← all systems · see it in The System
Galaxy
A galaxy is a physical system of stars, planetary systems, stellar remnants, substellar objects, interstellar gas, dust, and dark matter bound together by gravity.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | the earliest confirmed: about 300 million years after the Big Bang (z = 14.32) |
| born precision | redshift +0.08 -0.20 |
| boundary | Inside: the stars, gas (interstellar medium), dust, magnetic field, cosmic rays and central black hole, set in a dark matter halo; the circumgalactic medium fills the halo out to the virial radius ('bounded at the outside by the virial radius Rvir of a galaxy's dark matter halo, and on the inside by the disk or ISM', Tumlinson et al. 2017). Outside: the intergalactic medium and cosmic web, neighbours, the group or cluster. Both edges are fuzzy: 'Neither boundary is well-defined'. At the small end the line between a galaxy and a star cluster is drawn by dynamics (stars whose properties baryons and Newton's gravity cannot explain), and is contested for ultra-compact dwarfs. |
| nested level | Built from stars, gas, dust, a magnetic field, cosmic rays and a central supermassive black hole inside a dark matter halo; embedded in groups, clusters and the filaments of the cosmic web, all riding the expansion of space. Between stellar physics (its parts) and cosmology (its setting). |
| rewalk on opus | True |
| rewalk why | K-12 wave 11 was walked on Sonnet during the 11-09 model trial; the blind review found Opus walks deeper (research/backchain/MODEL-TRIAL-W11.md). Re-walk on Opus under the current walkSpec. |
| scale | galactic |
Measures (84) published science
| earliest galaxies | emerged from around 180 to 700 million years; earliest known by about 280 Ma; GN-z11 at z ~ 11.1 (about 400 Myr); most remote observed MoM-z14 at z = 14.44 cosmic time / z |
| galaxies in the observable universe | 2e11 to 2e12 galaxies |
| stars per galaxy | average about 100 million; dwarfs under a thousand to supergiants with one hundred trillion stars |
| typical diameter | 1,000 to 100,000 parsecs |
| typical separation | of the order of millions of parsecs |
| Milky Way D25 isophotal diameter | 26.8 kpc |
| Milky Way dark matter extent | total diameter possibly approaching 613 kpc (2 million ly) |
| Milky Way stars | 100-400 billion stars |
| Sagittarius A* mass | 4.100 +/- 0.034 million solar masses |
| Milky Way total mass | 8.5 x 10^11 (2014 study); about 6 x 10^11 (Galaxy article) solar masses |
| typical stellar orbital speed (Milky Way) | 200-220 km/s |
| characteristic clock: galactic year (Sun's orbit) | about 240 million years yr |
| characteristic clock: starburst duration | about ten million years yr |
| characteristic clock: Cosmic Dawn star-formation bursts | 5 to 30 Myr (stellar feedback) |
| future star formation | up to one hundred billion years; stellar age ends after 10^13-10^14 years yr |
| characteristic clock: quenching | within about 1 billion years yr |
| characteristic clock: major merger completion (Milky Way-Andromeda simulation) | two billion years after the collision yr |
| characteristic clock: galaxy formation | operates on the scale of a billion years yr |
| major-merger rate of large galaxies | on average once over the past 9 billion years per galaxy |
| Milky Way star formation | only a few new stars each year (~2) stars per year |
| major-merger star formation rate | can reach thousands of solar masses per year; typical merger SFRs under 100 |
| LIRG / ULIRG thresholds | above 10^11 solar luminosities with SFR at least 18; ULIRGs ten times more luminous with SFR > 180 L_sun; solar masses per year |
| starburst share of star production | an estimated 15% fraction |
| isolated galaxies | about 5% of galaxies surveyed fraction |
| magnetic field strength | about 10 microgauss in spirals; 5 (M31, M33); 15 (M51, M83, NGC 6946); up to 25 in arms; 50-100 in starbursts |
| molecular clouds in the Milky Way | about 6,000 above 10^5 solar masses; about half the ISM mass count |
| ISM composition by mass | 70% hydrogen, 28% helium, 1.5% heavier elements fraction |
| ISM disc scale height | about 100 pc |
| star formation efficiency in molecular gas | around 1% of the gas per free-fall time fraction |
| oldest Milky Way stars | HE 1523-0901 about 13.2 billion years; thin disc 8.8 +/- 1.7 billion years yr |
| Milky Way merger with 'Kraken' | 11 billion years ago (simulations) yr ago |
| Milky Way-Andromeda approach | about 130 km/s; collision in about 5-6 billion years (Galaxy) or about 4.5 billion years (Galaxy merger) km/s; yr |
| Milky Way peculiar velocity | about 630 relative to the local co-moving frame km/s |
| CGM inflow and outflow reach | around 100 kpc or above |
| Milky Way satellites | at least a dozen; an estimated 300-500 yet to be discovered count |
| dwarf galaxy central mass | approximately 10 million regardless of star count (27 Milky Way neighbours) solar masses |
| cosmic star-formation rate density: peak and decline | peak at z about 1.9, about 3.5 Gyr after the Big Bang; then an exponential decline with e-folding time 3.9 Gyr |
| critical halo mass for shock heating (cold flows below, shock above) | about 10^12 solar masses (Dekel & Birnboim 2006); the cold-mode to hot-mode switch is put at a halo mass of about 10^11.4 solar masses by Keres et al. 2005 |
| halo mass at which half the baryons are lost to the UV background | 6.5 x 10^9 h^-1 solar masses at z = 0, circular velocity 25 km/s |
| molecular gas depletion time in nearby spirals | about 2 x 10^9 yr |
| star formation per free-fall time (SFRff) | a few percent, consistent across densities (the share of a cloud's gas turned to stars each free-fall time) fraction |
