alternative) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Competition: inflationary dilution via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Phantom dark energy (phantom energy; hypothesised) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime loss
- Schwarzschild spacetime via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Anti-de Sitter spacetime via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Event horizon via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Horizon (general relativity) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Moduli (moduli fields; projected model) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Stably causal spacetime via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Globally hyperbolic spacetime via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Pseudo-Riemannian (semi-Riemannian) manifold via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Quintom dark energy (quintom scenario; hypothesised) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Interacting dark energy (coupled dark sector; hypothesised) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- k-essence (kinetic quintessence; hypothesised) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Asymptotic safety in quantum gravity (walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Causal dynamical triangulation (CDT; walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Spin foam (covariant loop quantum gravity; walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Radiation stress-energy (ultra-relativistic, w = 1/3) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Hilbert stress-energy tensor (metric energy-momentum tensor) via sys:stress-energy · Spacetime mixed
- Stress-energy-momentum pseudotensor (gravitational energy-momentum) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Dominant energy condition (DEC) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Spacetime interval (Lorentz interval) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Euclidean space via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Hyperbolic space via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Neutron star magnetosphere via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Spacetime event via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Minkowski spacetime via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Quantum Einstein gravity (walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Torsion tensor (of an affine connection; Einstein-Cartan gravity) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Closed string (projected model) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- 4-simplex (5-cell, pentachoron) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Complex spacetime via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Conformal boundary (conformal infinity) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Flux energy condition (FEC) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Strengthened dominant energy condition (SDEC) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Wave function of the universe (quantum state of a closed universe; hypothetical) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Lorentzian metric via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Spectral triple via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Finite noncommutative space F via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Averaged null energy condition (ANEC) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Smooth (differentiable) manifold via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Finsler manifold via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Quantum field theory in curved spacetime (quantum matter on a fixed classical background; walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Observable universe via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Real number (the practice of measuring the continuum, and the complete ordered field) via sys:sensory-environment · Spacetime even
- Quantum field theory via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Cosmic string via sys:spacetime · Spacetime mixed
- Time-orientable Lorentzian metric via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Speed of light via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Hypersurface (codimension-one submanifold of spacetime) via sys:spacetime · Spacetime even
- Time via sys:spacetime · Spacetime gain
- Geodesic focusing via sys:spacetime · Spacetime loss
- … 4 more
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (18)
- Gravitational field
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
- Dark energy
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Spacetime event
- Metric tensor
- Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity)
- Competition: inflationary dilution
- Matter's attraction and dark energy over the expansion rate
- Five-dimensional spacetime (Kaluza-Klein)
- Bouncing no-boundary history (classical history of the no-boundary state that bounces; hypothetical)
- Initially singular no-boundary history (classical history of the no-boundary state that starts at a singularity; hypothetical)
- Tunneling wave function (Vilenkin; universe from nothing; hypothetical)
- M-theory on G2 manifolds (projected model)
- Quantum fluctuation
- Event horizon of a non-rotating black hole
- Event horizon of a rotating black hole
- Universe
Sits inside / holds (252)
- Photon
- Inflaton field
- Big Bang
- Universe
- Galaxy
- Standard Model of particle physics
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity)
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy)
- Schwarzschild spacetime
- Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
- Kerr spacetime
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- de Sitter spacetime
- Anti-de Sitter spacetime
- Goedel universe
- Taub-NUT spacetime
- Event horizon
- Horizon (general relativity)
- Apparent horizon
- Non-totally vicious spacetime
- Chronological spacetime
- Causal spacetime
- Distinguishing spacetime
- Strongly causal spacetime
- Stably causal spacetime
- Causally continuous spacetime
- Causally simple spacetime
- Globally hyperbolic spacetime
- Riemannian manifold (positive-definite geometry; space at one time)
- Pseudo-Riemannian (semi-Riemannian) manifold
- Gravitational wave background (stochastic background)
- Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical)
- Causal dynamical triangulation (CDT; walked as a projected model)
- Causal set theory (causal sets programme; walked as a projected model)
- Semiclassical gravity (quantum matter on classical curved spacetime; walked as a projected model)
- Spin foam (covariant loop quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
- Loop quantum cosmology (LQC; walked as a projected model)
- Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0)
- Radiation stress-energy (ultra-relativistic, w = 1/3)
- Scalar-field stress-energy (Klein-Gordon field as a source)
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Causal set element (hypothetical discrete event)
- Timelike separation (timelike interval)
- Spacetime interval (Lorentz interval)
- Lightlike (null) separation
- Spacelike separation (spacelike interval)
- Absolute elsewhere (spacelike region)
- Light cone (null cone)
- Causal future (absolute future)
