← all systems · see it in The System
Closed timelike curve
In mathematical physics, a closed timelike curve (CTC) is a world line in a Lorentzian manifold, of a material particle in spacetime, that is 'closed', returning to its starting point. First discovered by Willem Jacob van Stockum in 1937 and later confirmed by Kurt Goedel in 1949.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the closed world line itself, the chronology-violating set of points through which CTCs pass, and its boundary, the Cauchy horizon, generated by closed null geodesics. Outside: the rest of the manifold, which may be causally well behaved (chronological censorship: CTCs hidden behind event horizons), and the solution that hosts it. |
| nested level | A kind of world line on a Lorentzian manifold; it exists only where the metric tilts light cones far enough to loop back (Goedel, Kerr interior, Tipler cylinder, traversable wormholes). Embedded in the host spacetime; breaks the event's ordering in the spacetime-event walk (SP4). |
| scale | field |
Measures (5) published science
| first discovered | 1937 (van Stockum); confirmed 1949 (Goedel) year |
| observed instances | none (hypothetical; 'Most physicists feel that CTCs in such solutions are artifacts') count |
| classes | 2 (contractible, noncontractible) count |
| characteristic clock: one circuit of the curve | no value given (depends on the host solution) |
| computational class with CTCs (Deutsch prescription) | quantum and classical computation equivalent, both PSPACE (Aaronson and Watrous 2009); PP-complete under Lloyd's prescription complexity class |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Closed timelike curve. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- barrier-gates-complexity (surface)
Chronological censorship: if every CTC passes through an event horizon, the spacetime with horizons excised is still causally well behaved, so ordinary cause-before-effect structure can stand outside the sealed region. - same role, different builds (surface)
The same closed curve is built by different geometries: rotating dust (van Stockum, Goedel), a rotating black hole's interior (Kerr), a rotating cylinder (Tipler), wormholes, cosmic strings (Gott), two spinning balls (Bonnor-Steadman).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (33) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Kerr spacetime via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Goedel universe via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Taub-NUT spacetime via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Event horizon via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve loss
- Non-totally vicious spacetime via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve even
- Chronological spacetime via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve even
- Universal cover of anti-de Sitter space via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve loss
- Cauchy horizon via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve even
- Contractible closed timelike curve via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve even
- Noncontractible closed timelike curve via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve even
- Tipler cylinder via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Van Stockum dust via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Misner space via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- BTZ black hole via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve loss
- Bonnor-Steadman solutions via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Traversable wormhole via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Goedel's expanding rotating universes via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve loss
- Ring singularity via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Totally vicious spacetime via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve even
- Averaged null energy condition (ANEC) via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve loss
- Lorentzian wormhole via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Misner string via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Gravitational field via sys:gravitational-field · Closed timelike curve gain
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines) via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve even
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature) via sys:stress-energy · Closed timelike curve even
- Spacetime event via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve even
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical) via sys:gravitational-field · Closed timelike curve loss
- Manifold topology of spacetime via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Spacetime topology via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Novikov self-consistency principle via sys:stress-energy · Closed timelike curve gain
- Chronology protection conjecture via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve loss
- NUT region via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve gain
- Generalized time function via sys:spacetime · Closed timelike curve even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (10)
- Goedel universe
- Taub-NUT spacetime
- Tipler cylinder
- Totally vicious spacetime
- Light cone (null cone)
- World line
- Spacetime event
- Cauchy horizon
- Novikov self-consistency principle
- NUT region
Sits inside / holds (8)
- Cauchy horizon
- Van Stockum dust
- Bonnor-Steadman solutions
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Kerr spacetime
- Goedel universe
- Taub-NUT spacetime
- Novikov self-consistency principle
floor filled by (37)
- Kerr spacetime
- Anti-de Sitter spacetime
- Goedel universe
- Taub-NUT spacetime
- Non-totally vicious spacetime
- Chronological spacetime
- Light cone (null cone)
- Spacetime event
- Universal cover of anti-de Sitter space
- Cauchy horizon
- Van Stockum dust
- Misner space
- BTZ black hole
- Bonnor-Steadman solutions
- Traversable wormhole
- Ring singularity
- Kerr-Newman spacetime
- Closed null curve
- Totally vicious spacetime
- Averaged null energy condition (ANEC)
- Lorentzian wormhole
- Misner string
- Averaged weak energy condition (AWEC)
- Gravitational field
- Electromagnetic field
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Event horizon
- World line
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
- Tipler cylinder
- Novikov self-consistency principle
- Manifold topology of spacetime
- Spacetime topology
- Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox)
- NUT region
- Generalized time function
represents (1)
Kinds (8)
- Contractible closed timelike curve
- Noncontractible closed timelike curve
- World line
- Causal (non-spacelike) curve
- Closed causal curve (causal loop)
- Time travel to the past
- Wormhole time machine
- Gott's time machine
wired (5)
- Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0)
- Cauchy horizon
- Van Stockum dust
- Ring singularity
- Misner string
Notes published science
- No loop can close at a single event: chronology makes the causal relation irreflexive, so feedback through an event always lands at later events. The only way back is a closed timelike curve, where the state 'must ... eventually result in the state that is identical to the original one'.