| star formation to black-hole growth ratio (last 10 Gyr) | about 1500 ratio |
| Milky Way central black hole mass (2016 review) | (4.2 +/- 0.2) x 10^6 solar masses |
| Sun's angular velocity about Sgr A* | 30.24 +/- 0.12 km/s/kpc |
| characteristic clock: Sun's orbital period about the Galactic Centre (derived from the angular velocity above) | about 203 (own arithmetic: 2 pi / 30.24 km/s/kpc, 1 km/s/kpc = 1.0227 x 10^-3 per Myr) |
| Milky Way virial radius and mass | 282 +/- 30 kpc; 1.3 +/- 0.3 x 10^12 solar masses kpc; solar masses |
| radiation momentum input ceiling (L/c) | the momentum input does not exceed L/c (Krumholz & Thompson, quoted by Naab & Ostriker) momentum per time |
| universal baryon fraction used for conversion efficiency | 0.17 fraction |
| typical radiative efficiency of accretion (assumed) | about 0.1 of the accreted rest mass, as Lbol = epsilon Mdot c^2; the review says it is 'typically assumed' fraction |
| accretion rate separating radiative-mode and jet-mode AGN | about 1% of the Eddington limit fraction |
| galaxy density contrast by environment | voids about 0.2 of the mean field density; superclusters and filaments about 5; rich cluster cores about 100; compact groups about 1000 x mean density |
| earliest spectroscopically confirmed galaxy redshift | 14.32 (+0.08 -0.20) z |
| Sun's distance from the Galactic Centre | 8.2 +/- 0.1 kpc |
| Milky Way virial mass | 1.3 +/- 0.3 x 10^12 solar masses |
| Milky Way virial radius | 282 +/- 30 kpc |
| Milky Way stellar mass | 5 +/- 1 x 10^10 solar masses |
| Milky Way star formation rate | 1.65 +/- 0.19 solar masses per year |
| Milky Way central black hole mass | 4.2 +/- 0.2 x 10^6 solar masses |
| galactic year | ~240 million years |
| molecular gas depletion time | ~2e9 years |
| gas depletion time | 1-2 Gyr |
| strangulation quenching timescale | ~4 Gyr |
| cosmic star formation e-folding time | 3.9 Gyr |
| starburst duration | ~10 million years |
| star formation per free-fall time in molecular clouds | ~1 % |
| fraction of baryons in stars today | <10 % |
| peak galaxy formation efficiency | ~20-30% of baryons (stellar-to-halo mass a few %) fraction |
| return fraction | 0.27 (Salpeter) / 0.41 (Chabrier) fraction of stellar mass |
| share of starlight reprocessed by dust | ~0.5 fraction |
| black-hole radiative efficiency | ~0.1 (0.057 non-spinning) fraction of accreted rest mass |
| quasar wind power fraction | 0.05-0.10 fraction of accretion power |
| jet heating effect on cooling and star formation | x0.1 factor |
| black hole to bulge mass ratio | 0.49 (+0.06 -0.05) % at Mbulge = 10^11 solar masses |
| satellites quenched by environment | 30-70 % |
| photoionisation suppression halo mass | ~1e8 solar masses |
| main-sequence width | ~0.2 dex |
| typical galactic magnetic field | 15 (20-30 in arms, 50-100 in starburst centres) microgauss |
| Andromeda radial velocity towards the Milky Way | -109.3 +/- 4.4 km/s |
| Local Group mass | 3.17 +/- 0.57 x 10^12 solar masses |
| Gaia-Enceladus merger mass ratio and age | 4:1, ~10 Gyr ago ratio, time |
| chance of no Milky Way-Andromeda merger in 10 Gyr | ~0.5 probability |
| galactic habitable zone | 7-9 kpc; stars formed 8-4 Gyr ago |
| share of humanity that cannot see the Milky Way | >1/3 (60% of Europeans, ~80% of North Americans) fraction |
| Galaxy Zoo classifications per galaxy | ~38 (nearly one million galaxies; >100,000 volunteers) classifications |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-098 Are galaxy rotation and cosmic acceleration caused by unseen matter and energy, or by gravity behaving differently?
booked: The map follows the mainstream view of unseen components (dark matter and dark energy), and keeps modified gravity alongside.
the other reading: gravity behaving differently; Willman & Strader build their definition so as not to depend on a cold dark matter model - C-1015 Do galaxies and their central black holes grow together?
booked: The map follows the 2013 review: black holes relate differently to different parts of galaxies, so they grow together only in some cases. The older 'one tight relation' view is kept alongside.
the other reading: one tight relation from the two regulating each other's growth, the 'widespread belief' the review sets out to replace - C-1016 What stops galaxies from forming new stars?
booked: The map uses two separate routes, one tied to a galaxy's mass and one to its surroundings, and keeps both main explanations for the mass route.
the other reading: bimodality set by the switch from cold flows to virial shock heating (mass ceiling, Bouche et al. 2010); maintenance-mode black-hole feedback in the most massive galaxies (Fabian 2012); where and how the fuel source is regulated is not agreed (Tumlinson et al. 2017) - C-1321 What makes a galaxy's spiral arms?
booked: The map rules no mechanism and keeps long-lived density waves, short-lived recurring arms and arms raised by passing galaxies side by side.
the other reading: long-lived quasi-stationary density waves (the classic reading); tidally induced grand-design arms that slowly wind up; bar-driven arms - C-1322 Where does a star cluster end and a galaxy begin?
booked: The map uses the definition of a galaxy as a bound group of stars that ordinary matter and Newton's gravity can't explain, and leaves the smallest dense dwarfs open.
the other reading: ultra-compact dwarfs as stripped nuclei or massive star clusters, not galaxies; a definition by size or luminosity alone - C-1326 Will the Milky Way and Andromeda collide?
booked: The map keeps it open: a 2025 study gives close to a 50% chance of no merger in the next 10 billion years, against the common expectation of a collision in about 5 billion.