- Causal past (absolute past)
- World line
- Minkowski metric (inner product)
- Generalized Minkowski spacetime (any number of dimensions)
- Complexified Minkowski spacetime
- Euclidean space
- Hyperbolic space
- Shape of the universe
- Primordial Era (the universe before the first stars)
- Gravitational wave
- Spacetime event
- Minkowski spacetime
- Ultimate fate of the universe
- Universal cover of anti-de Sitter space
- Maximally symmetric spacetime
- Trapped surface
- Null geodesic
- Trapping horizon
- Dynamical horizon
- Isolated horizon
- Torsion tensor (of an affine connection; Einstein-Cartan gravity)
- Holonomy (parallel transport round closed loops; its trace is the Wilson loop)
- Regge calculus (classical and quantum)
- Horava-Lifshitz gravity (walked as a projected model)
- Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet)
- Causal space (Kronheimer and Penrose 1967)
- Causal set grown by classical sequential growth
- Standard static spacetime
- … 172 more
expressed by (2)
floor filled by (135)
- Photon
- Gravitational field
- Electromagnetic field
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
- Cosmic neutrino background
- Dark matter
- Dark energy
- Inflaton field
- Neutron star
- Black hole
- Cosmic microwave background
- Galaxy
- Big Bang
- Earth
- Baryonic matter
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Special relativity
- Gravitational wave
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
- Ultimate fate of the universe
- General relativity
- Universe
- Photon-baryon plasma
- Supermassive black hole
- Competition for free neutrons in Big Bang nucleosynthesis
- Competition for free electrons at recombination (hydrogen vs helium)
- Standard Model of particle physics
- Photon-baryon fluid (partnership)
- Competition for each baryon overdensity (photon pressure vs gravitational collapse)
- Magnetic monopoles (hypothetical relics)
- Quintessence field (hypothesised alternative)
- Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity)
- Competition: inflationary dilution
- No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical)
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy)
- Phantom dark energy (phantom energy; hypothesised)
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- Event horizon
- Non-totally vicious spacetime
- Chronological spacetime
- Causal spacetime
- Distinguishing spacetime
- Strongly causal spacetime
- Stably causal spacetime
- Causally continuous spacetime
- Causally simple spacetime
- Globally hyperbolic spacetime
- Pseudo-Riemannian (semi-Riemannian) manifold
- Gravitational wave background (stochastic background)
- Interacting dark energy (coupled dark sector; hypothesised)
- k-essence (kinetic quintessence; hypothesised)
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
- Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model)
- Asymptotic safety in quantum gravity (walked as a projected model)
- Causal dynamical triangulation (CDT; walked as a projected model)
- Semiclassical gravity (quantum matter on classical curved spacetime; walked as a projected model)
- Bosonic string theory (projected model; the original string theory)
- Spin foam (covariant loop quantum gravity; walked as a projected model)
- Loop quantum cosmology (LQC; walked as a projected model)
- Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0)
- Radiation stress-energy (ultra-relativistic, w = 1/3)
- Scalar-field stress-energy (Klein-Gordon field as a source)
- Hilbert stress-energy tensor (metric energy-momentum tensor)
- Weak energy condition (WEC)
- Dominant energy condition (DEC)
- Absolute elsewhere (spacelike region)
- Light cone (null cone)
- Causal future (absolute future)
- Causal past (absolute past)
- Primordial Era (the universe before the first stars)
- Neutron star magnetosphere
- Spacetime event
- Minkowski spacetime
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense)
- Grand unification epoch
- Maximally symmetric spacetime
- Null geodesic
- … 55 more
represents (3)
- Noncommutative geometry (as a projected model of spacetime and quantum gravity)
- Palatial twistor theory
- the idea of Spacetime, as held by science
Kinds (37)
- Schwarzschild spacetime
- Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime
- Kerr spacetime
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- de Sitter spacetime
- Anti-de Sitter spacetime
- Goedel universe
- Taub-NUT spacetime
- Minkowski spacetime
- Causal space (Kronheimer and Penrose 1967)
- Tipler cylinder
- Van Stockum dust
- Misner space
- Bonnor-Steadman solutions
- Traversable wormhole
- Complex spacetime
- Kerr-Newman spacetime
- Ernst vacuum
- Kerr-Vaidya null dust
- Chandrasekhar-Ferrari colliding plane wave vacuum
- Interior Schwarzschild metric
- Lorentzian wormhole
- Two spinning particles on an axis (approximate vacuum solution)
- Charge and magnetic dipole on an axis (approximate solution)
- Finite spinning rod (exact, Papapetrou class)
- Spinning C-metric
- Colliding plane wave spacetime
- Alcubierre warp drive spacetime
- Kerr-Newman-de Sitter spacetime
- Extreme Kerr throat (near-horizon extreme Kerr)
- Majumdar-Papapetrou spacetime
- Kerr-Newman-NUT spacetime
- Vaidya spacetime
- Anti-Mach spacetimes
- Lorentzian torus (2-D Minkowski with both directions identified)
- Minkowski spacetime with periodic time
- Spinning cosmic string
wired (16)
- Gravitational field
- Dark matter
- Dark energy
- Inflaton field
- Photon
- Neutron
- Magnetic monopoles (hypothetical relics)
- Cosmic web
- Gravitational wave
- Induced metric
- Baryonic matter
- Quintessence field (hypothesised alternative)
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- QCD vacuum
- G2 manifold (Joyce manifold)
Notes published science
- Gravity's own energy has weight: Earth carries about 20 times more of its mass as gravitational self-energy than the Moon does, yet the two fall toward the Sun together to 1.3 parts in 10^13, as general relativity says they must. (src:murphy-2013-llr)
- Time runs at a measurably different rate at the top and the bottom of a cloud of atoms only one millimetre tall: the bend in spacetime has been read across a gap thinner than a fingernail is long (src:bothwell-2022).
- GPS satellites' clocks are set to run slow on purpose before launch, by about 38 microseconds a day, because up there the bent geometry makes them run fast; without it the system would drift off (src:ashby-2003-gps).
- In 2017 a ripple of spacetime and a flash of gamma rays from the same collision crossed more than a hundred million light years and arrived 1.7 seconds apart: gravity travels at the speed of light to within a few parts in a thousand trillion (src:abbott-2017-gw170817-grb).
- The 'elsewhere' is thick: unlike the Newtonian present it is 'not a 3-dimensional volume but is instead a 4-dimensional spacetime region', and Earth's world line is a helix that never returns to the same point.
- An event is known by its past: in a past-distinguishing spacetime 'two points which share the same chronological past are the same point'. Its identity is the set of everything that could have reached it.
- In Minkowski spacetime two different events can be zero distance apart: 'the interval between two distinct events can be zero. This occurs when one event is on the light cone of the other.' Light's whole journey across the universe has no length in the geometry it lives in.
