← all systems · see it in The System
Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution
The M–sigma relation is an empirical correlation between the stellar velocity dispersion σ of a galaxy bulge and the mass M of the supermassive black hole at its center; it is generally interpreted as implying some source of mechanical feedback between the growth of supermassive black holes and the growth of galaxy bulges, although the source of this feedback is still uncertain.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| asymmetry | Strong. The hole sets the feedback; 'far more energy is released in the formation of a supermassive black hole than is needed to completely unbind the stellar bulge' (citation needed in source). The hole needs no bulge to form; the bulge side's gain is unshown. |
| boundary | Inside: the recurring loop by which gas accreting onto the central supermassive black hole drives a wind or jets that act back on the infalling gas and on the bulge's gas, and the tie it holds between hole mass and the bulge's stellar velocity dispersion. Outside: the hole's own accretion physics, the bulge's own stars and orbits, the disk, the dark matter halo (correlations with disk-grown pseudobulges and halos 'are weak enough to imply no close coevolution'), and star formation as an outside taker of the same gas. |
| cheater | Unseen as such. Nearest: holes that escape the tie, such as NGC 1277 (an order of magnitude above scaling relations) and holes near the growth limit whose luminosity is too weak to trigger the feedback and 'can evolve above this'. |
| drive | driven |
| enforcement | shared-fate |
| flips when | Wind strength: compression that accelerates star formation turns to blow-out of nearly all the gas, quenching the galaxy (blue cloud to red sequence, within 1 Gyr); in radio mode the hole keeps baryons locked up in hot gas. |
| joint output | The M–σ tie: hole mass held in step with bulge velocity dispersion (M ∝ σ^4 to σ^5.1, mean hole to bulge mass about 1:200 in big early-type galaxies), kept tight in spite of mergers and gas accretion; with it, self-limited hole growth and quenched or stable host bulges. |
| knockout | Without a classical bulge the hole still forms and grows ('classical (elliptical-galaxy-like) bulges are not necessary for BH formation'), but the joint output does not appear: 'small BHs in largely bulgeless galaxies involves too little energy to result in coevolution' (src:arxiv:1304.7762); likewise 'the bulge environment is not strictly essential to the initial seeding and growth of massive black holes' (src:wp:galactic-bulge). |
| nested level | Built from two systems through the gravitational field and the gas between them: a supermassive black hole (10^6 to 10^10 solar masses) and a classical bulge or elliptical. Embedded in the host galaxy (container) and its interstellar medium. Galactic scale, epoch 4, below the first fold. |
| obligate | facultative |
| partners | sys:supermassive-black-hole, sys:galactic-bulge |
| recurrence | Episodic: most hole growth is 'through episodes of rapid gas accretion' (AGN or quasar phases); the tie is maintained across mergers and accretion that should scatter it. Number or period of episodes not given in the sources read. |
| regime | Start: not dated for the tie; holes are seen by z = 9.288 (about 500 million years after the Big Bang), and may form before bulges. End: quenching (the cold gas is gone) or a stable elliptical with the hole 'suppressing gas cooling'; outside classical bulges and ellipticals (pseudobulges, disks, halos) no close coevolution. |
| saturation | Hole growth slows from about 10 billion solar masses with a theoretical ceiling about 50 billion; no clear evidence for holes above 10^10, 'possibly an expected consequence of the observed upper limit to σ'. Only a few percent of the hole's energy acts on the gas. |
| scale | galactic |
| separability | Medium. Two different kinds of system (a black hole; a population of stars), and separable: holes are found in bulgeless galaxies (Henize 2-10, 2011), which 'may indicate that black holes formed before bulges'. But the hole sits at the bulge's centre (container risk), and its sphere of influence lies inside the bulge. Dissociation time vs cycle time not sourced. |
Measures (16) published science
| Merritt 1999 form ('Faber–Jackson law for black holes') | M/10^8 Msun ≈ 3.1 (σ/200 km/s)^4 relation |
| recent fit (McConnell et al. 2011) | M/10^8 Msun ≈ 1.9 (σ/200 km/s)^5.1 relation |
| hole to bulge mass, big early-type galaxies | ~1:200 ratio |
| Silk and Rees 1998 predicted slope; normalization too small | α = 5; by about a factor of 1000 (citation needed in source) slope; factor |
| King 2003 predicted slope; normalization vs Silk and Rees | α = 4; about c/σ ≈ 10^3 larger slope; factor |
| share of hole energy acting mechanically (King model) | a few % |
| smallest SMBH with well-determined mass | ~10^6 solar masses |
| no clear evidence for holes above | 10^10 solar masses |
| theoretical upper limit of SMBH growth (slowdown starts) | ~50 billion (~10 billion) solar masses |
| NGC 1277 hole as share of bulge mass | ~59 (14 of total stellar mass) % |
| most distant SMBH (CAPERS-LRD-z9) | z = 9.288, ~500 million years after the Big Bang redshift; time |
| SMBH in bulgeless dwarf Henize 2-10 discovered | 2011 year |
| quenching timescale | < 1 Gyr |
| hole to bulge mass fractions in the review (Magorrian 1998; later HST values) | ~0.0052; ~0.0013-0.0023 fraction |
| classical bulges in dense clusters (e.g. Virgo) | about 2/3 of galaxies |
