← all systems · see it in The System
Mach's principle
'the name given by Albert Einstein to an imprecise hypothesis often credited to the physicist and philosopher Ernst Mach': 'the existence of absolute rotation (the distinction of local inertial frames vs. rotating reference frames) is determined by the large-scale distribution of matter'; 'there is a physical law that relates the motion of the distant stars to the local inertial frame'. Its observational base, Mach0: 'The universe, as represented by the average motion of distant galaxies does not appear to rotate relative to local inertial frames' (Bondi and Samuel).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the tie between local inertial (non-rotating) frames and the cosmic distribution and motion of matter: the observed coincidence (Mach0), its partial realisation in general relativity (frame dragging, initial-value constraints, Wheeler-Mach-Einstein spacetimes), and its tests. Outside: the rival gravity theories built to satisfy stronger versions, the human formulations (the idea, rung 11), and the matter and observers it relates. |
| nested level | Walked as the physical structure (a hypothesised law relating matter there to inertia here), at rung 1 with spacetime and frame dragging; the many verbal formulations belong to its idea (rung 11). Below the first fold. |
| scale | cosmological |
Measures (7) published science
| distinct formulations listed (Mach0-Mach10) | 11 count |
| formulations possible in general relativity (Barbour's list) | at least 21 count |
| Tuebingen 1993 poll: 'Is general relativity perfectly Machian?' | 3 yes, 22 no; with closure boundary conditions 'very Machian?': 14 yes, 7 no votes |
| Sagnac time difference | Delta t = -4 A omega/c^2 formula |
| minimum detectable rotation rate of a laser ring gyro | 0.2 degrees per hour (30 s integration) deg/h |
| dates | Mach's Science of Mechanics 1883 (German), 1893 (English); term coined by Einstein 1918; Sciama's inertial induction 1953 year |
| characteristic clock: integration time of the laser-ring rotation test | 30 s |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (1) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Mach's principle. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- the whole sets the local reference (structural)
A global distribution (matter on a slice, distant galaxies) fixes a local standard (which frames do not rotate); the local measurement (Sagnac zero) and the global one (galaxies still) agree.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (9) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Fictitious force via sys:gravitational-field · Mach's principle even
- Sagnac effect via sys:spacetime · Mach's principle gain
- Galaxy via sys:spacetime · Mach's principle gain
- Kerr spacetime via sys:spacetime · Mach's principle gain
- Goedel universe via sys:spacetime · Mach's principle loss
- De Sitter-Schwarzschild spacetime via sys:spacetime · Mach's principle gain
- Inertial observer (inertial frame of reference) via sys:gravitational-field · Mach's principle even
- Brans-Dicke theory via sys:gravitational-field · Mach's principle even
- Frame dragging via sys:gravitational-field · Mach's principle gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (11)
- Goedel universe
- De Sitter-Schwarzschild spacetime
- Sagnac effect
- Galaxy
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Kerr spacetime
- Globally hyperbolic spacetime
- Inertial observer (inertial frame of reference)
- Wheeler-Mach-Einstein spacetimes
- Anti-Mach spacetimes
- Frame dragging
represents (1)
Kinds (5)
- Brans-Dicke theory
- Hoyle-Narlikar theory of gravity
- Inertial induction (Sciama 1953)
- Wheeler-Mach-Einstein spacetimes
- Relational (Barbour-Bertotti) models
Notes published science
- Spin one horizon of Nariai space and the other spins the opposite way: the page calls it 'a manifestation of Mach's principle in self-contained causal patches'.
- Spin on the spot and your arms fly out exactly when the stars seem to whirl: the frame where a ring laser shows no Sagnac shift is the frame where the distant galaxies stand still - an observation nobody has fully explained.
- Physicists voted on it: at Tuebingen in 1993 only 3 of 25 said general relativity is perfectly Machian; 14 of 21 said it becomes 'very Machian' with closed-universe boundary conditions.
- Two of the listed versions contradict each other: Mach3 and Mach10 predict opposite senses of frame dragging for the same rotating body.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
inertia tied to cosmic matter (own, gravitational field)
- L1: The coincidence (Mach0): 'the inertial frame defined by local physics (zero Sagnac shift) coincides with the frame in which the distant objects are at rest'; 'Mach0 is an experimental observation and not a principle'
- L2: The hypothesised law: 'mass out there influences inertia here'; Einstein 1918: 'the g_mu nu are completely determined by the mass of bodies, more generally by T_mu nu'
- L3: Realised in part: a rotating shell makes its interior frame precess (Lense-Thirring); 'The plane of the pendulum would not be dragged around if the shell of matter were not present, or if it were not spinning'; Mach3 'Einstein's theory is not' in conflict with it
- L4: Through the initial-value problem: on each slice the constraint equations are elliptic, so 'only part of the geometry of the slice can be given'; in Wheeler-Mach-Einstein spacetimes (spatially compact, globally hyperbolic) 'the distribution of matter and field energy-momentum ... at a particular moment ... determines the inertial frame at each point'; in asymptotically flat spacetimes boundary conditions at infinity define the frame instead
- L5: Test cases: Goedel's universe, 'designed to disobey Mach's principle in the worst possible way' (an 'Anti-Mach metric'); Nariai's counter-rotating horizons, 'a manifestation of Mach's principle in self-contained causal patches'
local rotation test against the sky (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Light as the test probe: two counter-propagating laser rays in a closed fibre loop on the spaceship; light from distant galaxies
- L2: Sagnac shift: Delta t = -4 A omega/c^2; a frame with zero shift is 'a locally non rotating frame'; a laser ring gyro's 'minimum detectable rotation rate is .2 degrees/hour (using an integration time of 30 seconds)'
- L3: Comparison with the sky: in the locally non-rotating frame 'the distant galaxies are still'; Bondi-Samuel note the early authors' 'fixed' stars move observably in our rotating Galaxy
Who fills each layer
- L1: Fictitious force
- L2: Sagnac effect