- Hyperbolic geometry, which cannot be drawn in ordinary space one dimension up, fits perfectly inside Minkowski spacetime: 'Hyperbolic spaces can be isometrically embedded in spaces of one more dimension when the embedding space is endowed with the Minkowski metric'.
- The universe ends in islands: after about 150 billion years nothing outside the Local Supercluster can ever touch us again, and by 2 trillion years even gamma rays from those galaxies are stretched longer than the observable universe. The same horizon that isolates us also limits a vacuum-decay bubble: galaxies more than 4.2 gigaparsecs apart would be spared. The Enclave shape that spacetime owns is what makes any part of the universe survivable.
- 'Now' is thick: unlike the Newtonian present, the elsewhere 'is not a 3-dimensional volume but is instead a 4-dimensional spacetime region', and each observer's 'now' is just one slice through it.
- Its spacetime is 4-dimensional for us and 2-dimensional at the Planck scale, the same as CDT finds.
- The Belinfante fix is the gravity twin of a magnet's bound current: spin gradients carry 'bound momentum', and it is free plus bound energy-momentum that curves spacetime, just as free plus bound currents make the magnetic field.
- Spacetime in CDT is a geodesic dome: flat everywhere inside each simplex, curved only where they meet.
- Near the Planck scale CDT spacetime looks 2-dimensional, the same answer asymptotic safety gets by a completely different route.
- An event is known by its past: in a past-distinguishing spacetime 'two points which share the same chronological past are the same point'.
- The night sky is the past cone: 'When we observe the sky at night, we basically see only the past light cone within the entire spacetime.'
- Two ingredients rebuild spacetime: who-can-influence-whom (the order) and how-many (the count). Sorkin: 'Order + Number = Geometry'.
- The whole difference between 'no time travel for observers' and 'no time travel for light' is one closed light ray: a chronological but non-causal spacetime always has a closed lightlike geodesic (Theorem 3.8).
- The volume of an event's past becomes a clock: in a causally continuous spacetime the past and future volume functions are themselves time functions.
- Static spacetimes are always causally continuous, and they climb to the top of the ladder exactly when a rescaled space metric g_S/beta is complete (Proposition 3.87).
- 'No compact spacetime (M,g) is chronological': a finite (compact) universe always contains a timelike loop; the proof is four lines of covering argument (Theorem 3.6).
- Chronology can be read off a clock built from volumes: the spacetime is chronological exactly when the volume of an event's past strictly grows along every observer's history (Theorem 3.49).
- In this model an electron's motion and spin become one complex vector: rho = u + is, four-velocity plus i times spin, so a spin state lives in a 'complexified' copy of spacetime rather than in a separate spinor space.
- One spacetime, three universes: de Sitter space can be sliced as a flat, an open or a closed FLRW universe, and its global slicing is 'conformally equivalent to Einstein static universe' - the static universe Einstein wanted and the ever-expanding one de Sitter found are the same geometry seen two ways.
- In a distinguishing spacetime the order alone rebuilds the geometry: J+ 'determines the metric, up to a conformal factor' (Remark 3.14). Who-can-influence-whom is enough to recover the light cones.
- Past and future can distinguish separately: remove one point and a half line from a cylinder and you get a spacetime that tells events apart by their pasts but not by their futures.
- In 1935 Robertson and Walker 'rigorously proved that the FLRW metric is the only one on a spacetime that is spatially homogeneous and isotropic', a geometric result 'not tied specifically to the equations of general relativity': assume the universe looks the same everywhere and in every direction, and its geometry is forced.
- Friedmann's 1924 paper showed that 'the finiteness of spacetime was not a property that could be established based on the equations of general relativity alone': the same local equations allow a finite and an infinite universe.
- Eleven is a ceiling: in 1978 Werner Nahm showed that 'the maximum spacetime dimension in which one can formulate a consistent supersymmetric theory is eleven' - the dimension of M-theory.
- The flat stage in any dimension already contains curved ones: de Sitter space and hyperbolic space are submanifolds of a Minkowski spacetime one dimension up.
- Compact causal diamonds are read physically as 'no losses of information/energy in the spacetime': nothing is suddenly lost or created at an edge, so no naked singularity can be seen.
- Every globally hyperbolic spacetime splits as R x S with metric -beta dT^2 + g_T: space and time can be globally separated, 'in a highly non-unique way' (Bernal and Sanchez).
- Locally every spacetime is globally hyperbolic: each event has arbitrarily small globally hyperbolic neighbourhoods (Theorem 2.14).
- Tilt the cones far enough and they can loop: 'if a series of such light cones are set up so as to loop back on themselves', an object in free fall 'would repeatedly return to the same point in spacetime'.
- Zero distance between two different places: in Minkowski spacetime 'the interval between two distinct events can be zero', when one is on the light cone of the other.
- No clock can ride a null line: 'For lightlike paths, there exists no concept of proper time and it is undefined as the spacetime interval is zero. Instead, an arbitrary and physically irrelevant affine parameter unrelated to time must be introduced' (src:wp:proper-time).
- Any compact spacetime with a timelike conformal Killing field is totally vicious: every event lies on a timelike loop and 'giving more and more rounds' makes the time-separation infinite (Theorem 3.3).
- The weakest rung is the only one not inherited by open subsets: cut a piece out of a non-totally vicious spacetime and the piece can be totally vicious.
- In the spectral picture the Higgs field is geometry: spacetime is an ordinary manifold times a tiny finite noncommutative space, and the Higgs and gauge fields are the 'distances' across that finite part.