the other reading: a merger in about 5 billion years forming an elliptical (the 'commonly believed' reading Sawala et al. test)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (27)
- Star
- Dark matter
- Neutron star
- Black hole
- Planet
- Interstellar medium
- Molecular cloud
- Star cluster (open and globular)
- Cosmic rays
- Supermassive black hole
- Galactic bulge
- Galactic magnetic field
- Disc
- Circumgalactic medium (CGM)
- Dark matter halo
- Disc (thin and thick)
- Competition for galactic gas (black hole vs star formation)
- Galaxy cluster
- Cluster-core gas: cooling flow against AGN heating
- Observable universe
- Cluster ram pressure against a galaxy's star formation
- Reachable universe (inner region)
- Region reachable below light speed
- Round-trip reachable region
- Mach's principle
- Competition for a cluster's member stars
- Universe
Sits inside / holds (38)
- Star
- Supernova
- Neutron star merger
- Neutron star
- Black hole
- Planet
- Interstellar medium
- Molecular cloud
- Star cluster (open and globular)
- Spacetime
- Intergalactic medium
- Galaxy cluster
- Galaxy group (e.g. the Local Group)
- Cosmic web
- Bound structures (the survivors, e.g. the Local Group)
- Supercluster
- Stellar remnant (compact star)
- Cosmic rays
- White dwarf
- Supermassive black hole
- Comet
- Competition for cloud gas (competitive accretion and stellar feedback)
- Competition for galactic gas (black hole vs star formation)
- Dark matter-baryon partnership (structure formation)
- Star and interstellar medium matter cycle (stellar recycling)
- Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution
- Galactic bulge
- Sun
- Cosmic dust
- Galactic magnetic field
- Gamma-ray burst
- Active galactic nucleus
- Kilonova
- Quasar
- Primordial black hole evaporation
- Ultracool dwarf
- Solar System
- TRAPPIST-1 system
Trades with (valence) (58)
- Dark matter via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy gain
- Dark energy via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy mixed
- Spacetime via sys:spacetime · Galaxy even
- Black hole via sys:interstellar-medium · Galaxy mixed
- Planet via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Star cluster (open and globular) via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Star via sys:interstellar-medium · Galaxy mixed
- Supernova via sys:interstellar-medium · Galaxy mixed
- Cosmic rays via sys:galactic-magnetic-field · Galaxy mixed
- Competition for galactic gas (black hole vs star formation) via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy mixed
- Dark matter-baryon partnership (structure formation) via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy gain
- Star and interstellar medium matter cycle (stellar recycling) via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy mixed
- Intergalactic medium via sys:interstellar-medium · Galaxy mixed
- Galaxy cluster via sys:interstellar-medium · Galaxy loss
- Galactic magnetic field via sys:galactic-magnetic-field · Galaxy mixed
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Galaxy even
- Active galactic nucleus via sys:interstellar-medium · Galaxy mixed
- Circumgalactic medium (CGM) via sys:interstellar-medium · Galaxy mixed
- Dwarf galaxy via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy gain
- Quasar via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy mixed
- Solar System via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Chaos and nonlinear dynamics (the practice, and the chaotic behaviour it studies) via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Stellar remnant (compact star) via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy mixed
- Comet via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Galactic bulge via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy loss
- Gamma-ray burst via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy mixed
- Extragalactic cosmic rays via sys:galactic-magnetic-field · Galaxy loss
- Intergalactic magnetic field via sys:interstellar-medium · Galaxy loss
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy) via sys:spacetime · Galaxy mixed
- Phantom dark energy (phantom energy; hypothesised) via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy loss
- Self-interacting dark matter via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy gain
- De Sitter horizon via sys:spacetime · Galaxy loss
- Particle horizon via sys:spacetime · Galaxy even
- Hubble sphere via sys:spacetime · Galaxy even
- FLRW dust (matter-dominated Friedmann models) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Galaxy gain
- Neugebauer-Meinel dust (rigidly rotating disk of dust) via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Cosmic time via sys:spacetime · Galaxy even
- Goedel's expanding rotating universes via sys:spacetime · Galaxy gain
- Dark fluid via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy gain
- Comoving frame (comoving observer) via sys:spacetime · Galaxy even
- Observable universe via sys:electromagnetic-field · Galaxy even
- Quantum fluctuation via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy gain
- Cosmological event horizon via sys:spacetime · Galaxy loss
- Ultracool dwarf via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy gain
- Cosmological comoving observer (Hubble-flow frame) via sys:spacetime · Galaxy even
- Lookback time via sys:electromagnetic-field · Galaxy loss
- Lambda-CDM model via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy gain
- Static Weyl vacuum via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Cosmic string via sys:electromagnetic-field · Galaxy even
- Reachable universe (inner region) via sys:spacetime · Galaxy loss
- Region reachable below light speed via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Round-trip reachable region via sys:spacetime · Galaxy loss
- Eventually observable universe (inside the future visibility limit) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Galaxy even
- Hubble's law (Hubble-Lemaitre law) via sys:spacetime · Galaxy even
- Mach's principle via sys:spacetime · Galaxy even
- TRAPPIST-1 system via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy even
- Universe via sys:gravitational-field · Galaxy gain
expressed by (11)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Ranged Attack
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Leverage Host/Amplification
- Divide & Isolate
floor filled by (77)
- Gravitational field
- Dark matter
- Dark energy
- Spacetime
- Black hole
- Planet
- Interstellar medium
- Star cluster (open and globular)
- Star
- Supernova
- Molecular cloud
- Cosmic rays
