← all systems · see it in The System
Competition for free electrons at recombination (hydrogen vs helium)
Electrons captured into atoms; helium recombines first.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the free electrons of the photon-baryon plasma, and the two takes, capture onto helium nuclei (two steps) and onto protons (hydrogen). Outside: the photon bath that re-ionises, the expansion that cools and dilutes, and the dark matter. The contest ends when electrons are bound and photons stream freely. |
| compete fns | fn:resource-denial-attrition |
| nested level | Built from the electron pool and the hydrogen and helium takers; embedded in the expanding universe at about z 6000 to 1000. |
| scale | atomic |
Measures (13) published science
| helium first recombination (He2+ -> He+) | z ~ 6000 (near Saha) redshift |
| helium second recombination (He+ -> He) | z ~ 2000 (slower than Saha) redshift |
| hydrogen recombination | about 378,000 yr, z = 1100 (Reionization: 379,000 yr, z = 1089; CMB: 379,000 yr, about 3000 K) years / redshift |
| Saha 50% hydrogen ionisation | about 4000 K, z = 1500 K / redshift |
| universe 90% neutral | z ~ 1070 redshift |
| 2s two-photon decay rate | 8.22 s^-1 |
| helium share of baryonic mass | about 24% mass fraction |
| helium share of electrons taken (derived from 8% of atoms, 2 electrons each) | about 15% fraction |
| helium ionisation energies | first 24.587, second 54.418 eV |
| hydrogen ionisation energy (1 Ry) | 13.6057 eV |
| modern recombination theory accuracy | about 0.1% fraction |
| characteristic clock: 2s two-photon decay (the slow door's own exit) | 8.22 s^-1 |
| characteristic clock: the contest's span (helium first step to hydrogen 90% neutral) | z ~ 6000 to z ~ 1070; ends about 378,000 years after the Big Bang redshift / years |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Competition for free electrons at recombination (hydrogen vs helium). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (partial)
Two takers, one job: helium (two electrons, two steps at z ~ 6000 and z ~ 2000) and hydrogen (one electron, through n = 2) both capture free electrons; 'The ionization energy of helium is larger than that of hydrogen and it therefore recombines earlier'. - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
Capture and photoionisation are one reaction run both ways, p + e- <-> H + gamma: the Peebles equation balances the 'case B' recombination coefficient against 'the corresponding photoionization rate'.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (5) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Hydrogen atom via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for free electrons at recombination (hydrogen vs helium) loss
- Electron via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for free electrons at recombination (hydrogen vs helium) gain
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for free electrons at recombination (hydrogen vs helium) mixed
- Helium atom via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for free electrons at recombination (hydrogen vs helium) loss
- Photon-baryon fluid (partnership) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for free electrons at recombination (hydrogen vs helium) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (2)
floor filled by (15)
- Big Bang
- Competition for free neutrons in Big Bang nucleosynthesis
- Hydrogen atom
- Electron
- Photon
- Spacetime
- Helium hydride ion (HeH+)
- Photon-baryon plasma
- Cosmic microwave background
- Proton
- Helium atom
- Alpha particle (helium-4 nucleus)
- Competition for ionising photons (hydrogen vs helium)
- Photon-baryon fluid (partnership)
- Competition for each baryon overdensity (photon pressure vs gravitational collapse)
Kinds (2)
Notes published science
- The fastest way to recombine is blocked: an electron dropping straight to hydrogen's ground state emits a photon that immediately re-ionises a neighbour. Hydrogen has to go the slow way, through n = 2, waiting for redshift or a two-photon decay at 8.22 per second.
- Winning the electrons opened the universe's window: once they were bound, photons' mean free path grew past the Hubble length. The CMB is the light released when this contest ended.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
cosmic expansion (spacetime)
- L1: Hubble expansion: its rate sets the overall evolution timescale for the temperature and density of the plasma
- L2: Cooling by expansion: T = (1+z) x 2.728 K and the hydrogen density scales as (1+z)^3, so the radiation field falls below what can immediately re-ionise neutral hydrogen
- L3: Redshifting of Lyman-alpha photons: cosmological redshift lowers the photon frequency, and a small fraction escape reabsorption by moving off the line resonance before meeting another ground-state atom
- L4: Dilution: expansion dilutes the electrons; shortly after recombination the photon mean free path exceeds the Hubble length and photons travel freely (last-scattering surface)
electromagnetic field
- L1: Free electrons and ions in the photon-baryon plasma, tightly coupled to photons by Thomson scattering
- L2: Capture thresholds: He2+ (54.4 eV), He+ (24.6 eV), H+ (13.6 eV); the deepest well fills first as the bath cools
- L3: Bottleneck: direct ground-state captures re-ionise a neighbour, so hydrogen recombines only via n = 2: Lyman-alpha escape by redshift, or two-photon decay at 8.22 s^-1
- L4: Outcome: universe 90% neutral at z ~ 1070; recombination about 378,000 years after the Big Bang (z = 1100); photons decouple and become the CMB
Who fills each layer
Sources (6) published science
Cosmic microwave background (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Helium atom (Wikipedia, rev 1371811794, 2026-08-28) (behind its links)
Big Bang nucleosynthesis (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Hydrogen atom (Wikipedia, rev 1371585341, 2026-08-27) (behind its links)
Diffusion damping (Wikipedia, rev 1370774848, 2026-08-23) (behind its links)