- A manifold, a metric and one integer pair (p, q): continuity forbids the signature from changing anywhere on a connected manifold, so a spacetime cannot be 'timelike here and timeless there'.
- Light from the farthest quasars arrives as sharp as expected, so spacetime is smooth down to a thousandth of a hydrogen nucleus.
- Spacetime exists because space and time do not: 'The fundamental reason for merging space and time into spacetime is that space and time are separately not invariant.'
- The finiteness of the whole sum over quantum spacetimes needs the cosmological constant to be positive.
- Stable causality is causality with a margin: open the light cones a little and nothing goes wrong; and that margin is exactly what lets you hang a global clock on the spacetime (Hawking 1969; Bernal and Sanchez 2005 made the clock smooth).
- Any simply connected two-dimensional spacetime is stably causal (Theorem 3.55): in 1+1 dimensions without holes, time travel is impossible by topology alone.
- Every spacetime is strongly causal in the small (Remark 2.15): the bad behaviour of the lower rungs is always global, never local.
- Charles Misner hid the string by making time periodic, which fills the whole spacetime with time loops.
- In twistor theory a point of spacetime is not basic: it is a whole line (a Riemann sphere) inside twistor space, and light rays are the points.
- Three-dimensional gravity in AdS may be dual to a CFT with monster-group symmetry (Witten 2007): the largest sporadic finite group showing up as the symmetry of a quantum black-hole spacetime.
- AdS3 is a group: Carlip identifies it 'with the universal covering space of the group SL(2, R)', so the spacetime and its symmetry are the same object.
- The theory gives up on particles and on a single vacuum and keeps only what can be measured in each patch of spacetime; it then proves that no one vacuum can be picked consistently in every spacetime.
- AQG holds every curved spacetime at once: each background is just a sector you reach by choosing a coherent state.
- A charge sitting on the axis of a bar magnet cannot be described by a static spacetime: the field forces the geometry to rotate, and near the axis time closes into loops. 'We surely cannot believe that ... a charge and a magnet constitute a time machine!'
- GW170817's gravitational waves and light arrived with distances that agree, telling us the waves felt D = 4.02 (+0.07, -0.10) spacetime dimensions.
- A Cauchy surface does not have to be smooth: even in flat spacetime the cone t^2 = (x^2+y^2+z^2)/2 is one, with a kink at the origin.
- Whole universes from one slice: in a globally hyperbolic spacetime the Einstein equations need only data on one instant, and 'all Cauchy hypersurfaces are homeomorphic'.
- The nearest neighbours of a point in a random discrete spacetime are infinitely many: links pile up along the light cone, out to infinity. Locality and discreteness pull against each other.
- In a totally vicious spacetime the cut disappears: everything is in every event's future and past.
- In 2d causal set quantum gravity a smooth spacetime appears as one phase of a sum over all orders, with a first-order transition to a crystal-like non-manifold phase, much like an Ising magnet; and the smooth phase comes with a negative cosmological constant generated by the dynamics.
- Strip spacetime down to 'who can reach whom' and 'who can reach whom slower than light', and you still hold nine-tenths of the metric in 4D (Finkelstein). Only the volume is lost.
- Penrose and Kronheimer wrote these axioms in 1967 partly so that spacetime could turn out to be 'a locally countable or discrete event-space': the seed of the causal set programme 20 years early.
- A causal space is the same kind of object as the 'way-below' structures of computer-science domain theory (a poset with an auxiliary relation): spacetime causality and program semantics share a skeleton.
- A clock made of futures: in a globally hyperbolic spacetime t(p) = log(m(I-(p))/m(I+(p))) is a time function; time runs as your future shrinks and your past grows.
- A point is its future: in a future-distinguishing spacetime 'two points which share the same chronological future are the same point'.
- A point is its past: in a past-distinguishing spacetime 'two points which share the same chronological past are the same point'.
- The topology of spacetime can be rebuilt from these pasts: the Alexandrov topology, 'generated by the chronological futures and pasts of all the points', equals the manifold topology exactly when spacetime is strongly causal.
- The same rules, read as Ising spins sitting on causal relations, make matter appear from pure spacetime growth: matter 'without having to be built in at the fundamental level'.
- The string is 'seriously high-maintenance' (Tong): asking one closed loop to stay Weyl-invariant hands you Einstein's equations for the whole spacetime it moves in.
- In twistor geometry a spacetime point is literally a 2-plane in C^4, and that 2-plane is the spinor space at the point: spin comes free with the geometry.
- Euclidean, Lorentzian and split-signature spacetimes are three real slices of one complex space, and passing between them is analytic continuation.
- In complex spacetime the left- and right-handed halves of the gravitational field come apart, so a spacetime can be curved on one side and flat on the other.
- Wick rotation, the standard trick of quantum field theory, is a walk from the real Lorentzian slice of complex spacetime to its Euclidean slice and back.
- Only four sizes are possible (1, 2, 4, 8) and spacetime seems to know it: the Lorentz groups in 3, 4, 6 and 10 dimensions are exactly SL(2) over R, C, H and O, and 10 is the superstring's dimension.
- Infinity, brought into view: rescale the metric by a factor that vanishes far away and all of Minkowski spacetime fits inside a finite piece of the Einstein cylinder, with its edge made of two points, two light-cone sheets and one point for all of space at infinity.
- The edge of spacetime is where gravity's energy can be weighed: the Bondi mass of an isolated system, and how fast radiation drains it, are read off at null infinity.
- The conformal group of our 4D spacetime is the Lorentz group of a 6D world with two times (O(2,4)): one extra space and one extra time dimension, and Penrose's twistors live on its four-fold cover SU(2,2).
- Every spacetime with a time loop is 'timelike multiply connected', even when the space itself has no holes (Monroe's folk theorem).
