← all systems · see it in The System
Quantum fluctuation
'a quantum fluctuation (also known as a vacuum state fluctuation or vacuum fluctuation) is the temporary random change in the amount of energy in a point in space, as prescribed by Werner Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. They are minute random fluctuations in the values of the fields which represent elementary particles'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Quantum fluctuations of the metric |
| born at | with the quantum fields (rung 2); hypothesised at the Planck scale (rung 1); the seeds during inflation (hypothesised) |
| born precision | not dated in the sources read |
| boundary | Inside: the temporary random departure of a field's value (and energy) from its vacuum expectation: the variance that remains when the field's average vanishes, with amplitude set by hbar; its virtual-pair and loop expression; and, as the cosmic seeds, the same variance in the inflaton stretched past the horizon, frozen, and handed on as primordial density perturbations. Outside: thermal fluctuations (amplitude set by k_B T), the fields and the vacuum state themselves, the expansion that stretches them, and the structures that grow from them. |
| nested level | A property of every quantum field's vacuum state (rung 2), hypothesised for the metric itself at the Planck scale (rung 1, Wheeler's foam), and, in inflation, of the inflaton, where it becomes the seeds of all later structure. |
| scale | field |
Measures (22) published science
| hbar/2 in the energy-time uncertainty relation | 5.27286e-35 J s |
| scale of spacetime fluctuations (expected) | about 1e-35 (Planck length) m |
| observed smoothness bound | 1,000 times smaller than a hydrogen nucleus length |
| LIGO mirror correlations below the standard quantum limit reported | July 2020 date |
| first calculation of inflationary fluctuations (Mukhanov and Chibisov) | 1981 year |
| characteristic clock: lifetime of a fluctuation of energy Delta E, shorter than hbar/(2 Delta E) | hbar/(2 Delta E) s |
| characteristic clock: lifetime of a vacuum fluctuation of energy Delta E | shorter than Delta t, with Delta E Delta t >= hbar/2 (an interpretation the sources call not universal) |
| Lamb shift of hydrogen 2S1/2 above 2P1/2 | observed 1057 MHz (Lamb-Retherford 1947: about 1000 MHz); about 27 MHz (about 3%) from electron-positron field fluctuations |
| Casimir force: prediction and first quantitative measurement | predicted 1948 (Casimir); measured within 5% of theory in 1997 (Lamoreaux) year / % |
| LIGO mirror-light quantum correlations | 'a factor of 1.4 (3dB) below the SQL' with 40 kg mirrors and 200 kW beams (2020) |
| expected scale of metric fluctuations (spacetime foam) | on the order of the Planck length (about 10^-35 m); some quantum-gravity models predict much larger |
| observed smoothness of spacetime (no image degradation of distant quasars) | smooth at least down to distances 1,000 times smaller than a hydrogen nucleus length |
| free parameters of the primordial spectrum | 2 (amplitude and spectral index) parameters |
| scalar spectral index n_s | Planck 2018: 0.9649 +/- 0.0042 (68% CL), no evidence of scale dependence; encyclopedia: 0.968 +/- 0.006; n_s = 1 is scale invariant dimensionless |
| tensor-to-scalar ratio r | Planck 2018: < 0.10 (95% CL); < 0.056 with BICEP2/Keck BK15 dimensionless |
| amplitude of the observed inhomogeneities | one part in 100,000 fraction |
| CMB anisotropy | isotropic to roughly one part in 25,000; rms variations just over 100 microK (after the dipole) |
| predicted CMB anisotropy from quantum inhomogeneities (1970s) | 10^-4 or 10^-5 (Harrison, Peebles and Yu, Zel'dovich) fraction |
| matter-radiation equality | ~47,000 years after the Big Bang |
| BAO standard ruler today | about 490 million light years (0.14 Mpc radius at recombination) |
| characteristic clock: horizon exit and re-entry of a mode | a mode freezes on leaving the horizon during inflation and re-enters during radiation and matter domination (no time given per mode in the sources read) |
| description dates | Lamb-Retherford 1947; Casimir 1948; Wheeler foam 1955; Tryon 1973; Mukhanov-Chibisov (first calculation); Nuffield workshop 1982 (four groups); COBE 1992; Lamoreaux 1997; Planck 2018; LIGO 2020 year |
Open contentions (3) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-137 What causes the Casimir force: empty-space energy, or ordinary forces between the plates' charges?
booked: The map uses the zero-point vacuum reading, and keeps the charge-to-charge reading alongside.
the other reading: B: the retarded van der Waals force; 'a heuristic and calculational aid ... but not a necessity in QED' (Jaffe 2005) - C-264 What is a vacuum fluctuation, really?
booked: The map describes it as the spread in a field's strength in empty space, and keeps the 'borrowed energy' and 'just a calculation' readings alongside.
the other reading: (a) pairs that borrow energy Delta E for a time Delta t: 'this interpretation of the energy-time uncertainty relation is not universal'; (b) a calculational picture not needed by QED (Jaffe; Schwinger's source theory) - C-265 Where did the first small ripples that grew into galaxies come from?