- Supermassive black hole
- Galactic bulge
- Intergalactic medium
- Galaxy cluster
- Cosmic dust
- Galactic magnetic field
- Active galactic nucleus
- Circumgalactic medium (CGM)
- Dwarf galaxy
- Disc (thin and thick)
- Spiral arm
- Stellar remnant (compact star)
- Big Bang
- Comet
- Competition for galactic gas (black hole vs star formation)
- Competition for ionising photons (hydrogen vs helium)
- Dark matter-baryon partnership (structure formation)
- Baryonic matter
- Competition for each baryon overdensity (photon pressure vs gravitational collapse)
- Star and interstellar medium matter cycle (stellar recycling)
- Quintessence field (hypothesised alternative)
- Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity)
- Intergalactic magnetic field
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy)
- Phantom dark energy (phantom energy; hypothesised)
- Goedel universe
- Fundamental interaction
- Quasar
- Ultimate fate of the universe
- De Sitter horizon
- Particle horizon
- Cosmological horizon
- Hubble sphere
- FLRW dust (matter-dominated Friedmann models)
- Dust solution
- Infinite flat universe
- Einstein-de Sitter universe
- Scale factor (cosmology)
- Cosmic time
- Milne universe (Milne model)
- Goedel's expanding rotating universes
- Dark fluid
- Comoving frame (comoving observer)
- Observable universe
- Quantum fluctuation
- Cosmological event horizon
- Cosmological comoving observer (Hubble-flow frame)
- Lookback time
- Lambda-CDM model
- Static Weyl vacuum
- Cosmic string
- Local inertial (free-fall) frame
- Comoving distance
- Reachable universe (inner region)
- Thermodynamic arrow of time
- Cosmological arrow of time
- Region reachable below light speed
- Round-trip reachable region
- Causal region of an observer (parent kind: the principal causal regions of our universe)
- Eventually observable universe (inside the future visibility limit)
- Cosmic antipode
- Hubble's law (Hubble-Lemaitre law)
- Mach's principle
- Solar System
- Universe
represents (1)
Kinds (16)
- Elliptical galaxy
- Spiral galaxy
- Irregular galaxy
- Lenticular galaxy
- Compact relic galaxy (overmassive holes)
- Peculiar galaxy
- Dark or ultra-diffuse galaxy
- Barred spiral galaxy
- Ultra-compact dwarf
- Dwarf galaxy
- Starburst galaxy
- Blue-cloud galaxy (main sequence)
- Red-sequence galaxy
- Green-valley galaxy
- Ultra-faint dwarf galaxy
- Active galaxy (AGN host)
wired (15)
- Black hole
- Molecular cloud
- Intergalactic medium
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Brightest cluster galaxy
- Light cone (null cone)
- Intracluster medium (ICM)
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense)
- Inertial observer (inertial frame of reference)
- Void field
- Baryonic matter
- World line
- Future light cone (future null cone)
- Scale factor (cosmology)
- Cosmological event horizon
Notes published science
- Your inner ear cannot tell gravity from acceleration: the otoliths feel only the total, and tilting your head forward feels the same to them as accelerating backward. The brain untangles it by mixing in the canals, muscles, gut and eyes, and by holding Earth's 9.81 m/s^2 as a built-in expectation. Einstein's equivalence principle was living in your head all along. (src:lacquaniti-2014-gravity-internal-models, src:jorges-2017-gravity-prior)
- About half the carbon in the Universe was made by massive stars and the other half mostly by smaller dying giants (AGB stars), which also made about three quarters of the nitrogen (src:kobayashi-karakas-lugaro-2020).
- Light is a rounding error: a core-collapse supernova releases about 100 foe, almost all as neutrinos, and only 0.001-0.01 foe as light, yet the light (powered mostly by the radioactive decay of nickel made in the blast) is what can outshine a galaxy.
- The ISM is a clock: iron in a galaxy rises roughly linearly with time through successive generations of stars, which is why [Fe/H] became the standard scale. 'Future generations of stars are made of the star stuff from past stars.'
- Dust waits only where the radiation lets it: grains survive beyond the sublimation radius (~0.5 L_46^(1/2) pc, ~1,800 K), so the brighter the quasar, the farther out its own torus sits. And that dust, pushed with an effective Eddington limit ~1,000 times lower than bare gas, may be what ties hole to galaxy at ~10^-3 (Fabian, flagged speculative).
- Gravity and light raced from GW170817, about 130 million light-years, and arrived 1.74 s apart, pinning the speed of gravity to light's within a few parts in 10^16 to 10^15. And a merger's recoil kick, up to 4000 km/s, can fling a supermassive black hole out of its own galaxy, dragging gas along as a 'naked quasar'.
- Radio below about 0.1 MHz cannot cross the galaxy at all, and 1 km waves die within 10-50 pc of the Local Bubble: the medium is a filter with a hard floor, and pulsar dispersion turns that filter into a ruler for the ionised gas.
- The earliest confirmed galaxy, JADES-GS-z14-0, shone 300 million years after the Big Bang, and bright galaxies that early turn out to be 'more common than what was expected before JWST' (src:carniani-2024).
- About half of all the starlight ever made in the universe never reaches us as starlight: dust swallows it and glows it back out in the infrared (src:kennicutt-evans-2012).
- The famous Milky Way-Andromeda collision may not happen: with the Large Magellanic Cloud's pull included, there is close to a 50% chance of no merger in the next 10 billion years (src:sawala-2025). Meanwhile artificial light already hides the Milky Way from more than a third of humanity (src:falchi-2016).
- The traffic builds its own doors: cosmic rays streaming through the Galaxy excite the very Alfven waves that scatter them, so the flux holds itself to the Alfven speed, about 10^4 times slower than light, and stays 3 x 10^7 years instead of 3,000.
- An ordered magnetic field 5 kpc across is already in place in a galaxy seen 2.5 billion years after the Big Bang, so galaxies build large-scale fields fast.
- Sound can cross a vacuum. Not by flying: between two piezoelectric crystals a whisker apart, the vibration turns into an electric field that leaks across the gap and turns back into vibration on the far side, and some phonons get through with close to 100% transmission; below 50 K this carries more heat than light does (src:prunnila-meltaus-2010; src:geng-maasilta-2023-phonon-tunneling).
- Element ratios are a clock: magnesium reaches a galaxy's gas within a few million years (massive stars), iron mostly after about a billion (white-dwarf explosions), so a star's Mg/Fe ratio tells you roughly when it was born.