- With a cosmological constant there are no pure translations: moving from place to place in de Sitter spacetime mixes a shift with a conformal transformation, at a scale of about 10^28 cm.
- Four is the odd dimension: in 1, 2 and 3 dimensions every manifold has one smooth structure; R^4, the shape of spacetime, has exotic ones.
- In the classical limit the quantum spacetime leaves behind Minkowski space times two copies of TS^2, and the two-point set {1, -1} 'recalls Connes' theory of the standard model'.
- A test with only four numbers: the traces of the first four powers of the Einstein tensor must be R, R^2, R^3, R^4 (with signs) or the spacetime cannot be filled with dust. Almost no spacetime passes.
- 'An event horizon may well be developing in the room you are now sitting in anticipation of a gravitational collapse ... a million years from now'; the dynamical horizon only appears where spacetime is actually curved.
- Gravitational-wave energy has a clean, gauge-invariant meaning right at a growing black hole, where waves can no longer be pictured as ripples on flat spacetime.
- All of general relativity's field equations come out of one number per geometry: the total curvature R summed over spacetime, made stationary.
- Empty spacetime with a cosmological constant is exactly this shape: the Einstein condition and Einstein's vacuum equation are the same sentence.
- Five different gravitational energy definitions (Einstein, Tolman, Landau-Lifshitz, Papapetrou, Weinberg) give exactly the same energy map for every Kerr-Schild spacetime, and for a charged hole they match Penrose's quasi-local mass.
- Every stationary, axisymmetric vacuum spacetime, the Kerr black hole included, is one solution of a single complex equation, and the equation is integrable like a soliton equation.
- Spacetime's distance is Pythagoras with one sign flipped.
- Spacetime with this internal space is 4 + 6 = 10-dimensional in KO-homology, the same number as superstring theory, and CCM note it 'may perhaps be realized as a low energy truncation' of compact string fibres.
- If spacetime were even slightly Finslerian, hydrogen's Lyman-alpha line would split; it does not, which pins the Finsler coefficients near 10^-24 while the Solar system only manages 10^-3.
- Each block is perfectly flat; all of spacetime's curvature lives on the triangles where blocks meet, like the panels of a geodesic dome.
- Every massive thing in the universe moves through spacetime at the same rate: 'the magnitude of the four-velocity for any object is always a fixed constant: ||U||^2 = -c^2'. Speeding up in space only tilts the vector; it never lengthens it.
- Gravity Probe B measured Earth dragging spacetime at -37.2 +- 7.2 milliarcseconds per year against Einstein's -39.2.
- In the Schwarzschild vacuum the slices of the Lemaitre observers are flat Euclidean space: 'a remarkable and rather special property ... most spacetimes do not admit a slicing into flat spatial sections'.
- Remove one point and a half line from a rolled-up cylinder and you get a spacetime whose events are told apart by their pasts but not by their futures (Fig. 6): the two halves of the condition really are separate.
- The size of an event's future is a clock exactly when this half holds: t+(p) = -m(I+(p)) increases along every causal curve if and only if the spacetime is future-distinguishing (Theorem 3.51).
- The stay-at-home twin ages more because he is on the geodesic: timelike geodesics 'maximize the proper time ... the one who stays home is basically on a geodesic, and therefore experiences more proper time' (Carroll). Straight lines in spacetime are the longest, not the shortest.
- Mercury's books: of 5601 arcsec per century of observed advance, 5025 is the equinoxes, 532 the other planets, and the last 43 is the geodesic of curved spacetime (GR computes 42.9).
- A singularity 'cannot be determined by where or when': it is not a place in spacetime but a hole in it, and a black hole's one 'at no time can it be objectively said to have formed' for anyone outside.
- Near the centre of a real (perturbed) hole space does not crush smoothly: it oscillates chaotically, the squeeze axis flipping again and again (BKL), a drum roll at the end of spacetime.
- Its Feynman diagrams are spacetimes: where ordinary field theory draws particles meeting at points, GFT draws tetrahedra glued along triangles, and the sum over diagrams is a sum over all shapes and topologies of space.
- The symmetry of a flat spacetime with n space dimensions is, all at once, the full symmetry of a curved de Sitter universe one dimension down: O(4,1) is both the Lorentz group of a 5D flat world and the isometry group of dS4.
- Every timelike curve gets an end: the IPs add 'ideal points to the spacetime so that any timelike curve acquires some endpoint in the completed space'.
- One equation, three homes: the clock curve, the space of all velocities (hyperbolic geometry) and de Sitter spacetime are the same hyperbola in different dimensions.
- Flat empty spacetime already has one: the light planes x = t and x = -t, where a boost's symmetry turns null. The de Sitter universe has one at r = sqrt(3/Lambda) that should glow at (1/2 pi) sqrt(Lambda/3).
- Spin-foam histories that can knot and link: quantum spacetime with braids in it.
- Whether a closed universe can carry a light-cone structure at all is decided by one number, its Euler characteristic: zero or no spacetime.
- You can build a topology-changing Lorentzian spacetime on paper, but it costs causality (closed timelike curves) and, in three or more dimensions, it cannot obey Einstein's equation with reasonable matter (Geroch, Tipler, Borde).
- A random discrete spacetime is guaranteed to have holes somewhere if it is infinite, but the odds of even one nuclear-size hole in a universe-sized region are about e^(-10^72).
- Of all possible discrete orders, almost all are 3-layer 'KR posets' with only three moments of time; spacetimes like ours are a vanishing sliver the dynamics must find.
- Every nonzero-curvature member, sphere or spacetime, is one 'quasi-sphere' in a flat space of one more dimension; only the count of minus signs in the ambient metric changes.
