← all systems · see it in The System
Goedel's expanding rotating universes
The family of 'spatially homogeneous expanding and rotating cosmological models' Goedel presented in 1950 (published 1952): 'They are invariant under a non-abelian G3 of isometries simply transitive on spacelike surfaces' (Bianchi type IX, group SO(3), compact surfaces of homogeneity), filled with pressure-free matter, rotating, expanding, and tilted (Ellis 2000). They 'exhibit both rotation and Hubble expansion and have other qualities of his first model, but traveling into the past is not possible' (Goedel metric page).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the dust-filled Bianchi IX geometries with non-zero vorticity and expansion, their tilt, their vorticity and shear relations, and their causal structure (no closed timelike lines when flow lines do not close). Outside: Goedel's stationary 1949 universe, the galaxies and radiation that would test the rotation, and the later Goedel-type generalisations. |
| nested level | A family of exact cosmological solutions: shapes of spacetime at rung 1 (exact-solution rule 17:28), hypothesised as models of our universe. Kinds of Bianchi dust and rotating cosmologies. Below the first fold. |
| scale | cosmological |
Measures (6) published science
| isometry group | G3 = SO(3), simply transitive on compact spacelike surfaces (Bianchi IX) group |
| date presented | 30 August - 5 September 1950 (Proc. ICM 1952, vol. 1, 175-181) date |
| rotation in the Goedel-type expanding model | omega = (m/2a) sqrt(sigma/(k + sigma)) formula |
| earlier estimate of cosmic rotation (from Birch's data, quoted) | omega/H ~ 10^-3 dimensionless |
| galaxy spin asymmetry cited as motivation (JWST, quoted in a preprint) | 50% more galaxies rotate opposite to the Milky Way than with it ratio |
| characteristic clock: present Hubble rate range used for rotating-model estimates, 4 x 10^-11 < H_t < 10^-10 per year; rotation decays as 1/a | 4e-11 to 1e-10 per year |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-096 Does the smoothness of the cosmic microwave background rule out a rotating universe?
booked: The map follows Hawking's result that only a very slow rotation is allowed, and keeps the argument that Gödel-type expanding models escape that limit alongside.
the other reading: B: not for Godel-type expanding models (Obukhov 2000)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Goedel's expanding rotating universes. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- spin-up on contraction (ice skater) (structural)
Contraction raises vorticity and vorticity resists contraction; expansion lets the spin die away. The same angular-momentum shape as a collapsing core spinning up. - trade one property for another (structural)
Adding expansion to Goedel's rotating universe buys realistic redshifts and costs the closed timelike lines: rotation stays, time travel goes.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (6) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Cosmic microwave background via sys:electromagnetic-field · Goedel's expanding rotating universes even
- Galaxy via sys:spacetime · Goedel's expanding rotating universes even
- Goedel universe via sys:spacetime · Goedel's expanding rotating universes gain
- Bianchi dust (spatially homogeneous dust cosmologies) via sys:spacetime · Goedel's expanding rotating universes even
- Four-velocity field via sys:spacetime · Goedel's expanding rotating universes gain
- Closed timelike curve via sys:spacetime · Goedel's expanding rotating universes even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
- Bianchi dust (spatially homogeneous dust cosmologies)
- Rotation group SO(3) (the 3D rotation group)
- Four-velocity field
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (2)
floor filled by (11)
- Cosmic microwave background
- Galaxy
- Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0)
- Einstein static universe
- Cosmic time
- Rotation group SO(3) (the 3D rotation group)
- Four-velocity field
- Goedel-type universe with rotation and expansion (Obukhov 2000)
- Stationary homogeneous rotating universes with Lambda > 0
- Bianchi ix universe
- Raychaudhuri equation
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
- Goedel universe
- Goedel-type universe with rotation and expansion (Obukhov 2000)
- Stationary homogeneous rotating universes with Lambda > 0
Notes published science
- Goedel kept asking 'Is the universe rotating yet?' and was always told 'No, it isn't' - yet his expanding rotating models are the first spatially homogeneous expanding and rotating universes ever written down, and they started the Bianchi-cosmology programme.
- Rotation and simultaneity cannot coexist: if the cosmic matter rotates there is no time function that slices space into a shared 'now' for all fundamental observers - yet in these models you still cannot travel into your own past.
- Goedel's paper seems to have fed into Raychaudhuri's equation, the engine of the Hawking-Penrose singularity theorems (Ellis 2000).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Goedel 1952 expanding rotating spacetime (own, tilted Bianchi IX dust)
- L1: Dust-filled spacetime 'invariant under a non-abelian G3 of isometries simply transitive on spacelike surfaces': Bianchi IX, group SO(3), 'compact spacelike surfaces of homogeneity'
- L2: Rotation, expansion and tilt: rotating solutions satisfying Goedel's conditions I-III, the last implying expansion; 'the models are tilted, i.e. the matter flow lines are not orthogonal to the surfaces of homogeneity'
- L3: Time and causality: 'omega = 0 implies the local existence of a time function defining simultaneity for all fundamental observers', so rotation removes it; yet 'spatial homogeneity precludes closed timelike lines' unless the flow lines close, and 'traveling into the past is not possible'
- L4: Dynamical results: no locally rotationally symmetric cases; 'no expanding and rotating spatially homogeneous type IX universes with vanishing shear'; stationary rotating solutions with lambda > 0 near Einstein's static universe exist, none with lambda = 0
- L5: Observable reading: 'As these permit non-zero redshifts, they could include realistic models of the observed universe'; rotation implies tilt and 'an anisotropy in source number counts'; vorticity axis compared with galaxies' rotation axes
rotation in an expanding dust flow (stress-energy)
- L1: Dust flow lines with four-velocity u; the derivative splits into expansion Theta, shear sigma and vorticity omega ('describing the rotation of the matter relative to a non-rotating (Fermi-propagated) frame')
- L2: Vorticity thins with expansion: omega-dot = -(2/3) Theta omega + sigma omega (Ellis-van Elst eq. 30); in the Goedel-type expanding model omega = (m/2a) sqrt(sigma/(k + sigma)) 'decreases in expanding world'
- L3: Rotation resists collapse: in the Raychaudhuri equation the vorticity enters as +2 omega^2 against -(1/3) Theta^2 - 2 sigma^2 - (1/2)(mu + 3p); and Goedel's models must shear ('no expanding and rotating ... type IX universes with vanishing shear')