- As a galaxy nears our horizon its clocks appear to slow to a stop and its light stretches until the wavelength is longer than the horizon itself.
- Cosmic time is the one clock in relativity everybody can agree on, but only because the universe is (on average) the same everywhere: every galaxy's clock was set at the same moment, where all their paths meet in the past.
- If space is small enough you would see the back of our own Galaxy as a distant 'phantom source', and the CMB would show 'pairs of matched circles of equal radii'.
- Rindler sorted this out in 1956 by separating one-off events (a supernova) from world lines (a galaxy's whole history).
- In a dust universe the grains are galaxies: the toy model shrinks a whole galaxy, or a supercluster, to one pressureless point.
- The 'constant' is not constant: H falls with time even while every galaxy speeds up, levelling off near 57 km/s/Mpc as dark energy takes over.
- MOND predicted in 1993 that a galaxy's baryonic mass grows as the fourth power of its flat rotation speed, and observation confirmed it; yet MOND-like theories still fail to reproduce galaxy clusters.
- The tool that solved it was born in 1967 for shallow-water solitons (the KdV equation): the same inverse scattering method that tracks waves in a canal builds a rotating galaxy-disk spacetime.
- Nothing ever leaves the particle horizon: once a galaxy is in view it stays in view (only ever more redshifted). The Hubble sphere, by contrast, lets objects in and out.
- A mode stretched past the horizon "freezes in" and is held unchanged until the horizon grows back over it; then it sets the initial conditions for structure. A write-once latch, set at one crossing and read at the next.
- Every galaxy we see beyond redshift 1.46 is, in proper distance, receding faster than light, and some always have been, yet their light still reaches us.
- The same supernovae both brake and spark star formation: their feedback expels the gas that would make stars, while their shock waves 'trigger a chain reaction of star-building'. One event, two loops of opposite sign running through the same floors.
- Every dwarf galaxy near the Milky Way, from thousands of stars to millions, has about the same central mass, about 10 million suns, which the source reads as a floor set by the dark matter itself.
- Where a galaxy lives sets how fast it makes stars: isolated void galaxies have the highest rate per stellar mass, galaxies in dense clusters the lowest, because the cluster's hot gas strips and strangles them.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
electromagnetic field (starlight, gas cooling and dust)
- L1: Light from stars, gas, dust and any active nucleus; ionising photons add an eV-scale heat (~10^4 K) to the gas they reach
- L2: Radiative cooling of the gas: where cooling is inefficient a hot halo forms; cool gas precipitates out of warm halo gas through thermal instabilities
- L3: Dust reprocessing: dust absorbs about half the starlight in the universe and re-emits it from infrared to millimetre
- L4: The integrated colour: blue cloud of star-forming galaxies, red sequence of quenched ones, the green valley between
- L5: Light out into the intergalactic medium: galaxies reionised intergalactic hydrogen by z ~ 6; today their light reaches observers, including human eyes
expansion of space (Hubble flow)
- L1: Comoving place in expanding space: separations between galaxies grow on average
- L2: Peculiar motion against the flow: Andromeda approaches the Milky Way at about 109 km/s on a near-radial orbit
- L3: Bound against the expansion: associations of galaxies overcome it locally through mutual gravity
- L4: The long future: star formation expected to continue up to a hundred billion years; whether the Milky Way and Andromeda merge is open
galactic magnetic field
- L1: The galaxy's own field, typical strength 15 microgauss (20-30 in arms and bars, 50-100 in starburst centres), amplified by supernova- and spiral-shock-driven turbulence (small-scale dynamo)
- L2: Large-scale ordered fields: spiral patterns that are signatures of mean-field dynamos
- L3: Cosmic rays on the field: the field controls their density and propagation; together they can drive fast hot outflows
gravitational field (the galaxy's bound potential)
- L1: Gravity binding the whole: a bound collection of stars that baryons and Newton's gravity cannot explain; from under a thousand stars to a hundred trillion
- L2: The halo well: every galaxy forms within a dark matter halo; rotation curves of bright spirals stay flat out to 50 kpc
- L3: Infall and settling: shock heating forms a hot halo where cooling is slow; cooled gas collapses until its angular momentum holds it up as a disc; tidal-torque spin needs extended haloes for discs as large as those seen
- L4: Disc and orbit dynamics: spiral arms (density waves, swing-amplified instabilities or tides; transient and recurrent except perhaps in bars); in spheroids, chaotic orbits from a central cusp or hole push the shape towards axisymmetry
- L5: Star formation in the potential: gas collapses in giant molecular clouds at about 1% per free-fall time
- L6: Interactions and assembly: mergers trigger bursts and black-hole accretion and transform discs into spheroids; peculiar shapes are mergers (Toomre & Toomre); a 4:1 merger built the Milky Way's thick disc about 10 Gyr ago
interstellar gas (feedback, quenching and the baryon cycle)
- L1: The galaxy's gas, fed back by stars: about 27% of the mass of each stellar generation returns (Salpeter IMF; 41% Chabrier)
- L2: Stellar feedback: stellar-driven winds, strongest at low masses; star formation stays at about 1% per free-fall time
- L3: AGN feedback: radiation, winds and jets eject or heat the gas; the energy of black-hole growth exceeds the bulge's binding energy; the same ejection may squeeze gas into stars
- L4: Quenching: mass and environment quenching, separable; strangulation (about 4 Gyr) the main route below 10^11 solar masses; processes act both ejectively and preventively
- L5: The baryon cycle with the circumgalactic medium: fuel source, feedback venue, recycling (halo fountain); where the supply is regulated is not agreed