booked: The map follows the most widely accepted explanation, quantum fluctuations stretched by inflation, and keeps a contracting phase before a bounce alongside.
the other reading: a contracting phase before a bounce (ekpyrotic and cyclic models), where 'Whether the correct spectrum of density fluctuations can be produced ... remains a topic of controversy'
Cross-scale patterns seen here (9) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Quantum fluctuation. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- causal ceiling (partial)
Without inflation 'no causal mechanism could have ensured that the universe was homogeneous on the scale of the perturbation mode'; a mode beyond the horizon cannot evolve causally until it re-enters. - not-diluting wins (partial)
Inflation 'smooths out inhomogeneities and anisotropies'; afterwards 'the only significant inhomogeneities are tiny quantum fluctuations': the fluctuations, renewed in every volume, are what survives the dilution of everything else. - runaway from an unstable balance (partial)
A nearly homogeneous universe is unstable to gravity: superhorizon fluctuations 'grow proportional to the scale factor', and after equality dark matter's Jeans instability 'is not opposed by any force', so ripples run away into halos. - seed (partial)
Two free parameters (amplitude and spectral index) describe the whole spectrum, yet the realised field is 'the primordial seeds for all structure created in the later universe': halos, filaments, galaxies. - templating (partial)
One mechanism in every field: 'all quantum fields have zero-point energies and vacuum fluctuations' (electromagnetic, W and Z, gluon, the inflaton, and, hypothesised, the metric). - trade one property for another (partial)
Squeezed vacuum moves noise out of one quadrature ('fluctuations below the shot noise level') into the other; LIGO's standard quantum limit is the balance between radiation-pressure and position uncertainty, beaten only 'via correlations'. - who opens the door (partial)
At the atom the receiver filters: 'The electron is unable to respond to the fluctuating field if the fluctuations are smaller than the natural orbital frequency'; at the plates the boundaries choose which modes fit. The receivers' own physics opens the door. - lightning (surface)
BICEP2's 2014 announcement of r between 0.15 and 0.27, then 'lowered confidence', and by 2018 'r is 0.06 or lower'. - same shape, opposite sign (surface)
At a horizon one member of a fluctuation pair escapes as Hawking radiation and its partner falls in: the hole 'would reduce the mass'; the outside gains a photon.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (22) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Cosmic microwave background via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum fluctuation even
- Casimir effect via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum fluctuation even
- Primordial gravitational waves (inflationary tensor modes) via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum fluctuation even
- Hydrogen atom via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum fluctuation even
- Electron via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum fluctuation even
- Electromagnetic field via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum fluctuation even
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch) via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum fluctuation gain
- Dark matter via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum fluctuation gain
- Inflaton field via sys:inflaton-field · Quantum fluctuation gain
- Black hole via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum fluctuation even
- Photon-baryon plasma via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum fluctuation even
- Galaxy via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum fluctuation loss
- Primordial black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum fluctuation loss
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Quantum fluctuation gain
- de Sitter spacetime via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum fluctuation gain
- Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical) via sys:spacetime · Quantum fluctuation gain
- False vacuum (metastable electroweak vacuum) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Quantum fluctuation even
- Zero-energy universe via sys:quantum-vacuum · Quantum fluctuation even
- Virtual black hole via sys:spacetime · Quantum fluctuation gain
- Quantum mechanics via sys:quantum-vacuum · Quantum fluctuation gain
- Quantum field theory via sys:quantum-vacuum · Quantum fluctuation gain
- Decoherence via sys:gravitational-field · Quantum fluctuation mixed
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (10)
- Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical)
- Zero-energy universe
- Electromagnetic field
- Weak field
- Strong (colour) field
- Inflaton field
- Spacetime
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Virtual particles (vacuum fluctuations)
- Virtual black hole
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical)
floor filled by (33)
- Cosmic microwave background
- Spacetime foam (quantum foam; hypothetical)
- Primordial gravitational waves (inflationary tensor modes)
- Zero-energy universe
- Hydrogen atom
- Electron
- Gravitational field
- Electromagnetic field
- Weak field
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
- Dark matter
- Strong (colour) field
- Inflaton field
- Spacetime
- Black hole
- Photon-baryon plasma
- Galaxy
- Primordial black hole
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Primordial density perturbation
- de Sitter spacetime
- Casimir effect
- Eternal inflation
- Cosmological horizon
- Baryon acoustic oscillations (cosmic sound)
- Quantum mechanics
- Quantum field theory
- Decoherence
- Squeezed vacuum
- Gravitational-wave detector (AdLIGO, GEO600)
- Virtual black hole
- Universe
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
wired (2)
Notes published science
- The biggest things we know, the cosmic web and a 490-million-light-year ruler written in the galaxies, began as quantum jitters in the vacuum, some of them smaller than the Planck length before inflation stretched them.