| characteristic clock: quenching once the cold gas is gone (the blow-out branch) | within 1 Gyr |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (4) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- coordination-before-mapping (structural)
Hole mass and bulge velocity dispersion stay in step, M ~ 1.9 (sigma/200 km/s)^5.1, though nothing maps one to the other: 'some kind of feedback acts to maintain the connection ... in spite of processes like galaxy mergers and gas accretion that might be expected to increase the scatter'. - holding / entrainment (partial)
The bulge's well sets where the hole's growth stops: the flow stalls when the energy deposited would unbind the protogalaxy in one crossing time, so the hole's mass is held to the bulge's sigma. - same role, different builds (partial)
One job, keeping the hole's fuel from cooling and collapsing onto it, done by two builds: quasar mode (radiative wind, energy or momentum injection) and radio mode (jets whose X-ray bubbles 'counterbalance cooling losses'). - same shape, opposite sign (surface)
Gas in and gas out mirror each other: the bulge routes gas to the centre ('gas dumped into the center'; secular evolution 'is also expected to send gas and stars to the center'), and the hole's winds and jets route it back out, heating or expelling it (or compressing it into faster star formation).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (7) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Interstellar medium via sys:interstellar-medium · Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution gain
- Galaxy via sys:gravitational-field · Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution gain
- Supermassive black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution mixed
- Star via sys:gravitational-field · Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution mixed
- Galactic bulge via sys:gravitational-field · Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution gain
- Active galactic nucleus via sys:interstellar-medium · Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution gain
- Quasar via sys:interstellar-medium · Supermassive black hole and host bulge co-evolution gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (5)
expressed by (3)
floor filled by (11)
- Supermassive black hole
- Star
- Photon
- Interstellar medium
- Galactic bulge
- Accretion disc
- Relativistic jets (radio-loud quasars)
- Disc wind (outflow)
- Active galactic nucleus
- Advection-dominated accretion flow (ADAF)
- Quasar
same pair (1)
slides to (1)
Kinds (2)
Notes published science
- The knockout is clean and sourced: take away the classical bulge and the hole still forms and grows, but the tie vanishes ('too little energy to result in coevolution'). The joint output needs both; the partner does not.
- King's flow: only a few percent of the hole's energy pushes on the gas, and that is exactly enough to give the right normalization, about c/σ ≈ 1000 times the Silk and Rees value.
- A ceiling with a loophole: holes near about 10 billion solar masses glow too faintly to trigger the feedback that holds the tie, so the biggest ones can slip above the relation.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
accretion disc and its radiation (AGN)
- L1: In the standard AGN model, cold material close to the black hole forms an accretion disc
- L2: Dissipative processes in the disc transport matter inwards and angular momentum outwards, heating the disc; accretion can convert potential and kinetic energy to radiation very efficiently
- L3: The disc spectrum peaks in the optical-ultraviolet; a hot corona above it inverse-Compton scatters photons up to X-rays; the radiation excites nearby cold gas into emission lines, and obscured light is re-radiated, most likely in the infrared
- L5: Radiatively inefficient accretion: well below the Eddington limit the matter does not form a thin disc and does not radiate away its energy efficiently, explaining quiet massive holes in cluster ellipticals
- L6: Mass ceiling: growth slows to a crawl from about 10 billion solar masses and has a theoretical limit around 50 billion, where the innermost stable orbit exceeds the self-gravity radius, disc formation is no longer possible and the unstable disc coalesces into stars
gas (interstellar medium) carrying the outflow
- L1: Cold gas reservoir: stars form out of cold gas, and a galaxy is quenched when it has no more
- L2: Accretion converts potential and kinetic energy to radiation (high Eddington luminosity)
- L3: Momentum-driven flow: gas cooling time so short that the flow's energy is in bulk motion; only a few percent acts mechanically (King 2003). Or energy-driven wind (Silk and Rees 1998)
- L4: Quasar mode (energy or momentum injection) and radio mode (collimated jets, X-ray bubbles that counterbalance cooling losses)
- L5: The flow stalls when the energy deposited would unbind the protogalaxy in one crossing time; the hole stabilises by suppressing gas cooling
gravitational field
- L1: The bulge's stellar orbits; their velocity dispersion σ measures the depth of its potential
- L2: Gas accreting onto the hole, past the angular-momentum barrier ('the limiting factor in black hole growth')
- L3: Black hole growth by gas accretion in episodes seen as active galactic nuclei or quasars; and by mergers
- L4: The tie: M/10^8 solar masses ≈ 1.9 (σ/200 km/s)^5.1; mean hole to bulge mass about 1:200 in big early-type galaxies
Who fills each layer
- L1: Quasar, Active galactic nucleus
- L2: Active galactic nucleus
- L3: Quasar, Active galactic nucleus
- L4: Quasar, Supermassive black hole, Active galactic nucleus, Galactic bulge
- L5: Active galactic nucleus
- L6: Supermassive black hole