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: The cold gas reserve (the disc's interstellar medium): its mass sets the star formation rate
- L5: Gas turned into stars in giant molecular clouds (1% per free-fall time, depletion 1-2 Gyr; bursts of about 10 Myr after mergers) and fed to the central black hole
- L6: Feedback and quenching: stellar winds (strongest in small galaxies), black-hole feedback (big ones), environment; the regulator set by consumption time and wind mass loading
- L7: The galaxy's standing state: stellar mass (formation efficiency peaks at 20-30% of baryons near 10^12 solar-mass haloes), morphology (Hubble sequence), colour (blue cloud, green valley, red sequence), place on the main sequence
the galaxy as astronomers describe it (reader's view)
- L1: The galaxy's surroundings: the cosmic web's filaments of cold gas, groups and clusters, the intergalactic medium and its ultraviolet background, all in expanding space
- L2: The halo's edge, the virial radius (about 282 kpc for the Milky Way), where cold streams push through or gas shocks to the virial temperature; neither edge is well defined
- L3: The dark matter halo and the circumgalactic medium: the potential well, and halo gas that is fuel source, feedback venue and perhaps the key regulator of supply
- L4: The cold gas reserve in the disc: the reservoir whose mass sets the star formation rate
- L5: Star formation in giant molecular clouds (about 1% per free-fall time; depletion time 1-2 Gyr), and fuelling of the central black hole
- L6: Feedback and quenching: stellar winds strongest in small galaxies, black-hole feedback in big ones, strangulation and stripping in dense surroundings
- L7: The standing state and what the galaxy gives back: mass, morphology (Hubble sequence), colour (blue cloud, green valley, red sequence), light that once reionised the universe, metals, and pull on neighbours
way in: Expansion of space (the Hubble flow)
- L1: Comoving place in expanding space: separations between galaxies grow on average
- L2: Peculiar motion against the flow (Andromeda approaching at ~109 km/s)
- L3: Bound against the flow: mutual gravity overcomes the expansion locally
way in: Gas falling in from the cosmic web
- L1: Cold gas in the cosmic web's filaments
- L2: The halo boundary: cold streams push through, or gas shocks and forms a hot halo where cooling is slow; downsizing set by a mass floor and the shock-heating ceiling
- L3: Through the circumgalactic medium: streams carry 2-3 times the halo's specific angular momentum; cool gas precipitates from warm; galaxies must acquire gas
way in: Gas returning from the galaxy's own halo (halo fountain)
- L1: Gas and metals the galaxy's winds put into its own circumgalactic medium
- L2: The circumgalactic medium as venue for feedback and recycling; cool gas precipitates out of warm through thermal instabilities
- L3: Recycled gas re-enters the disc on long timescales (the halo fountain); on what timescales is open
way in: Gravity of the neighbourhood (neighbours, group, cluster, mergers)
- L1: The mass around the galaxy: neighbours on their orbits (Andromeda on a near-radial approach), the group or cluster
- L2: Tides, torques and encounters: early tidal torques spin up the halo; mergers and near misses reshape the disc
- L3: Halo and orbit response: the merger's stars become halo and thick disc; satellites lose their supply
way in: The hot gas of a cluster (ram pressure)
- L1: Intracluster gas met when the galaxy falls into a cluster
- L2: Ram pressure on the disc's gas (Gunn & Gott criterion); the hot halo supply is cut (strangulation)
- L3: Gas removed, long cometary tails; 30-70% of satellites quenched by environment
way in: The ionizing UV background
- L1: Ionising ultraviolet light from all galaxies (and quasars) filling the intergalactic medium after reionization
- L2: Photoheating: ionising photons add ~1 eV per atom, about 10^4 K
- L3: The well-depth test: halos below about 10^8 solar masses cannot hold gas that warm, so galaxy formation is suppressed there (squelching)
way out: Jets and heating of hot halo gas
- L3: Heating of the hot halo or cluster gas, roughly continuous, cutting radiative cooling and star formation tenfold
- L6: Kinetic-mode jets from the nucleus, common in massive ellipticals
way out: Light out
- L1: What it acts on: intergalactic hydrogen (reionised by z ~ 6), other galaxies' halos (squelching), and observers' eyes and telescopes
- L5: Stars and any active nucleus emit; dust absorbs about half the starlight and re-emits it in the infrared
- L7: The integrated light and colour: blue cloud, green valley or red sequence
way out: Pull on neighbours
- L1: The group's shared gravity; Andromeda and the Milky Way on a near-radial orbit
- L3: Tides on satellites and member stars; the Sun's 240-million-year orbit
- L7: The galaxy's total mass, mostly dark matter (Milky Way virial mass 1.3 x 10^12 solar masses)
way out: Winds and outflows
- L1: Metals and energy into the halo and beyond, some returning as a fountain
- L3: Winds pass into the circumgalactic medium, the venue of feedback and recycling
- L6: Stellar winds (mass loading proportional to star formation) and quasar winds (5-10% of accretion power) launched
Who fills each layer
- L1: Galactic bulge, Interstellar medium, Stellar remnant (compact star), Hubble sphere, Reachable universe (inner region), Star cluster (open and globular), Solar System
- L2: Supernova, Black hole, Competition for galactic gas (black hole vs star formation), Photon-baryon fluid (partnership), Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution, Competition for each baryon overdensity (photon pressure vs gravitational collapse), Quasar, Interstellar medium, Galactic bulge, Comoving frame (comoving observer), Region reachable below light speed, Dark fluid
- L3: Dark matter-baryon partnership (structure formation), Galactic bulge, Cosmic dust, Causal region of an observer (parent kind: the principal causal regions of our universe)
- L4: Cosmological event horizon, Interstellar medium, Galactic bulge, Cosmological horizon, De Sitter horizon, Goedel's expanding rotating universes, Eventually observable universe (inside the future visibility limit), Static Weyl vacuum, TRAPPIST-1 system