- A mode stretched past the horizon "freezes in" and is held unchanged until the horizon grows back over it; then it sets the initial conditions for structure. A write-once latch, set at one crossing and read at the next.
- Vacuum fluctuations now move 40 kg mirrors: LIGO measured light-mirror correlations 'a factor of 1.4 (3dB) below the SQL', and squeezed vacuum is part of how the detectors listen.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
inflaton fluctuations stretched by inflation (inflaton field, hypothesised)
- L1: 'new inflation does not produce a perfectly symmetric universe, but ... quantum fluctuations in the inflaton are created' while the field slow-rolls.
- L2: Stretch and freeze: the exponential growth of the scale factor stretches them 'to macroscopic scales, and, upon leaving the horizon, to "freeze in"'; inflation 'separates quantum fluctuations before they can equilibrate'; afterwards 'the only significant inhomogeneities are tiny quantum fluctuations'.
- L3: The spectrum: 'a nearly-scale-invariant Gaussian random field ... has only two free parameters' (amplitude, spectral index n_s = 0.9649 +/- 0.0042, Planck 2018, no scale dependence); adiabatic (isocurvature modes small); scalar modes seed structure, tensor modes (r < 0.10; < 0.056 with BK15) would be primordial gravitational waves.
- L4: Quantum to classical: in the quasi-classical (large squeezing) limit the perturbations are equivalent 'to classical perturbations having stochastic Gaussian amplitudes', once an exponentially small decaying mode is neglected; the environment leaves the rms predictions unchanged.
- L5: Eternal inflation: 'quantum fluctuations can sometimes lift it to previous levels'; 'once it starts, inflation perpetuates itself and quickly dominates the Universe' (hypothesised).
metric fluctuations at the Planck scale (spacetime, hypothetical)
- L1: Fluctuating geometry: Wheeler (1955): 'over sufficiently small distances and sufficiently brief intervals of time, the "very geometry of spacetime fluctuates"', giving spacetime a 'foamy' character.
- L2: Scale: expected 'on the order of the Planck length (about 10^-35 m), but some models of quantum gravity predict much larger fluctuations'; some of the fluctuations that made today's structure 'were smaller than the Planck length before inflation'.
- L3: Readout as limits: photons 'should be slowed by quantum foam, with the rate depending on the wavelength'; MAGIC's 2005 delays not confirmed; distant quasar images show 'no detectable degradation' (smooth to 1,000 times below a hydrogen nucleus).
quantum fluctuation (own: random variance of a quantum field about its vacuum value)
- L1: The quantum fields at every point (electric and magnetic fields, W and Z fields, gluon fields): 'although the average values of the fields vanish in a quantum vacuum, their variances do not'; the vacuum state is Lorentz-invariant.
- L2: Uncertainty: Delta E Delta t >= hbar/2 with hbar/2 about 5.27286e-35 J s; 'the amplitude of quantum fluctuations controlled by the Planck constant', as that of thermal fluctuations by k_B T; quantum systems 'constantly fluctuate in their lowest energy state'. The energy-budget reading of the relation 'is not universal'.
- L3: Virtual pairs and loop diagrams: pairs 'are continually created and annihilated in empty space'; fluctuations 'enter at the level of loop diagrams'; the divergences are absorbed by renormalisation; fluctuations carry high energies into effective theories.
- L4: Measurable cumulative effects: 'the cumulative effects of these particles are measurable': finite mass and charge, charge screening, the Lamb shift (1057 MHz in hydrogen), the Casimir force (within 5% of theory, 1997), spontaneous emission, Hawking radiation at horizons.
- L5: Macroscopic reach: 'quantum vacuum fluctuations can influence the motion of macroscopic, human-scale objects' (LIGO's 40 kg mirrors, 2020: 'a factor of 1.4 (3dB) below the SQL'); squeezed vacuum, with 'one quadrature' below shot noise, sharpens AdLIGO and GEO600.
seeds of cosmic structure (primordial perturbations re-entering the horizon and growing; gravitational field)
- L1: Re-entry: 'At the later stages of radiation- and matter-domination, these fluctuations re-entered the horizon, and thus set the initial conditions for structure formation'; 'density variations in the early universe which are considered the seeds of all structure'.
- L2: Growth: fluctuations larger than the horizon 'grow proportional to the scale factor'; smaller ones stay 'essentially frozen' under radiation (Meszaros effect) until matter-radiation equality (~47,000 years); then 'all dark matter ripples could grow freely'.
- L3: Imprint: CMB variations 'of order a few parts in 100,000' that 'trace variations in the density that were the early "seeds"'; rms just over 100 microK; the BAO ruler (about 490 million light years today).
- L4: Collapse: 'dark matter begins to collapse into a complex network of dark matter halos well before ordinary matter'; matter condenses 'in large filaments and haloes which have an intricate web-like structure'; galaxies and stars form in the halos; a strong enough density fluctuation could collapse directly into a primordial black hole (hypothesised).