- An expanding universe with nothing in it is just flat empty spacetime seen from inside a light cone: the 'expansion' is only a choice of clocks.
- The whole number of dimensions of string spacetime (26 or 10) is decided by keeping a symmetry alive on a two-dimensional surface, the string's own worldsheet.
- Hiding the string has a price: Misner made time periodic (period 8 pi n), which fills the whole spacetime with closed timelike curves.
- The tool that solved it was born in 1967 for shallow-water solitons (the KdV equation): the same inverse scattering method that tracks waves in a canal builds a rotating galaxy-disk spacetime.
- The other side of the bounce is 'just as real as the pocket universes in an eternally inflating spacetime'.
- A curve can be trapped without ever closing: Carter's spacetime has no closed causal curves, yet a causal curve enters a compact region and stays there forever.
- Once a curve leaves a compact region in a non-imprisoning spacetime, it never comes back.
- Globally hyperbolic spacetimes are topologically boring (R x S); interesting topology needs time loops somewhere (Monroe).
- The size of an event's past is a clock exactly when this half holds: t-(p) = m(I-(p)) increases along every causal curve if and only if the spacetime is past-distinguishing (Theorem 3.51).
- The night sky is this one surface: 'When we observe the sky at night, we basically see only the past light cone within the entire spacetime.'
- Mass and spin, the two things every particle physicist first asks about a particle, are exactly the two Casimir numbers of the spacetime symmetry group: P^2 and W^2.
- The places where a spacetime fails to be reflecting are never isolated points: they always come as whole endless light rays.
- A spacetime where every event can reach every other (totally vicious) passes this test for free; the condition only bites once events can be told apart.
- Every smooth change of viewpoint in flat spacetime is one turn plus one push: the whole group is a bundle of 3D rotations sitting over hyperbolic space.
- Near the fixed point spacetime looks two-dimensional, and slightly above the Planck length there is a second plateau at dimension 4/3.
- The curved metric of hyperbolic space is hiding in flat spacetime: restrict the flat Minkowski form to the sheet of four-velocities and it becomes a positive-definite metric of curvature -1/R^2.
- The Rindler horizon was found long before black-hole horizons were understood: Kottler's 'border plane' (1914) and Bollert's 'horizon of the observer' (1922), in flat spacetime, just from accelerating.
- A rod is a curve in spacetime too, just a spacelike one: 'The circumference of a cylinder and the length of a rod are space-like curves.'
- The Earth's orbit closes in space, but its world line does not: it is 'helical in four-dimensional spacetime and does not return to the same point'.
- The same drawn line is a rod or a history depending only on its tilt: horizontal 'may represent a rod in spacetime', vertical 'a particle at rest'.
- Add a cosmological constant and pure translations stop being symmetries: de Sitter spacetime is moved around by translations mixed with conformal transformations, at a scale of about 10^28 cm.
- A regular grid can't be a discrete spacetime: boost it and a box that held 7 points holds none. Only randomness is fair to every observer.
- Same dice, different worlds: a random lattice in Euclidean space has preferred directions in each roll; in Lorentzian spacetime no single roll does.
- Every static spacetime gets the causal-continuity rung for free, by a one-line trick: slide a timelike curve back a little in time.
- Spacetime gets a Langevin equation: the same mean-plus-noise shape that describes a pollen grain jiggled by molecules, with the quantum matter's stress-energy fluctuations doing the jiggling.
- Its first test case is whether flat empty spacetime survives its own quantum noise; the authors argue it is stable.
- Dafermos and Luk proved the strongest version false for rotating holes, yet in a way that rescues the spirit: spacetime does continue past the inner horizon, but only as a crushed, weakly singular edge where no observer's fate stays predictable.
- The only way out: Coleman and Mandula proved spacetime and internal symmetries cannot mix, and Haag, Lopuszanski and Sohnius showed that supersymmetry is the single consistent loophole. Two supersymmetry moves in a row make a plain step through spacetime ({Q, Q-bar} = 2 sigma P).
- Two independent builds of spacetime's edge, by causal pasts and by conformal rescaling, agree where both work: the conformal boundary's 'accessible part ... agrees with the causal boundary'.
- Tipler's 1974 abstract in one breath: spin a big enough cylinder and a closed timelike line can 'connect any two events in spacetime', with no event horizon hiding it.
- Cartan proposed spacetime torsion in 1922, 'before the discovery of spin', influenced by the Cosserat brothers (1909), who considered a moments stress tensor in a generalized continuous medium (Trautman).
- In a totally vicious spacetime every event is in its own future and its own past, and the time between any two events is infinite: go round the loop as many times as you like.
- Any compact universe that has a timelike (conformal) symmetry is automatically totally vicious; no compact spacetime can avoid closed timelike curves altogether.
- Here the four-way split of spacetime about an event (future, past, light cone, elsewhere) collapses: every event is in every other event's future and past at once.
- Trapped surfaces are 'clairvoyant': they can reach into a region of perfectly flat spacetime whose whole past is flat, in anticipation of energy crossing them elsewhere.
- The word twistor comes from a picture: a non-null twistor read in real spacetime is a family of twisting light rays, nested circles in 3-space (the Robinson congruence).
- In twistor space a spacetime point is a whole line, and two events are light-like separated exactly when their lines meet.
- A virtual black hole could swallow two quarks of a proton and give back an antiquark and a lepton: proton decay by spacetime foam (lifetime of order 10^64 years).
- Time is not an input: 'time, and indeed spacetime, are only derived concepts' that appear only where the wave function oscillates; the scale factor can play the clock.
- Quantize gravity and time disappears: 'spacetime vanishes and only the three-metric remains' (Kiefer); time comes back only as a WKB approximation riding on a classical solution.