- L5: Star, Competition for cloud gas (competitive accretion and stellar feedback), Star and interstellar medium matter cycle (stellar recycling), Black hole
- L6: Galactic bulge
Sources (115) published science
Goedel metric (Wikipedia), definition, properties, cylindrical chart, cosmological interpretation (behind its links)
Chronology of the universe (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Milky Way (Wikipedia, rev 1382056834, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Galaxy formation and evolution (rev 1380681475, 2026-10-17) (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Galaxy merger (Wikipedia, rev 1378599912, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Star formation (Wikipedia, rev 1372522924, 2026-09-01, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Interstellar medium (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Warm-hot intergalactic medium (Wikipedia, rev 1373455838, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Madau P., Dickinson M. (2014) Cosmic star-formation history. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 52:415 (arXiv:1403.0007) (behind its links)
Dekel A., Birnboim Y. (2006) Galaxy bimodality due to cold flows and shock heating. MNRAS 368:2 (arXiv:astro-ph/0412300) (behind its links)
Okamoto T., Gao L., Theuns T. (2008) Mass loss of galaxies due to an ultraviolet background. MNRAS 390:920 (arXiv:0806.0378) (behind its links)
Bigiel F. et al. (2008) The star formation law in nearby galaxies on sub-kpc scales. AJ 136:2846 (arXiv:0810.2541) (behind its links)
Krumholz M.R., Tan J.C. (2007) Slow star formation in dense gas: evidence and implications. ApJ 654:304 (arXiv:astro-ph/0606277) (behind its links)
Bland-Hawthorn J., Gerhard O. (2016) The Galaxy in context: structural, kinematic and integrated properties. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 54:529 (arXiv:1602.07702) (behind its links)
Naab T., Ostriker J.P. (2017) Theoretical challenges in galaxy formation. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 55:59 (arXiv:1612.06891) (behind its links)
Behroozi P.S., Wechsler R.H., Conroy C. (2013) The average star formation histories of galaxies in dark matter halos from z=0-8. ApJ 770:57 (arXiv:1207.6105) (behind its links)
Boselli A., Gavazzi G. (2006) Environmental effects on late-type galaxies in nearby clusters. PASP 118:517 (arXiv:astro-ph/0601108) (behind its links)
Carniani S et al. (2024) Spectroscopic confirmation of two luminous galaxies at z~14. Nature 633:318-322. doi:10.1038/s41586-024-07860-9 (behind its links)
Bland-Hawthorn J, Gerhard O (2016) The Galaxy in Context: Structural, Kinematic and Integrated Properties. ARA&A 54:529-596. doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-081915-023441 (behind its links)
Bigiel F et al. (2008) The Star Formation Law in Nearby Galaxies on Sub-Kpc Scales. AJ 136:2846. doi:10.1088/0004-6256/136/6/2846 (behind its links)
Kennicutt RC, Evans NJ (2012) Star Formation in the Milky Way and Nearby Galaxies. ARA&A. doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-081811-125610 (behind its links)
Peng Y, Maiolino R, Cochrane R (2015) Strangulation as the primary mechanism for shutting down star formation in galaxies. Nature. doi:10.1038/nature14439 (behind its links)
Madau & Dickinson, Cosmic star-formation history (Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 52, 415; arXiv:1403.0007) (behind its links)
Somerville RS, Dave R (2015) Physical Models of Galaxy Formation in a Cosmological Framework. ARA&A. doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-082812-140951 (behind its links)
Wechsler RH, Tinker JL (2018) The Connection between Galaxies and their Dark Matter Halos. ARA&A. doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-051756 (behind its links)
Fabian 2012, Observational Evidence of AGN Feedback, ARA&A 50, 455, doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-081811-125521 (behind its links)
Kormendy J., Ho L. C. (2013) Coevolution (or not) of supermassive black holes and host galaxies, doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-082708-101811, arXiv:1304.7762 (behind its links)
Peng Y et al. (2010) Mass and environment as drivers of galaxy evolution in SDSS and zCOSMOS. ApJ 721:193. doi:10.1088/0004-637X/721/1/193 (behind its links)
Speagle JS et al. (2014) A Highly Consistent Framework for the Evolution of the Star-Forming Main Sequence from z~0-6. ApJS 214:15. doi:10.1088/0067-0049/214/2/15 (behind its links)
R. Beck, Magnetic fields in spiral galaxies, Astron. Astrophys. Rev. (2015), arXiv:1509.04522 (behind its links)
van der Marel RP et al. (2012) The M31 Velocity Vector. II. Radial Orbit Towards the Milky Way and Implied Local Group Mass. ApJ 753:8. doi:10.1088/0004-637X/753/1/8 (behind its links)
Helmi A et al. (2018) The merger that led to the formation of the Milky Way's inner stellar halo and thick disk. Nature 563:85 (arXiv 1806.06038) (behind its links)
Sawala T et al. (2025) No certainty of a Milky Way-Andromeda collision. Nature Astronomy. doi:10.1038/s41550-025-02563-1 (behind its links)
Falchi F et al. 2016. The new world atlas of artificial night sky brightness. Sci Adv. doi:10.1126/sciadv.1600377 (behind its links)
Lintott CJ et al. (2008) Galaxy Zoo: Morphologies derived from visual inspection of galaxies from the SDSS. MNRAS 389:1179. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.13689.x (behind its links)
Lilly SJ et al. (2013) Gas-regulation of galaxies. ApJ 772:119. doi:10.1088/0004-637X/772/2/119 (behind its links)
Robertson BE (2022) Galaxy Formation and Reionization: Key Unknowns and Expected Breakthroughs by JWST. ARA&A. doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-120221-044656 (behind its links)
Boselli A, Fossati M, Sun M (2022) Ram Pressure Stripping in High-Density Environments. A&ARv. doi:10.1007/s00159-022-00140-3 (behind its links)
Tumlinson J., Peeples M.S., Werk J.K. (2017) The circumgalactic medium. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 55:389 (arXiv:1709.09180) (behind its links)
Dark matter halo (behind its links)