- A CTC makes quantum and classical computers equal: under Deutsch's prescription both sit in PSPACE (Aaronson and Watrous 2009).
- The Cauchy horizon at the edge of a time loop is woven from closed light rays, each paying a redshift toll per lap, so the lap count goes to infinity in a finite affine length.
- Roy Kerr on his own solution: the exterior is 'in some sense generic', but the interior holds time loops that most physicists treat as artifacts.
- You can build a topology-changing Lorentzian spacetime on paper, but it costs causality (closed timelike curves) and, in three or more dimensions, it cannot obey Einstein's equation with reasonable matter (Geroch, Tipler, Borde).
- Hiding the string has a price: Misner made time periodic (period 8 pi n), which fills the whole spacetime with closed timelike curves.
- Even with closed timelike curves around the string, a freely falling observer never travels on one: for |C| <= 1 no closed timelike or null geodesic exists.
- Any compact universe that has a timelike (conformal) symmetry is automatically totally vicious; no compact spacetime can avoid closed timelike curves altogether.
- A closed causal loop in a spacetime without closed timelike curves must be achronal, and then it is forced to be a lightlike line (Minguzzi 2018, proof of Theorem 2.71).
- Physics defines spacetime as non-compact on purpose: a compact spacetime always contains closed timelike curves (time travel), which 'is unlikely' to describe our universe.
- A compact universe would have time travel built in: Minguzzi notes 'compact spacetimes contain closed timelike curves', which is why the textbook definition of a spacetime asks it to be non-compact.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
closed timelike curve (own, on the spacetime manifold)
- L1: Tilted light cones: 'In curved spacetimes the light cone will be tilted along the spacetime's geodesic'; in high-curvature metrics tilted beyond 45 degrees, so some 'future' positions are spacelike or past to outside observers
- L2: The closed curve: 'a series of such light cones are set up so as to loop back on themselves', so an object in free fall 'would repeatedly return to the same point in spacetime'
- L3: Chronology violation: 'an event can be simultaneous with its cause'; the event lies in its own future; determinism from a Cauchy surface fails
- L4: Cauchy horizon: the boundary of the chronology-violating set, generated by closed null geodesics, each with a redshift factor; beyond it a region 'that cannot be predicted from perfect knowledge of some past time'
- L5: Topology: no CTC is timelike-homotopic to a point (a 'timelike topological feature'); contractible CTCs cannot be undone, noncontractible ones can on the universal covering space
field states carried round the curve (stress-energy)
- L1: A field configuration (matter-energy) on the family of closed timelike worldlines
- L2: Self-consistency: propagated round the curve the configuration 'must ... eventually result in the state that is identical to the original one' (Novikov self-consistency principle)
- L3: Restriction on allowable states; 'explored ... as a possible approach towards disproving the existence of CTCs'; quantum formulations (Deutsch 1991; Lloyd et al. 2011) face the challenge of freely creating entanglement
Who fills each layer
- L1: Goedel universe, Contractible closed timelike curve, Novikov self-consistency principle, Tipler cylinder, Van Stockum dust
- L2: Taub-NUT spacetime, Bonnor-Steadman solutions, Contractible closed timelike curve, Noncontractible closed timelike curve, Novikov self-consistency principle, Traversable wormhole
- L3: Generalized time function, Novikov self-consistency principle
- L4: Cauchy horizon
- L5: Universal cover of anti-de Sitter space, Contractible closed timelike curve, Lorentzian wormhole, Misner space, Noncontractible closed timelike curve, Spacetime topology
Sources (20) published science
Goedel metric (Wikipedia), definition, properties, cylindrical chart, cosmological interpretation (behind its links)
Clement, G., Gal'tsov, D., Guenouche, M. Rehabilitating space-times with NUTs (arXiv:1508.07622, LAPTH-046/15) (behind its links)
Tipler cylinder (Wikipedia, rev 1371331807, 2026) (behind its links)
Novikov self-consistency principle (Wikipedia, rev 1382300669, 2026) (behind its links)
Lobo, F. S. N. (2010) Closed timelike curves and causality violation, arXiv:1008.1127 (review) (behind its links)
Kerr metric (Wikipedia), overview, frame dragging, surfaces, ergosphere, features, symmetries, extensions, relations, open problems (behind its links)
Van Stockum dust (Wikipedia, rev 1355733501, 2026-05-23) (behind its links)
Misner space (Wikipedia, rev 1268320897, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Banados M., Henneaux M., Teitelboim C., Zanelli J. (1993) Geometry of the 2+1 black hole, submitted to Phys. Rev. D (arXiv:gr-qc/9302012) (behind its links)
Bonnor W. B. (2002) Closed timelike curves in general relativity, arXiv:gr-qc/0211051 (behind its links)
Hartman T., Kundu S., Tajdini A. (2017) Averaged null energy condition from causality, JHEP 07 (2017) 066 (arXiv:1610.05308 [hep-th]) (behind its links)
Borde, A. (1994) Topology Change in Classical General Relativity, arXiv:gr-qc/9406053 (behind its links)
Visser M. (2002) The quantum physics of chronology protection, in The future of theoretical physics and cosmology (Hawking 60th birthday conference), arXiv:gr-qc/0204022 (behind its links)
Causal structure (Wikipedia, rev 1375920903, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)