- GW150914: in the last fraction of a second the merger released more than 50 times the power of all the stars in the observable universe, and three solar masses vanished into ripples of spacetime.
- In 1995 Ted Jacobson got Einstein's equation out of nothing but heat, entropy and horizon area, and concluded it is an equation of state: quantising it might be like quantising the equation for sound in air, rather than the air's molecules (src:jacobson-1995-einstein-equation-of-state).
- Gravity is so weak that its coupling is about 43 orders of magnitude below light's, yet a proposed table-top test could still tell whether spacetime is quantum: if gravity alone can entangle two tiny masses, it must be quantum (src:marletto-vedral-2017, src:bose-2017-gravity-witness).
- The brightest gamma-ray burst ever seen (GRB 221009A) shows light of all energies still racing at one speed: if spacetime is grainy, the grain sits beyond ten times the Planck energy for the simplest kind of effect (src:lhaaso-2024-grb221009a).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
electromagnetic field (light on null geodesics)
- L1: Light on null geodesics: the light cone is the set of events at zero interval
- L2: Cosmological redshift; radiation temperature scales as 1/a and energy density as a^-4
- L3: Particle horizon: the region within it is the observable universe; with a cosmological constant the observable amount is limited
horizon quantum radiation (Hawking and Unruh)
- L1: Quantum fields near a horizon: Hawking radiation derives from vacuum fluctuations
- L2: Unruh effect: an accelerating observer sees a thermal bath of particles that pop out of the local acceleration horizon; near a black hole a local observer must accelerate not to fall in, so by the equivalence principle sees the field excited at a local temperature
- L3: Pair split by the horizon: a vacuum fluctuation can give a photon outside the horizon paired with one inside; the horizon lets one escape in each direction
- L4: Thermal emission: the hole radiates as a blackbody at T_H = hbar c^3 / (8 pi G M k_B), about 10^23/M K; a typical quantum's wavelength is about the size of the hole
- L5: Evaporation: escaping particles drain mass and rotational energy; a hole that gains nothing shrinks and vanishes, with a lifespan scaling as the cube of its initial mass
- L6: Against the sky: the smallest stellar black holes (about 3 solar masses) sit near 10^-7 K, colder than the 2.7 K microwave background, so no stellar black hole can evaporate yet
matter and energy (stress-energy)
- L1: Whatever matter and radiation are present: the field equations specify how the geometry of space and time is influenced by them
- L2: The stress-energy tensor: mass is part of a more general quantity including energy and momentum densities and stress (pressure and shear)
- L3: Einstein field equations: the Einstein tensor G_mu-nu (built from Ricci curvature and the metric) equals kappa T_mu-nu, with kappa = 8 pi G / c^4 fixed by the Newtonian limit
- L4: Conservation: energy-momentum conservation is the vanishing covariant divergence of the stress-energy tensor, and hence of the curvature side too
spacetime (own medium)
- L1: Four-dimensional, smooth, connected Lorentzian manifold of events; world lines; locally flat; scale factor c (nearly 300,000 km per second) relating space to time
- L2: Metric and invariant interval (ds^2 = c^2dt^2 - dx^2 - dy^2 - dz^2): all observers compute the same interval; laws take the same form in all coordinate systems; Poincare group of 10 (3 boosts, 3 rotations, 4 translations)
- L3: Causal structure: light cones split events into timelike future, timelike past and elsewhere; no influence from A reaches X before light sent from A; paths of particles and light are timelike and null geodesics
- L4: Global geometry: horizons (black-hole event horizon, particle horizon, cosmic event horizon, Rindler horizon with Unruh radiation); singularities where worldlines end; cosmic censorship (unproven)
- L5: Cosmological geometry: FLRW metric, comoving coordinates, scale factor a(t); spatial sections consistent with flat; Hubble horizon (perturbations much larger are not dynamical); exponential growth of a under inflation and under dark energy
- L6: Asymptotic structure: the BMS group at lightlike infinity, infinite-dimensional, with supertranslations; independent of the particular gravitational field, so kinematics separates from dynamics there
spacetime as relativists describe it (reader's view: events and contents, the source term, the field equations, the metric and its curvature, waves and expansion, global structure, motion of matter and light)
- L1: Events and contents: the four-dimensional continuum of events, with matter, radiation, dark matter and vacuum energy in it
- L2: The source term: contents enter as the stress-energy tensor (energy density, momentum density, pressure, shear)
- L3: The field equations: curvature set by stress-energy (8 pi G / c^4) plus the cosmological term
- L4: The metric and its curvature: intervals and proper time, light cones and causal order, tidal curvature; locally special relativity
- L5: The geometry in motion: waves at c that carry energy, and the expansion of the cosmic scale factor
- L6: Global structure: horizons, trapped surfaces and singularities (incomplete geodesics), the area that bounds information
- L7: Action on what it holds: free bodies and light follow its geodesics, clocks tick its proper time, gyroscopes are dragged
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L3: The field equations: every source summed; curvature = 8 pi G / c^4 x stress-energy, plus the cosmological term
- L4: The metric and its curvature: intervals, proper time, light cones, tides; locally special relativity
- L5: The geometry in motion: gravitational waves at c carrying energy; the cosmic scale factor's expansion, now accelerating
- L6: Global structure: horizons, closed trapped surfaces and singularities (geodesic incompleteness); horizon area as entropy and the area bound on information
- L7: Action on what it holds: 'The trajectories of freely falling test bodies are geodesics of that metric'; light follows null geodesics, clocks tick proper time, frames are dragged
way in: Dark matter
- L1: Dark matter, Omega_c h^2 = 0.120 +/- 0.001 (Planck 2018)
- L2: Enters only through its stress-energy (pressureless matter): gravity is its only known coupling