Galaxy cluster (Wikipedia, rev 1382327768, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Observable universe (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Bondi, H., Samuel, J. (1997) The Lense-Thirring effect and Mach's principle, Phys. Lett. A 228, 121-126; arXiv:gr-qc/9607009 (read in full) (behind its links)
Krauss & Scherrer, The return of a static universe and the end of cosmology (Gen. Relativ. Gravit. 39, 1545; arXiv:0704.0221) (behind its links)
Galaxy group (Wikipedia, rev 1370775923, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Star (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Supernova (Wikipedia, rev 1381286413, 2026-10-21) (behind its links)
Neutron star merger (Wikipedia, rev 1367579662, 2026-08-03) (behind its links)
Neutron star (Wikipedia, rev 1381535165, 2026-10-23) (behind its links)
Black hole (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Planet (Wikipedia; metallicity and pulsar-planet passages) (behind its links)
Molecular cloud (rev 1378820683, 2026-10-06) (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Future of an expanding universe (Wikipedia, rev 1381370483, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched paced 2026-10-27) (behind its links)
Cosmic ray (Wikipedia, 2026-10-17) (behind its links)
White dwarf (Wikipedia, 2026-10-22) (behind its links)
Supermassive black hole (Wikipedia, 2026-10-24) (behind its links)
Oort cloud (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Initial mass function (rev 1370780295, 2026-08-23) (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Sun (Wikipedia, rev 1381179696, 2026-10-20) (behind its links)
Gamma-ray burst (Wikipedia, rev 1381033607, 2026-10-19, via Wikimedia Enterprise; history, classification, energetics, progenitors, emission, effects read) (behind its links)
Active galactic nucleus (rev 1378693852, 2026-10-05) (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Quasar (Wikipedia, rev 1382263223, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Primordial black hole (Wikipedia, 2026-10-19) (behind its links)
Solar System (Wikipedia, rev 1382642208, 2026-10-29; Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Burgasser, A. J. & Mamajek, E. E. (2017) On the age of the TRAPPIST-1 system. ApJ 845, 110; doi:10.3847/1538-4357/aa7fea (abstract read) (behind its links)
Conselice CJ (2014) The Evolution of Galaxy Structure over Cosmic Time. ARA&A. doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-081913-040037 (behind its links)
Dobbs C, Baba J (2014) Dawes Review 4: Spiral Structures in Disc Galaxies. PASA. doi:10.1017/pasa.2014.31 (behind its links)
Structure formation (Wikipedia, rev 1376287164, 2026-09-23) (behind its links)
Tumlinson J, Peeples MS, Werk JK (2017) The Circumgalactic Medium. ARA&A 55:389-432. doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-091916-055240 (behind its links)
Merritt D (1996) Chaos and the Shapes of Elliptical Galaxies (Science 271:337; arXiv preprint) (behind its links)
Dark energy (Wikipedia, 2026-10-21) (behind its links)
Expansion of the universe (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Rogue planet (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Ram pressure (Wikipedia, rev 1380332336, via Wikimedia Enterprise), galactic ram pressure stripping section (behind its links)
Self-interacting dark matter (encyclopedia, Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-10-01, version 1340961845) (behind its links)
De Sitter universe (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Re Fiorentin, M., Re Fiorentin, S. (2023) Cosmological horizons. Am. J. Phys. 91(8), 644-652; arXiv:2507.09322 (behind its links)
Dust solution (Wikipedia, rev 1370773679, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Meinel, R. (1997) The rigidly rotating disk of dust and its black hole limit, Proc. 2nd Mexican School on Gravitation and Mathematical Physics; arXiv:gr-qc/9703077 (behind its links)
Cosmic time (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise paced fetch 2026-10-28) (behind its links)
Farnes, A Unifying Theory of Dark Energy and Dark Matter: Negative Masses and Matter Creation within a Modified LCDM Framework, A&A 620, A92 (2018); arXiv:1712.07962 (behind its links)
Hubble's law (behind its links)
Cosmic inflation (Wikipedia, 2026-10-10) (behind its links)
Comoving and proper distances (Wikipedia, rev 1368675317, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Age of the universe (Wikipedia, rev 1381598943, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Lambda-CDM model (Wikipedia, rev 1379855309, 2026-10-12): Planck 2018 parameter table (behind its links)
Cosmic string (Wikipedia, rev 1370774544, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Springel V, Frenk CS, White SDM (2006) The large-scale structure of the Universe. Nature 440:1137. doi:10.1038/nature04805 (behind its links)
Manos T, Athanassoula E. Regular and chaotic orbits in barred galaxies I. MNRAS 415:629 (2011), arXiv:1102.1157 (behind its links)
Mo HJ, Mao S, White SDM (1998) The Formation of Galactic Disks. MNRAS 295:319. doi:10.1046/j.1365-8711.1998.01227.x (behind its links)
Dekel A. et al. (2009) Cold streams in early massive hot haloes as the main mode of galaxy formation. Nature 457:451 (arXiv:0808.0553) (behind its links)
Keres D., Katz N., Weinberg D.H., Dave R. (2005) How do galaxies get their gas? MNRAS 363:2 (arXiv:astro-ph/0407095) (behind its links)
Peng Y. et al. (2010) Mass and environment as drivers of galaxy evolution in SDSS and zCOSMOS. ApJ 721:193 (arXiv:1003.4747) (behind its links)
Kormendy and Ho (2013), Coevolution (Or Not) of Supermassive Black Holes and Host Galaxies, ARA&A 51, 511-653 (read via ar5iv, abstract and sections 1-2) (behind its links)
Veilleux S., Cecil G., Bland-Hawthorn J. (2005) Galactic winds. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 43:769 (arXiv:astro-ph/0504435) (behind its links)
Beck R. (2015) Magnetic fields in spiral galaxies. Astron. Astrophys. Rev. 24:4 (arXiv:1509.04522) (behind its links)
Somerville R.S., Dave R. (2015) Physical models of galaxy formation in a cosmological framework. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 53:51 (arXiv:1412.2712) (behind its links)
Reionization (Wikipedia, rev 1375348435, 2026-09-17) (behind its links)