way in: Gravitational waves arriving (the geometry's own ripples)
- L1: A wave from a binary black hole 410 Mpc away arrives: strain 1.0 x 10^-21, 35 to 250 Hz
- L2: The strain h alters lengths: 'A passing gravitational wave effectively alters the arm lengths'
- L3: The source-free field equations carry it at c: the speed of gravity equals the speed of light to between -3 x 10^-15 and +7 x 10^-16
way in: Moving mass (momentum currents, rotation)
- L1: Mass in motion: Earth's rotation
- L2: Momentum density (time-space parts of the tensor): a rotating mass drags the local frames, read by Gravity Probe B's gyroscopes as -37.2 +/- 7.2 mas/yr
way in: Ordinary matter (rest mass-energy)
- L1: Matter present at an event: 'whatever matter and radiation are present'
- L2: Its energy density, the time-time part of the stress-energy tensor (mass is 'part of a more general quantity')
way in: Pressure and stress
- L1: Pressure and shear in matter and radiation
- L2: The space-space parts of the stress-energy tensor: in GR pressure gravitates too (positive pressure decelerates expansion; sufficiently negative pressure accelerates it)
way in: Quantum fields on the geometry (horizon radiation; the Planck scale)
- L1: Quantum fields in curved spacetime; at the Planck length 'quantum fluctuations of spacetime are expected to play an important role'
- L2: Particle creation at horizons: black holes 'emit Hawking radiation with a perfect thermal spectrum'; accelerated observers see a thermal bath (both predicted, unobserved)
way in: Radiation (light and neutrinos)
- L1: Radiation: its energy density thins as a^-4 as space expands
- L2: Its stress-energy, with pressure one third of its energy density; radiation dominated the energy density until about 50,000 years after the Big Bang
way in: Vacuum energy (the cosmological constant)
- L1: A positive cosmological constant: supernovae 'favor eternally expanding models with positive cosmological constant'
- L2: The Lambda term: an energy density that stays put as volume grows, with negative pressure
way out: Clock rates: proper time
- L1: GPS satellite clocks run fast by 4.4647 x 10^-10 and are slowed before launch so receivers can fix position
- L4: Gravitational redshift: gamma rays climbing a tower (Pound-Rebka-Snider 1960-1965); a frequency gradient across one millimetre of strontium atoms
- L7: Each clock ticks the proper time along its world line
way out: Expansion: distances grow, light redshifts
- L1: Light in flight is redshifted: the CMB's temperature has dropped by a factor of 1,089 since decoupling
- L5: The scale factor grows (now accelerating)
way out: Fall and orbit: free bodies follow geodesics
- L1: Bodies fall and orbit; held up, they feel weight, which a person's balance channel reads as 'gravity and linear accelerations'
- L7: Geodesic motion of every free body
way out: Gravitational waves sent out
- L1: Lengths everywhere strained in passing: the 4 km arms of LIGO change by h x L
- L5: Waves carry energy out of a binary: 3.0 solar masses' worth in GW150914
way out: Gyroscopes turned: geodetic precession and frame dragging
- L1: Gravity Probe B's gyroscopes drift -6,601.8 +/- 18.3 mas/yr (geodetic) and -37.2 +/- 7.2 mas/yr (frame dragging)
- L7: Frames carried along by the curved, rotating geometry
way out: Horizon radiation (predicted): black holes glow and evaporate
- L1: Thermal quanta leave; the hole loses mass, faster the smaller it is (Hawking temperature inversely proportional to mass)
- L6: A horizon with a temperature set by its surface gravity
way out: Light bent and delayed
- L1: Lensed light and black-hole shadows reach telescopes and eyes (the 42 microarcsecond ring of M87*)
- L4: Deflection and Shapiro delay near the Sun: gamma - 1 = (2.1 +/- 2.3) x 10^-5 (Cassini)
- L7: Light follows null geodesics
Who fills each layer
- L1: Electromagnetic field, Closed universe (positive curvature), de Sitter spacetime, Flat universe (zero curvature), Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime, Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines), Quantum vacuum (vacuum state), Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical), Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature), Minkowski spacetime, Anti-de Sitter spacetime, Asymptotic safety in quantum gravity (walked as a projected model)
- L2: Standard Model of particle physics, de Sitter spacetime, Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime, Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines), Quantum vacuum (vacuum state), Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature), Spacetime event, Minkowski spacetime, Anti-de Sitter spacetime, Causal set (causet; hypothetical discrete spacetime), Goedel universe, Kerr spacetime
- L3: Inflaton field, Closed universe (positive curvature), Dominant energy condition (DEC), Flat universe (zero curvature), Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines), Quantum vacuum (vacuum state), Spacetime event, Minkowski spacetime, Ultimate fate of the universe, Absolute elsewhere (spacelike region), Causal dynamical triangulation (CDT; walked as a projected model), Causal future (absolute future)
- L4: Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy), de Sitter spacetime, Event horizon, Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime, Magnetic monopoles (hypothetical relics), Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines), Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature), Ultimate fate of the universe, Canonical loop quantum gravity (Hamiltonian LQG; walked as a projected model), Hilbert stress-energy tensor (metric energy-momentum tensor), Horizon (general relativity), Loop quantum gravity (LQG; candidate theory, walked as a projected model)
- L5: Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy), Euclidean space, Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime, Quintessence field (hypothesised alternative), Quantum vacuum (vacuum state), Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical), Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature), Hyperbolic space, k-essence (kinetic quintessence; hypothesised), Quintom dark energy (quintom scenario; hypothesised), Radiation stress-energy (ultra-relativistic, w = 1/3), Taub-NUT spacetime
- L6: Conformal boundary (conformal infinity), Asymptotic symmetry group, Relativistic angular momentum